There is NOT one Qur’an - Qira'at Conundrum - Episode 16
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 сен 2024
- Muslims are forced to say the Qur’an is perfectly preserved - but based on all of the evidence, the Qur’an is not perfectly preserved.
Muslim scholars are also making claims that they cannot support and prove true.
In the end, with all of the evidence, there has never been just one Qur’an - and certainly not any from the 7th century.
Al Fadi and Dr Jay wrap up our series in this video.
Watch the videos in this series:
• There is more than one...
Follow CIRA International:
Facebook: / cirainternational
Website: www.cirainterna...
Support Al Fadi:
Patreon: / cirainternational
Website: cirainternatio...
Dr. Jay Smith:
Patreon: / pfander
RUclips: / pfanderfilms
About CIRA International
CIRA's mission and goal is to; create awareness about Islam as a religion and political movement; inform and challenge the Church concerning outreach and evangelism to Muslims, equip the believers with effective outreach tools, and advance the Gospel message among our Muslim neighbors & communities so that the vast majority of Muslims will begin a Gospel conversation with a Christ-follower.
CIRA exists to mobilize the Body of Christ across North America, and globally, to more effectively reach Muslims with the Gospel, by discipling and equipping believers, and by empowering church and community leaders to influence the Muslim world for Christ.
Bingo! The size of the tablets must be the size of the Middle East to contain all the changes and corrections. There is one Quran, it is in the Nile river or was it burned by Uthman? The fairytale, known as the Quran is so bad Disney wouldn’t make a movie of this. To tie a bow on this story, it’s GAME OVER!
Another nail in the coffin of islam.
Islam has never ever faced a massive crisis like this. And it is indeed MASSIVE!!
If Allah aka Muhammad sees the Qurans circulating worldwide today, he will be confused 🤷♀️ and he will deny all of them. Even Uthman who standardized the Qurans will distant himself from the Qurans circulating worldwide today
Allah didn't know they were 7 sleepers in the cave. Surah Kaaf 18:22 Allah says Maybe they were 3 and the dog was the 4th or maybe they were 6 Men and the dog was the 7th lol.
@@mukhtaradan5717 Muhammad was Allah
@@lastprophet8338 I'm a ex Muslim
@@mukhtaradan5717 Allah got too sleepy in the "arms of the dog" and messed up the story.
@@boobsruntube6541 Allah wasn't sure how many Guys were in the cave I guess Muhammad heard that story Orally so he wasn't sure of details.
No muslim will dare to put all their sources and claims in a timeline bar, as all of their claims will be exposed and does not make sense.
Would you bring forward a proof of your books?
Of course no!
@@ahmedh5596 tap dancing?? still waiting for answer/s from Muslims....
@@11385djg just answered you if you care to read.
@@ahmedh5596 still no answer?? If feel sorry for you Muslims. Try look for answer somewhere else and maybe you’ll find a better answer and reply back.
@@11385djg I’m grateful to you for feeing sorry for me, means a world to me.
But why are you avoiding the question you posed on Muslims?
Why don’t you provide and prove the dates ect so we all follow you instead of our ‘false religion’
The job ahead is immense, may God almighty fill you with Holy Spirit immeasurably to achieve that goal for you brothers
Jobless works that prove to the world the necessity of Islam.
Try this bombshell. RUclips : CAESAR'S MESSIAH.Also go to Bhagavad-gita sura 4 verse 11. The Bhagavad-gita far outclasses the Quran and the Bible as the ORIGINAL scripture.
The author of the quran did not know much about planet earth as Quran 2:187 tells muslims to fast from sunrise to sunset during ramadan.
There are over 100 Million square kilometres of planet earth that can go weeks and even months without a sunrise or sunset during ramadan, which makes this verse impossible to obey in these places.
Allah will punish people who live in places like that. They are dogs and devils.
@@mikegreen2229 Allah didn't know these places existed. 😆
It also applies to space travel meaning that as one is in space the direction of Mecca/Petra becomes impossible to maintain a direction of prayer because both the person praying, the movement of the earth and the movement of the sun in it's galactic spin. Add in that even a colony of Mars would not be able to hole a direction of prayer. Muslims are stuck forever on earth.
That why the month of Ramadan is not fixed in the year ... it follows the lunar calendar ...
@@nunuandmiaostudio So to the Orthodox setting of Passover and Roshashon (sic) but it does not move through the year.
Thank you, Al Fadi for these short explorations on the topic! It makes thr whole thing clearer and easier to chew. God bless you and Dr Jay Smith!
Hi Al Fadi and Jay. I see Hatun has destroyed Islam at speakers Corner. Yeh she asked if Allah had a son and this old muslim guy would not answer and put up his folder to Hatun so he could not see her. I realise why she asking because if Allah does not have a son then Allah is not God, Because God Has Jesus his son... So this means Islam has no connection to the Bible at all, so the Quran is cut in half. Good luck Islam.
@@kevinunderwood9980 😂😂😂 what the heck are you even uttering lol. Hatun has been destroyed so many times in debates she dont even gets attention anymore. So many christians are converting to islm in speakers corner and never have i seen anyone convert to Christianity. Hatun speaks only about islam she never preaches about Christianity because she knows nobody will listen lol. And allah cannot he god without having a son?!?!?!?!?! Did you really just say this blasphemous statement. You think god is like humans he has a son or whatever. God is one he does not beget neither is he begotten
Many would take up guns before they would research the differences between the different korans.
actually turah&bible were from god but they had been corrupted afterwards as a result god sent down quran upon prophet muhammed&god said i`ll preserved the quran thereby god had fulfilled ,let me show u friendly&honestly the truth,okee dokee.sheding the light on christianity to know the truth first of all there is no original bible the 4 main bible are contradicted to each other yet there is 1 quran but who is the writer of bible the answer is paul the jewish who hates jesus let us discuss about the significant event which is crucifixion why does your claimed god left his only son to crucify without any sin he had committed the disaster reached its uttermost when u found bible said on the tongue of jesus my god my god why do u forsaken me means jesus never crucified willingly have u an idea why do they crucify jesus because it`s a penalty of impure &particularly crucifixion because dindn`t touched the earth make it impured that what paul said jeasus get impure for us &see the authentic god what does said in quran chapter 3 verse 55 by the name of god the most gracious&most merciful ,
O Jesus, I will take you and raise you up to me, and purify you from those who disbelieve, and He will place those who follow you above those who disbelieve until the Day of Resurrection, then to Me is your return, so I will judge between you regarding that in which you differed,the authentic god rose jesus to the sky before they kill him in addition he had purified him from a false accusation that he is impure,let alone of many verses in the bible incites to violence thus u found the largest massacres had happened in history the ww1&2 christian countries against christian countries 100 millions had been killed not to mention the sex stories in the bible nay u never found a single sex word in quran,don`t take it in personal just i clarify u the plain truth,bible said woman when she during the menstruation she gets impure &any thing she would touched it will be impure &should stay at her room till had done of it don`t see that an insulting to woman &how does the claimed god in bible said so he demeans& underrates his own creatures, yet islam honored the woman &she has a complete chapter its name women show us her rights,let us look at modern medicine which refutes the bible, ovulalation happens every 28 days from overy next month from other ovary when fertilization fails to happen mestrual bleading happens it always stops when a female gets pregnant ,menstrual cycle ovulation the female genital system consists of one uterus to overuse vagine& externat genital organs ,,the blood during menstruation could cause diseases to spread and that’s why a woman during her menstruation needed to isolate so the blood would not be passed around to other people And diseases not be spread that`s what god said in quran and they ask you about menstruation say, isolate women don't come near them untill they get purified verse 222 chapter 2,why there are priests,pastors&nuns reverted daily to islam,yet u never a muslim clergy left islam as per western media said that islam is the fastest growing religion in the world,i didn`t like to push islam onto u god said no compulsion in religion verse 256 chapter 2,figure it out then make up your mind ruclips.net/video/LEKgxZbFG_k/видео.html
Convincely concluded. Bravo to Dr.Jay Smith & Al Fadi you both now can rest your case.
