Correction in regards to Nougaku Performers: They did not always wear black, and would sometimes sit in a chair. We thought anything other than the traditional form would be considered Kyogen. Sorry about that! Thank you to everyone for your massive support! Stay tuned for more! 酔っ払いの日米ハーフとその妻が、 アサクリシャドウズのワールドトレーラーにツッコミをいれてみました。 お楽しみいただけたら幸いです。 もしよければコメントも残していっていただけると嬉しいです！
You know who wouldn’t admit making a mistake but would call an “expert” to prove they are right and you are all racist? Hint: it’s a French company and makes video games😂
@zzodysseuszz And you have just shown everyone your mental age. I mean the "zz" at the start and end kinda shows that. It's what kids do lmao. Id see that back on mw2 on the ps3. Not sure what you mean by "casual" like that's a negative thing or has any actual meaning since you specifically targeted it for that and being over rated lmao. Game did well because it was good. Get over it, stop being passive aggressive. Everyone can hop on and enjoy. That's the point, and a good thing. More can enjoy it. You don't need hours to grind for stuff or to progress. When you say casual and over rated you sound like such a loser being negative because people enjoyed something. As if they're different for enjoying something. Toxic child mindset. I've played countless "hard" games. Beaten every souls game, mortal shell on the 1 hit mode, so? I play them casually because I sit comfortably on my sofa. Every game is literally casual, it's up to you how you alter that experience
I like how Ubisoft brought this out like a kid brings a crayon picture to their parents like, “ look what I did!” And the parents are like “you’re 35 years old!Get out of my house!”
- Ubisoft : We have added Japanese music to the game! - Japanese : this is Chinese music... - Ubisoft : We have added Japanese folk instruments - Japanese : this is Chinese instruments... - Ubisoft: We have added Japanese architecture to the game. - Japanese : but this is Chinese architecture! - Ubisoft: Who cares, you're all Asians the same, don't be racist! Yes, Ubisoft screwed up, even for me, a Ukrainian, in some places it hurts to look at how they confuse Japanese and Chinese culture, where of course there are similar aspects, but the culture differs like the German from French. And I'm sure if they made a game about France they wouldn't show German culture in it. I hope Ubisoft won’t make a game about Ukraine, otherwise we’ll all be playing balalaikas and wearing earflaps)
I mean, they did a game about France with Unity. And it seemed pretty damn spot on, like the Notre Dame reconstruction had help from the game since it is so faithful and well made in the game.
I'm Italian and to me the Ezio trilogy is a huge love letter to Italy which also made me visit many of the locations in real life (e.g. Monteriggioni). It of course wasn't a documentary of the historic events but it gave you a jumping off point to learn more about history. The fact that we waited so long for a Japanese setting that has such a great fit just to be offered this slop is such a disappointment and a real insult to all fans but especially Japanese ones who deserve what I felt with AC2.
It really shows how far ubisoft has fallen. At one point they were so dedicated to being accurate it was said their game could help rebuild the notre dame after the fire, now they try to feed us this trash.
I feel the same way. I will tell everyone I meet to play Ghost of Tsushima over Shadows ANY DAY. Shadows is an absolute embarrassment. My heart goes out to the Japanese.
15:27 For the record, as an animal geek I can tell, they DID NOT USE THE RIGHT NOISE for the grey herons. Instead they're actually using the red-crowned crane noises.....🤦♂🤦♂🤦♂
@@DashBlue well thank you for your reply.🙏 And FYI, the actual grey herons make harsh raspy squawks, which is why both Suda Masaki and Robert Pattinson did a squawky voice dub in 君たちはどう生きるか.
I used to be a games journalist a decade ago and I remember hearing a lot of talk about people (developers) leaving Ubi after AC: Unity. As far as I know it was the last game made by the people who made Assassins Creed games great. With Unity they had a solid vision yet the management pushed them to release an unfinished game to coincide with the new console launch window. That decision, as far as I know, made many people (who were there from Prince Of Persia days) get a whiff of what was coming and they left. I know some felt as though they didn’t belong in this new era of gamedev, some decided to retire early, others moved to the indie scene. AC Shadows is the latest manifestation of what Ubi is nowadays. The care, intention and drive of those Sands Of Time days are gone. It’s sad. I wish it was a video of you guys happily enjoying and being surprised by the quality of the game, but alas, the torch has been passed on. Thank god not all is lost and games like Ghost of Tsushima exist. Ubi is not Ubi. Even though it’s their mission to pretend, to stand on the shoulders of all the great work those people did with early AC games so they can maintain their brand image and sell new products. So I also thank god for folks like you, who are making such videos to point out that the king is actually naked. ❤
Yeah I heard that actually greatly delayed some of their projects. It's why the feel of the games is so different now too. It's literally not the same devs.
This is one of the reasons why asking for games like Splinter Cell and Ghost Recon is just not even worth it anymore. They don't know how to make a good game like the original developers did. I really love your word choice, very poetic. Thank you so much for the kind words!
@@Hibernapepretty sure there are contracts drawn so they can not talk bad about Ubislop. And I'm sure all those original devs are working in silent, away from spotlight until the date ends. Try looking for statement from former devs and employees, you find very few or none at all.
You can't rule out Chinese influences doing this on purpose. Mocking ones history is right out of their propaganda playbook. It's not laziness. it's mocking you.
@@DashBlue That's really cool of you to do that, i mean we all know he's going to turn this into a 2hour video. It was really funny to see him move the camera every 2 seconds tho lmao
@@DashBlueiirc I came to your channel because he couldn’t move his mini screen often enough to satisfy my interest in the video he was reacting to. Credit to you guys finding issues in the trailer in every quadrant.
this game is like a gift shop made to sell to gulible tourists, this t-shirt "I love japan" very authentic, hand made, 100% bamboo, seal for proof that it comes from japan. 80$.
@@hoshi314 that was basically the whole genre of assassin creed till roughly the AC Origins (2017) game, you want to visit France during the French revolution? then AC Unity is for you (just expect a lot of bugs), you wish to visit America during the seven years war? then AC Rogue is for you, London during the industrial revolution? AC Syndicate, Constantinople after the fall of the Byzantine Empire? AC Revelations, Italy during the Italian wars? then AC Brotherhood if I remember correctly one of the articles that was made about the first games essentially stated that the whole point of the Assassin Creed games was to essentially show off the history (in "macro-historical" term) of the places they visited to inspire young gamers to become interested in history. of course that was before they had a soft-reboot in 2017 where they seemed to have drunk the "slow but in French" elixirs (I still say that AC IV Black Flag is the best game they have made, it was so good that Ubisoft created a off-shoot game project called Skull and Bones; they failed rather severely on that one)
To me what's crazy is the fact that when Ghost of Tsushima was made it got flack for being created by a western studio despite the fact that the team actually did research and created a game that was fun but still managed to be respectful to the history of the setting but then we have Ubisoft who is being pushed so hard by every mainstream news source simply because they have a black main character despite them clearly showing that they do not care to be somewhat accurate let alone respectful.
for westerners it is hard to notice this is not japan, especially after many years of movies and games mixing traits from all asian countries together. They should have hired real japanese historians/experts to guide them
@@marcogenovesi8570 I disagree. Any time you get involved in a project like this, and do research, it's impossible not to notice the differences. They must have done no research at all and created models from memory based on what they saw in a movie. That, or even worse, they thought that Americans would not like actually Japanese architecture because it doesn't fit their idea of what "Japanese" is.
@@CrizzyEyes You don't "create models from memory" at this level of graphical fidelity. The actual 3D artists and animators need plenty of photos to use as a template of what they had to make. Also in big productions you don't have random people do google searches on their own. Each team is fed the media they need as a template by the creative leads (that will have to gather that with their own team and the consultants if any). All workers here are french and I have strong doubts any of them have any idea of the differences in asian architecture or how a rice field works. Somebody at the creative lead team did a bunch of google searches without really understanding, any consultant they hired didn't notice either, so the media was passed to the workers that are french and have zero ability to tell if this is accurate or not. And any subsequent check on the work done also was not done by anybody remotely competent so again it was not caught later either.
They should have just made Yasuke an informant to the assassins. Played on the whole “Hes more of a commodity” and he uses that to his advantage. Slowly learning japanese and giving the assassins information that Nobunaga and his allies spout around him cause they dont think he understands. Though maybe the conflict is that he does respect Nobunaga (through decent character writing that Ubisoft isn’t capable of) and you end up having to fight Yasuke at the end due to trying to kill Nobunaga. Ubisoft can get their checkbox and the damage they did in “respecting history” wouldnt be as egregious.
It's funny because right now we don't even know just how far they went with the story. For all we know he might be primarily Nobunaga's lover. It's also an interesting aspect of how we could use the ambiguity. Like we know that he understood some Japanese but we can estimate that the skill was limited. We know that he was strong but maybe he would participate in sumo. Heck, we don't even know how he spent his money. All of these questions could be a good basis for a story. For example, if he had to sneak because he couldn't be seen (we have a historical account of him attracting way too much attention). If he had to guess what's going on because he couldn't understand nor read everything. Would it be unlike Assasin's creed? Maybe, but why call it the 'perfect candidate' for a protagonist then..
