BABYN YAR. CONTEXT. R12/ HANS ISENMANN

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 27 дек 2024

Комментарии • 198

  • @foreverblueclassics
    @foreverblueclassics Год назад +30

    He's handsome, young, articulate and appears to be intelligent. You look at him and initially feel some sympathy for him when you hear of his fate. Then you listen to his words and the way he speaks them. He's very matter-of-fact in talking about shooting civilians, including women and children, unemotional in fact. His words are all the more shocking because of the way he delivers them. He's the personification of the automatons who fought in the SS.
    Yes, he had a mother and a father, probably brothers and sisters, perhaps a wife or sweetheart. But so did the poor people he mercilessly gunned down into a pit. It really is difficult to look at him and think of him doing the things he did, but do them he did. And German soldiers, including those in the SS, could refuse an order to shoot civilians in these circumstances. The worst he would have got is bullying and less chance of promotion, but better to live with that than the dishonour of carrying out the evil deeds of the Nazis. Shame on him and the evil he served.

  • @akivaragen
    @akivaragen 3 года назад +77

    Hans, born in berlin, was executed for his crimes ten days after this testemony, at 29.01.1946 in Kiev

    • @madberlin
      @madberlin 3 года назад +11

      It's a nightmare, too many of those murders got away, it still makes me angry and furious. Only 1% of the auschwitz helpers (6000) came to court. It's a shame.

    • @MeisterPothead
      @MeisterPothead 3 года назад +10

      @@madberlin Do you understand the concept of military? if you deny a task you'll get shot..
      it was not the will of those soldiers to kill them.. it was a command= guess who's to blame? facepalm

    • @madberlin
      @madberlin 3 года назад +12

      @@MeisterPothead Don't talk lies. It's not true, nobody was forced to kill people. Everybody knows - you don't.

    • @makpazon11
      @makpazon11 3 года назад +17

      When the leader is crazy, the soldier follows the craziness.

    • @VinhNguyenf
      @VinhNguyenf 3 года назад +7

      @@MeisterPothead you are wrong .. every military..including the Wehrmacht at the time has its own code that allow the soldier to refuse to carry out order deemed illegal.. unfortunately these are killers that been screened and selected for this task. ..

  • @samm761
    @samm761 2 года назад +28

    I think the translator viewed Mr. Isenmann with utter contempt. You can tell by her body language. I give her respect for doing her job with such skill and professionalism.

    • @croissants1280
      @croissants1280 Год назад +2

      I don't agree. She was being professional. You are trying to find your own emotional reaction in her.

    • @samm761
      @samm761 Год назад +3

      @@croissants1280 I agree with you that she was professional with her job. Your second sentence was out to lunch. You have no idea what I was thinking when I made the initial comment. Let’s leave it at that.

    • @croissants1280
      @croissants1280 Год назад +5

      @@samm761 You have no idea what the translator was thinking either. Let's leave it at that.

    • @OrionCrusader
      @OrionCrusader Год назад +3

      ​@@samm761 Don't know what this other dude in the comments is on. I'm pretty sure you're exactly right. The way the translator won't even look at him, the most she'll look at is the podium in front of him. That's not professional, that's something else, and it's pretty damn easy to guess what.

    • @jerryking45
      @jerryking45 2 месяца назад

      I thought they were gonna hug after. Color me surprised 😮😮

  • @newday2447
    @newday2447 2 года назад +17

    For a man who shot dead so many innocent civilians he seems so calm, no sign of remorse in him.

    • @mikha007
      @mikha007 2 года назад

      so who was the woman at the end??

    • @elgato-v2g
      @elgato-v2g 2 года назад +1

      Er hat auf Befehl gehandelt.

    • @grillo8970
      @grillo8970 2 года назад

      @@elgato-v2g why you german always claim 'I just followed orders'. Dont you ppl have have your own brains to use? Is it always someone higher up making decisions for you?This is truly the most servile nation on earth

    • @Codiggity369
      @Codiggity369 Год назад +3

      ThAts what conspiracy theories and brainwashing does to a person

    • @andrewhooper7603
      @andrewhooper7603 Год назад +1

      ​@@elgato-v2g and look what that got him.

