It could’ve been a hundred dollar dlc and everyone would have bought it. I don’t think we’ll ever get it though, rockstar’s moved on from red dead 2 so unless it’s involved in rdr3 it’s never happening
My personal headcanon is that the night before the Blackwater heist, Dutch had found himself in a tavern for a shot of liquid courage before the big day, and had gotten a bit more tipsy than he'd expected, and that night he had met the Strange Man thinking it was Trelawny, and the Strange Man is who pushed him in the direction to make the choices he wound up making.
@@StrangeManChannel A darker version of the "Lenny!" scene in RDR2. Dutch is out with Trelawny, Trelawny excuses himself to use the jakes, and the Strange Man shows up and Dutch, already sauced, thinks it's Trelawny. The Strange Man starts picking at the threads of the plan they had, innocently enough, but Dutch starts getting his wheels turning and thinking he has a better idea.
Everyone's going on and on about the Blackwater Masacre. But, honestly, the entire game is filled with more masacres. Pretty much every climactic mission in RDR2 involves some kind of massacre in a town at the end.
Between Valentine, Strawberry, Rhodes, St. Dennis, Guarma, and Annesburgh...the entire map should have an invisible sniper at that rate. Arthur's bounty is supposedly $5k when he takes Jack fishing...imagine what it is by the time he goes to get Abigail from Milton.
@@EpikgamR74 The gang didn’t massacre the entire town, and I believe only Davey in the gang eventually died as a result of injuries from BW. They also only mention “the woman on the ferry” (Heidi McCourt). The gang essentially does kill the population of Valentine and Strawberry all within Chapter 2. They’d already be the most wanted men in America before they get to Rhodes.
I’m just gonna say this, related (kinda) to the video but Dutch could’ve always sent someone like Sadie or Kieran to collect the money in Blackwater because none of the bounty hunters or Pinkertons (except maybe Ross and Milton) would have known that they were in Dutch’s gang.
He never would have trusted them to do that tho, just remember how huge the amount of money was, it would not make sense to send two newbies in a police crowded place to collect and transport such a huge amount of money
@@rokz2099 I mean, Dutch would probably think chapter four Sadie was pretty loyal, since she has no home other than the gang, and because she obliterated the O’Driscolls in their Shady Belle raid
Genuinely starting to wonder if they keep adding stuff to RDR2 without telling anyone because there seems to be so much I've missed on my multiple playthroughs.
@StrangeManChannel hey strange man... I want to know if you could do secrets of valentine If there is anything to find lol And if not.. Maybe strawberry or Saint Denis if you haven't already
Idk if anyone has noticed this but I’m replaying undead nightmare & the girl that gives you the torch mentions a Mr. Braithwaite coming back from the dead & eating animals despite him loving animals, thought it was an interesting connection, not sure which Braithwaite it would be though
Your presentation style is so good. I really enjoy watching your videos on RDR2. I recently played it for the first time about 2 months ago. And then I stumbled across your channel while looking for more lore, and I've watched a bunch of episodes since. Just wanted to say I really enjoy your work, and I hope you keep it up.
There's a train station there and a bank, the buildings u see that are in construction in the epilogue are complete in the first game, maybe that's why haha
Relativity plays a role. If memory serves (and keep in mind, this is just me talking from memory), I think in RD1 it might have been the biggest town, save maybe one in Mexico. If nothing else, it certainly was the biggest spot of the final third of the map. In RD2, though, it's smaller than St. Denis by a long shot, and probably not that much bigger than some of the other newer towns as well, so it'll seem that much smaller.
@@angbandsbane It was definitely the most modern town, and had a modern town layout as compared to the more "western" Armadillo and the cramped Mediterranean Mexican towns.
@@TanksTanksAtTanks Oh yes, absolutely. I just think it would be a great easter egg to have some notable npc be called Gavin. Maybe off the cuff remark about his friend Nigel.
It's not impossible for that journal entry to be about the strange man, but seeing as they run into Trelawny not long after that point in the game, and Trelawny says he heard about everything that happened in Blackwater it could also just be Trelawny
damn when you put them side by side, strange man does look like trelawny. However, the journal said that the man "sounded" like trelawny and they dont sound similar at all tho
Broooooooooooo there’s no way I was literally in Blackwater 24 hours ago thinking “I wanna watch a secrets of Blackwater video” & boom now you upload this 12 hours later wtaf
Josiah blackwater kinda remind me of that guy that always hangs around the saloon in valentine, even though Josiah is most definitely dead they do seem to have a resemblance😂
I know some people were giving you a hard time for it but truly I think your videos are so much better without AI voices, at least for me. It lets all the messed up things sink in more as you read them.
