This is a very hot topic, here is my 2cents regarding sa issue na ito. You came here as a student to STUDY and you have the funds to sustain and support yourself. If you finished your studies you go back to your home country ganon lang kasimple. And sorry but students don't have the right to demand to have or be granted PR Status
NO! they don't have a right at all, the government did not promised them...Please for those who still have plans of coming here, please STOP and DON'T as not to WORSEN the living situation of Canada. Please bring the OLD Canada back to the Local Citizens
They should see their Statement of Purpose in application for their student visa. Diba sinasabi nila na babalik sila sa country nila after studies nila hehe. Naging mayaman ang mga agencies 😅
Canada has, for decades, been in the top 10 of safest and least racist countries on planet Earth. Plus prosperous. Now there is a new negative spin that most Canadians do NOT deserve to a high degree. People must look at both sides. Since 2020, international students have been flocking to a educational system that many Canadians now feel was used by many of them as a loophole-to-immigration. Students utilizing schooling as a back-door (not front-door) ticket to living in Canada. Swarming a 50+ year tradition/system that was not not NOT designed to be about every international student INSISTING on receiving Permanent Residency. Plus it was not designed to be primarily about students demanding lengthy work permits (& spouse permits etc.). Canadians have clued in that Canada's post secondary education system has (in 5 years time) turned into what many are now jokingly calling EDUGRATION. An extreme not approved by everyday Canadians. What about Ghost Consulting that Canada told India to halt? Canadians want $ greedy foreign agents to stop marketing & lying to their own people about access to PR or citizenship … or accommodation/jobs … in places like Canada being relatively easy. At best, there is a 20% chance of PR (better odds if career is in HIGH demand). And what about all the YT videos that primarily Indian nationals have posted (for half a decade now including today) all advertising Canadian PR like they're selling a product? Promoting Canadian visas & permits & schools & jobs etc. etc.. Videos not only posted hourly but rarely in English or French. With very very rare input from Canadian-born citizens. Plus Canada didn't have numerous PRIVATE 'diploma mills' until 40% of international students were from India. Coincidence? Mills that Canada is shutting down. AND the bulk of them are near Brampton Ontario and Surrey B.C.. Coincidence? Canada is now compelling ALL schools to report to Immigration whether a student is attending school and complying with permit requirements or not. Were Canadian public colleges & universities greedy too (while honest)? Sure. But the Canadian government stepped in and slowed them down too (like a trustworthy government should). Are most international students truly scholars who came to Canada with enough $ to support themselves while STUDYING? Or economic migrants, who borrowed $ to buy their way closer to the head of the immigration line? To say all the students or their consultants have not been at times 'gaming' Canada's education programs to gain western PR or $ is ridiculous. Students have contributed to Canada's severe housing crisis and lack of entry jobs because 90% conspire-to-outstay a TEMPORARY permit. Canada wants to help people, but not when it contributes to severe home unaffordability and a recession. If 36,000,000 Canadians travelled to India, since 2020, with the goal of being able to stay there permanently, that would raise India's population by 2.65%. Recent asylum seekers crossing into Canada… and international students... have raised Canada's population higher than 2.65%. More needing healthcare too (affecting waiting times etc.). What about the IELTS spouses? Anchor babies? Fraud? False asylum claims? What about Canadian food banks & other charity services being recklessly advertised on YT in Indian languages? What about Canadian housing being scooped up en-mass as investment vehicles by/for internationals? Home rental/boarding signs stating "vegetarians only can apply". Indian nationals buying local businesses then putting Indians only in key positions (while also drastically changing work practices that include working more hours for less money). Plus BC & Ontario are outlawing the Caste System. Then throw in the Sikh vs Hindu violence/extortions across Canada. Diasporas stirring up tribal hatreds (in Canada) … even though it all stems from their ancestral home. How can peace be found anywhere with this in play? Plus the Canadian government recently launched investigations in regards to foreign interference in Canadian elections, stemming from Asia continent. Canada also had to end flagpoling at the border. In recent years, Canadians are having to worry about their automobile being stolen by auto theft rings. For just one example of what Canadians see regarding this new concern research; "arrests in connection with $9.24M Toronto-area auto theft ring". Research; "Gold stolen in Canada's biggest ever heist ended up in India". On YT look up "TorontoPolice News Conference Project Déjà Vu". Major scams involving foreign call centres too. Canadians are so so so not used to all this. So many, who have embraced multi-culturalism and immigration for decades are now worried/fearful. All are praying it doesn't turn into anger. Canadians want multi-culturism to succeed and for all people (including immigrants) to be okay. Everyone I know is VERY happy with IRCC's recent changes (reductions & multifaceted investigations etc.). Including multi-generational long-term Asian Canadians MOST upset (by all of this). Canadians are aware that some wonderful students/humans are going through hell. And know Canada is partially to blame which is awful. But Canada decides what needs to be done in Canada to prevent further pains. Do you see Canadians protesting in other countries (that is not their own) making demands for themselves? No. Do Canadians now see primarily Indians protesting in Canada making demands? Yes. Protesting because they don't have the credentials to stay in Canada. And because rules designed to protect CANADA are not meeting their desires/demands. And why isn't there crowds of African or Caribbean or Filipino etc., students protesting & waving their flags? They're in Canada too. Did international students and their families pay into Canadian taxes all their lives like domestic students have (earning cheaper tuition fees)? No. Did Canada force internationals to move to Canada as a STUDENT when their primary goal is work/PR? No. Did Canada promise/guarantee a job? And PR? No & no. Yet do they only blame Canada when they can't get work/PR??? After they came to Canada as a STUDENT? Look up Human Rights Index 2023. Canada is ranked 13th. USA is 17th. India 109th.
