Can a Budget Lens Beat a Legend? (Meike vs Canon 85mm Battle)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 25 окт 2024

Комментарии • 78

  • @cameraconspiracies
    @cameraconspiracies  3 часа назад +1

    If you buy today's gear through my affiliate links, you can film Bigfoot feeding his pet raccoons.
    Thank you for your Bitcoin donations :) bc1qacvd72s9565hpat4jueeultha3qvrv4kznyl3f
    Meike sent me the lens to review for free.
    Meike 85mm f1.4 for Nikon/Sony/LMount amzn.to/3NHWbOq
    Nikon Z6 III amzn.to/3BVHl3V
    Fringer EF-NZ II amzn.to/3NltmXX
    Canon EF 85mm f1.2 amzn.to/4eHigIM
    Tascam DR10L amzn.to/48oQ0bs
    All my gear and recommended products can be found in my affiliate shop, thanks for shopping around! www.amazon.com/shop/vegetablepolice

  • @vampolascott36
    @vampolascott36 2 часа назад +9

    I didn't used to believe in 3D pop. But now I"m seeing it everywhere!

    • @mdenjoyer831
      @mdenjoyer831 Час назад

      and canon looked like a green screen

    • @LouisLuzuka
      @LouisLuzuka 41 минуту назад

      😮

    • @iamionscat9035
      @iamionscat9035 5 минут назад

      There has to be a way to get this effect in post. The non sharp lenses have a barrel like blur at the edges. Some wizard must have an effect that can be applied, because I love my sharp Sony zooms.

  • @axelfoley1768
    @axelfoley1768 2 часа назад +6

    From time to time this guy does legendary vids. This is one of them imo. Vlog... creative, relevant, informative, interesting, entertaining, technique watchable.
    Most of his vids attempt to address things in this field & are at least interesting. Kudos. But sometimes just 11/10 📸

    • @Localtraveler2376
      @Localtraveler2376 22 минуты назад +1

      It’s just nice he actually tests them and doesn’t read the company’s promotional script.

    • @iamionscat9035
      @iamionscat9035 3 минуты назад

      AND! in a shilltuber review at the same time!
      What we need more of is honesty, different approaches and more honesty even if it's got warts.

  • @ryanresavage7807
    @ryanresavage7807 42 минуты назад +2

    Your bestest buddy Robin Wong just did a video about the clinically flatness of sharpness in modern lenses.

  • @Filmgoblin
    @Filmgoblin 2 часа назад +3

    I was using the canon 85 1.2 yesterday! Such a ridiculously beautiful lens. I finally realize 3d pop is real

  • @Pedro.DSouza
    @Pedro.DSouza Час назад +3

    3D pop will always be a reality, in our hearts. And just there. This Meike lens is amazing for the price btw. Great video!

  • @scotthime6928
    @scotthime6928 35 минут назад +2

    Most people don't know that the first chromatic aberration wasn't an aberration at all. It was blood fringing the edges of those sabertooth tiger tooth lenses. You can get the same effect from soaking a modern-day lens in a can of cherry 3D-Pop. But not if you let the fizz out.

  • @pixelsandgrain
    @pixelsandgrain Час назад +3

    You just proved that Meike boy with all the ED elements has way more 3D pop than the Canon. Unless you are tricking us and the labels are backwards, zero 3D pop on the Canon in the intro section, vs 3D pop magic on Meike boy. Same on the railroad tracks, even in black and white. So either this is a the biggest ever camera conspiracy by mis-labeling the lenses on the video, or you can sell your Canon 85mm 1.2, and keep the cash and the free Meike shilltuber gift.

  • @bigrobotnewstoday1436
    @bigrobotnewstoday1436 Час назад +2

    I'm a Scientologist and once I get to OT 11 I'll unlock Lord Xenu's formula for 3D POP. Lord Xenu was wedding photographer on planet Teegeeack before he got into politics. When Lord Xenu became supreme leader he ordered all the engineers on planet Teegeeack to make the best lens with 3D POP.
    Once I get to OT 11 I'll be able to get the blue prints on those lens and sell them for millions of dollars on the black market in Japan to the Yakuza.

