I hate that it basically felt like "Damned if they do, damned if they don't" and had to endure the backlash for decsions that weren't even theirs to begin with :'( ... I hope they succeed in any and all future endeavors
Honestly, Stellar disbanding was probably to me one of the few times I wanted a group to disband. They were treated sooooo bad under their label. I also want to know why Eric left cause,though I’m not placing all blame on him, I do give him some blame for leaving cause after seeing the trajectory that the group went in wasn’t great. It also should say something about the public and how fickle they are. They bashed them for doing a sexy concept but as soon as they did an innocent/cute one, it goes unnoticed. To think they go to clubs and smoke just cause of that concept is just disgusting and awful
I agree. Stellar is the ONE group that comes to mind where the more you hear about their story, the more you realize that their disbandment was needed for the mental well-being on the girls. And though there's stuff that we don't know, Eric did essentially leave them to the wolves. Hopefully he made amends with the girls behind the scenes.
I 100% agree with being happy that they disbanded but I don’t blame Eric, the company was very bold/didn’t care about stellar at all, and it kinda seems like they would’ve done what they did to stellar whether Eric was there or not. Eric was also active in the industry then. So of course he needed time to focus on himself, and his own career. It probably would’ve been tiring and conflicts with the company probably would’ve arose about scheduling and/or other stuff.
@@ifallapart2000 I don’t place all blame on him don’t get me wrong. I just think he should’ve stayed around with them since he essentially created the group
The girls are such good people and didn’t deserve to be exploited by their company. I am glad that they are in the process of healing. I will be supporting the members in what they are currently doing. They deserve support!
I feel angry they ripped Gayoung from university to sexually exploit her. She was paid 10k the entire time and the erotic reputation burnt bridges and she couldn't teach or go back to uni.
Stellar calling out the Kpop industry is so amazing they used there songs to tell their story and expose the big problems in the industry. Their so correct a group from a small company can literally put out the song of the year but a big company artist can release recycled trash and steal the title because people can’t just judge for the music quality. So sorry for these talented queens hope they find happiness in their feature.
I never see people saying this but I have to say it: I think it was quite irresponsible of Eric to basically drop them when all of the girls were recruited into the company because of him. Sure, he wanted to "focus on his career", but Shinwa are legends and he was already an established artist, so I don't understand the rush. Both the company and him made sure the group's image depended on him, he produced and pick music and concepts and probably the lineup itself, they were called "Eric's" group", they were told to mention him on every interview, their album sales came mostly from his fans. Eric and the company probably fell off, he didn't renew his contract and in the end it was the Stellar girls who suffered.
Eric is also an actor, and he had stuff happen when Marionette dropped. I solely blame their agency. They shouldn't have depended on Eric and his clout. The girls were talented. They just needed better producers. Really sad that the agency resorted to sex appeal. :|
Marionette and Vibrato were absolutely amazing and I remember how much hate they got and it made me upset. I always thought it was a classy sexy and you could tell how badly they were being s*xualized and the members had no say. I hate how they were treated. 🙁
I LOVED stellar and always felt bad for supporting their company but also felt bad if i didnt support them you know what i mean?? I loved all their music. And i feel bad for how much gayoung was clearly traumatized. She dont go anywhere without a long skirt etc cuz of how sexualized she was
Ugh, I still cry when I remember the stories Gayoung said on Miss Back. Everything she said about their treatment and the traumas she got are so painful.
I really felt sad for stellar, one of my fav groups! I love their music so much! My favorite song is sting but they we're forced to do very revealing/very sexy concept :'(
Miss these girls so much. They were treated very poorly. They deserved so much more. Wish they would come back, maybe with a decent company like Girls Generation had. Breaks my heart...
Stellar: *debuts* The public: meh we have other cute girl groups we don't need a new one Stellar: *changes to sexy concept* The public: um wtf this is disgusting, do yall do drugs smoke and go clubbing all the time Stellar: *we want to be sincere and go back to our roots* The public: *yall hear something?* Stellar: *goes back to sexy* The public: YOOO WTF IS THIS!? This is disgusting why did yall go this route!?!? I adored Stellar since Marionette, I wanted them to find success but hated their company. I'm glad they disbanded because unlike what a lot of fans believe to be mistreatment of their kpop idols... STELLAR had REAL mistreatment! Mask, Crying, Archangels of Sephiroth and Sting will always be my favourites from them.
