Journalist's Trip to Tibet Shows China's Control
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 окт 2024
- “It's inexorably changing Tibetan culture and could potentially be wiping it away.”
For China, showcasing Tibetans singing the Communist Party’s praises helps affirm its legitimacy to rule the region, something that’s weighed on Beijing’s ties with the West since a failed uprising in 1959 forced the Dalai Lama to flee and set up a government-in-exile in northern Indian.
Tibet is crucial to Beijing for strategic purposes. Its mountainous terrain abuts a 4,000-kilometer (2,500-mile) border with countries including India, Nepal and Myanmar, forming a natural security barrier. Beijing has recently reinforced troops stationed in Tibet as it prepares for a long winter in its high-altitude standoff with India.It’s become more important recently as politicians in the U.S., Europe and India accuse China of using forced labor, detentions and re-education campaigns to assimilate ethnic minorities in its borderlands.
For Xi, the key to snuffing out calls for independence in Tibet and strengthening Communist Party rule is delivering economic growth in one of China’s poorest regions. Since 2016, China has spent more than $11 billion on poverty alleviation efforts in Tibet.
Subscribe to our RUclips channel: bit.ly/2TwO8Gm
QUICKTAKE ON SOCIAL:
Follow QuickTake on Twitter: quicktake
Like QuickTake on Facebook: quicktake
Follow QuickTake on Instagram: quicktake
Subscribe to our newsletter: bit.ly/2FJ0oQZ
Email us at quicktakenews@gmail.com
QuickTake by Bloomberg is a global news network delivering up-to-the-minute analysis on the biggest news, trends and ideas for a new generation of leaders.
Why Tibetans in tibet are put in jail for having dalai lama's photo....
Why 150 plus tibetans have self immolated....
ask 14th dalailama
@@小明-r4h Ask your god CCP.
apparently that’s okay according to some comments because the government helps poor people 🤡 kek
I guess there are also cults in US or other places which asked their believers to suicide. Like people' s temple, heaven's gate. The lama's suicide were just disguised to relate to politics by some media and politicians on purpose.
Good question Robert
It is wrong to report or say the Chinese government reasserted its control of Tibet in 1950s. The truth is Tibet was invaded and occupied by Communist China in 1959, which lead to the flight of the Tibetan leader, His Holiness the Dalai Lama, to seek political asylum in India. In 1989, the Dalai Lama was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize for leading the non-violent Tibetan struggle for freedom. The Chinese authorities continue to control Tibet with an iron grip with thousands suffering in prisons. The UNO is a powerless body under control of rogue Chinese and Russian regimes. But truth will prevail.
Well this is some great BS😂😂 also the Nobel Peace Prize means absolutely nothing
@@metalvideos1961Yeah bro absolute Bullshit he's talking.If he says that Tibet should be independent country then Hawaii should be independent country too.
@@spacegamer_aviation4910 *Are you out of your mind? Are you comparing Chinese oppression over Tibet with American annexation of Hawaii? Both are entirely different scenarios. Atleast USA is a democracy and Hawaii has their own people representing them in Senate, and what Tibet has! Nothing! China is a dictatorship and has no integral development in these areas. Huge buildings or roads can not define the way of life of the common oppressed Tibetans. They have their own religion (CPC is anti-religious), They have their own culture (which is proven to be in danger after 1950s), own lifestyle (CPC is trying to impose the mainstream communist features). Remember the 17 Points Agreement and how China disrupted the peace in disguise of development repeatedly? When will the Tibetans get the right to choose thier representatives in the form of parliamentary government with chosen President and Prime Minister just like the Hawaiians do? Now I hope you understand the difference between Tibet and Hawaii. And stop comparing majorly a small county of 23,000 sqkm to a gigantic and diverse cultural and ethnic land of 1,222,000 sqkm.* *FREE TIBET*
@@MD_ISSACI don't know if Hawaii should be independent,But I know a country that uses lethal weapons against civilians, children and schools.In order to support him, the United States voted against Palestine's entry into the United Nations, which made more children and civilians live in fear.
Moreover, I have been to China. I don't know that the so-called freedom of speech in the United States is to let American civilians see the carefully controlled remarks of the US government and be manipulated by the US government，. Then your so-called democracy is to let some people wander around, see who performs well and who has high sympathy like a draft, and then let the fooled American citizens vote for a drama master.Don't you think this Trump attack is a vivid portrayal?When the film selection is backward, I don't know if it is a self-directed attackThen stand up and let the royal photographer take a photo and send a tweet. The voters chose him inexplicably. Your democracy is really funny.😅
Dollar lama was cia agent
Very biased,even the thumbnail designed in a way to deceive
If by “biased” you mean any opinion that Communist Chinese Imperialism in Tibet is bad, I suppose a lot of videos on RUclips share that bias.
China invaded Tibet in the 1950s. Tibet was never Chinese. Tibetans have different language, culture and DNA from the Chinese.
