Do eggs cause heart disease?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 апр 2024
- JOIN THE PHYSIONIC INSIDERS [PREMIUM CONTENT]
Join the Physionic Insiders [Standard Tier]: bit.ly/PhysionicInsiders2
Join the Physionic Insiders [Pro Tier]: bit.ly/PhysionicInsidersPro
Standard Tier: Access to the Premium Video Library, Full Study Analyses (+ Summaries), Insider Podcast, , Research Reviews, and More
Pro Tier: All benefits of the Standard Tier + Live Sessions with Me, Consulting Lite, and More
HEALTH AUTONOMY [COURSE]
Learn to Analyze & Apply Studies for Yourself: bit.ly/healthautonomy
JOIN THE COMMUNITY
Join my Community [It’s Free!]: bit.ly/PhysionicCommunity2
EMAIL LIST
One Weekly Email of Value: bit.ly/2AXIzK6
HIRE ME FOR CONSULTING:
Consulting: bit.ly/3dmUl2H
DONATIONS FOR A SCIENCE BASED CAUSE
Patreon: bit.ly/PhysionicPatreon
OTHER SOCIAL MEDIA
Instagram: bit.ly/2OBFe7i
Created with Biorender
References (Copy & Paste DOI into Search Engine)
[1] doi:10.1016/j.amjmed.2020.05.046
[2] doi:10.1007/s00394-020-02345-7
[3] doi:10.1007/s11883-023-01109-y
[4] doi:10.1093/nutrit/nuac002
[5] doi:10.3390/nu12071995
*******CRITIQUES, RULES, AND NOTES*******
Be aware of the following rules before posting comments:
- Please do not post summaries of the video in the comments - it damages retention on the video and RUclips is less likely to promote it (these videos cost me a lot of money to produce).
Critiques of my work are welcome! Please be aware of the following notes & rules before submitting critique:
Be mindful that this content is not all encompassing on the subject at hand and is self-limited for brevity to reach a wider audience. Also, be aware that I receive hundreds of RUclips comments per day, so the only way your critique can be considered is if you follow the steps outlined below. Finally, RUclips auto-deletes links, so I do not see most comments with links attached.
RULES:
If your comment is rude, you will be banned.
If your comment is not about the studies/topics at hand (i.e. extending to other outcomes not discussed) or offers critique with no scientific basis, it is unlikely to receive a response.
If you can follow these rules, I will try to address your critique and if there is merit, I will add an AMENDMENT to the content in question and pin it so everyone can see it (thank you!).
Please use the following link to submit your critique: bit.ly/PhysionicCritique
Disclaimer: None of the information provided by this brand is a replacement for your physician's advice. This brand is information for the sake of knowledge and the options of choice it provides, not in any way a personalized prescription. Please consult your physician before making any health related changes.
Does being alive cause death?
No studies on that - big pharma doesn't want you to know, Z.
Necessary but not sufficient
Conflicting studies and insufficient data due to small sample size
@@Joe_C. 110 billion people have lived and passed so far and you say not enough data?!? 😅
@@Freja_SolstheimThat wasn’t an RCT, just observational.
My favorite channel for scientific analysis.
Only 8 eggs per week? I commonly consume twenty eggs/week.
So?
they only have negative effect when combined with statins.
28 eggs per week here for 3 years straight now
I don’t know how many I consume, maybe not 28, but between 12 and 24 is likely. No research on that apparently
12 to 14 here. My regular breakfast right now is 2 eggs, a handful of vegetables, cooked in a very small steel skillet at a low heat for about 4 minutes with a lid on. I add cheese and replace the lid and let it sit two minutes.
I used to eat name brand breakfast sandwiches in a red box but the bacon is thin as paper now and the "egg" patty now tastes like pure egg white. These cost about $1.25 each and I would add some tomato sauce and cheese and maybe a little fajita vegetables to them.
My current breakfast is cheaper even using $6.50 per dozen eggs. I'll add a thin pork loin to it a few days a week. And it tastes a lot better.
One key was "seasoning" the steel pan. The eggs were sticking to it. Basically put a bit of olive oil in the pan and then cook it til the oil turns into a brown layer. That layer is about as slippery as teflon. I have to avoid using steel to clean the pan to preserve it.