That does sound like a cool way to use him as a character. Even if they wanted him to play a combat role I feel it would have been more fun for him to have a fighting style that doesn't conform to any particular discipline. He's from abroad and nobody knows much about him so he really could have an advantage in that area - but no, they had to go and make him a straight up samurai
As an American who moved to Japan over 2 years ago (being half Japanese my self) its really interesting having insight into both cultures, which has given me a better understanding of how much Ubisoft has defaced Japanese culture and history in order to be "inclusive". they claim its historically accurate but there is only a single "real" historical report and its vague at best. Ubisoft has shown they don't care about being respectful about Japan's religion or culture. I dearly hope it comes to bite them in the butt either legally or by other means. btw I'm very glad to have discovered this channel through Asmong and Ubishit's fuck up. I hope you keep up the very entertaining content.
Ubisoft is based in Montreal. The people who made this game are mostly FRENCH Canadians, the worst type of combo. French are very well known to be very ignorant AND arrogant.
The only thing they did here for inclusivity is picking yasuke for mc. The rest has nothing to do with inclusivity it's just lack of research and them being dumb enough to think they didn't need to consult an actual Japanese historian to ensure the accuracy of the depiction of Japan. It's due to a mix of the arrogance westerners tend to have when interacting with other cultures and Ubisoft's own brand of arrogance thinking they can just make fastfood games and present/price it as a gourmet game.
@@amuro9624 And Ubi-slop daring to call it a AAAA game????? I once visited Korea and barely saw the countryside while there, and came to appreciate WHY Korean geography is in so many games. The voice line for the Korea course in "Cruisin' Exotica" is "Korea is beautiful!" Totes true. :D
I really like the dynamic of this channel, having two hosts speaking (mostly) two separate languages but being able to fully understand each other. I hope I can achieve that level of fluency in a second language someday. Keep up the analysis - these videos are very enlightening to the "real" _(non-Ubi)_ Sengoku Japan!
Even the Japanese can really learn a lot. UBI said in an interview with a Japanese game magazine that it was fiction based on facts, so I'm struggling to confirm what is true.
@@satotot3739 this is not surprising There are scholars in Japan who stand up and say "Yasuke is a real samurai" Then within a few days, it was discovered that this Japanese scholar’s identity and academic qualifications were all fake. Moreover, the company he works with has financial relationships with financial institutions that promote DEI. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ What’s even more interesting is that this fake Japanese scholar is a Communist member.
People can say "this is nit-picking" or "its unimportant details", but when its literally every detail, every frame, everywhere you look.... this is just embarrassing.
Yeah, couldn’t possibly be they are looking for things to complain about and so hyper fixated on the most consequential shit. Like that light source in the mountains that they said why is it there you’d have to climb up to it to light it. Yeah, it’s a Assassins Creed video game and those are probably there to draw players eyes towards points of interest. It’s not trying to create a fully realistic Japan but a video game set in Japan. Liberties will be taken for gameplay reasons. You could do this for every game set in a real world location but I suspect that the comment section wouldn’t be so happy if the game was developed by From or Rockstar. This is nothing but rage bait using certain gamers hate of Ubisoft.
@@BAD7667i agree that some of these are little nitpicks. but a lot of these are details that they should’ve gotten right, especially the architecture. it’s assassins creed, a game known for its historical accuracy, some of these details are just straight up wrong and yes they’re small, butting getting them right wouldn’t take that much more effort , so why are they wrong? older assassins creed really nailed the small details that brought these time periods to life, this game is just shitting all over it.
Everyone saying that "Naoe was Japanese hence this is a Japanese story with a black guy" are now absolutely wrong, it's a Japanese game with black and Chinese protagonists, wtf ubi
Ubi is counting on Western "tourist" who don't know anything about Japan accepting everything they say as, "This is the authentic Japan of this time period!" And to think, many years ago, Ubi was actually a decent company. How the mighty have fallen. That said, great and humorous video.
I know, right. They used to be one of my favorite game companies at the time until they slowly fell around... Ghost Recon (2001) Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell (2002) Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time (2003) Beyond Good & Evil (2003) Far Cry (2004) Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory (2005) Assassin's Creed (2007) Far Cry 2 (2008) Assassin's Creed II (2009) Far Cry 3 (2012) Watch Dogs (2014) Ghost Recon: Wildlands (2017) Then, around 2020, everything collapsed for them, I believe. It's as if COVID took out their best employees or something and now they don't know what to do and gave certain tasks to those who are unskilled for the job. It's got to be it. I just can't see other reasons for that.
It's funny coz across various social media platforms, it seems westerners are the ones who give the most positive feedback on trailers and act as staunch defenders of the game. Clearly they don't care about giving Japanese culture the respect it deserves, regardless if the game doesn't need to be historically accurate or not. They just care about the game looking cool. 😂
Yeah, Ubi can only fool those normies who know nothing about Japan, Japanese culture and watch atrocious Americanized dubs of anime. Otherwise, a true Otaku who knows both the good and bad of the Japanese culture which he got during his quest for knowledge about the land of anime can never fall for this shit.
I mean, the reactions from your wife were so cute and funny. When I first saw promotions for this game, I got angry, and I'm glad to see other Asians trashing this game.
Thank you for recommending Sakuna of Rice & Ruin!!!! I love playing Xseed games I never knew this one exist besides the Story of Seasons/Harvest moon titles!
I feel like the mix of English with Japanese and subtitles is such a perfect way to learn conversational Japanese. Add into the fact we get history lessons basically. Subbed!
As a Japanese who has studied Noh for a bit, among the Hayashikata (taiko, otsuzumi, kotsuzumi, and flute), the otsuzumi and kotsuzumi players (the two in the middle) sometimes sit on chairs. Also, looking at old picture scrolls, it seems that the musicians do not necessarily wear black kimonos. However, as someone who learned to play the taiko, I was concerned that he was not playing the drums properly. lol Sorry for my poor English… Anyway, I always astonish your knowledge about Japanese culture and history and enjoy your videos about AC Shadows! Please keep uploading videos like this!
@@AbystomaMexicanium Yeah this is a trailer they edited for release, not random gameplay clips.... and it's this crappy? Some of the errors would be forgivable if this was a demo play at a trade expo, but it's NOT.
@@marhawkman303 I'd say that the option of "they just don't care anymore" would be even worse reality for Ubisoft. Like at this point we can only argue whether it's bad or worse lol.
I can totally imagine a situation where the employee in charge of making the trailer just didn't care at all and stuck a bunch slop together out of spite thank you for watching!
This game is also developed by the same studio that worked on Odyssey, and that game had so many things wrong such as the inaccurate portrayal of the Persians, one of those inaccuracies with the Persians was also established lore since AC2 with one of those statues where you get the armor of Altair. I believe that one was for sure out of spite against Iranians, this company has always been questionable.
@@redcobra6016I am just glad, that the first real flop of the AC series was in their own country with Unity. That game was a mess and a half, on day 2 I logged on for the first time and my buddy took me to abuse a online mission for a bit just to instantly have enough currency to buy the best weapon after about an hour of play time…. Absolute trash, I quit the game 2h later
@@x2may374 obviously! Those games were good and that’s all they have to be! Putting an actual historical figure as main character however, is such a retarded move, that I am still baffled by it.
Sakuna does not just have farming mechanics, it also has 2d action platforming mechanics, with a cool combo system. If you like games like Castlevania or Metroid you'd probably like it.
Love how you guys shouted out Sakuna. Such a great game. Because that was also what came through my mind instantly when the drainage system for the rice was mentioned
I love this channel already. My wife is also Japanese, and I think your channel is very friendly towards a couple like us if we were the target audience. I'll be sure to watch it with her when she gets here once her US immigrant visa is approved and she comes to the States to live with me.
came here from Asmon, stayed for the content. love the banter with your half and both your roasts and comedic timing are impeccable. it's hilarious, and on top of that, we learn stuff. cheers folks ! keep doing what you are doing ! We can feel you're both having so much fun. That's what I really like. it's awesome! Greetings from France!
Literally found you a day before Asmon's video, wanted a native's take on AC:Shadows. Thought you guy were great and underappreciated, definitely needed more attention, and presto Asmon found you. Congrats guys on your growth, keep it up...
it also automatically keeps the water level constant, by teleporting water in or out of the field as needed. No water system necessary. Truly a wondrous species of rice
Another guy here who came from Asmon's video about your video. I've got to say, your channel is a real gem. I love the dynamic between you too, the fact that your wife speaks almost exclusively Japanese adds a lot to it, your editing skills are really clean, and I'm actually learning something! Finding fun, quality channels like yours really makes my day. Sub well earned!
Those are the things most players wouldn't pay attention to, but by exposing it, it really shows much respect and effort Ubisoft is putting into their product... absolutely pathetic by Ubisoft.
I really enjoy looking at the finer details in a game and thinking about the deeper aspects to them. This game went so overboard that I had to make some videos about it lol thank you for watching!