Is it true that their genetic makeup is a conglomeration of Chinese & Nepali?
So you're saying that the diversity of Indian subcontinent doesn't make sense for that place to be united as Indian Republic????
different dna?
@@kirkentachas9643 were talking abt China not India. Stay on topic
So also Canada USA n Australia. All these were not white.
" This is not what you expect Tibet to look like"? What? You want them to live like they did over hundreds of years ago? Deny them a way of life that includes modern utlilities? Some bastion of human rights you are!
It was already like that, until china came in and shot at protesters, there are monks dead in prison for protesting. But other than that china very good number 1 Tibet is china yes.
ruclips.net/video/wi8U-asY1QI/видео.html direct interviews from Tibetans
Free Tibet! Fuck China!
This video is not showing China's control over Tibet instead it shows China's control on journalism
#freejulianassange lol the USA hypocrisy on freedom of press.
What
Exactly
😂😂😂 你应该问问西方什么叫新闻控制
you control jounalism when you have many things to hide
Should Tibetans stay as poor as they were and don’t let them enjoy the modern civilization?
Its not about poor and modern.its all about peace and happiness.most important democracy.they destroyed our monastery and lot worst.we always follow our heart and chinese use their mind to dominate.soon that day will come when we will go back to our motherland.
@@wangyalfamily9519 democracy？you mean slavery in the old tibet?
@@wangyalfamily9519 It's always about life, Iraq/Afganistan are you happen with the USA freedom bombs, one thing must be clear, we never allow the fool decide what we should go even they are the majority, it's never about the so-called democracy, it's about the right decision, uneducated one should never share the same vote.
Honestly this video is relatively subjective compared to many others. I think many people can infer your point from what he said too
@@wangyalfamily9519 sounds like Tibet has a democracy before 1950.
Forced to move to a better house？BAD CCP😵
Tibet was never keen to developing especially forced developments. We never asked for that. Thanks.
@@Tsedoop Well then enjoy the squalor of pre-industrial life then. Better yet, why are you even on the internet? Don't you know it takes development to have internet? Get off right now 🤣🤣🤣
@@Tsedoop selfish rubbish
@@Tsedoop Lol, live in India forever China does allow you go back to Tibet.
@@ZZZ2573 exactly. The so-called tibetans outside tibet are the only ones that should enjoy modernity... These people are delusional 😂😂😂😂
Tibet is not the part of China
The history of domination of Tibet was brutal and violent . Let's not forget that to those who keep saying Chiina making Tibet better.
Learn about the history of the Dalai Lama’s abuse of Tibet
please elaborate on the history?
@@Lucas-vr1qr Yes Comrade! Tell us some Communist fairy tales. LOL!!
@@AaronGarton666 In ancient Tibet, human skins were used as drum skins and making thangkas. Leg bones make flutes. Your body fits perfectly.
as a black man, I can see that China treats Tibetans Better than the US has treated Blacks for the last 250 years
Treating your people good is buying their loyalty. You are genius man. I hope government can keep buying our loyalty. I guess your government dont need loyalty from your people and thats why so far I dont see any other countries change their people lives so much in few decades.
In return Greedy Chinese extracting the mineral resources worth of 200 billions.
@@lordvenom4419and using those same minerals to build homes and infrastructure for tibetan people to prosper and be well fed
@@lordvenom4419if you use your brain a bit you will remember that tibet is part of china so they are extracting their natural resources.. Is like saying that the USA is robbing the resources of Alaska 😂😂😂😂7
Maybe China is helping, however Tibet should still be allowed to practice there spiritually... live long Tibet !
China allows them to practice anything, it is the CCP that changed some spiritual beliefs in Tibetan Buddhism, such as no discrimination towards other religions, Tibet teaches generations to stay away from other religions and close of the region from other religions. Tibetan Buddhism uses humans as religious tools and sacrifices during the Dalai Lama rule, scripts made out of human skin, inks made out of fresh human blood, drum sticks from human bones, buddhist statues with actual human skulls. It is CCP that changed these inhumane acts to a better method of offering. Can you imagine out of 95% of serfs in Tibet, how many were used to make holy scriptures over centuries? The Tibetans that hated Bhutan and conducted 3 invasions, assisted China in killing the Indian King. Tibet is just like past Mongolia, equally inhumane, bloodlusted.
Tibet belongs to Tibetan
Just to notice,
strategies like Poverty alleviation and Village relocation is used all over the nations poorest villages, not only in tibet. for those people who have no job opportunities in the deep mountains. they have free house, relocated somewhere near bigger cities, sure you can call it concentrations or what ever you want.
@आदि राजपूत Very funny, that you said about my lies and intentions, Tibet or Xizhang is actually not my business. The only intentions i have is, i hope when i visit the destination, it will remain the beatiness and keep the culture. I like to visit this place, but it is a bit hard for me as a foreigner, I am actually a EU citizen. tooooo many restrictions for foreigners, i hope one day this place will become a non-conflict zone. which make foreigners welcome as well. I do not care about who control this place.