Part of the process in applying for the student permit is writing what we call the Statement of purpose. Unless you have dual intent which is to stay in Canada after graduation, international students are expected to go back to their home country after studies. Still, that doesnt give them the right to demand anything from the government. Also, (sorry po) but sometimes, it is the student’s fault for not doing proper research, naniniwala sa mga pangako ng agencies and I totally agree sa mga sinabi ng ibang nainterview na naging greedy ang mga agency. They’re all about making money and giving false hopes. One thing is for sure, nothing is guaranteed and anyone who is on temporary status - international students and temporary workers alike have no right to demand to extend their stay if the contract is over. If you wish to stay and gain permanent residency, idaan sa tamang process. Protesting is definitely not it though.
why do some people always yelling for their "Rights" but it's hard for them to comply to their "Responsibilities"? and what responsibility is that? Do your homework, be diligent. Lalo na yung nagsabing Police ang kurso nya, sus mio sa simpleng pangako lamang naloko na. This issue is not a political one nor violating rights , but rather these people is just manipulating as if sila ang agrabyado or inagrabyado. Ayaw sumunod sa proceso kaya ayan gusto i short cut.
Thank you ms Ina for this video.. now I know how to decide in the future. I said to myself, In God’s time, let God do the rest our stay here in Canada.. kung ano ibigay nyanpara sa amin..
They have no right to stay in canada if they applied as international student. Ang expectation sa kanila is may sapat silang pondo para mag-aral and after school uwi na sila. Pasalamat nga sila pinapayagan pa nga silang mag work. PR is a privilege not a right. Ang hirap sa mga bumbay na yan mga arogante mga bossy gusto nila gobyerno pa susunod sa kanila. They should have done their due diligence bago nila pinasok ang pagiging IS sa canada. Marami pati sa kanila hindi naman talaga nagaaral mga nagwowork lang. Isa pang problema jan hindi man lang nag-ungdergo ng criminal background check yang mga yan. May mga balita na mga gang member sa kanila nakapasok dito. Ever wonder why biglang dami ng carnapping jan sa BC simula nung dumami din yung mga yan jan? May mga nahuli na carnapper na kalahi nila.
Nature na nila yan may pagka rude at feeling superior o magaling! Kahit saang bansa ganyan sila but not all of them. May mga maayos din naman, madami din kaming kaibigan na indian at mababait at maayos. Siguro dala ng kultura at sitwasyon sa bansa nila na may mentalidad sila na “survival of the fittest” kaya ganyan sila dala dala nila yan kahit saan sila makarating. Just my two cents!😊
True yan...arrogant..i worked in indian company sa middle east panget ng management nila dinadaya kami sa oras ng work over ng 1 hr 8hrs dapat daily duty...mga supervisor dun mga epal kapag hndi nila ako mapasunod sa gusto nila dahil nasa tama ako sinusumbong ako sa GM tpos c GM ipapatawag ako pagagalitan...walang etiqette pati GM...kaya wala p kami 1 yr sa work nmin lumipat n kmi sa other company owned by arab...mas maganda management,benefits...salary....here in canada indian nagkalat sila...pati yun amoy akala mo nasa arab contry ka...😊
They have to regulate the entry of international students and have a more stringent selection process. I am an IS, but only 20% of my classmates come to class to study. The other 80% come to Canada to work and make money, and these are not even from professional jobs. Canadian education can be a great pathway to PR but it seems as if students are not being strategic about it and most are honestly NOT eligible to stay in Canada even with a permit.
I think mali ung approach to rally as if it's a "right" to become a permanent resident. The proper way is to come prepared. If you come as a student pero gusto mo pala maging citizen one day. Kailangan simula palang alam na ano plano para makapag apply for permanent resident. Hindi ung para silang nablindside kasi di pala sila qualified after studying.
About refugees, I think ibang usapan yun. Di proper "mainggit" kasi yung refugees nawalan ng home country so usually wala sila ibang options. Good for refugees na sila ay may pathway sa Canada. Wag tayo crab na porket mahirap for us ay dapat sila rin mahirapan.
