THE BEST DEMO ever, truly. Consistent, great, playing from version to version, yet with enough texture to find what I wanted to hear, especially as I have the JB Junior and could relate its tone. Thank you!
My guess 250 since it's stacked hb but I could be wrong. Couldn't go wrong either way but I think 250 would be smoother with more articulate single notes.
Both sound really good, the DiMarzio sounds a little thin but that's a good thing sometimes. I use the JBjr bridge in my Warmoth strat, when I want a thinner sound I switch it to parallel wiring, makes a Tele kind of bridge tone. I use the Duckbucker in the middle and a Vintage Rails on the neck, very versatile combo of sounds with a super switch and series/Parrallel options.
I'm 4 years late but I got to say, excellent playing and a great song! As you presented them I thought the JB was a better sound. It had a mid punch that cut through the mix with a little more character. Really good video!
Very nice demo!!! I had a Pro Track installed in my Classic 60s Strat, I changed it for a JbJr and I switched back to Pro Track! I gave a lot of chances to the JbJr (I had it installed for a year or so) but I thought I was trying hard to squeeze more tone out of it, like it was partially muting my strings and making them sound smoother. Finally, I went back to Pro Track and found the presence and bass I wanted and if I want a smooth tone I roll back the tone knob a bit (I have wired the middle tone to the bridge). Also, the Pro Track plays well with the stock 57/62 Fender pickups with quack in the combined b+m position while I had a hard time with the JbJr and the stock pickups. The Pro Track has 50% more output although it has half the DC resistance of the JbJr (a myth busted!).
I admire your way of present the two pickups on the guitar with a variety of styles to play. That’s how it should be done , if you’re shopping for a guitar pickup that’s how you can make a decision what you want to sound like…….!! I love the sound of the pro track on the neck position on my Kramer it sound so bluesy, can beat that……
I find this is generally the case with DiMarzios as opposed to Duncans. I've owned plenty of both, but for every pickup Duncan makes like the Full Shred, Custom, or Screamin' Demon with a tight low end, they make too many pickups like the JB, Custom Custom, Custom 5, and Pearly Gates that have a very flubby kind of low end. DiMarzio pioneered the high output humbucker more than any other company.
This video does not settle the question for me. I think the veriables are so many that we end up adapting our style and technique to the pickups,guitars and amps we play to get the most from them but they end up shaping our approach. I am ordering a Dimarzio DP 218 super distortion to put in the bridge of a Hiway 1 installed on a MIM standard with a maple back and top, I will have to wait and see where this leads but it will probably change the way I play or maybe the search will end here but I doubt it. \\
Open 2 windows, put 1 guitar in each, then play in 5 second clips. You will see the JB is the clear winner. While I did prefer the clean tones of the DiMarzio when the distortion kicks in the JB has a much more aggressive and clearer sound. When the fast playing starts you can actually hear the all the individual notes being played on the JB whereas the fast stuff gets blurred and muddy on the DiMarzio.
JB Jnr sounds great in your demo. I used the Protrack and I found the tone is very smooth and slightly boring. Dimarzio Chopper is the one I like with 250k controls, but I don't know how it compares the JB Jnr.
Sounds so similar to Opeth - My time of need. Thanks for the comparison. They both sound so good. Jb's have more crunchy mid-range. D'marzios have a crunchier low-mid with a more compressed sound. Jb's seen to ring more. D'ms seem to have a flatter response.
I just ordered a G&L USA Legacy from Chicago Music Exchange. It has Bare Knuckle Apache's in neck and middle position. I had them install a SD JB Jr in Bridge. Should sound killer and should be arriving in couple days. Be playing it through my '78 Marshall JMP. It's gonna be rockin'.
Hi there, I see that you installed bare knuckle apache’s in the neck and middle and a SD in jr in the bridge of one of your guitars. How did the Apache’s work? How about the jb jr? Did they work well together? Thanks!