आदि राजपूत u don’t have to. We Tibetans know that Tibetan people are the real host of Tibet now. No Longer controlled by some Lamas.
@आदि राजपूत look who is brainwashed by the western propaganda HAHAHAHA
@Addy Raj u are absolutely right. It’s a propaganda and those who replied to u making China doing good things in Tibet are all paid 50 cent army. 50 cent armies are those who have dozens of fake Id’s just to comment good things about China and they r getting paid.. such a low life way of earning. Spreading lies is their only job.
And so is the extermination of the local religion. Leave them be.
This guy thinks Tibet is poor, so he looks for it. An improved way of living somehow is a bad thing. You don't live a decrepit life style, why should the Tibetan? Yes, images of Xi , Deng and Mao are postered in Tibet. Incase you missed it, they are postered EVERYWHERE in China.
tibet is not china
@@thewkovacs316 Absolutely true！ Tibet is not China。 Tibet is only a small part of China。
Tibetan people are being oppressed by the Chinese Government. They are trying to eradicate their culture and lifestyle. They are all pretending to be happy but they aren’t. Tibet is Tibet not China.
@@okboomer8974 Looks like the West is way more successful brainwashing you. Your brain is now as white as a sheet of toilet paper.
@@yongebltechsupport6815 it's nothing to do with western ideology.. Bias is Bias you have to think freely.
I wish India was strong enough to "actually" liberate the Tibetans.
India already provided refuge to the Tibetans when they were fleeing from CCP attack, including the Dalai Lama.
Tibetans can trust India for sure.
@@Lucas-vr1qr Communist China could not stop 80+ year old Nancy Pelosi. The Chinese government knows that it is precarious. It would not want to be involved in a war with anyone.
@@AaronGarton666 yeah apparently India and USA is somehow on the same level lol
The ones who escaped were the theocratic class and slave owners who ruled Tibet back then. If you support them, you are supporting slavery. You are an anti human Nazi
Not a safe option.
Part of why China invaded and took over Tibet, is that the headwaters of many of the most important rivers in Asia are located in Tibet.
If India & China ever went to war,
China could shut off the water flowing into most of the biggest rivers in India.
With just a few thousand construction workers and a few weeks of construction,
& China could shut off the Indus river.
That’d kill more people in 3 months than dropping a nuclear bomb
Its poor country
Tibet is free county,Tibet is not part of china.
It's sad that Tibet is not free. I really hope the country of Taiwan can stand up to China so they don't befall the same fate.
China will be one once more
@@riotriguez5854Chinese lnvaded and stole Tibetan land, this is disgusting by the leaders of china
@@riotriguez5854tibet NEVER belonged to china, it was once part of the Mongolian empire, this is not chinese
@@brockcharz2104 Zimbakestan belongs to china
@@riotriguez5854 nothing belongs to you lol, Hong Kong belonged to the British and they will easily take it back if you not careful
The report sold his soul to evil, shame on you liar. From the video all unblinded person can see the great life of Tibetan.
the great life is the lying narrative of China and Xi. I wonder if you would survive by yourself if Xi did not feed you food and information every day?
@@jtomyhope575 Trump is even worst!
@@jagdpanther2224 he's irrelevant because he's not president now. Xi is still president. Next?
@@jagdpanther2224 Trump is not in charge anymore. That's the past. Focus on Biden
Liar! When will Chinese stop lying about Tibet? When they beg for mercy at the end of their life.
I visited Lhasa 5 years ago, the locals seem genuinely happy and doesn't looked liked oppressed at all
Tibet with China is better than Tibet without China. Tibet is lack of people, with such area only 3 millions that inhabit Tibet, most of technology in Tibet are from China, at the same time China also needs Tibetan freshwater which is called as the third pole. From the culture Chinese culture was influenced by Tibetan Buddhism and has similarity since they have the same ancestor, people who want seperate Tibet from China are US and other Western politicians who don't understand history and want to take China's geopolitical adventage and mutualism with Tibet by sponsoring people like Dalai Lama
@@__Man__ Please do some actual research before making assumptions
@@__Man__ you seem completely delusional. Tibet never wanted China to forcefully invade and take that land for their own selfish purposes. World wars long gone but countries like China still at it. They need to get what they’re doing with neighbouring countries. I hope china gets the karma they deserve 🤧
@@consistency991 no one is delusional. Instead, it is you and your alliances who are delusional. China needs Tibet for water, Tibet needs China for sea transport
@@honeybunny4841 before china came in, most of the people in tibet were kinda slaves. Dalai lama at the age of 14 has 6000 slaves. Idk what u are talking about?
Fake news & blunt propaganda
So.. they're urbanizing at a faster rate than people would've liked to see in the West, where urbanization is near saturation, and people think of rural living as desirable... But it isn't, not really, and certainly not for the people still living in the rural areas in the "old ways". There's a reason why people wanted to move to the cities in the first place. While it's commendable that people want to preserve a rustic lifestyle that's rapidly disappearing, it's also incredibly patronizing.