So brave servant of God. Bless you bro🙏
Did you know with all the different Quran, still they all state monotheism and you will never go astray to be thrown in HELL?!
So brave that he won’t sit with someone who could answer his nonsense.
@@ahmedh5596 Jay Smith has been talking to Muslims about this stuff for years lol. I’m sure that if there was a convincing answer for the things he is teaching he would acknowledge that.
Bro Al Fadi is a gem. Praise God for guiding him to the right path 👏🏼👏🏼♥️✝️
Praise the Lord Jesus Christ. 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Jesus, the Word of God is Eternal...not the bible. Great program/series 👍, most needful!
The word is not eternal and Jesus is not that word if he was the word eternal in complete simultaneous synergy situation god he would not have prayed to be removed from cruciFICTION with such intensity that his sweat turned to blood 🩸 the condition is called HEMOTOHYDROSIS which can be brought about by intense extreme emotional STRESS Jesus ain’t the word. He ain’t even a letter secondly the entire concept is pagan taken from Greek philosophy which was intern taken from the Canaanites when Philip of maccedon conquered the middle east before his son Alexander refer to the ugaritic text of the canaanites said to predate the Old Testament come back to earth Kirk
@@lorenzochimelis7359 I agree with you that the Quran is wrong.
@@lorenzochimelis7359 so 72 virgins in paradise is not fiction?
@@lorenzochimelis7359 Nothing you have written undermines the truth of Christianity and claims of Christ. The concept of Logos or Word was/is found all over the world in philosophy long before Philip and at far greater distances away than Macedonia. For Christians Jesus is the Word (reason) and the wisdom of God. And yes Jesus sweat turned to blood. And yes He was under unimaginable stress before the crucifixion because for the first time He would be separated from His Father as He bore the sins of the world. But He said He laid down His life and no one could take it from Him (John 10).
@@trufoshure1341 thank you for admitting it IS A INTERNATIONAL PAGAN CONCEPT common not only in pagan religions but pagan mythologies also now you wed was that so had to admit .... lol the reality is this Philip of macedon got it from the canaanites and it you have ever read the EUGARITIC of the canaanites you sill see it u sill not Ben see the. Inception of the MARDUK and NU NUDIMMUD one being the architect and the other the builder via the plan of the other. SOUND FAMILIAR well it should this is where you get the concept of god creating all tunings through Jesus so thank u for your comment you are most kind
The bible said already, false prophets will come and will deceive many... Who is the last prophet their telling.. Muhamaad is the last prophet..dont tell that the false prophets the first come in this world..muhamaad deceive many already..
Thank God for your life Bro Al Fadi, may God continually bless you and your family. God bless!
What a fool you are?! Do you believe whatever anybody tells you?!
Go and find out for yourself that the Quran never misguide you, my friend. The main thing is Monotheism, and believe that you are responsible for your deeds in the afterlife, and nobody can save you, but the "GOD the King of the World", who created you!
@@kouroshmemari2450 why are you trying to preach monotheism to monotheists? James 2:19 You believe that there is one God. Good! Even the demons believe that--and shudder.
Brother Al Fadi, this should be season 1. It's a very interesting subject!
God bless you AL fadi and Jay Smith
they get what they deserved... this claim totally backfired them
Faith is in the HART and MIND and NOT in the BOOKS!
Faith in what?
Interesting information! God bless these brothers
I love your series but one small criticism.. Please don’t keep saying that Muhammad received the Quran from the Angel Gabriel.. He didn’t he (if he actually existed in the first place) Simply suffered his first attack of Temporal Frontal Lobe Epilepsy in the cave on Mount Hira.. Muhammad was a fraudster and a charlatan.. Islam is a lie ..
in fact, most Christian priest denying the existence of this heavenly
book called " Gospel"..accordingly to narrative,after Jesus ( p.b.u.h)
ascencion to heaven,the Jews burned or somehow destroy the book..
at that time..,the gospel was not widely known yet ..for Jesus( p.b.u.h)
period was about 3 years .and those who believed him we're quite few
most of whom were illiterate peasant.for this reason another copy
of gospel couldn't written.only Jesus had committed to it's memory..
today's Bible are not original words of god..
@@aldredtawasil9339 really so when did the Bible get corrupted then @aldred Tawasil can you give me a date for this ..
@@trevorgriffiths5611,Bible corruption? the Bible as well underwent many changes.in fact the Bible was translated from Hebrew into
Greek and from Greek into Latin,was re- examined by various council
,e.g by the Nicene council was held with the command of Constantine
the great in 325 A.D.. by the council of ludicia( laodicen) in 364A.D
by the council of Istanbul in 381 A.D.
by the Carthaginian council in 397A.D.
by the Ephesus council in 431 A.D.
by the council of kadikoy and by many other council,
was re- arranged at each councils, some parts were changed
at each time..some books were exercised from the old testament
while some books that had been rejected by the previous council
were re- admitted.when Protestant sect appeared in 930 A.D[ 1524 C.E] these books were examined again and new changes were made.
during this long period, many christians,theologian raised objections
to these translation and changes and argued some parts of holy Bible
were addition,falsification,interpolation..
@@aldredtawasil9339 Great isn’t it Aldred Tawasil .. at least it’s got a pedigree.. The Quran on the other hand is pure fantasy fiction made up as a tool for Arabs to conquer and subjugate once free people... Nothing divine about the plagiarised nonsense in the Quran..
@@trevorgriffiths5611 who's plagiarised book? maybe it your corrupted Bible not the holy Quran...
What Shia had been telling from the beginning is true then. I think 'The lady of heaven' movie will cover all those incidents that are not allowed to speak in public in islamic countries.
Wrong advise.
Muslims don’t read.
