What If SHANE Was in The Ones Who Live! If Shane Survived in The Walking Dead The Ones Who Live Rick

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 2 окт 2024
  • Save up to 40% off the best Father’s Day gift at ridge.com/drake through June 15th. Sponsored by Ridge.
    Last year I made a video called What If Shane survived where I showed what I thought would happen with Shane still alive in the main show of The Walking Dead and now that The Walking Dead The Ones Who Live has at least for now wrapped up that Rick Grimes and CRM storyline, let's pick up from where we left off in that video, with Shane being the one in that Consignee jacket at the end of the The Walking Dead season 11 when Rick Grimes returned.
    In this video we answer the question of what if Shane was in The Ones Who Live? What would Shane do differently to what Rick Grimes did? How different would the series have turned out along with the Daryl Dixon series where Daryl and Carol are in France and Maggie and Negan are in Dead City with Negan getting another villain arc where it will potentially be Negan vs Rick Grimes?
    What do YOU think would happen if Shane was in The Ones Who Live? Would you have preferred if this happened? What other characters do you want me to do What Ifs on? Let me know what you think down below. Thanks for watching. I'll see you soon.
    Press the LIKE button on the video if you enjoyed it and subscribe if you're new, thank you for your support!
    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    ►Follow my NEW TikTok account! / georgedrakegd
    ►Follow me on Twitter!
    / georgedrakegd
    ►Follow my Instagram!
    / georgedrakeyt
    ►Join the official Discord!
    / discord
    ►Follow me on Twitch!
    / george_drake
    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Business Enquiries: georgedrakebusiness@gmail.com
    All audio content and resources used is my own and/or taken from the RUclips Audio Library and licensed. Permissions and links shown below. This is fair use and original content.
    -----------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Let's be real, if you've read this far down in the description, you should probably subscribe.
    #TheWalkingDead #TWD #TheWalkingDeadSeason11 #TheWalkingDeadRickGrimes #RickGrimes

Комментарии • 78

  • @GeorgeDrakeGD
    @GeorgeDrakeGD  4 месяца назад +7

    Save up to 40% off the best Father’s Day gift at ridge.com/drake through June 15th. Thank you to Ridge for sponsoring today's video!
    What do YOU think would happen if Shane was in The Ones Who Live? Would you have preferred if this happened? What other characters do you want me to do What Ifs on? Let me know what you think down below. Thanks for watching. I'll see you soon.
    Press the LIKE button on the video if you enjoyed it and subscribe if you're new, thank you for your support!

  • @name4195
    @name4195 4 месяца назад +9

    I 100% agree about Shane swearing on the sword.

  • @generalfilms9947
    @generalfilms9947 4 месяца назад +33

    Shane would have flashbacks if Okafor told him he blew Atlanta up

  • @KobaSteele
    @KobaSteele 4 месяца назад +2

    Can you do what if Tara never Dead

  • @legohenry620
    @legohenry620 4 месяца назад +2

    And after all this time, I still have a question- will there be The Ones Who Live season 2? I will stop asking, it, if I and somebody too will get an answer on this question.
    P.S also you should do, what if Lee was in the main show or comics?

  • @vespu1a
    @vespu1a 4 месяца назад +47

    can’t believe we got what if Shane survived part 2 before gta 6

    • @clownworld360
      @clownworld360 4 месяца назад +5

      i would like to see a big plot twist shane betrays crm and saves ricks plot and gets an heros ending

    • @austinhedges9776
      @austinhedges9776 4 месяца назад +2

      Well atleast we already got the trailer

    • @byeah4823
      @byeah4823 4 месяца назад +2

      @@austinhedges9776we wouldn’t have gotten the trailer if the game wasn’t leaked

    • @HerbCoswellBornAgain
      @HerbCoswellBornAgain 4 месяца назад +2

      Me too.

    • @ehh622
      @ehh622 4 месяца назад +2

      This joke will never get old 😂

  • @techsitkunkiew
    @techsitkunkiew 4 месяца назад +1

    Successful ty bro ❤❤🎉🎉 if It will come true 7:26 😂😂😂❤❤

  • @The-New-SlimShady
    @The-New-SlimShady 4 месяца назад +1

    Next can you make a video what if Daryl was the Leader

  • @Staysick17
    @Staysick17 4 месяца назад +1

    Who cares about Shane TWD so dead we're getting horrible content

  • @Mitsuri_Lover8456
    @Mitsuri_Lover8456 4 месяца назад +1

    What is Nick never died

  • @ismaelgingles9409
    @ismaelgingles9409 Месяц назад +1

    I personally think shane was killed off to early if they were going to kill him they should have done during the battle with Negan

  • @lisatso81
    @lisatso81 4 месяца назад +1

    I like it

  • @wesblanford3024
    @wesblanford3024 4 месяца назад +1

    Do a video on a what if TOWL ended differently then do what the 2nd season would be about.

