Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.
Land and Freedom (1995 Ken Loach) [ENG Sub]
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 май 2016
- Land and Freedom (or Tierra y Libertad) is a 1995 film directed by Ken Loach and written by Jim Allen. The film narrates the story of David Carr, an unemployed worker and member of the Communist Party of Great Britain, who decides to fight for the republican side in the Spanish Civil War.
It's been a long time since l've seen a movie that fits all the categories of what's meant to be a great movie...Not one minute of your time will be wasted if you decide to watch this film....Bravo.
I have become more conservative with my advancing years, but I am still moved by this Ken Loach film. Moved by the idealism. Moved by the bravery of those who committed everything to the fight. A few years after Spain it was everyone's fight to defeat fascism.
As exhibited in this movie, ideology has a hard time with complexity.
@@odiferousmusky1299 No... Ideas have a hard time fighting obfuscation by those who oppose them.
As we see here, and has been seen for decades by those who open their eyes to reality, Stalin was never communist. He was just a mad dictator who, in order to achieve power, not only fomented corruption in his his country but also in the ideology of Communism.
He was actually a supporter of Fascism in his methods and achievements.
@@Kimdino1 Yeah no he was a communist. One can be a communist and be evil, usually this is the case. He was in the underground resistance to the Tsar.
@@johnnotrealname8168 No, he was not a communist!
Communism, as described by Marx & many others requires a classless, stateless & moneyless egalitarian society. So I ask you was Stalins Russia:-
a) Egalitarian - Can you explain the leaders of the regime?
b) Classless - Can you explain the perks the leaders were given, the limos, dachas etc?
Stateless - So can you explain the existence of Russia, Czechoslavaikia, Ukraine et.al?
Moneyless - How does the rouble fit here?
Much as he professed to be, and the West used the term to describe his regime as such, he was NOT communist.
A name does not make the entity. Hitler described himself as a gentle man, would you describe the acts supported by him as gentle? No matter how much I call myself Superman, I will never be able to fly.
I have watched this movie over and over again for years and read many books about the spanish civil war. This struggle is deeply connected with my heart. The first tanks who arrived in Paris to liberate France had spanish names.
In World War II?
This movie really shows the "Maybe the real civil war was the friends we made along the way"
And also that blind idealism leads you nowhere.
@@ahmadm8382 I don't really see where that comes across. More like, "Don't make friends with Stalinists because they WILL betray the revolution."
People when civil wars aren't shown as COD campaigns:
@@ahmadm8382 You missed the point.
@@ahmadm8382 The person above me is right. The movie takes heavy influence from Homage to Catalonia with the whole point of the book and to a slightly lesser extent Orwell's work in general being that no matter how unlikely the hope is for genuine revolution against those who wish to destroy or corrupt it for their own selfish and totalitarian ends, that unyielding bravery and hope for a better world and willingness to fight for it to the bitter end is absolutely a cause worth fighting for.
A great film, if you're ever in Liverpool, call into the Casa on Hope Street, a pub set up by former Liverpool dockers and the photos on the wall of the men and women of the International Brigade No Pasaran !
Aye? How did that work out for them?
@@indigohammer5732how’s being a nonce working out for you?
@indigohammer5732 It never works out well for those who have the courage to rise up against the elites; it doesn't mean that we should stop trying. Without the sacrifice of heroic people like those depicted in the film, child labour would still be rife and we wouldn't have paid holidays, 8h work days, 2-day weekends, minimum wage laws, and a long etc of rights you take for granted. They were all written in labourists blood.
Anyway, we rightfully remember the selfless men and women who took up arms to fight against fascism in the last purely idealistic war, the Spanish Civil War, as heroes. That's more than what can be said about cynical, parasitic losers who have nothing better to do than writing flippant comments on RUclips.
Or you could just read "1984" by George Orwell, for a cultural legacy of making the mistake of fighting for the Spanish Repugnant....
@@TomasFunes-rt8rd Orwell fought for the republic. He never regretted it, he'd be disgusted by the attempt to co-opt his works by scvm like you.
I think a lot about what an exciting time it must have been, people traveled abroad to help the revolution because they believed in something bigger then themselves.
Death to all fugging communists, fugghead. This film is one parody about the stupidity of these idiots; what a chaotic group.
I know exactly what you mean. Iraq, 2003.
@@claudeperkins539
You mean because international, democratic troops also intervened against (Baath) fascism, albeit with more success?
I can see the common ground, but I think that would be too much of an honour for the USA and its 'coalition of the willingˋ.