The "We're really innocent" comment really got to me because a group's concept can sometimes keep the GP from seeing the members real personalities. 😢 Dreamcatcher has a rock/horror concept and I know that it's an automatic no for much of SK's GP but they're one of the sweetest, funniest groups in K-Pop. I suspect that one of the reasons DC is doing a reality show is to reach people who wouldn't normally give them the time of day. There have been so many really talented groups that have disbanded because of the sexy concept that I don't know why companies even try it anymore. There are adjacent concepts, like girl crush or dark elegance, that are safer and more profitable these days.
@@andredrw289 it's sad that this is soo true, the girl crush/bubble gum pop sound is so over saturated and too common that groups with amazing talents and concepts get overlooked or deemed "too dark" or "too scary"
I like how the public felt “so bad” for the girls when they only responded to the concepts that were forced on Stellar. Screw the public. They didn’t give a damn. They worked so hard, and now are forever traumatized by what that company made them do by always threatening them with their contractual obligations. Their other songs were bops too, but no one cared. Gayoung only wears super conservative clothing now because she doesn’t want the public to see her as sexy/slutty/*bad*, and Joenyul can’t drink white milk ever again because it makes her physically ill to think about that video and it’s allusion to “a certain act.” I’m so sad for them. Honestly.
many people think that girl groups like Stellar are only forced into doing the sexy concept but what about girl groups who were forced into the hyper-infantilized "innocent concept" like GFriend?
It's such a shame what happened with them. Marionette and especially vibrato are really good songs, and I think if the company wasnt so skeevy they could have reached a balance of sexy and member comfort. Sting was such a good album, and i really thought they had hit that balance, but it all went downhill :(
stellar was one of my ult fave girl groups, after they came back with marionette. but i did know about them for longer because they did a video thing with teen top once, because both groups were produced by shinhwa members. it wasn't the sexy concept that drew me in, but because marionette was a BANGER. and to dance like that in HEELS? and i saw the video where the sound tech messed up and hyoeun and minhee were effortlessly hitting the notes live, and they kept on going. so i've been a fan for awhile, so i was also definitely there when they released archangels of the sephiroth and fans did a petition not to support stellar financially in any way. we were like do NOT buy the album because the members want out. like, can you imagine? telling people NOT to buy your fave group's album because you feel so sorry for them, you just want them to be free from this hell hole.
Thank you for making this video. Stellar was one of my favs and I was so happy when they were able to put on a more confident concept again with Sting. The girls fought so hard and I'm glad they still have such a strong friendship ^~^
One of my first and fave stellar songs is sting, I feel like that was a perfect execution of the sexy concept they were comfortable with, could grab the public attention, and their company should have started with something years ago.
Thank you again for going into these kinds of stories in detail. RUclips needs more content like this, there’s too much rumor-mongering, spreading misconceptions and false narratives. The only suggestion I would make is to add links to shows (or links to articles about them) and just citing other sources in the description. But again, thank you, and brilliant as always!
"Mask" is my favorite Stellar song due to the melody and how it makes me shed tears at how good it is and the outfits they wore which consisted of coordinated tops with flowy skirts many people got angry thinking that they plagiarized Girls' Day's outfit for "Something"
🙏 Worldwide Royal Fans Love the Original Members of Stellar from 2011 to 2018! The Original Stellar will Live Forever in their Music Videos , Always! 🙏 Gamsahamnida! / Thank You So Much Stellar for your Lovely Music to UpLift us in our gloomy days! Stay Safe & Stay Grateful Stellar! 🕯🌷🌿🌍🇰🇷❤
It really sucks that these women were exploited bc they produced great music. Their sexy concept was also something I enjoyed. But obviously, if people are being hurt, it’s not good.
stellar came to Brazil to promote in my early years as a kpop stan. I have this vivid memory of a very famous Brazilian youtuber interviewing the members, asking them about the meaning of their MVs and the members telling him it wasn't sexual and looking very uncomfortable about it.