  • @jamiemullen8674
    @jamiemullen8674 4 месяца назад +1

    If shane were in crm he be part of beales pshycotic plans

  • @Staysick17
    @Staysick17 4 месяца назад +1

    It would sucked

  • @Goji_Edits20240
    @Goji_Edits20240 18 дней назад

    What if Shane stayed whith Andrea and they left in season 2?

  • @DcGaming19
    @DcGaming19 4 месяца назад

    😮

  • @drew6717
    @drew6717 4 месяца назад +4

    At some point Rick became Shane
    Between loosing the prison and walking into Alexandria Rick was worse than Shan

  • @Snorelaxnum7
    @Snorelaxnum7 4 месяца назад +3

    This is epic

  • @ImJusMoney
    @ImJusMoney 4 месяца назад +15

    i love the what if series and i think a perfect video would be what if carl was in the ones who live it could also be a sequel to your what Carl survived

  • @ToxicatedGator
    @ToxicatedGator 4 месяца назад +2

    Did the thumbnail change? I swear Shane was on the left

    • @gohan7926
      @gohan7926 4 месяца назад

      Yeah he changed it

  • @Joshua_Graham2281
    @Joshua_Graham2281 4 месяца назад +5

    Hey can you do a comic what if? I was thinking what if Judith wasn’t killed during the prison escape? I was thinking that in this case Carl was carrying her instead of Lori

  • @deadmonkey6835
    @deadmonkey6835 4 месяца назад +12

    You should do what if clementine was part of Rick's group

    • @WilliamAfton524
      @WilliamAfton524 4 месяца назад +1

      Depends on what season that little girl Clem with join. The farm group would be a good start and I don’t think Shane would be against letting her into the group and I think she’d have plenty of good father/mother figures with her.

  • @deathbyteyo
    @deathbyteyo 3 месяца назад

    Honestly I wish he did get banished in season 2 and survived unlike the comments. He could've made an amazing protagonist

  • @Infinite-99
    @Infinite-99 4 месяца назад +3

    Imagine if when rick killed Shane we dont see Shane actually turn and he got picked up by the crm for rick to encounter in towl

  • @HerbCoswellBornAgain
    @HerbCoswellBornAgain 4 месяца назад +14

    This was really good. Absolutely love the ending too, especially with Shane doing the opposite of what Rick did at the end, and actually swearing to the sword. I love it.

  • @deecawford
    @deecawford 3 месяца назад

    Shane loved the entire Grimes family. Hell they all had their mental break downs. He had one early. I say bring him back as Shane’s brother

  • @ricgillingham8056
    @ricgillingham8056 2 месяца назад

    Shane's fall from grace is tragic he had a nervous breakdown were Rick remained carm and decent Shane fell more and more in desperation the games Corrie played with him just about tipped him over the edge no chance in having a family he gave in to violence and in the end was unsavable....a good decent man turned in to a monster a dark refection very sad 😔

  • @908Capo
    @908Capo 4 месяца назад +3

    What If Rick Grimes and Joel Miller swap roles.
    Joel in the Walking Dead and Rick In Last Of Us 1 and 2

  • @EdPelletier-yb5vl
    @EdPelletier-yb5vl 4 месяца назад

    What if Ed survived

  • @CryWolf-sm9iw
    @CryWolf-sm9iw 4 месяца назад

    What if Madison never left ?

  • @stanleylucas2924
    @stanleylucas2924 4 месяца назад +4

    Could you do what if merle survived

  • @megamayhamgaming1296
    @megamayhamgaming1296 4 месяца назад

    Shane is an A he is killed

  • @jonathandiaz4997
    @jonathandiaz4997 3 месяца назад

    1 month ago 😮

  • @HerbCoswellBornAgain
    @HerbCoswellBornAgain 4 месяца назад +8

    You should do "What If Negan killed Rick in the S7 lineup and Glenn took over as leader of the group?". As well as a continuation of your What If Carl survived video, maybe called "What If Carl was in the Daryl Dixon Show?".

