*This video took a long time to make* if you would like to buy Paul a coffee to say thanks, link below: ☕ PayPal: www.paypal.me/TheEngineerinMindset Channel membership: ruclips.net/channel/UCk0fGHsCEzGig-rSzkfCjMwjoin Patreon: www.patreon.com/theengineeringmindset
None of us are born with the knowledge, it comes with time and effort. You're putting in the time and effort by watching something you don't yet fully grasp.
The power coming from the generator goes to a converter where the power frequency get converted to match the grid 60HZ. Insulated gate bipolar transistors and capacitors are used to achieve this. The power goes from the generator, converter, transformer, grid.
@@chrisanderson6538 This is true for small turbines in the 10s or 100s of kW. In the MW range it is almost always done by doubly fed induction generators because the converter doesn't have to pass the whole power but only a small amount to feed the rotor. This is usually in the order of the difference between the mains frequency and the rotors rotational frequency. So if you plan to have 100MW and +-10% deviation in speed, you need a 10MW converter instead of an 100MW one
Wind turbines extract energy from the rotation of the earth. This guarantees a slowing down of earth’s ration and inevitable collapse of the earths orbit round the sun … Even a few millimetres will see some real global boiling.
the mechanics part is what we hate most. also we all agree, we need a constant speed for the useable 50 or 60hz in sync. or the turbine just spins without producing exploitable 3AC. okay skip that, install a nuclear plant, problem solved. trees saved. birbs happy.
I just understood from u a whole chapter of fluid mechanics better than an entire semester in the faculty of engineering. Thank you very much fellow engineer
Great explanation of doubly fed induction wind turbines. These are referred to as type 3 wind turbines. Another method like the one used in your small scale wind turbine is too rectify and invert the variable frequency power from an induction or permeant magnet generator to the grid frequency. This is what the newer type 4 wind turbines do but they require higher capacity power electronics to do this because they are converting 100% of the wind power as opposed to only a small proportion that is being back fed into the doubly fed induction machine like in a type 3 wind turbine. The reduced cost of power electronics and lack of brushes and gears however is making type 4 more popular.
Thank you for making this video! I am a wind turbine technician and I watch this channel all the time. When i was in school this channel was great for helping me understand the basics of 3 phase electricity and power generation. Your content is very easy to understand and entertaining with all the animations. I always send people to your videos that has trouble understanding anything electrical. Its great to rewatch videos to brush up on the theory and basics from time to time. Thanks and keep up the great content
@weegal know theory and applications of both AC and DC electricity. Understand the concepts of IO systems and PLCs. Look into ethernet and fiber optic communication systems. Have a basic understanding of hydraulics. Pay good attention while they are teaching you safe climbing techniques. Most importantly be willing to learn and try to involve yourself in every job you can at the site. You will probably spend alot of time pushing a towel and cleaning things until you learn how to work safely and how things work in the real world but you don't want to rush into anything because all these systems seriously hurt you in many different ways. Working safe and coming home is most important in this industry always keep that in mind over fixing the tower. Good luck.
9 out of 10 as a windturbine technician i can confirm everything mentioned in the video. Ignoring shadow cast, lubrication and cooling of the gear, main converter. Everything else is very precise. Some Companys run there Windturbines with electric motors but some only use hydrolics to pitch or yaw the turbine.
17:17 this electrical load can also be used to vary the power output and breaking of the wind turbine as opposed to mechanical and aerodynamic breaks. Allot of smaller wind turbines use a maximum power point tracking algorithm via the the voltage on the inverter to vary the current and hence torque of the generator which can control the rotation and power output of the turbine. Small scale wind turbines can also use large variable resistors as dump loads but this is less efficient.
I grew up in imperial valley, and in great weather conditions, from the valley, you could see the silhouette of the turbine field near acorn casino. Just dozens of em, backlit by the sun easily noticeable. Now, if you go to imperial valley, many of the farms have been replaced with solar farms, and at the base of the mountains going to san diego, there is a massive wind turbine farm. Coupled with the areas numerous geo plants, the area is a hotbead of renewable energy. Thank you for finally answering one of dozens of questions i had about my homes renewble energies. This was a great video!!
i just started as a windturbine technician 8 months ago and its a really interesting job. Also most wings with variable pitch are hydraulik controlled and not with elektrik motors
I am reviewing my 5 years of engineering courses from this channel and to be honest I understood many things from “The Engineering Mindset” which I never understood during my full university years. Love this channel ❤
The way the frequency is regulated by adding/subtracting the frequency of the exciter coil is brilliant. I never realized the turbine output was synced to grid I assumed they went into some kind of controller and then that synced to the grid.
Yes your assumption is correct. There are many different methods used. For example in offshore power production the AC current can be converted into DC for transportation through the ocean. A nother method is to convert AC into DC and then back to DC with exactly 50Hz. Power electronics are quiet efficient so conversion losses are not that high.
I'm currently studying this topic during my master's, and I cannot express enough how spot-on this video is. Thanks so much for the great content; please keep it up; you are really making a difference to students!
