POWER LEVELS: Grand Line Review or B.D.A. Law? | One Piece Discussion

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 янв 2025

Комментарии • 28

  • @ShonenOuji
    @ShonenOuji  4 года назад +1

    Do you think One Piece uses power levels, or do you think there are too many nuances?

    • @ShonenOuji
      @ShonenOuji  4 года назад

      I think you're absolutely right. Even if you try to use Haki now, it can be beat by a strong enough devil fruit. And obviously bounties don't tell you enough because there are so many factors that go into them besides power.

    • @ShonenOuji
      @ShonenOuji  4 года назад

      *Also, in case you didn’t notice, the character’s name is Magna and not Magma. Sorry about any confusion caused by my negligent spelling error.

  • @GracieVeeVee
    @GracieVeeVee 4 года назад +2

    Excellent video! Thinking about power levels in One Piece always gives me a headache but you explained it really well!

    • @ShonenOuji
      @ShonenOuji  4 года назад +1

      Glad to hear you think so. It's something I always put off myself, but this project helped me see it's pretty fun once you break it down. Thanks for watching!

  • @SephTheSin
    @SephTheSin 4 года назад +2

    This was a great breakdown of the whole power level drama and shows a great understanding of both channels points and arguments, keep up the great work my friend

    • @ShonenOuji
      @ShonenOuji  4 года назад +1

      Thank you so much. Really tried to properly represent each side and not create any straw men.

  • @Aaron12345gr
    @Aaron12345gr 4 года назад +2

    Amazing video, and I am against all forms of power scaling in this manor for the simple fact that everyone views these ranks in a different light and a lot of that is based on how characters are viewed.

    • @ShonenOuji
      @ShonenOuji  4 года назад

      Thank you! And you’re right. Because there’s no feat to compare to, everything is just too relative for there to be a consistent power scale.

    • @Aaron12345gr
      @Aaron12345gr 4 года назад

      @@ShonenOuji Exactly! I always thought theu were both wrong, especially on the Admiral level thing. Not everyone views admirals at the same level of strength in comparison to other characters.

  • @tylerdoe1096
    @tylerdoe1096 4 года назад +1

    This video really highlights what I like about One Piece, in other shows (thinking of Dragon Ball specifically), it's like, "Oh, your power level is 9% higher than mine? Looks like I lose" lol. If there were DEFINITIVE power levels, Luffy would be long dead lol. Great video as always m8!

    • @ShonenOuji
      @ShonenOuji  4 года назад

      Exactly. That key word "definitively" is what prevents there from being actual power levels, rather than the broad tiers that exist. Glad you enjoyed the video.

  • @saxii1381
    @saxii1381 4 года назад +1

    Amazing video!! I most absolutely agree with you on this one! There are far too many nuances and that kinda is the beauty of the show! Well done!

    • @ShonenOuji
      @ShonenOuji  4 года назад +1

      Thanks! Told ya I really wouldn't change your mind. I hope I at least helped you see that it's easy to take the power system for granted, because I certainly did before making this. (Sits back and waits for response to the response to the response video.)

    • @saxii1381
      @saxii1381 4 года назад +1

      @@ShonenOuji If I even were to respond I'd 99% of the time just say "ye, I agree because...", but if I do think of something better be ready😂

    • @ShonenOuji
      @ShonenOuji  4 года назад +1

      Saxii Bring it on you son of a gun.

  • @ronaldtran8579
    @ronaldtran8579 4 года назад +1

    i'm not much of a power scaler cuz it gets so messy and meaninglessly argumentative, but this video is actually pretty organized and lit. I would rather compare the hype level based on bounty, but you did a really good job breaking down the nuances between the power within the titles. Also really like the feats point. This is a great and different look at One Piece

    • @ShonenOuji
      @ShonenOuji  4 года назад

      I’ve never been into power scaling myself, but after this video it actually seems pretty fun. Just have to make sure your story actually has power levels. Thank you for watching as always.

  • @MAMZYY_YT
    @MAMZYY_YT 4 года назад +1

    Good discussion video, I definitely wouldn’t say that power levels are completely unimportant in the world of one piece, but it definitely doesn’t take priority like in other series such as Naruto, DB or Fairy tail for example which is good aswell imo, by the way you’re close to reaching 150 subs 👀👏🏿

    • @ShonenOuji
      @ShonenOuji  4 года назад +1

      Stole the words right out of my mouth. It’s there, it’s just not very reliable. And I know! Nice to see that growth. Working hard to create a community where people can chat on discord, in streams, all that good stuff. Thanks for the support as always.

    • @MAMZYY_YT
      @MAMZYY_YT 4 года назад +1

      Shonen Ouji no worries man, Keep it up & congrats 👍🏿

  • @prashantkalauni8029
    @prashantkalauni8029 4 года назад +1

    I fully agree with Grandlinereview. The anime magic aka devil fruit/haki are not just for who punches harder but how one uses the abilities. Also there are counter powers where one devil fruit cancels others as well as some are more powerful version of the others.

    • @ShonenOuji
      @ShonenOuji  4 года назад +1

      Thank you for watching! While I don’t think there are clear power levels, I do agree with BDA Law that there are clearly broad gaps in power that some characters just can’t cross. Still, like you point out, anything can happen.

    • @charles9489
      @charles9489 4 года назад

      I don't agree with glr, he spent most of his videos bickering about toxic fans and how he doesn't like the names for the various power scales.
      I find him to be very facetious,listen to the way he talks in the videos as if he is talking down, using sarcasm and all.
      Finally because glr doesn't like power scaling in one piece it means the rest of us shouldn't talk about it. That's preposterous.

  • @kieferdalton7525
    @kieferdalton7525 4 года назад +1

    Decent video. Had good points. The one thing that I can say to help you improve is you need more warlocks. The incredible lack of warlocks is unsettling and downright disrespectful. I would say if you added at least 5 warlocks the video would have been the best one you have put out to date but it doesn’t so it’s a mediocre video. Also not to mention how you didn’t have a single can of spray cheese makes it laughable

    • @ShonenOuji
      @ShonenOuji  4 года назад +1

      The cheese warlocks were certainly missing in this my video. I apologize for any inconvenience. I’ll work to avoid any similar confusions.

  • @charles9489
    @charles9489 4 года назад +1

    I don't agree with your conclusion, so cause outliers exist means no power level exist.
    The day sugar or a sugar like character beats a and admira one their own one one. Then I'll concede.
    Love the video though 👍

    • @ShonenOuji
      @ShonenOuji  4 года назад

      Glad you enjoyed the video! I agree that outliers alone don't discount a possible power scaling system, however that's not why there is no system in One Piece. As it stands, there are no feats tied to the given ranks and titles. Without feats, like destroying demons or planets, there's no way to reliably rank characters. If feats were provided, then I could definitely see a power scaling system.