How to Make Comics - Marvel's The Art of Storytelling

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 17 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 145

  • @ProkoTV
    @ProkoTV  Год назад +44

    Start learning from Marvel’s incredible comic artists now at proko.com/marvel

    • @hanzlopez5888
      @hanzlopez5888 Год назад +1

      Ok.

    • @jasonirelan-ig5fl
      @jasonirelan-ig5fl 6 месяцев назад

      The Marvel way would be better if you brought Quazar back. Can you make that happen?

    • @juliooliveira5565
      @juliooliveira5565 5 месяцев назад +1

      Consigo assistir o curso com legenda em português?

    • @juliooliveira5565
      @juliooliveira5565 5 месяцев назад

      @ProkoTV

    • @ProkoTV
      @ProkoTV  5 месяцев назад +1

      @@juliooliveira5565 As legendas deste curso estão atualmente apenas em inglês e espanhol.

  • @mikekeppel7840
    @mikekeppel7840 Год назад +33

    I signed up for this a few hours ago but this intro has me even more excited.

    • @ProkoTV
      @ProkoTV  Год назад +5

      Nice! We've put a lot of work into this course and we're excited to finally start releasing it to our students!

  • @tonyb1984
    @tonyb1984 Год назад +39

    This course resonates with me so much. My drawings improved so much when I took the time to give them stories and background instead of just being a reference to someone's art. It gave me more ideas for my pieces and that alone will give you endless freedom to create *your own* ...magic!

    • @ProkoTV
      @ProkoTV  Год назад +6

      It really can help! Knowing who the characters are gives life to so much of their actions, what they'll wear, how they'll reply and those small things they might do in a drawn scene.

    • @tonyb1984
      @tonyb1984 Год назад +1

      @@ProkoTV ♥️🙏🏻♥️

  • @julianshaw4603
    @julianshaw4603 Год назад +20

    I'm drawing a Marvel comic as we speak and i still want this course. I've been watching proko for years

    • @paulwoodford1984
      @paulwoodford1984 Год назад +3

      Why not create your own idea. You won’t be able to sell your version

    • @julianshaw4603
      @julianshaw4603 Год назад

      @@paulwoodford1984 its called marketing. who has a bigger audience than the big two?

    • @paulwoodford1984
      @paulwoodford1984 Год назад +2

      @@julianshaw4603 marvel is dying. Less people are watching their crap now

    • @julianshaw4603
      @julianshaw4603 Год назад +6

      @@paulwoodford1984 yet you're here watching a video with Marvel in the title

    • @paulwoodford1984
      @paulwoodford1984 Год назад

      @@julianshaw4603 Look, people need to be told the truth

  • @DolphinCat9
    @DolphinCat9 Год назад +29

    This looks awesome! Comics are such a cool way to tell a story

  • @jbkhan1135
    @jbkhan1135 Год назад +13

    This course looks pretty awesome, not going to lie. I will definitely buy this once I'm done with Drawing Basics!

  • @Jakeeee2
    @Jakeeee2 Месяц назад +1

    I have learned a lot of how to draw comic style art
    Every time I draw I watch this video so I can focus on my art

  • @aberwood
    @aberwood Год назад +5

    Well done Stan and your team for putting this together! Looks like it'll be the most comprehensive comic course online. I hope traditional mediums like goauche, watercolour and acrylic get some love. You could talk to George Pratt who did Wolverine - Netsuke!

    • @ProkoTV
      @ProkoTV  Год назад +2

      They do! Erik Gist demos using oils for making a cover (There's also a digital section with him as well)

  • @Lumina_Dreams
    @Lumina_Dreams Год назад +3

    I’m so excited for this course!!

  • @eze8608
    @eze8608 Год назад +3

    Introduction? “A crummy commercial? Son of a Bitch!”
    I’m with Ya Ralphie.

  • @Dy1anGaming
    @Dy1anGaming Год назад +1

    Proko and Marco bucci are the best art teacher in RUclips

    • @ProkoTV
      @ProkoTV  Год назад

      I'm in good company there! Marco's great!

  • @ONEPEAKFRFR
    @ONEPEAKFRFR Год назад +161

    I've felt like its easier to draw a story than write one in my personal opinion.