  • @jerazi3936
    @jerazi3936 46 минут назад

    Wirklich der fundierteste Objektiv-Test, den ich (heute) sehen durfte!

  • @Democratiser
    @Democratiser 48 минут назад +1

    Dirty Photography Club has changed his channel name. The algorithm apparently categorised that name uncharitably. He is now Real Life Photography. I love his channel. Just set speed at x2 and away you go.

  • @jakilahmoulien9070
    @jakilahmoulien9070 42 минуты назад +2

    I believe chromatic aberration enhances depth perception. I just made a magazine cover with a Duplicate Word (very thin) layered on top of each other slightly adjacent. one was cyan, the one on top was red. when both are layered on top of each other it looks like it's popping out of the screen.

  • @JohnDrummondPhoto
    @JohnDrummondPhoto Час назад +2

    B&W does increase the 3D pop of both lenses. The foliage, though of varying colors, is of similar value (light/dark). So in monochrome, it all blends together more. The Meike lens does have better bokeh balls with less cats-eye. But the AF is horrible. Also, close focusing isn't great (98cm compared to the Canon's 85cm). You should really get at least one native Z-mount 85mm lens to see if the AF problems are the lens' fault or the body's. Thanks!

  • @yawningmarmot
    @yawningmarmot Час назад +2

    Meike took the phrase "stepping motor" way too literally.

  • @jlward953
    @jlward953 3 минуты назад

    You and I share a very specific sense of humor. Showing this to my wife she said, "You are the fan he needs." Lol

  • @RB-vf9xn
    @RB-vf9xn 5 минут назад

    Great video, you’re always entertaining and informative, keep it up!

  • @florabee9283
    @florabee9283 Час назад +1

    I see 3D pop as long as it’s labeled on the image so I know that I should see it.

  • @kostistau
    @kostistau 14 минут назад

    Hell yeah the 3d crab walk Test. The only scientific way do determine 3d pop.

  • @sneye1
    @sneye1 Час назад +2

    Hi, the Meike looks better than others but no match to the Canon 1.2.
    Sirui just announced its own version. The optical formula is interesting, maybe somewhat poppy. Please try it out when available.

  • @WorldMoneyWins
    @WorldMoneyWins 2 часа назад +2

    The dog blessed your gear with his pee.

  • @mdenjoyer831
    @mdenjoyer831 Час назад +2

    at 9:45 it looks like canon is a green screen and meike has better depth

  • @victor.ivanov
    @victor.ivanov 20 минут назад

    the last 5 seconds - cinema was ours. ma friends

  • @tommypaterson
    @tommypaterson Час назад +4

    This guy has half the photographers in the world believing there is such a thing as 3D pop, he is the Goebbels of RUclips.

    • @Austinite333
      @Austinite333 56 минут назад

      3D pop in a 2D flat world😏

  • @SebastianSas88
    @SebastianSas88 14 минут назад

    Thanks for the video.

  • @HereAfterBilliards
    @HereAfterBilliards 2 часа назад

    From one honesty inspired shill to another...your videos rock! Keep being you friend!

  • @williamwilson5127
    @williamwilson5127 2 часа назад +1

    The Canon seems to be more pleasing 95% of the time. It is just a choice of whether you want to fly budget or first class.

  • @filmedwith
    @filmedwith 2 часа назад +6

    Id hate to say it but i think Micky has some pop 🫢

    • @pixelsandgrain
      @pixelsandgrain Час назад +3

      Way more pop on Meike boy than the Canon for sure. In all settings. Maybe he changed the lens labels to create the biggest and baddest and dirtiest camera conspiracy of all times.

    • @PatrickWithCamera
      @PatrickWithCamera Час назад

      @@pixelsandgrain I think its because with meike he had a sun out of the clouds which gives higher contrast to the scene, while with canon looks like sun was behind clouds and its more muted. With meike I see weird cut out effect which I don't like, but that also could be the effect of higher contrast.