Yeah on that note most people in Tibet used to be nomads and farmers. They Chinese government sized all of the land so living as a farmer and nomad was very hard cause you have no land 💀. And also first time in Tibetan history there was faminine and after the Chinese invaded the number of wildlife life spices decreased. They start mining everywhere. Tibet is a very rich country full on minerals but we Tibetan's we don't like to destroy our environment, we only eat yak and lamp meat as it is forbidden to kill wild animals.
@@godiswatching7201
While I absolutely denounce the violence that has occurred since 1949!
But to play “devils advocate”. . .
When you read what people in Tibet wrote in the 19th & early 20th centuries, calling Tibetans serfs “farmers” is extremely generous.
It should absolutely be ethnically Tibetan people who should be in charge of Tibet!
The Chinese had no right to invade and occupy the country of Tibet!
But the feudal style of government
& the class system that existed was extremely harsh for anyone who wasn’t a monastic or from a noble family.
I infinitely would prefer to see the Tibetans reform their laws on;
land ownership, corvée labor, slavery, and citizens rights!!
I’m not praising the Chinese for modernizing Tibet by force and violence!
But let’s also not pretend like Tibet was a land of freedom & a paradise free from oppression
Before the Chinese government, Tibet was literally a feudal theocracy with a cast system and millions of slaves.
@rainbow so, explain why dalai Nama was nominated by Ancient Chinese government of Tibet is an independent country? Your country leader is nominated by China? Let US free your country first like what happened in Afghanistan
@rainbow maybe you can read? Wanna check out Wikipedia?
Free Tibet 🙏🏼😔
The scenery is beautiful! I have to admit that it is gorgeous
Free Tibet ❤
Long live his holiness the Dalai Lama🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼free Tibet . Tibet is belonging to Tibetan.
*Free Tibet, Mongolia and East Turkestan*
This guy is being too sarcastic that it is almost impossible to ignore the irony of his words.
He looks a liar.
ruclips.net/video/4sko0oEKoHk/видео.html
If the government arranged, then it will show only what China wants the world to see.
The free consent of Tibetans is important. Tibetan culture is not Chinese.
Point: Tibet is a Chinese colony in 21 century. Tibet is today like India was during British rule. Tibetans must fight for their freedom against foreigners and chase out Chinese from their territory.
I understand you are living in a society where people think freedom of speech is more important than having food to eat, but before acting like the police of the world, I would like you to how Americans are doing the same things by stealing Texas away from Mexico. Why don't you go and speak up to the Chinese government in china and see what's going to happen instead of asking the tibetans to risk their lives in order to have the freedom you enjoy such as having 10000 genders and a divided country.
@@justinanderson5231 funny mud pee
Tibet india comparison is absurd. They are actually building something positive for the population economically speaking. Of course its not the ideal situation and tibetans should be allowed to choose. The west still had colonies in 1950 and did so until the 80s and they were not treated any better. So sure china bad if it makes you feel good about yourself and your culture. People say they dont like being propagandized but it depends on the propaganda i guess.
You have killed hundreds of thousands of people because of Xinguan pneumonia, and you are still worrying about China's Tibet. Tibetans have been Chinese since ancient times, and Tibetan culture is Chinese culture. There is no dispute about this. You don't need to care about the freedom of Tibetans. Before 1049, those serfs were skinned into skin drums, and their heads were sacrificed. At that time, Tibet was managed by religion, People are slaughtered and oppressed. Do you want them to return to that life again?
Wasn't Tibet "conquered" in 20th century? Never mind, even if it was. 19th century, you wouldn't also care 😘
Um... To clarify, the people's republic of China wasn't founded until 1949. The last regime before them (the one that lost the civil war and retreated to Taiwan) set their capital in South China. The one before that was the Qing Dynasty based in Beijing. This guy claiming "Beijing's control over Tibet has been fraught for the last couple of centuries" are very suspiciously ignorant.
Also, it's not surprising that these guys would complain about Tibetan people upgrading their agriculture with technologies. SMFH.
Don't try to argue with Western media with facts. Let them sleep in bias and double standard. One day they will realize how outdated they are and by then their power would be long gone, just like Qing dynasty.
@俊介しゅんすけ 葵 いつき don't be sorry. It's not your fault that you're ignorant.
Really????what u know about Tibet..1959 Chiness occupy Tibet ...n Tibetans culture ,relagion n history is totally different than china
Will u accept China is part of Japan as they occupied mostly china .
@@banstangngawang4864Are the native tribes in the US part of the US?
If Qing China not backed Tibet and expell Nepali Gorkha from Tibet , Tibet will be remain under Nepal territory
Thank you China for lifting Tibetans out of Poverty.
China can you leave Tibet now.
Japanese lifted Chinese out of poverty but Chinese brand them as aggressor.