    • @itsspideyboi
      @itsspideyboi Год назад +9

      I agree

    • @powerbadpowerbad
      @powerbadpowerbad Год назад +31

      Writing is much easier,drawing is very time consuming.Most times ( depending on how fast you are )drawing a 22-to-26 page comic takes any where from a month-to-2 months to draw ( this is from listening to pro artists talk )and one pro writer says it may take him one week or two to bang out a script.

    • @ProkoTV
      @ProkoTV  Год назад +65

      Everyone's different! That's part of why comics can be so great. It's the product of people who are so good at individual parts of the process.
      For this course, we're trying to teach it all. Students may find a new appreciation for a different step in comic creation or come away with a better knowledge of the part they already liked the most.

    • @ONEPEAKFRFR
      @ONEPEAKFRFR Год назад +13

      @@powerbadpowerbad for me it's the opposite I often come up visual for a story I come up with in my head and I only write after I've drawn everything. For me it's easier to show things then it is to write it, but everybody's defrent in how they do things. Plus I just love to draw lol 😆

    • @powerbadpowerbad
      @powerbadpowerbad Год назад +4

      @@ONEPEAKFRFR Do what works for you,that's what matters.I love to draw also,it relaxes my mind and soothes me.I need it,I'm an ex-combat vet,did 4 deployments to Iraq and need all the peace of mind I can get. LOL.

  • @chaikajpeg2842
    @chaikajpeg2842 Год назад +1

    Would you recommend this course to people who never read Marvel comics and know nothing about its universe? I love the art and the storyboarding shown in this video and I'd love to learn more about it.
    Thank you to you and your team for your incredible work all these years!

    • @ProkoTV
      @ProkoTV  Год назад +1

      I would! While there's Marvel all over it, with Marvel characters and Marvel panel shown, the concepts being taught in this are about all comics. Action-heavy comics, slice of life comics and more.
      There will be some parts where you hear Jim Zub wax poetic about a certain character but that's just the love of a writer for the characters they're inhabiting while writing.
      Thanks for enjoying what we make! I hope to see you in the course!

  • @GameDeveloperTraining
    @GameDeveloperTraining Год назад +6

    I'm very interested but $200 plus tax is a lot to shell out for a course that isn't finished and doesn't have a guaranteed duration or lifetime access. Just too many questions left unanswered for me to even consider paying that money.

    • @ProkoTV
      @ProkoTV  Год назад +1

      We make sure that our courses cost less than what it would cost to go to a traditional art school, much less having this many instructors coming together on one course.
      In that expensive art school environment, you only have those lessons the one time, maybe some handouts, and you have to attend at a certain time to take them. Our courses can be taken any time, rewatched, rewound and are a time-tested great learning resource for our students.
      This course's windowed exclusivity until 2031 is a first for us because of the big company collaboration. But it's by no means a guaranteed end to the course existing. That's just the current legal mumbo jumbo and can extend beyond that point, when it comes.
      We hope you do join the course eventually and get to experience the skill and wisdom of all these instructors!

    • @Nikke283
      @Nikke283 Год назад

      @@ProkoTV Can I buy just some courses as well? How much would cost a single course?

    • @ProkoTV
      @ProkoTV  Год назад

      You can definitely buy individual courses! Our courses are individually priced but start below $100 for some.
      You can browse through and see those you might be interested in:
      www.proko.com/browse

    • @TheFutureLooksGrimm
      @TheFutureLooksGrimm Год назад +2

      [edit] I think I made a mistake here thinking it was a masterclass course because that ad popped up? Looks like the actual course is $250 on Stan’s site proko. He’s a years long student of Watts Atelier so anyone knowing that should realize how worthwhile this is in combining a course with pro Marvel artists. It’s as close as one can get without the opportunity for apprenticeship. This is the best team up course for comics I’ve seen. I mention Watts because something I think that’s vital to being a great teacher is being able to communicate and understand people psychologically in order to translate instruction into ways different people can understand and Watts has done this well and amazing teachers came from being students there. Obviously Stan being one them.

  • @sneetchw
    @sneetchw Год назад +6

    Woohoo! I love comics!!!

  • @Hoang-88
    @Hoang-88 Год назад +5

    I love drawing comics knowing that nobody is gonna read it. I created a world for my own and i enjoy being in it 😊

  • @alexanderurqhartjensen939
    @alexanderurqhartjensen939 Год назад +2

    I would be interested if this could be downloaded. But considering you can't promise this will be available in the future on your site, I would not want to purchase it. I bought the How To Draw Comics Ultra Omnibus bundle instead.

