Ranking the NEW Commanders from Commander Masters!

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 27 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 89

  • @danielgoldberg2129
    @danielgoldberg2129 Год назад +89

    WotC crossed whatever arbitrary line I had drawn on cost and I won’t be buying new product at these ridiculous prices. They’ve made the conscious decision to market to wealthy people and I don’t want to be a part of that anymore. Comments like: “This card is now only $12!” is tone deaf.

    • @CaiusTheShadow
      @CaiusTheShadow Год назад +3

      Exactly this!

    • @arkknight92
      @arkknight92 Год назад +4

      Yea it’s pretty crazy. I’m just going to buy the singles I need!

    • @AugustAMcClung
      @AugustAMcClung Год назад +9

      $12 for a card is relative. If someone offered an OG dual for $12, I would ask “where do I line up?”. Remember, single prices are driven by the market (supply and demand)-Economics 101. The issue with WoTC is their jacking up the price on sealed product with shit for expected value.

    • @danielgoldberg2129
      @danielgoldberg2129 Год назад +11

      At my lgs last week a new player asked for my help with a new EDH deck so I looked at his deck, which was basically a pile of common cards. I suggested that he look through the stores bulk rare bin and find a better Gruul commander. He said he didn’t want to spend the 50 cents and he’d rather use the money to buy a drink. Dropping $200 for a decent mana base for an EDH deck means it has become pay-to-win.

    • @colinhofer7830
      @colinhofer7830 Год назад +4

      If they printed this stuff at normal price all the singles would cost less too.

  • @stoane7424
    @stoane7424 Год назад +10

    always love your commander ranking videos. the massive list keeps growing

  • @RL_22
    @RL_22 Год назад +10

    Really looking forward to buying singles, or even better just printing my own proxies to use!

  • @scottnixon9367
    @scottnixon9367 Год назад +5

    If Leori had green in it's cost I would be more into it. Omarthis looks like the one I will go after. Goes in my Atraxa deck perfectly. Narci looks interesting. I already saw Anikthea. She is real cool.

  • @bobfranklin2572
    @bobfranklin2572 Год назад +9

    Putting Rukarumel Biologist as a 3 for power is absolutely criminal

    • @Constrictor_Victor
      @Constrictor_Victor Год назад

      Nah most of power is gonna be coming from silvers or another busted tribe you're also running. Also it's five mana and went it dies you've got to pay 7 to stitch your two tribes together, it only goes up from there.

    • @FatstaxMTG
      @FatstaxMTG Год назад +2

      Yeah don’t look at playing the world tree, realmbreaker, rooftop storm, or any other crazy free stuff with her she’s kinda terrifying.

    • @durttheelder4035
      @durttheelder4035 Год назад

      @@Constrictor_Victor you really don't have to play slivers with her
      you can play any tribes
      you could do somthing like human tribal that also gets the buffs from warrior tribal
      she also makes it so you don't have to run any changlings for any tribal deck you were making in 5 colors
      instead just a run a good creature and now it also gets pay offs from the tribe you are running in the deck
      yes you can remove her to remove your deck synergy, but isn't that true of a lot of commanders? (I am a new player so don't bash me too hard for that question)

  • @VexylObby
    @VexylObby Год назад +3

    I think a redeemable way to make Zhulodok legendary is that the 3 titans must be replaced by another collective entity when they perish. Perhaps Zhulodok is meant to replace Ulamog's absence?

    • @codeofzero1
      @codeofzero1 Год назад

      No what zhulodok is another avatar that the eldrazi that made Ulamog made when the Hedron where weakened so that all 3 of the eldrazis could get their avatars freed
      So Zhulodok is basically the same type of eldrazi as ulamog but slightly weaker then ulamog

    • @pops91
      @pops91 Год назад

      I believe the lore of him is that it is the creator of vampires in zendikar

    • @codeofzero1
      @codeofzero1 Год назад

      @@pops91 yes he does make them to but it dose say that he is made just like how ulamog is

  • @chaosbuster1275
    @chaosbuster1275 Год назад +2

    I think Guff is stronger them you give credit for. His deck came with multiple ways to repeat planeswalker abilities. So, you could just keep copyint his -3 and burn your opponents.

  • @Kheavenn
    @Kheavenn Год назад +2

    Name Zombies with Ruka and now you have a sliver deck with the op zombie support

  • @jgtmtg
    @jgtmtg Год назад +2

    Now that there’s ANOTHER Shadow on Mia’s shirt, I must ask-how many shadows will there be in the background before we all join hands??

  • @timaeusdelpueblosecretodel6801
    @timaeusdelpueblosecretodel6801 Год назад +2

    Zhulodok could be like a greater daemon in warhammer: rotigus is still part of grandpa, but he is still rotigus.

