why did everything change? before a male and female idol could hug and things would be fine and now they can't even be seen together without having a scandal
crystaldiamond920 i think bcs of immature fans. youtube, ig, twitter were supposed to be 13+ or even 17+. but nowdays i think kids are already had them. so yeah i think its because of immature fans, the kiddos
I used to be a huge Minstal fan during the first 3 years of f(x) aka 2009-2011. It's because Krystal was always paired with Minho in MVs, variety shows and SM Concerts. And they were super close. But then on 2012, SM paired Minho & Sulli in TTBY & people started shipping them. Then Taemin & Krystal started having more moments too so TaeStal ship overtakes MinStal ship. Then after that on 2013, The Heirs happen and Minhyuk/Krystal ship sails then on 2014 Myungsoo/Krystal then 2016 KaiStal etc. Along the way I just forgot about MinStal ship but then i come across this video again while randomly watching Kpop videos. It feel so nolgastic watching it now. I can't believe this was more than 9 years ago! Wow. So many things have change since then. It just seems like yesterday. Time move so fast. It's hard to keep up sometimes. We are all older now.
I love Krystal's high jumping skills. I almost drop my jaw when I saw her like that with Minho . I ship them both but I ship TaeStal more . Haha Taemin & Krystal
I had Taeyeon's name in mind because she sang the song in this video so when i read TaeStal i was like " what Taeyeon and krystal ??...oh... Oh ! Taemin !! How could i forget Taeminie. THE TaemAn!! XDDD "
lazy mofo this is so hard for me to say but Minho and Kristal look cute together ㅠㅠ (than my friend-she isn't kpoper-asked "isn't that your husband...Minho right? aren't u jelous?" i was like you aren't helping me ㅠㅠ
lazy mofo this is so hard for me to say but Minho and Kristal look cute together ㅠㅠ (than my friend-she isn't kpoper-asked "isn't that your husband...Minho right? aren't u jelous?" i was like you aren't helping me ㅠㅠ
Krystal's high jump is so perfect. This is one of the reason why I became a fan of her. I remember when I saw this, I didn't expect her to be that good I mean for an idol what do you expect? but damn she's good even her competitors think it's not her first time and she practiced but nah baby was born naturally good at sports
The 2 of them are really amazing! Their high jump is just wow! I miss this era of k-pop. This is what happens when 2 competitive individuals team up. 😊👏
+agung fullmagic maybe Krystal can cameo in Minho's drama its first time. kekekeke! I really want to see them again together this year. all of their vids are 2009 and the last is the gda 2014.
Why its just appears in my recommendation? And here i am watching again (Jan-2019) after years ago. Miss MinStal, Miss Krystal, Miss the old golden 2nd Generation💗
Holy s this video was from 2011 whut 5 years has passed by, but here i am, watching this with wide smile , having a thought like, Aahh back then i used to ship fx with shinee and minstal feels was so strong back then but i know Krystal's doing fine with Kai now , cuz i ship Kaistal too!
after watching LGDT2 episodes where krystal was featured, 2011 idol star athletics championship and king of idols, i must say that there's something going on between minho and krystal. There is big difference how minho treated krystal and jung ah when he was paired for a couples high jump in DT. With krystal, he clasp his hand withe hers after a high five and even hugged krystal while with jung ah it's just a plain high five.
Minstal does exist in everywhere :D Do you remember guys when king of idol before krystal came minho chosen the other girl but when krystal there he always choose krystal as his partner. how cute uri minstal :333
first kim myungsoo/L, then taemin, then hyun- (i can't remember the name but he's from CNblue) and now minho? idk anymore.. lol she is too SHIPPABLE >w
and I u can ship her with alot of exo members sehun kai suho lay chanyoel and everybody. I think because she is pretty inside out and people know that she is a good girl. She doesn't act cute all the time but she had it in her and she has a killer body and she is nice and sweet. she is not ur usual girl and I think that is why alot of people admire her.
The LGDT staff might have an idea about what's going on between the 2 of them coz in ep 32, every time krystal jumps, the cameraman focused and captured minho's reaction.
I was hoping them to be dating bcause they when to variety show together both active sport both strong and comfortable so many skinship. but sadly and it was surprise it kaistal but I think for minho krystal is like a sister to him.