@@egoinjury in conventional machines, you can imagine a magnet with north and south poles rotating with the prime mover (i.e. a gas turbine). So the frequency of the generator is directly proportional to the speed of the shaft. In wind turbines, imagine that the same magnet is able to rotate at a different speed than the shaft, so when the shaft is slow, the magnet will rotate to compensate for the generator to match the grid frequency (50 or 60 Hz).
@@r2d2chia sure, some sort of slip ring housing over the drive shaft I guess but how is the difference achieved? Maybe the answer is too long to explain but I’d like to know
@@egoinjury just by triggering the excitation’s SCRs to the poles in the correct rotational speed. Remember that it’s not the actual shaft speed that determines the generator frequency, but the rotation speed of the poles in the field (shaft), which in turn induce a voltage in the stator.
I worked on a site that had a huge wind turbine on the land around 50-70 feet from where I worked, it was pretty cool but very intimidating when it was rotating at speed. It did make me think if it goes wrong, someone is dying. I think they're cool but would rather not work around the potential debris field! Also, not sure how this channel wasn't suggested to me before but it was an easy sub before I finished watching your solar panels video, very clear and easy to understand as well as great visualisations, no wonder you are 3.4mil subs deep, great work and thanks.
Thank you very much for this wonderful explanation. Note, if a flywheel is used to help stabilize the frequency output, it is a simple system, simpler than electronics, feedback or a battery. Also, adding gears and a flywheel to a small turbine will greatly improve performance and reliability.
I have been working in the wind industry for years, and I have never seen a better video. This video is amazing! You guys did an incredible job putting all that information together. Thanks! Let me know if you want to translate this video into Spanish. I would be happy to help you with that for free.
This video should go in the education hall of fame. Had to pause many times because it was moving fast, but holy cow I learned everything. Great job and keep doing it just like this!!
Love hearing the "I'll explain this part later on in the video". Really engaging explanations, and to a level of detail that an engineer is looking for. Keep up the good work!
This is a great video and it explains the inner workings of these towers quite well. I actually work on the larger 1.5-4 MW wind turbine platforms for a career but never really know how the generator worked till now. The larger towers use a 2 stage planetary gearbox vs a single stage like what was shown in the video.
This channel is very informative. Has given a software developer the electronic hardware bug 😄 I am actually starting to understand this stuff all from watching your videos. The diagrams and 3d models are top quality! Keep up the good work 👍
i really love the way they change the landscape. they are very elegant and in a way futuristic and I like watching them spin. It also looks like a big ad for Mercedes, but this is an inside joke between my friends lol
There is no scientific evidence that wind turbines at sea kill whales. None. There is evidence that birds collide with wind turbines, but a tiny amount. Far more are killed by cats or air pollution or cars or flying into houses and windows. They are large, slow moving and fairly noisy structures.
Great video. I love wind turbines, prefer them offshore though I once stayed at a farm with a pretty big one and it was annoyingly loud - kept me AWAKE!
Having visited many windfarms, you literally have to be within 50mtrs of a turbine to hear it when one is at full performance. As opposed to listening to gigantic mining trucks rubbling 24/7 in nearby mines, I know which one animals prefer.
@@paulnotdownunder3172 This one was more than 50 metres away. Not by a huge amount... maybe 150 metres. Too loud to live with it, though I'm not comparing it to living next to a coal fired power station or a mine.
@@Phil_AKA_ThundyUK in Australia we have min 1.5km setbacks. I'll post a video of me standing literally under a 3.6mw turbine at full spin in a thundestorm.
@@paulnotdownunder3172 Cool. Aye in the UK onshore is effectively banned now and is by community exception only....so if a town want one they can have it but they can't be installed as part of a field of them like offshore can. For us it makes no sense to have them onshore really anyway as the offshore wind is almost always the better option. I mean here we have Dogger Bank in the North Sea where you can practically walk miles into the North Sea and it is only a handful of metres deep.
Every time I got the detail that I found fulfilling, it was followed up by another best fit detail and I was thinking why I was not anticipating that and there's how the whole experience has been nothing but satisfying.
Thanks! I had always wondered how the frequency was controlled on wind turbines. How do they parallel to the grid? Getting all those things to run in phase sounds challenging.
Speaking in general terms (it can get complicated on the micro level... so I'll stick to Macro) power produced by the generator is run through a "rectifier" (actualy an IGBT module) where the dirty AC is turned into DC. Its stored on a large capacitor bank then inverted into 60Hz by another IGBT module before leaving the turbine. The controlling circuitry has a grid moniter that watches the grid and tells the turbines IGBT module when to fire so it matches the grid. Dirty AC ----> Smooth DC ----> Clean 60Hz AC ready for use on the grid.
in canada the steps are something like this: spent massive sums of public money, pour 700m3 of concrete way up in the mountains, allow the turbines to spin in the wind for a decade before even connecting them to the grid and then likely take them down as they are already worn out. very green
Outstanding content! I'm a software engineer with some interest in electrical engineering and I can say it was quite easy to follow along. Phenomenal visualizations too!
Excellent tuturial. A lot of people don’t understand that wind turbines have to be connected to the grid to produce the required frequency. A large wind turbine thus cannot typically operate stand alone. Well done.