Thanks for the video. It's nice to be able discuss this within the Filipino community. Although siyempre, diverse parin ang opinions kasi iba iba parin ang pinagdadaanan ng Filipinos in Canada.
kaya po importante din na mag research tayong mabuti at wag lng basta maniwala sa mga consultants, may mga legitimate naman tlga pero marami din nagsasamanatala. wala po tlgang rights mag demand and mga IS pero maraming ways para ma-pr dito, dapat lng tlgang i-plano ng mabuti para makuha mo ung PR. DYOR is the key. another good content Ms. Ina! KUDOS! 🙏
Hi, Ms ina sa video mabuti walang pinoy,sa akin lang dapat huwag umasa maging PR kundi gawin ang lahat para maging PR dito sa canada,samahan ng dasal,salamat po...
It's true where does the govt. getting the money to help out the refugee? It's not bad to help, but govt. should check what's the standiing of Canadian Citizen that pay their taxes?
Canada has good intentions with its immigration plan aiming to boost the economy by inviting skilled and young individuals. However, the country was not fully prepared for this influx. The immigration program lacks adequate risk management and contingency planning. The International Student Pathway is not a guaranteed route to PR, but it is one of the possible paths. We cannot blame international students for coming here, given the current policies that allow them to work while studying and after graduation, as long as they meet the requirements. Only “genuinely motivated students” who want to upgrade their skills and become more competitive in the market would choose to study here if the policy required them to leave the country after graduation. Canada has taken on more than it can manage. While it is heartwarming to know that the country is recognized for its humanitarian efforts, the reality is that the world is about survival. Historically, refugees have been welcomed by other countries if they are skilled or if their situation is among the most dire.
IIts been a while na Di ako nag take Ng bus and one time this week that I need to take a bus. And I was soo very surprised the bus is full and we are only two passenger different from them.Ang dami nila
There's never been no such right. It's based on demand and with so many International Students nowadays, the average 30% of students that gets PR every year is now even lower. They can try the US, Australia and Europe, lots of jobs there.
Hello Ina, it is not a right but to be fair, if we check the government website, it is written there that after graduation, students can work and live in Canada and use that work experience to gain permanent residence. Even provinces have their own provincial nomination eligibility for international students who studied in their province. The problem is walang limit or cap previously. Ngayon na lang nagka-cap dahil dumami beyond levels na kaya ng provinces and federal government. These protesters came into Canada during the time na under the province's rule, they only need 6 months to 1 yr experience to be eligible for PR nomination. Nag-change bigla ang mga eligibility habang nandito na sila kaya sila nagpoprotest. Yes, PR after studies is not a guarantee pero sa totoo lang, Canada gains billions from international students. They can limit, but they will not stop accepting international students for Canada's economy.
Yes, nothing against with international student. The government is too blame. I've been here in Canada for 32 years and its my first time to having a hard time to find a job. I've been jobless now for more than 1 year then no EI at all (done). I am a Canadian citizen where am I going to get the money to pay all our bills. Every single day I am applying. Govt. should stop inviting people to come over here in Canada and they can't even give what they promise. This should be stop. I'm a tax payer invested a lot of time here. Does the government will help people like me? And I have a little money from my RPP if I used it they will take out 30% tax which is so unfair for me. Govt. has no contribution with my RPP why taking too much tax?
Canada has, for decades, been in the top 10 of safest and least racist countries on planet Earth. Plus prosperous. Now there is a new negative spin that most Canadians do NOT deserve to a high degree. People must look at both sides. Since 2020, international students have been flocking to a educational system that many Canadians now feel was used by many of them as a loophole-to-immigration. Students utilizing schooling as a back-door (not front-door) ticket to living in Canada. Swarming a 50+ year tradition/system that was not not NOT designed to be about every international student INSISTING on receiving Permanent Residency. Plus it was not designed to be primarily about students demanding lengthy work permits (& spouse permits etc.). Canadians have clued in that Canada's post secondary education system has (in 5 years time) turned into what many are now jokingly calling EDUGRATION. An extreme not approved by everyday Canadians. What about Ghost Consulting that Canada told India to halt? Canadians want $ greedy foreign agents to stop marketing & lying to their own people about access to PR or citizenship … or accommodation/jobs … in places like Canada being relatively easy. At best, there is a 20% chance of PR (better odds if career is in HIGH demand). And what about all the YT videos that primarily Indian nationals have posted (for half a decade now including today) all advertising Canadian PR like they're selling a product? Promoting Canadian visas & permits & schools & jobs etc. etc.. Videos not only posted hourly but rarely in English or French. With very very rare input from Canadian-born citizens. Plus Canada didn't have numerous PRIVATE 'diploma mills' until 40% of international students were from India. Coincidence? Mills that Canada is shutting down. AND the bulk of them are near Brampton Ontario and Surrey B.C.. Coincidence? Canada is now compelling ALL schools to report to Immigration whether a student is attending school and complying