Singapore is expensive if one has to pay for housing rental and owns a car. Otherwise, it is affordable compared with many big cities in the western developed countries. My family of 3 spends less than $2000/mth.
old uncle said he alone need $2000 ,I think he everyday drinking beers and dance cha cha with young foreigner woman lol . Or unless he still got unsettle loan etc>
The Malay lady's estimate of her family expenses could go up from 5 to 6K to 7k per month within 2 minutes. That's the fastest inflation rate I have come across! 😂
Uncle in green T shirt. Pls give yourself a big pat on your own back for surviving in the most expensive city in the world for so long. Until now I’m still trying to figure out what is Singapore is a first world country and citizen living in a third world.
Just visited. I'd say that if one can only spend 3k for single and 7k for family, as far as life enjoyment goes, you are really not getting the best that this country offers, which all cost quite a lot.
@@UUtalkCan u make a video why single men don't get married but like to hang out at Geylang at night time.I noticed many men around there everywhere can be seen,what is the reason?
Wow...that elderly uncle's monthly expenses $2000!!!! My gosh!!! My is around $800, of which almost half is for cigarettes. I know, I should quit smoking
Reminds me of my A level years, almost everyone in my class either trying to get into faculty of medicine or getting scholarships as the only way to afford education in USA or UK.
@@shadowj3311Ok, you have earned your 50 cents for your post. Today, I just bought 3 packets of economic mixed veggie rice with only 1 veggie and 1 meat for each packet and it costs $11.20. Inflation is real and and no matter how one plan and budget his spending will NEVER be able to beat inflation.
@@liangmincnif, you can buy houses in Malaysia & yet you're not Malaysian. Afford, to buy 250m squares & renovated 1 million plus plus Singapore dollars why's you still want to come to Singapore to working & living made no sense?
Expensive?? GST increased?? Just visit any restaurant, even on a weekday, not only full house but also has to Q up. I've seen a family of 4, eating at a hawker ctr. 4 x soft drinks + 4 different meals. Why not bring own plain water, which not only save $$ also healthier. Sure money not enough the way people spend $$. Kids after school meal, pepper lunch or Macdonald + bubble tea. Things are more expensive now and it affects the whole world, not just Sg.
wah, that uncle in green polo shirt, a bit exaggerated that for him alone every month spend 2k, but if your HDB flat is fully paid, and most of the time you cook your meal, monthly expenses should be less than 1k (including utilities, mobile subscription, take public transport).
Important eat nomer . buy cheaper. live simple . Stay safety . Don't worry . still can alive 😊 but why grovmemt don't control it . say Singapore bad . they don't love ❤️ Singapore
At least Spore dont hv slump area...and govt did help us a lot...pls be thankful..and one cup of coffee and tea in neighbourhood area is just 1.30 to 1.80...
He talk abt medical is real truth .. how to spend at least $30 and above cash even using subsidiary cards ? And those cards still need to pray for blue Chas .. if other colour totally dont help alot ...is not fair to me . For low income or average income .. stay in HDB . All should be give more benefits. Just one finger on the systems gov should know how much per family earn ... and those children earning more but not staying with family should not be included for subsidiary system ... i have many old age friends that not working and only depends on few hundred to survive every month but didnt get help from gov then some have cos her daughter earning 6k ... is not fair to ppl like him ..
@@Humorousguy64 you don't know there is a 5 billion medic fund set up by the government for all low income Singaporean? If people don't know and just blame the government? i myself already benefit from after apply the medic find zero cost for all medical fee. Just apply through any MSW office in any hospital.
the girl interviewed from 2.44 crap la.. GST 9% also good. This month give GST voucher, then how about next month, month after? If every month OK la, she just simply see current and don't see long term 🙄
One needs to increase his earning capacity. There is no point in scrimping the last dimes while the cost of living skyrockets year after year. It is like trying to bail out water from a sinking ship with a bucket.
The old man had the best summary. In name is first world country but citizens living in third world. Agree with the old man. In Singapore..cannot fall sick. Once fall sick..your wallet will burn big time. "Good news" to the 70% voters... 2025 gst may increase to 10%.
@1.09 Uncle said he needed 2ksgd per month... Uncle must say how n what he spent on? Cigarette and beer are highly taxed to protect health- so Uncle ? If sick, Uncle can go polyclinic
Not all uncles are so pessimistic like him. Perhaps he was one of those who didn’t do so well when young and had to struggle to meet ends meet. Anyway, he is not totally wrong as cost of living is escalating world wide, Singapore can never escape this fate. No matter how we must weather through the storm.
Those clinic charges us at least $30 csh after using our whatever subsidiary cards but clinics claimed from government if not wrong at least double ...what system is that ? Gov helping rich doctor to become richer? And dental is worst ..pulling out a teeth at least $60 cash ok . And they claimed more from gov i believe . Means those cards for subsidiary is like a game
As we aged, the money goes to hospital back to Govt. Such business projection good for them. Since when the money was for us in CPF. I was confused and disgusted.
Where did you get the statistics most Singaporeans are living in poverty? Don't just plug your figures from thin air. You may be living in poverty but have you ever wonder why you were different from others? A word of advice, get educated to begin with and understand there is no free lunch in this world. You have to work for it just like every other hard working Singaporeans.
@AleksiIvanov-kz5yb Oic, I didn't know you belonged to the 10 percentile circle. Hmmm, does "intelligent " people like you like to plug numbers out of thin air? You can't even answer where you derive your source from pertaining to your claim that "most" you emphasize "most" of Singaporeans are living in poverty. Indeed, mediocrity knows no boundary in your "intelligent " circle of life.