Месяц назад+17
your wife is so funny 🤣🤣🤣 the ubisoft staff joke had me cackling from the start. i knew this vid was gonna be great
9:22 in Thailand we have both black and green bamboo shoot both are same species Rough Giant Bamboo but we breed them to make 2 type of bamboo shoot so maybe they just ref from asian bamboo
About bamboos, they don't grow leaves on the culm itself but it grows branch nodes on the culm first then leaves sprout from there. I see this a lot in bamboo but again, in this trailer, it boils down to sloppiness, which affects the immersion. I remember a Japanese commenter replied to me once about Japanese sword forging and he said that forging is done indoors during the day so it will help blacksmiths see the color of the flame clearly, which is impossible outdoors. In addition, I was weirded out when fantasy Yasuke was practicing Karate as Karate is Okinawan and at the time Yasuke was in Japan, the Ryukyu Kingdom (present day Okinawa), was an independent kingdom until 1609, when the Satsuma clan invaded it. So, there is no way karate was already in the mainland. In fact, the samurai were more versed in disarming and throws, which were the basis for Jujutsu (where Judo, Aikido and BJJ originated) since opponents are in armor and strikes wouldn't work.
Ubisoft continues to belittle, provoke, and insult Japan. The fact that they don't know "the real thing" is easily understood by the Japanese when they see the trailer, and it is terrible. It's Azuchi Castle, but the stone walls still exist. The real thing doesn't have this high stone wall. The way of stacking stone walls is completely different. This alone shows that there is no on-site investigation in Japan. It's like a cheap plastic model. 安土城ですが石垣は現存しています 現物はこんなに高い石垣を築いてはいません(笑) 石垣の積み方もまったく違いますね これだけでも日本で現地調査はしていない事が丸わかりです 格安のプラスチック模型を参考にしたような感じです
専門家はダートマス大学の助教授、Sachi Schmidt-Horiっていう人だと思う その専門は中世日本における男性同士の性的関係とかジェンダー・アイデンティティの分析のようだ まあ個人的にそのような学問の分野に反対ではないが戦国時代のゲームの顧問にふさわしい人物かどうかはちょっと怪しいと思うんだけどｗ それでもダートマス大学はSchmidt-Hori氏のコンサルティング活動を支持する声明を掲載した。ここに直接リンクが貼れないが、「STATEMENT IN SUPPORT OF ASCL PROF. SACHI SCHMIDT-HORI 」とググればすぐ出てくるだろう
the only expert mentioned by Ubisoft so far is Sachi Schmidt-Hori, which is an american professor of japanese literature that focuses on weird sex and gender things in middle age japan. She does not seem qualified and is probably not enough to oversee thousands of people employed by Ubisoft making this game
@@JuanjoPP "Assistant professors" are basically frauds here in the US. It is a nominal title given to anyone the university likes, with no regard to credentials or qualification. They have no requirements to teach courses.
they actually used a Japanese ''expert''. You gotta understand just because someone is Japanese, that doesn't mean they know every single thing about Japanese history as is the case with the so called expert they used
I adore the way you two bounce off each other, even in different languages. Do you film in one language and cover in another, or are both fluent enough to keep up? The style is very unique and fun.
We mix English and Japanese in our speech, the edits are taken from a single session of recording Makes the editing chaos because I have to subtitle so many things lol Thank you for the kind words!
Correction in regards to Nougaku Performers: They did not always wear black, and would sometimes sit in a chair. We thought anything other than the traditional form would be considered Kyogen. Sorry about that!
Thank you to everyone for your massive support!
Stay tuned for more!
酔っ払いの日米ハーフとその妻が、
アサクリシャドウズのワールドトレーラーにツッコミをいれてみました。
お楽しみいただけたら幸いです。
もしよければコメントも残していっていただけると嬉しいです！
man so damn good!, nice done
@@Dumber0 thank you for watching!
Love your vids! Also at 17:05 I think that hand position is a chinese calligraphy hand position...
This channel is a hidden gem. 🗿💯
You know who wouldn’t admit making a mistake but would call an “expert” to prove they are right and you are all racist?
Hint: it’s a French company and makes video games😂
Finding your channel is the only good thing to come from Assassins Creed Shadows tbh ✨
thank you so much lol
we appreciate the kind words!
true!
Lmao so true. It brought a community together 😂
you mean only good thing come from bugsolf.
@@S-treme *bugisoft 🤣
These trailers just make me appreciate Ghost of Tsushima more.
totally agree, Ghost of Tsushima is a masterpiece
thank you for watching!
@@DashBlueit’s overrated garbage for casual players. Though it’s visuals were pretty
@zzodysseuszz And you have just shown everyone your mental age. I mean the "zz" at the start and end kinda shows that. It's what kids do lmao. Id see that back on mw2 on the ps3.
Not sure what you mean by "casual" like that's a negative thing or has any actual meaning since you specifically targeted it for that and being over rated lmao. Game did well because it was good. Get over it, stop being passive aggressive.
Everyone can hop on and enjoy. That's the point, and a good thing. More can enjoy it. You don't need hours to grind for stuff or to progress. When you say casual and over rated you sound like such a loser being negative because people enjoyed something. As if they're different for enjoying something. Toxic child mindset.
I've played countless "hard" games. Beaten every souls game, mortal shell on the 1 hit mode, so? I play them casually because I sit comfortably on my sofa. Every game is literally casual, it's up to you how you alter that experience
@@zzodysseuszzL take ghost is good
Best game.
I like how Ubisoft brought this out like a kid brings a crayon picture to their parents like, “ look what I did!” And the parents are like “you’re 35 years old!Get out of my house!”
😂😂😂
I love this comment lol
thank you for watching!
"Does that mean that it's not going on the refrigerator then, mom?"
- Ubisoft : We have added Japanese music to the game!
- Japanese : this is Chinese music...
- Ubisoft : We have added Japanese folk instruments
- Japanese : this is Chinese instruments...
- Ubisoft: We have added Japanese architecture to the game.
- Japanese : but this is Chinese architecture!
- Ubisoft: Who cares, you're all Asians the same, don't be racist!
Yes, Ubisoft screwed up, even for me, a Ukrainian, in some places it hurts to look at how they confuse Japanese and Chinese culture, where of course there are similar aspects, but the culture differs like the German from French. And I'm sure if they made a game about France they wouldn't show German culture in it. I hope Ubisoft won’t make a game about Ukraine, otherwise we’ll all be playing balalaikas and wearing earflaps)
I mean, they did a game about France with Unity. And it seemed pretty damn spot on, like the Notre Dame reconstruction had help from the game since it is so faithful and well made in the game.
@@vanaak9070 THEN DO THAT WITH THIS GAME this is like a parallel universe... twilight zone japan
@@dudechillout I'm pretty confused by your comment. The guy said "If they made a game about France". There is one game about France and it's unity
@@vanaak9070 he's saying to give the same treatment for this game like they did with unity
@@vanaak9070 Ubisoft is a French company. Go figure.
町を歩いてる人間が町人の恰好してる人間が一人もいない。
姫カットの女ばっかだけど、あれは姫様クラスの人であって、町人は髪を結うんやで。
髪を結んでいないバサバサの当時の女性には違和感ありますね
直江の髪型も近代すぎてふざけてるように日本人にはみえます
コメントありがとうございます。
高貴な人たちばかり歩いていましたね。そういう街なのかもしてません…
UBIは犬夜叉でも読んだ方がいい。
姫カットじゃなくて町人カットじゃん
RESPECT THE RICE!!!
Spoken as an asian.
Asian code of life
thank you for watching!
Rice was the payment of the samurai.
RICE FOR LIFE!
Uncle Roger endorses that message.
The rice must flow!
I'm Italian and to me the Ezio trilogy is a huge love letter to Italy which also made me visit many of the locations in real life (e.g. Monteriggioni). It of course wasn't a documentary of the historic events but it gave you a jumping off point to learn more about history. The fact that we waited so long for a Japanese setting that has such a great fit just to be offered this slop is such a disappointment and a real insult to all fans but especially Japanese ones who deserve what I felt with AC2.
It really shows how far ubisoft has fallen. At one point they were so dedicated to being accurate it was said their game could help rebuild the notre dame after the fire, now they try to feed us this trash.
His games are overall the best of the series.
I'm jealous that the Italian setting during UBI's heyday was recreated in a game.
UBIの全盛期にイタリア舞台をゲームで再現してもらって羨ましい。
I feel the same way. I will tell everyone I meet to play Ghost of Tsushima over Shadows ANY DAY. Shadows is an absolute embarrassment. My heart goes out to the Japanese.
I've been wanting JP AC since since I beat AC3 on XB360, such a massive disappointment that we'll never get a true japanese assassin
15:27 For the record, as an animal geek I can tell, they DID NOT USE THE RIGHT NOISE for the grey herons. Instead they're actually using the red-crowned crane noises.....🤦♂🤦♂🤦♂
oh my god you can't be serious...
thank you for telling me, I hope to hear from you again for more animal analysis!
@@DashBlue well thank you for your reply.🙏
And FYI, the actual grey herons make harsh raspy squawks, which is why both Suda Masaki and Robert Pattinson did a squawky voice dub in 君たちはどう生きるか.
Truly an "American Bald Eagle screech" moment
These look like Great Blue Herons from North America lol I see them all the time, eating chipmunks, frogs and fish.
Wikipediaにはアオサギの声が聞けるアーカイブがある
彼らが弥助の根拠にしている大好きなWikipediaをアオサギについて調べなかったのは冗談だ
I used to be a games journalist a decade ago and I remember hearing a lot of talk about people (developers) leaving Ubi after AC: Unity. As far as I know it was the last game made by the people who made Assassins Creed games great.