I would just like to say that I for one very much appreciate your light-hearted humor and how you let your quirks shine through, never fails to make me smile or chuckle, do keep ignoring the comments, and thank you for your input and videos! ❤🥚🥜(there is no almond emoji...)
I remember my parents, their siblings, and friends debating over this question over 40 years ago.
Of course they sided with the Almonds to kick ass...... am I right?
@@jakehayes1345 🤣 Most of them got fooled.
@@frankenz66 they got egg on their face::))
The Yoks on you 😂
@@jakehayes1345 Not in their stomachs for sure. They mostly fell for it. God forfend our government or media would lie to us, right?
I am also wondering how eggs are counted in those studies. Are cookies and pancakes and all the other egg containing foods being counted as egg consumption?
This is extremely relevant. Would like for Physionic to tell us here if this is happening.
Bologna on White Bread Covered in Ketchup is eating Meat by every Study done
Just how the egg is prepared has an effect, cooking beyond runny yolks oxidizes the cholesterol.
@@tgferg67really? So even boiling eggs oxides them? Wouldn't it depend on the temperature and if vegetable oil is being used?
@@wasteddude Hard yolk = more oxidized cholesterol.
If your great grandmother (who didn't get diabetes or heart disease because it was rare back then) ate eggs, then it is fine. She also ate lard, tallow, suet and butter instead of seed oils - the greatest confounder of modern nutritional studies.
She didn't get them as they weren't diagnosed *or* people were dying before that of other conditions we can now treat. Its not a confounder at all.
@@MichaelGGarry Seriously... these people who "Oh, we used to [fill in something ridiculous] and we were fine" need to get someone else to do their thinking for them
Yes, and she is probably one of the hundreds people who lived to her age, because everyone else is no longer with us
@@MichaelGGarryDo dietary fats matter? Yes. We're they controlled for? No. Therefore they are a confounder. Statistics is like that sometimes.
Then what killed her? Did she live forever?
Thanks for cracking this one open for us
Thanks for the information. I liked your presentation!
These studies need to be redone but with 30-40 eggs per week, and all participants get good amount of exercise per week as well. I need these results lol
There's someone here on RUclips that ate something like 100 in a short time and then got all of his blood work done. I don't think it showed a particular problem with his blood work. But you'd have to search for it. He does a lot of body experimentation like this but I forget his name.
The short and long answer is .. No.
No. The answer is that it depends on the amount of data correction.
❤
@@sergey9986I stick with my answer.
Well said
Saturated animal fat indeed raises CVD risk. That's well beyond proven. Only flawed studies ever showed no damage from saturated animal fats vs polyunsaturated. Mineral oil and margarine are in the studies that end positive for SAFAs. Those are not good comparisons. When actual polyunsaturated fats were put against the saturated animal fats the results were overwhelmingly negative for the saturated animal fats. I've read through 50 studies.
I went on a 6 to 8 boiled eggs per day diet with occasional bok choy and lost 21 kg (-20%) in 3-4 months. i.e. that's like an extended fast with some protein, fats, vitamins and minerals.
That says literally nothing about the risk of heart disease and eggs... It's just kinda worthless information 🤷
@ Well true! I took blood tests before and after and all I can say is that the doctor said both are okay. My low iron and hypothyrodism haven't changed.
@@SonnyDarvishzadeh I’m hoping to one day overcome my hypothyroidism. I developed low iron in the two years I was vegan and continued to donate blood regularly. Ate a lot of spinach and smoothies with it, but it took a couple of years of keto to get iron levels up.
What's your apo B?
@@dannyspitzer1267 do you assume every doctor is up to their game and every generic blood test includes apo B by default? every physical watches peter attia's videos?
I'll tell you my apo B after you tell me your telomere length. Measure the good ones please.
I’m 58 years old and since I was a young child I’ve been fascinated with health and nutrition. I’ve had many friends who were much older than me and I’d ask the ones who were in their mid to late 90s a lot of questions about their habits. Almost all said that they ate eggs daily. Most also had a routine of hanging from a bar overhead (stretching their spines). I’ve taken to doing both as I seriously think that there is something to this.
Thanks for mentioning other risk factors. Something that is often overlooked...
Why are so many heath influencers say dietary cholesterol has no effect on total cholesterol?