I prefer the Jeff Beck Jnr (red guitar). I have one in my US Strat and it's awesome! I also have a DiMarzio tone zone full humbucker in an Ibanez I own and that's pretty biting, ballsey, and not at all fizzy when distorted.
i literally cannot decide. the fact that these are 250k pots too are amazing. i love the higher end coming from the dimarzios so much, in the cleans AND lead/rhythm, the JB jr is a little muddier and darker to me, but i don't necessarily dislike it, i'm just so unsure of it against the dimarzio. EDIT, i put on airpods again and the JB jr wins, the laptop speakers lost a lot of definition, as to be expected lol EDIT 2: after more listening, i like the cleans on the jb jr more but the distortion on the protrack more, so i'm once again at odds
Very late to this, but this comparison shows that the pickups don't matter that much, as long as a player knows what to do and how to play. Both a very, very nice tracks, hats off 😊 In the end I'd prefer the DiMarzio for being a bit softer in the midrange - but that's a matter of taste, I think 😁
Basically, the DiMarzio is warmer, more muscle, the Duncan has more "spoink" and edge, let's your picking come through. I'm currently using the Custom Shop "Little Pearly Gates".
Jb cuts better but has a flubby bass and almost sounds like ghost notes on leads, Pro track tighter fundamentals low and high but gets lost in the mix. Is there a 3rd option?
The JB Jr has more mids, which I think work well on the full size hb version. Not sure how well that really works with ceramic on lower gain sounds. The Pro Track has a more open sound with a brighter high end (though that guitar also has maple fretboard which always makes a difference to my ears). Personally I'd prefer the Pro Track for various styles as a good all-rounder, But would go for the JB Jr if I was only gonna play high gain rock and metal and wanted solos to cut through with the mids.
The Jrs have a great lead vintage sound (a personal preference since solo tone sounded close to In Flames's 'December Flower' solo tone) but Di Marzios do have a great modern buttery rhythm tone.
I prefer the JBJr. It has a bit more snarl to the mids that'd be more suitable for my style of playing. However the the PT does sound good for fast solos and clean passages.
I think they both sound good, but the Protrack sounds brighter and the SD more bassy .....Not sure if it's the pups or the different tone woods (fret boards).....I know maple boards tend to be brighter and more trebly. I have 4 guitars with maple boards and they are definitely brighter sounding then my rosewoods. I have a Protrack but it's in the neck position. I was trying to set my Strat up for Satch tones. Would like to hear it in the bridge position ...... Love your progression....Great tune....😎🎸🎶👍
Nice playing and both sounds good, maybe SD is more transparent, DMZ more warmer...but they both sound good enough for bridge position in strat...i own Pro Truck...it is better in B position then i N
I have the JB Jr in my Strat and it sounds just like this demo: SD JB sounds muted 'warmer' compared to the DM Pro Track. I think the DM Pro Track sounds better (more clarity and cut into the mix)
Larger note and more sustain in the protrack when AB at the end. Similar EQ. More shimmer and body on the soloing. Both very similar riffing. I say protrack
Great music 🎶 👍 But I think the sound is also much depending on what fretboard you initiate the tone. You played the duncan on a rosewood and the DiMarzio on a maple neck. It's difficult to compare the pickups this way, because the fretboard deliver a very different tone. For me in the video the duncan sounded a bit fater and more accurate. It seemed to me also that the duncan has a bit more output than the DiMarzio? However, I know that both companies build great pickups. Maybe the result would be another one, if both pickups would be played in the same guitar to compare? Who knows? In the end its a matter of, what we like personally.
doesnt make any difference.maple fretboards and rosewood fretboards do not make sound,they just hold the frets in place.cork sniffing makes guitar sound analysis ridiculous
Would love to hear this song with vocals. Great tune. As for the pickups, I'm on the fence. I mean I like both SD and DiMarzio pickups but I'm undecided
Thats a hard pick!! jb seems more dirty sounding and the pt seems more that 70's sound more clean. kind of funny, i run DiMarzio in my strats and SD in my LP's. call me crazy but i like them both..
Lord help! They're both *great* pickups. JB is warmer, maybe. Seems DM's have a slightly bit more of treble. Would only make a difference depending who is playing it. Both sound pretty amazing.