@AleksiIvanov-kz5yb I did not know you belonged to the 10 percentile club. Indeed, mediocity knows no boudary. You can just plug numbers from thin air that is so intelligent. Btw, my previous reply to your comment was deleted. Wonder who did it. I will nake sure to save a copy of this.
@@johnchua9387 Who the fu k did this except yourself. Apparently, we are coming from a different perspective with a different expectation. Mediocre people have a lower expectation as they cannot visualize the obvious behind the scene.
In Hong Kong if you go to public hospital A&E is hk$100, a day, including everything (for ppl with hkid), although waiting time could be very long 😂, still affordable
If anyone want to know the reason as to why Singapore reached such a stage, why not read these two books: "Never on Bended Knees" and "It Starts with a Dream"?
really that old man need 2k? 1 meal $5, 3 meal a day $450. assuming he rent a room at $600, where did he spend the rest? medical $4 in polyclinic, why must c private n pay $50? he spend on cigarettes, alcohol or 4d? thats not basic need. fyi govt has rental flats for the really poor ie can't buy a flat @$123 a month
第二位老伯讲得太有趣了，高见。
真的有趣 😄
我是吉隆坡人，跟新加坡老板打工。公司給新币，车子与住宿在柔佛分公司办公。
我感恩新加坡老板，因为他的雇用与強大的新币，我得在马来西亚拥有超过五套房產。🙏
哇， 5套！
哇 🤩
羡慕。😂
老板又不是做慈善的，应该是你值得这价钱
@@vlhee5782 你懂的感恩飲水思源可见你人品好你的付出有回报祝你幸福也庆幸你遇到好老板不像有些人来这里工作说什么超时看脸色工作厌三道世但他也因为在这里工作而擁有两间洋房但是酸葡萄说这里工作苦😄
总结人口越密集生活压力越大，活动空间也比较少。所以要有经济基础在那里生活都写意。
我家附近的几间私人诊所的诊费都不超过$30。只有一间私人连锁诊所比较贵，最少$50起。便宜的要排长龙，贵的不需等太久。邻里的 咖啡$1·30，starbuck 最少$5还是很多人买。 贵与不贵是个人选择。
也是
可以说你家附近那几间诊所在那吗？我家宏茂桥的私人诊所看个尿道发炎都收$64了
同意❤
@@fkloh3289 Tay Clinic 117 Bedok Reservoir Rd, #01-62 Block 117, Singapore 470117
很客观的心
没有天灾的国家；治安安全。
新加坡🇸🇬 好的地方。
For work,career,business,Yes Singapore is the place but for Retirement,go stay in Malaysia
Good choice
Malaysia also need to find the right place…. Thailand better
Batam is better than Malaysia and Thailand.
Yang di interview semuanya bukan asal usul atau asli atau bumiputra 🇸🇬
Yang di interview semuanya bukan asal usul atau asli atau bumiputra 🇸🇬
Malaysia government hospital sibeh good, Rm1 to see doctor already!!! Some clinic dun need to wait more than 1hr.
Please don' come to Malaysia if you only wants to come here and enjoy without cotributing.
Only the citizen can enjoy this benefit dude!
每次都高声说,一块钱！！！
大佬啊！马来西亚的薪金如此低，政府敢收昂贵的医疗费用吗？
他们的政府在国际上说,马来西亚不是先进国。所以在国际医药条约拿的药都非常便宜。明白吗？
不要再喊，一块钱！
Singapore is expensive if one has to pay for housing rental and owns a car. Otherwise, it is affordable compared with many big cities in the western developed countries. My family of 3 spends less than $2000/mth.
old uncle said he alone need $2000 ,I think he everyday drinking beers and dance cha cha with young foreigner woman lol . Or unless he still got unsettle loan etc>
@@bensonnlp go geylang si bo
The Malay lady's estimate of her family expenses could go up from 5 to 6K to 7k per month within 2 minutes. That's the fastest inflation rate I have come across! 😂
-看那老亞叔，一定抽烟喝酒，什至赌錢，一直抱怨，活在福中不知福、不够用能活到今天，生话也要自己计划，仝样是老人，我舅舅只有65O元生活，他却活得很写意，还有錢存，还经常帶曾孙子买礼物零食，每次曾孙见到他，如见财神爺。
覺得新加坡去一次
就已經很足夠了
没有想再去的兴趣
我們全家去一次，連小朋友都覺得不願意再去了。
那邊不是旅遊熱門地點，我反而去馬來西亞玩比較多次。
星加坡没有煮飯
Uncle in green T shirt. Pls give yourself a big pat on your own back for surviving in the most expensive city in the world for so long. Until now I’m still trying to figure out what is Singapore is a first world country and citizen living in a third world.
Very stressed to retire in sg. Better to have retire plan in Malaysia.
Probably talking abt income inequality, wealth inequality
一分钱一分货。作为土生土长的新加坡人我从小懂这个社会是多么的现实，从小就努力也很感激这里的环境。政府也好，知道会比较幸苦但知道可以换来更安全的生活
❤
我們馬來西亞華人，羨慕和佩服新加坡從無到有，不分種族，大家一起把國家做起來，新加坡只會越來越進步。就像他們的國歌，majulah Singapore ❤
是马来西亚人就讲马来西亚人
不要说马来西亚华人
你这样说 那些中国人就说你是从中国移民过来马来西亚。
在中国眼里，因为你自称是马来西亚华人他们就认为你或者你父母是拿着中国护照申请做马来西亚公民就好像美国华人跟澳洲华人一样。
他们中国人认为= 华人就是中国人
就是拿着中国护照在外国生活
明白吗？ 同胞！
我已经被中国人问了几百次
你移民这里多少年？
你过年有没有回家乡就是中国？
@@andreakazyncski4518isi bangsa apa?