Please make the playlist of each topic containing all the videos related to that topic
I like the way you said that Jesus is the straight path in the end of the video
Beloved I don't know you in person but God knows you well God reveal a revelation to me when I was going through your profile to observe things about your spiritual life.
while I was meditating, I saw a divine breakthrough in your life and I saw evil attack of the enemies manipulating on seizing your favour and to come against your hand work for you to be confused and lost hope. As I was praying the Lord reveal to me and instruct you to sow a seed into the life of a baby suffering from leukemia in children of Saviour motherless foundation, located Edo state, Nigeria, before the end of tomorrow and let me know so I can join you in prayers deeply because he want to manifest his promises in your life and that of your family
Nobody should know about the seed is between you and God, you will testify to the Glory of God after you have done it if only you believe in him and do what he says Proverb (3:27;21:26;22:9 ,,Deu.28:1-5) contact the MD of the orphanage foundation WhatsApp:( +2349069326186 )or Email:(saviourfoundation39@gmail.com) send your donation to them.God bless you......
Many Qur'ans, many muhammads
Sura 29 aya 27 says WHAT all muslims will not accept......Koran verifies the Prophethood ONLY comes thru the line of Jacob and (Jesus or Iesa) not Ishmael where mooohammad claims his lineage is. If allah is their God of the old testament then that God cannot lie and it states Jesus [messiah] shall come through the line of Jacob according to Moses. Duet 18/18-19.
That is one thing that sends them running for the hills everytime. I noticed when I confront Muslims with that along with a challenge to prove that Muhammad is a descendant of Isaac and Jacob, they disappear really fast. Another interesting note. Sheikh Yasir Qadhi recently admitted that Isaac, not Ishmael was the child of the promise and that Muhammeds companions and the vast majority of early Muslims knew this.
@@user-vw1qn1er1l Sheikh Yasir Qadhi and mohammad hajib are THE poster boys for all Christians in his confessions, which are coming out slowly but never the less they are coming out besides stating there is HOLES in their narratives about Moohammad and the quran and about Jesus Christ being a Prophet 'messenger' from God,yet they refuse to believe his words. -----> It is coming whatever is hide shall be spoken on roof tops......----> islam is being exposed
@@dudeduderinoduderino9689 They are the two top anti-islam apologists, producing more ex-muslims than all others combined.🤣🤣🤣 I do have a couple videos in my "Mo false prophet" playlist about Yasir Quadis recent admission concerning Isaac. I think that is very helpful to include when talking to Muslims. Islam is collapsing. I hear most of Iran is now non-muslim majority. Other middle eastern countries are also having apostasy issues. Jesus is coming soon. God bless!
@@user-vw1qn1er1l could you give a link to that as I have to seen nor heard of it, thanks in advance.
@@dudeduderinoduderino9689 RUclips won't allow the posting of links. They get automatically deleted. You can find two videos in my Mo false prophet playlist. One is by Sam Shamoun, right underneath is the original video by Yasir Qadhi. Feel free to subscribe. I have alot of very helpful content. 🙂
The Qur'ans are the sahaba
Just got my warsh and hafs in the mail today, I'm ready to do some exposing lol
Bro learn Arabic first, I swear the weirdest people try to do most absurd things smh follow what Jordan Peterson says at least instead of these guys
@@shumthinspecial Al Fadi speaks Arabic, so does that make his arguments valid?
@@mikegreen2229 lmao I was hoping something would say this ... the fact that fadi speaks Arabic makes him more of a deceptive person because he’s not being truthful clearly
Majority of Muslims aren’t native Arabic speakers BUT we learn Classical Arabic which is the root of all types of Arabic.... to understand this is simple
Classical English vs New age English
It’s totally different even the grammar and use of words
Fadi speaks modern Arabic which he can still use to TRY and decipher the Quran but IRONICALLY modern Arabic speakers (like fadi) must refer to the Quran Arabic for definitions and meaning of root words.
He knows this but won’t say it. Let him go on Mufti Menks podcast or RUclips channel and try this.
@@silverltc2729 they speak modern day Arabic ... we learn the Classical Arabic ya Akki
Learning modern day Arabic is plus and comes easy when you know the roots of the language from the Quran. And the test for all of you is evident in the living language spoken today so you can go back and see the proofs yourself
@@silverltc2729 yo bro just stop
We were made into separate tribes and groups so that we may recognize each other.
✌🏽✌🏼✌🏿✌🏾✌🏻
Hello team You are doing a great work.... Textual criticism is the write way to do it.... it was really helpful, this whole series....! Carry on with unwrapping the mask. Hoping to see more of this
"FACTS" in the coming days......
Febin Augustine
Al Fadi and Jay Smith are so frustrated about Islam as the fastest growing religion thousands are converting as we speak they spent their whole life attacking Islam they go round and round like donkeys around a mill stone about the Quran but can't prove anything.
@@farookdinaully8029 Friend i believe i can understand your feelings....let me make myself clear, am not against your freedom of belief....!! I was appreciating the way they are doing it, i mean the textual criticism....rather than taking the way of violence ........ we might have different opinions....and i do believe we all have the right to express it, through any means of non-violence...!! If Bible must go through Textual criticism then that should apply to all other Religious Books that i believe is reasonable...!! As far as i can see they are pointing out some historical mismatches........and i believe there is enough proof to take them into consideration............ If you have any difference in opinion ...you are free to point it out with supporting proof..... And for me, to an extend, i do not doubt the existence of Mohammed..... as Dan Gibson himself has pointed out this fact....!!
Beef, sheep, goat, chicken, etc biryani same as Qur'ans - MSG
Quran is just 35 years old ! Wow, it's much older than me ! 🤣 🤣 🤣
As a Christian, I've interacted with many Muslims and most of them haven't even heard of the Hadiths. Those are the extra writings in Islam. They claim there's only one Quran when in fact there's more than 30 Qurans. All of which are completely different in wording. Most of the world use the Hafs version of the Quran, while in the northern area of Africa they use the Warsh version.
When I talk with Muslims, everything topic in the Quran that I ask them, they reply; "where does the Quran say that?". I was teaching them their own Quran. Muslims claim that the Bible is corrupted, but the Quran confirms the inspiration and preservation of the Bible. The Quran denies the resurrection of Christ, yet the resurrection of Christ is the foundation of Christianity. The Quran contradicts the Bible. Muhammad wasn't even sure if he was saved.
I am not degrading the Quran or Muslims by any means, but I wish they would study. I care for our Muslim friends and I hope they one day come to the truth. Jesus is the truth
DIFFERENT ARABIC QURANS Warsh quranS, SEVEN different Hafs quranS, qaaluun quranS, al-doori quranS, Khalaf quranS, Khaaled QuranS, Ibn Zkwaan QuranS, Dori quranS, Ibn Jamas QuranS , Qunbul QuranS, Ibn Kathir quranS etc etc = ONE quran
See RUclips: CAESAR"S MESSIAH. Essential watching for every single Muslim and the work of Dr. Richard Carrier and Robert M. Price. See how frail both Christianity and Islam really are?
Nile goddess eat the Qur'ans
Thank you for such a wonderful project and so much quality content. May many Muslims find true peace in Jesus Christ. ❤
Markmusatau1829.
Muslim don't have peace, because muhammad don't offer peace to them.
Infact whole muslim, their Aulloh and jibril prays and say peace to muhammad
Aylloh and jibril says:Peace uuuupon youuuu muhammad.
Muhammad is in great trouble, so he need peace.
If muhammad accept Christ Jesus, he will obtain peace from Jesus.
