The answer is simple. If u are Malaysians living in JB, to buy to live in is better to be in JB but for Investment then buy SG properties as it’s more certain of capital gains.
In 1985, my Malaysian colleague working in Singapore and I bought our first residential properties in Kuala Lumpur and Singapore respectively. I sold my apartment in 2008 and made a tidy profit of MYR 2.5 million. My friend's property in Kuala Lumpur had also appreciated but the margin is much lower.
Totally agree. I vote 2 as well. Iskandar was so badly hit during pandemic, compared to SG rentals hitting peaks. Even those who invested in KL, Penang condos, there is capital appreciation but MYR weakening erodes your gains if you convert back to SG. My comparison is private condos in both countries, since HDB is Govt subsidised housing so not apples to apples.
I am a property agent. In Singapore, there are many Malaysians applying for PR. The PR status is good as they can buy HDB and condo if the requirements are right. Singapore properties have a lot of potential for capital appreciation and SGD is strong. When they retire, they can sell Singapore properties, take out all the CPF money and go back stay in Malaysia.
2 - To buy SG property not only have good price appreciate, but also good demand for rental & sale. Could get stuck with JB house. And if want house in Malaysia why JB, so many other better places.
There are quite a number points: 1. In recent years, JB has more and more projects for new housing (condo, landed, etc) but alot of those projects dont really have people and becoming ghost town. 2. As a foreigner buying housing in JB, how is the security there, even for condo, there is chance of burglary. This is very bad even there is security, I saw it myself staying in 1 of the condo previously 3. When u own a property in JB, if u passed on, how can u transfer the ownership to your kids, etc, i think there is alot of restriction on the will and potentially could not transfer at all.
There are many housing options in Malaysia. Unfortunately most Singaporeans use Singapore mentality in their purchasing decision in Malaysian property and made unnecessary but unavoidable mistakes.
U will need proper n valid documents to reside in Malaysia! Customs will Question your purpose of visit even if it’s for 2 weeks stay ! your stamp entry n exit will reflect on your passport, even if Singaporeans have ASEAN agreements for 30 day visa ! buying a property in Malaysia don’t equal a visa ! property around or near CIQ is very Noisy with huge lorry’s horns throughout Day n Night ! heavy Traffic jams, foot traffic! a 10 mins ride back to my condo took me 3 hours back home ! condo facilities like swimming pool, gym etc r charged per square foot of your condo unit! the bigger your condo u pay more ! Foreigners purchase is 5hundred thousand n above SG! with state consent which the Malaysia gov want a slice of property market! property in Malaysia got no resale value it’s called sub sale in Malaysia! if u want to buy SG HDB u have to surrender all Foreign property before buying HDB Singapore HDB law in case u don’t know ! JB got over supply of property, in KL , Penang is 2 million to buy n Sarawak n Sabah states r protected n special to Malaysia gov ! I bought a property in Malaysia n regretted immensely!
Buy properties on both sides. Renting out in Singapore while living in Johor Bahru. The rental income from the Singapore property should be able to cover the mortgages for both properties.
Thanks for your video but just to clarify, Singapore PR alone is unable to own a HDB, unless he/she is married to a PR or Singapore citizen then only they can purchase a HDB.
JB properties ~ have $ can buy; but when you want to sell??? No buyer=oversupply of condos, there is no subsale market and Malaysians want landed only.(Malaysians do want to pay for maintenance charges every quarterly).
I agree.. Not only just applicable to jb properties, but also to properties in KL & seremban... Hv to think twice if buying property in msia is fr investment or for own stay
Seremban properties ~ 100% not suited for Singaporean in aspect of capital gain = very unlikely, because of location n lacking buyers(especially selling to Singaporeans only because Malaysian preference to landed). KL ~ must only be in “Orchard-Malaysia” = Bukit Bintang vicinity. Best choice for capital investment in Malaysia. JB ~ suitable only for own stay.
If you are a Malaysian staying in Malaysia buying Malaysian property for raising a family due to the much bigger space than SG then by all means cos your family will be happier with a big house rather than a pigeon hole. But if you are buying property for investment, it's obvious you can't make money with Malaysian property. Malaysian ringgit keeps falling. It used to be 1:1 to SGD. Now it's 3.5:1. My prediction is it will be 4:1 and beyond in the near future. Whatever capital appreciation is lost to depreciation of the currency. Singapore has scarcity of land. With limited land supply, there is very little downside risks. For investment purposes, SG properties will hold its value. In fact, so many foreigners are snapping up SG properties cos SG is a safe haven for their money until the government had to step in and introduce 60% ABSD to stop the buying. Frankly this move speaks volumes on the attractiveness of SG properties for investment. No brainer actually.