@楼上的网军
bangsa : cina ✓
kaum : cina ✓
puak : cina ✓
warga : malaysian ✓
nationality : Malaysia ✓
region : Malaysia ✓
没问题。
物极必反你有生之年必定有机会见证
@@路易斯尼歐很多人活在一無是處的國家，活在無能又贪污的政府的政策下水深火熱！比較一下你就應該感恩你活在新加坡！
Just visited. I'd say that if one can only spend 3k for single and 7k for family, as far as life enjoyment goes, you are really not getting the best that this country offers, which all cost quite a lot.
视频不错，敢讲真话。看背景是在居民区拍的，而不是像大多数up主那样专挑什么旅游点、休闲区之类的拍，甚至接受采访的4/5都是EP、PR之类而不是当地人。
是的呢😁
我也這樣覺得，多些聆聽新加坡人的聲音是很重要的
@@williamwxiang2979 有的声音並不確实，好像那讲英语的大叔说一个月开销$2000是
夸张了一点。
那也不是真实的。对于一个住组屋，不驾车的新加坡人来说。生活费成本根本不高。政府还有各种补贴。
@@vincentchia2489 我不觉得那位大叔说2000是夸张。 我来新加坡工作 ， 住这里吃这里 ， 没有什么消费，也不敢 吃一餐 50 快左右。有抽烟而已。一个月都要花费 1800 左右。 休息都是躲在家，根本没得消费。我低呈收入 一个月 2800. 给了家用 几乎没到月尾 一天都不能吃上 4 餐。所有我真的不懂你是怎么省。
Property price rise also contribute to huge inflation in food price and services.
我去做义工，有些老人一房式家门口挂了免费的打包饭盒。有些不只一盒，因为可能申请支援不同机构有重叠。 去探访的时候，他们都要分多余的美禄或咖啡粉给义工，说慈善机构和政府给很多，吃不完。 超市也有老人优惠，对弱势群组有很多的补贴。 uncle 可能没出过看看。 如果真有到外国看看，应该不会这样说了。
怨天尤人不努力当然会贫困。有多少新加坡人是富二代？大多都是努力上进，进修讨生活 做起来啊。现在的中年成功人士，家长很多都是kumpung养鸡养鸭出生的吧，哪不是努力从第三第二世界拼到第一。 新加坡能从第三到第一，uncle 有尽一份力吗？还是大家都积极向上往前走的时候，思想还在第三世界，活得像第三世界的人一样，一直觉得自己是第三世界的公民没想要试着逃离那？ 他的年龄应该更能看到新加坡的转变和进步吧。 身边的人一定有很多努力拼的啊。。。因为这50年都是靠大家拼出的。 难道到世界第一都不是新加坡人的功劳，完完全全靠外国人？一辈子自怨自哀当然会停留在第三世界。 据我所知,残疾人士都有福利和帮助，政府一直鼓励进修，还发钱给那些进修的人，希望能找到工作。智商如果正常，老实努力工作，不要乱花应该都过得OK。 即使是低智商的族群，若能独立，还是有企业帮助开餐厅支持弱势群体，养活自己。 所以。。。uncle 当初有去skillfuture 吗？ 有心要进步吗？新加坡竞争力强是因为上进。 要怨不会用电话上网什么的吗？要不要到中国看看人家马路边卖菜的农民都扫码了。而且10年前我去上海，马路上的乞丐也都挂着扫码号叫开车的捐钱啊。
@starshine Uncle 应该是埋怨您们的医药费及保险费贵，看上去他已经有60多岁。相信没有人要聘请50到60多岁的人。像我们这里马来西亚，45岁以上的人就不会被雇主聘请就算那个人拥有很多技能但医药保险费却是越老越高及一直涨价。这些医药保险费都是20多岁买的。😢顺道问您：“如果新加坡人一直进修后但还是没有找到合适的工作怎么办？还有那些为了照护家里的老人而辞职后就没有收入，改怎么办呢？谢谢。😊
@@visHan8 那是不是要求太高了？若进修对了，通常机构会配对。可以申请辅助，有family services 会接洽
@@starshine9836 他想過頭了
新加坡是很好的国家第一名
新加坡确实不错 👍
The living cost is stably expensive na.
Yes expensive
我一个住HDB 还在供一个月开消保水电费都不到一千。这里大有大花，小有小花。大马比起这里，更要谨慎花费。吃的尤其偏贵。当然赚新币去大马花就另当别论。
为你鼓掌👏
新加坡人很奇怪，一直说,用新币去马国化费很开心。情愿汗流浃背，排长龙花时间，把大把，大把钱往那个国家送，他们经济腾飞。看看新加坡的商店一间一间的倒必。爱国吗？
Especially service charge 10% + gst 9% = 19% This really expensive 😢
It is indeed!
我也是这样觉得，本身在一些地方食物就贵了再➕这些就更贵了，我想到➕➕➕那个就算了不吃了回家住个面煎粒蛋放两颗鱼丸又省了一餐
外地人看到这里很好。 但生活在这里的人天天叫苦。 你们所看到的不一定是真的，要自己体验才真正了解。切记
赞成，你看我好我看你好，真正来体验就能决定。
@@crystalpurple8877 不可否认这里的白衣团体是全世界第一高薪的一群， 但人们的生活却是完全相反的。 大家不会觉得不妥吗?