with permit requirements or not. Were Canadian public colleges & universities greedy too (while honest)? Sure. But the Canadian government stepped in and slowed them down too (like a trustworthy government should). Are most international students truly scholars who came to Canada with enough $ to support themselves while STUDYING? Or economic migrants, who borrowed $ to buy their way closer to the head of the immigration line? To say all the students or their consultants have not been at times 'gaming' Canada's education programs to gain western PR or $ is ridiculous. Students have contributed to Canada's severe housing crisis and lack of entry jobs because 90% conspire-to-outstay a TEMPORARY permit. Canada wants to help people, but not when it contributes to severe home unaffordability and a recession. If 36,000,000 Canadians travelled to India, since 2020, with the goal of being able to stay there permanently, that would raise India's population by 2.65%. Recent asylum seekers crossing into Canada… and international students... have raised Canada's population higher than 2.65%. More needing healthcare too (affecting waiting times etc.). What about the IELTS spouses? Anchor babies? Fraud? False asylum claims? What about Canadian food banks & other charity services being recklessly advertised on YT in Indian languages? What about Canadian housing being scooped up en-mass as investment vehicles by/for internationals? Home rental/boarding signs stating "vegetarians only can apply". Indian nationals buying local businesses then putting Indians only in key positions (while also drastically changing work practices that include working more hours for less money). Plus BC & Ontario are outlawing the Caste System. Then throw in the Sikh vs Hindu violence/extortions across Canada. Diasporas stirring up tribal hatreds (in Canada) … even though it all stems from their ancestral home. How can peace be found anywhere with this in play? Plus the Canadian government recently launched investigations in regards to foreign interference in Canadian elections, stemming from Asia continent. Canada also had to end flagpoling at the border. In recent years, Canadians are having to worry about their automobile being stolen by auto theft rings. For just one example of what Canadians see regarding this new concern research; "arrests in connection with $9.24M Toronto-area auto theft ring". Research; "Gold stolen in Canada's biggest ever heist ended up in India". On YT look up "TorontoPolice News Conference Project Déjà Vu". Major scams involving foreign call centres too. Canadians are so so so not used to all this. So many, who have embraced multi-culturalism and immigration for decades are now worried/fearful. All are praying it doesn't turn into anger. Canadians want multi-culturism to succeed and for all people (including immigrants) to be okay. Everyone I know is VERY happy with IRCC's recent changes (reductions & multifaceted investigations etc.). Including multi-generational long-term Asian Canadians MOST upset (by all of this). Canadians are aware that some wonderful students/humans are going through hell. And know Canada is partially to blame which is awful. But Canada decides what needs to be done in Canada to prevent further pains. Do you see Canadians protesting in other countries (that is not their own) making demands for themselves? No. Do Canadians now see primarily Indians protesting in Canada making demands? Yes. Protesting because they don't have the credentials to stay in Canada. And because rules designed to protect CANADA are not meeting their desires/demands. And why isn't there crowds of African or Caribbean or Filipino etc., students protesting & waving their flags? They're in Canada too. Did international students and their families pay into Canadian taxes all their lives like domestic students have (earning cheaper tuition fees)? No. Did Canada force internationals to move to Canada as a STUDENT when their primary goal is work/PR? No. Did Canada promise/guarantee a job? And PR? No & no. Yet do they only blame Canada when they can't get work/PR??? After they came to Canada as a STUDENT? Look up Human Rights Index 2023. Canada is ranked 13th. USA is 17th. India 109th.
the only ones who have the right to stay are the ones who have a 'dual intent' study permit applications..they are the ones who visa officers see as assets of canada..
None one of them has the ‘right’ to stay here. It’s a privilege they’re here, while on a study permit. If a Canadian goes to the US as a student, he doesn’t have the right to stay in the US beyond what’s allowed as a Canadian.
Of course, they don’t have the right. They applied under student visa - As a student. And I don’t agree with it also. Pero mas katanggap-tanggap pakinggan yung mga ganito, kapag nanggagaling mismo sa ‘totoong’ citizen. Yung hindi immigrant din. Yung hindi naging citizen because of PR.
ang dami kasing na ikot ng mga consultant kasi pagdating daw dito mkahanap ng trabaho😂lubog na sa utang sa pinas, lubog din sa utang dito kasi yung POF pinoprovide ng agency pero pagdating dito cla tlaga yung nahihirapan.
This is a very hot topic, here is my 2cents regarding sa issue na ito. You came here as a student to STUDY and you have the funds to sustain and support yourself. If you finished your studies you go back to your home country ganon lang kasimple. And sorry but students don't have the right to demand to have or be granted PR Status
NO! they don't have a right at all, the government did not promised them...Please for those who still have plans of coming here, please STOP and DON'T as not to WORSEN the living situation of Canada. Please bring the OLD Canada back to the Local Citizens
They should see their Statement of Purpose in application for their student visa. Diba sinasabi nila na babalik sila sa country nila after studies nila hehe. Naging mayaman ang mga agencies 😅
Good morning ina! Another interesting topic. For me hindi dapat mag demand ang IS to be PR. But, after studying there are hundreds ways to be PR.