I have a question. I'm Singaporean. If I wish to sell my Malaysian property, what I need to pay extra or tax for sales of property? Or if I pass away, does my children has a problem to acquire my property?
Thanks for the comment🙏🏻You may need to look for the agent who help you to sell your property because they will know more in details for your situation🌹
Buying a property in JB vs SG, JB property may appreciate but the RMB will devaluate. My friend bought a JB property some 15 years ago, that time S$1=RMB2.5, now it is S$1=RMB3.4. Convert back to SG$, you still loss money. You think you will make money? Unless you are Malaysian, nothing to say.
Use kamunting police-station and beautify using tai-ping and avoid mee-udang. Map overlay - find spot for dog dig bone and jack-sparrow to dig for bone.
Ai, got money SG. Property here is protected and double every 10-20 yrs. No money JB liao...JB is free market, price might drop drastically during crisis.
when you’re getting old, you need all the resources around you to support your living, I don’t understand why ppl want to “balik kampung” when they retire.
One will need proper n valid documents to reside in Malaysia, customs will Question your purpose of visit! even if it’s 2 weeks of stay , your entry n exit will reflect on your passport! even if Singapore has agreements with ASEAN for 30 days stamp ! buying a property in Malaysia does not equal a visa ! Foreigners pay 500 thousand SG n above for property or condo , Malaysia gov take a slice of property market State consent! condo facilities like swimming pool gym etc r charged per square foot of your condo unit , the bigger your unit u pay more , property near or around CIQ is very noisy with huge lorry’s horns throughout day n night , heavy traffic jam , foot traffic! a 10 mins ride back to my condo took me 3 hours back home ! different states got Different laws KL , Penang is 2 million to purchase, Sarawak Sabah r protected special states ! if Singaporean want to buy SG HDB u have to surrender all Foreign property before buying HDB SG Law in case u didn’t know ! if buy Malaysia property it is to live n not Hope to flip n make money ! Malaysia property got no resale value it’s called sub sale in Malaysia! I bought a property in Malaysia n regretted immensely!
Buying properties u need a healthy secondary mkt & stable currency exchange. It is not ta buying a cheap big bungalow but buying a gd value property ta can sell easily & gd return 😎 JB hvnt reach ta point yet cos due to low domestic participation 🥸
觉得应该在新山买房的打“1"😆；觉得在新加坡买房才是明智选择的打“2”😌
新加坡政府一路来对马来西亚都是支持双赢。李光耀说过他为曾经支持他的马来西亚留下来的华族们惋惜，希望能帮帮他们。而且马来西亚如果发展不起来对新加坡也没什么好处。反而，如果马来西亚又搞个回教徒与其他种族冲突那对这区域是非常不利的。幸好现在不是马哈迪当总理，不然又来他妈的分歧。柔佛如果真想发展就必须脱离马来西亚政府管辖。没其他办法。因为穆斯林的信仰与世俗发展是永远对利的。
想要在新山买房怎么联络你们呢？
马来西亚买房子完全没保障，撇开治安不说，食物卫生安全，医疗方便，周围环境都得不到保障，而且许多房子完全没有后续保养，不到8年就破旧不堪。
新山公寓烂尾八年无下文 狮城一众苦主越堤讨说法
22/10/2023 20:48
“还我们血汗钱！还我们棺材本！”马来西亚柔佛一栋烂尾高级公寓的大约100名苦主，当中包括好些特地越堤而至的新加坡受害业主，今天（22日）聚集新山向烂尾楼发展商讨说法，同时希望通过当地议员解决公寓烂尾问题。
据《8视界新闻网》记者了解，位于新山百万镇滨海地带的这个烂尾楼项目，原定2018年末竣工，如今却沦为废置工程。建筑承包商一换再换，许多业主苦等近八年无果。
记者今天（22日）也到新山了解情况，约百名来自新加坡和马国各地的苦主，聚集当地同柔佛巴西古当国会议员哈山卡林会面，望借助政府力量找到解决方案。
约三分之一买家是新加坡人