@@gyadre No. Japanese killed Chinese in their millions during the Second World War. That was before the US neutralized Japanese with Hiroshima and Nagasaki nuclear bombs.
@@ksgrmdsdl2383 So too Chinese killed Tibetans. Every invasion and occupation involves killing and Chinese occupation is no different
@Tanui Tanui And Thankyou China for butchering and mudering 1.5 million Tibetan people
My fellow Tibetan in Tibet stay strong and pray to God which never leaves us alone. Hope one day we will meet again in the fatherland.
To your disappointment, Your fellow Tibetans have been living a prosperous and virus-free life for long in Tibet. You're the one who really need to stay strong to survive the devastating second wave of the pandemic in India and hopefully have the chance to see you fellows live. May God be with you🙏
@@wcyandy yes they are may be literally physically free from virus-free in tibet but tibetans who are seperated from their homeland are more virus-free mentally accept their losen country.
@@wongmok9430 They died, but they were free?
Praying = genius Tibetan strategy! Victory assured!
@@wcyandy why can't I visit Tibet then?
I don´t really understand the criticism here. Of course Tibet is going to change is the cost of modernization this happens everywhere you eliminate extreme poverty.
But what about the Cultural genocide and murder of 1 mililion+ Tibetans??
hold on a minute, so the people are getting upskilled and hired for better paying jobs, and provided with modern amenities, but your worry is that they might become loyal to the government? can you tell me why they shouldn't support a government that changed their lives for the better?
It's propaganda, you only get to see the things they want you to see and in a way that portrays ccp as saviors. Not quite the same reality for those Tibetans who want to preserve their beautiful culture. I have been to Tibet twice, I feel sad when I see what's happening now.
@@happygold5 If you start by calling someone you don't even know sick and evil that means you are just trolling and you don't want to have a normal conversation. Bye troll
@@happygold5 Tibetans are religious and Chinese is anti-religion. Chinese wants to sinitized everything and tibetans wants to retain their language and uphold in tibet. They want the autonomity not just for name sake like how it is right now but true autonomity. Tibetans are less than 1% of China's population, their population and ethnic dominance will be easily over run by the han Chinese.
@@happygold5 I am one of those ethnic minorities lol. Han Chinese are the majority and they reproduce so fast. They get all the jobs and education and high post in our land, they don't use our people's language but instead our people have to use the language of the Hans instead.
@@christianevanherck6023 So what have you seen? You have seen that Tibet is more modern, and it is different from the backward Tibet you imagined, isn't it? Westerners!
The only thing that could make western media happy is an independent Tibet without a modern life for nobody, and everyone in Tibet "enjoy" a lifestyle exactly the same as at least 100 years ago. The funny thing is China has few connection with western world before 1840. It's UK and other western countries that brought their culture, science and lifestyle to China. For example, all the math, science, and art textbooks in China are basically Chinese versions translated from the West. The Chinese education system is westernized which is totally different from some 150 years ago. As well, Chinese clothing is so different from 150 years ago. But I personally appreciate this change and we never call it "cultural genocide".
Then why are they destructing tibetan monastaries and wiping tibetan language tot be taught to tibetans in school?
ignore his words, what can you see on the screen? they are living well.
I saw cultural genocide.
I'm sure you'd just love for us all to believe a government organized tour.
@@Aertheris ruclips.net/video/kJ90asUCVko/видео.html
@@khant4205If you watched the video thoroughly, you will noticed that more than 90% of the people in the video are Chinese tourists. Government tours give no effort in their set ups.
Yes only on TV. Otherwise why the CCP people are around n doing translator to the journalists people. Makes no senses.
Hello how about native Americans and aborigines of Australia? Colonialism of the last few centuries? Please compare the scenes of downtown San Francisco with this lol.
Cry more
whataboutism.
Sorry Comrade, Communist imperialism cannot be compared to anything else. The repression and murder of Tibetans as part of Chinese policy is extraordinary and will only end when China gets out of Tibet.
The whole video..I kept laughing...bcoz of the control of govt the journalist kept praising about china...🤣🤣
For firsthand insight into CCP Socialism/Communism, & Tibet, from someone who lived under it for 13 years in China, 11 years in Nanjing & 2 years in 24/7 military martial law occupied Tibet, and the only American ever to have dined with China President/Communist Party General Secretary Xi Jinping in Tibet, please see my now disclosed story with photos, many of which I took at significant personal risk, with some subject matter not available anywhere else in the Free World, at:
twoyearsintibet.com
--- Tibetan monks/lamas glaring directly at a present Xi Jinping
--- the 60th Anniversary of the Peaceful Liberation of Tibet parade samples
--- Tibetans openly showing disgust/shame at sharing a photo with portraits of their Communist ‘liberators’
--- surveillance camera monitor
--- arbitrary police searches of Tibetans
--- police and People’s Liberation Army (PLA) arm People’s Armed Police Force (PAPF) paramilitary soldiers
--- PLA tanks on the Tibetan plateau & armored police and “SWAT” vehicles in Barkor Sq in front of the Jokhang in Lhasa
--- the Tibet Autonomous Region (TAR) Communist Party leadership
--- Cultural Revolution desecration, etc.