@@fatimahanwaar306 I can listen to the ones you mentioned, they are on Spotify on another Stellar profile. Or maybe this other profile isn't available in your country.
stellar was so talented and it saddens me to see that many of the general public saw them as nothing more than sexual objects. Female kpop idols should never have to go through the trauma that female idols that arent from the big three have to go through to become successful or relevant. This just shows how much work needs to be made to progress for Korea as a society to look as women as more than just sexual objects. So much talent is being looked over and ignored just on that
They honestly have some of the best title tracks(after the concept change) I’ve heard in kpop, still one of my favorite gg musically but I hope they’re all healing now
Thanks for your usual well researched coverage. I'd forgotten about Eric's involvement in their debut and their final years were such a mess, I'd not really followed how it ended.
I actually got back and get to know Stellar because of Youngheun and what Gayoung said in Miss Back. For sure I’m deeply sorry for them, but it also did remind me that Rania/Blackswan have similar experiences. It’s just sad to see such talented and beautiful people being criticized for something else or things that are deemed harmless in other countries
I hate that they had to do Marionette, but I love that song. It was so great. The video shouldn’t have had all that nasty shit, including the milk scene and the butt rubbing (wtf was that?). However, how did they not go viral for that super professional and awesome a cappella performance? Most groups from the big three would not have continued like that. That’s showed true style, poise, professionalism, and I have no clue as to why they did not get super famous for it. Society really sucks sometimes Sex sells, huh? 😢
I dont think theirs is a story of the company's treatment of them like many think. I think its a story of the way the public treats them. Many people that weren't even fans were making demands of their music style and dress. The company and the girls were trying to cater to the public but didn't get results when they did. It was proof that these people weren't fans. They were just people that want kpop groups to fit their standards at all times. They arent going to buy the music or even watch it but still expect the idols to comply with their demands. It was clear that their legit fans liked their sexy look. That's what they needed to do. Do what your paying fans want. Don't worry about people that aren't paying u
Excellent video as usual Recently they reunited just by themselves and posted online💗😭 Support the comeback of former member Jeonyoul that is coming, second album 🥺💌
I honestly think the group found their perfect concept with crying, slightly sexy but cheerful and cute. on the other hand i cannot watch the mv for sting, its super uncomfortable. I actually like marionette and vibrato but I completely understand why they were uncomfortable. im not entirely surprised their early videos didnt catch on because rocket girl and ufo were kinda terrible and way too autotuned but i absolutely loved study and I'm sad mask never got recognition because it was an amazing song with a really pretty mv. I was really sad when they disbanded but I can't blame them at all for wanting to disband. sorry this is so rambley and doesnt flow well, I wanted to express my opinion on most of their discography.
ohhh i havent watched the video yet but i listen to sting and saw the album cover, ive always wanted to know about them but never got around to researching
I think this happened in another video which I liked but I wish that all the videos would should the word she bleeps out. I have no idea what word 6:03 is supposed to be lol
despite my other comment as a fan of stellar prior to marionette i kinda hated it at first. like I didnt think it was bad just that it wasnt stellar, didnt fit stellar, and honestly it gave me a weird feeling about it. I should have trusted my gut and known they were uncomfortable with it...
people are now using Stellar's poor management and exploitation as an excuse to generalize all girl groups and female idols as being "forced" to do the sexy concept but what about the hyper infantilized cute concept? people seriously need to grow up
They really deserved better. They were great performers, singers, dancers, all of it. I wonder why nothing stuck. They had such catchy songs too…catchier than some popular groups I shall not name. They can also sing and dance live, as they proved when they sang “Marionette” a cappella unlike some popular groups that can’t sing live when they’re standing still after a music show win. Hmmm…I wonder who I’m talking about…
The marionette choreography makes me so incredibly uncomfortable to this day. I don't know what the choreographer was thinking. You can generally get away with either very sexy outfits _or_ very sexy choreo. A mix of both is also possible, but it has to be correctly distributed. _(If that makes sense.)_ In my mind, properly balanced concepts look something like this: The horizontal line continuing on each side until the "|" vertical line represents how much or how strong the outfits are versus the choreo. And it usually works out as long as they are balanced, like any of the possibilities shown. If the outfits are very sexy then the choreo can't be overdone, and vice versa. As long as they balance each other out _(relatively, of course some concepts work well despite not being balanced. But that's a unqiue exception, not the rule)._ 1.) Sexy Outfits : ------|------ : Sexy Choreo 2.) Sexy Outfits : -|----------- : Sexy Choreo 3.) Sexy Outfits : ---------|--- : Sexy Choreo
They could've had it all... but once again, like other groups, that debut was absolutely terrible. Eric's expertise and connections meant nothing, he doesn't seem to know what good music is lol
Netizens: *female idols doing sexy dance moves and wearing sexy outfits* Omg they look disgusting and too erotic Netizens: *Male idols do the exact same thing* omg they look so sexy, they are kings Me: double standards much?
