Oo new book channel, i love that you said at the start you don’t like sad books and choose a sad book, i do like sad books but i prefer good endings where a natural conclusion is made whether that is sad or not.
allie: so i'm gonna talk spoilers now. me: should i skip? im 200 pages in,, surely its not that bad. allie: *biggest spoiler i never expected* me: ......i'll go cry now
Do you think I should left more time in between the warning and the spoiler?? I’m still trying to figure out how to do spoilers and all that 🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️
*SPOILER* This is my favorite book of all time... It is the most beautifully written, heartbreaking book I have ever read. Not a lot of books can invoke such strong feelings from me. This isn’t an easy read in terms of both literature and content. It took me six months to finish, as I wanted to savor each moment. A lot of people like to label this as trauma porn, but it is so much more meaningful. If you've ever experienced some of these traumas or forms of abuse, I can guarantee you will understand that these are real things that happen to real people- and the realistic struggle on how people cope with it. Or you may know someone who has had the same outcome. To me it is illuminating, I can relate to Jude in some ways and I have so much love for him. There were so many moments where I just wanted to reach out to Jude and comfort him whenever he had his bad thoughts. Though he had to deal with his trauma for years, I’m even more moved by the support system he had for over 30 years or so- Who were so loyal and loving to him, who just wanted to see him get better. This book taught me a lot about family and friendship values that made me happy, knowing that Jude got through more years than he would have if he didn't have that support from them. I fell in love with all of the characters as if they were my own family. It's all written in the most impressive prose. I will never come across another book like this. I have such a strong bond with all the boys and others. It took my breath away.
Ngl as a chronically suicidal person I could not feel more opposite. Not trying to discredit your take, but like honestly, trauma porn is a pretty fitting descriptor considering the book really doesn't have much to offer the reader except strong emotional reactions, decidedly separate from the legitimately traumatizing suicidal ideation of the book. The characters barely have actual development, most of which are hollow half ideas for characters that entirely revolve around Jude and his emotions.Yanigahara herself admits she did zero research on mental illness, self harm or trauma and it kinda shows. There was a point in Judes back story where the same traumatic events play out at the hands of like 4 different characters who all don't know each other and I was just like... this is just not realistic. And moreover, the gratuitously descriptive scenes of cutting, and the whole end notion of like "poor sweet angel Jude, at least he's finally at peace 🥹" is comparable to 13 Reasons why in terms of tactless, straight up DANGEROUS depictions of suicide for the sole purpose of making teen girls cry in their bedrooms. Watch any interview with Hanya on how she wrote this book and hopefully you'll start to see what I mean, but yeah, I would highly advise against reading this if you've been in the same emotional space the characters are meant to represent.
*spoiler* You said that you wanted an explanation why the book is written in the way that it is and there is one. Harold is the one who gets the booklet with al the little stories about Jude's his life. Starting at Lispenard street. (At the very end it said: you jumped of the roof?! “It’s a good story, I’ll tell you” Harold:Please. And he did.)From that part of Jude’s life Harold gets to hear the story and there are parts where he is involved himself so that explains the way it is written. Also Harold and Julia took multiple days to read the booklet of stories due to the fact that it was just to much, just like is was done in the book itself. This is my view on the matter, please let me know what you think and great video btw 🥰
It wasn’t a booklet, It was a letter that he hid for Harold and Julia in the bookshelf after his adoption ❤️ was finalized, it was intended for them to find it when they find it and then the book is Harold’s explanation of judes life
Loved this video! You edit so well!! I've re-read A Little Life once, and I swore I'd never read it again after the second time. Then I saw the stage adaptation in London this summer and now I feel like I need to read it again!
@@alliestephenson When I say there wasn't a dry eye in the house I'm not exaggerating. Several people ran out crying halfway through & I sobbed on the tube home 😂 unrelated but I have just binged every video on your channel 🤍
omg I am so excited for your channel! I am so excited for how your channel will grow! I am so excited to be here in the beginning and watch your first video and be subscribed for your whole journey :) i already love you ❤❤
14:10 I've never read the book in english, therefore I never caught that reference, so you just kinda made my brain explode and I'm never going to stop thinking about it
It’s an extremely heavy novel so I’d say 18+. I also recommend that you be in a good headspace before starting! I read it at 22 and want to read it again now at 24. It’s one of my favorites!
SPOILER ‼️ “if you don’t want to hear a spoiler skip this part” me: panically looking for my phone-“WILLIAM DYING” i’ve learned to just not look online about a book because i always get spoiled
We do not have to like all the characters in a piece of fiction ... they are as the author intended them to be ... who knows? We may not like them as perhaps their flaws are too close to ones we ourselves carry.