Because it’s generally true
@@Physionicyeah because you don’t take into account baseline serum cholesterol and the parabolic curve. If you already eat high amounts of cholesterol and you eat more.. your cholesterol tends not to spike. But if you are on a plant based diet for example and then you suddenly eat 3 eggs per day, you will see a dramatic spike. You can fudge the data and make it look like eating 10 eggs a day doesn’t raise cholesterol that much.. because the person already had a high cholesterol diet etc. like I said, it’s a parabolic curve not a linear
This was very interesting! Thank you!
Love the video. Thanks for the depth and balance, as always! This topic never seems to come to a satisfactory end. Egg yolks used to induce atherosclerosis in some experiments. Keto, pro-egg is real popular among RUclips audiences. These studies seem to look at up to 8 eggs per week vs 4 per day people are filling up on (unless I misunderstand). So much more to know but the studies aren’t there.
Do these studies include what was eaten with the eggs (salt, butter, potatoes, ham, etc)? Or what they eat when they eat when they don't eat eggs?
You mean ultra processed food like the white bread, fried potatoes, and juice?
Salt, butter, and ham aren't the enemies.
Very balanced review. As always, moderation seems to be the key. No need to avoid eggs, but it doesn't make sense to eat half a dozen before breakfast either. 😊
What about half a dozen for breakfast
That's fine 🫢
Worked for Rocky - -'Ey, yo! I prefer them cooked, though.
@@michaelpeters364 Raw eggs taste better
@@felixbonneau1834raw egg whites also inhibit biotin absorption, raw egg yolks are totally fine tho
I eat 3-4 per day and have for many years. At 61, I’m low carb/real food, healthy metabolic markers, athletic, and run circles around the grandkids.
I’m not even remotely concerned 😁
I really enjoyed the detail of this.
Thanks - I love telling stories through data. I think I can do a better job, but it turned out pretty nicely, regardless.
I eat 4 eggs per morning every single day
I used to do something similar, now I can't eat them at all, be warned.
@@MichaelGGarry did you become allergic?
@@MichaelGGarry that makes no sense. Why cant you?
So?
@@MichaelGGarry Ooooo scary eggs 😱
thank you for the balanced take on it, it would be great if in addition to plain correlation (controlling for variables) some causal inference would be brought into discussion. once again thank you for considering ("ignoring" the irrelevant comments, mine inclusive when it adds to the noise)
would love to hear a breakdown on L-citrulline.
I've been swallowing eggs and I feel okay most of the time
Like a snake?
I happen to be an honorary member of the nut council and I concur someone did fund a study or two about eggs.
Good stuff as always. Had heart blockage in 2004 so tried to keep up with this kind of thing. Needless to say it's been a big frustrating at times. Back then it was all about avoiding fat. Nothing on avoiding sugar (or whatnot). I have a hard boiled egg almost every morning and that's been going on for a decade. It doesn't appear to be making things worse as I have yearly stress test (though the value of that is coming into question). I'm going to side with 'positives outweight risks'...or at least neutral. I do have high LPa but diet has little effect on that.
High, or even low, Lp(a) is pretty much generally set by age 5 for life I believe, what are your ApoB levels comparatively?
@@the4theyeofra974 86..last time it was tested
_" Fish and eggs are the perfect food for humans. "_
~ Jack LaLanne 💪
This video was great and I’m glad I’m in a place where I’m not emotionally attached to the pro- or anti-egg crowd. As a young seemingly healthy and active person with high cholesterol, I’ve always been cautious about eggs but haven’t written them off outright. Anyways, I appreciate your ability to communicate the nuance of inconclusive information
Excellent channel.
I am on oatmeal and fish veggies diet from this channel.
Thanks 👍
Ps most baked goods have eggs in them also .
Let me be the first to say how eggselent today's episode was
Yes - all I can say is 'yes'.
(and, thank you)
@@Physionicdon't encourage that 😊
That was a good yolk.
That's not an eggageration.
@@anonymoussource7999 the chicks like it 🐤🐥
I wondered 1) if the effect is greater at lower levels of LDL. If youre at 70 it might go up easier than if youre at 150. 2) how do you know if youre a cholesterol hyper responder. My ldl did seem to go up 30 points or so when i ate more eggs. But maybe it was from other dietary changes as well.