  • @cofeebeing
    @cofeebeing 2 года назад +33

    So calm. So cool. As if presenting production numbers at a business meeting. These are human lifes'.

    • @jonallen-friend2405
      @jonallen-friend2405 2 года назад +5

      a typical SS soldier reaction.

    • @nealhurwitz6340
      @nealhurwitz6340 2 года назад

      Murdering. KISS.

    • @joelonzello4189
      @joelonzello4189 Год назад

      Alot of dog owners have the same attitude towards other humans !

    • @joelonzello4189
      @joelonzello4189 Год назад

      Update your concerns. Worldwide refugee crisis is an apocalypse.

    • @emmanueldidier321
      @emmanueldidier321 Год назад +1

      No, not "human lives". For the SS, THEY were the superior race, and their opponents or victims were not even human.

  • @yulimoonshine
    @yulimoonshine Год назад +18

    My grandparents were children and barely tweens when they escaped from Babi Yar during the Holocaust. It is the largest villlage massacre in Holocaust history. They murdered children, pregnant women, men, elderly, Jewish villagers in 3 days - about the total 33,771 people and then 100,000 for the remainder of the war. Majority of my family was murdered during this massacre. It is a known memorial site that was recently attemptedly bombed by russian troops - a deplorable act.
    My parents, my sister, and I escaped to the US in the early 90s when the USSR broke apart. They were in their early twenties and they left everything to come here and to be safe. My grandparents managed to get out too and my uncle. The rest of my family, majority did not make it out. In the 90s. They were blaming and persecuting Jewish people then as well.
    I grew up here in the US in a known liberal area but experienced heightened levels of physical assaults, death threats, hate speech, and stalking from kkk members, neo nazis, etc since I was a child (by children and adults alike).
    We still get people today using antisemitic hate speech and death threats and throw conspiracy theories at us... words and old thousands of years steroetypes used to help propel the Holocaust. And white supremacists use still today to weaponize other marginalized communities against us and ultimately have us fight one another and not pay attention to the monsters behind the curtain.
    I encourage everyone to continue to educate themselves about this history and csider looking into the world history as a whole. All over the world and thousands of years of massacres, progroms, mass exiles, acts of cruel and unusual punishments and torture and dehuminization of Jewish people has existed. And now more than ever it is important to understand how all of us must learn that more unites us than divides us.
    And I highly reccomend those willing to learn more to watch the movie "Come and See". It is depicts a part of the Holocaust often removed from our history books - the village massacres. The first set of millions of Jewish people murdered were in those massacres. This film, also known as "Iti Smotri", you can find it in youtube with English subtitles, is honestly one of the best depictions and war film ever made.
    I talked about my grandmother's survival of this massacre (this was one of the worst traumas of her life and she was only 10) in a short tiktok video and I got lengths of death threats and hate speech towards me - towards my appearance to be "targeted", towards my family who survived, and it was not only by white supremacists.
    This is not a fight that has stopped.
    Antisemitism still is alive and well.

    • @emmanueldidier321
      @emmanueldidier321 Год назад +5

      One: you are not alone. Two: you will never be forgotten.

    • @Nicht-die-Mama
      @Nicht-die-Mama Год назад +4

      Not the Russians! The Ukrain asow Nazi people themselve destroyed the memorial. Be sure of that

    • @nledaig
      @nledaig Год назад

      It's plastered all over the internet today, Sometimes openly, sometimes in sneery asides. But people like yourself also swallow lies and spread them as in the last sentence of your first paragraph.

    • @FILA1971
      @FILA1971 8 месяцев назад

      Там не мемориала😂😂там парк, стоит только памятник, сбежал он😂😂твои братья украинцы там все сравняли с землёй и сейчас об этой трагедии никто незнает😃

  • @felicitasschonfeld203
    @felicitasschonfeld203 2 года назад +8

    Schrecklich, einfach nur schrecklich traurig zu was Menschen fähig sind.