Fascinating i had some classes as an engineer in renewable energy but not this indebt or this clear. I remember that they said they used a synchronized motor design as the generator because it could be used to kick start the turbine. And that seems to be a half truth , the ability to feeding a frequency in to synchronize the speed to the net does sound like a better reason to have this design thant to just "bring it up to speed".
The efficiency has definitely increased, but wind is variable. True, you can have wind at night, but lately in the Antelope Valley in Southern California we've had little to no wind days except today. My house roof mounted solar panels are a great example of generating power and don't require much maintenance. If I had a LARGE piece of land I'd have both the panels and the turbine. When standing in the AV's wind turbine "farm," I noted how it sounded like a jet engine's turbine. Very interesting! Good description of operation Paul in this video!
in this day and age of short videos and concentration, i had so much fun watching this and understood it very well because of the way you illustrate things, very good job, thank you, hope you keep on going!
We got wind turbines in Gloucester MA about 7 years ago. They never even turn they’re always broken down and one even dropped an entire blade in a parking lot SMASH. Luckily nobody got killed it was the middle of the night. Then they took the rest of the blades off. Been shut down for years
I think the a bigger generator can be located on the ground. A gearbox is placed where the generator was located. Next, a long vertical shaft to turn the generator. 😎 Great video.
Please do a video on electrolysis and how that charges a battery using the different methods!! I can't find a good video to help make it make sense. Thanks for all the knowledge over the years. Keep doing God's work
You asked if i would live next to a wind turbine ? . I live on a 27 ft sailing boat my boat has two 300 watt solar panels and a 135 amp lithium battery, The system has a 400 watt wind turbine to fill in the days when there is no sun but plenty of wind. So the wind turbine contributes to my off grid system. Gerard on board, SV GEMSTAR.
Very great explanation, easy to understand. All of the major part well explained. I'd love to see the explanation of dynamic and stability aspect for the smaller wind turbine because they don't use DFIG
I never knew you could change the frequency of the output of a generator by changing the frequency of the powered stator. I though the stator was always a permanent magnet, but it now makes sense why it’s powered, cause permanent magnets cannot get any more powerful, and you cannot induce a variable rotating magnetic field in them, that’s such excellent engineering. I always thought a wind turbine would require a bulky external circuit that converts the variable frequency AC to DC and then back to the precise 60 Hz AC. Excellent. But, let’s say we have these wind turbines in a secluded place where the power consumption is very little, then converting to DC and then transmitting DC would be far more efficient than AC. There would be losses at the conversion plant that converts the DC back to AC, but in this situation, the overall efficiency of the entire system would be much higher than transmitting AC.
Here's some food for thought, why do they have to be wind turbines? based on info given to me by a guy who worked on wind turbines, the input shaft can be turned by hand by the average male. That means there is not a lot of force needed to turn it. So with that in mind, why do they have to be so far in the air and driven by unreliable wind. Why not take a simple 3 phase motor using gear reduction to make it so the motor can turn at say 500rpms and the output shaft of the reduction turn at say 10rpms. A small 3 phase motor will use much less power than the turbine puts out. Using that motor setup with say a ribbed belt that fits into grooves on pulley, like a timing belt, you could then control the motor to speed up or slow down and make as much or little power as needed. Also using that would allow you to put them right next to each other and even stack them like you do levels in a parking garage. You could literally put 50 of them in a one acre plot and still not be near as tall as one of the shortest towers now. I know there it the old saying you can't make electricity using electricity, but in this scenario, I don't see how it can't work.
At 5:45 wind is not always available when solar isn't... We often have a week or two of still frosty weather in winter... When we need energy for heating the most.
LOVE! ABSOLUTELY LOVE your videos and your down to earth explanation. I watch them for hours. gotta request though, might be a-bit outside, but how about "the 1553 Data Bus"?
Great video, but just one correction on aerofoil part. Because of it's shape, low pressure is produced on the top side and high pressure on bottom. Because pressure is different, speed is also different. It has nothing to do with longer distance.
I used to live on a hill that had a small/medium sized test wind turbine on it. This was 30 odd years ago. Don’t remember ever hearing it unless you went up to the top of the hill. Also sadly isn’t not always Sunny or windy. Sometimes it can be neither. Hence why we need ways to store energy too.
I love and work on a wind farm and I think they look beautiful and they are not very loud. Living next to an airport, train track, or even highway is much worse. Also the blades normally last the life of a wind turbine so for people worried about disposal the amount of trash from 1 person over 30 years would take more space than 1 blade. There isn’t 7 billion wind turbines. A better way to cut down on land fill space is for individuals to recycle, compost, and reduce their carbon foot prints.
There is common misconception asserted in this video. Wind turbines are more often than not constructed as a synchronous generator and not a primary supply generator. That is, they contribute to the capacity of the grid only (how many Amps the grid can supply) and still require the grid to have a base load power supply. The comparison between between a wind turbine and simple DC motor is good for understanding the theory, however it doesn't translate into reality and only leads to people believing that you only need wind turbines. Now, all this is not to say that you can't have a power generating wind turbines, but they are generally not made that because of the sheer size that would be required for such scaled application. So instead, they scale them down to be synchronous generators and contribute to maintain the overall capacity of the grid. On the whole though, really great video!