This struggle is still going on now. Are you really unaware?
@@tinabraxton4906 Which struggle today do you consider comparable?
Brilliant film, brilliant astounding acting, brilliant camera work. Kevin Loach does it again.
I watched this in two halves, as a film and production, only great, this caught the idealism, rebelliousness of the UK working class and them going to Spain captivated by idealism, they were going to DO it, here, in Spain. Thwarted ideals, failed ideals of these young men, dont you just love the lines where the two men, Liverpool and Manchester, they recognize the accents: "where are you from?" and the replies, "why aren't you over here?" Irish men on opposite sides fought in this same war. Only this week we get a glimpse, it's a country still divided, the lines of division are clear.
Sincere thanks for this upload!
Nice one pal, I've been looking for this film for ages!
Tomorrow is ours!
From the Spanish Revolution to the Zapatista Movement and to the Rojava Revolution. Our hopes are barely sustained.
Greetings from Tokyo, Japan.
I haven't heard from too many comrades from Japan, it's good to see. How is organization and the spread of class consciousness going over there?
Currently, Japan is in the process of decline.
Japanese companies that were once famous have lost their competitiveness, gone bankrupt, or been acquired by companies from other countries.
Japan, which was second in the world in terms of personal income 20 years ago, has now fallen to 19th place.
The current state of the Japanese economy is creating anxiety about the future among the Japanese people.
In Japan, nationalism is on the rise in an attempt to counteract the anxiety and disappointment of the people, and xenophobic demonstrations against Koreans living in Japan are taking place in the streets.
Currently, the main practical battle in Japan is to silence far-right nationalists who are stirring up nationalism and waging a movement to exclude Koreans living in Japan.
Racists, get out!
ruclips.net/video/HDWhAplsBOQ/видео.htmlsi=Vra5g9nmt_eYjbvg
ruclips.net/video/MMpGdOVzNzA/видео.htmlsi=zRDKXXZuW6cUuyPE
I never met my father’s brother my uncle Joe he died in Spain fighting for the Republicans against Facists My father only found out over a year later from one of his comrades who got back to England. He gave my father hi Joes watch that he promised Joe he would . My father treasured it and when he died I inherited it I have passed it on to my grandson on his 18th birthday. Telling him its story I have always felt proud of my uncle who gave up everything to go to fight and eventually die so far from home for the cause of freedom.
If you liked this watch 'The Wind that shook the Barley' Another Ken Loach classic
This is one of my favorite films ever. I saw it in a teather 1995.
Pobre jente Que vinieron a compartir su suerte y destino con el PUEBLO español muchos dejaron aqui su vida pero nos dejaron un legado soliradio, asi Como fueron traicionado Por el Stalinismo !!!
'Most people haven't got guns.' This is accurate. The republicans had a very hard time getting the weapons and ammo needed to fight the war. By contrast the nationalists were supplied by the germans and italians. In fact it was italian supplies that kept the nationalists in the fight. So much so that ironically when Italy entered WW2 its reserve stocks were dangerously depleted. Italy lost WW2 on the fields of Spain. The movie takes liberties with the facts but not as much as you would think. Details like the collective nature of republican forces with a loose respect for rank the lack of training and supplies those are mostly accurate. I also like the chaotic nature of the battles which seem more like an improvised affair than something well planned. And everyone remembers that bolt action rifles are bolt action no automatic or semiauto fire.
Amazing movie. Viva Durruti!
I've been learning Spanish at School alot and I love this movie. It's a tale of conflict between comrades in a time of civil unrest and war. Very emotional and a highly recommended.
VIVA UNA ESPAÑA Y IBERIA LIBRE! ✊🏼🇪🇸🇵🇹
España e Iberia
@@Chiquichu61SIM!
Absolutely inspiring 👏 Thank you for posting
I'm not gonna comment on how great the movie is or how important it is, and revolutionary activity...I just wanna say the acting in this is incredible! Seriously I need to find out how this movie was made cause these actors are incredible.
It’s Mr. Blanky! He was off to fight the Civil War before finding the Northwest Passage. Always an adventurer.
Watched this many, many times,,,,,,,,,,absolutely magnificent xx
Great stuff! thanks for posting this.
Good movie, thanks for postings. Really highlights the in fighting on the side of the left
I found this film even better than Hollywood's "To whom the bell tolls ..." with Gary Cooper and Ingrid Bergman.
No comparison. Read "Homage to Catalonia," which inspired this undoubtedly.
