Reaction: Nouman Ali Khan on Women's Leadership in Islam
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 авг 2024
- #haqiqatjou #noumanalikhan #alasna
To watch more in depth lectures and discussion, enroll at Alasna.org.
Daniel Haqiqatjou reacts to Nouman Ali Khan's message to Muslim women on leadership.
Fight anti-Muslim censorship and join: t.me/haqiqatjou
Support our work: muslimskeptic.com/contribute/
To watch more in depth lectures and discussion, enroll at www.alasna.org/
DH Uncensored Content: t.me/haqiqatjou
Support our work: muslimskeptic.com/contribute/
What fascinates me is that even if is a Muslim and has so much knowledge they will always be deficient in matters that are clear . U can’t have someone is is good in all matters
Are you doing the service of Islam and the work of spreading the Dawah to Tauhid this way? I honestly find that you’re a younger brother who either later in life regrets this foolish way or will double down on this type of RUclips take downs until it becomes no different than the antics of the Influencers
they want men in a traditional position, he has to pay and take responsebility and so on, women should modern at the same time, she can do what every she wants.
Respond to this if you're really so sincere & serious about your job.
Is mocking & being sarcastic while simply criticising necessary?
You're making your followers forget the 99% good the Imaams like Nouman Ali Khan do by just going on & on about their one mistake.
Be a little bit more mature & simply criticize from the next time instead of bringing the Twitter culture here
long overdue brother Daniel...what you do is unique as you expose where the cancer is..
I criticize some statements from Nouman Ali Khan in the latest reaction video, but I also acknowledge in the same video that I respect NAK for his Arabic instruction program and how he has inspired millions to learn Arabic in order to connect with the Quran. His program is innovative and I appreciate the ingenuity. This is a major service he has done for the Umma.
I also distinguish NAK from other Compassionate Imams in that he does not try to cash in on cheap political participation. He doesn't march with the rainbow flag, have iftar with the turban hijabis, or shake hands with head zionists, etc. He could easily do that in the same way that others do, but he doesn't. He does not betray the Umma in the way that others regularly do.
This appreciation does not prevent us from criticizing problematic statements NAK has made in his lectures and ideas he has promoted. Sadly, he has flirted with the ideas of certain reformists and modernists and injected them into an otherwise positive message. We need to push back on this.
As I always offer with those I criticize, I am happy to host NAK on this channel to give him the chance to defend his statements and/or clarify.
You should have a discussion with him moderated by someone neutral like Hamza Tzortis
I learn a lot from both of you brothers. I pray that Allah rewards you both immensely for your work. I do believe NAK could have answered that question a bit better Inshallah he'll take you on your offer and it would be amazing to see you both in conversation with each other.
You should reach out to him, that’ll be an interesting episode to look forward to.
In fact, I think NAK would probably take you up on it, I feel like he’s more humble than these other compassionate imams that we know of.
As a longtime follower of Brother Nouman, thanks Br. Daniel for being fair. No person is above criticism. It would be great to see you in direct conversation with some of those you pushed back against, as your influence grows they will find it harder and harder to ignore you.
Jazak Allahu Khairan katheeran may Allah swt reward you. Please also look at his comments on Homosexuality and request him to clarify - I respect Ustadh Nouman alot but the comments on Homosexuality are the most dangerous ideas spread amongst the youth. It's extremely nuanced and will need a project run by Muslim Skeptic. Please have a look at this for the sake of Allah. You don't have any contact details so I don't how to convey the message to you as to exactly what the problem is. Please look at the ayat of Lut as and how he explains them, it's almost microscopic and the ordinary layman or Iman even won't catch it. Only when you've studied post-modernist ideas would you be able to identify it.
I am the biggest fan of Ustad Nouman Ali Khan. But now I have to accept the truth. If someone's words do not align with the teachings of the Qur'an, then as Muslims, we should reject those things immediately. Whoever he is,
I love anyone for the sake of Allah, and I detest anyone. Ustad Nouman Ali Khan is also a human, so he can make mistakes, and hope he will correct himself. May Allah save us all. Amin.
I can't explain my love for you right now i know it's difficult to except truth
@@Neji.Hyuuga wrong
@@Neji.Hyuuga NAK giving example of the women close to the Prophet (saw) for what? Daniel didn’t disrespected women in any way rather he told only what Quran have said about the responsibility and role of women from family to society. Women are never been told in the Quran to show off their self for any reason like men do.
@@Neji.Hyuuga wasn’t nouman giving reference from Quran? What video were you watching? Nouman Ali have really given wrong and ridiculous interpretation about the ayah that opposites the whole islamic teachings and commandments despite of being known as a religious personality. I think you didn’t watched the video carefully or you would know what Daniel have explained on his criticism.
I love NK too. I do.
Nouman Ali Khan speeches helped me when I was very depressed, I still love him even if he made mistake ask Allah to forgive him
Whenever you feel depressed, pick up the Quran my dear brother. Insha'Allah it will soothe your heart and guide you better.
I am muslim woman and I totally support you Daniel!May Allah bless you and protect you in this hard time for umma.
He is a Muslim version of chandler
He has sarcasm
@@mohammadfarooqi6255 53:30 Cooperations backing feminism
This man is doing propaganda against Islamic scholars.. Plz don't listen him
I’m a Norman Ali Khan fan and have been for many years, I love his depth of translating the Quran, but I do agree with Daniel here and it did teach me to be more careful in not believing everything so easily, may Allah guide us
Stop learning from NAK. He is not qualified to teach the Quran.
I used to listen to his lectures a lot 9 years ago when I was a jahil but I have stopped listening to his lecture after learning the deen from proper scholars.
@@Emsyaz who are the proper scholars, is it you?
@@mahmudaakhter1430 All the major scholars of Mekkah and Madinah Islamic university.
@@Emsyaz Is that it brother?
@@Emsyaz I don't understand Arabic , so can't follow Makkan and Medinian Sheikhs, translations don't give proper understanding, so how should I follow the right Sheikhs?
As an American convert to Islam of 30 years, one of the biggest problems facing Muslims here, in my opinion, is the American attitude of "No one can tell me anything". What I mean is that everyone wants to be their own A'alim or sheikh, or Imam, everyone is a murshid and no one wants to be a murid. Traditionally, contrary to our modern popular belief, their has always been a hierarchy when it comes to Islamic knowledge and scholarship. Not just anyone could give lectures or halqaat, or teach. This is reason for the system of ijaazah and the concept of isnad. As Imam ibn Mubarak رحمه الله said:
"الإسناد من الدين، لو لا الإسناد لقال من شاء على ما شاء"
"The isnaad is a part of the Deen. Were it not for the isnaad, anyone who wishes, would say what he likes".
It has become fashionable for "everyone and their grandmother" to give fataawa and to give their opinion on even the most complex issues in the Deen.
These western appeasing "scholars" and "Imams" are exactly what the enemies of Islam want. They know they can't outright eliminate Islam and the Muslims, so distort the teachings of the Deen to the point that even the basic usool and foundations are at risk of being obliterated.
اللهم احفظ المسلمين
A reason for that may be the rejection of the traditional sunni islam promoted by saudis since early 1980s. This version of the deen allows every muslim who knows a few verses and a few ahadith to criticize or go against even mujtahid scholars.
Let's all make hijra then because we're all in need of guidance especially all these English only speaking speakers.
You have grabbed the problem of our youth at its roots. Every teenager now is an aalim, Faqih,shaykh,Qadi, quoting Hadith and ayat of Quran without no prerequisite knowlege of islam, its sciences and its history. They don't study our traditional prerequisite sciences. But still wish it give their foolish options.
@@AA123TD this is unrealistic. You can go any place and you will find some issue with speakers, or how governments and societies operate, etc. you want to degrade Muslims living in western countries, but look at the condition of our own Ummah. Muslims will need to practice Islam in west and in east, telling Muslims to leave will not be practical for most, especially since you can freely practice Islam in most places and in west there are masjids now. And you paint a bad stigma now on western Muslims, when you already know that many problems affect Muslim communities everywhere, and it is not just for you to say something like this
@@servantoftheexpander9688 Yes, this is the case. It's not only the problem of the youth though. Traditionally, seeking علم took great effort. Islamic history is full of cases where طلاب العلم would travel thousands of miles for knowledge, and these students would learn humility in front of their teachers. They knew that the purpose of acquiring the knowledge of Deen was not to prance around, make a name for themselves, and to belittle others. Besides studying the texts, they also learned humility and when to say they don't know.
