They sing above the pre recorded vocals, and they will lip sync in some areas, like when there is a heavily edited voice like RM’s ‘all the underdogs in the world’ part. They will lip sync in heavy dancing as well, but most of the time, they will sing live over the prerecorded vocals
They are not singing in these two performances. It's okay. It's not uncommon for groups to do that. They still can pull off live singing, albeit not perfectly because of their crisp dance routines.
i love this channel so much. ive been a fan of bts for over 2 years, but yall gotta admit this isnt live. the dancing to voice ratio is ridiculous. if they sang live, their voices wouldve been at least slightly unstable, but this is only straight singing. no breathing breaks, no nothing.
lip sync is actually banned by MBC, they don't allow the idols to lip sync unless they tell the fans before the performance, and I found a article that said KBS banned all lip sync in 2014, so there is no way this is lip sync
I know this is one year old, but I could not find an article by KBS stating they banned all lipsyncing in 2014. Not even a site like onehallyu or akp have conversations about such 'ban'. MBC DID "ban" lip-syncing, But for some special reason not for SM Artists. (Girls Generation were caught using Live MR/Live AR meaning they were lipsyncing on Show Music Core.) Also, Please explain 3:12 where when Jimin's vocal are quieting down, theres a hard auto-tune on them. on both performances (remove left/right headphone/earphone and replay. you can tell). anyways lip-syncing is fine I just wanted you to know that they were lipsyncing
Maybe that's just me being a protective BTS stan that believes in them, but I still believe they did sing live, because I remember clearly how Jimin's voice cracked in one mr. Removed, but it didn't in the others. Well, whatever. They slay every way, even without a song, that choreo would be worth watching for me.
They probably sang live in another performance, and I think most people will acknowledge these boys and their talent with live performances. Still, this channel knows what they're doing. It's a very hard choreo, I doubt even a group as strong as this would sing live every time. Then again, this is just what I think. Choose what you want to believe.
It's okay. It doesn't mean they NEVER sing live, but on these two specific cases, they do. That's normal K-pop. At their concerts though, they really do give their 100%. I love that they perform with a live band.
dallak93 Yes that's true. Sorry if I was being offensive, but BTS is just really important to me, so I can get a little defensive when it comes to them
I think most music shows doesn't support live singing (like equipment wise), another performer brought this issue up a few years ago i think. But i do think the boys do sing live when the equipment / stage allows it. But not in this comparison video (which is taken from music show..limited equipment support)
I don't think they did lipsync (or barely at all, just in some parts), but if they did, I'm not mad. Not Today has pretty hard choreography, and they sing the rest of their songs live. So honestly it's not a big deal.
If you want to hear their live in this song, go check when they sing in wings tour, you'll know the different and you will more love with the live, believe me, this is why i love them
I actually can hear two different things, the tones of their voices and such, the left is so different, speacually when Junkook was singing, his voice was a bit higher
I don't understand the views on this channel...200k+ views on one video, and this one doesn't even have 100 after a week? Anyway, I don't have a pair of working earbuds or headphones at the moment LMAO I can't really judge the video. They're using a live MR in assuming?
They are unless stated otherwise, lol. Yes, the Knock Knock video has reached more than 4k even though I uploaded these the same day. Anyway, thanks for watching!
I just watched bts gogo music show version and most of the boys really cant lipsync lol especially RM..which probably means they're more used to singing live when the situation / stage / equipment allows them to. I don't remember when or which artist said this, but that person said that Korean music shows doesn't really have the proper equipment to support live performance, so I do think it's not always the performer's fault for not singing live on music shows. Especially when they've proven on other occasions that they're able to sing + dance live.
if they was using live mr,i think because not today & spring day promotion week is so close with the tour. Sorry if there are grammar mistake,english is not my first language
So what if they didn't sing live? 😂 Name one artist who can sing flawlessly while doing a dance that requires as much stamina as BTS's dances. When they sing for real, they don't usually dance. But there have been times they sing and dance and it's great as fuck, but you can hear when they run out of breath or their voices crack.
