Classical Musicians React: MAMAMOO 'Memory' vs 'Decalcomanie'
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 фев 2025
- For the 78th video of this series, classical music majors react to MAMAMOO’s ‘Memory’ MV vs ‘Decalcomanie’ MV!
Yes I Am is on the to-react list and will be reacted to when we get back to school. I am currently exploring MAMAMOO’s b side to see what other songs I can add to the to-react list. Cat Fight and I Love Too are already on the to-react list.
~Channel instagram: @reacttothek_official
~Support us on patreon and get extra access to videos you’ll never see on YT: / reacttothek
~Full Reaction Schedule:
docs.google.co...
~THE FULL LIST OF MVs TO-BE REACTED TO: • Playlist
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Video editing by Umu
Thumbnail credit goes to Nozomi Murayama (insta: @nonchanyuzuru)
Pls halp with English Subs
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(PD) Umu:
Instagram and twitter: @_emcha_
RUclips (Kpop covers): EMCHA
Tumblrs: / kpop-instrumental-covers
/ omg-horns
/ bangtan-fanart
/ funny-vixx
(kpop, mamamoo, bts, vixx) Amino app: Umu @ ReacttotheK
(channel manager & assistant editor) Eric:
Twitter: @ricekangaroo
(Assist. filmer) Ash:
Instagram: @ashhfong
Snapchat: @ashleyfong457
Henry:
instagram: @zappa_yes_floyd_genesis
Twitter: @henry_carpender
Yunyi:
Tumblrs: / classic-jenny
/ beijingboi
Facebook: / classicjennycomics
Peyton:
Instagram and Twitter: @pjohnzzz
Jarod:
Instagram: @JVLPhotographic
and @Jarod_lau
Davis:
Instagram: @davisherndon9664
Kevin:
Twitter: @nerdymusicks
RUclips: nerdymusicks
Melissa
Instagram: melissa.447
Gwen:
Instagram and Twitter: @gwenpakerr
RUclips: Gwen Paker
Hugo:
Instagram: @hugohumbility
Shimon:
Instagram: @shimonohi
Ben:
Instagram: @ben.j.l.kronk
Naoki:
Instagram: @naokitoyomura
Lindsey:
Instagram and twitter: @lamusicstudio
tumblrs: / punk-popsicle
/ double-horn
Fiona:
twitter: @fiona_stout
Insta: @fionaastout
Emiel:
Fb: Emiel De Jaegher
Insta: @trumpetoats
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
*DISCLAIMER: I do not own any of the songs or videos being reacted to in this video. All credits to the companies that own them.
Also, none of us are PROFESSIONAL musicians. So if you come here for a strict breakdown/analysis of the music, you won’t be getting that.This is strictly my conservatory musician friends taking time in their schedule to watch kpop for fun, and throw in any musical comments that come into their mind! Also please do not complain about any "boring" reactions...some of the musicians have blank faces since they are concentrating so deeply on analyzing the music.
"I don't understand what she's saying, but it sounds important."- Yunyi
But really, same.
Haha yeah same 😂
You got the point haha!
exactly how I feel in my math class
@@Amber-jx6ig same
lol
In Korea, we express the First Kiss as rising into the air, feeling sweet like fruits and swinging in a high swing. That's why this MV has kind of those scenes.
About the patches over thier eyes, when they take patches over the eyes, they don't know the feeling of First Kiss. And taking off patches means now they know sensation of First Kiss.
김민정 ooohhh lmao thanks for telling
Oohhh thanks for sharing! It really helped me to understand it more😃
Lol, thanks for the info
But they sure made it seem like they went further than a kiss
Oh this makes sense and this is actually so cute 😫😫 in USA we kiss and get it over with
It's a really nice explanation. I couldn't really understand the music video when I first saw it. Now I do. Thanks to you. I'm a mamamoo fan by the way 😊
*"I don't know what she's saying but it sounds really important."* If that aint every international kpop trash ever :^) :'''')
@Inquisitive don't worry trash means stans/fans :)
Moonbyuls rap in Decal gives me so much life
At the same time, took my breath away...❤
"Waiting for her to deliver the truth."
Lol if this isn't every moos waiting for Moonbyul's rap part in every song 😂
Yunyi : "You can't just throw me around like that, i'm not ready !"
WE WERE NOT READY EITHER
But we LOVE it
YES LIKE GIRLL US MOOMOOS TOO
Its interesting to see the more 'outside' perspective of Decalcomanie. They say its one of their lesser liked out of Mamamoo's songs they've heard, but inner fandom (and even Hwasa herself) thought it was one of their better, if not best comeback titles. Perhaps its more of a grower song, or one thats best appreciated when viewing the performance? (They had so many variations of this song - eg. rock/orchestral versions)
Regardless, thanks for the reaction~ and congrats on being invited to Kcon!