    • @MrZer093
      @MrZer093 Год назад +2

      The fan idea I heard that I like is that this is a spawn of Ulamog that happened to be particularly brutal to the point where people felt the need to warn others about it and it eventually got a name as a result

  • @Buchaus
    @Buchaus Год назад

    Day 22 of guessing the Moxfield ad at 16:44. Somehow I feel like I'm not even close today 😂

  • @alwaysabiggafish3305
    @alwaysabiggafish3305 Год назад

    3:30 there is another card which flavour text refers to Rukarumel from several years ago, cant remember it though

  • @jasonromines7528
    @jasonromines7528 Год назад

    Ahh... I always think that I will guess where that Moxfield add is going to be and as always I was WRONG.

  • @Dracokey54
    @Dracokey54 Год назад

    Honestly the rising cost to be not competetive, but RELEVANT, is staggering. My friends who stopped playing three years ago are completely unable to get back into it since they'd have to drop at least 40-50 bucks to STILL get steamrolled at their lgs. Power creep is real and almost every lgs near me has banned proxies due to all events being wotc sponsored now

  • @RobertTheSmall
    @RobertTheSmall Год назад +1

    Mia's Tshirt is hilarious but also kinda hype

  • @geofferiswheel
    @geofferiswheel Год назад +1

    Alrighty. Let's go Nerds. Moxfield guess for today is 7:23.
    If it's Mia's birthday today, then Happy Birthday to the Shadow Hedgehog lover.

  • @codelicious6590
    @codelicious6590 Год назад

    Ill guess the Moxfield promo is immediately preceding a...two-color card.

  • @codeofzero1
    @codeofzero1 Год назад

    Zhulodok, Void Gorger is an avatar of the tame eldrazi as Ulamog, the Infinite Gyre that is why is a legendary creature also zhulodok is the reason why their are vampires on zendikari and when Ulamog was freed the force that controlled them when zhulodok toon control over most of them again and that is why as well most of the vampires side with the eldrazi

  • @derekgunnels4856
    @derekgunnels4856 Год назад

    I built an Anikthea deck. I also already had a Mishra deck, so now I'm on a quest to make all the "turn noncreature cards into creature" decks.
    Anikthea enchantments
    Mishra artifacts
    Magar spells
    Jolrael lands
    Just missing planeswalkera lol but that sounds uber bad tbh

  • @radiodemon5774
    @radiodemon5774 Год назад +2

    Is timeless dragon the best MDFC land ever printed?

  • @chickeneverythingisfine9338
    @chickeneverythingisfine9338 Год назад +3

    Hey question I asked this on another vid but what card draw would you put in the colorless deck?

    • @bobfranklin2572
      @bobfranklin2572 Год назад +1

      The one ring, and uhhh
      ...?

    • @chickeneverythingisfine9338
      @chickeneverythingisfine9338 Год назад

      @@bobfranklin2572 IKR

    • @Thoughtmage100
      @Thoughtmage100 Год назад

      I use The One Ring, Palantir of Orthanc, Mind's Eye, Eye of Vecna, Temple Bell, Howling Mine, War Room, Bonder's Enclave, and a few others I can't remember.

  • @jeremiahchamberlain4179
    @jeremiahchamberlain4179 Год назад +2

    Some of the elder spawn are becomming more relevant thats sweet leave zhul alone

  • @acetrainer8208
    @acetrainer8208 Год назад +2

    Moxfield is definitely gonna be at 8:26

  • @TubbyBubbleLove42
    @TubbyBubbleLove42 Год назад

    Do you ever update the list of commanders based on new non commander cards? Some newer cards/general power creep has made some commanders better.

  • @christopherstoeffel4811
    @christopherstoeffel4811 Год назад

    HUHHH HAPPY BIRTHDAY MIA MAYBE??? (but imagine I posted this comment on time!) [and also imagine the moxfield ad is at 6:47]

    • @NitpickingNerds
      @NitpickingNerds  Год назад

      Thank you but the next NN birthday coming up is Amber on Monday! Beezy and I both have April birthdays! -Mia

    • @christopherstoeffel4811
      @christopherstoeffel4811 Год назад

      @NitpickingNerds your shirt is a RED HERRING. Pls release a Monday video I will watch and will wish amber a happy birthday 😍

  • @fallsenseless9699
    @fallsenseless9699 Год назад

    think the sliver gravemother power rating is kinda high tbh. no real point in encoring your dead slivers when you just win the game with first sliver as soon as you cast any spell or can combo off with sliver queen and like 5 different cards. def think gravemother is an interesting take on slivers but encore requires the cards to be in the graveyard and if you've been hit with a board wipe as a sliver player you probably just lose or will lose bc no one will let you encore them.

  • @denncardoso
    @denncardoso Год назад

    Love you, folks. Nice content!

  • @chaosbuster1275
    @chaosbuster1275 Год назад +1

    Zhulodok was the essence of Ulamog unleashed when his prison was beginning to break, it was the one who spread his influence to what would become the Vampires. He was given his name by the people of zendikar who fought them.

    • @xxXDrManhattanXxx
      @xxXDrManhattanXxx Год назад

      so would you say pramikon is still the best commander for jeskai superfriends? since guff und leori dont seem that powerful

    • @chaosbuster1275
      @chaosbuster1275 Год назад +1

      @@xxXDrManhattanXxx no, Pramikon just stalls out the game, Guff and Leori actually pushes you to win.