It’s not a five because you want to throw it across the room. I mean it’s such a messed up book because ultimately her message is that for some people, life is hopeless. I’m not saying this is not true for some people but when the choice is darkness instead of light, all the profundity adds up to nothing. BTW, the author said that this book was a kind of fairy tale/ fantasy, as unrealistic as you can get, kind of book, so it’s really messed up that she kind of make it seem so real. So despite her very beautiful writing, the message she leaves you with just kind of kills your soul. Therefore it’s in my opinion not what a good book should be doing and therefore I think she’s kind of a terrible writer who has used her talent to create terrible messaging out into this world.
Caleb could fall into lava for all I care
It’s been 3 years since I’ve read it and I miss every single one of these characters. Such powerful writing!
Ik! Sometimes my heart will ache thinking about them like they were real ppl in my life! It’s crazy 😢
Oo new book channel, i love that you said at the start you don’t like sad books and choose a sad book, i do like sad books but i prefer good endings where a natural conclusion is made whether that is sad or not.
I totally get and that makes the most sense, I just HATE that empty feeling after finishing a sad book! 😭
Hii can u recommend some books like that? Sad with happy ending....
allie: so i'm gonna talk spoilers now.
me: should i skip? im 200 pages in,, surely its not that bad.
allie: *biggest spoiler i never expected*
me: ......i'll go cry now
Oh girl I’m so sorry 🫢🫢🫢🫢 truly such a dangerous game to play 😭
@@alliestephenson the problem was that it was just the one sentence… i would’ve never thought that that’s whats gonna happen😭😭
Do you think I should left more time in between the warning and the spoiler?? I’m still trying to figure out how to do spoilers and all that 🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️
@@alliestephenson no it’s purely my fault… i spend a good minute debating whether i should skip or not.. your vids are cool
im so glad i found this video. i played it right after i finished and it definitely helped me process what i read
I feel like I’m still processing it all 🙃🙃
@@alliestephenson oh girl it’s is always in the back of my mind. especially because i’m a counselor and i see judes everyday
You should read tomorrow and tomorrow and tomorrow 😊
*SPOILER*
This is my favorite book of all time... It is the most beautifully written, heartbreaking book I have ever read. Not a lot of books can invoke such strong feelings from me. This isn’t an easy read in terms of both literature and content. It took me six months to finish, as I wanted to savor each moment. A lot of people like to label this as trauma porn, but it is so much more meaningful. If you've ever experienced some of these traumas or forms of abuse, I can guarantee you will understand that these are real things that happen to real people- and the realistic struggle on how people cope with it. Or you may know someone who has had the same outcome. To me it is illuminating, I can relate to Jude in some ways and I have so much love for him. There were so many moments where I just wanted to reach out to Jude and comfort him whenever he had his bad thoughts. Though he had to deal with his trauma for years, I’m even more moved by the support system he had for over 30 years or so- Who were so loyal and loving to him, who just wanted to see him get better. This book taught me a lot about family and friendship values that made me happy, knowing that Jude got through more years than he would have if he didn't have that support from them. I fell in love with all of the characters as if they were my own family. It's all written in the most impressive prose. I will never come across another book like this. I have such a strong bond with all the boys and others. It took my breath away.
Ngl as a chronically suicidal person I could not feel more opposite. Not trying to discredit your take, but like honestly, trauma porn is a pretty fitting descriptor considering the book really doesn't have much to offer the reader except strong emotional reactions, decidedly separate from the legitimately traumatizing suicidal ideation of the book. The characters barely have actual development, most of which are hollow half ideas for characters that entirely revolve around Jude and his emotions.Yanigahara herself admits she did zero research on mental illness, self harm or trauma and it kinda shows. There was a point in Judes back story where the same traumatic events play out at the hands of like 4 different characters who all don't know each other and I was just like... this is just not realistic. And moreover, the gratuitously descriptive scenes of cutting, and the whole end notion of like "poor sweet angel Jude, at least he's finally at peace 🥹" is comparable to 13 Reasons why in terms of tactless, straight up DANGEROUS depictions of suicide for the sole purpose of making teen girls cry in their bedrooms. Watch any interview with Hanya on how she wrote this book and hopefully you'll start to see what I mean, but yeah, I would highly advise against reading this if you've been in the same emotional space the characters are meant to represent.