Anything is better than jewwywood shite.
I recommend you read Mine Were of Trouble (1957) By Peter Mant MacIntyre Kemp.
Excellent historical movie. Thank you.
Great film!
Seeing it after finishing Homage to Catalonia made it so much better
I listened. To, my great uncle bill hogan .he told me he fought for the socialist side ,of the spanish civil war then in second world war .i dont know ,much .of the spanish civil war but i have great respect for spain..well done in making the film .👍
Thanks so much for posting,
Left, Right, Communist, Fascist...when all's said and done it's a case of same shit, different moustache
ignorant statement
Are there any books that detail the power struggle between the POUM & Anarchists versus the International Communist Brigades? Any that detail the May Day conflicts that occured in Barcelona?
George Orwell’s An Homage to Catalonia covers it, albeit not in loads of detail and it’s more a personal account than anything.
Rudolf Rocker's The Tragedy of Spain might help you out here
This documentary touches upon this subject as well: Ethel MacDonald: An Anarchist's Story - Scottish International Brigades Spanish Civil War CNT ruclips.net/video/OEYLJb_sspU/видео.html
Blood of Spain by Ronald Fraser describes the rift in detail if you can follow the alphabet soup of acronisms.
Anything by Paul Preston especially " The Spanish Holocaust".
I have watched this movie because of my love's recommendation
It's worth to watch.
Thanks for uploading this film ❤❤
I think this film story based on homage to catalonia for George Orwell ❤
Fantastic film
God bless you for posting this film
Great 🎉 thankyou 🙏
Ken Loach could have chosen the easy way, 'good versus evil' - instead, he chooses the truth, and makes the one of the best political films I've ever seen in 40 years' activism, a magnificent monument to the Spanish comrades and the foreign volunteers. It's also an inspiration for today: look at the world - the new fascists, parties like Vox and Fratelli D'Italia, demagogues like Orbán, Putin, Ramaswamy, Milei, are all spouting garbage while the earth burns. The power to stop their hate and madness is the same as then - we, the millions who make the world work, but don't control it; we are that power, if we only use it... ¡Viva la clase obrera! ¡Viva la revolución!
If you think Milei is a fascist then you aren't deserving of oxygen
A guy who thinks the climate crisis is a 'socialist lie', wants to ban abortion, abolish (among others) the ministries for women and science, legalise human organ sales, and introduce gun laws that make Texas look restrictive, a guy who supports and is supported by Ted Cruz, Ron De Santis, Donald Trump, Jair Bolsonaro, and Vox - yes, I'd say his fascist credentials are pretty good. So, I don't deserve oxygen? Oh, OK, that's me done, then, I can't possibly win against such penetrating analysis and argument.@@mansendwish
Lol shut up commie😂
@@mansendwish If you want to deny someone oxygen because they called out an authoritarian moron, then maybe you are not one to talk about fascism.
@@wonkothesane4490 They don't deserve oxygen I said. Also how dare you call Milei an Authoritarian when that's exactly who he's fighting against.
A bit of Homage to Catalonia
Thank you for sharing
Saw this when it came out. Brilliant.
思いは世代を超えて受け継がれて行きます。No Pasarán!
I dream and believe, our day will come
I heard of the Franco-Spanish war but only part of the German Luftwaffe but this film made it real.
At least now we can say today we have our united front. Not just in Spain either. Rest well comrades, we will take it from here.
Came here because one Stalinist on Twitter was complaining that this movie was Trotskyite propaganda. They referenced an article also, in some communist paper. Maybe it is Trotskyite propaganda, but let the Stalinists make their own propaganda rather than complain. We will see if it is as good, or if the characters and their relationships are as appealing as the ones in this film.
VIVA el comunismo libertario y democratico!!!
I am fortunate to say that when I was a kid in the mid/late 1970s my Dad told me of The Spanish Cival War and the anti fasist domonstrations in London's East End (Brick Lane) he made me awear of our world song The Internation!.
A truly great film. Though the "This film is protected by copyright" message in the end credits is hypocritical. Acceptable only because that's the way our world works .
Please upload kes 1969
I am from Russia, I am against war and dictatorship, they will not pass. Нам ребята в этой жизни только с правдой по пути.
this is so beautiful ❤🖤
No comments from 16 hundred views. Huh. My comment would be either have the movie in English or Spanish or have subtitles. A little hard to understand.