With playing that good, they both sound awesome.
THE BEST DEMO ever, truly. Consistent, great, playing from version to version, yet with enough texture to find what I wanted to hear, especially as I have the JB Junior and could relate its tone. Thank you!
Loved your guitar Playing..Its DiMarzio for me
Came for comparison ended up enjoying watch you play. Great video.
My guess 250 since it's stacked hb but I could be wrong. Couldn't go wrong either way but I think 250 would be smoother with more articulate single notes.
Both sound really good, the DiMarzio sounds a little thin but that's a good thing sometimes. I use the JBjr bridge in my Warmoth strat, when I want a thinner sound I switch it to parallel wiring, makes a Tele kind of bridge tone. I use the Duckbucker in the middle and a Vintage Rails on the neck, very versatile combo of sounds with a super switch and series/Parrallel options.
I love the sound of both but the JB is the sound I'm looking for in my Strat. I just got one in the mail and I can't wait to install it!
How'd the JB Jr go in the strat?
@@motothumper5598 Sounds great!!!
Great video.Finally someone who known how to make a proper demo video..Excellent sir!
Thank you! I'm glad you liked the video! Best regards from a cold Sweden :-)
I have both, and the JB is much more articulate, and well rounded. But both pickups are very nice.
DiMarzio sounds more aggressive to my ears. It has more lows and highs. Duncan with more high mids.
yes the DiMarzio it's clearly more hard rock / metal.. I love it..
Pro trick : you can watch movies at Flixzone. I've been using them for watching lots of of movies lately.
@Gregory Arlo yea, have been using flixzone} for months myself :)
Both sound phenomenal. Can't lose with either one.
DIMARZIOOOO ALL DAY
I'm 4 years late but I got to say, excellent playing and a great song! As you presented them I thought the JB was a better sound. It had a mid punch that cut through the mix with a little more character. Really good video!
Yea the lead single notes cut through better on the JB Jr but the Dimarzio does sound good on chords, ive
used both on my two strats,
Brilliant mate 1st class demo thanks for putting this up both sound bloody great
Thanks! Have a great day! /Christian :-)
Very nice demo!!! I had a Pro Track installed in my Classic 60s Strat, I changed it for a JbJr and I switched back to Pro Track! I gave a lot of chances to the JbJr (I had it installed for a year or so) but I thought I was trying hard to squeeze more tone out of it, like it was partially muting my strings and making them sound smoother. Finally, I went back to Pro Track and found the presence and bass I wanted and if I want a smooth tone I roll back the tone knob a bit (I have wired the middle tone to the bridge). Also, the Pro Track plays well with the stock 57/62 Fender pickups with quack in the combined b+m position while I had a hard time with the JbJr and the stock pickups. The Pro Track has 50% more output although it has half the DC resistance of the JbJr (a myth busted!).
Thank you!! Take care!
Good Review but bottom line which do you prefer? I thought the pro track had more clarity am I wrong?
Great playing! Great video for comparison. Both do sound great.
I love the Protrack in the bridge. I have one in a Mustang. Very underrated pickup.
I admire your way of present the two pickups on the guitar with a variety of styles to play. That’s how it should be done , if you’re shopping for a guitar pickup that’s how you can make a decision what you want to sound like…….!! I love the sound of the pro track on the neck position on my Kramer it sound so bluesy, can beat that……
Very Great video,.... I like The kind oF style you play.....!! 🎸 THANKYOU
Thank you my friend!!
Both sound great but going with JB Jr since that's what Dave Murray uses on the middle position
Janick Gers use jb jr in bridge and neck position 🤘
@@Berkovicz Yeah, but my favorite Maiden tone is Dave's, that's why I put Hotrails in the neck and bridge positions and a JB jr in the middle position
That DiMarzio sounds so beefy and crunchy......love it!