I am currently pitching this idea to my family of close to 30 people in the US. They also have come to think that the “new” “American Islam” is the way to go. This diluting Method of becoming Progressive and aligning ourselves with American and Western way of Life-code. May Allah grant us motivation of start to become a scholar of Deen for ourselves and our household and hold us steadfast against this enemy of Islam that is called “Islamic Dilution” and “American Islam”. Ameen suma Ameen
why are you running away?? The topic is what Allah believes what Christians believe! Which is completely wrong! the topic is not what Islam teaches about Islam!
Begotten refers to a Psalm The same is said about Solomon, but everyone knows it's not meant literally! And exactly this statement about Salamon is only repeated but related to Jesus!! According to Rabbis and Christians, this statement means that God Himself appointed this person! What Paul also explains in the New Testament!
@@rosalia2940 "The problem isn't that he said "it's better to marry young". It's that he said, "women age like milk".
That's just a horrible thing to say to a woman. Why could he not approach it with care like the Prophet (saw) would?"
****** ****** ******
Oh no! Are women's feelings hurt?!!! Are they going to cry?!!! Oh heavens, noo! ANYthing but that!!! Nooooooooo!!!!!!
You're right. We should approach things with care like the Prophet ﷺ, like when he said, "Women are the majority in hell," and, "I have not seen anyone more deficient in intelligence and religion than you (women)."
@@rosalia2940 New Bible Update: Pope Francis Says Homosexuality Is Perfectly Fine 😮
🤣🤣🤣
I didn't expect this to nouman ali , how he misinterpreted the ayah and hadiths . May Allah guide him to the right path. We should not follow anyone blindly every human do mistakes 👍🇮🇳
To kha ap nouman ali sy nafrat karti hoo
nouman ali khan helped me understand islam better during my early years and removed misconceptions and bettered my relationships with ppl around me with the tawfeeq of Allah. Alhamdulilah *(Edit:* my main point is lets not boycott/cancel/dismiss him, we or others can still benefit from him even though it appears he made a mistake here)
Me as well!
Still, he's human. We make mistakes but it doesn't we shouldn't be called out for them especially when it a guy teachings religion
They wish you would disbelieve as they disbelieved so you would be alike. So do not take from among them allies until they emigrate for the cause of Allah. But if they turn away, then seize them and kill them wherever you find them and take not from among them any ally or helper. Quran 4:89
@@moholah3745 what are you trying to say?
@@misteryolo7248 I think he's trying to push the same ol' "Oh no Islam is soooo violent" trope lol
I'm from Pakistan and as a person from the middle-class, we have no interest in 'Western' Muslim scholars unless they're debating on theological points.
That is so false. Most of the youth in pakistan from the middle-class that have daily access to the internet follow those american and europe based imams on social networks and have close to no interaction with their local, national imams.
The few that does, do with similars ways but following pakistani imams who are better (sometimes only slightly).
Where in Pakistan are you living, i say this from the point of view of the biggest city in KPK.
So I would like to know where you are speaking from.
Lol 😂 Ur funny
@@rumialkhurasani2612 You are Right.
Speak for yourself, not for others.
I know many Muslims in Pakistan suffering from the inferior complex.
its just you mate. Im from Pakistan and I follow my brothers in deen really closely
NAK is a human being like the rest of us and is not immune to making mistakes or having misunderstandings but the amount of good knowledge he has shared cannot be discredited- we are all students in our own sense please guys no one should be on a pedestal and knocked off cos of small errors we have discernment and we are a brotherhood we support and learn together this culture of sheikhs imams scholars Ustaads calling each other out and going to war is becoming something else
I think in my limited knowledge, I've noticed that there's a wisdom behind listening to a variety of scholars with different opinions. The benefit is that it makes us think critical about Islamic tradition. I listen to many scholars from different schools of thoughts and it makes issues clear. The main thing is that we Muslims should also put effort in reading Quran and hadith to gain more knowledge. That way we can make better decisions. Allah swt knows best.
Allahu Akbar
The knowledge must be conforming with the sunnah narrated in a correct degree and the understanding of the companions and those two generations that followed them. And to stay with majority of scholars agreements.
One of End times signs is that real scholars will be rejected and non-scholars will be followed
Daniel is a non scholar too lol🫣
@@MohammadQasim firstly i don't think the commetor was talking about Daniel, To be a scholars isn't decided by me or you but by the quality and quantity of knowledge. I wouldn't say that he is a scholar nor does he claim to be one, he calls himself a student of knowledge.
💯
@@MohammadQasim Don't learn Islam from Daniel. We should learn Islam from true scholars like Sheikh Albani, Sheikh Saleh Al Fawzan, Shaikh Ibn Uthaymeen etc and with knowledge we can differentiate the haqq and the batil.
Daniel is only warning us against those who seek to change our religion. But in this case Daniel has made it clear that NAK is not a simping imam like OS, MM etc but that he is only correcting his mistakes...
@@Therebelliousprince001 lol that's the part Daniel is wrong about NAK
He's one of the most HARDCORE simp imams....
This video is literally an absolute gem. I could not agree with Daniel any more. This topic is so dumb but so many muslim "speakers" are pushing the agenda of feminism on us. Brother Daniel doing amazing work to undo their agenda. May Allah bless you and your family with worldy and heavenly success.
Believers! Do not take unbelievers as friends over fellow believers. Would you give Allah a clear reason to punish you? Quran 4:144
He literally has daughters that’s why he’s passionate on the subject smh
@@hamnakhan3656 passionate about pushing them to their own destruction? Yeesh
Mohola.. Thankyou for the reminder
@@hamnakhan3656 making own daughter as a bitch? Funny
Ustad Nouman Ali Khan is how I found my way into understanding my Deen. May Allah guide us to what is true about this video.
Why can’t we disagree politely, instead of criticism using words like “nonsense” or “ trash” , you could simply say that you disagree with that opinion and give evidence on your opinion without underestimating the other side whatever his mistake was.
If you are concerned about the ummah just tell your opinion. You oppose ideas not persons.
The nonsense can make any sane man furious, on the contrary Daniel was still really polite considering the toxic speech of NAK
I agree! the language used here is very harsh! this is not constructive criticism
Nouman Ali khan is one of the person bought me back to Islam.
Allah is the one who brought you back into Islam. He made Nouman a means.
Good….. you don’t have to follow every thing come out of him , make our prophet peace be upon him your leader and follow him.
Their agenda is making an imam so famous than he starts saying untrue things here or there.
That's OK, just be careful what you learn from him, this is the case with everyone not just NAK, because we aren't supposed to blindly follow anyone no matter how nicely they speak. We are supposed follow the evidence.
Omar Suleiman is also one of the persons that "brought" many to Islam. The question is which version of Islam? The feminist version or the LGBTQ version?
@@twoplus7647 Of course.
Its interesting we complain about cultural islam overseas. But now we have our OWN cultural islam in AMERICAN ISLAM
wow you are right.
@@motibilli yup SubhanAllah, i hope American muslims dont go down the same road iA
There is no Islam without culture.
*There was a dire need for a person like you Daniel to counter these incorrect narratives with logic and reasoning. You are a blessing of Allah to Muslims who are in search of truth.*
Nouman Ali Khan has really great understanding of the QURAN, he is really wise and intelligent.
I love the way, he explains QURAN.
I started reading Quran because of Nouman Ali Khan.
How did he get caught up in a scandal with women?
Son of God does not mean that God has a child in Christianity!
*what a mistake in the Qur'an!*
Son of God is a title referring to the Word of God!
Hebr 1,2 Hath in these last days spoken unto us by his Son, whom he hath appointed heir of all things, *by whom also he made the worlds;*
as everyone can see the term Son of God refers to the Word of God = god himself! For through that God created the worlds! *what a mistake in the Qur'an!*
@@MelaninMagdalene No one is Angel... Everyone has thier own dark sides..... He was not always religious and has ups and downs too
Pathetic
Based on following Nouman Ali khan since almost 10 years or more, he isn't on the same level at all by any means whatsoever like those crypto imams and feminizing so called shoyoukh. I have no problem with refuting any mistakes he would make, but let's not throw the baby with the bathwater.