Canada has, for decades, been in the top 10 of safest and least racist countries on planet Earth. Plus prosperous. Now there is a new negative spin that most Canadians do NOT deserve to a high degree. People must look at both sides.
Since 2020, international students have been flocking to a educational system that many Canadians now feel was used by many of them as a loophole-to-immigration. Students utilizing schooling as a back-door (not front-door) ticket to living in Canada. Swarming a 50+ year tradition/system that was not not NOT designed to be about every international student INSISTING on receiving Permanent Residency. Plus it was not designed to be primarily about students demanding lengthy work permits (& spouse permits etc.). Canadians have clued in that Canada's post secondary education system has (in 5 years time) turned into what many are now jokingly calling EDUGRATION. An extreme not approved by everyday Canadians.
What about Ghost Consulting that Canada told India to halt? Canadians want $ greedy foreign agents to stop marketing & lying to their own people about access to PR or citizenship … or accommodation/jobs … in places like Canada being relatively easy. At best, there is a 20% chance of PR (better odds if career is in HIGH demand).
And what about all the YT videos that primarily Indian nationals have posted (for half a decade now including today) all advertising Canadian PR like they're selling a product? Promoting Canadian visas & permits & schools & jobs etc. etc.. Videos not only posted hourly but rarely in English or French. With very very rare input from Canadian-born citizens.
Plus Canada didn't have numerous PRIVATE 'diploma mills' until 40% of international students were from India. Coincidence? Mills that Canada is shutting down. AND the bulk of them are near Brampton Ontario and Surrey B.C.. Coincidence? Canada is now compelling ALL schools to report to Immigration whether a student is attending school and complying with permit requirements or not. Were Canadian public colleges & universities greedy too (while honest)? Sure. But the Canadian government stepped in and slowed them down too (like a trustworthy government should).
Are most international students truly scholars who came to Canada with enough $ to support themselves while STUDYING? Or economic migrants, who borrowed $ to buy their way closer to the head of the immigration line? To say all the students or their consultants have not been at times 'gaming' Canada's education programs to gain western PR or $ is ridiculous. Students have contributed to Canada's severe housing crisis and lack of entry jobs because 90% conspire-to-outstay a TEMPORARY permit.
Canada wants to help people, but not when it contributes to severe home unaffordability and a recession. If 36,000,000 Canadians travelled to India, since 2020, with the goal of being able to stay there permanently, that would raise India's population by 2.65%. Recent asylum seekers crossing into Canada… and international students... have raised Canada's population higher than 2.65%. More needing healthcare too (affecting waiting times etc.).
What about the IELTS spouses? Anchor babies? Fraud? False asylum claims? What about Canadian food banks & other charity services being recklessly advertised on YT in Indian languages? What about Canadian housing being scooped up en-mass as investment vehicles by/for internationals? Home rental/boarding signs stating "vegetarians only can apply". Indian nationals buying local businesses then putting Indians only in key positions (while also drastically changing work practices that include working more hours for less money). Plus BC & Ontario are outlawing the Caste System.
Then throw in the Sikh vs Hindu violence/extortions across Canada. Diasporas stirring up tribal hatreds (in Canada) … even though it all stems from their ancestral home. How can peace be found anywhere with this in play? Plus the Canadian government recently launched investigations in regards to foreign interference in Canadian elections, stemming from Asia continent. Canada also had to end flagpoling at the border.
In recent years, Canadians are having to worry about their automobile being stolen by auto theft rings. For just one example of what Canadians see regarding this new concern research; "arrests in connection with $9.24M Toronto-area auto theft ring". Research; "Gold stolen in Canada's biggest ever heist ended up in India". On YT look up "TorontoPolice News Conference Project Déjà Vu". Major scams involving foreign call centres too.
Canadians are so so so not used to all this. So many, who have embraced multi-culturalism and immigration for decades are now worried/fearful. All are praying it doesn't turn into anger. Canadians want multi-culturism to succeed and for all people (including immigrants) to be okay. Everyone I know is VERY happy with IRCC's recent changes (reductions & multifaceted investigations etc.). Including multi-generational long-term Asian Canadians MOST upset (by all of this).
Canadians are aware that some wonderful students/humans are going through hell. And know Canada is partially to blame which is awful. But Canada decides what needs to be done in Canada to prevent further pains. Do you see Canadians protesting in other countries (that is not their own) making demands for themselves? No. Do Canadians now see primarily Indians protesting in Canada making demands? Yes. Protesting because they don't have the credentials to stay in Canada. And because rules designed to protect CANADA are not meeting their desires/demands. And why isn't there crowds of African or Caribbean or Filipino etc., students protesting & waving their flags? They're in Canada too.