据了解，该项目至少三分之一买家是新加坡人。约20名狮城业主今天（22日）早上也特地从新加坡越堤而来，参加这项受害业主的集会。他们受访时诉苦说，公寓的工程虽已搁置，但银行利息还得照还，直斥发展商不负责任。
47岁的罗绍忠说，他在2016年10月与41岁妻子孙敏仪买了这个项目一个逾百万令吉（约28万8075新元）的单位，当初是因为看中这里优越的地理位置，想要用来养老，没想到如今却变成“啃老”。
“工程停，银行还是继续叫我们还贷款，现在每个月的利息是1600令吉（约460新元）。我们有询问银行，为何没建好却要我们继续还钱。他们回复说，是发展商叫我们还，如果不这么做就会宣告我们破产，到时候进来马来西亚也会成问题。”
56岁的曾国奋今天（22日）则是和妻子、小姨一起越堤前来，小姨在该发展项目同样买了一个单位。据了解，他的小姨目前已支付了约70%房贷。
“现在失望多过于生气。我们有听说，发展商在马来西亚政府那边放了一笔钱。如果发展不成功，那个钱会拿来赔我们 ，但是不知道这个钱要找谁去要。”
用养老金买楼 苦主：不知多久才能赚回
同样来自新加坡的56岁苦主蔡先生则透露，自己在买房时用上了养老金，原本是为养老，如今项目成为烂尾楼，坦言日后不知道还要工作多久才能把这笔钱赚回来。
“全部都是辛苦赚来的钱，作为一个普通的打工族，对我来说真的是很辛苦。（房子）你看得到，但却住不到。“
54岁的Eunice受访时也说，自己曾咨询过律师，想通过法律途径解决问题，然而律师无奈告知，过程将非常漫长，而且最后可能会没有结果。
马国议员：助向部长反映问题
柔佛巴西古当国会议员哈山卡林今天（22日）约3点抵达烂尾楼现场，并在附近一家餐馆与受影响业主会谈，同时也答复了业主询问。
他在接受媒体访问时表示，会把苦主的问题视为自己的问题，并承诺将把问题反映给马国地方政府发展部副部长阿克马。
“这是我第一次会见业主。我作为国会议员，将会向负责烂尾楼项目的副部长反应事件，我也将促请政府委任新的承包商，并对政府负责。”
不过他也提醒业主，如果委任新的承包商成事，可能需要面对罚款问题，屋主若想看到工程复工，可能得考虑放弃对发展商追讨罚款，与此同时，发展商可能会提出新的附加协议书，这些都是业主必须考虑到的。
2
我觉得现在新加坡买 五年后再在马来西亚买 x j p❤的房子供马来西亚的房子多好 😊
The answer is simple. If u are Malaysians living in JB, to buy to live in is better to be in JB but for Investment then buy SG properties as it’s more certain of capital gains.
Thanks for sharing your point of view👍🏻
In 1985, my Malaysian colleague working in Singapore and I bought our first residential properties in Kuala Lumpur and Singapore respectively. I sold my apartment in 2008 and made a tidy profit of MYR 2.5 million. My friend's property in Kuala Lumpur had also appreciated but the margin is much lower.
Thanks for sharing👍🏻
2 - SG for property appreciation in the future and easier to rent out. JB house is big but mainly for own stay and hard to earn profit
Totally agree. I vote 2 as well. Iskandar was so badly hit during pandemic, compared to SG rentals hitting peaks. Even those who invested in KL, Penang condos, there is capital appreciation but MYR weakening erodes your gains if you convert back to SG.
My comparison is private condos in both countries, since HDB is Govt subsidised housing so not apples to apples.
Thanks to sharing your point of view👍🏻
你是华人你不会华语？@@joycegoh8628
I am a property agent. In Singapore, there are many Malaysians applying for PR. The PR status is good as they can buy HDB and condo if the requirements are right. Singapore properties have a lot of potential for capital appreciation and SGD is strong. When they retire, they can sell Singapore properties, take out all the CPF money and go back stay in Malaysia.
HDB price is now very high and could have reached the peak. Moving forward unlikely to enjoy the hugh capital appreciation as before.
Thanks for sharing🌹👍🏻
你是华人你不会华语？
可能Jb比较好吧，🇸🇬的装修质量真是一言难尽，贵又土、才90多年地契、没阳台、隔音差、容易发霉、朝向/风水更是没得选全凭运气。就连当地的private properties我看了很多质量和设计基本也只相当于🇨🇳40年前的水准。
感谢分享观点👍🏻
2 - To buy SG property not only have good price appreciate, but also good demand for rental & sale. Could get stuck with JB house. And if want house in Malaysia why JB, so many other better places.
Thanks for sharing👍🏻
There are quite a number points:
1. In recent years, JB has more and more projects for new housing (condo, landed, etc) but alot of those projects dont really have people and becoming ghost town.