Nouman Ali khan's impact on youths when it comes to the interpretation of Quran and how to apply the lessons learned in our lives for anyone who watched his videos scrupulously will come to the conclusion that he is an inspiration and never waters down Islamic rules or teachings.
All in all, I am with any constructive criticism but let's not throw the important work and influential wisdom learnt from this amazing guy. May Allah bless him and you and all Muslims.
Brother Daniel did say that he acknowledges so much good that brother Nouman has done.
That's fine bro, just watch out what you learn from him, knowledgeable scholars when asked about if someone should take knowledge from another scholar or not, they answer take what's good and leave what's bad, it's not that hard, if they say something that doesn't align with Quran and sunnah or the scholarly consensus, them leave it, only learn beneficial knowledge that you're sure isn't a misguided opinion.
Edit : REMINDER to myself firstly and also to my dearest fellow muslims.
Remember, regardless of disagreements and differences in opinion, always think kindly of our fellow muslims, firstly and foremost.
Brother Nouman has done so much for Islam, perhaps worth more than I ever could in several lifetimes. His work, with Allah's Will and Permission, especially with regards to literary magnificence of the Quran is exemplary service to Allah and His Religion, insha Allah!
As muslims, we may disagree or differ in some areas, refrain from thinking that he did it with malicious intent. Perhaps he was sincerely mistaken, perhaps we are the ones who are mistaken. It is natural to hold a different opinion, even the closests of friends and loved ones, we have disagreements. That is normal and healthy.
If I have ever thought wrongly of our Brother Nouman, or implied unjustly, whether knowingly or unintentionally, I pray to Allah by His Mercy and His Magnificence that are incomparable, that He forgives our brothers' mistakes and his past sins, increases his reward in this life, in the grave and in the HereAfter for all the good deeds and sacrifices he has endured to spread Islam in the best way he knows how.
I pray and beg the same for Brother Daniel and to my dearest fellow Ummah as well, especially those who fought to uphold the truth of our Religion in the manner we think the best.
May Allah straighten our path towards Him and His Worship, by His Grand Mercy without comparison, forgives us for our negligence, transgressions and our mistakes, be it both intentional or unintentional.
May Allah increase the love and peace we have among each other as dearest muslims, for we are all desperate for His Approval, His Blessings and His Love, without which, we are worth less than dust.
Allahu Allahu Allahu! Ya Allah, forgive us in our imperfections of our worship and service to You, Ya Allah, we beg you to save us from Your Righteous Anger and Your Divine Wrath, for without Your Mercy, who is there to help us, Your meek and ignorant slaves except by Your Incomparable Forgiveness, Ya Allah Ya Allah Ya Allah!
Never look at Islam by the lens of any other ideology or principles. Never.
Islam stands on its own. Its Message and Instruction are clear, Alhamdullilah.
Why does Islam attract more converts than any other religion? One major reason is that Islam says: "Refugees welcome" to those fleeing failing liberal social and religious institutions.
Let me explain.
Liberal secularists promote the idea that their norms for regulating marriage, family, and religion are ideal.
Nevertheless, statistical data indicates that wherever a society is governed by liberal secular norms, people stop marrying, having children, and practising religion.
Put differently, the liberal is fundamentally a hypocrite - despite what he or she might say, no liberal person is actually interested in being part of a liberal marriage, a liberal family, or a liberal religion.
Matters are different when it comes to Islam.
Muslims also promote the idea that their norms for regulating marriage, family, and religion are ideal.
Moreover, statistical data indicates that wherever a society is governed by Islamic norms, it boosts marriage, birth rate, and religious practice.
Put differently, the Muslim is actually interested in being part of a Muslim marriage, a Muslim family, and the Muslim religion.
The current era is an era of refugees fleeing from liberalism. Liberal marriage, family, and religion have collapsed.
As a result, refugees from liberal societies seek marriage partners abroad, and if they practice any type of religion , it is a non-liberal version whose centers are located abroad. Islam is the most obvious choice for them.
"The problem isn't that he said "it's better to marry young". It's that he said, "women age like milk".
That's just a horrible thing to say to a woman. Why could he not approach it with care like the Prophet (saw) would?"
****** ****** ******
Oh no! Are women's feelings hurt?!!! Are they going to cry?!!! Oh heavens, noo! ANYthing but that!!! Nooooooooo!!!!!!
You're right. We should approach things with care like the Prophet ﷺ, like when he said, "Women are the majority in hell," and, "I have not seen anyone more deficient in intelligence and religion than you (women)."
REMINDER to myself firstly and also to my dearest fellow muslims.
Remember, regardless of disagreements and differences in opinion, always think kindly of our fellow muslims, firstly and foremost.
Brother Nouman has done so much for Islam, perhaps worth more than I ever could in several lifetimes. His work, with Allah's Will and Permission, especially with regards to literary magnificence of the Quran is exemplary service to Allah and His Religion, insha Allah!
As muslims, we may disagree or differ in some areas, refrain from thinking that he did it with malicious intent. Perhaps he was sincerely mistaken, perhaps we are the ones who are mistaken. It is natural to hold a different opinion, even the closests of friends and loved ones, we have disagreements. That is normal and healthy.
If I have ever thought wrongly of our Brother Nouman, or implied unjustly, whether knowingly or unintentionally, I pray to Allah by His Mercy and His Magnificence that are incomparable, that He forgives our brothers' mistakes and his past sins, increases his reward in this life, in the grave and in the HereAfter for all the good deeds and sacrifices he has endured to spread Islam in the best way he knows how.
I pray and beg the same for Brother Daniel and to my dearest fellow Ummah as well, especially those who fought to uphold the truth of our Religion in the manner we think the best.
May Allah straighten our path towards Him and His Worship, by His Grand Mercy without comparison, forgives us for our negligence, transgressions and our mistakes, be it both intentional or unintentional.
May Allah increase the love and peace we have among each other as dearest muslims, for we are all desperate for His Approval, His Blessings and His Love, without which, we are worth less than dust.
Allahu Allahu Allahu! Ya Allah, forgive us in our imperfection of our duty to You, Ya Allah, we beg you to save ur from Your Righteous Anger and Your Divine Wrath, without Your Mercy, there is no help for us, Your meek and ignorant slaves except by Your Forgiveness, Ya Allah!
Murji waffling
❤
Women must be respected, same as men, and that's not feminism.
No.
NO
Yh
No
So that mean that we should treat woman the same as men then from the obligations of being the provider to the severe conditions and punshiment that are on men too right ? right so that's how we must be respecting woman the same way as men from now on (lol)
To be honest, if I watched that video of NAK, I might have been fooled easily too, as a Muslim female. This video is the one I watched before that one, and it really opened my eyes.
Daniel is the one who always holds me back from falling into these feminist agendas not going to lie. Sometimes they're so subtle and presented in such a manner so that the person listening is easily tricked into believing whatever the other person is saying, without questioning.
May Allah سبحانه وتعالى always protect us from falling into the T rap s of d a j a l by always surrounding us with Muslims who hold onto Islam without sugarcoating Ameen
If you think that whatever Daniel is saying is nauzubillah from wahi or somehow superior, you are blatantly wrong yourself and not knowledgeable in the principles of deen, as daniel himself is ignorant of them. These RUclips speakers are not real scholars so don't believe them blindly. Daniel is also commenting and producing his own opinions without nay evidence or basis in islam. Its ridiculous to believe that these are the entire truth, this is just how Daniel views women and he's quite misogynistic in his views and supports his views culturally. Islam is vast to support different views in cultural dynamics, and mr daniel puts irrational fatwas on everyone and wants everyone to live in the utopia created by his own mind.
@@Jorjina.hayatt Allah says in the Quran:
“Thus righteous women are obedient and guard the rights of men in their absence under Allah's protection” (4:34)
It was said to Sayyida 'A'isha :
"Which type of woman is best? She said: “The woman who does not speak evil, is not tricked by the machinations of men, and whose heart is free of all but pleasing her husband and taking care of her family.