Whoever it' is sulli or Krystal, that's minho choice.... But I think minho always warm, kind and romance with sulli. However..as long as they are happy.. We r happy too...
I am low-key waiting for some of these Kpop artists to get older so they can date, heck even marry without fearing that their careers will get ruined because of crazy jealous fans. Because some of these ships must sail period
These era of kpop bands will never be replace. I miss 2011,2012,2013 era's 😭
why did everything change? before a male and female idol could hug and things would be fine and now they can't even be seen together without having a scandal
One of the best era of K-pop 😍
crystaldiamond920 i think bcs of immature fans. youtube, ig, twitter were supposed to be 13+ or even 17+. but nowdays i think kids are already had them. so yeah i think its because of immature fans, the kiddos
Halfblood Princess agreeee. when minstal...
I always think that SHINee members treats Krystal as their sister 😬
Krystal is natural beauty btw 😍
What was this variety show?
@@pamelahuntress let's go dream team
how much I love this era's of kpop.. 😭😭... fshinee hwaiting
I used to be a huge Minstal fan during the first 3 years of f(x) aka 2009-2011. It's because Krystal was always paired with Minho in MVs, variety shows and SM Concerts. And they were super close. But then on 2012, SM paired Minho & Sulli in TTBY & people started shipping them. Then Taemin & Krystal started having more moments too so TaeStal ship overtakes MinStal ship. Then after that on 2013, The Heirs happen and Minhyuk/Krystal ship sails then on 2014 Myungsoo/Krystal then 2016 KaiStal etc.
Along the way I just forgot about MinStal ship but then i come across this video again while randomly watching Kpop videos. It feel so nolgastic watching it now. I can't believe this was more than 9 years ago! Wow. So many things have change since then. It just seems like yesterday. Time move so fast. It's hard to keep up sometimes. We are all older now.
Can I know the show name
@@bhumanaswethareddy5321 Dream Team
Krystal really good in math and athletic. Cute and Smart.. Perfect.
I love Krystal's high jumping skills. I almost drop my jaw when I saw her like that with Minho . I ship them both but I ship TaeStal more . Haha Taemin & Krystal
I had Taeyeon's name in mind because she sang the song in this video so when i read TaeStal i was like " what Taeyeon and krystal ??...oh... Oh ! Taemin !! How could i forget Taeminie. THE TaemAn!! XDDD "
haha lol
lazy mofo this is so hard for me to say but Minho and Kristal look cute together ㅠㅠ
(than my friend-she isn't kpoper-asked "isn't that your husband...Minho right? aren't u jelous?" i was like you aren't helping me ㅠㅠ
lazy mofo this is so hard for me to say but Minho and Kristal look cute together ㅠㅠ
(than my friend-she isn't kpoper-asked "isn't that your husband...Minho right? aren't u jelous?" i was like you aren't helping me ㅠㅠ
Krystal's high jump is so perfect. This is one of the reason why I became a fan of her. I remember when I saw this, I didn't expect her to be that good I mean for an idol what do you expect? but damn she's good even her competitors think it's not her first time and she practiced but nah baby was born naturally good at sports
The 2 of them are really amazing! Their high jump is just wow! I miss this era of k-pop. This is what happens when 2 competitive individuals team up. 😊👏
Krystal is still took young here. but, they do really look close with Minho. I wish o could see more of them together in a show.
+kreet2x yeah in drama or film maybe next time :)
+agung fullmagic in we got married! or a kdrama. that would really be daebak!!!!
In WGM i think it's imposible because they're in same agency. But in kdrama it's more possible 😊😊😊
+agung fullmagic maybe Krystal can cameo in Minho's drama its first time. kekekeke! I really want to see them again together this year. all of their vids are 2009 and the last is the gda 2014.
me too ☺
Wouldn't be surprised if they dated back then
Why its just appears in my recommendation?
And here i am watching again (Jan-2019) after years ago.
Miss MinStal, Miss Krystal, Miss the old golden 2nd Generation💗
Jessica's look of concern when Krystal made the jump doe 😘😘😘
Minho's hair is so fab xD
Aww~ Look how he always wants skinship with her xD
+Demi1DVioletta〈3 That's what I noticed too. He's always trying to touch her or hold her hand or hug her. So cute!!