你來香港生活看看， 我教你什麼叫苦！
苦？现在的本地人的生活会苦？ 请你問問老年人才知道什么叫做苦
我在新加坡活的很好。 我最多也是中产阶级，跟大多新加坡人一样。说什么白痴话
Inflation is killing us gradually n life stressfully pass lo.. 5-6k for single can’t have much luxury either lo.
感觉单身人士56千薪水因该过得不错了还能存钱呢，你不可以整天越级消费那金山也没有办法吧
新加坡适合勤劳的人，也要看你从什么地方来，新加坡最适合蓝领和高端人才，中产家庭如果买不了组屋那真是日子没法过，新加坡本地解决贫富矛盾的主要手段也就是组屋
🇸🇬最不适合蓝领了好么，蓝领在澳洲、米国、欧洲都是跟白领一样高，甚至达到金领的工资，但在🇸🇬低到当地人根本不愿意去干，只能从越南、印度和孟加拉找人去做。以前也有很多中国、🇹🇭，甚至🇰🇷人做蓝领，现在越来越少了，🇹🇭和🇰🇷人近乎绝迹。
@@ManjuTiger 我是指真正的蓝领低薪群体，像是新加坡的印度和孟加拉人，去新加坡相比澳洲门槛要低很多的，国内也有很多做劳务输出的中介。澳洲算是蓝领高薪了，算是生活方式的选择吧
@@TheZiqi 他们在新加坡压根不算人。海湾国家和新加坡对外劳的使用标准简直是文明国家中最恶劣的。
现在的新加坡绝不适合蓝领，除非是那种还吃不饱饭的地方。如果在母国可以吃穿不愁了，跑去新加坡就是找死，普通中产去就是自虐。
就像视频里老爷爷说的：新加坡是第一世界的国家，但国民却生活在第三世界。
那里的生活比HK还惨。起码很多人可以白天在HK赚钱，晚上就回广东享受。记住是“享受”。
普通的新加坡人都有一间属于自己的房子呀。比起别的国家好太多了。
7:07 计划是很重要,but计划往往赶不上变化。不适合养老因为生活指数太高东西昂贵,人老了新加坡谢谢你。孩子留下继续发展,老人可以选择去它国颐养天年。这所以给一等教育目的
It is an interesting video.
Yes I think so 👍
High monthly living cost is mainly driven up by never ending rises in housing and health care costs.
Yes agree, thank you for your opinion! 🙏
Great video😊
Glad you enjoyed
@@UUtalkCan u make a video why single men don't get married but like to hang out at Geylang at night time.I noticed many men around there everywhere can be seen,what is the reason?
人各有志 Is Singapore Worth it ?
有人喜欢
有人不喜欢
生活成本太高 , 物价上涨 , 全世界目前都在涨涨涨价 ！。。。。。。没有【一技之长】者，还是【留在原地踏步】好 ！😁😁😁😁😁😁
谢谢
说的好，要如何规划人生是自己的问题不是国家和环境的问题，我们须要改变自己来适当环境而非要求环境改变来适应自己。
其实总结一下就可以很简单地知道什么情况，采访里面的每一个人都是地道的新加坡人，采访言谈中弥漫着艰辛，刚刚好过生活的气氛，大家自行感觉一下吧。
比早报的采访真实十倍以上
我们报道真实的人
我看到的都不是這樣的叻。有bias看到的也會不一樣。
我看過朋友夫妻都是高收入, 但是花很多錢在小孩, 加上超級愛面子所以.....很辛苦, 好多才藝要學, 小孩也不快樂, 壓抑
另一個朋友生病了也要排隊看醫生, 插著尿管等幾十天等手術空缺排出來
最貴最容易想到就是屋價, 車價和消費税. 😅😅😅😅😅😅
還有粗房和酒店價格. 😅😅😅😅😅😅
对于外地打工租房是贵。購买政府房是有津贴 60㱑老人家津贴䃼贴多 新加坡交通方便 有能力需用才买车 收消费税是为国家建设.
新加坡最贵的是医药费，屋子可以用公积金，车子不是必需品，所以再怎么没钱都要买一点保险，不然生一次病就够耗掉几年的储蓄
医药费确实很贵
How come no one talk about last year COE hit record high and how it cause huge inflation in food price and everything.
开一个小時車去馬來西亞消费便可以了
对呀 周末去进货买水 买蔬菜食物 所有的生活物质都可以 实在不行也可以淘宝from China
很多人都説新加坡物價高。我去過很多國家。物價一樣高。不衹新加坡。我仃所有貨物都是進口的。這樣價錢不算很高。
去过那么多国家的你如果还说你没钱就被骂了
因为政府把货币推高嘛
WAKE UP CALL
Would be good if you can interview some Singapore Buddhist Temples and Taoist temples on prayers and praying cultures :)
新加坡的水都向馬來西亞進口、所以水類很貴的、還有那麼小的地方、剛剛遇到中國人、任何代價都要出去、其實他們也怕房子被炒高、所以用60%印花稅、要阻止房價被炒、才不會像台灣的年輕人那樣、怨政府沒有讓年輕人、可以低價買到房子、所以想進辦法 平紋物價、我去過一次30年了、如果能在馬來西亞消費、可以賺新加坡的錢、那是最好的、它跟馬來西亞只有五公里、一個很高、一個很低
Wow...that elderly uncle's monthly expenses $2000!!!! My gosh!!! My is around $800, of which almost half is for cigarettes. I know, I should quit smoking
how u survive with 800 a month? That's crazy 🫡
Reminds me of my A level years, almost everyone in my class either trying to get into faculty of medicine or getting scholarships as the only way to afford education in USA or UK.
The interviewees didn't include housing costs I believe. Most own their HDB ?
Singapore good government .