2. As a foreigner buying housing in JB, how is the security there, even for condo, there is chance of burglary. This is very bad even there is security, I saw it myself staying in 1 of the condo previously
3. When u own a property in JB, if u passed on, how can u transfer the ownership to your kids, etc, i think there is alot of restriction on the will and potentially could not transfer at all.
There are many housing options in Malaysia. Unfortunately most Singaporeans use Singapore mentality in their purchasing decision in Malaysian property and made unnecessary but unavoidable mistakes.
Thanks for sharing👍🏻
Make sure you add the person you want to transfer to eg son or daughter as a co owner, then should not have problem with inheritance.
很仔细的分析，加上你们不偏激的个人观点，个人觉得很棒，加油！
谢谢你👍🏻
只要新加坡持續對外國人提供工作機會，不管是高薪還是低薪、租屋就有市場。
要能先賺到錢才會考慮怎麼消費，畢竟買房不是買菜、一定要慎重規劃。
新加坡政府不鼓勵炒房，外國人買私人房產需付額外30%的稅。
新加坡人
有能力又符合條件當然先在新加坡買政府組屋，私人公寓或馬來西亞地產等真有錢才考慮買。
馬來西亞打工人
符合在新加坡買政府組屋的，我建議考慮出租一間房間。假設月租$600～$800，那就等於有人幫你還房貸。但屋齡不要超過50年，不然住了二十年剩30年地契很難賣到合理價錢。
「外國人」買馬幣100萬元地產要考慮三點
兌換率
出租率
自住率
買馬來西亞「永久地契」產業是很難有短期利益的，外國人買的房子已經比馬來西亞人貴一倍多。租金比分期付款少20～30%是正常現象，地點差的更別指望了。
如果是投資就認認真真做功課。如果是留產業給子孫就沒問題了，犧牲你的生活品質換取兒孫的快樂！誰能說什麼？
最後重點：馬來西亞過百萬的公寓庫存有很多很多，十幾年內是消化不完的。有底住宅才是考慮重點。至於新山不會因為RTS房價就亂亂漲，90多萬去新加坡打工的人也不會全搬回去住。騎摩托的照樣騎摩托。
感谢分析和提供有用信息🙏🏻👍🏻
當然是在新加坡買了房後出租，幾年後在新山買一間拿來住。有得收房租，不需要做工了。
感谢分享看法😊👍🏻
我的建议单身的来新加坡做工，存多多钱回去买屋子，赶快供完，就轻松了
👍🏻🌹
如果是有钱的马来西亚人，房价不是问题，问题是ABSD。有PR的话第一套5%，第二套就30%了。外国人第一套就是60%。如果ABSD也拦不住的土豪新加坡的房产肯定是比JB值得投资的。如果是普通家庭估计都是在新加坡生活，拿了PR买hdb吧。那时候就是比新加坡的组屋和JB的各种房子了。而新加坡人肯定是在新加坡有房才会去考虑投资。新加坡人第二套是20%ABSD。投资JB的新加坡人并不少。
感谢分享👍🏻
200K新币, 750K马币, 可以买走路10分钟到CIQ的RnF二房condo.
RTS通车之后, 多个20分钟, 就到Woodland North.
新加坡人, 将新加坡屋子出租, 就可以在JB退休了。
感谢分享你的观点😊👍🏻
听说r&f 的finishing 很差。而且富力集团在中国已经破产😂
新加坡买房，大马租房更划算😊
U will need proper n valid documents to reside in Malaysia! Customs will Question your purpose of visit even if it’s for 2 weeks stay ! your stamp entry n exit will reflect on your passport, even if Singaporeans have ASEAN agreements for 30 day visa ! buying a property in Malaysia don’t equal a visa ! property around or near CIQ is very Noisy with huge lorry’s horns throughout Day n Night ! heavy Traffic jams, foot traffic! a 10 mins ride back to my condo took me 3 hours back home ! condo facilities like swimming pool, gym etc r charged per square foot of your condo unit! the bigger your condo u pay more ! Foreigners purchase is 5hundred thousand n above SG! with state consent which the Malaysia gov want a slice of property market! property in Malaysia got no resale value it’s called sub sale in Malaysia! if u want to buy SG HDB u have to surrender all Foreign property before buying HDB Singapore HDB law in case u don’t know ! JB got over supply of property, in KL , Penang is 2 million to buy n Sarawak n Sabah states r protected n special to Malaysia gov ! I bought a property in Malaysia n regretted immensely!
1 for your weekend holiday use and 2 for investment. Ringgit may get weaker further.
👍🏻
要大買JB , 要賺錢買新加坡，兩樣都要，努力勤勞點😊
感谢你的观点👍🏻
Really depend on your purpose.