Showing a true face of Communist ‘liberation’, twoyearsintibet.com is an important testament, especially in today’s America.
Thank you.
Thank you
"... which is a very good salary. One thing though, is this is not what you expect Tibet to look like." It really makes me laugh. Thank you Bloomberg.
How ironic. America can also gain loyalty with bombs.
Is this journalist mad? Every thing he does is to explain the positives in a negative way? How dare you!
So that's happens than journalist doesn't have freedom to speech like normal journalist.
Truth is bitter and sometimes ugly so cannot cover or bury it.
We have this word in Chinese “杠精”, it sums up everything
We have this Tibetan phrase "རྒྱ་མི་སྐྱག་པ་ཟ་མཁན་ལྐུག་པ།", it pretty much sums up Chinese. :)
Aertheris exiles bull shit
O2 supply changes to CO2 if you criticize Xi or CCP.
wowowwiwow, why RUclips and Bloomberg delete my comment about the Crisis happen in US Lakota Indian reservation and how democrat try to using modern colonization method to further control natives? Bloomberg What are you afraid about?
You deleted those comments yourself and you want to make it seem like it was RUclips doing the censorship. You want to pass on a false narrative that China is not the only country where censorship can happen. Your previous comments referenced certain misdeeds by the U.S. government. My reply to that was yes, we are not perfect, but at least we get to talk about it. We can protest and make balloon animals out of the likeness of our president. At least we make an effort to stand up for people who are underrepresented (despite that effort is sometimes misplaced). At least we our system can get terrible leaders out of office (Trump is gone now). If you tried to do any of that in China, you'd end up in a concentration camp (or "reeducation camp"). Where are the people standing up for the Uyghurs in China?
To provide context on why America is unique (not great) just unique: ruclips.net/video/Ggz_gd--UO0/видео.html&ab_channel=AmericanRhetoric.com
@@peterfamous8794 No, RUclips delete my comment for sure!
@@peterfamous8794 All the comments disappeared at the moment I sent it out. Doesn't this explain the problem? And I leave a message under the comments of other people, it is impossible for me to delete all the comments by myself unless I am the RUclips officer. If you are familiar with RUclips’s comment mechanism, you should be very clear that it is impossible for me to delete host comments.
@@ymptxwub6188 perhaps youtube will find you and send you to a “reeducation” camp.
The reporter is a shady little man
I wish religious conservative locales in India, Hindu or Muslim or what not, had this kind of control on them.
It's not called "buying loyalty" when u do good works for the people vs rant and rave over culture and folks appreciate what u do.
Everytime I see a video on China , someone will start talking about India, 2 different countries different opinions different lifestyle. How hard it is to understand
Tibetans have no choice...it either they agree or they lose their kidneys
As Tibetan I can say this … in terms of material world ; China did indeed bring lots of beneficial Amenities and improved lots of living standard but at the same our identity is becoming more and more Chinese , our language and script are kinda disappearing (government help ). Tibet will no longer exist if it continues as way is now
Society is progressing, from primitive farming culture to modern culture, that is why everyone is pursuing material life, otherwise no developed countries, If let you pass serf society again, you feel is good, why do you still need Internet, Internet is a mark of progress, we hope to enjoy the best, we need to develop, move forward, not return to poverty. There is you are Chinese, followed by ethnic, if a family has several ethnic groups, do you think he is not your family?···
@@autumn5905 We are not talking about primitive farming ,.Tibetan language and script is fully developed to flourish in this modern world. and also just because your economy is better then other, doesn't give you right to absorb other country , same reason Japan was wrong ,when they were killing Chinese in 1940 back then Chinese were primitive. get it ???
@@55jigme This is completely different from China and Japan. You need to study history and geography. Tibet was a part of China when it was very early . The earliest recorded history is in the Tang Dynasty. In addition, if you think that China is not good, you can emigrate. Individuals cannot represent the majority. India will welcome you. Because you like primitive society. You like living in a dirty slum all your life.
Tibet before 1950, human skins were used as drum skins and making thangkas. Leg bones make flutes. Your body fits perfectly.
@@autumn5905Tibetan culture is far older than any chinese dynasty ldlot 😂 tibet was part of the mongolian empire not chinese,
And also by your logic if another country is more advanced than china it has the right to lnvade and steal chlnese land?? Answer this?
Western journalists: indigenous people must live traditionally - the way I expect!
Raising their standard of living...liberals would be begging for that in the states.
I doubt liberals would like cultural genocide. Maybe you should ask them first.
I totally agree, i think that the Chinese government did a great job!