(Ibn Hanbal, Musnad 2:251; al-Raghib al-Isfahāni, Muhadarat 2:222)
The Messenger of Allah said:
"If a woman prays her five prayers, fasts her month of Ramadan, guards her chastity, and obeys her husband, she will enter Paradise from any gate she wishes."
(Source: Sahth In Hibban 4252)
The Prophet (peace be on him) said:
“The best wife is she who, if you look at her, will please you; who, if you bid her to do something, will obey; and who will safeguard herself and your property in your absence”
(Cited by Ibn Kathir, and reported by Tabari and Ibn Abi Hatim)
The Prophet says in a hadith:
“If I were to command any to prostrate to other than Allāh, I would command the woman to prostrate to her husband” [Aĥmad, Ĥākim, Tabarānī, Bayhaqī]
The Messenger of Allah says:
“Every one of you is a shepherd and is responsible for his flock. A woman is the guardian of her husband’s home and his children and she is responsible for them”
(Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 7138, Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 1829)
Ibn Kathir writes in the explanation of this ayah (4:34):
“righteous women (are Qanitat), obedient to their husbands, as Ibn `Abbas and others stated”
Allah says in the Quran:
“And stay in your homes and do not go about displaying your allurements as in the former Time of Ignorance” (33:33)
In the interpretation of the same ayah (33:33) there is a hadith which states:
“The women made a submission to the Prophet (peace be upon him), saying: All kinds of virtues have been secured by the men: they fight and accomplish great deeds in the way of Allah. What should we do that we may also get a reward equal to that of the warriors? The Prophet (peace be upon him) replied: The one who sits in her house from among you; will attain the reward of the warriors.”
(Hafiz Abu Bakr Bazzar has related on the authority of Anas)
Another hadith explaining this ayah (33:33) states:
“The Prophet (peace be upon him) said: Woman is ‘awrah (that which must be concealed), and when she goes out the Shaytaan’s hopes are raised. She is never closer to Allaah than in the inner part of her house”
(Bazzar and Tirmidhi have related on the authority of Abdullah bin Masud)
Mujahid writes about this ayah (33:33):
“Women used to go out walking in front of men, and this was the Tabarruj of Jahiliyya”
Ibn Kathir (Shaf’i) writes about this ayah (33:33):
“These are the good manners which Allah enjoined upon the wives of the Prophet so that they would be an example for the women of the Ummah to follow”
Abu Bakr al-Jassas (Hanafi) writes in the explanation of this ayah (33:33):
“And this verse (33:33) proves that women are commanded to stay in their homes and forbidden from going out of them”
Imam al-Qurtubi (Maliki) writes in the explanation of this ayah (33:33):
“The meaning of this verse is that women are commanded to try remain in their homes, and while the wives of the Prophet ﷺ are addressed, other women are also included in its meaning”
Al-Aloosi (Shafi'i\Hanafi) writes in the explanation of this ayah (33:33):
“They (the wives of the Prophet ﷺ) have been commanded to remain in their homes and this is also required from all other women”
The Prophet is reported to have said:
“You are permitted to go out for your needs”.
(reported by Muslim)
Where can you find the original video from NAK? Jazakallahu khairan
@@Jorjina.hayatt It's not that I put Daniel on a pedestal. I actually find that he's straight up honest about Islam and he's trying to protect Islam from these agendas. I know he isn't perfect either (no one is) but I agree with most of what he says.
Also no, I don't think that Daniel is misogynistic. You can't throw that term around. I mean, give me an example of something misogynistic that he may have stated. Daniel is against feminism, more specifically third-wave feminism, and he has explained many times why.
Just curious, are you perhaps a female? Because honestly I imagine you're just a little hurt / emotional since Daniel is straight up honest. Nonetheless, do give me an example of Daniel being ‘misogynistic’.
i'm from belgium ,( i speak french) and in france they transformed the term Islam en France to Islam DE france ( which literally means islam in france to islam of france) very subtile and very similar to what's happening in the US may Allah help us, amine
This massive discrepancy exists despite the fact that there is no gender bias in the law favouring females.
Whether you like it or not, the welfare system forces you as a man to pay for single women, many of whom, as you know, are degenerates.
Without welfare and all kinds of affirmative action promoting women in the workplace, women can't support themselves. The feminist welfare state just distributes the burden of taking care of women to all working men. So you, as a man, have the burden of financially supporting these women without any benefit in return, women who will berate you and call you an incel if you disagree with how stunning and brave they are.
Basically, Western liberalism forces you as a man to fund the lifestyle of women drinking, sleeping around with a new man every night, popping anti depressants like candy, going to the womens march on weekends to whine about how oppressed they are. You're literally subsidizing all that.
Women being free is not free. Someone has to foot the bill.
Islam says no. No one gets a free ride. You want to be taken care of. You have to be in a marriage as an obedient wife. And if you dont want to be an obedient wife, go be a burden on your father, who didn't raise you right. And if you don't want to live under your father's roof, go live in the wilderness or beg on the streets. See how long you last there.
If you had done al-walaa wal-baraa you wouldn’t have this problem. Allah already told you that the non-Muslims are your enemies.
These compassionate imams are getting out of hand and may Allah guide us all to the right path
Imams might be paid to purposely destroy islam through these soft suggestions.
@@chadtyrone That's the best you can come up with, tinfoil hat? Seriously, do you actually have anything constructive to comment with ...... cause people usually result to these kind of 'catch word' insults when they can't argue with a valid point.
Daniel clearly said in one of the comment that Nouman Ali Khan js not one of those “compassionate” imams….. go up and look at Daniel’s comments.
@@chadtyrone you're so naive....
@@AnonymousPerson-hr6qd an example of this is don't convert2islam, he pretended to be a Muslim scholar just to switch and trick the weak minded people astray. In reality he's just a paid actor.
I agree with you brother Danial I'm a woman but I respect the Arabic language work brother Nouman has done too Allah humma baarik may Allah subhaanahu ta aala protect guide and forgive us all Aameen 🤲😥
May Allah bless you sister.
Get in the kitchen and stop watching haraam RUclips videos showing men.
Muhammad (PBUH) is the best example for Muslim men, and his wives are the best example for Muslim women.
The reason of my journey for Arabic language is NAK. Now I speak and understand Qur’an verses without any issues. May Allah bless NAK for that🤲 I also ask Allah swt guide our ustaz on feminism matters🤲
Best approach brother. Acknowledging the pros and negating the cons.
As salamu alaykom, did you use NAK’s course to learn the Arabic language? If so would you recommend it, or what would you recommend.
...
@@YEAGERlST I use it and it's pretty good
@@YEAGERlST i recommend it. The classes are very engaging and comprehensive without making you feel too overwhelmed considering Classical Arabic is very vast and goes pretty deep.
Best intellectual talk I have watched in decades.
Barakallah fik, Daniel.
Inshallah the next generation has somebody like you. Thank you brother may Allah reward you.
Daniel is 100% spot on! Just recently Yaair Qadhi was hosted by some Deobandi seminaries in Pakistan and I saw how his audience was so fascinated by an American Islamic scholar.
I thought 'Oh No', because I foresee what the real agenda is.
Sending 'Western Islamic Scholars' to conservative traditional Islamic cultures is obviously no coincidence.
Wow this is messed up bro, we truly have no one other than Allah to rely upon. May Allah protect us 🙏❤️🌹
YQ is very dodgy
🤦🏻
Salaams. Can you please clarify the difference between a 'western Islamic scholar' and an 'eastern/middle eastern scholar'?
What Deobandi seminar? Could you provide some evidence for this? Any video links would be appreciated.
Finally someone responding to this man. You need to make more videos like this because people like him are a lot but people like you are very little. jazakallah khair 👍
@sev how ? What did he say wrong prove your words
@@fareehan1 who ? me ? do you know me ? Your the one not thinking critically if Daniel starts saying things that clearly go against islam i will not support him just like anyone else, i support the truth to my knowledge Daniel has said many truths and benefited many Muslims to not be ashamed of showing their religion
@@fareehan1 his version of islam ? Are you calling him a kafir ? Are you making takfir with no proof ? You’re saying that he’s making change in the religion ? That’s takfir.