  • @evilkittyofdoom195
    @evilkittyofdoom195 Час назад

    You have trained your clone well!

  • @esteigh
    @esteigh 2 часа назад +2

    No choose the dog!

  • @donphobos
    @donphobos 19 минут назад

    Little did I know, that I am in need of 3D pop. Now I know it and am aware. Thank you. I will leave....

  • @maximkrivov
    @maximkrivov Час назад +1

    What AF lenses in 21/35/50mm for L mount that have 3D Pop do you recommend apart from the Sigma 45mm f2.8 DG DN C ?

  • @SPQR3ROME
    @SPQR3ROME 3 часа назад +1

    Lol, The guy on the left has green glasses.

  • @IlyaPodnebesmiy
    @IlyaPodnebesmiy Час назад

    I'm starting to grow a beard too. and I would like the beard to pierce you in a black and white image. that is, you know what I mean, these old black-and-white photographs of old men, where their thick beards seem to fall out into your hands through the image plane. but I also don't want to lose the 3D effect for this. I want to feel the sharp hair and the depth of space in a black and white video at the same time.

  • @ivandj707
    @ivandj707 2 часа назад

    The Meike is exactly the lens I need, too much 3D pop makes me dizzy 😊😊.

  • @YouSnoozeYouNooze
    @YouSnoozeYouNooze 32 минуты назад

    Maybe 3d pop is just dark blacks. The first time I saw an OLED TV I was struck by how the show I was watching looked obviously like actors on a set. Like it was so much more realistic I could tell it was faked

  • @iamionscat9035
    @iamionscat9035 8 минут назад

    Have you ever actually tried one of these new, really sharp, Sony t2.8 zooms? I mean actually tested it against one of Sony Zeiss lenses?
    I want to see what it looks like side by side in a Pepsi style 3D pop quiz challenge.

  • @technodronesogxl9783
    @technodronesogxl9783 Час назад

    Now Sirui has an 85 1.4 for Nikon

  • @rikkiekhrist6823
    @rikkiekhrist6823 Час назад +1

    the meike looks a little better to my eye

  • @AprilClayton
    @AprilClayton 58 секунд назад

    I was wondering what ED stood for.

  • @thissidetowardscreen4553
    @thissidetowardscreen4553 2 часа назад +2

    I learn so much here! I love hearing about our early ancestors, cave people, who used saber tooth for lens, Amazing! I never knew ED meant erasing depth! I am a better photographer because of this channel! 13:18 was nightmare fuel! So much for a good night sleep! Thanks for sharing, educating and entertaining us!

  • @Spiritfractals
    @Spiritfractals 2 часа назад

    Its really hard to tell you need to buy another nikon body so you can do them side by side - that would be the bees knees of comparison ❤😂

  • @mdenjoyer831
    @mdenjoyer831 Час назад +1

    the canon looks like you are using a green screen

  • @LiveMyJourneyTom
    @LiveMyJourneyTom Час назад +3

    If you have to go through all that rigmarole to get an inconclusive result it sort of feels pointless. It like choosing a car base not on its size, type of fuel, comfort or performance but based on the material lining the glove box. Very few people will care even if they could ever notice it. But it’s nice to have a hobby even if no one else understands it.

  • @m0nztam0nk
    @m0nztam0nk Час назад +1

    I recently shot the Z8 with the 85 1.2 for the first time…idk what to say, but never in my life have i seen such incredible 3D Pop and dimensional Rendering. The images it produces are beyond stunning…not even Sonys 135 1.8 could do that…
    I know This channel was of a different opinion, but after shooting with it im convinced Nikons Z 85 1.2 is the best Glass to ever be created for Portrait Photography …. (Ive shot all Systems for multiple years now, all the high end Primes and such, but never have i seen such rendering and 3D Looking imagery)

  • @qbukhari
    @qbukhari Час назад

    Why the hell I liked mono chrome footage better than the color one

  • @drhito
    @drhito 3 часа назад

    I watch your video a few weeks back about you getting a Leica SL 50mm f2 when the new Panasonic S1H releases. Apparently, its a rebadged Panasonic 50mm 1.8; It has the exact same optical formula, and the 3D pop present. The Sigma 50mm F2 Contemporary has the pop for sure surprisingly since it has lower elements and less ED glass.
    I would love to see your take on rebadged lenses. Has Leica lost their way with modern AF lenses?