Do you have more videos available or would you be willing to make a video on the output voltage frequency sequence described in 18:00 to end of video? I am a Mechanical Engineer so I deal with this sort of thing when considering pump and fan motors especially for facilities without power conditioning or perhaps utilizing site power generation or backup power with poor frequency control. I believe the topic is Permanent Magnet vs. Induction type motors. The permanent magnet type motors make sense and that's what we learned about in undergrad but I am curious about this induction type of motor. Superposition of phase makes sense but I am having a hard time understanding how strong the rotor current needs to be and other quirks about the induction motor. You make great videos, I have learned so much from this channel! Cheers.
I would also be really interested in a deeper dive into this this is the first time I've heard of this. And I always asked myself how grid frequency is maintained.
Worth noting a lot of the bigger turbines are also moving to direct drive motors to reduce maintenance costs. As stuff like grid injection can be handled in a central location on the ground.
Not only would I live near wind turbines, but I have one attached to my home with plans to attach three more in the coming years. Add that to my solar array, also attached to my home, and I have enough power to be completely off-grid for everything but my largest shop tools. For them, I have a pair of 6.5kw generators. I believe every new home should be built with renewable energy designed into the home. The solution to the energy problem is for every household to generate as much of their own power as possible, using the grid only for the highest loads like shop equipment and large appliances.
My dream, and probably many peoples, is it be completely self sustaining. Generate my own energy as priority (no bills!), glad to hear you're heading down that route. The problem with wind turbines attached to buildings is the vibrations can cause structural damage so do be mindful of that if attaching it to your home. Better to have it's own support structure.
@EngineeringMindset I hear you.... but it's been there for 5 years now. Spun clear up to the governor and stayed there for a little under 6 hours one night. Hit dynamic braking twice.... THAT was noisy!!!! No damage. I seriously overbuilt the mounting, I think... I actually enjoy the sound of it. Whistling screaming shriek with the blade tips doing 300mph, at which point they start aeroelastic twisting as another means of controlling rotor speed. That's a WICKED fluttering whooshing sound... THAT gets some vibration, but again... I went a bit overboard building the tower and roof mounting system. I love wind and wind power. I'm looking forward to moving to Montana next year. LOTS more wind over thataway.
I understood most of the video but when he was describing how the generator works, I got a bit confused. Because of the fact that the generator does not use permanent magnets, the stator windings must need electrical power to activate the magnetic field, and if I understood the speaker, it seems that the stator gets power from the grid. If that's true then these wind turbine generators cannot produce power unless the grid supplies power to activate the generator. Is that how the generator works, or did I misunderstand something?
*This video took a long time to make* if you would like to buy Paul a coffee to say thanks, link below: ☕
PayPal: www.paypal.me/TheEngineerinMindset
Channel membership: ruclips.net/channel/UCk0fGHsCEzGig-rSzkfCjMwjoin
Patreon: www.patreon.com/theengineeringmindset
Thank you for enhancing our knowledge!
All that talk about Hertz, hurt my brain!😢
k
Where can we find that wind walking thing.
Link in video description @@pulsedmotor
As an electrician, some of what you say does go over my head when it's outside my field, but i love to learn the things I can grasp. Great channel!!!
None of us are born with the knowledge, it comes with time and effort. You're putting in the time and effort by watching something you don't yet fully grasp.
The power coming from the generator goes to a converter where the power frequency get converted to match the grid 60HZ. Insulated gate bipolar transistors and capacitors are used to achieve this. The power goes from the generator, converter, transformer, grid.
@@chrisanderson6538 This is true for small turbines in the 10s or 100s of kW.
In the MW range it is almost always done by doubly fed induction generators because the converter doesn't have to pass the whole power but only a small amount to feed the rotor. This is usually in the order of the difference between the mains frequency and the rotors rotational frequency. So if you plan to have 100MW and +-10% deviation in speed, you need a 10MW converter instead of an 100MW one
Wind turbines extract energy from the rotation of the earth.
This guarantees a slowing down of earth’s ration and inevitable collapse of the earths orbit round the sun … Even a few millimetres will see some real global boiling.
the mechanics part is what we hate most. also we all agree, we need a constant speed for the useable 50 or 60hz in sync. or the turbine just spins without producing exploitable 3AC.
okay skip that, install a nuclear plant, problem solved. trees saved. birbs happy.
I just understood from u a whole chapter of fluid mechanics better than an entire semester in the faculty of engineering. Thank you very much fellow engineer
Glad it was useful
Great explanation of doubly fed induction wind turbines. These are referred to as type 3 wind turbines. Another method like the one used in your small scale wind turbine is too rectify and invert the variable frequency power from an induction or permeant magnet generator to the grid frequency. This is what the newer type 4 wind turbines do but they require higher capacity power electronics to do this because they are converting 100% of the wind power as opposed to only a small proportion that is being back fed into the doubly fed induction machine like in a type 3 wind turbine. The reduced cost of power electronics and lack of brushes and gears however is making type 4 more popular.