Great video
If you eat loads of exogenous cholesterol, your LDL will already be very high, adding more eggs on top of that won’t cause a linear rise.. it will be a small increase, that is because there is a parabolic curve. If you are zero exogenous cholesterol for example a plant based diet, and then decided to eat 5 eggs per day, you would see a dramatic rise in cholesterol. The damage to the heart is done when you have constant elevated levels of LDL that oxidise in the bloodstream and cause atherosclerosis. LDL is the only critical risk factor for atherosclerosis. Other risk factors such as smoking damage endothelial cells which make it easier for ldl particles to stick. Macrophages infiltrate into the arterial wall and uptake excessive ldl lipids, leading to the formation of foam cells which explode and the cycle continues.. it then calcifies which is the plaque formation.
Great video as always. Appreciate sharing all your work and your honesty!! This channel will be one of the most busy ones in the future 😁 I'm wondering though what all those food studies are really worth? While watching the video, I only kept asking myself, how are the eggs eaten/prepared in most households? And What do people with let's say higher egg consumption mostly eat beside the eggs? Like e.g. do the Europeans eat them with fried ham and half burnt toast on the side? 😅And/Or do the Asian's rather just boil their eggs and hence the eggs might have less altered or oxidised fats? Which is probably not the case, just some random thoughts. Too many factors seem to always play a role in those studies. 🧐 Anyway...love your content! 🤘🙃
Great, thanks a lot!
An apropos video for my morning, as I just sat down to watch a video with my three egg breakfast! And I'm pairing it with my temperature perfect coffee from my "joeveo" mug. Thanks Dad!! 🥚🥚🥚☕😋
You're very special.
As with all animal products, the diet of the animal is important. Grass fed (vs. grain fed - usually grains with high pesticide & herbicide levels) will have a different nutrient profile as well as a lower burden of chemical residues. Grains are high in fatty acids that promote inflammation while grasses and forbes provide anti-inflammatory fatty acids. Big difference!
Could you collect all the data you've reviewed so far and make some kind of ultimate health guide?
I am 92 years old and I have been eating eggs my entire life along with free range bacon and I am still alive and kicking.
Congratulations I know smokers who are 80 and still kicking, doesn’t mean smoking and eggs don’t contribute to atherosclerosis
That's a nice anecdote. Wish you great health!
@@Lozwave - Those who smoke and live a long life eat eggs ! 🥚👌
How many bypasses have you had?
Until i meet you in person, i will call this BS
This is a very timely video for me. I'm very healthy except for high LDL and ApoB results, so have started Lipitor to control cholesterol levels. This all started at the end of February.
My typical breakfast was two eggs per day, which I tried to restrict. So, I've been debating if I should stop eating eggs, and these results do give some interesting things to think about. I think I won't completely stop eggs, since I know they have other benefits, but will at the same time keep a close eye on my LDL-C levels in blood tests which I plan on getting about every 6 months.
After doing a meta-analysis of more than 36 studies, I found your channel is one of the best we should follow.
And you are one of the best, most intelligent and most ISTJ medical-health-nutricional RUclipsrs.
However, as always, there is one caveat: you don't like (and might delete?) summarizer for your videos.
Yes, please no summaries - they hurt the channel.
Thank you for the hard work on your meta-analysis. :)
@@Physionic Is there any meta-analysis showing that summaries hurt the channel?
Or is it just your educated guess?
Your videos have no timestamp, because you think it hurts the channel?
@@YuanYuLiaoit seems pretty common sense that if people get a summary then many just won’t watch the video. So all of his work would be wasted
@@marshallsaltzman9924 Please be careful with "common sense":
Pseudo Dr. Berg and Pseudo Dr. Ekberg allow summary in their videos, both have millions of subscribers and views.
Dr. Huberman too.
Nevertheless, this is NOT the "proof" that summary help the channel.
I will do a meta-analysis to find out.😃
Clearly the answer here is yes. Your risk simply goes up or down depending on what the rest of your diet looks like.
A low dietary saturated fat and dietary cholesterol diet is simply the most protective and it's not even close.
I wonder if egg preparation matters, such as frying eggs in seed oil vs animal fat vs a healthier oil like evoo or avocado or no oil at all such as hard boiling.
Certainly a possibility
Yikes I typically eat two large or extra large eggs a day...14 eggs a week. I'm 78...maybe the end is near.
Interesting but my concern is the possible increase in prostate cancer associated with egg consumption. A video on that would be enlightening.
Any thoughts on studies that link egg consumption and prostate cancer?