Thank you for your opinion! 😊
Hahaha,uncle so cute!
Well said👍
No matter how,singapore is safe and clean 👍,
Yes I think so
我還是覺得新加坡比台灣好很多！很喜歡那裡！之後孩子上小學打算送過去唸書到高中再回澳洲！社會、交通安全至上！
謝謝你的觀點！👍
My only complain is extremely stressful place to work and stay.
High costs of living but salaries also very high.
High COE is a pain though
新加坡生活丰简随意 结婚不需彩礼 購政府房有津贴 老人家补贴多 出外安全交通便利 出国新币最好用 .
新币真的好用啊～
购房和津贴这种也是看你的收入阶层的，薪水超过一定的数额是不能买最便宜的政府组屋的，也不是每个群体都符合领取补贴的资格，所以当有人说新加坡房价高医疗费用高时，不要拿政府组屋和津贴来说事力证新加坡生活费不高。
@@tanqiyun4616呵呵。你真是个笑话。如果你收入很高了，还需要那点补贴吗？你收入很高了，还会在乎那点通胀和补贴？
@@tanqiyun4616你说得族群是什么族群，非新加坡人吗？还是高收入族群？说话动动脑
@Jack_Ren 在新加坡如果家庭收入高于新币7000是不能买政府组屋的，只能买价钱更高的其他房子，这是全新加坡人都知道的购屋限制。另外我说的是“群体”不是“族群”。你说高收入不会在乎通膨和补贴，那如果收入高不成低不就呢？有些人的收入水平让他领不到补贴，也购买不了价格低廉的政府组屋，但是他的收入要应付通膨和房价还是有些吃力的。现今社会过得比较辛苦的是薪水有点高但不算富裕，同时又不符合资格领取津贴的中产阶层，不仅新加坡如此，很多国家都是这样。
Good❤
Singapore is expensive. But I feel that if can plan for living cost and budget properly, it is still affordable to stay and live in Singapore 😊
Sounds good
Totally agree, some just like to complain for nothing, always blame others or government for their own fault.
Step into those who make noise then will understand okay? Not all that complaint means nothing ...
@@shadowj3311Ok, you have earned your 50 cents for your post. Today, I just bought 3 packets of economic mixed veggie rice with only 1 veggie and 1 meat for each packet and it costs $11.20. Inflation is real and and no matter how one plan and budget his spending will NEVER be able to beat inflation.
@@fkloh3289Really? Come to Tampines, 1 meat 2 veg $2.80. Your 1 neat 1 veg made of gold? What baloney is that.
my要办个演唱会都难，许多事情上固步自封，我看到的是my发展之路很难走，新币对马币只会越拉越悬殊。
新加坡cpf发放严格，反观my一个covid让人民拿钱后，有了一次，如今许多人都吵着要拿epf来用，现在看不到问题，多2/30年就会有社会问题了。
Now HDB flats need to sell 1 or 2M how to buy ?IlNot every Singapore here is earning 10K n above .
那是给有钱人买的。他们把自己的私人排屋、或独立洋房卖了,有上千万的钱，买间百万的屋子,算什么？那些望尘莫及的人，为什么去想百万房屋？去买政府的新屋不好吗？人会来一句,我不能等,要,马上要。。。
新加坡尽管物价比较高，但是政府对公民的福利补贴非常好，孩子上学，初中每天有7新币的午餐补助，小学3.5。 博物馆经常有免费的票。
知道知道！這點台灣學不上錢都貪污掉了😂
Pui💩💩💩💩💩💩💩👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼
外国人没门，把话说好。
那香港好些！年輕人現在還可以多天出外食飯旅遊
台湾贪污也很严重吗
BTO also very expensive now lor
不要放屁啦。白送你好啦。你看看中国大陆，台湾屋子多少钱？只是可笑
其实新加坡东西不会贵跟别的国家比，跟马来西亚比当然新加坡贵，跟一般国家比起来东西很便宜
在新加坡🈶安全的环境，但是牺牲了枯朽空间，很难受，都不爱回家，住的地方太小了。
笑死了。新加坡住的地方小。110使用面积的屋子。你说面积小，你中国国内的屋子有多大。呵呵
@@Jack_Ren 110平米，没有公摊也不算大啊，客厅很小，如果再三房，那房间小客厅也小。在新加坡租房子太贵了，之前租房子每个月将近人民币18000，没那么多钱。马来西亚买250平大平层，装修完才人民币500多万，不比新加坡性价比高啊。富豪不说了，如果是不工作的人，在马来西亚钱耐花。如果工作，那在新加坡更惨，赚的钱不能用，不然租了房子，每天吃外面，加上点娱乐活动那就不剩多少钱了，房租算大头。居住不推荐新加坡。总之亿万富豪哪里都随便，如果千万的人，新加坡可不是适合你的地方。
@@Jack_Ren 我现在在国内住的话多数回农村，更舒服，有地有院的，随便溜达。
@@Jack_Ren 如果你是新加坡人，那可能110你就觉得很大了，毕竟香港新加坡这些地方，人们已经习惯了住在狭小的空间里，寸土寸金要发展，总要牺牲居住空间的，有利有弊。
@@liangmincnif, you can buy houses in Malaysia & yet you're not Malaysian. Afford, to buy 250m squares & renovated 1 million plus plus Singapore dollars why's you still want to come to Singapore to working & living made no sense?