  • @CarraTheKirrer
    @CarraTheKirrer Год назад +2

    Im very curious where Mia got that shirt lol

    • @finks1
      @finks1 Год назад

      Yeah is it her birthday??? Did Beezy forget to wish her HBD?!??

    • @NitpickingNerds
      @NitpickingNerds  Год назад

      I got it on Etsy, I got it as a joke because it was a custom shirt for like a 7 year old but they just happened to make it for adults so I got it for my 25th birthday 😂 and no, it wasn't my birthday. My birthday is very close to Beezy's! -Mia

  • @ChefKazam
    @ChefKazam Год назад

    Commander is no longer "the format for everyone"

  • @Froggyswipe8383
    @Froggyswipe8383 5 месяцев назад

    My guess is at 8:14

  • @mrjey3434
    @mrjey3434 Год назад +4

    🎉

  • @ospero7681
    @ospero7681 Год назад +1

    "How can it be its own entity? It's literally part of Ulamog. It's gonna drive me insane."
    Yep. I feel like that's kind of the point with the Eldrazi - they're literally from beyond the universe, so *nothing* about them should make conventional sense.

  • @mtgsus
    @mtgsus Год назад

    I'm glad wizards gave me so many cards recent years. Love me some white and abzan needed extra commanders for sure.

  • @bobfranklin2572
    @bobfranklin2572 Год назад +5

    These videos are probably the only time that fun, coolness, art and uniqueness will ever be seriously considered on this channel now

    • @brandonm994
      @brandonm994 Год назад +5

      Literally 5 days ago they had a video about how to make your decks fun and unique

  • @jh1716
    @jh1716 Год назад +1

    I thought they said in the commodore guff live stream that none of these cards are technically canon?

  • @tymenvanessen3119
    @tymenvanessen3119 Год назад

    i think Zhulodok would have been fine to be a nonlegendary eldrazi, with an ability stating it can be your commander, much like how planeswalker commanders work.

  • @Munchie3777
    @Munchie3777 Год назад

    I wanna build anika ^.^

  • @hughjakeman5296
    @hughjakeman5296 Год назад +1

    You guys rank the lord of the rings commanders yet? Or is that coming soon?

    • @mrjey3434
      @mrjey3434 Год назад +2

      They already did that

    • @ewpert69
      @ewpert69 Год назад +1

      bro did NOT watch the video

    • @hughjakeman5296
      @hughjakeman5296 Год назад

      Nope I'm watching it now... didnt get the memo that it was out

    • @durttheelder4035
      @durttheelder4035 Год назад +2

      @@hughjakeman5296 I don't like how quick it is
      I understand there was a lot of commanders
      but I feel like at least giving the top 10 from the set some time should happen
      maybe it's cause there is less dynamic talk/distractions/tangents
      only Beezy in that video

  • @unseeliedream42
    @unseeliedream42 Год назад

    I w i s h I had money in my wallet these days

  • @andresperez7476
    @andresperez7476 Год назад

    Bill the pony 🌅🏯🗻

  • @insertnamehere9975
    @insertnamehere9975 Год назад +1

    Did they kill joe?

    • @gemkid85
      @gemkid85 Год назад +2

      He left the show. He made a video about a month ago. It's on the channel

    • @insertnamehere9975
      @insertnamehere9975 Год назад

      @@gemkid85oh.

    • @Malverde888
      @Malverde888 Год назад

      Yes, they’re hiding from authorities while uploading daily content

  • @trueslna
    @trueslna Год назад

    This is still, imo, the weakest video series by far on this channel. Everything else is great, but this format doesn't really work for its purpose. The "fun", "coolness" and "uniqueness" scores are completely random. Even artwork ends up being random. If you like a card, you give it high "artwork" to make sure it's not dragged down to a lower spot. If you don't like a card, it might have amazing artwork but you will not give it a very high grade. "Fun", "Coolness" and "Uniqueness" end up just being mostly arbitrary, they don't seem to be scored in a vaccum. If you don't like a card, you won't give it high uniqueness even if it is super unique. If you like a card, even if it is the most un-original-but--powerful card ever, you will give it medium or high uniqueness. So, it ends up being manipulating this "scale" to get the cards to land where you would want them to.
    There are countless examples. But, just in this list, how can a card that manifests cards from the top of your library when it dies equal to its power be just a 5 for uniqueness? I would even question the 4 for coolness. How can a card that makes all your sliver have a second creature type, and crosses the streams with so many archetypes, be only a 7 for uniqueness? And 3 for coolness? It's just random. And I get it, sometimes you have to rank like 50 cards and 30 of those are boring cards that have no business being commanders, so you just score whatever.
    I get that now you are in to deep with this system to change it, but it feels meaningless from the outside.
    All the rest is great though, keep being awesome.

  • @troublemack9876
    @troublemack9876 Год назад +2

    Joe Cherries

  • @yoyohenboi7955
    @yoyohenboi7955 Год назад

    Maybe zhuloxok is a different eldrazi titan