V Nguyen
Ik xD
He is a hugger
The old kpop is the best
Choiza (dynamic duo) : sulli is mine !!
Minho : haha i have krystal too !! Krystal is mine
MINSTAL IS JJANG !! Mianhae but minstal is my style
Holy s this video was from 2011 whut 5 years has passed by, but here i am, watching this with wide smile , having a thought like, Aahh back then i used to ship fx with shinee and minstal feels was so strong back then but i know Krystal's doing fine with Kai now , cuz i ship Kaistal too!
Same lol
Nadia Zulkifli 8
Nadia Zulkifli too bad they broke up ;-;
7 years now
What show was this?
after watching LGDT2 episodes where krystal was featured, 2011 idol star athletics championship and king of idols, i must say that there's something going on between minho and krystal. There is big difference how minho treated krystal and jung ah when he was paired for a couples high jump in DT. With krystal, he clasp his hand withe hers after a high five and even hugged krystal while with jung ah it's just a plain high five.
Minstal does exist in everywhere :D
Do you remember guys when king of idol before krystal came minho chosen the other girl but when krystal there he always choose krystal as his partner. how cute uri minstal :333
SWEET! MINHO IS A VERY PROUD BOYFRIEND, KEEPS HUGGING KRYSTAL WHENEVER THEY JUMPED.
minho looks like a proud boyfriend
Minho never loses
SM's forever visual couple
first kim myungsoo/L, then taemin, then hyun- (i can't remember the name but he's from CNblue) and now minho? idk anymore.. lol she is too SHIPPABLE >w
yeah thats why i ship them :)
and I u can ship her with alot of exo members sehun kai suho lay chanyoel and everybody. I think because she is pretty inside out and people know that she is a good girl. She doesn't act cute all the time but she had it in her and she has a killer body and she is nice and sweet. she is not ur usual girl and I think that is why alot of people admire her.
+300dma has it in her**
Who myungsoo?? Krystal already have ship with minho and taemin since 2009/2010 >
Park Myungsoo? LMAO
Minho: sakin ka dapat nahulog para nasalo kita
😂😂
I watched this years ago. Now still watching this year 2018.
I miss them a lot 😿😿
where do you watch?what ep Is this?I watch season 2 but only the recent one
Krystal knows how to dance Ring Ding Dong pretty well!!
When God pour talents and Minho and Krystal are wide awake.❤ That pretty faces are bonuses. ❤💯
Kim Hwang true
Krystal is sooo cute. Greetings from Switzerland-
any minstal stan in 2019?
I’m here with you 🙂
Me!!!
its been 6 years. i dont ship minstal but i love how great their teamwork is! and how lively and competitive krystal is, back then.
melanie atendido true...i miss her joining variety shows like this but variety shows nowadays aren't good anymore
what ep is this??
muling ibalik ang tamis ng kahapon,
still watching though it's already August 2016...
#MinStal
Bernadeth Tajonar OMG. You're a Filipino right??
Bernadeth Tajonar Woah! 😱 May kasama pala akong Pilipino dito 😀
Watching this in 2017! Minstal!! #kilig
hahaha 2018 july 15
Bernadeth Tajonar August 2018💜💚
I wonder if Minho and krystal still keep in contact...does anyone know if they do?
The LGDT staff might have an idea about what's going on between the 2 of them coz in ep 32, every time krystal jumps, the cameraman focused and captured minho's reaction.
2019?
Hello there
Hi!
Yo ✋
Hereee
2020. I still ship them!
I was hoping them to be dating bcause they when to variety show together both active sport both strong and comfortable so many skinship. but sadly and it was surprise it kaistal but I think for minho krystal is like a sister to him.
thank you for this! i've been searching this on all of the comments.
Still watching {2018} 🌸😂😍😍😍
I love minstal 😂
wow more hugs, and holding hands, if i didnt know they might be secretly dating
omg they are soo cute ;33 i love how they hug, holding hand ;;;
They just really look compatible together😭❤
She is with kai now but I miss her interactions with Minho and taemin
I prefer Taestal but these two are so cute together as well!
Yayyyy..minstal..love this couple so much...