  • @liittlemiissd
    @liittlemiissd 4 месяца назад

    What if Sophia had lived?

  • @Staysick17
    @Staysick17 4 месяца назад

    What if Beale didn't die?

  • @leonardobrilli5742
    @leonardobrilli5742 4 месяца назад

    What ifff Shaaaaane wass in the ones who livvve?

  • @wesblanford3024
    @wesblanford3024 4 месяца назад +2

    This video is a fine piece of work

  • @guilliman1990
    @guilliman1990 4 месяца назад +1

    If Shane lived we never see negan no whispers no nothing

  • @Tedbigman9877
    @Tedbigman9877 3 месяца назад

    do what if carl was in the ones who live

  • @dragonballradiant2744
    @dragonballradiant2744 4 месяца назад

    Dixon, I doubt wouldn’t ever be able to get on board with Shane. He will probably hit the road. Again with Merle. He found out what happened with Randall. First. So he wouldn’t be able to trust Shane. Who is he going to kill next? Once his leader ship is threatened. I like Shane leaving the group. And ending up one of the savior lieutenants. Best. I feel like Michonne ends up at Woodbury regardless. And Shane, Andrea, become savior lieutenants. I like your version, but this is more what I would like to see. The reason why Michonne wouldn’t really like. Shane. Is because of his manipulation tactics. They’re similar to what the governor would do. And you saw what happened with that. Maybe Michonne’s and Andrea. Do still travel together. But split up for some reason prior to the helicopter crash. And she ends up with Shane and the saviors. Then Michonne’s, fights, Andrea. At the final confrontation with the saviors. When Eugene, breaks their guns. And Michonne’s wins. And put Andrea in jail. With Shane, Negan, And they all have to earn their freedom. Same as. Negan. Pretty much everything with Dwight, ends up the same. Dixon decides to let him go. To honor Carl. RJ still happens. But still with Rick. Shane and Andrea. Disappear after they earn their freedom. Realizing they would be ostracized from the group.negan, still stays. Because of his relationship with Judith And Lydia. So everything following is still the same. Until the one to live. And that’s where. Shane, Andrea, Rick and Michonne. Rivalry would reach a climax. In the finale. General bill wouldn’t die. Even though I’m not against that. I just think it was too quick. Instead, he would be critically wounded and in a coma. And his son would take over. Beginning a generational rivalry. With RJ and Judith Grimes. Shane, Andrea, kids. Sorry if it’s kind of long. But if you have time, let me know what you think. Daryl Dixon, would eventually find himself. At Alexandria anyway. After some goofy scheme by merle. Get him killed by another group. But more on the outskirts. Until after the war. Because he doesn’t like Shane because of the stuff that happened with Randall. Merle can get killed, by the reapers. Or one of his biker gang buddies. From before the apocalypse. That managed to catch up with him. Either is fine with me. Dixon would never be able to get on board with Shane. He didn’t even like him before the Randall thing. I can’t really see him being OK. With him murdering Rick. It just doesn’t fit for me.

  • @vjvtobar9736
    @vjvtobar9736 4 месяца назад +2

    What if Glenn died before the lineup ?

  • @Ryan-ok12096
    @Ryan-ok12096 4 месяца назад +1

    Anime is overrated

    • @byeah4823
      @byeah4823 4 месяца назад

      Who asked

    • @byeah4823
      @byeah4823 4 месяца назад

      nvm ur just an npc

  • @GleenQuagmire-lb7km
    @GleenQuagmire-lb7km 3 месяца назад

    What if John Dorie survived

  • @CheeseGrater-ki5lu
    @CheeseGrater-ki5lu 4 месяца назад +5

    Nice to see the previous what ifs are being continued into the spin-off era.

  • @remakestudios2020
    @remakestudios2020 4 месяца назад +2

    George Drake please can you do video about The Walking Dead What If Jacqui don't stay in CDC and came with Rick's Group, what's story change in this way. Please doing I and anothers wants to see this story because is very interesting.

  • @leonardosamuel6528
    @leonardosamuel6528 3 месяца назад

    Creo que shane en the wan who lives, sería leal a la república cívica militar, nadie iría a buscarlo, le diría a el general beale donde están las comunidades y luego lo terminaría matando.