10:48 I understand that English is your second language, so you might not be familiar with the connotations of all English words, but you really need to be less aggressive with all the words you're bleeping out. It's gotten to the point where you're now randomly bleeping and censoring words that are not in any way problematic in English. The word "lingerie" is not profanity. The word "sex" is not profanity. The word "thong" is not profanity. They don't need to be censored. They're routinely used in normal conversations by English speakers everyday. They appear in newspapers, books, articles, TV, and movies on a daily basis in the English speaking world without problems. You're cutting and censoring so many words from your videos, for no reason whatsoever, that it can actually make it difficult to follow what you're saying. 12:54 Here for example you cut out so much here that what's left is actually incomprehensible. "for the company to scratch that members to the extreme with Vibrato." I can't even figure out what you were trying to say here? The sentence didn't even make sense.
i think they censored it bc youtube demonetizes certain videos if they feature certain words such as "slut" "death" etc. as well the algorithm wont push out certain videos if they contain certain words. Ik a youtuber who censored the word 'bully' bc the youtube algorthim wont promote her video for having the word 'bully'
The topics of your videos are interesting but the uptalking that you add to your voice is really not pleasant. Trying to reduce it would make trying to watch your videos better..
![Noob To Max With DRAGON REWORK In Blox Fruits [FULL MOVIE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LnBMOinoOvA/mqdefault.jpg)
![Blox Fruits Dragon Rework Update [Full Stream]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EqDAp8udhm0/mqdefault.jpg)
Netizens: That’s so wrong I don’t like it!
*Stellar does cute*
Netizens: I don’t like it go back to sexy!
I hate that it basically felt like "Damned if they do, damned if they don't" and had to endure the backlash for decsions that weren't even theirs to begin with :'( ...
I hope they succeed in any and all future endeavors
Meanwhile the Boy Groups: Rips their shirts off
@@kalali7448 I mean stellar was overly sexualized and it was worse than a male idol being shirtless
@@kalali7448watch the whole video
Honestly, Stellar disbanding was probably to me one of the few times I wanted a group to disband. They were treated sooooo bad under their label. I also want to know why Eric left cause,though I’m not placing all blame on him, I do give him some blame for leaving cause after seeing the trajectory that the group went in wasn’t great. It also should say something about the public and how fickle they are. They bashed them for doing a sexy concept but as soon as they did an innocent/cute one, it goes unnoticed. To think they go to clubs and smoke just cause of that concept is just disgusting and awful
I agree. Stellar is the ONE group that comes to mind where the more you hear about their story, the more you realize that their disbandment was needed for the mental well-being on the girls. And though there's stuff that we don't know, Eric did essentially leave them to the wolves. Hopefully he made amends with the girls behind the scenes.
@@kaemarieautumn I surely hope so cause I feel like once he left like you said they were left to the wolves
I 100% agree with being happy that they disbanded but I don’t blame Eric, the company was very bold/didn’t care about stellar at all, and it kinda seems like they would’ve done what they did to stellar whether Eric was there or not. Eric was also active in the industry then. So of course he needed time to focus on himself, and his own career. It probably would’ve been tiring and conflicts with the company probably would’ve arose about scheduling and/or other stuff.
@@ifallapart2000 I don’t place all blame on him don’t get me wrong. I just think he should’ve stayed around with them since he essentially created the group
@@andredrw289 I doubt anything would’ve changed tho they probably would’ve still been forced to be sex dolls by whoever made them
The girls are such good people and didn’t deserve to be exploited by their company. I am glad that they are in the process of healing. I will be supporting the members in what they are currently doing. They deserve support!
I feel so bad for them. they are really strong besides going trough all of that.
She was like
She has to be i the
She I II I
They
They is not if they are
I feel angry they ripped Gayoung from university to sexually exploit her. She was paid 10k the entire time and the erotic reputation burnt bridges and she couldn't teach or go back to uni.