Recently I was riding near armadillo when a group of del lobos also riding caught my attention. I trailed behind them. They were talking about a socialist professor from the university of Mexico City. One ends up admitting he killed him and keeps his heart in a tin can. Any idea who the professor was?
@@TanksTanksAtTanks that would be an interesting theory, but if I remember correctly, he states in one of his earlier dialogues that he came from England looking after his friend
I stumbled across a friendly camper somewhere between Saint Denis & Butcher Creek, sitting and listening to his little spiel I was scoping out stuff I could steal. The usual things were available to take but there was also the jade mask sitting there.
I’ve never recorded any of my play through, and I always figure if I’ve seen it, many others before me have as well. I also could be wrong in the area I was in, but I’m pretty certain it was somewhere between the two I mentioned, I do remember it was somewhat near flowing water. I didn’t think to remember my location or anything because like I said, I’m so late at playing the game I figure anything I’ve come across has been seen numerous times before. The mask wasn’t highlighted but the female fertility statue was also one of the items the camper had, I could have taken it but I already acquired the one from the brothel. If I’m remembering the other stuff correctly, there was a bird cage and a phonograph among the campers things. If by chance I come across him again, I’ll definitely record it, I figured it was a typical encounter with a friendly camper.
Time to dive in to the mysterious creatures. like the sasquatch. the chupacabra the 4 horses ot the Apocalypse and much more of the mysterious world. (and the rarest of them all the Unicorn in Dias Coronas)
No, I don't think Strange Man was in Blackwater. It simply introduces Trelawny as being itinerant a gang member, whom you first encounter after the saloon fight where he gives information about Sean and Blackwater. For the story purposes, this justifies you not being able to go to Great Plains, and definitely not the town of Blackwater.
7:02 I really hope we get to see The Blackwater Massacre one day with The Strange Man. 7:39 Insert Spiderman pointing at Spiderman meme here with The Strange Man and Trelawny. 7:51 Gavin!! 8:00 I find it funny all while John and Nigel are talking the lady is just standing there watching them as she fans 🪭 herself.
Doing the story for the fourth time. Your clips gave made it soo much easier. Sick of dying to damn cougars fir the challenge. When ya want em,cant find em, when ya dont need em. Surprise!😂
Strange man i just want to say i love your videos and please tell me are u satan himself the grim reaper or god? i love your vid though bro and all the details u find and put into these vids love u man❤️
Recently just started another play through of rdr2 and man it’s still so great after all these years. They don’t need to i guess but i wish they made the ps5 update for it. I mean they released gta v multiple times so why not give this one a fresh coat of paint too.
what does dutch means when he say that her mother manage to have the last laugh even from the grave? im sorry im not good at english and I dont understand the meaning of the metaphor of it.
i believe its because they all want to go back to blackwater for the money that was left there but cant cause they are wanted. Dutch's mother being where they want to be is why she got the last laugh.
![Shenseea - Dating Szn (Options) [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/eUePmZFIXUg/mqdefault.jpg)
2:28 Blackwater civilian: "Mommy, why does that man keep pointing his gun at street signs?"
"Well, dear, that's just a Strange Man."
😅
The blackwater massacre could've easily been a 40 dollar DLC, and everyone would've bought it and ofc undead nightmare 2
It could’ve been a hundred dollar dlc and everyone would have bought it. I don’t think we’ll ever get it though, rockstar’s moved on from red dead 2 so unless it’s involved in rdr3 it’s never happening
@@Ncpsteve123 rdr 3 has been rumored to be in development a year ago, so it looks like that's gonna be their next entry after gta 6
@@skxlter5747 knowing rockstar it’ll be 2100 by the time we get it
R* only cares about money and they can milk more out of microtransactions from whales.
Cowboys and aliens would have been better.
My personal headcanon is that the night before the Blackwater heist, Dutch had found himself in a tavern for a shot of liquid courage before the big day, and had gotten a bit more tipsy than he'd expected, and that night he had met the Strange Man thinking it was Trelawny, and the Strange Man is who pushed him in the direction to make the choices he wound up making.
Imagine playing as Dutch while all of this is happening, too.
@@StrangeManChannel maybe in RDR 3 😀
@@StrangeManChannel A darker version of the "Lenny!" scene in RDR2. Dutch is out with Trelawny, Trelawny excuses himself to use the jakes, and the Strange Man shows up and Dutch, already sauced, thinks it's Trelawny. The Strange Man starts picking at the threads of the plan they had, innocently enough, but Dutch starts getting his wheels turning and thinking he has a better idea.