  • @efrainjesusuntiverospizzar4955
    @efrainjesusuntiverospizzar4955 Год назад +1

    Great subjects 🎉, greetings from Perú 🇵🇪

  • @Msannamitta
    @Msannamitta Год назад +1

    Wow, this took work. I'm impressed. Its here!!!! ❤🎉 👍

  • @bravezoom
    @bravezoom Год назад +1

    it really help thanks for helping us and I do a lot of art projects and have a wonderful day

  • @hanzlopez5888
    @hanzlopez5888 Год назад +1

    Great 👍🏼 comic 📕 drawings ✏✒🖍🖋🖊🖌 in Marvel.

  • @goatsurgeon
    @goatsurgeon 9 месяцев назад

    I'm in college to become an accountant but I would get this course to have some fun
    I love drawing and being creative and stuff

  • @DeviousXct
    @DeviousXct Год назад +1

    Will you eventually put the marvel way on the channel? When that time comes?

  • @kiwifruitkl
    @kiwifruitkl 5 месяцев назад

    This must be the old-fashioned traditional way of making comics.
    The script is all printed and ready to go.
    The paneling, sketching, inking, coloring, flatting -- all done traditionally.
    I cannot imagine doing the traditional way.
    I do own my own art supplies, but my art supplies are for doodling and journaling, not comic-making.
    I much prefer to work digitally. On my iPhone and iPad, I just use my finger to do a lot of finger-painting. On desktop and laptop, I use my mouse or the laptop's trackpad.

    • @ProkoTV
      @ProkoTV  5 месяцев назад

      Not old-fashioned. Just what this one instructor likes lol
      Across this course, we feature people who work exclusively digitally, traditionally, and others who work in a hybrid way.
      The section on covers features 2024 Eisner nominee EM Gist showing working in Procreate as well as doing an oil painting for a cover.
      We don't want to only cover one way of doing things for a course that covers principles that work for all types of comics-making.

  • @introvertincognito4518
    @introvertincognito4518 Год назад

    It was my dream, like all I wanted as a kid was to be a comic book artist. In my mind it was a done deal. Then at about 11 my parents told me I'd be poor. "Only the best of the best make money." Decades later, spinal issues cause tremors in my hands.....I miss drawing so much.

    • @ProkoTV
      @ProkoTV  Год назад

      Sorry to hear that you have to deal with that. Hopefully, you've found a different way of expressing your imagination that doesn't depend on your hands quite so much.
      Your unique vision should get to be shared with the world, whether that's with words or something else.

    • @introvertincognito4518
      @introvertincognito4518 Год назад +1

      @@ProkoTV I read my Bible, I read to my daughter, and try to explain to her in imaginative images, what truly took place.

  • @miriams.1996
    @miriams.1996 Год назад +1

    I'd Wish you could make a similar guide but with mangas

    • @ProkoTV
      @ProkoTV  Год назад +1

      That's definitely something we'd consider with the right instructor.
      Some day!

  • @emmahamilton1514
    @emmahamilton1514 7 месяцев назад +1

    I’m doing the basics course. Should I do anatomy or something after that before doing this comics course?

    • @ProkoTV
      @ProkoTV  7 месяцев назад

      Anatomy and figure drawing would be great for you before taking this course, depending on how you've felt with the materials in the Drawing basics course.
      If the basics course has been challenging, definitely consider those others first. Thanks for asking!

    • @emmahamilton1514
      @emmahamilton1514 7 месяцев назад

      @@ProkoTV Thanks. The Basics course is great. Really really good. It’s filling in a lot of gaps that other teachers just seem to assume you will know without being taught. The only problem with the Basics course is getting feedback, because I only started a few weeks ago, so I’m behind. People don’t seem to comment on the older lessons. Is Anatomy and figure drawing one course? If not, then which comes first?

    • @ProkoTV
      @ProkoTV  7 месяцев назад

      @@emmahamilton1514 You won't be able to get critiques in the video critiques but if you post your work on an assignment with a help request, people will give you notes on your submissions.
      Anatomy and Figure Drawing are two separate course. They're kind of like a branching path where you choose one or the other to start. Neither needs to come fist.
      If you want super technical knowledge, anatomy is for you. But if you prefer more free-flowing drawing, Figure Drawing will be better for you.