Thank you for making this video! I am a wind turbine technician and I watch this channel all the time. When i was in school this channel was great for helping me understand the basics of 3 phase electricity and power generation. Your content is very easy to understand and entertaining with all the animations. I always send people to your videos that has trouble understanding anything electrical. Its great to rewatch videos to brush up on the theory and basics from time to time. Thanks and keep up the great content
Glad to hear you enjoy the channel
Hey I need your help for ai project in this domain., How can I reach out to you..........?
Im just starting the studies this week.i start from zero.could you giv me basic tips what to study so ill succeed better.
Thank you.
@weegal know theory and applications of both AC and DC electricity. Understand the concepts of IO systems and PLCs. Look into ethernet and fiber optic communication systems. Have a basic understanding of hydraulics. Pay good attention while they are teaching you safe climbing techniques. Most importantly be willing to learn and try to involve yourself in every job you can at the site. You will probably spend alot of time pushing a towel and cleaning things until you learn how to work safely and how things work in the real world but you don't want to rush into anything because all these systems seriously hurt you in many different ways. Working safe and coming home is most important in this industry always keep that in mind over fixing the tower. Good luck.
9 out of 10 as a windturbine technician i can confirm everything mentioned in the video.
Ignoring shadow cast, lubrication and cooling of the gear, main converter. Everything else is very precise. Some Companys run there Windturbines with electric motors but some only use hydrolics to pitch or yaw the turbine.
17:17 this electrical load can also be used to vary the power output and breaking of the wind turbine as opposed to mechanical and aerodynamic breaks. Allot of smaller wind turbines use a maximum power point tracking algorithm via the the voltage on the inverter to vary the current and hence torque of the generator which can control the rotation and power output of the turbine. Small scale wind turbines can also use large variable resistors as dump loads but this is less efficient.
I grew up in imperial valley, and in great weather conditions, from the valley, you could see the silhouette of the turbine field near acorn casino. Just dozens of em, backlit by the sun easily noticeable.
Now, if you go to imperial valley, many of the farms have been replaced with solar farms, and at the base of the mountains going to san diego, there is a massive wind turbine farm. Coupled with the areas numerous geo plants, the area is a hotbead of renewable energy.
Thank you for finally answering one of dozens of questions i had about my homes renewble energies. This was a great video!!
Where's your food coming from?
@@MelbourneHandyman the Central Valley, which has much more fresh water than the Imperial Valley
i just started as a windturbine technician 8 months ago and its a really interesting job.
Also most wings with variable pitch are hydraulik controlled and not with elektrik motors
I am reviewing my 5 years of engineering courses from this channel and to be honest I understood many things from “The Engineering Mindset” which I never understood during my full university years.
Love this channel ❤
The way the frequency is regulated by adding/subtracting the frequency of the exciter coil is brilliant. I never realized the turbine output was synced to grid I assumed they went into some kind of controller and then that synced to the grid.
Yes your assumption is correct. There are many different methods used. For example in offshore power production the AC current can be converted into DC for transportation through the ocean. A nother method is to convert AC into DC and then back to DC with exactly 50Hz. Power electronics are quiet efficient so conversion losses are not that high.
Inverters are expensive so skipping them is great
@@aw244The use of solid state d.c. power to 3 phase converters, also allows power factor correction to be applied which increases overall efficiency.
I'm currently studying this topic during my master's, and I cannot express enough how spot-on this video is. Thanks so much for the great content; please keep it up; you are really making a difference to students!
As a wind tech I work on the components described in this video every day. This video is spot on and a good visual guide.
I love this channel, just straight to the point, very informative without all the BS and opinions. Much more in depth than any other videos usually.
The virtual rotating magnetic field of the to rotor done by the excitation to achieve rated frequency at lower rotor speeds is just brilliant.
how does that work i didn't understand that part
@@egoinjury in conventional machines, you can imagine a magnet with north and south poles rotating with the prime mover (i.e. a gas turbine). So the frequency of the generator is directly proportional to the speed of the shaft. In wind turbines, imagine that the same magnet is able to rotate at a different speed than the shaft, so when the shaft is slow, the magnet will rotate to compensate for the generator to match the grid frequency (50 or 60 Hz).
@@r2d2chia sure, some sort of slip ring housing over the drive shaft I guess but how is the difference achieved? Maybe the answer is too long to explain but I’d like to know
@@egoinjury just by triggering the excitation’s SCRs to the poles in the correct rotational speed. Remember that it’s not the actual shaft speed that determines the generator frequency, but the rotation speed of the poles in the field (shaft), which in turn induce a voltage in the stator.
I worked on a site that had a huge wind turbine on the land around 50-70 feet from where I worked, it was pretty cool but very intimidating when it was rotating at speed. It did make me think if it goes wrong, someone is dying. I think they're cool but would rather not work around the potential debris field!
Also, not sure how this channel wasn't suggested to me before but it was an easy sub before I finished watching your solar panels video, very clear and easy to understand as well as great visualisations, no wonder you are 3.4mil subs deep, great work and thanks.
Thank you very much for this wonderful explanation. Note, if a flywheel is used to help stabilize the frequency output, it is a simple system, simpler than electronics, feedback or a battery. Also, adding gears and a flywheel to a small turbine will greatly improve performance and reliability.