  • @cornellouis
    @cornellouis Час назад

    bro when are you testing ursa cine 12k?

  • @robertgoerss
    @robertgoerss 55 минут назад

    The conversation with the model was a little too one sided. It lacked 3D oops.

  • @iamionscat9035
    @iamionscat9035 28 минут назад

    Are you wearing hobbit shoes? I can't tell if they are sandles with socks (comfy and great) or some sort of weird homemade leather bespoke things.

  • @DaphneEleazarar
    @DaphneEleazarar 3 часа назад +2

    This video made me forget about all the things I was doing. Now I have a new goal of watching it over and over again🍓

  • @RArecordingsRickValcon
    @RArecordingsRickValcon 3 часа назад

    the question is.. can you make a picture have the 3D pop in post editing?
    Because that would mean you have alll the options in a modern lens. Question 2: Is distortion and chromatic abboration correction inverted your 3D pop?

    • @jakilahmoulien9070
      @jakilahmoulien9070 35 минут назад

      the chromatic aberration should be adjusted by distance. if you apply it without that distance aberration adjustment it will pop out but will not show the depth by distance, only like on 2 flat planes. 3D works the same way with those red and blue overlays. thing is the aberration changes with distance. if you figure how to do it you're onto something. Try it with thin Letters layered (Cyan on top of red) you will see it pop out

  • @iteachtime
    @iteachtime 2 часа назад +1

    You owe me a keyboard. Spewed coffee over the, "Hard one to measure by Scientology" comment. Bwahahahahahaha. Thanks Camera Conspiracies for starting my day off right.
    Then there's the ED for Erasing Depth.
    Love this channel!

  • @Michael-fw5ef
    @Michael-fw5ef Час назад +1

    The Micky-boy produces too much sharpness, just like a Sigma.
    But it does have better 3D pop than the Canon.

  • @gregboyce360
    @gregboyce360 2 часа назад

    You could be a model as a side hustle! Laughing.

  • @RB-vf9xn
    @RB-vf9xn 6 минут назад

    If 3D pop is caused by chromatic aberration, we should NOT be able to notice it on black and white imagery, as the CHROMA (color) in chromatic aberration is gone in black and white… our boy here needs to go revisit the color theory chapter of his Scientology book, or indeed this is the greatest lens conspiracy ever…. 😜

  • @tara6664
    @tara6664 Час назад

    The Meike makes your head look fatter .

  • @stevenjohnson4283
    @stevenjohnson4283 2 часа назад

    When you were closer to the camera the Canon appeared to have more 3D pop, but when you were furthest away, the Mieke had better 3D pop and maybe because it seemed sharper. I think I disagree with this idea about ED elements snuffing out 3D pop/dimensionality. Lenses can have ED elements and CA's. ED elements probably have more to do with sharpness. The more Chromatic Aberrations, the more the 3D pop. If the Meike has CA's then it has some 3D pop.

  • @vivianp5962
    @vivianp5962 2 часа назад +1

    :)

  • @TerriblyCinemaddict
    @TerriblyCinemaddict 5 минут назад

    am I the only one here who thinks the canon has less 3d pop?

  • @DrWasim
    @DrWasim Минуту назад

    I don’t see it man

  • @SetPace
    @SetPace 3 часа назад

    Early

  • @HeadlessChickenTO
    @HeadlessChickenTO 2 часа назад

    CC; ED, stands for...
    Me; Errect...
    CC; Erease Depth.
    Me...oh right. I'm watching RUclips.

  • @jimgiraffe5253
    @jimgiraffe5253 2 часа назад

    is there ever just too much pop ? it almost looks like a goofy green screen :/

  • @TheChosenOne_
    @TheChosenOne_ 2 часа назад

    Michael Mouse sent you a lens?