With Unity they had a solid vision yet the management pushed them to release an unfinished game to coincide with the new console launch window. That decision, as far as I know, made many people (who were there from Prince Of Persia days) get a whiff of what was coming and they left. I know some felt as though they didn’t belong in this new era of gamedev, some decided to retire early, others moved to the indie scene.
AC Shadows is the latest manifestation of what Ubi is nowadays. The care, intention and drive of those Sands Of Time days are gone. It’s sad.
I wish it was a video of you guys happily enjoying and being surprised by the quality of the game, but alas, the torch has been passed on. Thank god not all is lost and games like Ghost of Tsushima exist.
Ubi is not Ubi. Even though it’s their mission to pretend, to stand on the shoulders of all the great work those people did with early AC games so they can maintain their brand image and sell new products. So I also thank god for folks like you, who are making such videos to point out that the king is actually naked. ❤
Yeah I heard that actually greatly delayed some of their projects. It's why the feel of the games is so different now too. It's literally not the same devs.
This is one of the reasons why asking for games like Splinter Cell and Ghost Recon is just not even worth it anymore. They don't know how to make a good game like the original developers did.
I really love your word choice, very poetic.
Thank you so much for the kind words!
Any news on where those old Ubi folks are now? Did they form a new studio or just end up scattering here and there?
I always considered Unity to be the last good game, so this makes so much sense
@@Hibernapepretty sure there are contracts drawn so they can not talk bad about Ubislop.
And I'm sure all those original devs are working in silent, away from spotlight until the date ends.
Try looking for statement from former devs and employees, you find very few or none at all.
このゲームに中国の、相当古い時代の笛が出るということは、UBIは日本の「戦国時代」と古代中国の「春秋戦国時代」を混同しているのだろうか?
コメントありがとうございます。
中国春秋時代との混同説、大いにあり得そうです…！
很有可能，因为这个乐器在中国也是属于原始人才吹的玩意🤣，中文和日文里战国时代的汉字是一样的，一肯定ubisoft在google的时候直接混在一起了😅
Does it look like I speak BLOODY CHINESE
You can't rule out Chinese influences doing this on purpose. Mocking ones history is right out of their propaganda playbook. It's not laziness. it's mocking you.
AI told them so
"ASMON CAM HERE" Glad you've prepared a nice spot for Asmon. Great analysis video once again!
yeah I saw he had trouble with camera placement lol
thank you so much!
@@DashBlue That's really cool of you to do that, i mean we all know he's going to turn this into a 2hour video.
It was really funny to see him move the camera every 2 seconds tho lmao
@@DashBlueiirc I came to your channel because he couldn’t move his mini screen often enough to satisfy my interest in the video he was reacting to. Credit to you guys finding issues in the trailer in every quadrant.
only for Asmon to pause the video and proudly stare at his camera for about 30 seconds in total victory lmao. Great vid brother
I wonder if he will even notice that in the intro
this game is like a gift shop made to sell to gulible tourists, this t-shirt "I love japan" very authentic, hand made, 100% bamboo, seal for proof that it comes from japan. 80$.
hahaha
you know what? i'll take your thought on this, this is basically a "Tourist Trap" game
What a perfect analogy, you gotta start writing it down 😂 I see great comedy shows in your future my man
@@hoshi314 that was basically the whole genre of assassin creed till roughly the AC Origins (2017) game, you want to visit France during the French revolution? then AC Unity is for you (just expect a lot of bugs), you wish to visit America during the seven years war? then AC Rogue is for you, London during the industrial revolution? AC Syndicate, Constantinople after the fall of the Byzantine Empire? AC Revelations, Italy during the Italian wars? then AC Brotherhood
if I remember correctly one of the articles that was made about the first games essentially stated that the whole point of the Assassin Creed games was to essentially show off the history (in "macro-historical" term) of the places they visited to inspire young gamers to become interested in history. of course that was before they had a soft-reboot in 2017 where they seemed to have drunk the "slow but in French" elixirs (I still say that AC IV Black Flag is the best game they have made, it was so good that Ubisoft created a off-shoot game project called Skull and Bones; they failed rather severely on that one)
一品すぎる例え😂
最近、京都にある日本家屋の中国人経営のカフェ（外観はめちゃくちゃ純日本）が、シャトレーゼ（工場直売の全国チェーンのお菓子屋）のお手頃価格のケーキを高価格で転売して炎上してたけど、日本人はどこのケーキかすぐ気付くので、外国人を対象に騙してたっぽいんですよね。
UBIといい日本文化って、悪い外国人の金儲けに利用されるんだなぁと。
Ubisoft don't care about sacred places.
so true
their own offices are tainted
thank you for tuning in!
..or gamers
With Ubisoft's special training only available for trans people I'm not even surprised they don't care about traditions
actually what even do they care about? It doesn't even seem to be money...
@@Norwolf2097 If they cared about the money, they won't be making a game like this.
To me what's crazy is the fact that when Ghost of Tsushima was made it got flack for being created by a western studio despite the fact that the team actually did research and created a game that was fun but still managed to be respectful to the history of the setting but then we have Ubisoft who is being pushed so hard by every mainstream news source simply because they have a black main character despite them clearly showing that they do not care to be somewhat accurate let alone respectful.
ゴーストオブツシマって本当にリスペクトの塊だったんだなぁ
皮肉
こうして比較すると、比べるのが申し訳ないくらいの差がありますね。
コメントありがとうございました。
I'm forever impressed how your wife has this hyperfocus for detail while drunk. It's like her super power quirk or something!
Japanese people really relax when drunk. That is why they notice stuff like this. Believe me, I know.
thank you for the kind words!
the alcohol activates the inner hawk lol
@@Tchudwell my girlfriend doesn’t, because she has very strong asian flush and gets super drunk only after a little of nihonshu.
Found you by Asmon, stayed because of immensely great content. Keep it up!
thank you so much for the support!
Same here 😊
Found the channel right before Asmon's video... probably due to the algorithm boost he gave it lol
全てのシーンに違和感があるのが逆にすごいｗ
丁寧な解説で面白かったです！
本当に問題点しかなくてびっくりですｗ
ご視聴ありがとうございました！
唯一、水の表現だけは良いなと思ったけど…オブジェクトの意味を考えないで雰囲気で置いてるから違和感を生むのかな？と思った。米俵とか。
これだけ細かくやっているつもりでも抜けあるんだから
ある意味凄いよね…違和感しかないゲー
なんか、AIで出力した絵を無理矢理3Dにしたような違和感ですよね…
能面が面じゃなくて被り物になってるし、般若（女性）なのに山伏（男性）の服装だし…
そうだ、山伏だ…！
ポリコレ最先端な戦国時代ということ…？
コメントありがとうございました。
"The green bamboo shoot,
Metal armor in blizzard,
Fire fish rooftops."
-Ubisoft, probably
are you missing a syllable in the last line?
@@joe4339 Fire is two syllables. I guess?
Though it'd also be in character for ubisoft to screw up a haiku.
@@natchu96 I've heard ir both as one or two syllables.
"Chinese, Korean, Japanese, same difference" - Ubisoft
Did nobody ask the question of "is this actually japanese?"
they probably used ai to do research but was all just hallucinations
for westerners it is hard to notice this is not japan, especially after many years of movies and games mixing traits from all asian countries together. They should have hired real japanese historians/experts to guide them
@@marcogenovesi8570 I disagree. Any time you get involved in a project like this, and do research, it's impossible not to notice the differences. They must have done no research at all and created models from memory based on what they saw in a movie. That, or even worse, they thought that Americans would not like actually Japanese architecture because it doesn't fit their idea of what "Japanese" is.
@@CrizzyEyes You don't "create models from memory" at this level of graphical fidelity. The actual 3D artists and animators need plenty of photos to use as a template of what they had to make.
Also in big productions you don't have random people do google searches on their own. Each team is fed the media they need as a template by the creative leads (that will have to gather that with their own team and the consultants if any).
All workers here are french and I have strong doubts any of them have any idea of the differences in asian architecture or how a rice field works.
Somebody at the creative lead team did a bunch of google searches without really understanding, any consultant they hired didn't notice either, so the media was passed to the workers that are french and have zero ability to tell if this is accurate or not.
And any subsequent check on the work done also was not done by anybody remotely competent so again it was not caught later either.
Yes men don't question. Also stop buying demo's they are supposed to pay ppl to test their games not the other way around
They should have just made Yasuke an informant to the assassins. Played on the whole “Hes more of a commodity” and he uses that to his advantage. Slowly learning japanese and giving the assassins information that Nobunaga and his allies spout around him cause they dont think he understands. Though maybe the conflict is that he does respect Nobunaga (through decent character writing that Ubisoft isn’t capable of) and you end up having to fight Yasuke at the end due to trying to kill Nobunaga.
Ubisoft can get their checkbox and the damage they did in “respecting history” wouldnt be as egregious.
yeah if it was a blatantly fantasy story and they advertised it as such from the beginning it would've gone a lot better
thank you for watching!
@@DashBlueOf course man, you and your wife? girlfriend? Have good chemistry. Also pretty damn funny with the objective criticisms.
What you suggested to do with Yasuke is way more logical and sounds like a intriguing plotline.