Not sure about heart disease, but they can cause some massive allergies, even more severe than dairy.
but that is in People, Who are allergic. there are other foods that also cause allergic reactions in People, Who are allergic to certain compounds contained in them. or do You mean that a normally tolerated food can cause allergy in an otherwise non-allergic Person? regards. ps. why on Earth do You call Yourself "pazuzu"? I dare You, and Anybody reading this, to check out the case of pazuzu algarad-there are a few documentaries about the guy, You will be beyond disgusted having found out what da dude did in his house...
Can you make a video about Peptides E4 to treat fibrosis? There is also an article on the Internet that says that 20% of published research is false. What do you think about that? Thank you
Would like to see you review the Sydney heart diet study. Someone dug the data up.
Is this for cooking eggs with oils or every form of consumption like boiling or cooking with water?
Thanks for the video. Are the studies used in the meta-analysis double blind experiments or "just" observational studies? In the latter case I would take it with a pinch of salt (just as I take my 5 eggs a day, so it would be nice if I could downplay the risk).
Cheers!
I would be interested to know, in a general population, if greater egg consumption is tied to greater overall consumption. I believe almost every food would have a greater risk if it is measured on an additive basis as opposed to a substitutional one.
It all depends on what else you eat when not eating eggs. For example in my own case breakfast cereals send my glucose levels straight into the diabetic range whereas 3 eggs do not. So even if eggs are associated with increased cholesterol, the glucose spiking effect of breakfast cereals is probably much worse. Also everyone responds differently, as well as differently with age.
Most people buy the cheapest eggs possible, I'm quite sure the balance switches to something more positive if we consider free range eggs, and even more if we consider omega 3 eggs (hens fed with flaxseed oil)
Chicken eggs coming from China, chickens fed soybean garbage feed, or chickens raised on free ranging bugs. It matters!. That's the problem with these studies. They are lacking in way too much data!!
Your underpants you are wearing coming from China also
So please reference the studies comparing how the variables you list change things?
If you can't do that we will know you are merely expressing an opinion (i.e. a hate for anything from China which is a known horrible and wrong bias)
Are the Chinese shipping eggs to the US? Seems like refrigeration and shipping costs would be more than the retail cost.
@PardieDiem are you referencing eggs that come from farms that are in the US, and owned by Chinese/ follow common practices of Chinese animal husbandry? I don’t know enough about the ways that people from different cultures raise animals to comment on your question… I just know that I really like eggs that come from pasture raised chickens that eat a lot of bugs! LOL! They seem to have the most orange & tastiest yolks!
@@sophiacromwell8017 Do a search on food safety concerns in foods from China. I'm not saying the USA doesn't have safety concerns either. I was just pointing out there are issues with quality and that could reflect on the quality of the eggs in reference to a scientific study. Plus that's a long way for eggs to travel to get to your grocery store.
How about the role of cholin in the eggs in acetylcholin? I fry my egg whites for taste and better protein absorption, and I eat my yolks raw to preserve the cholin. Tastes fine in many foods. However, I don't know how the body actually deals with the cholin from the yolks - wether it gets put to good or bad use.
Is there ever any distinction between backyard free range chicken eggs vs factory farmed eggs? The eggs look so different. It seems like this could be why a study in Asia didn't show the negative results like the studies in the US.
No, almost all eggs in Asia are factory farmed nowadays as well. I think the health differences between free range and factory farmed are likely to be miniscule (although ethically they're very different.) My guess as to why the effects are different is that the way eggs are prepared differently. Eggs are likely being consumed together with more saturated fats (bacon, butter, etc) in the West compared to Asia which might use it more for stir frys.
My understanding is ~40% of people will see a sharp increase in LDL from dietary cholesterol. Hard to know if you’re a “hyper responder” without checking your own numbers. I saw a big drop in LDL when I cut out eggs
Good one, still would like to know if high LDL or oxidized LDL are the cause of atherosclerosis or both are as bad as each other????
I eat upwards of 60 eggs a month & when I had a heart catheterization performed 2 years ago my coronary arteries were clear. You might ask why I had to undergo a heart catheterization. I had to have my aortic valve replaced due to endocarditis. Still eating about 2 eggs per day, and my current lipids are: Total Cholesterol=186, Triglycerides=46, HDL=62, LDL=115, VLDL=9.
could you please analyse dr robert lustig and his "it's the fructose" theory?