V • it is humanly impossible to dance that fierce and sing that well without taking deep breaths. Even opera singers have to take deep breaths for long notes even though they don't move. And they are supposed to be professional singers who went to school and learned diff. Exercises etc but they still struggle. So I agree with you and I don't think it's a bad thing at all. They are there to perform which is why they dance and that's still a talent not a lot of people can bash on that. Plus you right when they don't move as much they sing beautiful and live too because you can hear them breathing and singing with so much emotion, because they be feeling the music.
Thank you for not blindly believing they never lip-syncing. It's understandable they compromise vocals for their overall performance, and it prolly wouldn't be as fierce if they didn't do so. Thanks for watching!
Someone help me I don't understand the point of the comparison they sound the same to me obviously it's recorded but like I don't get the point explain
LISTEN bts are humans just like us of course they do use mr for comback shows BUT not at a live performance SORRY ENGLISH IS NOT MY FIRST LANGUGAGE BUT I HAVE TO COMMENT BC THIS IS SOOO ANNNOYINGGGG FUCKK-
It's okay, pop artists in general tend to lip-sync while performing such complex dance routines. Those who expect them to sing live all the time are just as delusional as those who think their idols sing live all the time. Your English is fine btw!
Bts do live in some part and getting help with the mr in some other part in this performs. We already know and always hear ther singging or rapping in live. This not cz they can't sing or anything. I think Mr is always used in singer performs. Sorry for my bad engglis.
of course they lip sync, you can't dance like crazy and sing well at the same time x0 if they were really singing live you'd hear them catching their breaths and all that (not sure how to explain what I mean in English lol)
L F I'm not disagreeing in a immature way, but technically it is possible. Most of the times, you could hear them breathing hard. Many Kpop idols are trained to sing and dance live (though some do lip sync because it is hard).
Jimin Bebe the thing is that Army are hella annoying about it "Bts never lip sync" and in the meanwhile they insult other artists. What's wrong with admitting that sometimes the lip synced? As you said they are human, their dance are really difficult and sometimes they are just tired, so it's understandable, but don't pendent they never did it
Lola Art i didn't say that they never did but some people saying every kpop group does lipsync ALL THE TIME this is not true and it's really annyoing and disrespectful bc the artist try to do their best and then some people talk shit
Jimin Bebe yeah, i totally agree with you. Let's just say that there are "extremists" on both sides. Those who defend them too much and those who hates them for everything
![BTS(방탄소년단) - Not Today [The 2017 KBS Song Festival / ENG]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5_bMMH1eP2Q/mqdefault.jpg)
![BTS(방탄소년단) - Not Today [The 2017 KBS Song Festival / ENG]](/img/tr.png)
![171201 Intro+Not Today BTS Performance @ MAMA2017 [fancam]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/FSa2DxhuJOs/mqdefault.jpg)
![[BTS - Not Today] Comeback Stage | M COUNTDOWN 170223 EP.512](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Sq9SuUnkNeE/mqdefault.jpg)
I'm sorry but, Jimin cannot keep a jacket on his shoulders for the life of him.
They sing above the pre recorded vocals, and they will lip sync in some areas, like when there is a heavily edited voice like RM’s ‘all the underdogs in the world’ part. They will lip sync in heavy dancing as well, but most of the time, they will sing live over the prerecorded vocals
They are not singing in these two performances. It's okay. It's not uncommon for groups to do that. They still can pull off live singing, albeit not perfectly because of their crisp dance routines.
dallak93 but i think music core not accept lipsync
Taehyungs voice is so damn charming I'm going to kms
seftlock lemme join (:
please do. we can dream everyday about him
He's actually the best vocalist in BTS! Wish he wasn't somewhat left out on title tracks, though. The life of a baritone.
i love this channel so much. ive been a fan of bts for over 2 years, but yall gotta admit this isnt live. the dancing to voice ratio is ridiculous. if they sang live, their voices wouldve been at least slightly unstable, but this is only straight singing. no breathing breaks, no nothing.
Thank you for watching and for your comment!