Stellar calling out the Kpop industry is so amazing they used there songs to tell their story and expose the big problems in the industry. Their so correct a group from a small company can literally put out the song of the year but a big company artist can release recycled trash and steal the title because people can’t just judge for the music quality. So sorry for these talented queens hope they find happiness in their feature.
I never see people saying this but I have to say it: I think it was quite irresponsible of Eric to basically drop them when all of the girls were recruited into the company because of him. Sure, he wanted to "focus on his career", but Shinwa are legends and he was already an established artist, so I don't understand the rush. Both the company and him made sure the group's image depended on him, he produced and pick music and concepts and probably the lineup itself, they were called "Eric's" group", they were told to mention him on every interview, their album sales came mostly from his fans. Eric and the company probably fell off, he didn't renew his contract and in the end it was the Stellar girls who suffered.
I would’ve said it too. Idk what happened behind the scenes, but he honestly should’ve stayed considering the trajectory the girls went after he left
Eric is also an actor, and he had stuff happen when Marionette dropped. I solely blame their agency. They shouldn't have depended on Eric and his clout. The girls were talented. They just needed better producers. Really sad that the agency resorted to sex appeal. :|
Same with Rain & Hwanhee (Fly to the Sky). The only good CEO is Andy Shinhwa.
@@deanab-se5op I don't know anything about Hwanhee but Rain makes Eric look like an angel
@@ninanano Hwanhee - MYNAME, Rain - Madtown
It's really sad seeing something like that happen to them.
Marionette and Vibrato were absolutely amazing and I remember how much hate they got and it made me upset. I always thought it was a classy sexy and you could tell how badly they were being s*xualized and the members had no say. I hate how they were treated. 🙁
Girl! You forgot their Legendary song 'Sting'. 🥺❤️
@@leyley8234 Sting is such an evergreen song 💛 I still listen to it today
I LOVED stellar and always felt bad for supporting their company but also felt bad if i didnt support them you know what i mean?? I loved all their music. And i feel bad for how much gayoung was clearly traumatized. She dont go anywhere without a long skirt etc cuz of how sexualized she was
Ugh, I still cry when I remember the stories Gayoung said on Miss Back. Everything she said about their treatment and the traumas she got are so painful.
I really felt sad for stellar, one of my fav groups! I love their music so much! My favorite song is sting but they we're forced to do very revealing/very sexy concept :'(
The fact that one member can't even drink white milk to this day is just sad.
That member is Jeonyul :(
@@AdiVA03052 from what MV?
@@gyuriyuri3153 Stellar - Marionette
@@AdiVA03052 oh thanks
Miss these girls so much. They were treated very poorly. They deserved so much more. Wish they would come back, maybe with a decent company like Girls Generation had. Breaks my heart...
Clicked as fast as I could!
Edit: seeing them saying "we are innocent kids, pls love us a lot" broke me 😢
Stellar: *debuts*
The public: meh we have other cute girl groups we don't need a new one
Stellar: *changes to sexy concept*
The public: um wtf this is disgusting, do yall do drugs smoke and go clubbing all the time
Stellar: *we want to be sincere and go back to our roots*
The public: *yall hear something?*
Stellar: *goes back to sexy*
The public: YOOO WTF IS THIS!? This is disgusting why did yall go this route!?!?
I adored Stellar since Marionette, I wanted them to find success but hated their company. I'm glad they disbanded because unlike what a lot of fans believe to be mistreatment of their kpop idols... STELLAR had REAL mistreatment! Mask, Crying, Archangels of Sephiroth and Sting will always be my favourites from them.
The "We're really innocent" comment really got to me because a group's concept can sometimes keep the GP from seeing the members real personalities. 😢 Dreamcatcher has a rock/horror concept and I know that it's an automatic no for much of SK's GP but they're one of the sweetest, funniest groups in K-Pop. I suspect that one of the reasons DC is doing a reality show is to reach people who wouldn't normally give them the time of day. There have been so many really talented groups that have disbanded because of the sexy concept that I don't know why companies even try it anymore. There are adjacent concepts, like girl crush or dark elegance, that are safer and more profitable these days.