Then sold your country to your neighbour by developing your country
I think his comments sometimes quite stupid...eg Tibetan culture under threat , show he know nothing.
reporter "Tibetan culture under threat"
also reporter "they no understand chinese, they only speak tibetan, we can't know if they are oppress because we can't speak tibetan"
me: "there is something call a school, why don't you learn tibetan instead of being a donkey?"
the translator from the govt mouth piece translated to the media. its great
Next: Journalist's Trip to New York Shows USA's Control
I wish my government would try to buy my loyalty too.
the communist dictator NEED to do these things to buy loyalty, otherwise unrest won't let them rule. in your country(which ig is a democracy) you when govt does not do good things, loyalty disappears and govt changes in the next elections
so this reporter only worry about those Tibetans are having a better life?
He tells you all the people we spoke to were under the direct supervision of the government, but they said they wanted to move and really like it. Why even act like that could be the truth when you just said it was highly censored, i.e. government propaganda/public relations?
The west’s Schrödinger’s China.
Americans flag is raised in Hawaii And Guam and America Samoa please save those people From colonialism
The idea that Tibetans need to live in the Stone Age to preserve their culture is ridiculous
Yes, people here can use internet but Tibetans should not cuz it is cultural genocide.
@rainbow China is committing genocide on their black and Asian population
Free Hawaii! Free Texas, Free California Free USA!
Tibet is not part of china
What's the point of talking to someone the government arranged? But I have to admit, even that is better than some BBC BS fishy as fk
enjoy your CCTV then.
Free Tibet ❤❤❤
My father told me respect is earned never bought...
Does your father told you that poor people got exactly the same amount of respect just like the rich people got in a real human society? Tell me where is your "respect" coming from if you couldn't have enough food, never got educated, can't find a job to earn a living, can't access to a decent health care system?
@@milkwolfcheng359 Happiness is what matters. That's why people of this generation resort to money which is only a temporary happiness. Let us live happily in our own way. We don't need China.
@TibetanAlpha With all my respect, obviously from the words you're using (bark, dog, etc.), I don't think you're "developed" like the rest of the human beings... btw, mutual respect is a key value of the western society
who are u?
compare tibetans living in India,Kashmir and tibetans in China,who live a better living standards? Look the city of Changdu not say Lhasa,much better even than big city in South Asia.
#freetibet
They already enjoying the freedom from serfdom
@@kirkentachas9643 Exactly, they already have freedom. And please stop with saying Free Tibet, because the western world is so hypocrite. Why shouldn't Palestina have freedom then?. They lost their country too. It's called conquering. The winner takes it all period.
@@nk6772 I don't know what kind of intelligence those who saying Free Tibet have HAHAHAHA
@@nk6772 so you do believe china invaded Tibet
Maybe bloomer and the USA have bought the reporter's loyalty. Is that wrong if government make citizens live better?
Yes it’s not wrong if the government makes cities live better. If that’s the real thing doing then why it’s so strict to get in even the translator are government people. Government people are all around you. That’s clearly shows that they are hiding behind n only show good thing on camera. Even the Tibetan people want to tell real story to the reporter they can’t say it. Coz they know every where is CCP people. No Freedom. Just show off that they are living good life.
@@tenzinpassang5482 India Tibetan, stop the wet dream. China would not allow you go to Tibet. Stay poor in India and build your country in India. Good luck
@@celine7511 well, thank you. Even though we live in India as refugee. but Indian people never treat us bad as your government treating to your own people. i felt bad n sad to saw your own people are so suffering in your own country which you are so proud for your CCP. You have no guts to raise your voice for unfair. coz who ever did they put in silence. nothing much to say even though you know it well still. please be positive. can see your comment how your thoughts are. Have a good day.
Who here after the "suck my tongue"
The CCP imagines that material comfort is all there is to the human condition.
The leaders and Peoples Liberation Army freed the tibetan from the dictatorship of ruthless dalai lama who skinned them alive while they worked on fields of aristocrats as serfs!
@rainbow Yes
OH so killing more than a million of buddhist destroying monasteries beating innocent monks is considered development in china wow
and tibetans were happy even if china didnt help them mordenise they were happy with their inner happiness they were not materialistic like u
Chinese bot howuch did you Supreme leader pay you
They are very successful. A great country!
我是在西藏的一个懂藏语的汉族，我骄傲我自豪哈哈哈，中国藏区占据了中国面积的四分之一弱，大体上分成安多，康巴，卫藏三部分，我说的藏语是拉萨音，属于卫藏部分。海外藏人的藏语都是一种融合各种藏语的类似于卫藏的新口音藏语。在国内那种口音是没有的，有趣的是一听就听出来是印度藏人的口音。好像我们一听就能听出来是台湾人一样。我从来没有后悔来西藏，一个占中国四分之一弱的地方，命中注定我就一定要懂藏语吧哈哈。
All big countries do the samething. We can only talk about it. Example is America and Puerto Rico, Hawaii and soon Cuba and All USA territories. Having a nation always means the control over a certain area gradually. China doesnt even have as many military bases as most nations around the world. I'm not sticking up for China.