  • @AnnasWorld-f1z
    @AnnasWorld-f1z 4 месяца назад

    Can u do a vid on vanishing points

  • @LosSantosCity
    @LosSantosCity Год назад

    Will we be getting feedback on our assignments?

  • @redmayneyas
    @redmayneyas Год назад +3

    Any details on the release schedule? Are lessons gonna get uploaded today?

    • @ProkoTV
      @ProkoTV  Год назад +3

      Today was the course introduction. First premium only lesson with Jim Zub will be next week. That will cover scripting.

    • @ProkoTV
      @ProkoTV  Год назад +2

      You can expect new lessons to come out once a week if you're a premium student.

    • @linkinaball
      @linkinaball Год назад +5

      Kinda weird to not have a lesson at the start of the course. But we’ll wait. 🙈

    • @tonyb1984
      @tonyb1984 Год назад +1

      ​@@linkinaballit's not weird at all. It's introducing everyone to the product and what to expect. Also, gives the people that truly want to sign up for premium lessons time to gather their funds if needed. Among many other reasons, but I assure none being "weird"...make sense??

    • @eze8608
      @eze8608 Год назад +3

      @@linkinaballYES! I appreciate that You said it out loud. You are absolutely right. A 10 min intro that is free on You Tube is a huge let down given the hype that the first lesson was coming out today. & given the amount we paid by today to get started. This intro is just another advert for the course. I’m not angry, just a bit disappointed.

  • @chucklee9280
    @chucklee9280 Год назад

    I’ll probably wait for all of the lessons to com out before buying.

  • @CultureU-pendrawing_Studio
    @CultureU-pendrawing_Studio Год назад +1

    Wow~ I like this course 😀

  • @darioscomicschool1111
    @darioscomicschool1111 Год назад

    Gonna watch this later!

  • @robbebruers2841
    @robbebruers2841 Год назад +1

    you really need to try and get mike mignola to do a video with you guys that would be legendary

    • @ProkoTV
      @ProkoTV  Год назад +1

      I'd love that! Maybe some day.

  • @edmundobaca3498
    @edmundobaca3498 Год назад

    Beautiful video🎭🎨

  • @willrib
    @willrib Год назад

    Hi Proko. I'm from Brazil and I would like to know if it's easy to take classes here. I'm not an expert in the language, but I can understand enough. An international credit card is reasonable for making the payment, I believe. Is the course unlimited? And I would also like to know if you have any discount coupons. Hehehe

  • @carlosfrostygreen6855
    @carlosfrostygreen6855 Год назад

    Thanks

  • @B_Kerson
    @B_Kerson Год назад +1

    I have a story I’ve written over the past 8 years and can not draw to save my life 😭😭😭 I’m trying to learn though

  • @emekaabuah6029
    @emekaabuah6029 Год назад

    Hi Stan. Love your videos, very insightful. You don't give discounts on this course?

    • @ProkoTV
      @ProkoTV  Год назад +1

      We had a months long presale on it with the steepest discount it'll ever have. We run presales for all of our courses and make sure and let people know.
      Hope you're able to join the course!

    • @emekaabuah6029
      @emekaabuah6029 Год назад

      @@ProkoTV Oh I see, my bad. I really would love to.

  • @rukmanichoudhary13
    @rukmanichoudhary13 7 месяцев назад

    Which ink pen brands you use can you share a buy link for it please

    • @ProkoTV
      @ProkoTV  7 месяцев назад

      There are two inking lessons in our Marvel course playlist. They'll talk about not just their brands of ink but also other tools you may be interested in:
      ruclips.net/video/P_n7ynuuMb0/видео.html

  • @fantasygameplay256
    @fantasygameplay256 Год назад

    When you are inking, if you do some wrong line, how you fix it?

  • @r...323
    @r...323 Год назад

    Los cursos tienen subtítulos en español??

    • @ProkoTV
      @ProkoTV  Год назад +1

      A lot of our courses do have multi language subtitles. The Marvel course does not currently.

  • @BaboSkabo
    @BaboSkabo Год назад +1

    Is this 200 us as a one time payment or a subscription? It's a bit unclear to me.