i read this book backwards and it was life changing 😅
Genuine question, do u mean in chapters or do you mean like actually backward 😅💀
@@richardhawkins481 haha just the chapters 😂 no that would've been insane to do it like that 😂😂
*spoiler* You said that you wanted an explanation why the book is written in the way that it is and there is one. Harold is the one who gets the booklet with al the little stories about Jude's his life. Starting at Lispenard street. (At the very end it said: you jumped of the roof?! “It’s a good story, I’ll tell you” Harold:Please. And he did.)From that part of Jude’s life Harold gets to hear the story and there are parts where he is involved himself so that explains the way it is written. Also Harold and Julia took multiple days to read the booklet of stories due to the fact that it was just to much, just like is was done in the book itself. This is my view on the matter, please let me know what you think and great video btw 🥰
Oh wow, I like that explanation! That makes so much sense, thank you! 🫶🏼🫶🏼🫶🏼
@@alliestephenson no problem 🥰 glad you like it! ☺️
It wasn’t a booklet, It was a letter that he hid for Harold and Julia in the bookshelf after his adoption ❤️ was finalized, it was intended for them to find it when they find it and then the book is Harold’s explanation of judes life
wasn’t it just an 8 page letter? Not a booklet
just got mine today and i was wondering what i got myself into so thank you for this video :)))
I just found your channel, and I loooove it!! This is also going to be one of my next reads
Ahh thank you!!! ❤️❤️ and good luck!
This has sat with me for the last 7 years 😫 time for a reread ❤😢
I am so happy I found your channel I loved watching!! and I can’t wait for the experience of reading this
ive been contemplating reading this book for soo long omg
Im new in your channel and i absolutely loved the way that you talk and express your thoughts, it was really fun to watch thank you for this!
Loved this video! You edit so well!! I've re-read A Little Life once, and I swore I'd never read it again after the second time. Then I saw the stage adaptation in London this summer and now I feel like I need to read it again!
Thank you!!! Oh my gosh I do not think I could handle seeing it play out in real life!!
@@alliestephenson When I say there wasn't a dry eye in the house I'm not exaggerating. Several people ran out crying halfway through & I sobbed on the tube home 😂 unrelated but I have just binged every video on your channel 🤍
your so beautiful and I already love your channel ❤ so exited to see more of your videos ily
Thank you 🥹 that makes me so happy! ❤️
omg I am so excited for your channel! I am so excited for how your channel will grow! I am so excited to be here in the beginning and watch your first video and be subscribed for your whole journey :) i already love you ❤❤
It’s so good
Thank you bestie 🥰🥰
14:10 I've never read the book in english, therefore I never caught that reference, so you just kinda made my brain explode and I'm never going to stop thinking about it
Once you see it that way, you’ll never be able to unsee it 🫣
great first vid Allieeee (devastating book choice tho ;-;)
youuu look soooo beautiful while reading omg
🥹🥹🥹 thank you
you pointing out the reference 'show a little life' literally gave me goosebumps because what the fuck
Literally the one thing I remember most from the book
never been more scared to read a book haha
it’s an experience to say the least 😭
Congratulations… love you
Thank you love you!! 🫶🏼🫶🏼🫶🏼🫶🏼
I LOVE IT!
Ooop i got this book recently too!!!! Haven’t read it yet
Oh good luck sis 🫶🏼🫶🏼🫶🏼🫶🏼🫶🏼
I’ve just bought this book and really want to read it. For people who have read it what age rating do you recommend for it? ❤
It’s an extremely heavy novel so I’d say 18+. I also recommend that you be in a good headspace before starting! I read it at 22 and want to read it again now at 24. It’s one of my favorites!
I will be reading this soon and I’m scared 🫣
Good luck girl 🫶🏼
Currently reading this
Praying for you
I love your vibe 🧘♀️ I just subbed
Glad you’re here 😌🫶🏼
You are really pretty
SPOILER ‼️
“if you don’t want to hear a spoiler skip this part”
me: panically looking for my phone-“WILLIAM DYING”
i’ve learned to just not look online about a book because i always get spoiled
i just got spoiled by reading the comments, I wasn't fast enough to skip your comment LMAO😭😭😭
Have you finished reading it yet?
This is not spoiler free lol. Also please make your spoiler warning longer!! I didn't have enough time to pause and so I heard it.
😍
We do not have to like all the characters in a piece of fiction ... they are as the author intended them to be ... who knows? We may not like them as perhaps their flaws are too close to ones we ourselves carry.
It’s not a five because you want to throw it across the room. I mean it’s such a messed up book because ultimately her message is that for some people, life is hopeless. I’m not saying this is not true for some people but when the choice is darkness instead of light, all the profundity adds up to nothing. BTW, the author said that this book was a kind of fairy tale/ fantasy, as unrealistic as you can get, kind of book, so it’s really messed up that she kind of make it seem so real. So despite her very beautiful writing, the message she leaves you with just kind of kills your soul. Therefore it’s in my opinion not what a good book should be doing and therefore I think she’s kind of a terrible writer who has used her talent to create terrible messaging out into this world.
Girl you said SPOILER FREE wtf :(((
I gave a warning before the spoiler section?
You still spoiled some little things like I didn’t know about a kneee injury or nth 😂💕