It's funny because right now we don't even know just how far they went with the story. For all we know he might be primarily Nobunaga's lover.
It's also an interesting aspect of how we could use the ambiguity. Like we know that he understood some Japanese but we can estimate that the skill was limited. We know that he was strong but maybe he would participate in sumo. Heck, we don't even know how he spent his money. All of these questions could be a good basis for a story. For example, if he had to sneak because he couldn't be seen (we have a historical account of him attracting way too much attention). If he had to guess what's going on because he couldn't understand nor read everything. Would it be unlike Assasin's creed? Maybe, but why call it the 'perfect candidate' for a protagonist then..
That does sound like a cool way to use him as a character. Even if they wanted him to play a combat role I feel it would have been more fun for him to have a fighting style that doesn't conform to any particular discipline. He's from abroad and nobody knows much about him so he really could have an advantage in that area - but no, they had to go and make him a straight up samurai
As an American who moved to Japan over 2 years ago (being half Japanese my self) its really interesting having insight into both cultures, which has given me a better understanding of how much Ubisoft has defaced Japanese culture and history in order to be "inclusive". they claim its historically accurate but there is only a single "real" historical report and its vague at best. Ubisoft has shown they don't care about being respectful about Japan's religion or culture. I dearly hope it comes to bite them in the butt either legally or by other means.
btw I'm very glad to have discovered this channel through Asmong and Ubishit's fuck up. I hope you keep up the very entertaining content.
Ubisoft is based in Montreal. The people who made this game are mostly FRENCH Canadians, the worst type of combo. French are very well known to be very ignorant AND arrogant.
The only thing they did here for inclusivity is picking yasuke for mc. The rest has nothing to do with inclusivity it's just lack of research and them being dumb enough to think they didn't need to consult an actual Japanese historian to ensure the accuracy of the depiction of Japan. It's due to a mix of the arrogance westerners tend to have when interacting with other cultures and Ubisoft's own brand of arrogance thinking they can just make fastfood games and present/price it as a gourmet game.
@@amuro9624 And Ubi-slop daring to call it a AAAA game?????
I once visited Korea and barely saw the countryside while there, and came to appreciate WHY Korean geography is in so many games.
The voice line for the Korea course in "Cruisin' Exotica" is "Korea is beautiful!" Totes true. :D
I really like the dynamic of this channel, having two hosts speaking (mostly) two separate languages but being able to fully understand each other. I hope I can achieve that level of fluency in a second language someday. Keep up the analysis - these videos are very enlightening to the "real" _(non-Ubi)_ Sengoku Japan!
金継ぎ笛のシーンは二人で並んで吹いてるけど金継ぎされとる場所が同じなので（同じ場所が壊れる？）金継ぎを粋な補修じゃなく完全に単なる絵付けデザインと思ってるよねぇ。動画で指摘されてる通りなんで尺八にしなかったんでしょうね。
自然のオブジェクトも盆栽見たいな木も葉っぱが針葉樹じゃないし、たぬきぽい動物も赤毛でレッサーパンダに見えるしRUclipsなんか見ればすぐわかる様なものまで調べてないのがまるわかりですよね。
コメントありがとうございます。
枝のようにもみえるのですが、どうなんでしょう？
また、楽器を金継ぎしたら音程変わるんではというコメントもいただき、確かにと思いました（やってみようかな…笑）
あちらさんの完成でアジアンテイストなものを切り貼りしたものを、歴史的に忠実なファンタジーとして販売されても困惑しかないですね。
ナオエの前の塤(Xun)はCGでは有りません。
現代中国の塤の画像を加工して、そのまま使っています。
拡大して明るくするとはっきり分かりますよ。
あと、今とは違って、この時代にショートヘアーの成人女性は居ませんよ。
なぜか見落とされてるんですよね。
PLZ SAY OCHINCHIN SAMURAI FOR ME
@ミントミルクティー-q3v ＞水戸黄門でもなんでもいいから時代劇を見てくれ
指コンサル「ちゃんと見ましたよ、新幹線も軽バンも走ってましたね」
尼さんならショートも有りだろうが、尼さんはそこら辺をフラフラ出歩いたりしないんだわ。
服装も地味な普段着を捲りあげたら暗器が出てくるみたいなギミックが理想的なんだが、デフォルトでこの格好はホント不審者。500歩譲って傾奇者。
(歴代主人公のデザインを踏襲したい意図は理解する)
しかも半袖の右裾を襷がけで摘んでいるので、右腕上がらないと思う。
奈緒江なんて名前の人もいないだろうね
歴史知ってたら絶対直江兼続が先に来るし、当時の女性名は一文字が基本だ
コメントありがとうございます。
塤が浮き出て見えるのはそのせいなんですね。
奈緒江の忍べていない見た目に関しては、一番はじめの動画でも言及しております。せめて歩き巫女だろ…と。まああの外見はアサクリのシンボルでしょうから、そこはゲームとして許容してあげなくもない…と思ってます。
沒有日本美學，每一幕場景都有著只是堆疊3D素材跟把認知的亞洲元素放進去的不協調感
侘、寂、幽玄、物哀、渋み，那是一種文化與品味，人文跟美學融合而成的，那不是google搜尋出圖片，或是AI產圖可以展現出來的
UBI的遊戲讓我覺得像是大學生，遊戲就是每一年一次的作業發表
Even the Japanese can really learn a lot.
UBI said in an interview with a Japanese game magazine that it was fiction based on facts, so I'm struggling to confirm what is true.
繁体字からおそらく台灣の方とおみうけしました
さすがよく日本をわかっていらっしゃる
@@satotot3739 this is not surprising
There are scholars in Japan who stand up and say "Yasuke is a real samurai"
Then within a few days, it was discovered that this Japanese scholar’s identity and academic qualifications were all fake.
Moreover, the company he works with has financial relationships with financial institutions that promote DEI. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
What’s even more interesting is that this fake Japanese scholar is a Communist member.
とりあえず日本っぽいものをAIで作っただけの様にしか見えないですね
People can say "this is nit-picking" or "its unimportant details", but when its literally every detail, every frame, everywhere you look.... this is just embarrassing.
Yeah, couldn’t possibly be they are looking for things to complain about and so hyper fixated on the most consequential shit. Like that light source in the mountains that they said why is it there you’d have to climb up to it to light it. Yeah, it’s a Assassins Creed video game and those are probably there to draw players eyes towards points of interest. It’s not trying to create a fully realistic Japan but a video game set in Japan. Liberties will be taken for gameplay reasons.
You could do this for every game set in a real world location but I suspect that the comment section wouldn’t be so happy if the game was developed by From or Rockstar. This is nothing but rage bait using certain gamers hate of Ubisoft.
@@BAD7667i agree that some of these are little nitpicks. but a lot of these are details that they should’ve gotten right, especially the architecture. it’s assassins creed, a game known for its historical accuracy, some of these details are just straight up wrong and yes they’re small, butting getting them right wouldn’t take that much more effort , so why are they wrong? older assassins creed really nailed the small details that brought these time periods to life, this game is just shitting all over it.
Everyone saying that "Naoe was Japanese hence this is a Japanese story with a black guy" are now absolutely wrong, it's a Japanese game with black and Chinese protagonists, wtf ubi
Except Naoe looks like mix of Vietnamese and Korean ethnicity. Japanese people especially around that time hardly had jaw line like that.
町人？らしき連中が誰も刀持ってなくて草生える。刀狩りは信長か伝説のスーパーチャドサムラーイがやった？
最初に刀狩りをしたのは柴田勝家、後にやったのが豊臣秀吉。時代が狂っとるw
なお当時の農民は奪略目的で戦に参加してました。
農民は普通に武器を持ってる為、馬鹿領主が農民に重税噛ますと一向宗のハゲが一揆煽るか農民がぶちギレて自発的に領主に土一揆かます為話の最初に出てきた変なババアが怪しい初見の余所者に愚痴る前に終わる可能性大。伝説のスーパーチャドサムラーイはいらないことになる為ゲームが始まらない模様。
プロットの始めからやり直してどうぞ
Ubi is counting on Western "tourist" who don't know anything about Japan accepting everything they say as, "This is the authentic Japan of this time period!" And to think, many years ago, Ubi was actually a decent company. How the mighty have fallen.
That said, great and humorous video.
I know, right. They used to be one of my favorite game companies at the time until they slowly fell around...
Ghost Recon (2001)
Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell (2002)
Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time (2003)
Beyond Good & Evil (2003)
Far Cry (2004)
Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory (2005)
Assassin's Creed (2007)
Far Cry 2 (2008)
Assassin's Creed II (2009)
Far Cry 3 (2012)
Watch Dogs (2014)
Ghost Recon: Wildlands (2017)
Then, around 2020, everything collapsed for them, I believe. It's as if COVID took out their best employees or something and now they don't know what to do and gave certain tasks to those who are unskilled for the job. It's got to be it. I just can't see other reasons for that.
It's funny coz across various social media platforms, it seems westerners are the ones who give the most positive feedback on trailers and act as staunch defenders of the game. Clearly they don't care about giving Japanese culture the respect it deserves, regardless if the game doesn't need to be historically accurate or not. They just care about the game looking cool. 😂
Tbf lots of their veteran dev and employees already replaced
Yeah, Ubi can only fool those normies who know nothing about Japan, Japanese culture and watch atrocious Americanized dubs of anime. Otherwise, a true Otaku who knows both the good and bad of the Japanese culture which he got during his quest for knowledge about the land of anime can never fall for this shit.