It just means she's unexpectedly incredible at flips, d'oh..
what an incredible pair wewwwwwwwwwwww they were seriously friggin cool!!!
still ship them until now, 2020
2019 and their record remains unbreakable.
Missing this Era of Kpop 😭😭😭😭
I really miss this era:")
2021. Minstal: sweet and competitive. Taestal: aAaah, i just prefer this more. aegyooo.
shinee version boy and shinee version girl, the pervect combination 😘👍
love minstal
1st song: Like a star - Taeyeon ( 0:00 - 1:51 )
2nd sond: Because You Loved Me - Taeyeon & Seohyun ( 1:51 - end )
The thing Krystal and Kai (EXO) are dating now
So what? You do know this video is over 5 years old
Trinh is it already confirmed by SM?
Do you mean the dating thingy of kaistal?? yeapp SM confirmed it already ^_^ ..
Einjeru Mei jinjja? I never hear it tho...
Btw,tgaks for the information.
Kim Taeyeon yes, it was around april I guess? that it was confirmed that they are really dating .. you're welcome btw ^_^ ..
Чхве минхо мой самым лудшыи актер люблю его 😍😍😍😍😘😘😘💋💋💋💋💋💗💗💗💗💖💖💖💕💕💝💝💜💞💟💙💙💚💚❤❤❤👑👑💍💍💍💎💎
@giiiirlzzz I am also a fan of SNSD and you're right, when it comes to chemistry this pair, krsytal and minho has it, they are perfect.
aww....minho is so nice to his dongsaeng :) they're cute
Smiling while watching and it's 2018
Just Love their couple high jump sm 🤧💜
MinStal
it's weird to watch they dancing to ring ding dong but the background music was celine dion's because u loved me hahahaha
minyul, minsul, minstal. OMG I LOVE THEM SO MUCH!
like a star - taeyeon & the one
BEST VIDEO ON RUclips
Whoever it' is sulli or Krystal, that's minho choice.... But I think minho always warm, kind and romance with sulli. However..as long as they are happy.. We r happy too...
Waaahhh. How I wish MINSTAL forever.
มินตัลจะรู้ไหมว่าชิคก้ามองซะ 5555
นางหวงน้องตัลนะเออ 555555
2018 anyone? Seohyun & Taeyeon cover of Because You Loved Me in the background though 😍😍😍😍
I used to ship them but now shes dating kai its still cool cause they are so cute too
Minho is so cute with her... im a little jealous, but love MinStal! ♥
I am low-key waiting for some of these Kpop artists to get older so they can date, heck even marry without fearing that their careers will get ruined because of crazy jealous fans. Because some of these ships must sail period
They both look cuteeeee together
I love MinYul and MinStal...SM Family jjang!!
Wow I was never really into many pairings, this being one of them, but this made me totally love Minstal! Great job!
Like a star -Taeyeon ft The One
Because you loved me - Taeyeon and Seohyun (Cover) (Orgirinal by Celine Dion)
MY FIRST MINSTAL VIDEO
THE CHEMISTRY
I SEE IT
I SEE THE GOD DAMN CHEMISTRY
THEY ARE ADORABLE OMFG
i love it how you used Taeyeon's OST for this video😍
Jessica Parker whats song name?
Miss this era's of kpop 😢😢😢😢
크리스탈 대체 못하는게 머야?!!ㅋㅋ쵝오♡
Taeyeon & The One - Like A Star
What show is this? i really want to watch >.
LOVE MINSTAL
THEY ARE SOO CUTEE
yahhh where am i at that era? im really miss something precious
They Cute dolphins flying in the air love you krystal & minho
what show was this? and do you know where I could watch it? thanks :)
I love Krystal
My God! I Really Missed This! 😍😍😍
MINSTAL FOREVER.!!! so sweet... ♥
MinStal FIGHTING!! SARANGHAE!
Like A Star - Taeyeon ft. The One
Miss their old days..now they will never hv so much time for these kinda shows
Bring back this era!!
Krystal : Minho😍 *Yikkks*
Minho : (Blush) ❤
#MINSTAL
i love how jessica look at her sister
The way Minho look at Krystal❤
sibling goalssss
im still watching this!!! 2017
I love Krystal but I ship minsul