很多没有认知的留言，格局很小，没考虑到新加坡政府给的所有津贴和福利，更重要的是别拿新加坡和较落后的国家比，要比就比同等级的发达国家，同等级的发达国家没几个会比新加坡生活的轻松，基本上那些负面的受访者如那个穿绿衣的老人都是反社会主义者，只想到不好的地方没想到政府为人民做了什么？反社会主义者都是人生的失败者，他谈到的新加坡医疗费，政府提供了这么多津贴和福利自己不知道或者不会利用要怪谁？ 新加坡有一个五亿的医疗基金专为低收入者提供100% 免费医疗，不知道就问别人啊！去找议员或者义工他们就会给你详细的指示如何申请。
恭喜, 你发的贴子就是人民行动党欢迎的新移民的论述, 今天可以向你所属的人民行动党党书记领取五毛了
同意，說的有道理，
Pui哈巴狗🐕🐕🐕🐕👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼
他可能不是低收入者，新加坡complain 最多的人是那些月赚兩三千的人，不上不下的，是有点慘😅
@@steven88poo49 无论是不是低收入者，保健基金针对的是没能力支付医疗费的那一些人，而如果他是有钱人还投诉什么？重点是政府有照顾到有须要的人民，普通人2-3千收入那会惨？ 除非他收入2千要过收入一万的生活。
我是每天来回新马两地的工做人士。我知道的是，新加坡什么东西贵。打油-车的拥车证-carpark-还有一个就是补习。5000块一个月就可以养活一家人。在马国除了以上的东西便宜、什么都贵。吃喝买东西都贵新加坡很多这些东西可以说是每天都要的.5000块马币只可以养单身人士。
是，马来西亚本地成本是很贵
@@UUtalk聽起來新加玻比馬來西亞更適合一般人退休
是的。
新加坡人生活最有問題的是，老年人。因為他們年輕時薪水比較低,他們累積的CPF比較少.所以他們唯一能refinance的是, 大屋子換小屋子,提出現金來使用,這是比較可行的.
但這不是新加坡獨有的，基本上全世界的老人都有同樣的問題，因為愈活愈久，才發現savings不夠. 以前的退休制度,都是以壽命70不到規劃的,結果人類壽命迅速增加,活到90的比比皆是,saving就不夠了.
謝謝你的意見 😊
新加坡人平均工资每月新币$3000，中国人的平均工资人民币3000元（约等于新币$600）。在新加坡吃一顿KFC快餐约新币$10，在中国吃同样的KFC快餐要付人民币50元（约新币$10) 。新加坡人的$3000新币可以吃300顿KFC，中国人的3000人民币只能吃60顿KFC 。那里的物价贵一目了然。
炸鸡吃到吐🤮
新加坡中位數工資大慨在4500 左右，我身边的人工資在3000 到8000 之間。
@@steven88poo49 官媒说的你信？ 反正我不信。🇨🇳那边的官媒说🇨🇳人人工资1w人民币以上。
even88poo49 大多数在2千以下，16oo，1200。
人均收入大概在5600左右。收入中位数是4500左右。
今天早上母親人不舒服帶嘔吐，帶她去polyclinic，看醫生加拿止吐藥。藥$0.5，醫生門診費$8.10, government subsidy for pioneers(政府對先驅老人的補貼) 扣除 - $ 4.3. 免9%的GST.
最後需要付的價格是$4.3新幣。你認爲會貴嗎？
贵闷又热！😢
新加坡不热啊，你都没有去过真正热的地方，这里天气很好有风不闷
@@猪猪宝贝-m1c你是本地人习惯了而已，太闷热了好不好。
根本就不貴，吃的蔬菜水果超級市場比台灣的便宜好多
Expensive?? GST increased?? Just visit any restaurant, even on a weekday, not only full house but also has to Q up. I've seen a family of 4, eating at a hawker ctr. 4 x soft drinks + 4 different meals. Why not bring own plain water, which not only save $$ also healthier. Sure money not enough the way people spend $$. Kids after school meal, pepper lunch or Macdonald + bubble tea. Things are more expensive now and it affects the whole world, not just Sg.
我是土生土长的新加坡人 每个国家都有它的好坏 我个人比较喜欢马来西亚 泰国 寮国 越南
確實是 👍
你不喜欢自己的国家么？
@@meiLiu1227 没有所谓喜欢不喜欢 只是那种环境适合我 懂吗？我不喜欢周末人挤人 商场 公交 开车堵车 去哪里？ 新山？ 东海岸都是人潮 没有大自然 瀑布
@@abetterman1927 哈哈哈哈，明白了！
那些国家的东西真的便宜？便宜到你天天用？薪金又高？天真得可以。。。
这当然全世界都是一样，第一世界国家样样都好当然是开消较高，省省用是不错的，生在福中不知福
恭喜, 身在福中的你可以为刚发的贴子领取五毛
👍
让新加坡人去大陆看看啦 去看看就知道啦。新加坡的物价只是高一丢丢啊，3块4块吃叉烧 烧腊饭，有时间走点路还能吃到2块钱的饭，大陆想吃肉的快餐不也得20以上，如果上海 深圳 更贵。新加坡 相对于外地人就是住贵 其他都不贵，买只鸡10-15块，大陆买只鸡 也要50 60rmb，但是工资是大陆8-10倍，怎么总是说贵 想不通。住虽然贵 但是也看你个人选择，要省钱也有便宜的住，这也只是相对于非新加坡公民，如果是本地人 贷款还房贷 完全没压力的，贵贵贵 贵个鬼。新加坡就是条条框框的规定太多，外地人会非常不习惯，容易被罚款，还挺贵。但是相对于欧美来说晚进入文明社会100年，所以用条条框框来约束是明智之举，几十年过去 证明是对的，新加坡的文明程度 现在相当高。还说喝水贵的 只想说 免费的不喝你要去买 活该。
其实一直是免签呢 以前可以去大陆15天 现在可以去一个月，感受一下什么是真的贵。千万别去杭州西湖啊 吃个素面都要10块新币。
這能說這些抱怨的都是無能的一群人
最近我到过香港/澳门物价也不便宜，食物比新加坡还来得贵，我觉得越南泰国就比较便宜，马来西亚有些地方也便宜不多。
@@yanfookchurn6035 没错 泰国是真便宜 是我计划去退休的地方之一 另一个地方是西班牙
来新疆看看 一碗面带肉的就要三十五以上
Bravo
wah, that uncle in green polo shirt, a bit exaggerated that for him alone every month spend 2k, but if your HDB flat is fully paid, and most of the time you cook your meal, monthly expenses should be less than 1k (including utilities, mobile subscription, take public transport).