😮
Everyone's going on and on about the Blackwater Masacre. But, honestly, the entire game is filled with more masacres. Pretty much every climactic mission in RDR2 involves some kind of massacre in a town at the end.
Yep, and they even have another robbery-shootout on another boat so I think that's got it covered.
Between Valentine, Strawberry, Rhodes, St. Dennis, Guarma, and Annesburgh...the entire map should have an invisible sniper at that rate. Arthur's bounty is supposedly $5k when he takes Jack fishing...imagine what it is by the time he goes to get Abigail from Milton.
But the black water massacre was basically a hell hole everything and everyone was dead or they had to run
@@EpikgamR74 Yeah... just like every other shootout in every other town you go to in the game.
@@EpikgamR74 The gang didn’t massacre the entire town, and I believe only Davey in the gang eventually died as a result of injuries from BW. They also only mention “the woman on the ferry” (Heidi McCourt). The gang essentially does kill the population of Valentine and Strawberry all within Chapter 2. They’d already be the most wanted men in America before they get to Rhodes.
This is S tier content. Each of these videos must take so much work to produce. Respect.
I’m just gonna say this, related (kinda) to the video but Dutch could’ve always sent someone like Sadie or Kieran to collect the money in Blackwater because none of the bounty hunters or Pinkertons (except maybe Ross and Milton) would have known that they were in Dutch’s gang.
He never would have trusted them to do that tho, just remember how huge the amount of money was, it would not make sense to send two newbies in a police crowded place to collect and transport such a huge amount of money
@@rokz2099 I mean, Dutch would probably think chapter four Sadie was pretty loyal, since she has no home other than the gang, and because she obliterated the O’Driscolls in their Shady Belle raid
Josiah Blackwater is basically a reference and based from another frontier legend, David "Davy" Crockett.
Including the "you can all go to hell and I'm going to St. Denis" (Texas) line...
I think the video should have ended with the yelling of "Gavin" in the background. Gets me everytime 😂
Genuinely starting to wonder if they keep adding stuff to RDR2 without telling anyone because there seems to be so much I've missed on my multiple playthroughs.
Naw its been there since launch, I've found most of them in 2019, you just haven't been exploring much
@@skxlter5747 Sure bud.
Didn’t the civil war hat use to be called civil war cap instead of civil war hardee hat
@GetaMotion you might be thinking of the military forage cap which is also a civil war hat.
I've played it many times and I'm still finding new stuff. It's insane just how huge and detailed this game is.
went back and noticed that you’ve finally returned to your original format. Love this!
You always pay close attention to details, amazing all the things you find. Thanks for another fun and interesting watch Strange Man! 😊
Thank you so much! I'm really happy you enjoy the content and thank you for the continuous support, ThatOneChick. 🖤
@StrangeManChannel hey strange man...
I want to know if you could do secrets of valentine
If there is anything to find lol
And if not..
Maybe strawberry or Saint Denis if you haven't already
Idk if anyone has noticed this but I’m replaying undead nightmare & the girl that gives you the torch mentions a Mr. Braithwaite coming back from the dead & eating animals despite him loving animals, thought it was an interesting connection, not sure which Braithwaite it would be though
the freaking transition from nigel to bad voodoo was so good i love that song man
Saturdaynight. I'm once again having a rum and coke. Both the kids and wife are asleep. A new upload from Strange Man. The planets have aligned.
Already? Where do you live? Poland?
Hope you enjoyed the rum and coke! 🥃
You have to watch RUclips in secrecy? Sad.
This scrub again
Your presentation style is so good. I really enjoy watching your videos on RDR2. I recently played it for the first time about 2 months ago. And then I stumbled across your channel while looking for more lore, and I've watched a bunch of episodes since. Just wanted to say I really enjoy your work, and I hope you keep it up.
Don't ask me why but Blackwater feels much more big in the first game.
There's a train station there and a bank, the buildings u see that are in construction in the epilogue are complete in the first game, maybe that's why haha
It is bigger in the first game, rdr2 epilogue happens before rdr
Relativity plays a role. If memory serves (and keep in mind, this is just me talking from memory), I think in RD1 it might have been the biggest town, save maybe one in Mexico. If nothing else, it certainly was the biggest spot of the final third of the map.
In RD2, though, it's smaller than St. Denis by a long shot, and probably not that much bigger than some of the other newer towns as well, so it'll seem that much smaller.
Probably because RDR2 has Saint Denis and Saint Denis is bigger than Blackwater.