    • @michaelschulz6667
      @michaelschulz6667 4 месяца назад

      Fähig sein müssen ! Befehl ist Befehl . Eid ist Eid .

  • @paulmoore120
    @paulmoore120 Год назад +3

    Chilling.

  • @ivb815
    @ivb815 2 года назад +4

    He is talking about the massacre in Lemberg? Not Kiev?

  • @bh0931
    @bh0931 Год назад +8

    Such a young man ! How could he casually murder innocent, frightened people ?
    Incredibly sad.

  • @chr.burm.2529
    @chr.burm.2529 2 года назад +9

    Sagenhaft wie emotionslos dieser Kerl über das Morden berichtet.

  • @reinhard7572
    @reinhard7572 2 года назад +13

    Lowest rank in a unit. Young and following horrific orders. Judging by his calm and cool ways of answering, he never thought much of it at all. Cold blooded and no feelings.

    • @elgato-v2g
      @elgato-v2g 2 года назад

      Diese Soldaten musste es auch geben und nicht jemand der sich gleich ins Hemd macht.

  • @Fritz_Maisenbacher
    @Fritz_Maisenbacher 2 года назад +12

    This man is strangely pure. Is this not strange in itself ?

    • @Codiggity369
      @Codiggity369 Год назад

      What do you expect? A rambling insane person? Human are evil bro

    • @AbdulMalik-gg1hw
      @AbdulMalik-gg1hw Год назад +3

      @@Fritz_Maisenbacher well, hes pretty honest but still a monster

    • @croissants1280
      @croissants1280 Год назад

      @@AbdulMalik-gg1hw If you were a German in Nazi Germany, would you also have been a monster?

    • @OrionCrusader
      @OrionCrusader Год назад +2

      Pure? In what way could he possibly be pure?

    • @Fritz_Maisenbacher
      @Fritz_Maisenbacher Год назад

      Pure engagement, pure destiny and pure sincerity.
      Very seldom today.
      And I am not talking about what he did, which was horrible, only about his courage in front of his destiny.@@OrionCrusader

  • @jeffreyhodge5564
    @jeffreyhodge5564 Год назад +5

    No words can be added to this ,except to say the depravity of man is beyond belief ,absolute beyond belief.

  • @gijbuis
    @gijbuis Год назад +16

    His total lack of empathy is remarkable. Hans Isenmann tries to report his role in killing 120 victims as accurately as possible without showing any hesitation.

    • @RON_HART
      @RON_HART Год назад

      In war, the more you kill, the more you become desensitized and used to killing. For men like Isenmann, killing the Jews was a crucial part of the war. They were the “enemy within”, the puppeteers who, if given the chance, would butcher every single German down to the last child. The Nazi’s genuinely believed that Jews were that dangerous and what they were doing was for the good of all mankind.

  • @jeffreyhodge5564
    @jeffreyhodge5564 Год назад +4

    Has the manners to cover his mouth when coughing but commits heinous crimes!

  • @Fade007fade007
    @Fade007fade007 Год назад +1

    Kannur. Kerala. India 🇮🇳

  • @nicknoga564
    @nicknoga564 Год назад +5

    He didn’t believe what he did was wrong. He thought it was just, he thought it was necessary, and it was his job.

    • @dylanbraun1635
      @dylanbraun1635 Год назад

      His job to mercilessly massacre people. Yea ur really trying to rationalize it huh Nick?

    • @OrionCrusader
      @OrionCrusader Год назад

      See that's bullshit. Everybody, even deeply evil people, knows what they are doing. They're not blind, stupid, or morally confused. They've just broken down their internal moral barriers against committing atrocities, step by step, which is one of the most evil things you can do. You still know what you are doing is sick and wrong, that you are torturing and massacring men, women, and _children_. You just don't care.
      A soldier with even a shred of righteous conscience left would've refused to commit genocide even if it meant him being imprisoned or executed, or at the very least, he would have turned his gun on himself when it came time to execute.