The market is so over saturated that unless you’re from a big label, any concept you do is gonna get overlooked
@@andredrw289 it's sad that this is soo true, the girl crush/bubble gum pop sound is so over saturated and too common that groups with amazing talents and concepts get overlooked or deemed "too dark" or "too scary"
@@angelichobi__18 or they’re too sexy and even the ones that just do a grown women concept they just get overlooked
@@andredrw289 I know, it's so sad, there's been so many talented groups but get overlooked just because of their concepts, like spica or Dreamcatcher
@@andredrw289 honestly, i feel like cute concepts especially are FLOODED with mediocre songs
Every time I hear their story I cry. My heart breaks for them, they went through so much :(
I've met them in a fansign years ago, they were stunning and sweet. I'll always support them
This group was the light that shows the dark side of kpop.
I like how the public felt “so bad” for the girls when they only responded to the concepts that were forced on Stellar. Screw the public. They didn’t give a damn. They worked so hard, and now are forever traumatized by what that company made them do by always threatening them with their contractual obligations. Their other songs were bops too, but no one cared. Gayoung only wears super conservative clothing now because she doesn’t want the public to see her as sexy/slutty/*bad*, and Joenyul can’t drink white milk ever again because it makes her physically ill to think about that video and it’s allusion to “a certain act.” I’m so sad for them. Honestly.
WAKE UP BABE NEW MIDNIGHT THEORIES VIDEO
many people think that girl groups like Stellar are only forced into doing the sexy concept but what about girl groups who were forced into the hyper-infantilized "innocent concept" like GFriend?
i think twice went through that period starting with cheer up and ending with what is love
Lovelyz and Oh My Girl too. They were forced to perform as innocent, pure idols until the GP was tired of that concept.
@@qkamatska true
Stellar. A group that I will cherish forever.
It's such a shame what happened with them. Marionette and especially vibrato are really good songs, and I think if the company wasnt so skeevy they could have reached a balance of sexy and member comfort. Sting was such a good album, and i really thought they had hit that balance, but it all went downhill :(
All stellar songs minus rocket girl and ufo aged like wine. Their songs can still be released right now and will still be a very enjoyable listen.
Stellar's Crying is one of the best KPOP song of all time...
stellar was one of my ult fave girl groups, after they came back with marionette. but i did know about them for longer because they did a video thing with teen top once, because both groups were produced by shinhwa members. it wasn't the sexy concept that drew me in, but because marionette was a BANGER. and to dance like that in HEELS? and i saw the video where the sound tech messed up and hyoeun and minhee were effortlessly hitting the notes live, and they kept on going. so i've been a fan for awhile, so i was also definitely there when they released archangels of the sephiroth and fans did a petition not to support stellar financially in any way. we were like do NOT buy the album because the members want out. like, can you imagine? telling people NOT to buy your fave group's album because you feel so sorry for them, you just want them to be free from this hell hole.
their music is amazing
marionette, vibrato, sting, and crying are so good
Its crazy bc i love their original debut song
Thank you for making this video. Stellar was one of my favs and I was so happy when they were able to put on a more confident concept again with Sting. The girls fought so hard and I'm glad they still have such a strong friendship ^~^
Bro mask was iconic 😭
One of my first and fave stellar songs is sting, I feel like that was a perfect execution of the sexy concept they were comfortable with, could grab the public attention, and their company should have started with something years ago.
My favorite group that has ever existed, I would never judge them..they are all amazing women!
their vocals were very good when they sing Marionette at cappella
Thank you again for going into these kinds of stories in detail. RUclips needs more content like this, there’s too much rumor-mongering, spreading misconceptions and false narratives. The only suggestion I would make is to add links to shows (or links to articles about them) and just citing other sources in the description. But again, thank you, and brilliant as always!
Marionette is still one best songs to be released in K-Pop over the last 10years. Regardless of all the sexual innuendos, the song itself is 🔥.
"Mask" is my favorite Stellar song due to the melody and how it makes me shed tears at how good it is and the outfits they wore which consisted of coordinated tops with flowy skirts many people got angry thinking that they plagiarized Girls' Day's outfit for "Something"
🙏 Worldwide Royal Fans Love the Original Members of Stellar from 2011 to 2018! The Original Stellar will Live Forever in their Music Videos , Always! 🙏 Gamsahamnida! / Thank You So Much Stellar for your Lovely Music to UpLift us in our gloomy days! Stay Safe & Stay Grateful Stellar! 🕯🌷🌿🌍🇰🇷❤
ur videos help me learn so much more abt kpop groups that i don't know so well or havent heard of before! tysm!