For investment in JB, you got to understand the FX risk and capital gain for foreigner upon selling.
Thanks for sharing🙏🏻👍🏻
And also the constant change of rules 😎
如果要在新山创业和工作的话，因该在新山买房，省下的钱可以用作*创业*和后备资金。 迈向经济独立。如果打算在新加坡工作，创业 十年以上，应该在新加坡买房。不管任何选择，记得不要变成房奴。 向银行借钱一定要量力而为。做好财务规划。
感谢分享🙏🏻👍🏻
Buy properties on both sides. Renting out in Singapore while living in Johor Bahru. The rental income from the Singapore property should be able to cover the mortgages for both properties.
Thanks for sharing👍🏻🌹
我见过新加坡家庭将他们的组屋出租，并在新山租用房屋过着舒适的生活。
Thanks for your video but just to clarify, Singapore PR alone is unable to own a HDB, unless he/she is married to a PR or Singapore citizen then only they can purchase a HDB.
Yup correct👍🏻Thanks for point out the part I missed😆
买耒住 理所当然去到哪里買在哪里方便 如果投资必须买新加坡的 如果一切如常外国人获利最大就算屋价不涨 十年后卖掉汇率就可賺翻了
👍🏻🌹
如果是要自己住的，我觉得可以在新山买，然后把新加坡屋子租出去。
如果是投资的话，很多新加坡人过去都投资了，有些买一间也有些买三四间，价格现在也有起了，算起来应该是赚到了，但兑换回新币就不是那回事了。
新加坡人喜欢新山的屋子并不是喜欢那些公寓，而是喜欢有土地的排屋或独立式房子。
现在新山屋子也不便宜了，如果有车的话，可以考虑买偏远一点的，价钱会便宜很多。
如果可以的话，我还是觉得买土地最合算，一两依吉的农业地种种果树假期时带孩子去果园玩玩，那就最理想了。
感谢分享观点😊👍🏻
马来西亚买房子完全没保障，撇开治安不说，食物卫生安全，医疗方便，周围环境都得不到保障，而且许多房子完全没有后续保养，不到8年就破旧不堪。
新山公寓烂尾八年无下文 狮城一众苦主越堤讨说法
22/10/2023 20:48
“还我们血汗钱！还我们棺材本！”马来西亚柔佛一栋烂尾高级公寓的大约100名苦主，当中包括好些特地越堤而至的新加坡受害业主，今天（22日）聚集新山向烂尾楼发展商讨说法，同时希望通过当地议员解决公寓烂尾问题。
据《8视界新闻网》记者了解，位于新山百万镇滨海地带的这个烂尾楼项目，原定2018年末竣工，如今却沦为废置工程。建筑承包商一换再换，许多业主苦等近八年无果。
记者今天（22日）也到新山了解情况，约百名来自新加坡和马国各地的苦主，聚集当地同柔佛巴西古当国会议员哈山卡林会面，望借助政府力量找到解决方案。
约三分之一买家是新加坡人
据了解，该项目至少三分之一买家是新加坡人。约20名狮城业主今天（22日）早上也特地从新加坡越堤而来，参加这项受害业主的集会。他们受访时诉苦说，公寓的工程虽已搁置，但银行利息还得照还，直斥发展商不负责任。
47岁的罗绍忠说，他在2016年10月与41岁妻子孙敏仪买了这个项目一个逾百万令吉（约28万8075新元）的单位，当初是因为看中这里优越的地理位置，想要用来养老，没想到如今却变成“啃老”。
“工程停，银行还是继续叫我们还贷款，现在每个月的利息是1600令吉（约460新元）。我们有询问银行，为何没建好却要我们继续还钱。他们回复说，是发展商叫我们还，如果不这么做就会宣告我们破产，到时候进来马来西亚也会成问题。”
56岁的曾国奋今天（22日）则是和妻子、小姨一起越堤前来，小姨在该发展项目同样买了一个单位。据了解，他的小姨目前已支付了约70%房贷。
“现在失望多过于生气。我们有听说，发展商在马来西亚政府那边放了一笔钱。如果发展不成功，那个钱会拿来赔我们 ，但是不知道这个钱要找谁去要。”
用养老金买楼 苦主：不知多久才能赚回
同样来自新加坡的56岁苦主蔡先生则透露，自己在买房时用上了养老金，原本是为养老，如今项目成为烂尾楼，坦言日后不知道还要工作多久才能把这笔钱赚回来。
“全部都是辛苦赚来的钱，作为一个普通的打工族，对我来说真的是很辛苦。（房子）你看得到，但却住不到。“
54岁的Eunice受访时也说，自己曾咨询过律师，想通过法律途径解决问题，然而律师无奈告知，过程将非常漫长，而且最后可能会没有结果。
马国议员：助向部长反映问题
柔佛巴西古当国会议员哈山卡林今天（22日）约3点抵达烂尾楼现场，并在附近一家餐馆与受影响业主会谈，同时也答复了业主询问。
他在接受媒体访问时表示，会把苦主的问题视为自己的问题，并承诺将把问题反映给马国地方政府发展部副部长阿克马。