I totally agree. I'm a army but, I fully agree its lip sync. Every kpop idol does it when they have hard choreo like this.
lip sync is actually banned by MBC, they don't allow the idols to lip sync unless they tell the fans before the performance, and I found a article that said KBS banned all lip sync in 2014, so there is no way this is lip sync
I know this is one year old, but I could not find an article by KBS stating they banned all lipsyncing in 2014. Not even a site like onehallyu or akp have conversations about such 'ban'.
MBC DID "ban" lip-syncing, But for some special reason not for SM Artists. (Girls Generation were caught using Live MR/Live AR meaning they were lipsyncing on Show Music Core.)
Also, Please explain 3:12 where when Jimin's vocal are quieting down, theres a hard auto-tune on them. on both performances (remove left/right headphone/earphone and replay. you can tell). anyways lip-syncing is fine I just wanted you to know that they were lipsyncing
I was hearing heaven both sides rn
Maybe that's just me being a protective BTS stan that believes in them, but I still believe they did sing live, because I remember clearly how Jimin's voice cracked in one mr. Removed, but it didn't in the others. Well, whatever. They slay every way, even without a song, that choreo would be worth watching for me.
They probably sang live in another performance, and I think most people will acknowledge these boys and their talent with live performances. Still, this channel knows what they're doing. It's a very hard choreo, I doubt even a group as strong as this would sing live every time. Then again, this is just what I think. Choose what you want to believe.
It's okay. It doesn't mean they NEVER sing live, but on these two specific cases, they do. That's normal K-pop. At their concerts though, they really do give their 100%. I love that they perform with a live band.
dallak93 Yes that's true. Sorry if I was being offensive, but BTS is just really important to me, so I can get a little defensive when it comes to them
Bts sing very well live but in this case both of these videos it's pre record, I'm a Bts trash I know when they sing live or not .
I think most music shows doesn't support live singing (like equipment wise), another performer brought this issue up a few years ago i think. But i do think the boys do sing live when the equipment / stage allows it. But not in this comparison video (which is taken from music show..limited equipment support)
I have returned after listening to a video of the mr removed and I now also have come to realised that V and Jin's voice are very on point
I don't think they did lipsync (or barely at all, just in some parts), but if they did, I'm not mad. Not Today has pretty hard choreography, and they sing the rest of their songs live. So honestly it's not a big deal.
I Swear Taehyung Voice 😍😍 I'm Gonna Die All Their Voices Are So Beautiful!!!!!
If you want to hear their live in this song, go check when they sing in wings tour, you'll know the different and you will more love with the live, believe me, this is why i love them
I genuinely can't tell the bloody difference, just sing along just sing along.
I actually can hear two different things, the tones of their voices and such, the left is so different, speacually when Junkook was singing, his voice was a bit higher
But wait!!! What are you proving??
I don't understand the views on this channel...200k+ views on one video, and this one doesn't even have 100 after a week? Anyway, I don't have a pair of working earbuds or headphones at the moment LMAO I can't really judge the video. They're using a live MR in assuming?
They are unless stated otherwise, lol. Yes, the Knock Knock video has reached more than 4k even though I uploaded these the same day. Anyway, thanks for watching!
probably because people don't believe BP wouldn't sing entirely live (the 200k vid). Also the fanchant videos are prob really popular
I just watched bts gogo music show version and most of the boys really cant lipsync lol especially RM..which probably means they're more used to singing live when the situation / stage / equipment allows them to. I don't remember when or which artist said this, but that person said that Korean music shows doesn't really have the proper equipment to support live performance, so I do think it's not always the performer's fault for not singing live on music shows. Especially when they've proven on other occasions that they're able to sing + dance live.
Where did you read that? That sounds interesting. Thanks for watching!
dallak93 i think it was a few years back, i don't remember exactly but i think it was a male idol group or band. Thank you for the video!!
I can't blame them if they do lip sync. To sing and dance like that would be difficult.
OMG I see that icon everywhere (your profile picture)
Do you know why? I can explain if you don't.
Can you do one for TTS holler?
I should've used the one where they're wearing the uniforms! It's the one where Jimin's voice cracked so I think they were singing live then.
if they was using live mr,i think because not today & spring day promotion week is so close with the tour. Sorry if there are grammar mistake,english is not my first language
They didn't lipsync in their concert like wings,life trilogy 1-3 etc
this is crazy
even two different performances are very much in sync! Vi killed me! i love V! BTS is the best! there's nothing like BTS!