Destroyed completely good job brother jay n al fadi
dear jay
I have a doubt waiting for your clarification.
Mohd was born in 570
Got revelation and became a prophet in 610
So for the first 40 years of his life he was an ordinary man with an ordinary name
That is , for the first 40 years of his life he must have been loitering around with his ordinary name -
Khatum ?
O nly after he has attained the prophethood he must have been called Mohmed - praised one ? -
My question is
do we have any dicument that this man was living around mecca with his natural name ?
Obviously no. He was only known by name mohammad
Blessing to you , our brother-in-Christ ❤
Christ of the resurrection (The Messenger of the covenant) is good to listen to, but Jesus takes you to hell with himself! Did you not learn from what happened to his disciples?!
@@kouroshmemari2450 You clearly don't understand your own religion, let alone Christianity.
@@dillonraleigh421
Do you know why Jesus and his disciples had to be killed?!
18:20 (Deuteronomy)
"And as for a prophet who dares to speak in the name of 'I', which I did not say, or in the name of other gods, that prophet must be killed!"
@Zackery Peterson
I am not sure which verse you are talking about?!
If you talking about 18:20 (Deuteronomy), it is definitely for Jesus, since he confesses that he lied (11:42 John), as well as claimed to be GOD! (42:8 Isaiah)
If you are talking about the messenger of the covenant, it can't be, because this covenant is also mentioned in Quran, and Muhammad is also among all the other prophets, which means it is after Muhammad.
Major Prophecy Fulfilled* God's Messenger of the Covenant
[3:81] GOD took a covenant from the prophets, saying, "I will give you the scripture and wisdom. Afterward, a messenger will come to confirm all existing scriptures. You shall believe in him and support him." He said, "Do you agree with this, and pledge to fulfill this covenant?" They said, "We agree." He said, "You have thus borne witness, and I bear witness along with you."
Footnote
Muhammad Pledges to Support God's Messenger of the Covenant*
[33:7] Recall that we took from the prophets their covenant, including you (O Muhammad), Noah, Abraham, Moses, and Jesus the son of Mary. We took from them a solemn pledge.
Very impressive breakdown.
Muslims got it correct - JESUS IS THE WORD OF GOD - then why anything else?? -- No answer -- Case closed. Response should be to seek HIM and HIM alone...
About the 7th question: Do we know the date of the first complete Coran available and visible? Where is it? in which museum, in which library??
There is no One complete available Quran. The book was completed by more than 50 persons, for more than 200 years.The one in the Museum of Birmingham is even dated earlier than the Muhammad, and just before Othman.
The earliest Koran in its present form dates from 1924.
The answer is no. Do we have any similar proof about Bible and Torah? Find me the answer and I will be one of your followers.
THANK YOU JESUS ❤️ (Micah 5 : 2) !
See RUclips: CAESAR'S MESSIAH. It will open you r Christian eyes, my friend!!!
So true
Next, explain why if one were to want a prophet after Jesus, Joseph Smith (Mormonism) has a much better claim than Muhammad (better preserved holy book, better chains of witnesses, better theology, does not accuse Jews and Christians of corruption, admits to adding to Bible, etc).
Just saying, some cult lesders are better than others...
@Majo Flinterman You missed my last line about cult leaders, didn't you?
@Majo Flinterman No wrong here, it's not like you insulted me or anything.
Happens to the best (even, me!)
As the bible teaches ( many false prophets)
@@stevenjohnson-yx1fl But the Bible missed something: the black stone.
I like to call it the sixth Infinity Stone, whose power is to turn anyone who kisses it into an utter imbecile.
Thanos would have won had he collected it...
@@el_killorcure yes the bible does not say anything about glory holes
You've had two great Jays on recently, if you add Jay Dyer. Good stuff, indeed!
Rudy: This is an Epoch in Islam. A MASSIVE RENAISSANCE IN ISLAM. Forcing Islam to answer each and every question of Al Fadi and Dr. Jay. ISLAM HAS NEVER EVER FACED A MASSIVE DEVASTATING CRISIS LIKE THIS.
Your episode ' there is not one Quran ' is absolutely right , because the followers of the different countries have not same view and donor want to talk on Muhammad.Mr Smith has elaborately made us know the differences among the Followers of Islam in the world.
KEEP IT UP FOR THE SAKE OF HUMANITY LOVE KINDNESS WOMEN POWER PROSPERITY DIGNITY AND HAPPINESS
I want watch this interview they brought
So many writters in Quran.
It's thier anylise study.
Why does God split the moon according to thier doctrine
Not logic.
Hi Al Fadi and Jay . Hatun has destroyed Islam at speakers corner. She asked the question , does Allah have a son, and this old guy would not answer and held up his folder so he couldn't see her. So Allah does not have son, so this means Allah is not God, because God has his son Jesus Christ. So if Allah is not God, then Islam has no claim to God or anything in the Bible, so Quran is cut in Half.
@@onlignebridge4224 Hello - It takes very little inteligence to know Islam is false, It is absolutely impossible that the same God created such diametrically opposed Religions, if that was the case he could not be God, because he would not be true to his charactor. 99.9% of people have no Idea why Islam Was created and by whoom..Muhammad was just a pawn in the conquest...... and it all backfired.... signed- simplistic.......
Sir if you are Muslim, go and do a deep dive into Islam and you will not be Muslim any more. - - Go chat with Christian Prince, he challenges any Muslim to show him something good about Islam and he will prove it wrong with the quran and the hadeths. He has degree in Arabic and also degree in Islamic studies, so you better know your stuff.... He knows the Quran better than the top Islamic scholars.... so go and tell him how good your religion is.... good luck, and you will need it....
Mohammed had sex with a nine year old girl and Muslims say that girls are sexually mature at nine years old ( child molesters)
I need your help
I MUST delete BOOK OF Esther from Bible and I must replace that FALSE book with book of Enoch□
Islam bursted!
Christianity busted too! See RUclips CAESAR"S MESSIAH.
👍👍EXPOSED BLIND☪️ULT
You should open your eyes first!
Did you know with all the different Quran, still they all state monotheism and you will never go astray to be thrown in HELL?!
@@kouroshmemari2450
IF YOU HAVE COURAGE THEN ANSWER MY QUESTION
1...NO MUSLIM CAN SHOW ME THAT ABRAHAM.ISAAC AND JACOB CALLED GOD AS ALLAH IN B.C HISTORICAL BOOK
@@ankur7773
Is this all you got?!
Allah has the same meaning to Arabs, as Ellahem, to Israelite.
Arabs most respected Idoles was named after Allah. so, instead of using a different name that most likely would have been rejected, our "LORD" made it easy for them and told them that is "HIM" but don't on earth for "HIM" and lookup.
What is with the names?! Call "HIM" the most respected names, you will be fine.
[7:180] To "GOD" belongs the most beautiful names; call upon Him therewith, and disregard those who distort His names. They will be required for their sins.
@@kouroshmemari2450
CHECK HISTORY AND HOLY BIBLE
@@ankur7773
About what should I check the bible and history?! what are we talking about?!
