Does the Turkish R sometimes sound like Ş?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 18 дек 2022
  • In this video, we look at a phenomenon whose existence is vehemently denied by native Turkish speakers.

Комментарии • 33

  • @antananarywa
    @antananarywa 4 месяца назад +4

    Very interesting! I was trying to find info whether it is similar to Czech ř.

  • @MrGianeta
    @MrGianeta Год назад +11

    OMG, this is exactly what I was looking for. I relaxed immediately when he mentioned "alveolar tap"-like terminology and then fricative and the like. Finally, something clear and technically . I would appreciate if there were schemes with the position of tongue etc. Can anybody point me to a video with a good description of Turkish phology for consonants and vowels, preferable with schematic pictures. I would like to get the answers to things like are turkish t and d dental, is there aspiration (non at all? very soft at the begining of the words for instance). what about n? dental? which sounds are palatalized (or more palatalized then say in English) and which are not. the vowels - how do that compare. For instance, when turkish speakers say "ceket" - the e I hear is very narrow and clearly pronounce in the front of the mouth, while a typical e in "ben" is very deep and sounds closer to " a" to my ears, etc. Is there smth I can watch?

    • @cleopatraonlyfans
      @cleopatraonlyfans 8 месяцев назад +1

      Fuck yeahhhhhh this is also exactly what i was looking for
      Subscribed

  • @Tcgmaster808
    @Tcgmaster808 5 месяцев назад

    very valuable video thank you sir ! short, and well explained

  • @caribmale
    @caribmale Год назад +4

    This was very helpful. It was a challenge at first, but I wanted to sound authentic so I found that by letting out a bit of air after a voiceless R. It worked. I’m very happy now, but I’d almost been driven crazy deciphering why Gülru sounded so different between my pronunciation and that of a native speaker. 😂

  • @dregga7638
    @dregga7638 Год назад +8

    That's the best explaination i've seen so far. I noticed a potential forth 'R' wich is when it's followed bey an consonant as in 'Merhaba' or 'Türkçe'. Or would you say it's the same as the second one you mentioned?

  • @alexandrashvydun8726
    @alexandrashvydun8726 Год назад

    this is a great video, i can tell you know a lot about linguistics

  • @Nehauon
    @Nehauon 24 дня назад +2

    This guy sounds like his name would be Pilbert

    • @OfficialHelix
      @OfficialHelix 19 дней назад

      funniest fucking yt comment i’ve ever seen

  • @DaveHuxtableLanguages
    @DaveHuxtableLanguages Год назад +1

    Brilliant explanation! What happens before another consonant? In the work Türkiye, for example.

  • @abluecassette
    @abluecassette Год назад +4

    Great video, well explained! I used to always wonder why I heard a 'whistle' in words ending with r, especially evident in songs sung by Göksel.

  • @shelookstome8727
    @shelookstome8727 Год назад +3

    Teşekkürler!!

    • @catboy721
      @catboy721 6 месяцев назад +2

      This word is the perfect example of the topic. Almost every source on the internet says that thank you should be “teh-shed-kür-LAHSH” (laş). Is it?

    • @ashsgirl
      @ashsgirl 3 месяца назад +1

      ​@@catboy721Yes!

  • @cogito919
    @cogito919 Месяц назад

    THANK YOUUU. It seems like for nearly every language I learn, whether it’s French, Spanish, German, or Dutch, the problem consonant for me is ALWAYS THE R. But unlike those languages, Turkish speakers are unhelpful with or unaware of how non-native speakers should say the r correctly.

  • @nochu9753
    @nochu9753 Год назад +1

    What about the sound in words like erkek for example? It sounds or it seems to sound a little different from all these 3

  • @alexandrashvydun8726
    @alexandrashvydun8726 Год назад +2

    i didnt even know alveolar tapped fricatives exist!

    • @antananarywa
      @antananarywa 4 месяца назад +1

      It is a similar case to polish .