Lustig also claims that branched chain amino acids can (and do) promote fatty liver disease. I recently did a cursory Google Scholar search using such terms as 'branched chain', 'leucine', 'fatty liver', 'NAFLD' in various combinations, and the general thrust of the references that my search returned - at least based on the articles' titles - was that branched chain amino acids protected against fatty liver disease, or at least mitigated some of its associated abnormalities.
I am interested in the research being done in Japan; on natural teeth regrowth. what the science says?
The medium length answer is potentially
I wonder about the quality of the egg, does it make a real difference. Such as "Egglands" which boasts higher Omega 3s, or "Pasture Raised" eggs. I noticed in the recent news about eggs they encouraged higher quality eggs.
One important note here. If confidence interval contains "1" we can't get decisive conclusion because group is too heterogenous regardless if it is RCT or epidemiological study. Confidence interval is important because is it a c.i. which provides main statistical conclusion for general population. Single value of RR refers ONLY to a stydy sample and is exact. True value of RR for general population lies inside confidence interval. But You said it, so I'm writting it for recapitulation. The second note: In epidemiological studies RR anything less than 2 is considered as a statistical hum even if test gives statistical significance. All presented meta-analysies were epidemiological ones. We need RCT studies.... Eggs have high fraction of HDL cholesterol and they tend to rise HDL in humans as much as even up to 50-80% from baseline. But we know that single nutrient works in specific context of other nutrients. Eggs work well in context lower carbohydrate diets and low consumption of Omega-6 fatty acids (seed oils in general). Eating eggs on SAD diet (Standard American Diet - eat as much sugar, sweets, starches and seed oils as you can) is a bad choice from my perspective..... Good video otherwise.
UPDATE: 11/20/2023
Originally published 6/10/2023
Several published research articles on eggs and prostate cancer point to choline, a nutrient primarily in egg yolks, as a possible culprit in causing prostate cancer (PCa). A 2022 Cleveland Clinic study[i] found that, “Men with increased choline … had almost twice the risk of lethal prostate cancer as controls,” according to a medical news story. Choline is an important nutrient, but overdoing it by consuming egg yolks may increase PCa risk. According to the published paper, “Men who consumed 2.5 or more eggs per week had a 81% increased risk of lethal prostate cancer compared to men who consumed less than half an egg per week.”
Question. Shouldn't you separate egg consumption and diet? Eggs and a high carb diet will have a different effect verses eggs and a keto diet. Do you agree?
What about eating only egg whites? I’m 65 Years old & very healthy :-) Love your videos!
is there an info on omega 3:&:9 ratio in eggs (gassfeed, organic or in battery grown chicken) ? i guess thiss is important how good egs are
It is critical what the fatty acid profile of the eggs are. As in, what were the chickens fed. Corn and canola? Or grass, bugs, and the odd mouse? Very different result.
I am adding eggs into my diet…I was trying to avoid because I thought with my high cholesterol I wanted to stay away from all dairy…I bought macadamia nuts and oil too after one of your videos. I’m desperate to lose 20 ish lbs and lower my cholesterol. Hashi hypo post menopause sux.
If you have Hashimoto's you need to cut out all gluten, all grains and possibly dairy as well. I went Keto exactly 5 years ago (at the age of 53) and that fixed ALL my health problems. I recommend you take a look at the videos of Amy Berger (Keto and thyroid specialist), Dr. Eric Berg, Dr. Eric Westman, Dr. Peter Osborne.
Hm, not sure how you will decrease cholesterol by consuming food which increase choleterol?
@@ZmogusJaponija Silly question...
@@ZmogusJaponijaplease do not go keto if you are trying to lower your CDL. That guy who responded probably doesn't even believe that high CDL is harmful, when there is plenty of evidence that it is, including on this channel.
@@noah5291 too late. I was on low carb (little meat, but eggs 4 per day and diary and fish) for a ~5 year. It worked for a few years because I moved to keto from eating shit. But I ended up with LDL of 140, insulin resistance and brain inflamation (results of high saturated fat diet by the book). Luckily somehow I was able to break from keto/low carb bubble, got info about whole food plant based diet and it completely changed things for me.
Were any of these studies based upon food substitutions, i.e. substituting eggs for unhealthy foods, which would skew the results? Thanks.