The Old testaments are okay, but the New Testaments are all distorted.
Do you know about the Nicene creed?!
I think it is you who should do some serious research.
Well done sirs, You have worked diligently hard, you have made deep research to establish facts.
God shall continue to strengthen you and renew you.
It is just the beginning, more are still coming. Bible says "You cannot do anything against the Truth but for the Truth"
I hope both of you will also work diligently hard to make a research on the Bible too since it is the holy book of the Christians. The research may be based on the premise "Is Bible the book of God or is it man made?"
@@MrMohdanuar9134 The Quran is a comic compared to the Bible.. The Quran is a rip off ..
@@MrMohdanuar9134 It’s already been done numerous times, who hasn’t at that point.
@@MrMohdanuar9134 The Bible has been researched very thoroughly by both Christians and non-Christians for centuries already. Actually, the subject of textual criticism taught in all universities is really based on the critical studies of the Biblical texts. Abdools should learn facts before opening their mouths and embarrassing themselves.
How did Quran defined God.
It is very easy to understand Bible, and what is the WORD of God based on how Bible defined God.
It is difficult to know who allah is or the word of allah without how quran defined it.
Quran did not define allah. So it is difficult to know who allah is and this is given Muslims lots of problems.
If you don't know who you are searching for, how will you recognize him when you meet him?.
Br,
Al. Fd and J Smith.
I learnt that who is the writters of the bible
But, I heard that writters of Quran make me confuse.
I attend yr channel make me attentive re - the doctrine..
I do not want to miss your channel if I have time to attend it.
Very2 inspiring.
God bless you and br J. Smith
Mohammed changed the name of the moon god Artemis to allah
To thy complaint ,love reacheth ,if like Hafiz
Thou recite by heart the Quran with the FOURTEEN TRADITIONS
Is one of the traditions having sex with a nine year old girl like Mohammed did?
Your lasts videos are wonderful. Subject and data are insane. Thank you! May God bless hafs quran ;)
Should the Qur'an be allowed outside Islamic countries ??
I’m still over here wondering why god needed Gabriel to give the “word” to Muhammad? So how are the words in the Quran gods word? Without lies Islam dies.
Amen ....
Making peace among the communities is highly recommended in the Holy Quran.
It's also available in the Bible, right?
mic drop
Who is Devil.
God created Jinns and gave them the earth for so many years but they corrupted the earth and God then decided to replace them with human beings. So God told the angles that I am creating a human being Adam to inherit the earth and once I create him and God blow His breath into Adam breath he became alive and all the angels bow down to Adam as instructed by God, But not the Devil who refused to bow down. From here the Devil (Jinn father ) become rebellious to God and The enemy of human because he is being replaced by Adam. So the Devil declared a war against human beings and said will work to take many human to the hell fire as God after the Devil refused to bow down to Adam God condemned him to hell fire. So the same that happens to the Devil against human is now happening to those people God has replaced them with the prophethood and Quran. They have joined hand with the Devil to be against the prophet and Quran but that will not misguide accept themselves. Read Quran chapter two for details of above.
I don’t know why youtube put this channel in my feed. I feel sorry for the hosts and their fans. May Allah give guidance to those who seek His guidance. Put away your arrogance and egos and pray to God so that He will you show you the correct path.
Comment for the algorithm.
I jumped the gun, too.
FROM THE NEW TESTAMENT BOOK IT IS EVIDENT THAT JESUS IS NOT GOD OF CHRISTIANS.
JESUS DIDN'T KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT CHRISTIAN.
THERE IS NO VERSE IN THE NEW TESTAMENT THAT PROVES THAT JESUS IS GOD OF CHRISTIANS.
JESUS WAS NEVER SENT TO CHRISTIANS.
THERE IS NO RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN JESUS AND CHRISTIANS.
JESUS ONLY HAS A VERY CLEAR RELATIONSHIP WITH THE PEOPLE OF ISRAEL.
MATTHEW 15: 24
But he answered and said, I am not sent but unto the lost sheep of the house of ISRAEL.
JESUS WAS BORN TO BE A LEADER WHO WILL SHEPHERD THE PEOPLE OF ISRAEL, NOT SHEPHERD CHRISTIANS.
MATTHEW 2: 6
And thou Bethlehem, in the land of Juda, art not the least among the princes of Juda: for out of thee shall come a Governor, that shall rule my people ISRAEL.
JESUS ONLY INTERACTED WITH THE PEOPLE OF ISRAEL, JESUS NEVER INTERACTED WITH CHRISTIANS.
MARK 12: 29
And Jesus answered him, The first of all the commandments, Hear, O ISRAEL, The Lord our God is one Lord.
JESUS IS THE SAVIOUR OF THE PEOPLE OF ISRAEL.
JESUS IS NOT THE SAVIOUR OF CHRISTIANS.
THERE IS NO VERSE IN THE NEW TESTAMENT THAT STATES THAT JESUS IS THE SAVIOUR OF CHRISTIANS.
ACTS 13: 23
Of this man's seed hath God according to his promise raised unto ISRAEL A SAVIOUR, JESUS.
JESUS WAS PRAYED FOR AS KING OF ISRAEL, NOT AS KING OF CHRISTIANS.
JOHN 12: 13
Took branches of palm trees, and went forth to meet him, and cried, Hosanna: Blessed is the King of ISRAEL that cometh in the name of the Lord.
ALL THE ACTIVITIES OF JESUS IN THE NEW TESTAMENT WERE WITH THE ISRAELITES, NEVER WITH CHRISTIANS.
WITH THE EVIDENCE ABOVE, IT IS IMPOSSIBLE FOR JESUS TO BE GOD OF CHRISTIANS.
Mohammed had sex with a nine year old girl and Muslims say that girls are sexually mature at nine years old ( child molesters)
True Muslims have been prohibited hands shaking with non-Mahram women.
It's totally Haraam.
Therefore, we too hate it.
It's found in the Bible too, isn't it, Sir?
30 Qurans ? What do the experts say. Blogging Theology.
Qiraat in Arabic meas types of readings . The type of reading do NOT change the meaning of a ward. The qiraat gives many melodies to the Quran but does NOT change the meaning of Quran.
Mohammed changed the name of the moon god Artemis to allah
Allah is God the creator of the universe and the owner of everything including human. He has created human beings starting with Adam and sent prophet like Abraham Moses Jesus and the last prophet Muhammad to teach people to believe in one God the creator.
@@saidmohammed7597 Mohammed changed the name of the moon god Artemis to allah ( Mohammed had sex with a nine year old girl and Muslims say that girls are sexually mature at nine years old ( child molesters)
Quran is the best one among the rest in the world . It was not written by any man. Revealed by the almighty Allah. Tiny word can't be changed. It is unique bearing facts not lies. It does not bear man made stories .
Who wrote it then 😂? The words of god just appeared on to paper?
Jay is coaching al fadl
Thank you. Sir
God bless you brother 🙏
Nothing quite like one band of Abrahamics tearing down the conceit of another band of Abrahamics.
Do you think though that the rest of us could have our planet back at some point?