@Super Mario i think and she can correct me on this one, that she’s impacted by the feminist ideology.
@TRY No He spares no one, so why you fan boy of DH get offended when we view him from the same lens he uses on others.He is a pseudo scholar and you are herds he bewitches.
JazakAllahu Khairan brother Daniel.
May Allah SWT bless your efforts and make these efforts sadaqah jariyah (an everlasting charity).
And keep up this hard work and don't listen to the fanboys.
The ending was the punchline for me. Jazakallah khairan Umm khalid.
Nouman Ali Khan is one of the people who solidified my Iman. I have immense respect for him and the work that he has done.
@@tanzimabir1181 iblis does not do dawah lol
@@yorgenibnstrangle3072maybe iblis doesn’t think that we are worth his time. His soldiers might be sufficient enough to corrupt our weak minds. May Allah protect us.
@@wasbtf Be mindful of what you are saying. NAK is wrong about this women empowerment nonesense. But he is not a soldier of iblis.
@@wasbtf "His soldiers might be sufficient enough to corrupt our weak minds"
@@yorgenibnstrangle3072 take it easy, you are reading something that’s not even there.
I love you Daniel for how you deconstruct their arguments and lay bare their tricks.
Honestly, I kinda fell for his trick when I saw this video the first time (a month ago).
A sigh of relief, finally!
Daniel’s contribution is very helpful here. He is correct to show us when even NAK is wrong. May we be blessed with good husbands ameen 🙏🏿
@SAMI Sam Stop simping and have some self-respect like a Muslim man.
You and Umm khalid are doing amazing job in counter attacking these ideologies .....
may Allaah swt grant immense barakah in your rizq
Ameen ya rabb
Ameen.
Ameen
Ameen
They are both Satan agents. Be aware of them! Watch the 👁️ of the dejjal
The more I watch DH, the more I think he is a Legend of our time (no bullshit, just straight orthodox Islam)
Exactly 💯
Don’t cut his head. You put him in a dangerous position. Kibr feeds on comments like these
True, but please don't use swear words brother. The Prophet (saw) forbade it
No he is a Luciferian agent
@@zainahmed6791 with all seeing eye 👁️ he makes,it's clearly he is munafik and is here for divide and conquer
Br Daniel Jazaak'Allah khayr for the eye opener. May Allah preserve you and keep up the good work.
I watched this video when it was released and felt the same thing that Nauman ali Khan is very influenced by Western values and feminism.
He is great in Arabic teaching and quran translation. He has a charming personality and beautiful way of teaching. We should benefit from his work But dont think if him as a authority on Quranic understanding.
I recently attended his Quran week in Sydney. It was great from quranic language perspective but at few occasions his comments reflects that he dont like separation between men and women.
Women specially young ladies were acting like he is celebrity and getting his autographs like crazy. I am sure none of them would do the same with a more mature religious scholar.
I remember watching this a few weeks ago and hoping you would react to it. Alhamdulilah!
could you share the link to NAKs video. Please. JazakAllah khair
If you notice, most of these so called Islamic scholars who try to modernize Islam don't even like to have sunnah beard.. That's one of the reasons why I stopped listening to the scholars who don't even like to have a sunnah beard.
May Allah SWT guide me and all of us to the straight path. Ameen.
What is a Sunnah beard ☺️
A man is not allowed to stop his wife from going to the masjid. How do you reconcile with this Daniel?
Its like high school student reacting to university professor, not even in the same league.
Why don't you do a debate with him?
For all of those who think it is ideal if Muslim women are not financially dependent on men:
Would it be ideal if Muslim men were not sexually dependent on their women? For example, would it be ideal if men could purchase (at low cost) harems of docile life-like forever-young sex robots?
How would you respond to Muslim men who justified this by saying such robots are necessary to give men true independence, such that they are not forced to stay in relationships with women who are rude, jealous, controlling, manipulative, fat, old, or ugly?
How would you respond to Muslim men who said that Muslim women need to "step up their game" such that men choose to be with them instead of a robot that is more friendly, beautiful, young, and thin?
The cop out answer is to say sex robots are haram, but there are other conceivable halal alternatives that would do the same thing: flood men with cheap alternatives. Obviously, such alternatives would weaken and ultimately destroy marriage because it takes away the dependence that men have on women for sex.
But that is literally what giving women financial independence does; it makes them independent from men. And that's why no society or religion ever did give women that independence, except for our current dystopia.
Becareful what you wish for. Daniel will wipe the floor with NAK. NAK mostly rehashes stuff he has learned from salafi/wahabi books. Daniel is an original thinker, not a repeater.
That might seem like an insult but most uni professors these days are garbage so your comparison is.....not as nice as you thought.
As a huge fan of Nouman Ali Khan, the title and introduction made me uncomfortable. Even the idea that women should stay home and can't engage in public duties itself is against my point of view. It was hard for my heart to navigate through the video as I didn't want to believe in this.
Most of us were influenced by western ideologies since we were child through cartoons and movies. Unfortunately, we might have views that are against Islam. Now, some of the Islamic teachings may be hard to grasp or accept. But as muslims, we should all be ready to find, accept and understand the truth despite our own worldview (which is incomplete). We should study our deen and try to understand it best.
After analyzing deeper and weighting arguments of both, it's clear to me that islamically Nouman Ali Khan's arguments are incomplete and Daniel Haqiqatjou provided strong evidences.
I appreciate that you are not arrogant. May Allah bless you. Ameen
@@kodvavi150 I am from the West and I feel the same.
Atleast you are sincere. We as muslims should "hear and obey".
May Allah make easier your transition ameen
Whatever they (pseudo-"humanists") filled my head with when I was a kid/teenager was rotten.
The truth is that men and women mixing themselves at work is very recent even in western societies. They really want to make us believe that this modern social engineering was just about freedom and equality and whatever, and that all those things are good : they're a disaster. Almost every major problem we have right now is because of this and I hate when muslim "speachers" try to enforce it to other muslims like they were enlightened and want to enlight the ignorant. The muslims who weren't brainwashed yet are the enlightened ones.
"If women ruled the world, it would just be a bunch of jealous countries not talking to each other."
Hahahaha 🤣 true story sister may Allah bless you and protect you
Hahaha. The fem'ini'sts are gonna come after you now, sis. May Allah protect you!
Better than starting wars like men
Also I know you're uneducated but there already have been successful female leaders
Sounds better than what we have now.
But that still applies to what we have know though and reality is far worst to be honest, with all the bombings, wars and propagandas 😅
I'm in no way encouraging or supporting women ruling countries but I wish countries didn't talk 😂
I am a victim!
For his lecture i became friends with non mahrams and was trapped into depression as a consequence!
I dont understand.
Please tell me what you talking about.
Beware of the man who is too impressed by his opinions
For all of those who think it is ideal if Muslim women are not financially dependent on men:
Would it be ideal if Muslim men were not sexually dependent on their women? For example would it be ideal if men could purchase (at low cost) harems of docile life-like forever-young sex robots?
How would you respond to Muslim men who justified this by saying such robots are necessary to give men true independence, such that they are not forced to stay in relationships with women who are rude, jealous, controlling, manipulative, fat, old, or ugly?
How would you respond to Muslim men who said that Muslim women need to "step up their game" such that men choose to be with them instead of a robot that is more friendly, beautiful, young, and thin?
The cop out answer is to say sex robots are haram, but there are other conceivable halal alternatives that would do the same thing: flood men with cheap alternatives. Obviously, such alternatives would weaken and ultimately destroy marriage because it takes away the dependence that men have on women for sex.
But that is literally what giving women financial independence does; it makes them independent from men. And that's why no society or religion ever did give women that independence, except for our current dystopia.
@@d.bcooper2271 smooth brain comment
Up to this day I associate NAK with my first steps into Islam. I would always get home after school and literally binge-watch him on TheDeenShow or QuranWeekly when I first caught interest in Islam. This man, with Allah's permission, really was a guidepost for me, to the extent that his videos were the first I started translating about Islam. This was 11 years ago. I really appreciate this video and how it was done and I hope he will take heed of it.
He is not qualified to teach the Quran to begin with.