    • @ProkoTV
      @ProkoTV  Год назад

      One time payment!

  • @paigesteiner6086
    @paigesteiner6086 Год назад

    Idk if i wanted to do course or not cause I’m not the greatest artist but I do some writing I wish know how to write a story into a comic I visualize my own story of a superhero but idk what to do with this character of mine

  • @jay-wu8fj
    @jay-wu8fj 5 месяцев назад

    stan prokopenko ?

  • @RogerHistoric
    @RogerHistoric Год назад

    Yes

  • @mythorlegend
    @mythorlegend Год назад

    Is the course fully available? By that I mean composed and complete? in case I wanna speed up learning?

    • @ProkoTV
      @ProkoTV  Год назад

      Lessons in our courses come out weekly and are not available up front. This allows us to work with students at a pace that allows them to absorb the materials and enables us to make video critiques for the students who submit their work as the assignments are given.

  • @art.Shantha
    @art.Shantha 3 месяца назад

    Plz tell, if I want to enroll marvels art of story telling should I have knowledge on head and anatomy drawing? Or any one who have beginners level knowledge can join?

    • @ProkoTV
      @ProkoTV  3 месяца назад

      If you've got a bit of drawing experience under your belt, this course will work for you.
      You don't need to have DEEP anatomy knowledge or anything. But if you find yourself having a hard time with some anatomy consistently, some of our free anatomy lessons might help.
      Good luck with this course!

    • @art.Shantha
      @art.Shantha 3 месяца назад

      @@ProkoTV Thank you Proko team , for your guide , I love to learn comic.

  • @gamallielsharon3261
    @gamallielsharon3261 Год назад +1

    What course should I take before take this course?

    • @ProkoTV
      @ProkoTV  Год назад

      That depends on what you're looking to do and where your skill level is. We have courses on drawing, sculpting and more.

    • @tenorsurfer87
      @tenorsurfer87 Год назад

      It's a good idea to understand the basics, if you check out the Drawing Basics course and feel you don't have a strong grasp on those concepts and skills it's probably a good idea to practice from that course. If you can do the Figure course though you're definitely ready for this one

  • @ZephyrBW
    @ZephyrBW Год назад

    How much do you charge for this course exactly?

    • @ProkoTV
      @ProkoTV  Год назад

      It's currently $249

    • @ZephyrBW
      @ZephyrBW Год назад

      @@ProkoTV wow 😯 that much. I don’t suppose there’s a discount

    • @ProkoTV
      @ProkoTV  Год назад

      Not currently but we have an annual Black Friday sale coming up!

  • @Cyranowan
    @Cyranowan Год назад

    Should let me show you how to flat colour comics as someone who’s been doing it for almost a decade

  • @viglakielefteria4443
    @viglakielefteria4443 Год назад

    What equipment is required for the coloring section ? I ask because I do not have a tablet or any similar device and I have never worked on digital coloring or drawing. Do I need to buy a tablet or something similar ? Or I will be able to complete the coloring section with traditional ways of coloring ?

    • @ProkoTV
      @ProkoTV  Год назад

      You can absolutely work traditionally for the coloring section. The demos will be digital but that's not because the techniques and process breakdown are exclusive to digital.
      You can complete that section traditionally and apply the core content of the lessons to traditional work as well.

    • @viglakielefteria4443
      @viglakielefteria4443 Год назад

      @@ProkoTV Thank you ! However , I would like to know what equipment I need to learn to color digitally. Can you recommend me what device and software to use, please ? And also, to complete the course traditionally what material should I use ? Markers , color pencils or something else ?

    • @ProkoTV
      @ProkoTV  Год назад

      That's not really something that I can decide for you without knowing a whole lot about your hardware, software preference and more. I like Wacom tablets but a lot of people use iPads and the Apple pencil now.
      For doing the coloring traditionally, use whichever medium you like best. Markers are great but expensive. Use what you have on hand first and then change it up if you feel the need.