Seymour more vintage sound ,Dimarzio more modern sound ,more mass and high and low ,seymour more sweet highs and tight lows.Great pickups,very cool
Seymour. Warmer n Vintage = Classic.
i like jb in this video..it has that little 'springy' sound when you pick the string..
for high gain, Dimarzio seem to have more tightness and output
I find this is generally the case with DiMarzios as opposed to Duncans. I've owned plenty of both, but for every pickup Duncan makes like the Full Shred, Custom, or Screamin' Demon with a tight low end, they make too many pickups like the JB, Custom Custom, Custom 5, and Pearly Gates that have a very flubby kind of low end. DiMarzio pioneered the high output humbucker more than any other company.
I like the Pro Track in the bridge of my strat as well.
Great tone, i really enjoy your Music, thank you !
Thanks a lot my friend! :-) /Christian
Rockn rolly, Christian cederberg!👍
Thank you!! /Christian 😀🤟
forget the pickups, nice guitar lesson!
Thanks man! :-)
I have a Seymour Duncan JB jr strat-sized humbucker on order.
You will not be disappointed! That is a great pickup!
This video does not settle the question for me. I think the veriables are so many that we end up adapting our style and technique to the pickups,guitars and amps we play to get the most from them but they end up shaping our approach. I am ordering a Dimarzio DP 218 super distortion to put in the bridge of a Hiway 1 installed on a MIM standard with a maple back and top, I will have to wait and see where this leads but it will probably change the way I play or maybe the search will end here but I doubt it.
\\
Geez please release this music !
Thank you so much!! That would be cool to release some music but I think nobody would listen to music by a crazy swede! 😁😜
@@goodenoughguitar8824 hello again ! I sent this music/riff to some friends and they all answered o-m-g
It's a badass riff
@@turtle733 Thanks! You have some great friends! 😁
4:20 Dimarzio test begins
Open 2 windows, put 1 guitar in each, then play in 5 second clips. You will see the JB is the clear winner.
While I did prefer the clean tones of the DiMarzio when the distortion kicks in the JB has a much more aggressive and clearer sound. When the fast playing starts you can actually hear the all the individual notes being played on the JB whereas the fast stuff gets blurred and muddy on the DiMarzio.
like the dimarzio better
Both pickups would compliment each other nicely if both tracks were played at the same time and panned hard left and hard right.
Jb for melodic hardrock ..Pro track for metall..
Id say the Dimarzio makes better tone, cleaner and brighter.
I've get that in the neck position of a tele. The treble side is nice but the bass strings are muddy.
@@rsaathoff then lower the bass side of the pickup..
Hey! What value volume and tone pots are in those guitars? 250 or 500?
JB Jnr sounds great in your demo. I used the Protrack and I found the tone is very smooth and slightly boring. Dimarzio Chopper is the one I like with 250k controls, but I don't know how it compares the JB Jnr.
Both great pickups but what I find with most pickups is that they excel in one thing. If its great clean it won't nail distortion as well.
Sounds so similar to Opeth - My time of need. Thanks for the comparison. They both sound so good. Jb's have more crunchy mid-range. D'marzios have a crunchier low-mid with a more compressed sound. Jb's seen to ring more. D'ms seem to have a flatter response.
Great demo and AWESOME tune man!!
Thank you!! I'm glad that you liked the video and the music. Best wishes from Sweden! /Christian
I just ordered a G&L USA Legacy from Chicago Music Exchange. It has Bare Knuckle Apache's in neck and middle position. I had them install a SD JB Jr in Bridge. Should sound killer and should be arriving in couple days. Be playing it through my '78 Marshall JMP. It's gonna be rockin'.
Hi there, I see that you installed bare knuckle apache’s in the neck and middle and a SD in jr in the bridge of one of your guitars. How did the Apache’s work? How about the jb jr? Did they work well together? Thanks!
I prefer the Jeff Beck Jnr (red guitar). I have one in my US Strat and it's awesome! I also have a DiMarzio tone zone full humbucker in an Ibanez I own and that's pretty biting, ballsey, and not at all fizzy when distorted.
Probably the best pu test I ever seen.
You are too kind. I am just a simple guitarplayer...