He is a deviant
@@Emsyaz
Deviant...
Watch your tongue bro.
He makes mistakes. Granted. But who doesn't?
@@abdelw
Nouman is a deviant who deliberately uses Islam for personal gain.
He is not qualified to teach the Quran to begin with.
He made up his own interpretations of Quran in his lectures which is contrary to the tafsir of Salaf.
@@Emsyaz
Not qualified?
Who said qualifications prevented anyone from making mistakes?
People make mistakes regardless.
Ibn Baz said it was OK for the US army to attack Irak from Saudi.
That was one serious mistake.
Ibn Baz was seriously qualified, wasn't he?
@@abdelw Ibn Baz is a real scholar
But Nouman is a deviant who has zero qualification and he is making a business out of Islam.
Thank you for this great video Ustaadh Daniel 🇵🇰❤️ 🇮🇷.
You should make a whole playlist of these reaction videos, I love these types of content!
He isn't a shia, he is a muslim
I am amazed with your knowledge and wisdom my brother. May Allaah increase it more.
Thank you so much for posting this vedio of Nouman Ali Khan. I've been trying to find it for a long time. And finally i found it. Although i had to put some efforts in skipping your parts in the vedio. But still a big thanks because i got to watch it...😊
Assalam mu alaikum my brother, I am from Cape Town, South Africa. I appreciate your content and have learnt a lot and appreciate your videos on these topics especially the alphabet movement and our islamic leaders and their "stance" on the topic or lack of it. Jazakallah khair brother. May Allah swt protect you and your family and continue your work.
Ameen
I am from Cape Town too! Daniel is fantastic. I am glad you found him too!
Ameen.
Keep doing what you do, Daniel. Never stood down. Everyone's doing their parts.
When u have mentioned so many good points about NAK there was no need to criticize upon a minor matter looking at the scale of work he has done. Pls try to lift other muslims .
What proof Daniel has that Allah is talking to all women ? Allah is talking to the mothers of the prophet in the verse right before (62) . Why would the subject Change without noticing ?
@MuslimSkeptic Yes, civil service in Pakistan is different. There is a competitive exam for it and hardly 1% get through and then they are assigned to powerful roles in the police, administration, and so on
It's a remnant of the colonial project
Nation-states as a whole are colonial project, the nation-state identity is secular at it's core. Period. Everything else doesn't matter as long as that fact remains to be a reality.
Yeah but they still all really stupid and corrupt and can't stop taking bribes.
I literally just checked the big scholars' interpretations of this verse in which Allah tells prophet Muhammed's wives to stay at home, all of them including Ibn Kathir (which is probably the most famous) are saying it is for all muslim women, it is encouraged for all muslim women to stay at home unless there is a need to go out and how Allah prefers that for them, and they keep mentioning other speeches for prophet Muhammed and other things in Islam that encourages the same thing, also the whole verse are commands that are meant for the prophet's wives and all muslim women, why would they exclude this one command to stay at home as if it's only for the prophet's wives.
He says that “that ayah is for the ummul mumineen” that’s not true, and nonsense. They are the best of women, and they are a model for all muslimah.
Linguistically, 33: 32-34 is addressed to ummul mumineen. Passage starts by (giving English translation) "O Wives of the Prophet, you are not like anyone amongst the women...". Then later on a reference is made to them again as "People of the House".
In certain matters, standards of behaviour and even some rulings were different for wives of the Prophet compared to other women.
Ikr thats what iam saying aswell@@mem807
I indeed have doubted islam in my coming of age reading all the propaganda spewed by Christian and atheist alike, but thanks to Nouman Ali for bringing me back to Islam with his thorough research of the text of the Quran
This massive discrepancy exists despite the fact that there is no gender bias in the law favouring females.
Whether you like it or not, the welfare system forces you as a man to pay for single women, many of whom, as you know, are degenerates.
Without welfare and all kinds of affirmative action promoting women in the workplace, women can't support themselves. The feminist welfare state just distributes the burden of taking care of women to all working men. So you, as a man, have the burden of financially supporting these women without any benefit in return, women who will berate you and call you an incel if you disagree with how stunning and brave they are.
Basically, Western liberalism forces you as a man to fund the lifestyle of women drinking, sleeping around with a new man every night, popping anti depressants like candy, going to the womens march on weekends to whine about how oppressed they are. You're literally subsidizing all that.
Women being free is not free. Someone has to foot the bill.
Islam says no. No one gets a free ride. You want to be taken care of. You have to be in a marriage as an obedient wife. And if you dont want to be an obedient wife, go be a burden on your father, who didn't raise you right. And if you don't want to live under your father's roof, go live in the wilderness or beg on the streets. See how long you last there.
I really hope Daniel or someone knowledgable sees this comment and responds, because I don't see the logic at all.
Those ayat are very clearly about the wives of the prophet. YES, other muslim women should model themseleves after them just like men should model after the prophet pbuh and sahaba, BUT, and here lies the actual issue, it is not A SIN that they don't.
It is not a sin for anyone not to model themselves after the best of creation if they are not sinning. Calling something haram that Allah did not forbid is a horrible thing to do, and even the prophet pbuh wasn't allowed to do that.
What other muslim women should do is in other places in the quran, and that is what they would be sinning if they didn't do
Why would you want to model yourself after them? Are you high?
May Allah show us the straight path and inspire us to follow it🌹
Guys regardless of your opinion on this
*IQRAA:* Read, Recite & Understand
Less time on the phone more time doing Iqraa
From the phone you can also learn a lot.
And that IQRAA is about to read, recite and understand about Islamic knowledge...not school and college studies.
@@adm2399 how can you be so wrong?
@@thedamnkbob4044
Need not; you're already being ignorant pretty good.
When Islam talks about ilm; it's about the knowledge of haraam and halal...not physics, mathematics, biology etc.
Those are just means to achieve livelihood.
@@adm2399 You are right and wrong
1. Ilm is indeed the BEST knowledge (aka Islamic Knowledge
2. Science without cult philosophy behind it (aka liberal, atheistic, communist n all other isms and schisms) is simply another form of Dzhikr as it should be
But the verse 33:33 does read exactly as applying the the household of the Prophet. We Muslims complain when others take our verses out of context, and yet within context, it's clear 33:33 is continuing from the previous verse which is speaking to the Wives of the Prophet.
DH should read Surah Ahzab properly, before mocking and misinterpreting the Quran.. With due respect, Allah's word is clear and unambiguous, especially the Aayah 32 stating "O wives of the Prophet, you are not like anyone among women..." And it is not NAK saying things like this "for the first time", there is whole precedent of Sahaaba's life as a testimony to what he is says and clearly contradicts DH's (so called traditionalist view) about women being incarcerated at home.. The truth is closer to what NAK explained..
From the first time he released that video about one Pakistani woman , i disagreed with him on that topic,the girl who asked him is solely a liberalist mindset girl, even she was accusing other imams by names too,and Numan Ali Khan agreed with her and denounce imams who prevented her ,we are saying that is so mistake from Numan Ali
Bro Daniels reaction gives me peace and comfort in my heart... ive been suffering from this wasting potential argument and other feminist garbage by the feminists/liberals in my family ever since i decided to give up my job and homschoole my children after discovering Alasna institute and enrolling in umm khalids courses. I fight this battle daily and if it wasent for this videos It would have taken a mental toll on me. May Allah reward you the highest and your wife you are showing the light for this ummah.
Oreo is named in many Muslim countries because it has haram component in it
Ameen
May Allah give you the strength to continue th j had which you are doing again st batil ideologies
May Allah سبحانه وتعالى give us all hidayat Ameen
@@tuliprose8585 The Haram components are removed in Muslim-majority countries. Similar to certain candies that possess gelatin, while non-Muslim-majority countries used pigs for that, Muslim-majority countries tend to replace them with cow-based, sheep-based, and or goat-based gelatin.
@@tuliprose8585 it is halal certified in muslim countries
Same, as a woman I agree 110% with him. Feminism and modern society are the one that makes me feel small for being a housewife and not contributing outside. For record, I have a medical degree, but I didn't continue to pursue working as a doctor because of the stupidly long working hours and the abusive environment. I have to sacrifice so many of my wife's role and time with my family, basically its like I marry the hospital. I hate that kind of life so I quitted. But everyone around me constantly pressure to rethink my decision or go find some other work because they think I'm wasting away my potential for staying at home. Tbh I'm tired of all that pressure. THEY made me feel small and useless when in fact I am fulfilling my duty better as a wife and a future mother Insya Allah. Thank you so much for this video, I feel so much better now.