  • @RedGallardo
    @RedGallardo Год назад +1

    I... don't understand how do people draw that much that well. Maybe I am broken after all. I can't physically get the good. Not even 1% of that good. Years of studies gave me nothing. I don't have a billion years and if I had I'd burn out the first 100 years. After this neverending failure. Seeing all these artworks makes me wanna hang myself. I have 0 chance, no fractions. Maybe I should indeed stop looking at others' art at all. It's literally like looking at birds dreaming of wings I'll never have. It only hurts.
    I'll yell at whoever says "you just need to practice". 20 fking years. If that practice wasn't enough, maybe it's time for me to go. I'm at point 0 but now I'm old and tired and the world is falling apart around me, filled with idiots and maniacs. Screw this all. Enjoy your godlike skills. That's freaking cheating. No way these people aren't immortals who have spent 20 billion years on their skills. They must have been learning all my life's experience every day. That's impossible! Damn...

    • @chujiwu68
      @chujiwu68 Год назад

      You truly have my sympathies. I haven't tried even a fraction as hard as you have, but I totally relate. This was my first time watching a Proko video in years because I gave up years ago, yet here I am for some reason. 🫂

  • @OnionSavoya-jf5hz
    @OnionSavoya-jf5hz 7 месяцев назад

    I feel like the average comic is so complex now. With multiversity and infinite variants and timelines. I feel like the what actually works is actually forgotten.

    • @ProkoTV
      @ProkoTV  7 месяцев назад

      Take a hop over to some indie comics! They don't need to have a character on the street and fighting space wars all the time. there are great stories in comics from the biggest western companies but there are others out there that might give you more of what you're looking for too.

  • @Ariana-024
    @Ariana-024 Год назад

    I thought that the way i wanted to express my creativity would be through writing a lengthy book but boy was i so wrong

  • @hanzlopez5888
    @hanzlopez5888 Год назад +1

    That's it.

  • @leondominguez9386
    @leondominguez9386 3 месяца назад

    ❤❤❤

  • @jay-wu8fj
    @jay-wu8fj 5 месяцев назад

    how to write a proper story of comic

  • @royaebrahim2449
    @royaebrahim2449 Год назад

  • @derryberry16
    @derryberry16 Год назад +1

    You said 300lbs Bristol paper but what GSM? 300lbs is hard to understand because its not accurate. Please give us a clear understanding and make this more accessible to your worldwide audience. Only America measures oranges and Ariana Grandes. We don't understand this sorcery

  • @SP8inc
    @SP8inc Год назад

    This looks awesome, but the cost is pretty high for a broke artist like me, especially one not paid in dollars.

  • @samankucher5117
    @samankucher5117 Год назад

    oh nice :0

  • @alisonmcglone750
    @alisonmcglone750 Год назад +1

    Still lead a gouache course. Please

    • @ProkoTV
      @ProkoTV  Год назад +1

      We've always got new courses in development. We'll keep that in mind!

    • @alisonmcglone750
      @alisonmcglone750 Год назад +1

      @@ProkoTV ty. It’s a nagging one for me.

  • @antonioolarte4369
    @antonioolarte4369 Год назад

    Proko in spanish please 😔

  • @watermxrk
    @watermxrk Год назад +1

    $249 wow too much

  • @notablevirtues
    @notablevirtues Год назад

    Really long course commercial

  • @M.a.r-V
    @M.a.r-V 11 месяцев назад +1

    Marvel's storytelling is really bad nowadays! So I would skip that part and writing.

  • @Dookie_Blaster
    @Dookie_Blaster Год назад +3

    I trust Proko but I dont trust modern day Marvel comics. Are their artists running out of work or something? lol

    • @ProkoTV
      @ProkoTV  Год назад +12

      We respect the instructors we got for this course. They work hard and are incredibly busy, taking their time to work and share their skills with us and our students.
      We ask that you do the same. Trash talk a company as much as you want but respect the individuals.
      We were lucky enough to get Eisner-level talent and some of the most sought-after pros who work for big publishers and on creator-owned books. They're not just some Marvel factory workers.

    • @samtonnude941
      @samtonnude941 Год назад +1

      @@ProkoTV Absolutely agree with this bro.💪

    • @princessunicorn9267
      @princessunicorn9267 Год назад +2

      I would say it's most of the writers fault. Some artists have nothing to do with the story. Writers are literally telling the artists what to do. And if it's not the writer, it's the editor that's telling the writer.

  • @paulwoodford1984
    @paulwoodford1984 Год назад

    I don’t want to pay for this course so i won’t watch it. It’s all free on youtube anyway. Not like this guy needs the money