  • @PopDasKorn
    @PopDasKorn 8 месяцев назад

    I was wondering if I heard correctly that the r in Turkish is like or similar to the r in Chinese

  • @LL-zp7ut
    @LL-zp7ut 3 месяца назад

    I needed this phonology based explanation! Teşekkür ederim.

  • @ceydakovan7359
    @ceydakovan7359 3 месяца назад

    I‘m really trying but I just can‘t do it…

  • @bozlakmapping7987
    @bozlakmapping7987 Год назад +2

    İts not like ş but more like whistle or wind sound

  • @PimsleurTurkishLessons
    @PimsleurTurkishLessons Год назад

    Video bitince bitir neden başa sarıp tekrar anlatıyor?

  • @bensully94
    @bensully94 Год назад

    Also when you pronounce Ben it sounds like ban

    • @ahmedahmedli818
      @ahmedahmedli818 2 месяца назад +2

      Because there are 2 types of e in Turkish in daily speech.I am an Azerbaijani, and my language is very very similar to Turkish, but we use different letters for these types of e:
      e and ə
      Ə is the sound in the word cat.

  • @Philantrope
    @Philantrope 2 месяца назад

    I did not understand how to pronounce kar or bir

    • @lordofdalkiran
      @lordofdalkiran 14 дней назад

      Turkish have fast and explosive sounds using frontal part of the mouth exclusively. minimal tongue movement. Imagine You have battery %2 and dont want to use extra movement/enegery to spent rest of it and you r in hurry :) No jaw drop sounds and dont roll your tongue hard, not move your lips horizontally much. Turkish is all about Minimal effort more pew pew.. Lets try to pronounce ''bir'' ''kar'' . open your mouth and theeth a bit and keep steady naturally. imagine sound bi bi bi bi bi fast as possible and repeat ka ka ka ka. now almost r sound here . just move your tongue tip bit back. Tongue slightly moves ( imagine index finger is your tongue . child knuckle challange. can you move your outer first knuckle seperately without move other parts of the finger . your tongue literally in the position like number ''1'' .... Lets try sth else ''Car'' english word. Lets pronounce this word with Turkish accent without knowing english much. C is K sound in Turkish here . a sound similar but dont jaw drop . my lips almost never move, even my tongue almost no moves when i say ''car'' . 0.1 sec fast and explosive.

  • @yedeque7858
    @yedeque7858 Год назад +1

    2:13 burda yanlış diacritic kullandın sanırım raised oluyor öyle

    • @turkishwithanil
      @turkishwithanil  Год назад +1

      Raised zaten.

    • @yedeque7858
      @yedeque7858 Год назад +1

      @@turkishwithanil tap raised olamaz ki, senin anlattığın da zaten raised değil

    • @turkishwithanil
      @turkishwithanil  Год назад

      @@yedeque7858 Literatürde bu alofonlar hep [ɾ̝] / [ɾ̝̊] olarak gösterilmiş, onu takip ettim. Keza Çekçedeki (Türkçedekinin trill versiyonu olan) Ř sesi için de /r̝/ kullanılıyor.

    • @yedeque7858
      @yedeque7858 Год назад

      @@turkishwithanil nerde? [ɾ̞] [ɾ̞̊] olarak gösterilir zaten raised senin dediğinin tam zıttı

    • @turkishwithanil
      @turkishwithanil  Год назад

      @@yedeque7858 Gördüğüm kadarıyla [ɾ̝] / [ɾ̝̊] ve [ɾ̞] / [ɾ̞̊] çiftlerinin ikisi de kullanılmış. (www.google.com/search?q=%22%C9%BE%CC%9D%22+OR+%22%C9%BE%CC%9D%CC%8A%22+OR+%22%C9%BE%CC%9E%22+OR+%22%C9%BE%CC%9E%CC%8A%22+turkish) Biri yanlış olsa gerek. Tap'in fricated olması için raised olması daha mantıklı geliyor bana, Çekçedeki kullanım da böyle çünkü. Ama phonetician değilim, bir dipnot düşeyim.