Raineydropp I think they like it less than other songs because it's rather poppy than jazzy, less characteristic and original, more mainstream ;)
I agree with them but anyway I love my Mamamoo :D
honestly decalcomanie is my favorite comeback so far of mamamoo because of the different style of music. i listen to this once a day just to cleanse my soul with good music, no kidding lmao
Decalcomaine is my most favorite song of theirs'. 😭
New moomoo here. Discovered them through Hip.
Really? I just discovered them a week ago and Decalcomanie is the song that hooked me on them!
Def a growing song. I didn't quite liked it the first listen but now it's one of my favorite specially LIVE my god the live stages of decalcomanie is amzinggg
Decalcomanie is one of my all time favourites xD It might not be as vocally-intense or as jazzy/cheery as their other songs, but Mamamoo slays it anyways~ and plus the ad libs always make my day
8:35 "damn, they're so hot." I know right? (;
Decalcomanie has to be paired with its lyrics for its full meaning, u have no idea how explicit that song fully is lol.
But then again to be fair, the title already gives you an idea of how explicit it is 😂
When all you want is for them to react to Delilah bc that performance gave you actual life
Trash: I like "The Way to Sampo". Both songs got moved to the CVR playlist. I'm hoping that Umu is able to do more Vocalists reactions when they return to school. Can't see it happening unless she "hires" more videographers and or editors!
Mamamoo Trash If I remember correctly, Umu started to do that where she shows them all of Mamamoo's Immortal Songs 2 performances by chronological order but KBS kept blocking it due to copyright so I guess she decided to not continue it. I think the only one still available on this channel is the first 2 performances (Wait A Minute and Flying Into The Night Sky) but I remember when I was new to the channel that they did already react to it - just got blocked. 😔
Edit: oops, I was wrong. It was an Umu-only reaction but yeah, they still got blocked. She reacted to most of MMM's IS2 performances but only a few survived. I guess that's why she discontinued it from the CM react list bc there wouldn't be a point to react, edit and post if it was gonna be blocked anyway. 😢
That perfomance made me a Moomoo
When I first heard Decalcomanie, I thought I didn't like it as much as other Mamamoo songs.... until I found myself humming it without realizing it. And the imagery, I was suddenly reminded of Gain pole dancing while water spurts out around her...(that song is literally called Blooming, as well)
Yeah me too.. at first i didnt like decalcomanie. It was not a bop for me. But for whatever reasons, one morning i woke up humming the chorus and i really felt good 😂😂
9:35 naoki looks out of breath and giggles while talking *remembers that video a while ago of him laughing for straight like 10 min*
mamamoo usually does multiple genres that really suits their voices. that's why i love their music and love them ❤
moomoos where you at? 💜
Raliavoir HERE🙋🙋
hereee!
Raliavoir hereeeee ofccccc my favorite girl group♥️♥️♥️
Hereeee!
Raliavoir here
I don't know but I'm always nervous while watching them react to mamamoo lol. Anyway thank you for your honest opinions, even though i'm a moonbyul bias i appreciate the constructive criticism to her rap in memory. I may disagree (cause I like it so much T-T but i might be very biased hehe) but I trust their words and getting feedbacks like these can help mamamoo's music grow better in the future. Thank you umu :) Hardworking as always! And thank you to the reactors for sparing their time, some of them look tired, hope they'll have a great rest and take care of yourselves 😊
Moonbyul...Gay: Keep in mind that the criticism of the rap in Memory is also shared by the arranger(s)/composer(s) of the song. I don't believe Moonbyul fulfilled all of the roles!
bob ansak yep i think the arranger should also take note on how to add raps in a jazzy song cause it felt like they just added byul's part randomly without thinking that much which is sad :( cause it made people feel like byul's rap is unnecessary to the song. Which is why i stated feedbacks like this can help mamamoo's music grow in the future (which includes their composers, producers, arrangers etc.) 😊
I loved her rap in it but it felt out of place in memory
Yesss... I agree... Fans should be more like you! Open-minded
YESSSS. MAMAMOO AGAIN
edit : Yeah memory rap was weird to most of us. I think RBW should let Moonbyul sing more. I really like how they can freely criticise mamamoo more freely than other groups because they won't get hate lmao. Actually I hope RBW watches and takes constructive criticism into account.