I have been working in the wind industry for years, and I have never seen a better video. This video is amazing! You guys did an incredible job putting all that information together. Thanks! Let me know if you want to translate this video into Spanish. I would be happy to help you with that for free.
This video should go in the education hall of fame. Had to pause many times because it was moving fast, but holy cow I learned everything. Great job and keep doing it just like this!!
I think they're beautiful, and have no problem with them....
Yes, they are beautiful to me too.
Love hearing the "I'll explain this part later on in the video". Really engaging explanations, and to a level of detail that an engineer is looking for. Keep up the good work!
This is a great video and it explains the inner workings of these towers quite well. I actually work on the larger 1.5-4 MW wind turbine platforms for a career but never really know how the generator worked till now. The larger towers use a 2 stage planetary gearbox vs a single stage like what was shown in the video.
This channel is very informative. Has given a software developer the electronic hardware bug 😄 I am actually starting to understand this stuff all from watching your videos. The diagrams and 3d models are top quality! Keep up the good work 👍
i really love the way they change the landscape. they are very elegant and in a way futuristic and I like watching them spin. It also looks like a big ad for Mercedes, but this is an inside joke between my friends lol
I agree! I can understand the annoying moving shadows people talk about, but if they're several miles off the coast I think it just adds to the view
@@TehRealChruZ Any more news about all the whales washing up on shores near these wind farms? Or dead birds on land?
There is no scientific evidence that wind turbines at sea kill whales. None. There is evidence that birds collide with wind turbines, but a tiny amount. Far more are killed by cats or air pollution or cars or flying into houses and windows. They are large, slow moving and fairly noisy structures.
Your stuff has really reached a new level recently. Fantastic
Great video. I love wind turbines, prefer them offshore though I once stayed at a farm with a pretty big one and it was annoyingly loud - kept me AWAKE!
Yeah, I was surprised how much noise they produce when up close.
Having visited many windfarms, you literally have to be within 50mtrs of a turbine to hear it when one is at full performance.
As opposed to listening to gigantic mining trucks rubbling 24/7 in nearby mines, I know which one animals prefer.
@@paulnotdownunder3172 This one was more than 50 metres away. Not by a huge amount... maybe 150 metres. Too loud to live with it, though I'm not comparing it to living next to a coal fired power station or a mine.
@@Phil_AKA_ThundyUK in Australia we have min 1.5km setbacks. I'll post a video of me standing literally under a 3.6mw turbine at full spin in a thundestorm.
@@paulnotdownunder3172 Cool. Aye in the UK onshore is effectively banned now and is by community exception only....so if a town want one they can have it but they can't be installed as part of a field of them like offshore can. For us it makes no sense to have them onshore really anyway as the offshore wind is almost always the better option. I mean here we have Dogger Bank in the North Sea where you can practically walk miles into the North Sea and it is only a handful of metres deep.
my wife used to be a buyer for some wind farms, I always wondered how they maintained 60 hz. Great explanation!
This was absolutely amazing. Very clear and concise delivery of the information, without it becoming too much to handle.
Every time I got the detail that I found fulfilling, it was followed up by another best fit detail and I was thinking why I was not anticipating that and there's how the whole experience has been nothing but satisfying.
Thanks! I had always wondered how the frequency was controlled on wind turbines. How do they parallel to the grid? Getting all those things to run in phase sounds challenging.
Frequency converters at the bottom of the tower
Speaking in general terms (it can get complicated on the micro level... so I'll stick to Macro) power produced by the generator is run through a "rectifier" (actualy an IGBT module) where the dirty AC is turned into DC. Its stored on a large capacitor bank then inverted into 60Hz by another IGBT module before leaving the turbine. The controlling circuitry has a grid moniter that watches the grid and tells the turbines IGBT module when to fire so it matches the grid.
Dirty AC ----> Smooth DC ----> Clean 60Hz AC ready for use on the grid.
The grid also uses reactive power from the turbine ( dirty energy )so its not always clean @@calebkemplay6040
in canada the steps are something like this: spent massive sums of public money, pour 700m3 of concrete way up in the mountains, allow the turbines to spin in the wind for a decade before even connecting them to the grid and then likely take them down as they are already worn out. very green
Outstanding content! I'm a software engineer with some interest in electrical engineering and I can say it was quite easy to follow along. Phenomenal visualizations too!
Excellent tuturial. A lot of people don’t understand that wind turbines have to be connected to the grid to produce the required frequency. A large wind turbine thus cannot typically operate stand alone. Well done.
Thanks, glad you enjoyed it
Icing conditions can be very hazardous with respect to wind turbine operations. Seldom mentioned in discussions on the topic. Good Vid. Enjoyed it.🍻
Interesting point
I love how the thumbnail is a burned out husk of a wind turbine. Fires in them are actually pretty common.
the worst case scenario for a wind turbine is the best case scenario for coal plants
Fascinating i had some classes as an engineer in renewable energy but not this indebt or this clear. I remember that they said they used a synchronized motor design as the generator because it could be used to kick start the turbine. And that seems to be a half truth , the ability to feeding a frequency in to synchronize the speed to the net does sound like a better reason to have this design thant to just "bring it up to speed".