He properly needs long term medication
难道国外生活条件低过新加坡 ? 新加坡有它好的一面， 怎么大家没说呢 ? 政府有津贴医药教育住屋，国家安全人民生命有保障，公积金体制的完整 ，政府能干不贪污 . 生活成本高的同时， 也取决于自己要做出明智的生活习惯
是的，他们都只是片面的来评价新加坡
👏👍
Money no enough.
新加坡除了戶外很熱我無法接受外
其他我覺得都還好
新加坡真的很熱
Important eat nomer . buy cheaper. live simple . Stay safety . Don't worry . still can alive 😊 but why grovmemt don't control it . say Singapore bad . they don't love ❤️ Singapore
前面三位朋友怎么那么中肯呢？
That old man interviewd telling the truth ...1st world country but 3rd world living
活在第三世界的新加坡人天天埋怨，可是，花天酒地不会少，外食照叫出门照叫grab行李照样推着世界走🤨，在新加坡如果你还不懂的感恩还在说你活在第三世界，我只能说那是你自己的问题，政府不欠你！
@si👍👍👏👏ewlynnchua5573
At least Spore dont hv slump area...and govt did help us a lot...pls be thankful..and one cup of coffee and tea in neighbourhood area is just 1.30 to 1.80...
年轻人可以过来新加坡闯一闯。我老了，年轻人，你们加油😂
加油！
如果你是潮汕或福建人可以去，其它省份的人受不了那里的潮湿闷热的.
新加坡确实很热 🥵
Agree with the uncle wearing green shirt 🥵🥵🥵
Antiscoical mindset what to agree with with? Only failure in life has antiscoical mindset.
He talk abt medical is real truth .. how to spend at least $30 and above cash even using subsidiary cards ? And those cards still need to pray for blue Chas .. if other colour totally dont help alot ...is not fair to me . For low income or average income .. stay in HDB . All should be give more benefits. Just one finger on the systems gov should know how much per family earn ... and those children earning more but not staying with family should not be included for subsidiary system ... i have many old age friends that not working and only depends on few hundred to survive every month but didnt get help from gov then some have cos her daughter earning 6k ... is not fair to ppl like him ..
@@Humorousguy64 you don't know there is a 5 billion medic fund set up by the government for all low income Singaporean? If people don't know and just blame the government? i myself already benefit from after apply the medic find zero cost for all medical fee. Just apply through any MSW office in any hospital.
the girl interviewed from 2.44 crap la.. GST 9% also good. This month give GST voucher, then how about next month, month after? If every month OK la, she just simply see current and don't see long term 🙄
在新加坡坐過TEXI，老年人似乎很多牢騷？
怎樣的牢騷呢？🤔
One needs to increase his earning capacity. There is no point in scrimping the last dimes while the cost of living skyrockets year after year. It is like trying to bail out water from a sinking ship with a bucket.
uncle! 哇，你生活费一个月需要起码两千块？怎么用的？买马票？喝酒？抽烟？去新山玩？帮忙子女？？？？那是你个人问题啦！，讲的似乎生活在水深火热中，我年纪跟你差不多，平时没事做喜欢逛街吃喝买东西，周末跟老公上餐馆都不需用到一千块！典型的新加坡人！一概的只会投诉，但钱照样花，不懂的节制规划就怪自己，生活成本贵是全世界面对的问题，但有那国政府像新加坡政府一样在想方设法尽量的在帮助人民度过煎难时刻？最讨厌这种人！整天只会埋怨！
他一个老家伙每个月生活费要花新币2000元？有没有搞错？肯定抽烟喝酒买万字票，周末去马场铺草皮，晚上去芽笼但不买榴莲也不吃田鸡粥。
Uncle的两千块还不够，别忘了阿叔的年龄是有政府津贴，再多的钱去花天酒地也不够。😲
The old man had the best summary. In name is first world country but citizens living in third world.
Agree with the old man. In Singapore..cannot fall sick. Once fall sick..your wallet will burn big time.
"Good news" to the 70% voters... 2025 gst may increase to 10%.
@1.09 Uncle said he needed 2ksgd per month... Uncle must say how n what he spent on? Cigarette and beer are highly taxed to protect health- so Uncle ? If sick, Uncle can go polyclinic
If uncle buy toto /4D, buay beh (horse) cig, beer of course 2k not enough at 5-10K, what i meant 2K spend within your means is marginally enough 😎
Uncle $2k not enough...Geylang night suppers are expensive 🤭🤑
Not all uncles are so pessimistic like him. Perhaps he was one of those who didn’t do so well when young and had to struggle to meet ends meet.
Anyway, he is not totally wrong as cost of living is escalating world wide, Singapore can never escape this fate. No matter how we must weather through the storm.