Edit 2: Hugo was me throughout decalcomanie reaction 😂😂
Shreya 朱利夜 In the new album Moonbyul got her own song 💜
Autumn Spark lmao. I know that. what I mean by making her sing in songs like memory, the songs where concept is more jazzy and soothing and rap isn't really needed
the thing abt moonbyul's rap is u can appreciate it more if u know the meaning behind the lyric itself.
luxoriaa agree, knowing the meaning behind her lyrics makes it so much better that you can't help but appreciate her rap in every song. I really grew a soft spot for her raps especially after translating every single one of them lol. She don't just rap, she write and create poetries. It might not suit to others but they are treasures to me.
yep, there are soooo many girl group's rapper thats better than moonbyul but there's something special on moonbyul's rap.
Decalcomani is one of the best KpOp songs and vids of all time .. its massive vocals is something unique!!
Periodttt
Seriously, Mamamoo could sing any song and they would sound amazing. I'm a proud Moomoo 💓
omg the girl with the pixie cut and floral shirt is soo precious and she says such cute but savage comments
They really need to react to the 'Delilah' live performance on Immortal Song, it is life
I love all their inmortal song performances but 'Delilah' Is my all time favorite 😍💕
Océane Mathieu If I may just copy & paste my reply to one of the comments above saying the exact same thing you just said:
If I remember correctly, Umu started to do that where she shows them all of Mamamoo's Immortal Songs 2 performances by chronological order but KBS kept blocking it due to copyright so I guess she decided to not continue it. I think the only one still available on this channel is the first 2 performances (Wait A Minute and Flying Into The Night Sky) but I remember when I was new to the channel that they did already react to it - just got blocked. 😔
Edit: oops, I was wrong. It was an Umu-only reaction but yeah, they still got blocked. She reacted to most of MMM's IS2 performances but only a few survived. I guess that's why she discontinued it from the CM react list bc there wouldn't be a point to react, edit and post if it was gonna be blocked anyway. 😢
Soojung's RBF saved kpop Oh I see, thank you for your answer :)
Océane Mathieu Lol, sorry to confuse you again, but I was informed that it was moved to the Classical Vocalists react-to list rather than the Classical Musicians react-to. Idk how Umu's gonna overcome the KBS copyright issue tho but if her other IS2 reactions survived, I'm sure there's a way. But it would probably be a while since she's not focusing too much on CVR as much as CMR
ooh new people. new thoughts. new reaction
Mama..mama..mooooo
Yunita Haryanti i read it and heard it in my head with the full harmony and everything. Does this officially make me a moomoo now?
Mamamoo are definitely pioneer and every time they stick perfectly to the concept. Hope you will react to few more immortal song performances like "Wonderful confession" "Backwoods" and "You in my fading memory". Can't wait for september reaction of "Yes I am"
I think i seen this comment somewhere in Yes I am mv vid, i quote it back although maybe not total 100%, cant remember the whole comment. 'What maked mamamoo a mamamoo is not the genre, people always accociate them with genre of jazz, classic, 80, but what make mamamoo a mamamoo today we know is their abilities to interpret in theri own ways, their own color, the mamamoo color, the vocal, the performance, the lyrics, the adlibs of course, not the genre only.' forgive me if im wrong. Huhu. Mamamoo hwaiting.
Something like that. :)
Honestly 'Decalcomanie' would have been my favorite Mamamoo song but it feels like two songs happening at the same time. Although the music video is by far my favorite from them.
If you mean the break, listen to the audio, and if you are referring to the solo parts then the chorus, listen to the life performances, it only strange in the first few listens
last time i was this early Yunyi was Jenny
exactly
Tee Hyun Flashbacks.
André Domingues she changed her name or something? lol
they started to go by their chinese name.
Tee Hyun ff
😂😂😂😂 the "ummm, hmmm, yeaaah kisssss, you have my attention, wooow" during the kiss scenes are totally different from moomoos protective, frustrated reaction.. They made me go through the scenes more smoothly this time, thank you for the criticism and honest reaction, we love you, and Welcome to the new girls 💜💜
New people 😊 welcome!!!
"A sensual crayon" I love that girl already omg
For 'Decalcomanie', you should have told them that it was two different songs for the M/V. For the actual song, it would have been best to show the dance version:)
The one dude: 'it's groovy but it's not as comfy as the last one. The chorus transition wasn't natural'.
The other dude: 'F theyre so hot'
Lmaoo priorities
"edward cullen, is that you?" I'M DYING
You need to make them listen to the live version of MMM decalcomanie bcuz it shows their vocals better especially the Harmonies of the high note at the end.
영상을 보면서 느낀 점은 생각보다 클래식을 하시는 분들이라 그런가요?
음악에 대한 고정관념이 있으시네요.