There is nothing more beautiful than a woman making her home a sanctuary for her husband and her children. Society and leadership starts from the home. Allah SWT has made it easy for women and created a balance.
NAK has helped me get closer to Islam by understanding the Quran better. I realize these scholars mean well but we shouldn’t follow what they say entirely if it doesn’t come directly from Islam
So whats the point.
i respect both NAK and DH with their ups and down
May Almighty Allah protect , guide and shower His abundant and miraculous blessings on Daniel and family dunia akhirat..Aameen Ya Rabb Alamin..Always anticipate his next video..the divine Truth, not misinterpreted , watered down by reformist compassionate imams..
Ameen. ♥️
Women like you, give me hope about islam in Pakistan. Alhumdulliah
can someone explain Daniel's point about learning only from regional scholars? like is he saying it's there are no valuable lessons..? that point feels a little flakey
Could someone please share the link to the original NAK video. I tried searching it!
Timestamps for the video:
00:00:45-00:06:50 Intro: The spread of American Islam' in the Muslim world.
00:06:50-00:19:39 Weird vibes & weird claims
00:19:39 -00:19:39 Command only for Mothers of the believers?
00:34:10-00:40:55 Women In battlefield!?
00:40:55-00:47:49 Are mothers wasted potentials?
00:47:49-00:54:39 Husband died? Do business sissies. Marriage isn't an option.
00:54:39-00:59:49 Who is really making women feel small?
00:59:49- end What are we missing here?
His tafsir and lectures are very useful to this day in modern time, so I will just stick to those and leave anything outside the fold of Islam from him, Insha Allah. Unless he crosses the line extremly and even try to normalize 'lgtv' like the yakeens.
Multiple scholars warned from him. Take that for what it is worth
How do you as a layperson decide which parts of his lectures in tafsir are okay ? I think it is better to stay away altogether and find proper scholars with a proper sanad.
@@therealdoctory-roblox3844 There is no scholar whom you can hand your brain to. You as a layperson are always required to refer back to the Qur'an and sunnah. Do not do as the Jews and the Christians did. See Qur'an 4:59, 3:109 and 9:31
@@therealdoctory-roblox3844 it’s called the LGTV/Liberal/Feminist radar. See enough of it and you’ll develop one.
Don't risk your Deen. This guy even openly lies on the companions of the Prophet , صلا الله عليه وسلم
Brother Daniel, may Allah protect you and preserve you for the Ummah
I wonder whats NAK's opinions about women being second wife ? Can he really does a video about on that issue as well ? If he is really "honest" about himself lets see if he can does a video that promotes there is nothing wrong about being the second wife in Islam ? I believe 90% of muslim women, even if they wear hijab, will not like it and try to manipulate the subject. And since the guys like NAK's knows that, they will never do a video on this issue. We know what their agenda is and the biggest harm comes from the ones like NAK. You may not aware of it but, the biggest problem in ummah is the women mindset which is heavily brain washed by feminisim. I am a divorced brother of yours. And the only reason that I divorced my wife is that she wants to the become her own leader, and she did not obey me. And it was perfectly ok for her to not to obey me. Why? Because of the people like NAK who either has no idea what he is doing or who has a hidden agenda. The idea that they are trying to sell will destroy marriages and consequently reduce birth rates. As you can see, you dont need weapons. Sometimes all you need is a celebrity imam to inject the poison and watch your enemy dies slowly. And again; I cant thank you enough DAniel. You are the only one who is fighting against these people. I really appriciate the your effort to make people understand how vital the issue is. Jazakallah Khair.
You nailed it brother.
i was about to marry a girl. At the start, if she wanted to go places and I was uncomfortable, she wouldn't go. We were happy. Then, she started to argue with me. Because i loved her, i gave up on these views and thought maybe I'm wrong, she should be able to do as she pleases and i am being controlling. What then happened was she began to resent me, as i wasn't her guardian anymore and not acting like a man. She then cheated on me. His point as 32:00 minutes is true. I have experienced it.
Edit: Balance is key, and I don't recommend enforcing these ideas in a harmful or arrogant way. Just be sure of yourself and be dominant, and be prepared to walk away. Always be kind even in these situations and explain in an assured manner.
Also, even though I kept this relationship "halal" and had purely the intention of marriage, I still would never recommend having a partner when you cannot get married within a short period.
Being in a relationship is HARAM for a reason. Its common now, but don't fall into the trap like I did.
You a Muslim?
And was she a Muslim?
@@abidsalaheddine5767 are you guys surprised muslim women cheat? lol the fitnah can affect muslim men women and children
Are you musliim ? Was she muuslim? You can not date in Islaam, that is the first wrong you did. Dating leads to these types of scenarios. Your family should have been looking for a decent girl for you, this would have saved you a lot of heartache.
@@clearskybluewaters not surprised just asking because if she knows the penalty of cheating in sharia she wouldn't have dared to even think about it, which bring us to the big problem, and that is not following islam the right way and the ignorance of people
Daniel you have no idea about Pakistan situation where most lower and middle class women have to go out to support their family to meet their needs
There are lots of problems in Pakistan, though. Deviant groups and grave worshipping being one of them.
True, as a Pakistani one of the most prominent issues I see is Sufism.
@dailyislamicreminder7858 I never said there isn't a lot of good. Pointless comment. The military leadership is corrupt, and when a sincere leader like Imran Khan tries to do good and doesn't steal the money of the people, they try to kill him. Bangladesh is doing way better than Pakistan. I'm realistic, not pessimistic. The people of Pakistan are one of the best, but the leadership is seriously lacking and have betrayed the people.
Barelvis are largest sect in pakistan a lot in india too
@@GigaFloyd there is nothing wrong with tasawwuf. Just pakistani characters that use it for money, power and influence is the problem. They introduce and practice things that are contrary to the shariah.
@Daily Islamic Reminder Enjoin good and forbid evil
Salamun alaykum Dear Brother Daniel. Muslims making videos against other Muslims (who dont agree with some of your opinions) I belive is unnecessary and wrong. I didn't recall anything wrong with what he (Ali Khan)said. And also mocking him and laughing at him! This is not what Allah swt commanded us to do. He is your brother in Islam, and if he has said or done somthing wrong, then contact him and talk to him in a respectful way. In Islam we are taught to do to our brother what we would want for ourselves. Think for a seccond would the Prophet pbuh react to him the same way you did? The Shaitan wants us to divide so that he can be stronger over us. Do you think that us Muslims making videos against eachother, (by mocking, ridiculing, laughing at eachother,) is ever going to bring us closer to Islam? No, it will never, and it will just divide us even more. So Please, for Allah's sake, stop making videos ridiculing,laughing,mocking, other Muslims. If they did somthing wrong publicly, then make a video correcting him RESPECTFULLY. And if he did it in private, then correct him privately RESPECTFULLY. May Allah swt guide us all, and unite us like we were before.
Stop making these silly reaction videos on RUclips for views. If you were really interested in NAK's views and wanted to debate him, you would contact him and sit down like a grown up and have a debate. Then upload the debate on RUclips, fine no problem, have some views. Brother Nak is not fooling anyone, he clearly mentions he is NOT a scholar and he only teaches from his own understanding of the language of Arabic. Anyway, grow up and just debate him, simple.
Simp Nouman. His marriage lecture advice was very one-sided and lacked substance. The feminists ran with it .
Finally someone said it..
they want men in a traditional position, he has to pay and take responsebility and so on, women should modern at the same time, she can do what every she wants.
Your supporter from Pakistan 🇵🇰. I agree with you when he was coming to Pakistan I was confused why he is coming to Pakistan where he is not even least comparable in knowledge to the scholars we already have
After some backlash. Daniel back tracks. Exposing the faults of your brother to get more views akh. No good.
@classified name lol. Wake up.