Did international students and their families pay into Canadian taxes all their lives like domestic students have (earning cheaper tuition fees)? No.
Did Canada force internationals to move to Canada as a STUDENT when their primary goal is work/PR? No.
Did Canada promise/guarantee a job? And PR? No & no.
Yet do they only blame Canada when they can't get work/PR??? After they came to Canada as a STUDENT?
Look up Human Rights Index 2023. Canada is ranked 13th. USA is 17th. India 109th.
Part of the process in applying for the student permit is writing what we call the Statement of purpose. Unless you have dual intent which is to stay in Canada after graduation, international students are expected to go back to their home country after studies. Still, that doesnt give them the right to demand anything from the government. Also, (sorry po) but sometimes, it is the student’s fault for not doing proper research, naniniwala sa mga pangako ng agencies and I totally agree sa mga sinabi ng ibang nainterview na naging greedy ang mga agency. They’re all about making money and giving false hopes. One thing is for sure, nothing is guaranteed and anyone who is on temporary status - international students and temporary workers alike have no right to demand to extend their stay if the contract is over. If you wish to stay and gain permanent residency, idaan sa tamang process. Protesting is definitely not it though.
why do some people always yelling for their "Rights" but it's hard for them to comply to their "Responsibilities"? and what responsibility is that? Do your homework, be diligent. Lalo na yung nagsabing Police ang kurso nya, sus mio sa simpleng pangako lamang naloko na. This issue is not a political one nor violating rights , but rather these people is just manipulating as if sila ang agrabyado or inagrabyado. Ayaw sumunod sa proceso kaya ayan gusto i short cut.
Thank you ms Ina for this video.. now I know how to decide in the future. I said to myself, In God’s time, let God do the rest our stay here in Canada.. kung ano ibigay nyanpara sa amin..
They have no right to stay in canada if they applied as international student. Ang expectation sa kanila is may sapat silang pondo para mag-aral and after school uwi na sila. Pasalamat nga sila pinapayagan pa nga silang mag work. PR is a privilege not a right. Ang hirap sa mga bumbay na yan mga arogante mga bossy gusto nila gobyerno pa susunod sa kanila. They should have done their due diligence bago nila pinasok ang pagiging IS sa canada. Marami pati sa kanila hindi naman talaga nagaaral mga nagwowork lang. Isa pang problema jan hindi man lang nag-ungdergo ng criminal background check yang mga yan. May mga balita na mga gang member sa kanila nakapasok dito. Ever wonder why biglang dami ng carnapping jan sa BC simula nung dumami din yung mga yan jan? May mga nahuli na carnapper na kalahi nila.
Nature na nila yan may pagka rude at feeling superior o magaling! Kahit saang bansa ganyan sila but not all of them. May mga maayos din naman, madami din kaming kaibigan na indian at mababait at maayos. Siguro dala ng kultura at sitwasyon sa bansa nila na may mentalidad sila na “survival of the fittest” kaya ganyan sila dala dala nila yan kahit saan sila makarating.
Just my two cents!😊
True yan...arrogant..i worked in indian company sa middle east panget ng management nila dinadaya kami sa oras ng work over ng 1 hr 8hrs dapat daily duty...mga supervisor dun mga epal kapag hndi nila ako mapasunod sa gusto nila dahil nasa tama ako sinusumbong ako sa GM tpos c GM ipapatawag ako pagagalitan...walang etiqette pati GM...kaya wala p kami 1 yr sa work nmin lumipat n kmi sa other company owned by arab...mas maganda management,benefits...salary....here in canada indian nagkalat sila...pati yun amoy akala mo nasa arab contry ka...😊
They should give priority to all old Immigrants and Canadian Citizen who pays their taxes and spent a lot of time here in Canada.
They have to regulate the entry of international students and have a more stringent selection process. I am an IS, but only 20% of my classmates come to class to study. The other 80% come to Canada to work and make money, and these are not even from professional jobs. Canadian education can be a great pathway to PR but it seems as if students are not being strategic about it and most are honestly NOT eligible to stay in Canada even with a permit.
Because we Filipinoes are resilient.
Absolutely not ! They are not Canadian citizens!
I think mali ung approach to rally as if it's a "right" to become a permanent resident. The proper way is to come prepared. If you come as a student pero gusto mo pala maging citizen one day. Kailangan simula palang alam na ano plano para makapag apply for permanent resident. Hindi ung para silang nablindside kasi di pala sila qualified after studying.
About refugees, I think ibang usapan yun. Di proper "mainggit" kasi yung refugees nawalan ng home country so usually wala sila ibang options. Good for refugees na sila ay may pathway sa Canada. Wag tayo crab na porket mahirap for us ay dapat sila rin mahirapan.