Very clever design, thanks for the video
Now that was a very interesting but rather long winded video! Well done! 👍👍💥💥
lol I see what you did there
It takes a lot of effort and time to create such a comprehensive video about wind turbines. Much appreciated ❤
Wind turbines have been my comfort structure ever since i was a kid. I was a bit of a nerd who was into building/engineering
When it comes to wind turbine, I'm a huge fan.
Probably one of the best (If not the best) video about wind turbines.
The efficiency has definitely increased, but wind is variable. True, you can have wind at night, but lately in the Antelope Valley in Southern California we've had little to no wind days except today. My house roof mounted solar panels are a great example of generating power and don't require much maintenance. If I had a LARGE piece of land I'd have both the panels and the turbine.
When standing in the AV's wind turbine "farm," I noted how it sounded like a jet engine's turbine. Very interesting!
Good description of operation Paul in this video!
I never knew such a thing as a doubly fed induction motor existed, and I found that absolutely fascinating and brilliant
Excellent video sir 👏👏
lots of love from India❤
I learn a lot about wind turbine from this channel. Really great content and somewhat easy to follow with practical demonstration
All this is so insane
This is exactly why I love Engineering
in this day and age of short videos and concentration, i had so much fun watching this and understood it very well because of the way you illustrate things, very good job, thank you, hope you keep on going!
We got wind turbines in Gloucester MA about 7 years ago. They never even turn they’re always broken down and one even dropped an entire blade in a parking lot SMASH. Luckily nobody got killed it was the middle of the night. Then they took the rest of the blades off. Been shut down for years
Thanks!
Thank you!
You have taught me allot, really has helped me around the farm
I think the a bigger generator can be located on the ground. A gearbox is placed where the generator was located. Next, a long vertical shaft to turn the generator. 😎 Great video.
Concise and insightful some complex concepts portrayed with incredible elegance.
This teaches more valuable information than any university lecture of 3 hours.
Very imformative and well construct love from Arvin
great video 👍🏻
keep it up. as an engineering student i love to watch this kind of videos
Currently commissioning the protection on 9 4.8MW turbines. They really are a site to behold
Wow the concept of the doubly fed induction generator was just genius. Very well explained, thank you!
Please do a video on electrolysis and how that charges a battery using the different methods!! I can't find a good video to help make it make sense. Thanks for all the knowledge over the years. Keep doing God's work
You asked if i would live next to a wind turbine ? . I live on a 27 ft sailing boat my boat has two 300 watt solar panels and a 135 amp lithium battery, The system has a 400 watt wind turbine to fill in the days when there is no sun but plenty of wind. So the wind turbine contributes to my off grid system.
Gerard on board,
SV GEMSTAR.
This video gave me a better understanding of Yaw and Pitch mechanism!
Thank u
What a wonderful film , these should be used in schools 😊
wow this is incredible - I am so impressed with this video... good job guys.
I was looking for a video like this in order to add more content to my report. Thanks sir Paul.
Really loving these 3d models and animations used.
It can't be more clear than this. Thank you Paul!
Brilliant video with excellent explanations.
Very great explanation, easy to understand. All of the major part well explained. I'd love to see the explanation of dynamic and stability aspect for the smaller wind turbine because they don't use DFIG
I never knew you could change the frequency of the output of a generator by changing the frequency of the powered stator. I though the stator was always a permanent magnet, but it now makes sense why it’s powered, cause permanent magnets cannot get any more powerful, and you cannot induce a variable rotating magnetic field in them, that’s such excellent engineering. I always thought a wind turbine would require a bulky external circuit that converts the variable frequency AC to DC and then back to the precise 60 Hz AC. Excellent. But, let’s say we have these wind turbines in a secluded place where the power consumption is very little, then converting to DC and then transmitting DC would be far more efficient than AC. There would be losses at the conversion plant that converts the DC back to AC, but in this situation, the overall efficiency of the entire system would be much higher than transmitting AC.
I’d love to live next to one of these. They’re terrifyingly massive, but also so cool
Here's some food for thought, why do they have to be wind turbines? based on info given to me by a guy who worked on wind turbines, the input shaft can be turned by hand by the average male. That means there is not a lot of force needed to turn it. So with that in mind, why do they have to be so far in the air and driven by unreliable wind. Why not take a simple 3 phase motor using gear reduction to make it so the motor can turn at say 500rpms and the output shaft of the reduction turn at say 10rpms. A small 3 phase motor will use much less power than the turbine puts out. Using that motor setup with say a ribbed belt that fits into grooves on pulley, like a timing belt, you could then control the motor to speed up or slow down and make as much or little power as needed. Also using that would allow you to put them right next to each other and even stack them like you do levels in a parking garage. You could literally put 50 of them in a one acre plot and still not be near as tall as one of the shortest towers now. I know there it the old saying you can't make electricity using electricity, but in this scenario, I don't see how it can't work.
One of the best material I've seen before!
Amazing explanation👏👏
At 5:45 wind is not always available when solar isn't... We often have a week or two of still frosty weather in winter... When we need energy for heating the most.
LOVE! ABSOLUTELY LOVE your videos and your down to earth explanation. I watch them for hours.
gotta request though, might be a-bit outside, but how about "the 1553 Data Bus"?