“这是我第一次会见业主。我作为国会议员，将会向负责烂尾楼项目的副部长反应事件，我也将促请政府委任新的承包商，并对政府负责。”
不过他也提醒业主，如果委任新的承包商成事，可能需要面对罚款问题，屋主若想看到工程复工，可能得考虑放弃对发展商追讨罚款，与此同时，发展商可能会提出新的附加协议书，这些都是业主必须考虑到的。
你买房是来自己家住，还是投资很重要。马来西亚的房产过去资产回报率普遍比较低，连负的都有。如果不是柔佛人，买个小中型或组的比较实惠。
赞同👍🏻
完全没有说到重点，外国人大马买房会征税2%，100万收2万，反观新加坡是60%，100万抽税60万，你有钱也下不了手。
感谢分享👍🏻
如果你们是大马公民。应该在自己的国家买房置业才对。新加坡的房产太贵了。
🌹
身边很多人觉得买房子就要买大间，landed最好。 其实房子的位置才是房子升值的关键。 纽约曼哈顿的一个小公寓远比底特律大洋房值钱。
赞同👍🏻地点是重点🌹
There’s over supply of housing in Malaysia. Moreover, depreciation of Malaysian currency will impact any capital appreciation.
Thanks for sharing👍🏻
小建议！ 我觉得你们在介绍房屋单位的时候，如果时间充足可以尝试顺便也介绍那个单位，的周边环境和商店之类的，并且加入英文字幕方便来自更多国家的人观看就更好了。
好的，感谢给予反馈😊🙏🏻
@@ZackWinnieChannel 希望你的频道能够越做越好👍
如果您可以在那里赚到很多钱或者您有很多钱来应对高昂的生活成本，那么新加坡是一个居住的好地方。在考虑加入公民身份之前请仔细考虑。
感谢分享观点👍🏻
In singapore if hdb 4 rooms we can rent s $4500 to 5000..one room can be rent out $900 to 1000.s dollars.
🌹
我见过新加坡家庭将他们的组屋出租，并在新山租用房屋过着舒适的生活。
赚钱赚新币，花钱花马币。如果马币一直下跌的话，老实说投资房产的回报是有限的，除非政策上能吸引大量的中产移民J B。
感谢分享观点👍🏻😊
当然是在新加坡买，马来西亚的货币贬值就够你受的了。
谢谢你的观点👍🏻
90%貸款，马币贬值，开心才对
看马币一直在创新低和坚挺的新币就知道要选哪里了
感谢分享观点👍🏻
Need to be a PR (married) to buy HDB (resale only) in Singapore.
Yes, must be husband and wife, married status if PRs👍🏻
有本事的人在新加坡买比价实际. 没本事的就在马来西亚买吧.
感谢观点👍🏻🙏🏻
请问JB买个landed养老，治安还好吗？担心老了以后被抢
看地区😌
If applying for a new HDB, there is an income ceiling. I am not sure about the amount now, I think it’s SGD12K per household?
Thanks for sharing👍🏻🌹
thanks and i am thinking of buying one at JB
🌹
JB properties ~ have $ can buy; but when you want to sell??? No buyer=oversupply of condos, there is no subsale market and Malaysians want landed only.(Malaysians do want to pay for maintenance charges every quarterly).
I agree.. Not only just applicable to jb properties, but also to properties in KL & seremban... Hv to think twice if buying property in msia is fr investment or for own stay
Seremban properties ~ 100% not suited for Singaporean in aspect of capital gain = very unlikely, because of location n lacking buyers(especially selling to Singaporeans only because Malaysian preference to landed).
KL ~ must only be in “Orchard-Malaysia” = Bukit Bintang vicinity. Best choice for capital investment in Malaysia.
JB ~ suitable only for own stay.