Yeah they really need to saying it's authentic in any way. It's more fantastical than Willy Wonka
thank you so much for watching!
I mean, the reactions from your wife were so cute and funny. When I first saw promotions for this game, I got angry, and I'm glad to see other Asians trashing this game.
thank you for the kind words!
"Sakuna: Of Rice and Ruin" is also an anime that airs on this day (Sat), though next week 9/28 is the last episode.
Barelegged smithing next to a wooden fence, sword on back, and rice bales lying around are wild.
Found this channel from Rev says desu video about the other hyper analyse and now i'm watching every single video, you two are the best!
Rev is great! Thank you so much!
@@DashBlue your welcome , i told Rev to have a look at your stuff
great content & funny wife
That's awesome! We sincerely appreciate the support!
生えてる木が縦に伸びた盆栽なんだよね…
モドキでね…
欧米の回転寿司にあるプラスチックの盆栽をスキャンしたっぽい
@@唐辛子魔王草
そうか、違和感の正体は盆栽の松だったからなんだ…！
コメントありがとうございます。
Thank you for recommending Sakuna of Rice & Ruin!!!! I love playing Xseed games I never knew this one exist besides the Story of Seasons/Harvest moon titles!
it's a really wonderful game!
it also has some interesting combat mechanics, definitely one of my favorite games!
Great game, great character development. You're in for a treat.
I feel like the mix of English with Japanese and subtitles is such a perfect way to learn conversational Japanese.
Add into the fact we get history lessons basically. Subbed!
弥助の背中の刀はマグネットでかちょんかちょん、で笑わしてもらいました
UBIテクノロジー！
ご視聴ありがとうございました！
奥様のツッコミ毎回おもしろいですｗ
コメントありがとうございます。
氷結で出来上がっております笑
As a Japanese who has studied Noh for a bit, among the Hayashikata (taiko, otsuzumi, kotsuzumi, and flute), the otsuzumi and kotsuzumi players (the two in the middle) sometimes sit on chairs. Also, looking at old picture scrolls, it seems that the musicians do not necessarily wear black kimonos.
However, as someone who learned to play the taiko, I was concerned that he was not playing the drums properly. lol
Sorry for my poor English…
Anyway, I always astonish your knowledge about Japanese culture and history and enjoy your videos about AC Shadows!
Please keep uploading videos like this!
I have a feeling Ubi had someone sitting not because they had done research 😂
UBIが考証して詳しいから座る姿を描いたのじゃないと思うけどな😂
"Poor English"
Don't downplay yourself. Your English is excellent
They are the ancestors of Milli Vanilli and had playback running with their performance.
Poor English? I saw no problems. Your English is excellent.
服装がおかしない？太鼓叩いてる人の。
What's even worse about these trailers is the that these are the best scenes, clips and gameplay segments that they have 😂
either that, or they just don't care anymore
@@AbystomaMexicanium Yeah this is a trailer they edited for release, not random gameplay clips.... and it's this crappy? Some of the errors would be forgivable if this was a demo play at a trade expo, but it's NOT.
@@marhawkman303 I'd say that the option of "they just don't care anymore" would be even worse reality for Ubisoft. Like at this point we can only argue whether it's bad or worse lol.
@@AbystomaMexicanium Either way not worth buying.
I can totally imagine a situation where the employee in charge of making the trailer just didn't care at all and stuck a bunch slop together out of spite
thank you for watching!
Thank you Ubi and Lockley-kun, without you, this type of content wouldnt be possible!
突然おすすめに出てきて初めて拝見しましたが、
コメント欄から察するに奥様？の知識が豊富すぎて、あと表現力も
脱帽です
もやもやしていた所がどんどん言語化されてスッキリしました笑
妻は通りすがりの一般人です…笑
日本で育ったなら、言葉にできなくても違和感だらけで居心地悪い感じがしますよね。
たくさんの動画の中から当動画をご視聴いただき、ありがとうございました！
"respect the rice" as a half filipino i 110% agree with this
As a person of Scandinavian descent who has eaten rice... I also agree!
Rice is life!
thank you for watching!
I think your channel is the first one to actually make Ubi scared in their game development history, lol
oh man, I don't want to fall into their crosshairs lol, we're still a baby channel!
thank you for watching!
Nah, brother, we gonna make you big😂❤
I've witnessed the AC Shadows drama since May, and I'm going to bet that UBI is doing this on purpose just to spite Japan and its people...
and we'll keep making fun of them for it
thank you for watching!
Yup just a bunch of middle class white people who think they have moral superiority
This game is also developed by the same studio that worked on Odyssey, and that game had so many things wrong such as the inaccurate portrayal of the Persians, one of those inaccuracies with the Persians was also established lore since AC2 with one of those statues where you get the armor of Altair. I believe that one was for sure out of spite against Iranians, this company has always been questionable.
@@redcobra6016I am just glad, that the first real flop of the AC series was in their own country with Unity. That game was a mess and a half, on day 2 I logged on for the first time and my buddy took me to abuse a online mission for a bit just to instantly have enough currency to buy the best weapon after about an hour of play time…. Absolute trash, I quit the game 2h later
@@x2may374 obviously! Those games were good and that’s all they have to be! Putting an actual historical figure as main character however, is such a retarded move, that I am still baffled by it.
忍者は刀を踏み台にして塀とか飛び越えるから直刀だよね
伊賀忍あたりでは、鍔が四角い短めの直刀を使用していたのではないかと認識しております。
コメントありがとうございました。
お米は収穫後しばらく干してから脱穀し俵に詰めるのだが、それを水辺に置くとかまったく意味がないよね～
コメントありがとうございます。
妻側の祖父母が米農家でして、自分たちの食い扶持の稲は、近くのガードレールで天日干ししてました。
あんなふうにおいていたら、カビだらけの虫食いだらけで食べれたもんじゃないです。
ちょっとまて 安土城見たら よくある江戸城みたいな四角い石垣じゃないか？本来安土城の石垣は今の所出てきてる資料だと不等辺八角形で江戸城見たいな四角い土台の天守閣の石垣ではなかったような？
UBI「皆様はこのゲームでぜひ日本の歴史を学んでください」
山城と（平山城と）平城の区別も分からなかったんでしょうね。築城された時代によって違うのに。
@@もらもら 動画を見てたら天守閣の土台が木々で隠れてるけれど長方形に見えたので江戸城とかと一緒で土台が四角形なのかと安土城は上から石垣を見ると変形した８角形なのが一般的でだいたい安土城プラモでも変形した８角形の石垣の土台が付いてますよね
コメントありがとうございます。妻の方です。
城についてはちんぷんかんぷんなのですが、城に詳しい知人に既出のトレーラー諸々を見てもらった際、安土城っぽいけど姫路城の要素もある。時代も造りもごちゃ混ぜでよう分からんとのことでした。
米に対する扱いに比べたら、まぁファンタジーとしてギリ許容してやってもいいけどな…なスタンスです。（その道の方ごめんなさい）
@@DashBlue 安土城を乗せる土台の石垣が江戸城とか名古屋城とかは上から見た土台の形が四角形の土台の上に立ってますが安土城の天主の土台は８角形の土台の石垣なんですが辺の長さが変形したゆがんだ８角形の上に天主が乗ってるんですよ 説明すると長くなるので検索で安土城天守台と検索かければ不等辺七角形（天主初重は、不等辺八角形でしたって出てきますので図解で説明されてるのでわかりやすいと思います。
the rice game feels like an actually not boring cozy game
and
these guys are hilarious hahaha
thank you for watching!
it is a cozy and fun game!, if you like the Rune Factory series or Stardew Valley you will feel right at home, and the aesthetic is really great too.
Did the game come before the anime? I've been watching the Sakuna anime for a while, and the game looks pretty appealing.
@@SundaraRamanR The game was released about four years ago.
Sakuna does not just have farming mechanics, it also has 2d action platforming mechanics, with a cool combo system. If you like games like Castlevania or Metroid you'd probably like it.
お米を食べない国の人には、UBIの田んぼの描写になぜ奥様があそこまで怒っているかわからないでしょう
日本ではお米にリスペクトをしろと教わって育つので、収穫した米俵が野ざらしだったり、田んぼがでたらめな描写なのは日本人の怒りを買います
戦国というか、武士による領地争いも、基本的にお米のための田んぼとそこで働く農民の争奪戦です。田んぼの管理者「名主」の中の最大級のものが、「大名」です。領地争いだけでなく、飢饉などでお米がないと餓死に直結します。神社は基本的に豊作を祈って、その収穫に感謝する場所ですし、いつ頃からは知りませんが、「お稲荷さん」に狐が神のお使いになっているのも、狐が稲を荒らすネズミを退治してくれるからです。
違うトレーラーで、日干ししてあった魚や干し柿を弥助が意味なく蹴り飛ばしたシーンがあったのですが胸糞悪くなりました！
お米に限らず、食べ物を粗末に扱う輩は最低です！
コメントありがとうございます。
妻側の祖父母が米農家でしたので、より沸点が低くなっております。茶碗に一粒でも米粒を残そうものなら、厳しく叱られたものです。
たとえ米に対して日本人ほど理解がなかったとしても、年貢米など貨幣のように重要視されていたことを知っていれば、あのような描写にはならないはずです。
@@DashBlue 仰る通りですね
日本人にとってお米はただの穀物では無い、日本人の心です
もしubiが「我々は日本を正確に再現しました」とか言わなければ、無視も出来ましたが彼らは境界線を超えました
すっごい分かります
小さい頃、ご飯粒を残すと目が潰れると言われました、他にも、一粒のお米には七人の神様がいるとか、神棚にお米をお供えしたりしますね
台風で稲が倒され水に浸かったとき、コメを栽培していた親戚の落胆たらなかったです
お米は日本人の心...ソウルフードです
Love how you guys shouted out Sakuna. Such a great game. Because that was also what came through my mind instantly when the drainage system for the rice was mentioned
Sakuna is such a beautiful game
Thank you for watching!