I haven't been watching for very long, but I absolutely love your use of graphics and titles. Can't wait to see more
It really sucks that these women were exploited bc they produced great music. Their sexy concept was also something I enjoyed. But obviously, if people are being hurt, it’s not good.
stellar came to Brazil to promote in my early years as a kpop stan. I have this vivid memory of a very famous Brazilian youtuber interviewing the members, asking them about the meaning of their MVs and the members telling him it wasn't sexual and looking very uncomfortable about it.
UFO did that poorly but it’s personally my favorite Stellar song. I loved it so much.
And now all stellar title track are removed from spotify…
They're still there, but you have to search in Korean.
@@foxcanaa except Marionette Vibrato Mask etc.
@@fatimahanwaar306 I can listen to the ones you mentioned, they are on Spotify on another Stellar profile. Or maybe this other profile isn't available in your country.
stellar was so talented and it saddens me to see that many of the general public saw them as nothing more than sexual objects. Female kpop idols should never have to go through the trauma that female idols that arent from the big three have to go through to become successful or relevant. This just shows how much work needs to be made to progress for Korea as a society to look as women as more than just sexual objects. So much talent is being looked over and ignored just on that
Kpop idols will always be looked at as objects tho it’s never gonna change
I vividly remember stellars debut, sad it ended up like this
I hope they get a second chance like Brave Girls! I'm waiting for one of their songs to go viral 💖
YES FINALLY A VIDEO ABOUT STELLAR THEY ARE ONE OF MY FAVOURITE GROUPS
They honestly have some of the best title tracks(after the concept change) I’ve heard in kpop, still one of my favorite gg musically but I hope they’re all healing now
Thanks for your usual well researched coverage. I'd forgotten about Eric's involvement in their debut and their final years were such a mess, I'd not really followed how it ended.
Great video
I actually got back and get to know Stellar because of Youngheun and what Gayoung said in Miss Back. For sure I’m deeply sorry for them, but it also did remind me that Rania/Blackswan have similar experiences. It’s just sad to see such talented and beautiful people being criticized for something else or things that are deemed harmless in other countries
Kbs censoring rocket girl is so ????😭
I hate that they had to do Marionette, but I love that song. It was so great. The video shouldn’t have had all that nasty shit, including the milk scene and the butt rubbing (wtf was that?). However, how did they not go viral for that super professional and awesome a cappella performance? Most groups from the big three would not have continued like that. That’s showed true style, poise, professionalism, and I have no clue as to why they did not get super famous for it. Society really sucks sometimes
Sex sells, huh? 😢
Stellar one of my FAVORITE UNDERRATED girl group.
I dont think theirs is a story of the company's treatment of them like many think. I think its a story of the way the public treats them. Many people that weren't even fans were making demands of their music style and dress. The company and the girls were trying to cater to the public but didn't get results when they did. It was proof that these people weren't fans. They were just people that want kpop groups to fit their standards at all times. They arent going to buy the music or even watch it but still expect the idols to comply with their demands. It was clear that their legit fans liked their sexy look. That's what they needed to do. Do what your paying fans want. Don't worry about people that aren't paying u
Mask + sting are their best songs.
I was sad when they disbanded. They re so talented and I enjoyed their songs they were really good.
*does sexy concept*
Public: no that’s too much don’t do that!
*does cute concept*
Public: uh where’s the sexiness???
Excellent video as usual
Recently they reunited just by themselves and posted online💗😭
Support the comeback of former member Jeonyoul that is coming, second album 🥺💌
ayye, here we go again with another banger of a video and to announce that I am first to see it!
I honestly think the group found their perfect concept with crying, slightly sexy but cheerful and cute. on the other hand i cannot watch the mv for sting, its super uncomfortable. I actually like marionette and vibrato but I completely understand why they were uncomfortable. im not entirely surprised their early videos didnt catch on because rocket girl and ufo were kinda terrible and way too autotuned but i absolutely loved study and I'm sad mask never got recognition because it was an amazing song with a really pretty mv. I was really sad when they disbanded but I can't blame them at all for wanting to disband.
sorry this is so rambley and doesnt flow well, I wanted to express my opinion on most of their discography.
ohhh i havent watched the video yet but i listen to sting and saw the album cover, ive always wanted to know about them but never got around to researching
My favorite song is sting by stellar and I had no idea they were this exploited :(
And they were so good
Does anyone know where I can watch all the episodes of miss back with subtitles since on RUclips it only goes to episode 10 with subs
Usually kissasian website has it. Just search miss back eng sub
gayoung taking a bath wearing clothes
I think this happened in another video which I liked but I wish that all the videos would should the word she bleeps out. I have no idea what word 6:03 is supposed to be lol
Will you do a video about hello Venus!