Good question. No.
Almond vs Egg:
I think we need to remember that the egg wont crack so easily or fall apart when it's in hot water, aka a fight🤷♀️
In my opinion, this(like many other aspects) again comes back to fatty acids & mitochondrial haplogroups.
Which would also explain the difference in the results between Asian peoples vs European & American.
Another study found a high correlation between eggs and heart disease with a 95% confidence interval, but looking deeper in the study it didn’t measure the cholesterol but the strain on the participants; as they were asked to try to lay eggs….
Did the consumption of toast, butter and salt increase with every egg? If the studies controlled the daily calorie intake, then we need to know what the eggs were swapped with, fish or cake etc.
Thanks!
Quick question about how a meta-analysis of studies does actually help. If we do not look into the methodology of every single study, do we not run the risk of aggregating a lot of nonesensical studies? If you ask 1.000 hospital patients or 1.000 college students about their egg consumtion and then (ignoring all 1.000 their risk factors for their cardiological health) show some correlation, how does that make us any wiser?
Would be randomized in the studies but worth mentioning that there is a genetic mutation that makes a small minority of people hyperabsorbers of dietary cholesterol.
He's mentioned it in the video. regards.
And people with naturally low ldl may all hyper respond?
@@carinaekstrom1 Unlikely. A person would need the genetic mutation to absorb xenosterols. Those patients actually absorb a lot of phytostetols from plants, which is bad news.
A lot of people in the US use butter, which contains saturated fat, to cook eggs. High saturated fat consumption may be a factor in the difference from the Asian studies.
Good thought
Thank you.
Hello, please guide me, I eat about 5 small eggs daily so thats 35 per week and I workout 6 days a week for 2 hours every day. Should I stop eating eggs and consume whey protein and chicken for primary source of protein?? Should I get a blood test done?? Please.
I've seen videos that state how the eggs are cooked can have a big impact on their healthiness. Basically, cooking at high heat is bad. Something happens to the cholesterol at high temps. You should boil them in water. Don't fry them.
Eggs with bacon, or steak? Buttered toast? Anyway, if it raises LDL and some say in excess can be inflammatory, then have your eggs with avocado (anti-inflammatory and maybe increase HDL).
Asians tend to eat a lot of rice. Adding an egg to a rice meal may lower the glycemic index of that meal; done often may lower the A1C of the person.
I have been consuming 6 eggs/weekly for many years. Most of the time with bread and 2 at the time on weight lifting days. But the eggs I eat are very high in Vit.D3 and Omega3. You want eggs from chickens that have a great diet and are healthy themselves. The yolks should be almost a orange color. Very nutrient dense. Actually, I mainly take them for choline as a biohacker, not specificly for protein. As always, quality over quantity. Alot of protein is not a good thing, no matter how many health gurus try to convince yo otherwise.
colour is irrelevant, unless You get your eggs from a safe, high-quality source. colourants are added to chickens' feed that then give colour to egg-yolks. also, I wouldn't rely on any food for Vitamin-D. regards.
I eat one egg, banana or apple and some walnuts for breakfast. This seems about right in comparison to eating the traditional American breakfast of several eggs, bacon and toast every day.
I've always thought of focusing on a single food item a bit weird and likely results in useless analyses. It is the entire diet that matters, namely total saturated fat consumption.
So doesn't it all depend on what you are replacing with those eggs? And is it even possible to keep your ldl as low as 50-70 (with diet only) if you keep eating eggs?
Nope. If you are aiming at 50-70, this can be possible with mainly whole food plant based diet with little or no oil, but nuts and seeds. Both Dr. Greger and J. Fuhrman has more info and links to multiple studies. Ok, one egg per week maybe you can get away with.
What do you mean "with diet only", you cannot remove genetic factors from the equation.
@@pomberry3591 The majority of people don't have genetic difficulty keeping ldl low. It's mostly a dietary choice.
Would be good to test just egg yolks or whites
Here's a study to contemplate...how does increasing egg consumption impact the health of those with Type II on medication vs those not taking any.
Love the nuance in these videos. As ever - compared to what? Compared to breakfast meats, hell no it's much better! Compared to a tofu scramble sure, even if it's a tiny amount (LDL raising)
You mentioned tofu in carnivore/keto community comments. Brave soul :)))
Always compared against 0 egg consumption. Thanks!