I love V too!
So what if they didn't sing live? 😂 Name one artist who can sing flawlessly while doing a dance that requires as much stamina as BTS's dances. When they sing for real, they don't usually dance. But there have been times they sing and dance and it's great as fuck, but you can hear when they run out of breath or their voices crack.
V • it is humanly impossible to dance that fierce and sing that well without taking deep breaths. Even opera singers have to take deep breaths for long notes even though they don't move. And they are supposed to be professional singers who went to school and learned diff. Exercises etc but they still struggle. So I agree with you and I don't think it's a bad thing at all. They are there to perform which is why they dance and that's still a talent not a lot of people can bash on that. Plus you right when they don't move as much they sing beautiful and live too because you can hear them breathing and singing with so much emotion, because they be feeling the music.
Thank you for not blindly believing they never lip-syncing. It's understandable they compromise vocals for their overall performance, and it prolly wouldn't be as fierce if they didn't do so. Thanks for watching!
Someone help me I don't understand the point of the comparison they sound the same to me obviously it's recorded but like I don't get the point explain
Are you still making these? pls do some more
I just did one on Likey. Check it out!
LMR?
wow.. i could hear clearly the high notes of Jiminie .. magaling magaling..! GodBless #BTS
CAN WE APRECIATE HOW POWERFUL ARMYS ARE AND HOW LOUD THEY SING? 😭❤️
Will you do a live mr comparison with blackpink's as if your last?
cindikpop It’s been uploaded.
0izzi0 Thanks
LISTEN bts are humans just like us of course they do use mr for comback shows BUT not at a live performance
SORRY ENGLISH IS NOT MY FIRST LANGUGAGE BUT I HAVE TO COMMENT BC THIS IS SOOO ANNNOYINGGGG FUCKK-
It's okay, pop artists in general tend to lip-sync while performing such complex dance routines. Those who expect them to sing live all the time are just as delusional as those who think their idols sing live all the time.
Your English is fine btw!
The Fanchants thoooooo
Bts do live in some part and getting help with the mr in some other part in this performs. We already know and always hear ther singging or rapping in live. This not cz they can't sing or anything. I think Mr is always used in singer performs.
Sorry for my bad engglis.
They can do that but they can also lip-sync a whole performance. It's not uncommon and it's not bad, either.
Your English is just fine, btw!
But i hear breath jimin.___. #sorrymyenglishsobad :v hahaha LOL
i see no different!!!!!!!!!!
Thao Do omg i love kanna
oh really? I love her!!! :V :)
I think Rap Monster was lip syncing. At the beginning while speaking english.
D. Arshyd I mean the first part. When he was speking english
sorry i mean you judge rm
of course they lip sync, you can't dance like crazy and sing well at the same time x0 if they were really singing live you'd hear them catching their breaths and all that (not sure how to explain what I mean in English lol)
(Don't worry, I understood!) I agree with you. Thank you for your comment!
Lucas Fredin Bigbang cant
L F I'm not disagreeing in a immature way, but technically it is possible. Most of the times, you could hear them breathing hard. Many Kpop idols are trained to sing and dance live (though some do lip sync because it is hard).
pffft and the army still pretends they are not lipsyncing
Demonitized. Of course, they will always say Bts NEVER lip sync 😅😂
Omg stop they are also humans of course they do sometimes or at comeback shows but not at a live performance
Jimin Bebe the thing is that Army are hella annoying about it "Bts never lip sync" and in the meanwhile they insult other artists. What's wrong with admitting that sometimes the lip synced? As you said they are human, their dance are really difficult and sometimes they are just tired, so it's understandable, but don't pendent they never did it
Lola Art i didn't say that they never did but some people saying every kpop group does lipsync ALL THE TIME this is not true and it's really annyoing and disrespectful bc the artist try to do their best and then some people talk shit
Jimin Bebe yeah, i totally agree with you. Let's just say that there are "extremists" on both sides. Those who defend them too much and those who hates them for everything