Thanks for the video. It's nice to be able discuss this within the Filipino community. Although siyempre, diverse parin ang opinions kasi iba iba parin ang pinagdadaanan ng Filipinos in Canada.
kaya po importante din na mag research tayong mabuti at wag lng basta maniwala sa mga consultants, may mga legitimate naman tlga pero marami din nagsasamanatala.
wala po tlgang rights mag demand and mga IS pero maraming ways para ma-pr dito, dapat lng tlgang i-plano ng mabuti para makuha mo ung PR. DYOR is the key. another good content Ms. Ina! KUDOS! 🙏
Hi, Ms ina sa video mabuti walang pinoy,sa akin lang dapat huwag umasa maging PR kundi gawin ang lahat para maging PR dito sa canada,samahan ng dasal,salamat po...
It's true where does the govt. getting the money to help out the refugee? It's not bad to help, but govt. should check what's the standiing of Canadian Citizen that pay their taxes?
Canada has good intentions with its immigration plan aiming to boost the economy by inviting skilled and young individuals. However, the country was not fully prepared for this influx. The immigration program lacks adequate risk management and contingency planning.
The International Student Pathway is not a guaranteed route to PR, but it is one of the possible paths. We cannot blame international students for coming here, given the current policies that allow them to work while studying and after graduation, as long as they meet the requirements. Only “genuinely motivated students” who want to upgrade their skills and become more competitive in the market would choose to study here if the policy required them to leave the country after graduation.
Canada has taken on more than it can manage. While it is heartwarming to know that the country is recognized for its humanitarian efforts, the reality is that the world is about survival. Historically, refugees have been welcomed by other countries if they are skilled or if their situation is among the most dire.
IIts been a while na Di ako nag take Ng bus and one time this week that I need to take a bus. And I was soo very surprised the bus is full and we are only two passenger different from them.Ang dami nila
It’s only the Indian Nationals that are complaining!
There's never been no such right. It's based on demand and with so many International Students nowadays, the average 30% of students that gets PR every year is now even lower. They can try the US, Australia and Europe, lots of jobs there.
previlege not right
Hello Ina, it is not a right but to be fair, if we check the government website, it is written there that after graduation, students can work and live in Canada and use that work experience to gain permanent residence. Even provinces have their own provincial nomination eligibility for international students who studied in their province. The problem is walang limit or cap previously. Ngayon na lang nagka-cap dahil dumami beyond levels na kaya ng provinces and federal government. These protesters came into Canada during the time na under the province's rule, they only need 6 months to 1 yr experience to be eligible for PR nomination. Nag-change bigla ang mga eligibility habang nandito na sila kaya sila nagpoprotest. Yes, PR after studies is not a guarantee pero sa totoo lang, Canada gains billions from international students. They can limit, but they will not stop accepting international students for Canada's economy.
hinde ho pinilit ng canada na mag aral sila sa canada po
Yes, nothing against with international student. The government is too blame. I've been here in Canada for 32 years and its my first time to having a hard time to find a job. I've been jobless now for more than 1 year then no EI at all (done). I am a Canadian citizen where am I going to get the money to pay all our bills. Every single day I am applying. Govt. should stop inviting people to come over here in Canada and they can't even give what they promise. This should be stop. I'm a tax payer invested a lot of time here. Does the government will help people like me? And I have a little money from my RPP if I used it they will take out 30% tax which is so unfair for me. Govt. has no contribution with my RPP why taking too much tax?
Canada has, for decades, been in the top 10 of safest and least racist countries on planet Earth. Plus prosperous. Now there is a new negative spin that most Canadians do NOT deserve to a high degree. People must look at both sides.
Since 2020, international students have been flocking to a educational system that many Canadians now feel was used by many of them as a loophole-to-immigration. Students utilizing schooling as a back-door (not front-door) ticket to living in Canada. Swarming a 50+ year tradition/system that was not not NOT designed to be about every international student INSISTING on receiving Permanent Residency. Plus it was not designed to be primarily about students demanding lengthy work permits (& spouse permits etc.). Canadians have clued in that Canada's post secondary education system has (in 5 years time) turned into what many are now jokingly calling EDUGRATION. An extreme not approved by everyday Canadians.
What about Ghost Consulting that Canada told India to halt? Canadians want $ greedy foreign agents to stop marketing & lying to their own people about access to PR or citizenship … or accommodation/jobs … in places like Canada being relatively easy. At best, there is a 20% chance of PR (better odds if career is in HIGH demand).
And what about all the YT videos that primarily Indian nationals have posted (for half a decade now including today) all advertising Canadian PR like they're selling a product? Promoting Canadian visas & permits & schools & jobs etc. etc.. Videos not only posted hourly but rarely in English or French. With very very rare input from Canadian-born citizens.
Plus Canada didn't have numerous PRIVATE 'diploma mills' until 40% of international students were from India. Coincidence? Mills that Canada is shutting down. AND the bulk of them are near Brampton Ontario and Surrey B.C.. Coincidence? Canada is now compelling ALL schools to report to Immigration whether a student is attending school and complying with permit requirements or not. Were Canadian public colleges & universities greedy too (while honest)? Sure. But the Canadian government stepped in and slowed them down too (like a trustworthy government should).