His argument is so weak, he say albokhari said Quran from year 625 but there is no physical evidence, this is stupid argument, its like an atheist say to a christian your god is weak, he died on a cross hopelessly, can’t defend himself and cant forgive people without a sacrifice.
Christians pray in Sunday while Jesus Christ used to pray in Saturday, Jesus never prayed using cross or a physical form thing. You Christians are doing the Anti Christ work.
@@johnseventhday9145 ya ya, but he prayed in the direction of the dwelling wall, so..
As I've been saying, these differences do not make you go astray like the new testaments do and make you polytheists?!
However, I am the "Messenger of the Covenant" as it is written and prophecized in all the 3 books.
3:81 (Al-Imran)
And when "God the Wisest" took a "covenant" from the prophets, that indeed "I" have given you scripture and wisdom, thereafter, a messenger will come to you upholding what you have, you shall believe in him and support him. "His Majesty," said: « Do you agree and make a solemn covenant? » They said we agree. "His Majesty," said: «Therefore be witnesses and I am witnessing this along with you. »
3:82 (Al-Imran)
Therefore, whoever rejects this, then, is wicked.
That's the creation of men. Yiu can reoeat that as much as you want That's not the Word of God. I can write a book and say the same thing and it doesn't mean that's the Truth.
Mohammed had sex with a nine year old girl and Muslims say that girls are sexually mature at nine years old ( child molesters)
The Problem is He changed the WORD of "GOD" and he had to die for it!
18:20 (Deuteronomy)
"And as for a prophet who dares to speak in the name of 'I', which I did not say, or in the name of other gods, that prophet must be killed!"
*************
He should have just repeated the words of his "Lord", like a talking book, and not praise himself! The repetition of these lies led Jesus and his apostles to death.
*****************************
11:42 (John)
Of course, I knew that you would always answer my request; But I said this because of the group that is present here, so that they may believe that you have sent me, Your Excellency!
I like the analysis of Islam. I can imidiately tell that they try to bring you to Christianity which is sadly also nonsense 😁 and ruins their careful research. It comes across as manipulation.
Mohammed changed the name of the moon god Artemis to allah
No there is nothing amazing about expressing opposition nothing at all here what is amazing lets go to Bible hub punch in the BOOK OF MARK.3:21 see all the biblical renditions of the verse and then let us explore then the reasons for the dramatic differences let’s discuss what’s amazing about that and see if there are any Quranic equivalents let’s do that let’s really dip into what is amazing what say you !!!
Mohammed had sex with a nine year old girl and Muslims say that girls are sexually mature at nine years old ( child molesters)
"What’s more, he suggests that many
of the Qur’ānic variants coexisted during the time of the prophet just as variants in ancient poetry coex-isted during the lifetime of the poets and rawī-s who lived in an oral-transmission environment (p. 232). Nasser concludes that the mysterious tradition of sab`at aḥruf (in its broader sense encompassing the Qur’ānic qirā’āt) was probably a consequence of the failure of the codification process by ‘Uthmān, which was not able to produce a single unified Reading of the Qur’ān. Thus, the variant readings kept multi-plying exponentially until Ibn Mujāhid, when their number became limited again." Marcin Grodzki on Shady Nasser's critique of the variant qiraats of the Quran
Jay Smith name drops Shady Nasser a lot but blows the discussion out or proportion just to prove his ridiculous claims. The Arabs were an oral people and only a select few could read and write. Therefore there are multitude of pronouciations. You travel anywhere in a specific country and its people will have their own dialects to the SAME language. This is the reason Uthman codified the Quranic text and scholars such as Ibn Mujahid set the pronunciations later on after Prophet Muhammad. To PRESERVE the Quran and its intended meaning as Islam was expanding outside the Arab lands and reaching non Arabs.
The meaning of the Quran is unchanged and the book we have today is preserved as how it was revealed.
Fun fact: Qur'an in Arabic comes from the root word qara'a yaqra'u (verb: reading or recitation). It is recited and spoken. Its not a "Book". Even the Qur'an that we hold today is actually not the Quran and rather more accurate called Mushaf (compiled texts/scripture)
What we have to look that what Quran has to offer. Whether one or hundred version of Quran how does it matters?
What kind of benefits Quran can offer for whole of humanity ?
If the answer is not even 0 %, better leave Islam and join some place.
Read Chidbhavananda's Ramakrishna version of the Bhagavad-gita. There is no scripture like this. Superior in every way to both the Bible and the Quran.
Any 50 khafft tema no problem Mr Fadi...!
Hahaha Thanks brothers. Love u both
These two sometimes talk like married old couple :D
Quran is just a copy paste of bible....i m sure that Mohamed was a big fan of jesus, he followed Jesus's life style. He used the teaching of jesus for his personal benefits in a evil way by modifying and adding some words by his own. Mohammed was a very talented person who knew how to manipulate the innocent public in the name of god. He knew about the woman sexualities very well. He knew that divorced women are very good for sex, so he used to marry a divorced women. Mohammed was a saitan in human form.
Mohammed married and had sex with a nine year old girl and Muslims say that girls are sexually mature at nine years old ( child molesters)
Their are now fasting 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Confused channel. Empty content 😌.
Mohammed had sex with a nine year old girl and Muslims say that girls are sexually mature at nine years old ( child molesters)
Salam al-Masih ya al-Fadi!
The Quran does not contain Bible stories although they may share similarities in a few of the stories. The stories in the Quran are the stories of the many sects of the Jewish and Christian tribes in 7th Century Arabia. Among the Jewish sects were those who worshipped Ezra as the son of God. The Christian sects included Trinitarians, Gnostics, Collyridians and others. The traditions of these Christian and Jewish tribes in the Arabian Peninsula diverged from those traditions practiced by the Jews and Christians residing in Palestine, Syria and Babylonia. It was from these latter northern traditions that the Biblical writers drew for their narratives in Biblical texts. There are commonalities, to be sure as the name of the Biblical deity, Aloah which parallels the Arabic name Allah and appears in more than 50 Biblical verses as Deu 32:15, Deu 32:17, 2 Chr 32:15, Neh 9:17, Job 3:4, Job 3:23, Job 4:9, Job 4:17, Job 5:17, Job 6:4, Job 6:8, Job 6:9, Job 9:13, Job 10:2, Job 11:5, Job 11:6, Job 11:7, Job 12:4, Job 12:6, Job 15:8, Job 16:20, Job 16:21, Job 19:6, Job 19:21, Job 19:26, Job 21:9, Job 21:19, Job 22:12, Job 22:26, Job 24:12, Job 27:3, Job 27:8, Job 27:10, Job 29:2, Job 29:4, Job 31:2, Job 31:6, Job 33:12, Job 33:26, Job 35:10, Job 37:15, Job 37:22, Job 39:17, Job 40:2, Psa 18:31, Psa 50:22, Psa 114:7, Psa 139:19, Prov 30:5, Isa 44:8, Dan 11:37, Dan 11:38, Dan 11:38, Dan 11:39, Hab 1:11, Hab 3:3. The stories regarding Jesus and Mary parallel Biblical stories in many aspects but deviate in many others. The same can be said about the stories regarding Moses, Joseph and others. The differences between the Biblical narratives and those in the Quran are reflective of the fluidity of Judaism and Christianity in the 7th Century. So, it is academically helpful if one compares the origins of the stories in both the Bible and Quran as they reflect the beliefs of Judaism and Christianity in the 7th Century. Muslims hold that the stories in the Quran were revealed to Mohammed to demonstrate to these Arabian Christian and Jewish tribes that he was a true prophet as he could recite their traditions in the most eloquent language and in the most accurate manner. Mohammed knew nothing of these stories and many of the verses in the Quran are answers to inquiries from these Christian and Jewish tribes whose beliefs varied widely from modern Western Christianity. So, a good advice would be to research the languages of both of these texts as well their historical context and cultural contexts. Otherwise, debates and discussion become contentious and uninformative.