랩이 왜 크리스마스와 함께 나오냐는 둥 자신들의 기준에서 벗어나면 알레르기 반응을 보이시네요.
"I'm sorry, that was a *lemon*" blush laughs as well
i was reading the tentative schedule and i was sad to know that Ben and Yunyi are leaving soon, am so happy that they will graduate but we gonna miss them :( :(
BTW, I think showing the performances of MAMAMOO in year end stages such as MMA, KBS song festival, blue dragon awards....etc will also be another good choice~ By this video, I think the reactors may not be used to these different style of MAMAMOO, however, watching live stages may let them know that MAMAMOO is equal attractive in performing different songs~ Look forward to the reaction of YES I AM, they will like it more, I guess. Umu fighting!!
i826678 add the blue dragon awards to that list they were witty and flawless!! go search up the performance with subs😂
Finally !!! Mamamoo :)
Decalcomanie was the song that got me into MAMAMOO. I love it and certain sounds in it remind me a bit of Eurythmics, which I grew up with. But musically, I've never liked how the music video version of the song cuts it up with a chunk of Memory in the middle, even though it narratively makes sense for the video.
Fa Fa Finally!!! 🎶🎶 Ive been waiting for this 😀😀😀😀
Vania Sunardi W. oooohhhh i see what you did there!!!!
the two new reactors are so adorable haha,im excited to see them in future reaction:) !
i can still remember Naoki laughing at 'decalcomanie' 😂😂
Fall for décalcomanie is like fall asleep. Slowly and then.. Then you just fall and enjoy it too much and you don't want to wake up. First time listen to décalcomanie I just like 'huh? ' but then I can't stop humming it everyday. 😁
"Idk what she's saying but it sounds really important"
HAHAHAHA me with kpop
I was waiting for this, I LOVE DECALCOMANIE 🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 every time I hear this song I got goosebumps hahaha
Thanks for the reaction 🙏🏼☺️💜
i think the fact that it's "energetic sexy" well describes Decalcomanie.
Minor verses with Major choruses. Can't tell if that's rare or not
Flashbacks to the pain I felt watching decalcomanie the first time. This and dynamite at the end made my night! Thank you Umu!
Love Mamamoo!!!Moomoos plz vote for them so they go to MAMAS!!! Ask me questions if wanna help
My fave parts:
10:15 - his shock face is so cute! Marry me! 😍
10:49 - when they realise the meaning of the song
11:33 - their synchronized dance
Y'all can be my best friends any day ❤
I thought exactly the same first time I saw Decalcomanie's MV. But then, I always watch them live and Decalcomanie is an explosion of vocals between UOAY and YTB for example. It went fast one of my favorite. That's why the success of that song was slow and not immediate.
"I don't know what she's saying, but it sounds really important" MY WHOLE LIFE
are rachel and katie the female and upgraded version of shimon and naoki's bromance
It's another violinist!!! I'm so happy for some reason, and I loved the reaction as always.
Rachael looks soooo pretty without glasses 😍
rachell!!! glad to see you againnn
If you are really interested in knowing what's the meaning of this MV, you should search what those fruits, wine, flowers and blindfold mean. But briefly, it's a soften way to talk about sexual topics like growing up, losing innocence, falling in love and wanting to "cross the line" (as they say)... décalcomanie with another one (which basically is to press one thing to another). It's very elegant and aesthetic. Also, the slow song in the middle (if someone hasn't get it) it's Memory (the first song on this video).
Moonbyul was giving it that spoken word, that speakeasy/cafe vibe. It makes more sense with subtitles translating in English since we don’t speak Korean.
YEEEES MAMAMOO! their vocals are soooo explosive! MOONBYUL RAPPING IS ON FIRE
yunyi, an intellectual (about memory): it's just so silky, how can you not like it?
i've waited for this for so long bc memory is one of my fave mamamoo songs and i'm blessedt 🙏🏻
AHHHHHH KATIE WELCOME!!!! FINALLY A VIOLINIST!!! MAKE US PROUD GURRRL!!!
The whole video I was waiting for you to replay Ben saying Decalcomanie. It was just so funny! 😂
You can watch all of the mamamoos' videos and there's no way I get bored of it
I NEVER made the instrumental connection between Memory and Decalcomanie before this ... thank you.
It's ok Moonbyul
Décalcomanie was my favourite song of 2016 tbh and by far my favourite Mamamoo title track
Edward Cullen is that you I'm so done
LMAO IM DEAD xD
The first time I listened to decalcolmanie I didn't like, but now... I do... Mamamoo is life!!
as a moomoo im soooooo damn happy, thank you for the awesome reaction
The number of "OH!OOOHHH!WAAOWWW!!AH!OH MY!" noises are hilarious from 12.05!