@@angbandsbane It was definitely the most modern town, and had a modern town layout as compared to the more "western" Armadillo and the cramped Mediterranean Mexican towns.
The editing on this is flawless
The quality of your videos is incredible. Thank you for making these.
I hope Gavin turns up in the next RDR game xD
I think I read that Gavins friend was schizophrenic and Gavin doesn't actually exist. But if that isn't true it would be cool to see Gavin.
@@TanksTanksAtTanks Oh yes, absolutely. I just think it would be a great easter egg to have some notable npc be called Gavin. Maybe off the cuff remark about his friend Nigel.
Ive played RDR2 for years and there's still things ive yet to discover that you have in this video. Thanks.
It's not impossible for that journal entry to be about the strange man, but seeing as they run into Trelawny not long after that point in the game, and Trelawny says he heard about everything that happened in Blackwater it could also just be Trelawny
damn when you put them side by side, strange man does look like trelawny. However, the journal said that the man "sounded" like trelawny and they dont sound similar at all tho
Sounded like as in the way he had was described sounded like him
I wish the game started with us playing as Dave’s Callander for a prologue during the blackwater massacre before the gang to refuge in the mountains
Broooooooooooo there’s no way I was literally in Blackwater 24 hours ago thinking “I wanna watch a secrets of Blackwater video” & boom now you upload this 12 hours later wtaf
Your vids are always top shelf.
Awesome production and editing style on this, great work
what an upgrade in video edditing and the would to do further ! Really great ! Big up for the next buddy !!
Josiah blackwater kinda remind me of that guy that always hangs around the saloon in valentine, even though Josiah is most definitely dead they do seem to have a resemblance😂
what a coincidence. just started with the epilogue and am now able to visit blackwater for the first time today
I love these videos. Would you consider making videos on Rdr1 lore
Music you chose for the Aztec writings segment was a banger.
Moby song. It's in Undead Nightmare
@@jasonrist6582 It's not Moby, it's "Stinkin Zombies" by Misterio lol
@@michelle.pearl. It's "Bad voodoo" by kreeps
I know some people were giving you a hard time for it but truly I think your videos are so much better without AI voices, at least for me. It lets all the messed up things sink in more as you read them.
You wrong for making the screen shake for that thicccy thiccc thiccc npc at the end 🤭.
I can't wait to see all the videos your gonna do on GTA 6 😌
I think Strange Man is the Gavin that everyone is looking for
1:16 looks like dude with racoon hat from Valentine
First day of summer, UCL final and Strange mman posts? The best day ever
Borussia: i have... a GOD DAMN PLAN!
Bvb needed one big score
Recently I was riding near armadillo when a group of del lobos also riding caught my attention. I trailed behind them. They were talking about a socialist professor from the university of Mexico City. One ends up admitting he killed him and keeps his heart in a tin can. Any idea who the professor was?
Great video, as always!
Always thought that was Jebediah Springfield
"A Noble Spirit Embiggens teh Smallest Man!"
Next secret guarma
Mountain Banjo is my favorite RDR2 song
i loooooove this man,love this videos love your work you make my day better
The bull horn trinket is one secret that I did not know about. Shame it cannot be collected.
Posted 47 seconds ago ! Let's get 'er done ! Hey strange man, Lots of love from Newfoundland and Labrador xx 💖💖💖
Nigel not finding and still looking for Gavin for 8 YEARS is so sad
I read Nigel is schizophrenic and Gavin isn't real. It would be sad if he died and still didn't “find” gavin
@@TanksTanksAtTanks that would be an interesting theory, but if I remember correctly, he states in one of his earlier dialogues that he came from England looking after his friend
Get ready when gta 6 is comes up with many many and many Easter eggs for our guy to solve them all 🔥🔥🔥😤
Those NPCs aren’t obese they are in the final stages of Lumbago! 😢
I stumbled across a friendly camper somewhere between Saint Denis & Butcher Creek, sitting and listening to his little spiel I was scoping out stuff I could steal. The usual things were available to take but there was also the jade mask sitting there.
what? Butchers creek and saint denis Are Pretty far away could u pick it up? U should take a vid if u can
I’ve never recorded any of my play through, and I always figure if I’ve seen it, many others before me have as well. I also could be wrong in the area I was in, but I’m pretty certain it was somewhere between the two I mentioned, I do remember it was somewhat near flowing water. I didn’t think to remember my location or anything because like I said, I’m so late at playing the game I figure anything I’ve come across has been seen numerous times before. The mask wasn’t highlighted but the female fertility statue was also one of the items the camper had, I could have taken it but I already acquired the one from the brothel. If I’m remembering the other stuff correctly, there was a bird cage and a phonograph among the campers things. If by chance I come across him again, I’ll definitely record it, I figured it was a typical encounter with a friendly camper.