Are most international students truly scholars who came to Canada with enough $ to support themselves while STUDYING? Or economic migrants, who borrowed $ to buy their way closer to the head of the immigration line? To say all the students or their consultants have not been at times 'gaming' Canada's education programs to gain western PR or $ is ridiculous. Students have contributed to Canada's severe housing crisis and lack of entry jobs because 90% conspire-to-outstay a TEMPORARY permit.
Canada wants to help people, but not when it contributes to severe home unaffordability and a recession. If 36,000,000 Canadians travelled to India, since 2020, with the goal of being able to stay there permanently, that would raise India's population by 2.65%. Recent asylum seekers crossing into Canada… and international students... have raised Canada's population higher than 2.65%. More needing healthcare too (affecting waiting times etc.).
What about the IELTS spouses? Anchor babies? Fraud? False asylum claims? What about Canadian food banks & other charity services being recklessly advertised on YT in Indian languages? What about Canadian housing being scooped up en-mass as investment vehicles by/for internationals? Home rental/boarding signs stating "vegetarians only can apply". Indian nationals buying local businesses then putting Indians only in key positions (while also drastically changing work practices that include working more hours for less money). Plus BC & Ontario are outlawing the Caste System.
Then throw in the Sikh vs Hindu violence/extortions across Canada. Diasporas stirring up tribal hatreds (in Canada) … even though it all stems from their ancestral home. How can peace be found anywhere with this in play? Plus the Canadian government recently launched investigations in regards to foreign interference in Canadian elections, stemming from Asia continent. Canada also had to end flagpoling at the border.
In recent years, Canadians are having to worry about their automobile being stolen by auto theft rings. For just one example of what Canadians see regarding this new concern research; "arrests in connection with $9.24M Toronto-area auto theft ring". Research; "Gold stolen in Canada's biggest ever heist ended up in India". On YT look up "TorontoPolice News Conference Project Déjà Vu". Major scams involving foreign call centres too.
Canadians are so so so not used to all this. So many, who have embraced multi-culturalism and immigration for decades are now worried/fearful. All are praying it doesn't turn into anger. Canadians want multi-culturism to succeed and for all people (including immigrants) to be okay. Everyone I know is VERY happy with IRCC's recent changes (reductions & multifaceted investigations etc.). Including multi-generational long-term Asian Canadians MOST upset (by all of this).
Canadians are aware that some wonderful students/humans are going through hell. And know Canada is partially to blame which is awful. But Canada decides what needs to be done in Canada to prevent further pains. Do you see Canadians protesting in other countries (that is not their own) making demands for themselves? No. Do Canadians now see primarily Indians protesting in Canada making demands? Yes. Protesting because they don't have the credentials to stay in Canada. And because rules designed to protect CANADA are not meeting their desires/demands. And why isn't there crowds of African or Caribbean or Filipino etc., students protesting & waving their flags? They're in Canada too.
Did international students and their families pay into Canadian taxes all their lives like domestic students have (earning cheaper tuition fees)? No.
Did Canada force internationals to move to Canada as a STUDENT when their primary goal is work/PR? No.
Did Canada promise/guarantee a job? And PR? No & no.
Yet do they only blame Canada when they can't get work/PR??? After they came to Canada as a STUDENT?
Look up Human Rights Index 2023. Canada is ranked 13th. USA is 17th. India 109th.
the only ones who have the right to stay are the ones who have a 'dual intent' study permit applications..they are the ones who visa officers see as assets of canada..
None one of them has the ‘right’ to stay here. It’s a privilege they’re here, while on a study permit. If a Canadian goes to the US as a student, he doesn’t have the right to stay in the US beyond what’s allowed as a Canadian.
Of course, they don’t have the right.
They applied under student visa - As a student.
And I don’t agree with it also.
Pero mas katanggap-tanggap pakinggan yung mga ganito, kapag nanggagaling mismo sa ‘totoong’ citizen. Yung hindi immigrant din. Yung hindi naging citizen because of PR.
ang dami kasing na ikot ng mga consultant kasi pagdating daw dito mkahanap ng trabaho😂lubog na sa utang sa pinas, lubog din sa utang dito kasi yung POF pinoprovide ng agency pero pagdating dito cla tlaga yung nahihirapan.
Sinabhan ko lahat ng staff ko na Int. students kuha sila ng Healthcare at matutu ng French pra sure shot ang PR.
Very true. I migrated to Canada directly from the Philippines via the French stream…
When you applied for your VISA did you tell the Canadian government that you wanted to stay permanently in Canada?
No!
Oh.. kaya pala nawala kana sa tv dahil at anjan kana sa canada
Hindi ko tinapos panoorin, napagod alo😂
It’s only the Indian Nationals that are complaining!