  • @tomberenger2057
    @tomberenger2057 3 года назад +17

    Спасибо за напоминание о страшных фактах массовых убийств беззащитных людей только по причине их принадлежности к еврейской национальности. Все эти видео показаний свидетелей о зверствах нацистов относительно евреев на оккупированных территориях Украины увидели впервые. Советские коммунистические правители старательно умалчивали правду о Холокосте.

    • @sergkoval2853
      @sergkoval2853 3 года назад +6

      так замалчивали что все с детства знают , в школах рассказывали , в книгах , ври дальше

    • @michaelschulz6667
      @michaelschulz6667 4 месяца назад

      Katyn ?????​@@sergkoval2853

  • @rokana9641
    @rokana9641 3 года назад +2

    i wonder how he was apprehended

  • @didierdrouin
    @didierdrouin 2 года назад +5

    Le mal peut s’incarner en tout homme à qui l’on donne une arme et qui doit obéir aveuglément aux ordres.
    Se présenter devant le Créateur avec 120 morts sur la conscience...
    Ce témoignage est glaçant.

  • @Z24BL2
    @Z24BL2 2 года назад +2

    Who is the source of this forever cycle of genocide/revenge/genocide/revenge ? The modern and civilized people, or the old and tribal one?

  • @sandykristensen8099
    @sandykristensen8099 3 года назад +12

    NICE. Finelly the real killer's testemony in coart 👍 Thanks a lot

    • @johnnicolaou554
      @johnnicolaou554 2 года назад +2

      court

    • @sandykristensen8099
      @sandykristensen8099 2 года назад

      @@johnnicolaou554 Yep a lithle fast on the Phone..👍😉

    • @sandykristensen8099
      @sandykristensen8099 2 года назад

      @@johnnicolaou554 Do you talk Danish..??
      Nope rigth..!! Well i AM Danish and SORRY i spelt a Word ore 2 badly.. so so soooo Sorry. 😅 Wat is this 3Grade

    • @johnnicolaou554
      @johnnicolaou554 2 года назад

      for you yes

    • @johnnicolaou554
      @johnnicolaou554 2 года назад +1

      i talk german and dainsh and english and greek

  • @ryanisenmann1774
    @ryanisenmann1774 Год назад +2

    Unreal

  • @nealhurwitz6340
    @nealhurwitz6340 2 года назад +4

    poor guy--- but what were his feelings about this atrocity???????????????????? and then he is hanged. The Nazi horrors are never-ending; same with Japanese atrocities. -------------------------------------------------Am Israel Chai!!!

    • @prof4659
      @prof4659 2 года назад

      Poor Guy? He may be young, but he is old enough to know when he is murdering civilians en masse. There is something very wrong with him, albeit a result of his upbringing,xposure to propoganda, and/or his own fear.Yet no one forced him, nor would he be punished if he refused to participate. That is a fact. And that some DID refuse to do this proves that it was possible legally, and that it is possible to remain decent while others are less than men. He watched the people--children, old folks, mothers and babies--line up, and then he shot them and he watched them fall, into the pit some still alive in agony. And he did not stope

    • @nealhurwitz6340
      @nealhurwitz6340 2 года назад

      @@prof4659 yes--- it has always amazed me how people can do what they do--- Mai Lai for example: women and babies there too... War is hell and it just corrupts. Nazism was Evil. Period. That we know. See the book I published in English: Der Gelbe Stern, The Yellow Star, Fordham U Press, 2008. --- Am Israel Chai!

    • @davidgrahamscott
      @davidgrahamscott 2 года назад +1

      @@nealhurwitz6340 great book, Neal! Read it twice

    • @AbdulMalik-gg1hw
      @AbdulMalik-gg1hw Год назад +1

      @@prof4659 yep..he could've refused to murder .some did n were not shot but reassigned.