藤の花の所で気づいたけど飛んでる鳥って「カモメ」じゃね？声もカモメだし、、、何でそこに居るんだ？
まじか、カモメかｗ
それに「藤の花はもっと細々としているはず」 藤はつる性の植物だから、他の大きな木に巻き付いて生えるんで、単独では育たないんです。
琵琶湖にはカモメがいるのと、川沿いだと結構内陸まで入り込むからまあ…
コメントありがとうございます。
カモメ…カモメかあ…確かに」そう見えますね。
まぁ日本にいる鳥だからいいか…笑
コメントありがとうございます。
私は藤棚しかみたことないのですが、あの大きな木に巻き付いてるなら立派になりそうですね！
でも川向かいから見てるのに縮尺大丈夫か？と言いたかったのですが…うまく伝わらずごめんなさい！
前のトレーラーでは、灯りの点いた室内から、夜の室外の人影が映っていたりと、科学の知識が無くても「観察」だけで分かる間違いとかありましたけど、今回のも多くの間違いだらけでしたね
ほんとに「酔っ払いながら突っ込みを入れる」ために生まれたトレーラーで、この動画を楽しめました
コメントありがとうございます。
ツッコミ入れ過ぎて、１時間越えの動画になってしまうくらい。日本人にとって没入感ゼロのトレーラーでした！
酔わなきゃやってられない…
Yasuke wears multiple layers of Heattech under his armor while on the snowy mountains.
LOL this comment killed me
Ubi Technology!
Thank you for watching!
Just like that guard who was covered in snow, except for his helmet. Must have had it in his helmet too!
I love this channel already. My wife is also Japanese, and I think your channel is very friendly towards a couple like us if we were the target audience. I'll be sure to watch it with her when she gets here once her US immigrant visa is approved and she comes to the States to live with me.
Why not just live in Japan
came here from Asmon, stayed for the content.
love the banter with your half and both your roasts and comedic timing are impeccable. it's hilarious, and on top of that, we learn stuff. cheers folks ! keep doing what you are doing ! We can feel you're both having so much fun. That's what I really like. it's awesome!
Greetings from France!
最後の風景ですが、どう見ても奥の湖が琵琶湖に見えないｗ日本最大の湖である琵琶湖の湖中島は一つしかありませんｗ
人が住んでいるのは沖島、住んでいないのは竹生島、他はあったかな？ ともかく土城が琵琶湖の水運の利を考えて建てられたことが、全く理解されていないようです。
コメントありがとうございます。
関東住まいの私には、どうしても海辺にみえてしまう…笑
日本でもツッコミ動画は沢山あるけど、それ以上に見つけてくれてますねw
こんな日本文化が11月には全世界に伝わりそうなのか😅
私も見落としてたなーってトコロあって参考になりましたわ
止めてじっくり見られたから
さらにおかしな点見つけたりもしましたわ
コメントありがとうございます。
いえいえ、他の方のご指摘もいただき、「そんなエラーもあるんだな」と感心しているところです。日本人って勤勉ですねぇ…
もはや祭りと化してますね。
どうせ発売されるなら、（いろいろな意味で）楽しんでしまいましょう笑
2月に延期になりましたね！このまま販売中止になればいいのに。
I feel like I'm actually learning about history by watching these lol
おかしな点がどんどん出てきて面白すぎて思わず声を上げてワロタ
コメントありがとうございます。
いや、UBIの言う通り戦国時代を体験したいんですよ。でもそれを許してくれない笑
最後には間違いはどこか探すゲームになっちゃう…
日本人として、海外に向けて正しい情報を発信して下さって、とても有り難いです。
ツッコミも面白く、楽しく視聴させて頂きました。
日本人としてのモヤモヤを海外の方と共有できたらと思いまして。
楽しんでいただけてうれしいです！
ご視聴ありがとうございました。
The Asmon effect is real. Been in his chat for countless years. Even tho he boosted you your videos are the reason that was possible. Keep killing it!
Thank you for the support!
Literally found you a day before Asmon's video, wanted a native's take on AC:Shadows. Thought you guy were great and underappreciated, definitely needed more attention, and presto Asmon found you. Congrats guys on your growth, keep it up...
thank you so much!
you're one of the OG's!
Your roast of Ubi is priceless. Such a hilarious and accurate review. Keep up the good work. Ubisof technology!🤣
thank you so much for the kind words!
These videos are 10000 times better than what the game itself will end up being!
Congrats on the channel growth. Absolutely deserved :D - Loved the video btw!
thank you for watching!
we sincerely appreciate the kind words!
時代考証や地学も、詳しい人でないとわからない程度であれば、まぁ御愛嬌かなと目を瞑るんですが、そうでない人からしてもおかしい部分ばっかりで、それで日本に敬意を払ってると言えちゃうんだねって。
間違いの内容や数の多さから見て、作品づくりに必要最低限の努力をしてないのが明らかだから、敬意がないって言われてるのに。
エミー賞を受賞した際の真田広之さんのスピーチを、100回くらい繰り返し聞けばいいんじゃないかな。
コメントありがとうございます。
そうなんですよね。別に完璧でなければダメだというわけではないんですよね。日本の時代劇でも鶏が闊歩している描写とかたまにありますけど、時代考証からいって不正確であるものの、受け入れられていましたしね。
UBIスタッフからみて、日本っぽいアジア的な何かを切り貼りして、それをあたかも時代考証したかのように売るスタンスが許せないですね。
UBI How is Yasuke going to draw his sword from his back when his sword is longer than his arms.
Same problem but even worse with Naoe
takes a lot of technique to unsheathe a long katana effectively lol
thank you for watching!
He'll get a Shadiversity back scabbard
Some long swords, like the knight's spear, are used on horseback and have no scabbard problems.
It requires skill to handle.
I bet he pushes the sword into the air, and dash-jumps to catch it. Because he is brave and styles🤣
that rice is lockley rice, it just needs water, 24/7 365 days a year, it even grows during winter.
it also automatically keeps the water level constant, by teleporting water in or out of the field as needed. No water system necessary. Truly a wondrous species of rice
Another guy here who came from Asmon's video about your video. I've got to say, your channel is a real gem. I love the dynamic between you too, the fact that your wife speaks almost exclusively Japanese adds a lot to it, your editing skills are really clean, and I'm actually learning something!
Finding fun, quality channels like yours really makes my day. Sub well earned!
UBIも許せんが、アトキンソンにも全裸土下座させたいわ
あの界隈は別の次元で許しがたいです…
コメントありがとうございました。
日本人じゃないのに日本人ぶりたいハシモトカズヤさんは弥助を見てついつい感情移入しちゃうんだろうねー。かわいそうだね、頭沸いちゃってる人達は。
ご視聴いただきありがとうございます。
こうした方々って、なぜか声だけは大きいんですよね…
Ah yes, the poser. I read his interview statements and was annoyed by his high school student mannerisms.
Those are the things most players wouldn't pay attention to, but by exposing it, it really shows much respect and effort Ubisoft is putting into their product... absolutely pathetic by Ubisoft.
They r too busy excited about the "legendary historical" character
I really enjoy looking at the finer details in a game and thinking about the deeper aspects to them. This game went so overboard that I had to make some videos about it lol
thank you for watching!
your wife is so funny 🤣🤣🤣 the ubisoft staff joke had me cackling from the start. i knew this vid was gonna be great
thank you for the kind words!
I'm currently in Osaka now, this video just made my morning even better
この動画がおすすめに出てきてくれたことに感謝します。日本人が指摘するより、外国人のホストで日本人は｢有識者｣の立場でツッコミしてくれた方がやはり多くの外国人は理解してくれると思います。これを作ってくれて本当にありがとう。指摘を笑いに変える、これがRUclipsのエンタメだと思う！
コメントありがとうございます。
Dashは日米ハーフですが、在米期間が長いのでアメリカ人の考え方寄りです。それでも幼少期は日本に住んでいましたので、日本人の感性も理解していると思います。だからなぜ日本人が怒っていることを海外の方が理解できないのかがよくわかっています。（多くのアメリカ人は、笑いがないと見る気にならないんだそう…細かい指摘過ぎで終わらせちゃう笑）
これを機に日本文化に興味を持っていただいた海外の方に、日本ってこんな感じだよ！とカジュアルに知っていただけたら嬉しいです。
9:22 in Thailand we have both black and green bamboo shoot
both are same species Rough Giant Bamboo
but we breed them to make 2 type of bamboo shoot
so maybe they just ref from asian bamboo
you guys are hilarious, keep the Ubiroast coming!
thank you for watching!