  • @crizle5259
    @crizle5259 4 месяца назад +4

    100k 🎉

  • @EveningShadeLori
    @EveningShadeLori 4 месяца назад +3

    I never saw Shane as a villain. I saw him as a very strong survivor. I hated what the writers made him do to Otis, They could have at least written the scene better because the way it played out there was no need for it. They were almost to the truck. Anyway Shane would soon realized he didn't love Lori that it was just a trauma bond with benefits. The fact that Lori was pregnant. Thats what pushed him over the edge and viewed Rick as an obstacle-and at the time he was beginning to view Rick as weak and Shane didn't agree with many of Ricks new decisions. I could see where he was coming from. The thought of Rick making all the rules for the new baby made Shane over react. Even if Shane would have come to his censes that night the herd hit the farm and made it to the prison. I believe Rick and Shane both being Alpha dogs would not stay as one group long. But while still together would have taken out the Govenor and Shane and Andrea would have taken over as leaders of the Govenor's group. Somehow the Govenor's doctor (I forgot his name) would have done a paternity test on Judith and Rick would find out he actually is Judith bio Dad-not Shane. By then Adrea would be preg.& happy with Shane then later down the road they would have all ended up fighting Negan. Anyway, I have a entire storyline for how the two groups would have come back together. LOL But this is all for now

    • @cloneboi6681
      @cloneboi6681 4 месяца назад

      The truck was still far and they both were hurt,also the walkers are still fast at this point.i don’t think both of them would of made it no matter what and i think Shane knew that too.there was a video on it I forgot the name tho

  • @sehvlo0254
    @sehvlo0254 4 месяца назад +2

    W Shane arc

  • @laverniustucker8198
    @laverniustucker8198 4 месяца назад +1

    Geroge, please do What If Carl and Enid lead the Commonwealth? Essentially what if they both survived

  • @davef3932
    @davef3932 4 месяца назад +1

    Enjoyed this but can't get on board with Carol looking for Shane over Daryl. In this situation yes I can see her looking Shane at some point but definitely not before Daryl

  • @vjvtobar9736
    @vjvtobar9736 4 месяца назад +1

    What if Morgan went with Rick to Atlanta also what is Milton survived and what if Bob survived

  • @adamskywalker9113
    @adamskywalker9113 4 месяца назад +1

    That’s exactly what happens. But he has Judith! His own daughter

  • @Johndoriescolt
    @Johndoriescolt 4 месяца назад +1

    Totally agree with analysis on the crm’s ending. Since Dead City now has 8 episodes for s2 I’m hoping the ones who live can get renewed and have the more runtime it deserves. There is still a potentially interesting story with the spies Beale briefly mentioned but variant walkers seem like the direction the universe is going to me. Hopefully that’s more interesting.

  • @michaelashayagori2255
    @michaelashayagori2255 4 месяца назад +2

    What if Andrea survived because of comics

  • @holdentudiks9390
    @holdentudiks9390 4 месяца назад +1

    You should make a alternative to this if Shane left in s2 like he wanted and falls in with the crm and Rick finding him later when he’s captured in s9

  • @WilliamBoulet-vb7vk
    @WilliamBoulet-vb7vk 4 месяца назад +1

    They should make a what if series but with other scenarios

  • @THEGOVERNOR117
    @THEGOVERNOR117 4 месяца назад +4

    I’ve actually cant imagine Shane living past season 3 I personally think his head would be in the Governors fish tank and the rest of the group fed to walkers also it would be very annoying hearing him talk about Ricks family as if they were his own

    • @RickGrimezTWD
      @RickGrimezTWD 4 месяца назад

      shane wasnt governors family member 💀
      the heads in the fish tank was the governors family members if i recall
      if shane actually lived past season 3
      (yea rick isint dead shane and rick both make it out)
      shane would probably leave as he planend to or he would be banished

  • @DownBadCristal
    @DownBadCristal 4 месяца назад +1

    A very interesting video I love the punisher clip ins 😊

  • @jamesbounds
    @jamesbounds 4 месяца назад +3

    Great editing of Shane in the scenes.

  • @Eddieavina123
    @Eddieavina123 4 месяца назад +2

    Love your video and keep up the great work you are awesome

  • @WilliamAfton524
    @WilliamAfton524 4 месяца назад +2

    “M’aska somethin Beale”

  • @byeah4823
    @byeah4823 4 месяца назад +1

    1:43 bro casually calls out every shane fanboy