    • @nledaig
      @nledaig Год назад

      @@prof4659 They went back and shot into the fallen to kill those that seemed still alive. But although many were shot at Babi Yar there were multiple other shooting sites where the Huns and their allies carried out massacres. The disregard for other people did not start in the West with the Hitler regime. The Kaiser's army carried out atrocities in South-West Africa before the Great War and the storm-troopers who returned from the front in 1918 had fallen in love with slaughter so much that they shot a multitude of their fellow countrymen and carried out mass-murder in the post-war Baltic states. The Hitler gang just built on and refined what was already in existence.

  • @BERENCEV
    @BERENCEV 3 года назад +2

    Лозница это глаза и голос Истории! Даже его игровое «Счастье моё» содержит в себе очень честные исторические образы.

  • @cooper28clark
    @cooper28clark 2 года назад

    was wurde aus Hans Isenmann, finde keine Informationen über Ihn, weiß jemand mehr?
    what became of Hans Isenmann, can't find any information about him, does anyone know more?
    что стало с Гансом Изенманном, не могу найти о нем никакой информации, может кто знает больше?

    • @russian8086
      @russian8086 2 года назад

      Казнён спустя 10 дней после съемки этого видео

    • @ivb815
      @ivb815 2 года назад +1

      He was executed ten days later.

    • @cooper28clark
      @cooper28clark 2 года назад

      Thank you for the Informationen

  • @user-666-qqq
    @user-666-qqq 9 месяцев назад

    Такий молодий, а стільки добрих справ зробив.

  • @justinbailey7870
    @justinbailey7870 Год назад +1

    There were no tears shed for him when he left this life.

  • @davideasson
    @davideasson 4 месяца назад +1

    He was convicted and hanged 12 days after this testimony

  • @MrAkbar2
    @MrAkbar2 3 месяца назад

    Remember folks, we have many a Hans Isenman types walking among us. Had times been different, had the war not broken out, this unemotional precise young man might have worked in a pharmacy or as an accountant. But fate took him to the Soviet Union where like a little emotionless robot he shot and killed civilians with zero hesitation or regret. It goes to show our assumptions about the universality of independent moral reasoning are unfounded. Many like Hans Isenman do not kill because they are conformists but if the social situation changes they simply do as the group does. Let us make sure we don’t allow his type to activate.

  • @jaylenwrice8064
    @jaylenwrice8064 7 месяцев назад

    Found this dude on LinkedIn

  • @charlesmartella
    @charlesmartella Месяц назад

    He would make an excellent Centre Half Forward.

  • @joelat4674
    @joelat4674 2 года назад +6

    Watch him die here: ruclips.net/video/vNi5-fEDrGA/видео.html

  • @HarryRushfan
    @HarryRushfan 10 месяцев назад

    For heavens sake, why do people give a thumb up.....

  • @emeyero
    @emeyero 2 года назад +7

    Pure evil

  • @brrrlak
    @brrrlak Год назад +1

    120 Leute auf kürzeste Entfernung. Krass.

  • @Fritz_Maisenbacher
    @Fritz_Maisenbacher Год назад +1

    I am looking since many years a real illustration of courage.
    This is one.

    • @karfomachet7265
      @karfomachet7265 Год назад

      u all ready knew it was here as per your stupid pure comment one year ago

    • @Fritz_Maisenbacher
      @Fritz_Maisenbacher Год назад

      @@karfomachet7265
      And why is my comment "stupid" ?
      Explain yourself.

    • @nledaig
      @nledaig Год назад

      @@Fritz_Maisenbacher Explain YOURSELF

    • @Fritz_Maisenbacher
      @Fritz_Maisenbacher Год назад

      @@nledaig
      Why should I ?
      All is very clear.

    • @nledaig
      @nledaig Год назад

      @@Fritz_Maisenbacher So ve see

  • @at1970
    @at1970 Месяц назад

    Initially many of the people in Russia considered the German invaders as liberators because Stalin was so brutal and murderous. But then the Germans initiated their racial policies and the people realized there was something worse than Stalin.

  • @smithyman33
    @smithyman33 2 года назад +4

    Looks and sounds like he’s reading from a script.

    • @shirleybalinski4535
      @shirleybalinski4535 2 года назад +1

      That's what I thought. He keeps glancing down as if reading from a book.