Can you do SPICA bext they were my favourite groups
Who were the backup dancers?
please do one for laysha
The SOS video.. :(
Finally
What is with the kpop industry's use of the word concept? it seems weird to me
despite my other comment as a fan of stellar prior to marionette i kinda hated it at first. like I didnt think it was bad just that it wasnt stellar, didnt fit stellar, and honestly it gave me a weird feeling about it. I should have trusted my gut and known they were uncomfortable with it...
people are now using Stellar's poor management and exploitation as an excuse to generalize all girl groups and female idols as being "forced" to do the sexy concept but what about the hyper infantilized cute concept? people seriously need to grow up
They really deserved better. They were great performers, singers, dancers, all of it. I wonder why nothing stuck. They had such catchy songs too…catchier than some popular groups I shall not name. They can also sing and dance live, as they proved when they sang “Marionette” a cappella unlike some popular groups that can’t sing live when they’re standing still after a music show win. Hmmm…I wonder who I’m talking about…
The marionette choreography makes me so incredibly uncomfortable to this day. I don't know what the choreographer was thinking. You can generally get away with either very sexy outfits _or_ very sexy choreo. A mix of both is also possible, but it has to be correctly distributed. _(If that makes sense.)_ In my mind, properly balanced concepts look something like this:
The horizontal line continuing on each side until the "|" vertical line represents how much or how strong the outfits are versus the choreo. And it usually works out as long as they are balanced, like any of the possibilities shown. If the outfits are very sexy then the choreo can't be overdone, and vice versa. As long as they balance each other out _(relatively, of course some concepts work well despite not being balanced. But that's a unqiue exception, not the rule)._
1.) Sexy Outfits : ------|------ : Sexy Choreo
2.) Sexy Outfits : -|----------- : Sexy Choreo
3.) Sexy Outfits : ---------|--- : Sexy Choreo
They could've had it all... but once again, like other groups, that debut was absolutely terrible. Eric's expertise and connections meant nothing, he doesn't seem to know what good music is lol
Netizens: *female idols doing sexy dance moves and wearing sexy outfits* Omg they look disgusting and too erotic
Netizens: *Male idols do the exact same thing* omg they look so sexy, they are kings
Me: double standards much?
They were victimized though
Their label seriously sucks…..
10:48 I understand that English is your second language, so you might not be familiar with the connotations of all English words, but you really need to be less aggressive with all the words you're bleeping out. It's gotten to the point where you're now randomly bleeping and censoring words that are not in any way problematic in English.
The word "lingerie" is not profanity. The word "sex" is not profanity. The word "thong" is not profanity.
They don't need to be censored. They're routinely used in normal conversations by English speakers everyday. They appear in newspapers, books, articles, TV, and movies on a daily basis in the English speaking world without problems. You're cutting and censoring so many words from your videos, for no reason whatsoever, that it can actually make it difficult to follow what you're saying.
12:54 Here for example you cut out so much here that what's left is actually incomprehensible. "for the company to scratch that members to the extreme with Vibrato." I can't even figure out what you were trying to say here? The sentence didn't even make sense.
i think they censored it bc youtube demonetizes certain videos if they feature certain words such as "slut" "death" etc. as well the algorithm wont push out certain videos if they contain certain words. Ik a youtuber who censored the word 'bully' bc the youtube algorthim wont promote her video for having the word 'bully'
They have to be cut out because of RUclips's algorithm.
It's bleeped out because of RUclips guidelines.
upload with captions please, otherwise i cant watch
I'm half hoping NewJeans doesn't end up in these kinds of videos these days...
The topics of your videos are interesting but the uptalking that you add to your voice is really not pleasant. Trying to reduce it would make trying to watch your videos better..
I have a gut feeling that they were not that innocent. I think they knew more than what they are saying. I’m not hating I’m just saying
i think they were innocent