Great video, but just one correction on aerofoil part. Because of it's shape, low pressure is produced on the top side and high pressure on bottom. Because pressure is different, speed is also different. It has nothing to do with longer distance.
I work for an energy company that owns natural gas, solar and wind assets. I have a renewed (heh) appreciation for wind turbines and this video.
How does your company mix and match solar, wind and gas? Thanks.
Wish I discovered this channel before I started Engineering school, still happy I found it though
I used to live on a hill that had a small/medium sized test wind turbine on it. This was 30 odd years ago. Don’t remember ever hearing it unless you went up to the top of the hill.
Also sadly isn’t not always Sunny or windy. Sometimes it can be neither. Hence why we need ways to store energy too.
That was so complicated, but I appreciate the effort.
Nice explanation about wind turbines
Very informationally dense video, but explained so well! Thank you!
Really great video, to understand wind turbine concepts, Thanks team.
I love and work on a wind farm and I think they look beautiful and they are not very loud. Living next to an airport, train track, or even highway is much worse. Also the blades normally last the life of a wind turbine so for people worried about disposal the amount of trash from 1 person over 30 years would take more space than 1 blade. There isn’t 7 billion wind turbines. A better way to cut down on land fill space is for individuals to recycle, compost, and reduce their carbon foot prints.
There is common misconception asserted in this video.
Wind turbines are more often than not constructed as a synchronous generator and not a primary supply generator.
That is, they contribute to the capacity of the grid only (how many Amps the grid can supply) and still require the grid to have a base load power supply.
The comparison between between a wind turbine and simple DC motor is good for understanding the theory, however it doesn't translate into reality and only leads to people believing that you only need wind turbines.
Now, all this is not to say that you can't have a power generating wind turbines, but they are generally not made that because of the sheer size that would be required for such scaled application. So instead, they scale them down to be synchronous generators and contribute to maintain the overall capacity of the grid.
On the whole though, really great video!
Do you know what a synchronous generator is?
This video is mesmerizing... 👌
Do you have more videos available or would you be willing to make a video on the output voltage frequency sequence described in 18:00 to end of video? I am a Mechanical Engineer so I deal with this sort of thing when considering pump and fan motors especially for facilities without power conditioning or perhaps utilizing site power generation or backup power with poor frequency control. I believe the topic is Permanent Magnet vs. Induction type motors. The permanent magnet type motors make sense and that's what we learned about in undergrad but I am curious about this induction type of motor. Superposition of phase makes sense but I am having a hard time understanding how strong the rotor current needs to be and other quirks about the induction motor. You make great videos, I have learned so much from this channel! Cheers.
I would also be really interested in a deeper dive into this this is the first time I've heard of this. And I always asked myself how grid frequency is maintained.
Worth noting a lot of the bigger turbines are also moving to direct drive motors to reduce maintenance costs. As stuff like grid injection can be handled in a central location on the ground.
Wind turbines are a great landmark.
Not only would I live near wind turbines, but I have one attached to my home with plans to attach three more in the coming years. Add that to my solar array, also attached to my home, and I have enough power to be completely off-grid for everything but my largest shop tools. For them, I have a pair of 6.5kw generators.
I believe every new home should be built with renewable energy designed into the home. The solution to the energy problem is for every household to generate as much of their own power as possible, using the grid only for the highest loads like shop equipment and large appliances.
My dream, and probably many peoples, is it be completely self sustaining. Generate my own energy as priority (no bills!), glad to hear you're heading down that route. The problem with wind turbines attached to buildings is the vibrations can cause structural damage so do be mindful of that if attaching it to your home. Better to have it's own support structure.
@EngineeringMindset I hear you.... but it's been there for 5 years now. Spun clear up to the governor and stayed there for a little under 6 hours one night. Hit dynamic braking twice.... THAT was noisy!!!!
No damage. I seriously overbuilt the mounting, I think... I actually enjoy the sound of it. Whistling screaming shriek with the blade tips doing 300mph, at which point they start aeroelastic twisting as another means of controlling rotor speed. That's a WICKED fluttering whooshing sound... THAT gets some vibration, but again... I went a bit overboard building the tower and roof mounting system.
I love wind and wind power. I'm looking forward to moving to Montana next year. LOTS more wind over thataway.
Excellent video, thank you!
Beautifully Made ❤
Thank you very much for the video
U make understanding easy.. sometimes I do forget but easy to learn ❤😅
Great video as always! Thank you for that. Question: are the three motors in the blades powered via a slip ring?
Truly great how we have infinite energy in our face but people dont see it.. amazing keep it up human race.
I understood most of the video but when he was describing how the generator works, I got a bit confused. Because of the fact that the generator does not use permanent magnets, the stator windings must need electrical power to activate the magnetic field, and if I understood the speaker, it seems that the stator gets power from the grid. If that's true then these wind turbine generators cannot produce power unless the grid supplies power to activate the generator. Is that how the generator works, or did I misunderstand something?
Very interesting! Thank you Paul!
thanks for this informative video! nice animations and explanations
Great informative video well prepared
To increase the wind use Walls to capture large a volume of energy and concentrate it onto a central point