Everyone can go to Tibet,and get the answer.
😂😂😂😂😂
People with answers are in China prison lol or people who get real answer will be jailed
No no Tibet was never part of china. Tibet is no different from the Chinese it’s totally different. China reasserted authority no. China saw the opportunity to keep India at bay by occupying Tibet that is the only reason they are making these settlement to know the where about of the Tibetan people to keep them in control. The rich nomadic traditions of Tibet is now a mere sadness cos of the obligation and authoritarianism
From 1950-1976. Tibet had been destroyed by Mao for sure. But after 1980, Tibetan's life has been well improved. If Tibet had not been part of China since 1950, it will be as messed as India today.
Don't say anything before you saw this and it's just a small part, "China, Tibet, and the Strategic Power of Water: Pollution and Global Warming Threaten Asia's Most Important Freshwater Source" I have a tibetan friend who didn't see her mother for 18yrs and logically we can know that they are many more like her.
Again one thing you don't know about India, it's does look messes from outside but it's not what you wrote, they are optimistic in using things. I love them. There are properly using earth resources. More using new and clean things is a bad sign of making more garbages. I wish these sound true to you.
India does look messes from outside but it's not what you wrote. They are optimistic, they will use things till the last, it's not about misery. More using new and clean things is a bad sign of making more garbages. Again one thing, tibetans are still suffering, one of my tibetan friend, she didn't see her mother for 18yrs. May be some tibetan youngsters are chewing chinese new chewing gum in tibet but that sweet taste won't last long until the Chinese let them stand on the middle way.
@@wongmok9430 How many people have you died of the plague? The freedom of Tibetans does not need your concern
Relocated and forced to work, sounds like human trafficking and forced slavery. What a strong enduring people. Prey for them and their liberation.
European colonizers did build factories and provide education to local people, but that does not justify colonialism.
No evidence can only be called conjecture, not facts.
Tibet to the Americans!
Tibetan should be in the traditional way of life as 100years ago in your mind.
CCP nazi puppet.
😆😆😆 first of all who are you a han Chinese????
seems like bloomberg would prefer tibet to stay quaint and poor because that's what they think Tibet should be like
This Tibetan guy wants to tell you: We are doing fine in Tibet, we have had enough you western hypocrites! Leave us alone with your myths, we are Chinese now!
You are not tibetan.
@@MiguelDS5547 Sure! And what is the problem?
I thought Tibet was a peaceful colony
Free Tibet now.✊
Never show the wrong map of India.. Anti Indian bloomberg
Free Tibet
My name is Tenzin and I’m Tibetan
No chance for you to go back. Build your Tibet in India.
"Couple of Centuries" I think you better read some history books. Tibet has only been under Chinese control since 1949.
Tibet has been under the control of the central government since the Qing Dynasty. Learn your history well
in Tibetans word said … if you give water … i will do the best i will keep your kindness for😂ever
China come to arunachal and make us developed, we are still so backward and underdeveloped in this poor india.
Is Tibetan people people?
You can be sure, “Tibet is different from the rest of China” for many reasons. 1. Tibet was a sovereign Independent nation which was brutally and unashamedly invaded purely out of greed by communist China. 2. Tibetans have and still can produce truck-loads of documentary proof of it's independent statehood to which China has produced tons of lies that cannot be substantiated. 3. What journalist would not be biased, when China provides them with “oxygen” 5 star accommodation, a massive stage show of life in Tibet and all the “proof” that Tibetans are happy and loyal to China for providing them with meagre life sustenance, when China exports all of Tibet's wealth back to the Han heartland!
Tibet joined China (Yuan dynasty) at 800 years ago .no matter what, this is the final decision which was chosen by the ancestors of Tibetan .for some reasons I can understand them the ancient Tibetan .
Tashi delek ❤❤❤ freedom Tibet ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Endiot
It has been said that "The Mills of the gods turn very slow, but that they grind very fine in the finals" Wait, watch, observe and wonder, but
be patient as this unrolls/unfolds phenomenally. It is getting very close for His direct hand involvement now, however subtle or open it
gets Basically what I am saying, is that we are living at a time now that God is starting to intercede with the direction that we are
going. There will be many unprecedented, unpredictable events taking place, like Dominoes, time and time again. It has been a long time since this has happened, but it is high time it did. I have a Bachelor's and a Masters degree in Theology and have studied many religions and their historical patterns. Civilizations have always gone up to a peak and then go down, get refined a bit of dangerous/non-eternal behaviors and choices. Some never get back up to where they were before. This is the lengthy or long-term pattern I have observed.
Robert
Is this reporter guy Asian Chinese American?
we don't need a change in Tibet. just need free of religion and free speech. we need the way we live before 1959. what they r changing is just an illusion.
China and Russia’s leaders are both old, hopefully the new leaders after them will respect the rights of others.
Don't worry we will liberate tibbet
Are they free to chose their politics ? They are as free as Chinese are free : It can be good to live, but you can't chose your politics.