Thanks for sharing your point of view👍🏻
If you are a Malaysian staying in Malaysia buying Malaysian property for raising a family due to the much bigger space than SG then by all means cos your family will be happier with a big house rather than a pigeon hole. But if you are buying property for investment, it's obvious you can't make money with Malaysian property. Malaysian ringgit keeps falling. It used to be 1:1 to SGD. Now it's 3.5:1. My prediction is it will be 4:1 and beyond in the near future. Whatever capital appreciation is lost to depreciation of the currency. Singapore has scarcity of land. With limited land supply, there is very little downside risks. For investment purposes, SG properties will hold its value. In fact, so many foreigners are snapping up SG properties cos SG is a safe haven for their money until the government had to step in and introduce 60% ABSD to stop the buying. Frankly this move speaks volumes on the attractiveness of SG properties for investment. No brainer actually.
Thanks for sharing🙂👍🏻
应该问在哪里赚钱比较多,比较稳及比较容易。
好主意😆👍🏻
新加坡就这么大，土地除了填海就不会再长大了，马来西亚反过来还一堆的未开发森林。如果两边的需求一样你们自己认为那边更值得买？何况现实需求两边都不一样。买房子不止得看房子本身还得看周边环境，看工作机会。
感谢分享观点👍🏻
新加坡的组屋很难有99年～
大家都会卖旧买新。
强制收回如果成真～也是因为这是危楼了～政府也会用市价跟你买回～拿这钱去买另一个组屋，政府也会给你选择买有经贴的新组屋～或者你也可以不要经贴～选择在公开市场选自己喜欢的成熟区域买转售组屋。
钱不会被“吃掉”的😂😂😂
感觉大家对99年的屋契有很大的误解
@@yamphengtang130很不理解买永久地契说要传给下一代的说法，屋子那么老了下一代会要吗？ 😂
@@actnaturally388 没有永久，只是屋子最久是99年～
屋主住了五年以上，随时都可以买卖。
屋子最后也可以传给下一代～如果只卖不买～从公积金用到的数目就会回到公积金～剩下的的就是现金。
@@yamphengtang130 对的，身边很多朋友买房的时候就只考虑到买大间一点住到老。但像新加坡这种经济发达的地方，人是一直流动的，买间房子住到老这种观念其实不太实际。
@@actnaturally388 也很少人会一直想要住在旧屋………哪里方便～哪里新，大屋换小屋～小屋换大屋，看当时的情况呗
I have a question. I'm Singaporean.
If I wish to sell my Malaysian property, what I need to pay extra or tax for sales of property?
Or if I pass away, does my children has a problem to acquire my property?
Thanks for the comment🙏🏻You may need to look for the agent who help you to sell your property because they will know more in details for your situation🌹
Put in your children name as co owner
加油！
谢谢你👍🏻
如果是foreigner要买马来西亚房产可以借贷款吗？
可以的🌹
你是买来投资还是买来住？ 买来住舒服开心买马来西亚的。买来投资赚钱的买新加坡的。
1。新币强劲，未来10，20年可能1兑4，10年后卖掉新加坡房子兑马币，房价赚，货币差价也赚。
2。新加坡廉政金融安全，就业机会多，货币大工钱高，世界从商人精英到工人都往这里进入赚钱，房子需求量大，所以房价会涨，单单出租房间就赚1千新币一个月，而且很容就能找到住客出租。马来西亚房间租不到这个价钱。
3。新加坡是移民国家，只要你是精英都能拿永久居民，拿新加坡国籍。房子需求量自然也提高。
马来西亚以上3点都没有，不适合投资。但是你是想要享受生活住洋房，马来西亚房子适合。
感谢分享👍🏻🌹
Buying a property in JB vs SG, JB property may appreciate but the RMB will devaluate.
My friend bought a JB property some 15 years ago, that time S$1=RMB2.5, now it is S$1=RMB3.4. Convert back to SG$, you still loss money.
You think you will make money?
Unless you are Malaysian, nothing to say.
Thanks for the comment🙏🏻👍🏻
👍👍👍👍👍
🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹
请问我是新加坡 pr 可以在马来西 哑政府 买 廉价 房子。吗？
只有马来西亚公民才能购买马来西亚的廉价屋哦🌹
这根本不用比，天淵之别，第一和第三
😌🌹
Buy singapore for value
Old already sell
dollar 1 bacome 5
Already 😊 to the bank.
🌹🌹
新加坡买的会真值
🌹
Buy no, rent OK.
👍🏻🌹
Sgrean buying msia house for investment? 😢
🌹
HDB is not meant for foreigners and not designed as speculative commodity. Please do not use it as a comparison item.