The vocal queens!
I get chills everytime that second rap verse in decalcomanie comes in
Anyone else expecting to see Naoki's laughing breakdown?
I will come right out and say that Decalcomanie is my favorite video of theirs, it's just gorgeous everything is perfect. It's what drew me in to them in the first place
she lost her k card for a great group ;D
"Edward Cullen, is that you?"
TELL ME IM NOT THE ONLY ONE LAUGHING
Jerod's reaction when Moobyul's part came on Decalcomanie. SAME BRUH SAMEEEE
I screamed twice for this video so far (I'm still not finish watching at this moment) :
1. When I saw this on the recommendation list while I was watching another video (screaming because I didn't get the notification wth RUclips ??)
2. When I saw NO Gwen next to Hugo. Where is our cutie pie Gwennie ~~
*Also, I'm the 100th commenter* 😄😄
Im definitely going to check out mamamoo
Check out MamamooTrans as they have an index of english subbed MAMAMOO videos.
"I don't know what she's says but sounds really important" is my new catchphrase
Low Key wanted Gwen to react to this,but i loved everyones reactions
i can't believe i clicked on this video so fast just to see how much footage could be used for Shimon, Naoki and Ben's reaction because of "Decalcomanie"
Plz react to DREAMCATCHER- FLY HIGH
Ps. Love your reactions
RANDOM PERSON Watched the MV and it was really good!!!
I was scared it wouldn't have any rock aspect, but thank goodness it did.. I know they'll like it ❤️
YAAAAAAAAAS
+ᗷEYOᑎᗪ TᕼE ᔕᑕEᑎE Same. The rest of the album is really good too.
Check the description
This video lead me to "Envoyez de l'aide" 😂😂😂 basically the explanation why Naoki's so happy in this video 😂
Yeees ma girls!!
Can you please do a SPICA - You Don't Love Me vs Secret Time ?? Pleease Umu!!
햇빛 hobie i think it comes out September 18
햇빛 hobie yup they have already reacted to the girls I'm pretty sure! :D they don't get enough love and it's sad :(
Watashiwakat Oh really?? Where did you get this information? I found nothing about ;-;
Lisa Chiang They already reacted? Oh, I didn't know that. And about the girls, yeah, and now they have already disbanded, it is sad when a group like theirs ends without having the recognition they deserved...
햇빛 hobie in the link description there's a PDF on upcoming reactions
10:15 when you're in the middle of something but you're striked by moonbyul's swag, so you're like, wait, I think I'm in love.
Please react to Sohyang - Bridge Over Troubled Water and Lean on Me (Immortal Song 2) Live performance for Vocalist reaction *-* thank you~
Cat Moo Yass
Cat Moo They will be blown away by her vocals and techniques
Cat Moo Also her performance of Arirang is amazingly beautiful.
Cat Moo I want them to compare her performances of Lean on Me and Arirang Alone, from Immortal Song; and then her performances of Mona Lisa and Home from King of Mask Singer. I want to watch all the vocalists lose their minds.
Pleaseeeeeeeee!
People always seem to be divided on Moonbyul's rap in Memory, but man, I love it so much and it's what made me realize she was my bias.
90 % of romance scenes need background music to make sense lol
What a great day, first JJProject comeback teaser (after 5 years) and now this :D
Can you do a react* to SNSD Genie vs Gee
they really need to do snsd
Irene Bash the reason they don't do snsd is because of yunyi. She doesn't like them and I think she's doing them when she leaves
I don't remember the video where she said she doesn't like them, when did it happened?
Lion Heart x You think
That's really unfortunate... I hope it's not because she's not into the early cutesy SNSD. Just because one of them doesn't like SNSD doesn't mean they can just skip one of the most icon kpop groups of all time.
"You're loosing your k-card"
-omg I died 😂
my moomoo heart feel blessed.
The moment I heard VIXX's Dynamite bgm at the last part.. I flipped. It's VIXX time to shine~
Ok but seriously I'm really excited for them to react to VIXX, I feel like its been so long and I can't wait for them to react to Fantasy specifically since they incorporated classical music there. The anticipation is killing me!!!!!
마마무는 여신이다.
THE TENSION WAS SO APPARENT I LOVE IT
YAS MAMAMOOOO
Aaaah, VIXX Conception is next!!! 😍
Btw great reaction as always, tanks umu and the reactors! ❤
Would you consider having the reactors watch Hi x Suhyun x Bobby's "I'm Different"? It's like 2 years old... but it has one half of AKMU in it!
My Chemical O's I AGREEE
I love how hyped Hugo gets when he talks about something.