@classified name Al-Mustawrid reported: The Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “Whoever eats so much as a morsel at the expense of a Muslim’s reputation, then Allah will feed him the likes of it in Hell. Whoever clothes himself with a garment at the expense of a Muslim’s reputation, then Allah will clothe him with the likes of it in Hell. Whoever stands in a position of repute and fame at the expense of a man, then Allah will make him stand in a position of repute and fame on the Day of Resurrection.”
Source: Sunan Abī Dāwūd 4881
Grade: Sahih li ghayrihi (authentic due to external evidence) according to Al-Albani
So if both parents go to work then who looks after the kids?... exactly.
Thankyou brother Daniel
JazakAllah
Spot on Sir, it’s quite sad the situation these days
Thankyou for bringing this to light brother, I hope things start changing soon because it’s getting too messed up!!!
Daniel! Your work is very important may Allah reward you!
BRAVE & TRUTH. Nailed to the bottom of it.
If the best and purest & cleanest places on earth - the Masjids - women are told they get more reward if they pray at home, and if they insist going to the Masjid they are told they get more reward if they pray in the furthest rows from men, so how could we encourage women to mingle with men and compete with them in the worst environments ⁉️⁉️⁉️⁉️
Then women should not pray in the last rows of the masjid, they should compete with men to pray in the first rows...
yes, certain civil servants posts are a big thing here. They get big houses and servants and they head specific departments :) my parents are ( and many parents as they are obsessed with making their children civil servants) asking to prepare for its exam but I don't like these things. but I understand why parents want their daughters to have these jobs. these jobs provide security that unfortunately, some husbands don't. Daniel, you have to understand our culture its really really bad. Our family culture. I am a woman 26 and unmarried not by choice necessarily. all my friends who are married are treated like trash by their in-laws and their husbands silently watch all that. One of my friends had to get a job only to afford a servant for herself because her husband refused to get her one. she is sick and that makes it difficult for her to take care of all her in-laws. The physical work was hard for her. now she has a small job enough to take her away from her in-laws and to pay a servant who helps her with the chores. Women are treated literally like trash sometimes so our parents try their best to educate us and make us capable of jobs, in times of need.
Is this a solution? Or only reactionary mindset?
@why not
See, I am just saying that we just adopt the reactionary mindset, our fathers are educating us so that we can save ourselves from vultures in the form of husbands.... Does we really submit our will to Allah???
Guys remember Islam when they have to marry four wives.
Girls remember Islam when their in laws treat them like trash or want saperate households....
Most of the Pakistani households practice CULTURE not Islam...
It's the need of Hour to get back to Islam in all spheres of life and really submit our will to Allah
Do girls really probe for a person's deen before marrying a guy?
We never take stand for Islam and live our whole life submitting to our culture. Did we ever care to care about Islam? I always say if we never stood up for Islamic values and submitted to culture for whole life then everyone of us deserves to be oppressed by Culture.....
I would advise you one thing ( as you aren't married) please learn Islam and understand it and then if you ever had a proposal of any guy, probe his deen please. Mostly Men are cowards and they will never stand against culture just like women and that's why they will never ever protect their wives from the zulm of in laws. Do have a session in presence of your Mahram with that person and try to figure out his thought process where it's coming from or you can make a questionnaire and give it to your brother so he can ask on your behalf
( Obviously in our culture this thing is considered Haram, we have to educate our parents about this)
You should stand against this Hindu driven Jahez culture, the baraat culture, flashy marriage culture, have big amount of Mahr ( as in pakistan, susral considers this a huge insult اعوذ باللہ) and most of the guys will fail this simple litmus testing.
Be very careful in selecting your spouse but first work on your self to be a صالح مومنہ and then make dua after every prayer
رب یسرلی جلیسا صالحا
اللہم انی اسئلک زوجا صالحا فی الدنیا والاخرۃ
And after making a decision do Istikhara
And May Allah make us Saleeh and may we all be blessed with the Salih spouses Ameen sumaa Ameen ya rab Al almeen.
@@laiba7383 thank youu so much for this. I will remember everything you said . and yes i have started to learn Islam, years of university education made me a liberal so i am trying to unlearn all these beliefs. Thank you again for typing these beautiful words.
I really appreciate u for bringing out these issues to light... its very important in the current society where families are broken apart from these toxic feminists ideologies..its heart breaking
Fr
Yes we should go back to traditional societies where husbands beat their wives
Great Daniel I really believe whatever you told is truth
I know women always played a supportive role in islam she was a mother of all Great pious and walis of Allah
May Allah guide all the Muslims of world to haqq so that non believer s actually know what is Islam and who is a true muslim
May Allah increase us in the knowledge that is beneficial for us
Hahahahaha i like your humour. THis Nouman is a great guy to be honest, but we dont stop critizing somebody just because he did good things. that is not the good approach. Your approach is:
"you did good, we recognize that. But if you take the wrong path, you will be called out ( in a mild way at first)" . Nothing wrong with this approach
Growing up as Western minded and English speaking, I was more inclined to western imams because of common language and that they presented Islam in common with Western values.
Now that I’m matured, I know realise the wisdom of Islam not being align with western values due to its godlessness, evil and degenerate ways. This shift is largely due to Muslim Skeptic and Daniel, now I’m learning my deen by qualified scholars (in my area).
Those who grow up like me should let go of the Western baggage and inferiority complex we held. We’ll just end up shooting ourselves in the foot.
Every place and time has its people to bring sharia into understanding, application, etc. you paint western values with a broad brush of immorality, but do not forget there are many virtues in western societies also. And Muslims who live in the west and grow up there, it is their country, they have to practice Islam there, deal with unique circumstances. Closing your eyes to pretend East is perfect is just being ignorant to the problem. Islam finds its home in any place, it is the abode of believers. May Allah guide us to what is better,
@Jack Birdie could y please show me then? Maybe I am coming from a different place, I realize having visited East and also being from the West, I realized “western” is a mindset and so many things I always saw people maligning us for things like living our lives as Muslims in a western country. I kept seeing things like western society is corrupt, and that it is no place for Muslims…. But now I realized that Muslims must be able to spread Islam, and that so much of the characterization of the west is based on stereotypes. Just like westerners make a whole fake image of the East as violent, backwards, etc… similarly, easterners come with this idea as west being all decayed and degenerate… there is specks of truth in this… but I realized the real fight is between truth and falsehood. And there is a lot of good in the West also, so do not discount it. Do not make the Muslim in the west feel like he can never belong anywhere… he must feel he is part of society to steer it towards Islam. Of course, all Muslims in this dunya are strangers. But I am tired of seeing so much outright misrepresentation of what it is like to be in a western country. No doubt western countries have a lot of evil and their governments also… but please consider that we are all part of societies, peoples, etc. To tell us we cannot live in a place where we can practice our religion and spread it, to deny us any useful perspective because of our location and society, it really stifles us.
@Jack Birdie ok thanks. But where is kufr being viewed as virtue? I am saying there is also lots of things like honesty, fairness, accountability, good manners and behavior when people deal with each other, there is a lot of this to be found also in West.
@Jack Birdie you are wrong in a way. If you travel to Muslim countries like Pakistan, Saudi even, others, etc. you will find cruelties and dishonesties and scams that will make you wonder, where is the Islam in this place. It is not all about materialism only in West, although this is a major criticism of western countries. Truth is materialism has permeated most countries, and sometimes ideologies show their worst face in Eastern countries. One example I will give you, how fellow Muslim laborers are often treated in gulf countries (many stories) and paradoxically western citizens get upgraded treatment based on passport!!! Of course Allah swt gives people tests whom he loves, but the lack of akhlaaq and completely missing the message of the Prophet saws that is found in some places makes one so sad. And by the way, I am not the first person to make such observations. At least, for example, western countries have a more fair and transparent process of courts, justice, employee benefits, the people do not discriminate on nationality outright for a pay basis!!! (See some gulf places), and many more individual examples of honesty present in society. These are praiseworthy virtues in these societies, similar how the Prophet saws spoke about the virtues of Quraish conduct, even though ofc they were disbelievers.
MaShaAllah!
Jazaka’Allahu Ahsanal Jaza! brother DH you are trul a legend for Muslim ummah of America.
Keep it going may Allah give you more strength and happiness!