I think in a way that’s the point is to portray language barriers realistically as well as challenge the audience, motivate them to learn Español as it is an important language internationally, and thus for purposes of solidarity
@@justinanderson617callme I agree with you, but if you are going to get Americans to learn Español to watch this movie, Good Luck!!!
@@davidlafranchise4782 If you don't speak any Spanish then you experience the film the same way David does when he first gets to Spain, and by the end of the film you'll have at least picked up a little. The acting is really authentic, so what's going on in a scene emotionally is quite easy to follow even if you don't know what exactly they're saying.
The original cinema release was subtitled as was the BFI DVD release. Without subtitles most viewers (including me) would not appreciate the brilliant 20 minute scene when the villagers discuss and argue about collectivisation.
The movie is suppose to have subtitles.
The kind of film we will never see in my country...plagued by hollywoodian rubbish...🤔👎👎🇸🇻
Lessons from the past to be applied to the future . Say no more. SNm 😃💕💕💕💕💟
How did European Monarchies loose power except England? Nothing changed by 2023.
Hasta la victoria siempre.
A spanish customer of mine says they don’t even teach about the spanish civil war in school.
Millions of fractions
TIME TO WAKE UP
Will this story will be remembered as Moses's Party vs Pharaoh? Or as Noah's Party struggle? Yes it will as humans still have they soul
what??
Hasta la Victoria!
No Pasaran!
this is a good film
I was very angry Stalin who betrayed Spanish revolution. It's the same as Chinese Communist Party betrayed Thai revolution in late 1970s.
Stalin murdered the Bolshevik Revolution first, then made sure the Chinese, the Germans and the Spanish would also fail. True world revolution would have meant Stalin was just another Bolshevik, and he wanted to be Tsar.
Me too. It makes me really hate tankies/people who defend the Soviet model/authoritarian "socialism". They are just as, if not more damaging to the proletarian movement than anti-communists.
Viva la revolución! ✊🏿✊🏾✊🏽✊🏼✊🏻
@@joeyj6808 Если бы не Сталин, Вы бы не высказывали сейчас свои мысли. Вас бы просто не было, Адольф сожрал бы всех. Подумайте над этим.
Soviet chatos and international brigades were literally why Madrid didn't fall to Franco.
Not to mention the only actual move to the Aragon front was after the battle of belchite, when communist general lister occupied belchite.
@@JSmusiqalthinka authoritarian socialism, you mean socialism?
the opening goes hard as fuck
The scenes have a, 'made for TV' drama vibe about them. The clothes don't look lived in.
Acracia al fin triunfara
REspect and sorrow
No pasarán ✊
What is the name of this anthem??? 3:22
A las barricadas
@@davidvillegas3530 thanks
Spain stayed neutral in the second world war, but it got its fair share of wartime atrocities in this civil war, committed by all sides.
Good film but quite biased towards the Republican side.
Thankfully!
W E NEED THIS IN ALL COUTRIES OF THE WORLD TODAY....UP THE REVOLUTION!
"land of freedom" is what they use to call "USA".. can you say, "negative impacts of progress"?
very good film
Poundland 'Hommage to Catalonia' by bolly Bolshevik #1
El socialismo es algo muy Grande, Que para Que funcione hace falta Mas Que pensamiento, CORAZON!!!
La unica iglesia que ilumina es la que arde...37:50
We will not let any change fascism to succeed
Bad syntax. Illegible.
This is such a wonderful film
Best ideology ever ❤
Long live Republican Spain
非常好电影👍 爱来自中国
does anyone have any other leftist film recommendations?
I don't, unfortunately
Anything by Alan Clarke, Ken Loach.
@@jody1367 thank you!
Matewan about US coal wars.
Kes and Looks and Smiles are a good start! Both Loach films.
In these times, No pasarán feels more important that ever. Many believe the neofascist parties are going to advance a lot in the coming European Parliament elections (beginning of June 2024). People voting for fascists. Tragic.
SNM 💟💟💟💟
thank God the stalinist side lost the war....
Reactionary..
@Leo I The Thracian the stalinist were pure evil. anything is better. do you know who stalin was?
@Leo I The Thracian of course, but stalin was behind the "republican" side. if they won spain would have became a soviet state dependant of USSR. in that second fase anarchists, liberals and socialists would been eliminated, just as happened in the soviet union.
In what universe does Franco's fascists look like the "good guys" to you?!
@Leo Da Vince And no worse.
Wow, Spain was sure torn between two evils in the '30's.
Arriba el trozkismo y abajo el FACISMO
POUM wasnt trotskyist
The andrew tate of the spanish civil war