Damn! I really like watching your content. Keep it up.
thank you so much!
About bamboos, they don't grow leaves on the culm itself but it grows branch nodes on the culm first then leaves sprout from there. I see this a lot in bamboo but again, in this trailer, it boils down to sloppiness, which affects the immersion. I remember a Japanese commenter replied to me once about Japanese sword forging and he said that forging is done indoors during the day so it will help blacksmiths see the color of the flame clearly, which is impossible outdoors.
In addition, I was weirded out when fantasy Yasuke was practicing Karate as Karate is Okinawan and at the time Yasuke was in Japan, the Ryukyu Kingdom (present day Okinawa), was an independent kingdom until 1609, when the Satsuma clan invaded it. So, there is no way karate was already in the mainland. In fact, the samurai were more versed in disarming and throws, which were the basis for Jujutsu (where Judo, Aikido and BJJ originated) since opponents are in armor and strikes wouldn't work.
Wait, are you saying Assassins Creed isn’t a historically accurate portrayal of world history?
That can’t be true!
Your editing accompanying both your sense of humor, makes for hilarious content, thank you so much
まあ戦国時代の建物に殆ど二階建ての建物が無いのは、まずすぐ戦争になっちゃうから焼き討ちに遭う前に破壊して延焼を防ぐ方が確実だったからとかとありますが、ただそれ以前この二階だと部屋の中にいる人身長1メートル以下じゃないと立ってすごせないと思いますｗ
コメントありがとうございます。
なるほど、焼き討ちされるなら簡易的な建造物の方が理にかなってますね。
今回のトレーラーは縮尺がバグリきってますね。中二階だとしてもメチャ狭そう…
As an asian yeah if I disrespected rice. I will remember it with fear from my mom.
I completely know what you mean lol, rice is sacred
thank you for watching!
ツッコミお疲れ様です(笑)
御二人の掛け合い、今回も楽しませていただきました。
一応、一点だけ
江戸初期古能狂言の図、という作品で床几を用いている人物が描かれています。
確実とは言い切れませんが、おかしいとまでは言い切れない演出かもしれません。
コメントありがとうございます。妻です。
他の方からのご指摘もあり、調べさせていただきました。おっしゃる通りの絵図が確認できましたので、英語ですが固定コメントにて訂正しております。浅学にて誤解を招く表現をしてしまい、申し訳ありませんでした。
私たちは一般人知識ほどしかありませんが、皆さんのコメントで新たな学びを頂いております。これからも「ここ間違ってるよ！」と気軽にご指摘いただき、楽しく学びのあるコミュニティにしていきたいと思っています。
日本在住の日本人(ワイ)より遥かに日本文化に詳しいの、尊敬するやら己の無知を恥じるやら…
英語でこういう発信してくれるの本当にありがたいっす
Somebody is getting famous gratz
it's fun being able to share these moments like this with so many people
thank you for your support!
米へのリスペクトがすげぇ
こりゃ日本人だわ
コメントありがとうございます。
祖父母が米どころの農家だったもので…笑
wife nitpick so funny yet so educational... thanks
thank you for watching!
突っ込みが秀逸！！ マジありがと！
これも拡散されるといいですねー！
コメント感謝です！
Sakuna: Of Rice and Ruin.....🤔? *added to steam wishlist
It's an incredible game!
Thank you for watching!
天守閣に忍者侵入用の天窓付いてるの笑うし
太鼓も角度的に真ん中叩くの無理だなw
つつけば色々ボロ出てくるの笑うw
ゲームさんぽがアンバサダーになったみたいだけど専門家呼んで徹底的に検証して欲しいw
コメントありがとうございます。
そう、あの太鼓の構造からして、中央を叩くには突くしかないんですよね笑
そう思ってどこ叩いているのか追っていたら…まさかのエアプでした！ビートボックスかな笑
ゲームさんぽさんでは、他アサクリを専門家と検証する動画を拝聴したことがあります。
すごく学びになったんですけど…
いやぁ、さんぽさんのスタッフ、今頭抱えてるだろうなぁ…
@@DashBlueここまで来たら日本の専門家という専門家を呼んでボロクソ言って欲しい。アンバサダーなんか知らねぇー！って感じで
Ubisoft continues to belittle, provoke, and insult Japan.
The fact that they don't know "the real thing" is easily understood by the Japanese when they see the trailer, and it is terrible.
It's Azuchi Castle, but the stone walls still exist.
The real thing doesn't have this high stone wall.
The way of stacking stone walls is completely different.
This alone shows that there is no on-site investigation in Japan.
It's like a cheap plastic model.
安土城ですが石垣は現存しています
現物はこんなに高い石垣を築いてはいません(笑)
石垣の積み方もまったく違いますね
これだけでも日本で現地調査はしていない事が丸わかりです
格安のプラスチック模型を参考にしたような感じです
うん、一切現地調査はしてないだろうね。
日本を少しでも知ってる人がいれば日本の伝統を受け継いでる旅館がある、というのは知ってるだろうし、旅館に来てれば畳は少なくとも勘違いしないだろう。
@@手水舎-k1r
沖縄バカンスして琉球畳を見学したのかも(笑)
本州では旅館ではなくホテルにのみ宿泊ｗ
そしてガイドは本州の畳の種類も琉球畳との違いも知らない希少な日本通ぶった人だった🤣🤣
Yeah. Looks like what Ubisoft did was replacing assets in their last 3 AC games with anything that is Japanese looking to them.
I think I found the best channel ever, spot on takes❤
thank you so much for the kind words!
とりあえず、UBIにはこのゲームを監修した日本の専門家を公表して欲しい。
絶対に、日本の「歴史の」専門家では無いだろうし、なんなら日本人ですらなさそう
ご視聴いただきありがとうございます。
一体「どこ」の「どういった」専門家なのか私も気になります。文化盗用のエキスパートだったりして…なんて邪推してしまいます
専門家はダートマス大学の助教授、Sachi Schmidt-Horiっていう人だと思う
その専門は中世日本における男性同士の性的関係とかジェンダー・アイデンティティの分析のようだ
まあ個人的にそのような学問の分野に反対ではないが戦国時代のゲームの顧問にふさわしい人物かどうかはちょっと怪しいと思うんだけどｗ
それでもダートマス大学はSchmidt-Hori氏のコンサルティング活動を支持する声明を掲載した。ここに直接リンクが貼れないが、「STATEMENT IN SUPPORT OF ASCL PROF. SACHI SCHMIDT-HORI 」とググればすぐ出てくるだろう
the only expert mentioned by Ubisoft so far is Sachi Schmidt-Hori, which is an american professor of japanese literature that focuses on weird sex and gender things in middle age japan. She does not seem qualified and is probably not enough to oversee thousands of people employed by Ubisoft making this game
@@JuanjoPP "Assistant professors" are basically frauds here in the US. It is a nominal title given to anyone the university likes, with no regard to credentials or qualification. They have no requirements to teach courses.
they actually used a Japanese ''expert''.
You gotta understand just because someone is Japanese, that doesn't mean they know every single thing about Japanese history as is the case with the so called expert they used
初っ端から爆笑！何故かお腹から出血してますね確かに！
そう！私もあの田んぼ脇のやつ(柱と藁？で出来た屋根のみ)と田んぼの中の棒が気になってました。絶対日本じゃない。
桜はデカすぎるし、灯篭もあんな連なって配置しないと思うし……リアス式海岸っぽい岸壁には草と木の根がむき出しで、海水に負けない植物なのかとかも……町中、道の真ん中に木？の通路みたいなのが見えて何これ？腐るぞ？とか……黄色い花も見た事ないやつw
天守閣でのシーン、弥助の腰の刀が抜き身らしいです。鞘を突き抜けているとかw
開始早々違和感しかありませんでした！笑
天守閣のシーン、確認しました。刀身が下半分ぐらい出でいるように見えます。omg
コメントありがとうございました。
海岸のフェイク感はそれかあ、まるで中国の大河と岸壁のようだと思った
台風もあって海水の浸食がすごい、塩害で植物が枯れる、木は真っすぐ育たない、日本は火山列島で岩石に穿孔ができたり鋭い崖や棚を作る
なにより海苔類や海藻類がなく全然潮の香りを感じない、これは日本人のスピリットなんだな、海苔と醤油！
気候や風土、地形や植生を理解していない、Ubiのスタッフはフランス内陸にいて分からんか
I adore the way you two bounce off each other, even in different languages. Do you film in one language and cover in another, or are both fluent enough to keep up? The style is very unique and fun.
We mix English and Japanese in our speech, the edits are taken from a single session of recording
Makes the editing chaos because I have to subtitle so many things lol
Thank you for the kind words!
You guys need to critique all media that uses Japanese culture, I’d watch it all!
I'm actually going through Sakuna right now, I'm looking forward to how the rice mechanics work. Good to know that it's an accurate representation.
That's great to hear, I hope you enjoy!
Thank you for putting yourselves through this, both of you are great!