Non of these guys went on the dawahwise channel or scdawah channel NO ONE entertains these guys 🤣 they don’t have anyone with credentials on their show, they invited a person like me to argue the case ! 😂
Look at Fahdi face when he’s told he knows Arabic this guy is a huge decepticon !
There’s are 7 variants (qirat) on the recital of the Quran,
Guys go read into the history about the prophet Muhammad and you will find out everything these guys hide from you is already explained.. this is sad no one here is looking for unbiased truth no one here studied the Quran or Hadith and yet they make rejections about something you don’t know.
If you don’t play ball or never played ball keep your two cents to yourself. It’s simple.
The same logic racist used to say why black peoples weren’t human is being applied here INCONSISTENT logic.
Bring on a Muslim intellectual if your true.
If a Muslim intellectual doesn’t come on this show you can clearly see how insincere these guys are. Use your head guys
These guys never been in a Muslim household apparently... how is it that a Muslim from America, Africa, China, Russia ALL recite the Quran exactly the same
I guess when you put a Mac book in front of you, it’s automatically considered you
“ know what your talking about “
Notice Fahdi doesn’t say anything he puts on his Arab attire (predominantly worn by Muslims) he just sits and nods
No accredited Christian institute backs Jay Smith up
Guys never trust a dude with a beach shirt
Btw fadi doesn’t wear this attire outside this podcast smh crazy deception here.
“ God became man God died God doesn’t change “ bro what are you talking about !?
The premise is flawed but whatever man there are gonna people who are astray to push their views
Muslims belief is simple, Believe in GOD and do not associate partners with him.
@Bj D
Have you considered the OFFICIAL Sources from Byzantine, Persia, China during the time of the prophet Muhammad. What do you mean by independent sources, who are these independent sources?
The advent of Data entry and preservation during His lifetime and afterwards. The advent of university and education for all humans from his teachings.... what are you talking about
The only religion that keeps the language alive for 1400 years while others constantly change their principles and fully assimilate to the NEW WORLD ORDER
Biased opinions will get you so far man
Historians have more data on The prophet Muhammad then they do on George Washington, Americas 1st president.
The argument the opposition comes with is,
“ The majority of information we have about Muhammad is from local sources that surrounded the area of Arabia “
Do you know how many people consistently recorded his history ?? Over thousands !! With the same account from each individual! and those people giving the account have been verified from head to toe, from birth to death, with full names and family names, with locations and specific details on character, appearance, in-laws, profession, everything !
Where is this level of verification done on any other individual in history ??
The words he spoke were repeated by thousands of individuals whose history and lifespan have been recorded to the T
No other group brings this level of verification
When you graduate from School/College/University you guys wear the MUSLIM Cap and Gown to symbolize your completion of higher education, why is that ? Did we force that on you ?
No, the history is known and the responsibility is on you to find the truth (ask yourself what would Jordan Peterson do? Even he hasn’t made claims on Islam only assumptions of what he doesn’t know YET, as he said he needs to study more on Islam and only has been 3 years into it and isn’t educated enough to comment on Islam, though has has his concerns)
How about keep the Jordan Peterson approach on this matter and fallback till you know what your talking about.
@Bj D how about this,
Bring forth your evidences
Muslim & Non - Muslim, to prove your claim.
I didn’t make an absolute claim about ALL Muslims, be consistent.
Majority of our Data is from Muslims (thousands) who have been verified in more detail then your Facebook/Twitter accounts
I kept a bit short this time so you don’t lose your train of thought trying to address every point. We’re in the 45 second attention span era so my bad I should be more considerate of OTHERS.
@Manuel Delacroix congratulations, you played yourself again. Your claim on 2 translation hold no merit if you can’t explain the Arabic or read it. Your loosely throwing stones at something you think you know but your deception is clear how your present and explain your point.
@Manuel Delacroix bro send me a voice note of you reciting the Hadith matter fact send me the recital of the Quran .... go ahead
Hadith science takes years to learn but you somehow learned it online from These guys... bravo you continue playing yourself
@Manuel Delacroix It’s incredible how clear the deception is lmao
and this is why we say read the Quran in it’s original text so you don’t have people like you deceiving folks
For example you quoted verse:
6:86 fro Surah Al-An’am ( do you even know what Al- Na’am means , anyways that’s besides the point. )
The verse you quoted in your deceptive English translation, here’s the original verse from the Quran
I can’t put the Arabic in this RUclips section but let me give you a transliteration after Ishmael, elisha, Jonah, and lut, the verse ends with ;
Wa Kula Fazaalun Alelun Alameen
Which translates to:
“ And each one of them We favoured over all mankind “
So back to you what you translated to mislead the audience, there is no mention of book ( kitab) or anything close to what you tried to allude too smh
Who are you trying to fool.
How about explaining the drying of the fig tree by Jesus, for not having fruits in the wrong season so nobody else could eat it in the future?! Just as it was not the time for him to claim the end of the world at his time, and thinking that he was the Messiah?!
Did you know, that the fig tree is the symbol of world peace?
3:10 (Zacharia)
In that resurrection day, said the “LORD” of hosts, you all shall invite your neighbor under the vine and under the fig tree to sit in peace.
Why don't you tell your audience why Jesus was hanged in the first place?!
Why don't you tell your betraying friend and your audience that anyone with the "Holy Spirit" in him, was not allowed to drink, just like John the Baptist?!
1:15 (Luke)
Because he will be one of the chose elders in the presence of "God the King of the Resurrection"; And because he is full of the "Holy Spirit" from his mother's womb, he should never drink wine and intoxicating drinks!
Mohammed had sex with a nine year old girl and Muslims say that girls are sexually mature at nine years old ( child molesters)
Jay Smith . Lol
Quran are not the different " Version" or " text" of the Quran as fantasized by non Muslims or anti Islam...many aspects ,they convey
the same meaning and message.quran contains a verse conveying
that Allah ( s.w.t) confirm his preservation of Quran..
@Temporary Account4 apparently for Muslims that counts as similar...
@@11385djg And this doesnt even touch up on Dr. Brubakers work on the rasm. this just dots vowels with all these differences.
Which version is in heaven?