@@ZmogusJaponijaactually there's plenty of vegans who watch Nick's videos, including myself. This doesn't seem to be a carnivore/keto channel, it seems like Nick is interested in the truth, I see commenters of all different stripes in here.
@@noah5291 Those vegans are pretty silent then :) Quickly looked through the comments here, seems majority here eats XX eggs per week and have an uncle who was eating 20 eggs per day and lived until 96 :)))
@@ZmogusJaponija that's because most people are omnivores, and most keto and carnivore people can't help but the write up a 3 sentence paragraph as soon as eggs, keto, or some other combo of words sets them off.
Frying up 4 eggs in a few minutes - thanks!
Well that is the problem of these random studies that the other factors for general health, lifestyle and diet is so different for people that so reliable studies are imposible to make just adding few eggs into the diet.
There should always be large amount of people (even better if everyone would be a clones from one human) and everybody should have same kind of health, diet and lifestyle.
Also it makes big difference are people having carb based "normal" diet/lifestyle or ketogenic.
For food in general is it mostly processed or whole foods made from scratch.
I wonder if the studies in these meta analyses were looking at particular age groups, etc. I've seen some such that looked at "university graduates" and found no association between egg consumption and cvd ... but then, we wouldn't expect much at younger ages. I know a meta analysis is said to be the gold standard for examining such questions, but I've seen too many with, essentially, sketchy studies included.
I’m 64, lifelong athlete, I take zero prescription drugs, lift weights, average 10,000 steps a day, do two HIIT workouts in the pool a week, use my Joeveo miracle travel coffee mug a few times a day, do a 72 hour water fast during the first week of every month, track my macros in My Fitness Pal and believe the chicken was created first before the egg! 🍳 My goal is to consume 4 eggs a day so I’m at 90 to 120 eggs per month. Organic brown eggs from Costco. My blood work is spot on and my general appearance and stature is better than many friends of mine 15 to 20 years my junior. Since I’m very serious about being responsible for my own healthcare I dropped my Health Insurance at age 50 and have saved a lot of money 🤑 and have certainly been healthier for it!
Eggs are a multivitamin.
The only food which is even more nutrient-dense than eggs is liver.
And choline is an extremely important nutrient, especially for the liver. I had NAFLD for 10 years, I was told that it was "irreversible" 🤣 I reversed it within the first year on Keto!!!
shellfish is more nutrient-dense than eggs, no? also other organ-meats, not only liver. regards.
I bet you lost weight.
@@wolfrahmphosphoros5808 Shellfish is highly nutrient dense but has no choline, as far as I know.
And methinks other organs are somewhat less nutritious than liver.
But eating nose-to-tail is always a good idea.
@@carinaekstrom1 No. I was not overweight. I was TOFI. A lot of people with health problems are not overweight.
@@aurapopescu1875 What is TOFI?
So, two key takeaways. Are these correct?
1) eggs can be good for you if you're healthy
2) an almond would win a fight against an egg
I think that's fair to say... :)
No. The key takeaway is that it's all full of confounders and a relative risk ratio between 0.5 - 2.0 is not likely to even be real.
Almond would win in accumulating oxalates😂
@@powerguiller Eggzactly!
@@powerguillerbetter getting kidney stones than dying of prostate cancer 😅
The lack of randomized double-blind placebo-controlled trials in your analysis will make me feel confident in continuing to eat my 3-4 daily eggs. Not to mention my grandpa of 90 years that's been eating more eggs than this his entire life.
Thank you for your egg analysis. You nailed it...definitely a confusing topic.
Now, can we talk you into diving into Alzheimer's? Specifically the use of Sildenafil in reducing risk by 60%.
Would love to hear your analysis before forming my own opinion. Thank you!
Every single food or nutrition must be evaluated in the context of the metabolic state of the body that is consuming it. low vs high insulin enviroment. The same food has a very specific effect on your system. We need much more nuance and contextual perspective to come to more robust statements about what is "good" and what is "bad". A food in condition A with amount B under the metabolic condition C will have effect D within this uncertainty interval E.
In the US, people who eat more eggs tend to eat more overall. Did the studies take BMI into account? This could explain the Asian differences as they have lower BMI.
Are you current on cholesterol studies, many doctors are saying low cholesterol increases health risks. Is cholesterol like the low fat studies in the past?