Close but i went with the Pro Track
Excellent playing and pup comparison 10/10
Great video. This is what I need before where I go for. Thanks.
Thanks a lot! I´m glad you liked the video and made you´re decision i little bit easier. Have a great 2018! :-) /Christian
i literally cannot decide. the fact that these are 250k pots too are amazing. i love the higher end coming from the dimarzios so much, in the cleans AND lead/rhythm, the JB jr is a little muddier and darker to me, but i don't necessarily dislike it, i'm just so unsure of it against the dimarzio. EDIT, i put on airpods again and the JB jr wins, the laptop speakers lost a lot of definition, as to be expected lol EDIT 2: after more listening, i like the cleans on the jb jr more but the distortion on the protrack more, so i'm once again at odds
Both sound great. But I prefer the JB Junior.
Great video 👍 Dimarzio all the way for me
Thank you so much!! Best wishes from The North 😁
Jb looks better! Both sound good nice playing. DiM for your style, but I'll take the jb
Very late to this, but this comparison shows that the pickups don't matter that much, as long as a player knows what to do and how to play. Both a very, very nice tracks, hats off 😊 In the end I'd prefer the DiMarzio for being a bit softer in the midrange - but that's a matter of taste, I think 😁
such a stupid comment
Então se tem preferência é pq o captador importa
Basically, the DiMarzio is warmer, more muscle, the Duncan has more "spoink" and edge, let's your picking come through. I'm currently using the Custom Shop "Little Pearly Gates".
Great Comparison but Greater Playing awesome job!!
You have a great sound in your hands. Like!
Jb cuts better but has a flubby bass and almost sounds like ghost notes on leads, Pro track tighter fundamentals low and high but gets lost in the mix. Is there a 3rd option?
The Dimarzio is the clear winner for metal crunch and growl. The Duncan dosen’t quite make it for a proper metal pickup.
Great layering mate, well done
Wish I could get a pickup thats a cross between the two
The JB Jr has more mids, which I think work well on the full size hb version. Not sure how well that really works with ceramic on lower gain sounds. The Pro Track has a more open sound with a brighter high end (though that guitar also has maple fretboard which always makes a difference to my ears). Personally I'd prefer the Pro Track for various styles as a good all-rounder, But would go for the JB Jr if I was only gonna play high gain rock and metal and wanted solos to cut through with the mids.
Seymour mas brillante y clasico. Dimarzio no tan brillante pero cremoso especial para riff en de lo 90..
The Jrs have a great lead vintage sound (a personal preference since solo tone sounded close to In Flames's 'December Flower' solo tone) but Di Marzios do have a great modern buttery rhythm tone.
I prefer the JBJr. It has a bit more snarl to the mids that'd be more suitable for my style of playing. However the the PT does sound good for fast solos and clean passages.
Like both. Slight edge to pro track clean and slight edge to JB distorted
Exactly what I said!!
Chili SheepDog I agree
I like the SD cleans better and love the Dimarzio distortion tone better(ballsy and warm)
hi.. which one will you more prefer? And which one has more high output pickup?
Very cool comparison I like the JB JR a lot that little bastard sounds good
Hi, 250k or 500k volume pot?
Great pickup demo...are you using 0.022uf or 0.047uf capacitor for Dimarzio Pro Track?
are you using 250k or 500k pots?
great video n love ur demo. i like duncan jb jr
Thank you!! Have a great day my friend. /Christian
Hey Christian. What pot value are you using for the volume with the Pro-track? 250k? Thanks
Hello there! Thanks for watching my video! Yes, I'm using a 250k pot! Best wishes from the woods in Sweden! 😀
@@goodenoughguitar8824 Thanks from Canada 😀
@@goodenoughguitar8824 thank you! Got the answer I needed
The dimarzio seems to have a reverb to it.
Thanks for the video. Really good comparsion. I prefer SD pickup, more transparent and more interestng sound on both clean and dist. Nice tune too
Thanks! I´m glad you liked the video! /Christian
do you all 250k pots, or a mix of 250 and 500?