Time to dive in to the mysterious creatures. like the sasquatch. the chupacabra the 4 horses ot the Apocalypse and much more of the mysterious world. (and the rarest of them all the Unicorn in Dias Coronas)
Micah wasn’t with the Pinkertons before chapter 4
Love your vids
8 years on and that dude STILL looking for Gavin. Smdh
Awesome video
You forgot an essential piece from RDR1. The Serendipity ferry was from Tallulah Jetty.
It actually makes sense that they didn't include the obese characters - obesity was supposedly pretty rare back in those days.
I love your videos keep them up and here's a like 👍
Main St was named after the Main Quest in the game. Fun Fact
Imagine the GTA universe was part of the red dead universe. Imagine hearing characters mention, Liberty City, San Fierro, and San Andreas.
I love the name of this town since RDR I; such a cool and even mysterious name
No, I don't think Strange Man was in Blackwater. It simply introduces Trelawny as being itinerant a gang member, whom you first encounter after the saloon fight where he gives information about Sean and Blackwater. For the story purposes, this justifies you not being able to go to Great Plains, and definitely not the town of Blackwater.
If co ck star would invest more in rdr2 they would have doubled maybe tripled their monney easely
Isn't Josiah Blackwater just the guy with the raccoon hat in Valentine's saloon? 🤔
I believe Dutch may be stashed the blackwater ferry money in his mothers grave.
Amazing :)
GAVIINNN
WHERE ARE YOU GAVIN
GAV!
Shame how much Undead Nightmare 2 was teased, but it won’t happen :(
Dinner worth content
The Strangeman is figment of John' imagination and apparently a RUclips audience.
Pretty sure Trelawny and Strange Man are the same type of reaper/entity.
Ngl he mysterious as the gman
Fun Fact : I call my coffee “BlackWater”
I want to make a funny comment so I get alot of likes, here I go, "Lumbago".
we got a comedian over here
It's very serious john
what are you some kind of wise guy?
Dead meme
@@skxlter5747 killed by Lumbago
7:02 I really hope we get to see The Blackwater Massacre one day with The Strange Man.
7:39 Insert Spiderman pointing at Spiderman meme here with The Strange Man and Trelawny.
7:51 Gavin!!
8:00 I find it funny all while John and Nigel are talking the lady is just standing there watching them as she fans 🪭 herself.
I love you strange man
Unpopular opinion: Bad Voodoo is my fav rdr soundtrack
Same, my favorite song. It hurts me so much to think Rockstar won't consider making Undead Nightmare 2 ;-;
Doing the story for the fourth time. Your clips gave made it soo much easier. Sick of dying to damn cougars fir the challenge.
When ya want em,cant find em, when ya dont need em. Surprise!😂
Last clip was violation 😂
Strange man i just want to say i love your videos and please tell me are u satan himself the grim reaper or god? i love your vid though bro and all the details u find and put into these vids love u man❤️
Blackwaters kin he was the Child of Blackwater
Recently just started another play through of rdr2 and man it’s still so great after all these years. They don’t need to i guess but i wish they made the ps5 update for it. I mean they released gta v multiple times so why not give this one a fresh coat of paint too.
guessing josiah blackwater isnt in rdr1? cause in that game the name of the town is definitely a joke based on some kind of diarrhoea disease
Bazinga
What's the name of the song during the "Aztec Writings" section?
I always see that josiah Blackwater is ver looklike to jebediah springfield
Kifflom, brother-brother
nice music stranger!
Let me know when that guy finds Gavin.
Im gonna miss this game so much once GTA 6 comes out with all their goofy unrealistic stuff.
I thought he would include the supermarket glitch lol. Has it been fixed though?
What's the music at 9:00?
I don’t visit blackwater that often, very interesting video.
tell me if Red Dead 3 will come out after GTA6 like a Year
The obese NPC I’ve met was the Aberdeen guy
the real secret is I freaked it in Blackwater
Thank god there is narration!
what does dutch means when he say that her mother manage to have the last laugh even from the grave?
im sorry im not good at english and I dont understand the meaning of the metaphor of it.
i believe its because they all want to go back to blackwater for the money that was left there but cant cause they are wanted. Dutch's mother being where they want to be is why she got the last laugh.
Rdr “2”
Takes place b4 rdr
whats the track at @0.37
I try.. today thank bro
You're the best.