    • @nledaig
      @nledaig Год назад +1

      He wasn't just dragged into the room ten minutes before. He had been interrogated at length and he had a good idea what was going to be asked. He knew what he had done.

  • @carlcarlson1369
    @carlcarlson1369 Год назад +5

    I know nothing I just followed orders. Same old crap excuses

    • @itskarl7575
      @itskarl7575 Год назад +2

      What excuses? He told plainly what he did, he didn't try to excuse his actions.

  • @shakkeelrahman3073
    @shakkeelrahman3073 Год назад

    Nigalek athiranjalikale nerune aa a aaaa

  • @ltcolumbo9708
    @ltcolumbo9708 Год назад +1

    Great 6minutes video to proof why God is a joke

  • @crypterixxcrypterixx5918
    @crypterixxcrypterixx5918 2 года назад +5

    Sowjetischer Schauprozess!!

  • @charlesmartella
    @charlesmartella Год назад +1

    Bloke was only following orders and one of the lowest ranks and just a kid - get over it .

    • @NataBol
      @NataBol Год назад +7

      Сегодня ездила в архив и смотрела его последнее слово перед трибуналом, а так же допрос. Нигде он не оправдывался, что просто выполнял приказы. Каждый видит на видео свое, но я смотря его последнее слово, увидела признание его участия в зверствах и мужественную готовность принять любое наказание за это.
      Некоторые злятся, что нет раскаяния на видео, а как он должен был его проявить? Начать рыдать на публику и оправдываться? Разве публичное раскаяние что-то изменит?
      В общем, мне тоже его и его жертв очень жаль, и в то же время я восхитилась мужеством, с которым он прошел через суд и казнь

    • @charlesmartella
      @charlesmartella Год назад +2

      ​@@NataBol very well said

  • @FILA1971
    @FILA1971 8 месяцев назад

    Is bullshit😂😂

  • @shanetharle4030
    @shanetharle4030 Год назад

    It is obvious Hans was tortured for these confession,because Babi yar never happen ,just like Disneyland, it Fantasyland cooked up by the Russians

    • @thewwiiprofessor5808
      @thewwiiprofessor5808 6 дней назад

      That is the issue, is not? The USSR takes facts heaped with lies, then it is clear a mud.

  • @charlesmartella
    @charlesmartella Год назад +1

    Imagine what would have happened to him if he had of objected to doing his job ?? He's a Big Young Bloke . He would make an excellent Centre Half Forward. Very sad . He was so young caught up in all the madness of the time.

    • @emmanueldidier321
      @emmanueldidier321 Год назад +2

      He would simply have been sent to the frontline. Participation in the SS or Einsatzgruppen was VOLUNTARY.

    • @philipnestor5034
      @philipnestor5034 Год назад

      There is this misconception that Germans that refused to shoot children , pregnant women, elderly people etc were executed, this isn’t true. Himmler passed a order stating that anyone refusing to kill people would just be transferred to a desk job or someplace else. Read the book The Good Old Days! It’s all’s In the testimony from old Germans who took park in wiping out villages and some of their complaints were that the blood and brains of small children being shot at point blank range would mess up their nice uniforms and boots, not that they were killing children and mothers as they screamed and cried!!. In the book they said that a few men that complained about the job they did were laughed at and called a baby or sissy. Also many of these men were in their 30’s and 40’s and were well educated, a number of their German Einstazgruppen leaders and SS police leaders were lawyers, Physicians, university professors, etc.They were all willingly doing this for the good of the German people , they had plenty of enthusiastic helpers from Ukrainian cilivians, police units and Ukrainian SS. This was the same in other countries they Germans invaded, Latvian, Lithuanian, Croatian Volunteers and SS units. You can also read the book Hitler’s Willing Executioners.

    • @charlesmartella
      @charlesmartella Год назад

      @@emmanueldidier321Netanyahu is way more guilty than this kid right now but that's ok.

  • @Antydemokrata
    @Antydemokrata Год назад +2

    Quite a circus. The Bolsheviks wrote him what to say.