He needs to spend in KTV to those china’s girls $500 per night lol
Those clinic charges us at least $30 csh after using our whatever subsidiary cards but clinics claimed from government if not wrong at least double ...what system is that ? Gov helping rich doctor to become richer? And dental is worst ..pulling out a teeth at least $60 cash ok . And they claimed more from gov i believe . Means those cards for subsidiary is like a game
Go to Msia to pull out ur rotten tooth. 😊 Survey first.
As we aged, the money goes to hospital back to Govt. Such business projection good for them. Since when the money was for us in CPF. I was confused and disgusted.
SG is a 1st World country but most of its citizens are living in poverty.
Where did you get the statistics most Singaporeans are living in poverty? Don't just plug your figures from thin air. You may be living in poverty but have you ever wonder why you were different from others? A word of advice, get educated to begin with and understand there is no free lunch in this world. You have to work for it just like every other hard working Singaporeans.
@@johnchua9387 It just shows how mediocre you are if you do not understand the essense of my content.
@AleksiIvanov-kz5yb Oic, I didn't know you belonged to the 10 percentile circle. Hmmm, does "intelligent " people like you like to plug numbers out of thin air? You can't even answer where you derive your source from pertaining to your claim that "most" you emphasize "most" of Singaporeans are living in poverty. Indeed, mediocrity knows no boundary in your "intelligent " circle of life.
@AleksiIvanov-kz5yb I did not know you belonged to the 10 percentile club. Indeed, mediocity knows no boudary. You can just plug numbers from thin air that is so intelligent. Btw, my previous reply to your comment was deleted. Wonder who did it. I will nake sure to save a copy of this.
@@johnchua9387 Who the fu k did this except yourself. Apparently, we are coming from a different perspective with a different expectation. Mediocre people have a lower expectation as they cannot visualize the obvious behind the scene.
新加坡的教育不错，但是要想进好的学校，需要很多补习，补习费也是很高
說的沒錯，凡事靠自己，一旦開𢿣，一切都順利，若是自己不爭気，就怪自己吧！有一部新加坡人，年輕時不做財務規劃，一到老了，還是怪這怪那，我只能說要怪自己。百物齐漲的是不單單是新加坡的問題，世界各地也是，幸虧的是基本上，多數人還是可以應付，我們要記得新加坡什麼天然資源都無，常常受國際、自然環境的影響，所謂牽一發而動全身，小巿民須時時的警惕，要未雨綢繆，才能处之泰然面對明天與將來。
这要看自己本身我们一家都读名校但是从来不去补习都是靠自已而且中学大学假期还教补习赚学费，中一到中四，四年都是全新加坡学校前十名优秀生大学只读一年半就畢业，成绩特优。这不是显耀，而是靠自己不要太宠孩子
在🇸🇬补习对于学生成绩影响真的很大，这样不是很好，因为会导致阶级流动的停滞。那些不怎么有钱的家庭根本负担不起补习费。
@@jessielaw3462 名校就已经是一个plus point了，如果你孩子够聪明又肯拼，那完全就可以直接碾压那些非名校+负担不起补习费的家庭子弟。
但很大压力，因为新加坡学校注重成绩！
No la, house or car you buy only one, going up all the time doesn’t effect you but only that one time.
新加坡賺錢，新加坡生活，新加坡其實並不貴，當然不要拿新幣換馬幣去哪裡花，那就當然哪裡比較便宜，
其實馬國人在馬國賺，馬國花，哪裡其實比較貴的
真心话👍
长年呆在国外的人“都并不喜欢新加坡！就係新加坡本地人也一样、曾經的香港、是很多人最愛的城市、就算现在我们一样愛香港！新加坡一座让人无法靠近的城市！
I love Singapore so much
来访问马来西亚就知道什么叫钱不够用了，工资和物资完全不成正比。
A&E visit, after subsidy, around $50 ---- Expensive?!!!! Try medical expenses in other countries
In Hong Kong if you go to public hospital A&E is hk$100, a day, including everything (for ppl with hkid), although waiting time could be very long 😂, still affordable
Singapore $50 for A&E which hospital you visit. Even KKH A&E cost $180.
If anyone want to know the reason as to why Singapore reached such a stage, why not read these two books: "Never on Bended Knees" and "It Starts with a Dream"?
哈哈哈，你推荐的这两本书很值得看
WAKE UP EXPENSIVE COSTLY GST HELP POOR RICH RICHER WHAT NEXT
吃便宜
住贵
工资 6000 很好过了
新加坡生活指数總香低,香港下午茶餐一杯凍o茶+件蛋牛治平均36元,在餐廳一個平民小菜也70-90港元
現在的香港是很貴的
香港的生活成本一直居高不下，但香港的收入水平比新加坡高出一大截，而且是亞洲最高。
@@Kevin-tk5ly香港的收入比新加坡高而且還是一大截、 來來來解釋一下什麼行業。 我在中港生活工作22年8個月 我怎麼不知道 ？ 你去過香港去過中國你了解香港 你了解中國嗎？
@@CrossbredmiMiyang
很簡單，這22年8個月你白活了。
是的香港KFC restaurant manager还比新加坡高
really that old man need 2k? 1 meal $5, 3 meal a day $450. assuming he rent a room at $600, where did he spend the rest? medical $4 in polyclinic, why must c private n pay $50? he spend on cigarettes, alcohol or 4d? thats not basic need. fyi govt has rental flats for the really poor ie can't buy a flat @$123 a month
住在城市的人们都很冷漠，虽然是dollar 的迷人状态，但是，还是很多人望梅止渴的，还是自已国家好吧！
Nothing so great abt SGP，没人情为。You can get the better experience in China & Malaysia too.
China and m,sia worst than sgp