@@grandmasterlucien i was gonna say, it’s the Hafs version that is in heaven. Hafs who was called by his contemporaries as liar, not trustworthy etc...
you have the wrong quran, the one collected by Abu Bakhr is not the authentic , in fact the true quran was the quran that allah collected himself, " its for us to collect the Quran" who is us? Allah. however its possible that the quran that Abu Bakhr collected may accidentally have e few authentic verses . I trust the quran that allah collected only.
How about explaining to your audience these verses, that you claimed were divine! If these are the "GOD", words, then why would he claim to be God himself?! It is like the speaker of the White House, have a coupe and claimes to be the President!
" In the Name of God, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful "
12:51 (Luke)
Do you think that I have come to establish peace on earth? no! Rather, I say to you: "conflict and hypocrisy!"
12:52 (Luke) = 19
For henceforth the inhabitants of a house will be divided; If five people are in the same house, two people will have conflict against three people, and three people against the two people!
12:53 (Luke)
The father has conflict against the son, and the son against the father, and the mother against the daughter, and the daughter against the mother, and the mother-in-law against the bride, and the bride against the mother-in-law will have animosity!
Pure praise to "God the Most Merciful"
Mohammed had sex with a nine year old girl and Muslims say that girls are sexually mature at nine years old ( child molesters)
Variant Readings
كانت قراءة أبي بكر وَعمر و عثمان و زيد بن ثابت و المهاجرين وَالأنصار وَاحدة كانوا بقرءون القراءة العامة وَهي القراءة التي قرأها رَسُوْلَ اللّٰہِ صَلَّي اللّٰہُ عَلَیۡہِ وَسَلَّمَ علي جبريل مرتين في العام الذى قبض فيه وكان زيد قد شهد العرْضَة الأخيرة وَكان يقرئ الناس بها حتیمات
The reading of Abu Bakr, ‘Umar, ‘Uthman and Zayd ibn Thabit and that of all the Muhajirun and the Ansar was the same. They read the Qur’an according to the al-qira’at al-‘ammah. This is the same reading which was read out twice by the Prophet (sws) to Gabriel in the year of his death. Zayd ibn Thabit was also present in this reading [called] the al-‘ardah al-akhirah. It was this reading that he taught the Qur’an to people till his death.[5]
It is this very reading that is written in our codices of the Qur’an. Not a single bit of evidence can be furnished from history except the endeavours of ‘Uthman (rta) (d. 36 AH) and Hajjaj ibn Yusuf (d. 94 AH) to unite all Muslims on one Qur’an in which a scholar used his influence or a ruler or a qadi used political power to impose this Qur’an among the Muslims, the way it was done is some West African counties with regard to the reading of Nafi‘. It was this Qur’an which the Prophet (sws) and his successors gave currency to among the Muslims and it has remained in currency ever since. Consequently, when the readers of the Muslims were compiling their preferences in readings and when their Hadith scholars were collecting the reports of ‘ilm al-khassah and their jurists and exegetes were solving the difficulties of the Qur’an through them, Muslims were reading this very Qur’an in the whole world. At the end of the first century hijrah when they entered India, they entered while reading it and when they landed at the shores of Java, Sumatra, Malaya and other islands of the Far East at the end of the eighth century, it was this very Qur’an which was in their hands and God willing will remain in their hands till the Day of Judgement.
Here a person can pose the question: if despite all these facts, the academic tradition of the Muslims accepted all the reports related to ‘ilm al-khassah, why has the Farahi School adopted a different stance in this regard? Our answer is that it is not easy for any person of learning to disregard reports narrated by reliable narrators; this needs an explicit Qur’anic directive. Thus if the true meaning of the relevant verses of Surah Qiyamah had become evident at the very beginning, Muslim scholars, jurists and exegetes would probably have adopted the same stance as the scholars of the Farahi School. Imam Hamid al-Din Farahi (d. 1930 AD) has explained the true meaning of these verses.[6] Hence, that explicit Qur’anic directive has become available on the basis of which it can be said that even if all the narratives which depict the variant readings of the Qur’an are correct, they have been abrogated by the reading of the ardah akhirah for the universal addressees of the Qur’an; hence they cannot be accepted in any way whatsoever.[7] It is a directive of the Qur’an that after its collection and arrangement, Muslims will be bound till the Day of Judgement to read it on the reading it was read by the Almighty after this collection. No Muslim can dare deviate from this directive of the Qur’an. It states:
لَا تُحَرِّکۡ بِہٖ لِسَانَکَ لِتَعۡجَلَ بِہٖ. اِنَّ عَلَیۡنَا جَمۡعَہٗ وَ قُرۡاٰنَہٗ . فَاِذَا قَرَاۡنٰہُ فَاتَّبِعۡ .(75: 16-18)
[To acquire] this [Qur’an] swiftly [O Prophet!] do not move your tongue hastily over it. [It will be revealed like this. Rest assured] its collection and recital is Our responsibility. So when We have recited it [at that time], follow this recital. (75:16-18) no
Proof?
Just by the Islamic information which Qur'an was presented to Java? Warsh? Qaloon? Dari? No Hafs yet or one of those Uthmanic copies? If that info is not available Why Not? Lost in translation or eaten by an asian elephant? What was given to the Mongols, or the Bosnians? What mustaf will you write on this blank vellum? ------ No, We Don't Talk About This In Public!!!!!!
@@gilbertjones9157
Our non muslim freind take Quran just like other books but they ignor the special way of presrvation i e the Quran is also preserved by memorization. If written manusript is available then well and good . If written manuscript is not available then there is no harm in preservation of the Quran as is given by the prophet to his companian by letting them memorization not by in a manusript form. In this materialistic age u can find numbers of people who memorize Quran by heart, this is the continuation of preservation of Quran from the very beginning of Islam.....
@@msbalghari3163 If memorization is sooo good than there is no need for a written Quran and do as Uthman did and burn the lot. Or as the Dept. of Education did in 1924 Cairo dump them into a large body of water. Then there will be nothing to check and all is well.
you have the wrong quran, the one collected by Abu Bakhr is not the authentic , in fact the true quran was the quran that allah collected himself, " its for us to collect the Quran" who is us? Allah. however its possible that the quran that Abu Bakhr collected may accidentally have e few authentic verses . I trust the quran that allah collected only.
As usual these guys mastered in lying.
rUBBISH, RISING SUN. THESE GUYS ARE RIGHT ON TARGET. LET ISLAM TAKE ON WHAT THEY HAVE SAID POINT BY POINT.
Tony Stakes Is this how your religion taught you to talk? By the by, are you a christian?
Read the Quran Mohammed had sex with a nine year old girl and Muslims say that girls are sexually mature at nine years old ( child molesters)
The Holy Quran condemns scolding Gods of others.
It must have been mentioned in the Holy Bible too, isn't it, Sir?
It could never be written in the Bible, because that's the true Word of God, and no pagan god has the Way the Truth and the Life. That's what the Bible says. You have tradition, a religion created by men, that's all. Younlike to claim to have the same God as our. Our God is not your god. I am sorry, I am not trying to be rude.
Mohammed had sex with a nine year old girl and Muslims say that girls are sexually mature at nine years old ( but the bible teaches not to worship anything else but the God of the bible)
May Allah swt guide you☝ .inshaAllah.