Thanks for sharing your point of view👍🏻
没有那个国家是最好的，只有最适合自己的国家，因每个人的家庭家族结构不一样只有最适合自己的国家，没有最好和最不好的分别。
赞同👍🏻适合自己最重要～
我很多朋反友新山租房新加坡买房
感谢分享👍🏻
Use kamunting police-station and beautify using tai-ping and avoid mee-udang.
Map overlay - find spot for dog dig bone and jack-sparrow to dig for bone.
I caught the malaysians, before covid19. After that they sulk-tun the tiny-states individually
Now they political-master short-term yahya-pap-aya yip-blap-him
Pitstop NS-highway RR-level
👍🏻
錯字更正：「植」房產-> 購「置」房產
感谢纠正😆👍🏻
What make you an expert to sell property in S’pore? Please don’t compare. S’pore is far more advanced than M’sia in many aspects..😅
Thanks for sharing your point of view🙂
槟城买房不好么，作为一个从上海搬到新加坡的人，另一半香港生新加坡籍，比来比去还是槟城最好。新加坡，上海，香港房子一卖，槟城住的爽到家🤣
感谢分享观点👍🏻
Ai, got money SG. Property here is protected and double every 10-20 yrs. No money JB liao...JB is free market, price might drop drastically during crisis.
Thanks to share you point of view🙏🏻👍🏻
Without a stable job or big income, do not blindly follow people to buy property for 'investment'.
👍🏻
別害人， 新加坡房子是会increase in value plus exchange rate - the gain is exponential . 马来西豆的房子是没有resale value
Different conditions because of scarcity of land in Singapore.
感谢分享观点🌹
sgedit-r不要胡说八道
我的双层排屋买RM300K
现在可以卖RM600K
@@cac1504你写什么鬼？你不会华语？
Singapore is good place to earn money, but not a place for retirement.
Gaza strip is a good place for retirement. Cheap and adrenaline pumping days and nights.
Thanks for sharing👍🏻
when you’re getting old, you need all the resources around you to support your living, I don’t understand why ppl want to “balik kampung” when they retire.
@@actnaturally388not everyone needs the capitalist resources of a big city to retire comfortably and safely.
可悲的是，大多数新加坡人都认为购买房产是致富的一种手段。
感谢分享观点🌹
新加坡比較有好價。又有價錢。馬東西亞沒價錢。又不安全。
感谢分享观点👍🏻
一个屋顶
一个屋下
除非你是亿万富翁
感谢分享观点👍🏻
1
🌹
One will need proper n valid documents to reside in Malaysia, customs will Question your purpose of visit! even if it’s 2 weeks of stay , your entry n exit will reflect on your passport! even if Singapore has agreements with ASEAN for 30 days stamp ! buying a property in Malaysia does not equal a visa ! Foreigners pay 500 thousand SG n above for property or condo , Malaysia gov take a slice of property market State consent! condo facilities like swimming pool gym etc r charged per square foot of your condo unit , the bigger your unit u pay more , property near or around CIQ is very noisy with huge lorry’s horns throughout day n night , heavy traffic jam , foot traffic! a 10 mins ride back to my condo took me 3 hours back home ! different states got Different laws KL , Penang is 2 million to purchase, Sarawak Sabah r protected special states ! if Singaporean want to buy SG HDB u have to surrender all Foreign property before buying HDB SG Law in case u didn’t know ! if buy Malaysia property it is to live n not Hope to flip n make money ! Malaysia property got no resale value it’s called sub sale in Malaysia! I bought a property in Malaysia n regretted immensely!
Thanks for sharing👍🏻🌹
Enter using egate.
Buying properties u need a healthy secondary mkt & stable currency exchange. It is not ta buying a cheap big bungalow but buying a gd value property ta can sell easily & gd return 😎 JB hvnt reach ta point yet cos due to low domestic participation 🥸
Thanks for the sharing👍🏻🌹
Investment = singapore. Malaysia just buy as a retirement home, make money gd for u, lose money normal.
😆👍🏻
2
🌹🌹🌹
马币一直下滑！。
🙂
Is that obvious?
🌹
你是以住的观点还是赚钱的出发点来探讨这个话题？😮
没有一个标准，就是需要看个人的观点是什么，完全认同可以往“住”和“赚钱”的方向去想👍🏻
有錢買SG，沒錢買JB。
😆
买新加坡房产赚新币， 用马币租马国房产
👍🏻🌹
欸廢話，當然是新加坡買完才考慮新山買多一個。你買新山不可能買回新加坡的
🙂🌹
我见过新加坡家庭将他们的组屋出租，并在新山租用房屋过着舒适的生活。
1
🌹
2
🌹
1
👍🏻🌹