I think they both sound good, but the Protrack sounds brighter and the SD more bassy .....Not sure if it's the pups or the different tone woods (fret boards).....I know maple boards tend to be brighter and more trebly. I have 4 guitars with maple boards and they are definitely brighter sounding then my rosewoods.
I have a Protrack but it's in the neck position. I was trying to set my Strat up for Satch tones. Would like to hear it in the bridge position ......
Love your progression....Great tune....😎🎸🎶👍
Dimarzio is killer Pickups!!! The Best sound 🎯👉🎸🚀🚀🇧🇷
Great jam!
Ritchie Blackmore in your playing .... Nice .....
Jb Jr or Texas Special???
Need both? Put JB Jr in middle and DM in bridge \m/
Nice video. Are you using 250k or 500k with the JB Jr? Thanks.
Hi Bruce! Thanks! I am using the original 250k pot. /Christian
I prefer the JB's clean sound but the Pro Tracks Overdrive.
How about clean with no effects?
Nice playing and both sounds good, maybe SD is more transparent, DMZ more warmer...but they both sound good enough for bridge position in strat...i own Pro Truck...it is better in B position then i N
Thank you!!
I have an SSS musicman silhouette special, and I really want to pop the pro track in there. this video convinced mew to buy one, cheers dude
Its great that my video helped you to decide what pickup to choose! Cheers dude!
I have a jb it in the bridge position in my strat and it's awesome but I gotta say in this demo the DiMarzio sounds better to my ears
I have the JB Jr in my Strat and it sounds just like this demo: SD JB sounds muted 'warmer' compared to the DM Pro Track.
I think the DM Pro Track sounds better (more clarity and cut into the mix)
Larger note and more sustain in the protrack when AB at the end. Similar EQ. More shimmer and body on the soloing. Both very similar riffing. I say protrack
Dude... nice touch!
Thanks!!
Great music 🎶 👍
But I think the sound is also much depending on what fretboard you initiate the tone. You played the duncan on a rosewood and the DiMarzio on a maple neck. It's difficult to compare the pickups this way, because the fretboard deliver a very different tone. For me in the video the duncan sounded a bit fater and more accurate. It seemed to me also that the duncan has a bit more output than the DiMarzio?
However, I know that both companies build great pickups. Maybe the result would be another one, if both pickups would be played in the same guitar to compare?
Who knows? In the end its a matter of, what we like personally.
doesnt make any difference.maple fretboards and rosewood fretboards do not make sound,they just hold the frets in place.cork sniffing makes guitar sound analysis ridiculous
trillrif axegrindor sometimes it’s better to say nothing than to say something ridiculous
@@Mahavek prove it
Would love to hear this song with vocals. Great tune. As for the pickups, I'm on the fence. I mean I like both SD and DiMarzio pickups but I'm undecided
Thanks!! It would be really cool to put some vocals on this one. Do you know someone?? Maybe you have a strong voice?? ;-) Cheers from Sweden!
@@goodenoughguitar8824 I don't consider myself to have a voice fit for lead vox LOL. Nor unfortunately do I know anyone who does.
Well damn dude can play!
Yeah he's pretty badass. Very musical composition instead of some guy just shredding.
Have you tried SD little 59, its my favourite out of single sized humbuckers
I´m glad you like the track! Yes, I have tried the little 59 and that is also a great pickup!
Thats a hard pick!! jb seems more dirty sounding and the pt seems more that 70's sound more clean. kind of funny, i run DiMarzio in my strats and SD in my LP's. call me crazy but i like them both..
Pro track sits better in the mix, I hear it especially on the 16th notes.
Lord help! They're both *great* pickups. JB is warmer, maybe. Seems DM's have a slightly bit more of treble. Would only make a difference depending who is playing it. Both sound pretty amazing.
Jb had fuller tone but both was equally great sounding on leads
Killer video what's your tuning
Hi there! Thanks! The guitar i tuned in E standard. Cheers from Sweden!
What tuning are you in D?
what pedal are you using?