"The Rough Sex Defence” For MURDER: Grace Millane’s Tinder Date From Hell

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 25 июл 2024
  • #Ad - The first 500 people to use my link will receive a one month free trial of Skillshare: skl.sh/eleanorneale04241
    Today’s case is about Grace Millane, who was strangled to death by her Tinder date in Auckland, New Zealand in 2018. Grace’s case shocked the country and held a mirror up to a society with a problem of violence towards women.
    Love Grace Handbag Appeal: www.lovegrace.co.uk/
    Listen to my true crime episodes as a podcast:
    bit.ly/3qtVG20
    Request a case - www.videoask.com/fsuda4gnk
    My second channel - @ellieneale1
    My Links - linktr.ee/eleanorneale
    Business - EleanorNeale@sixteenth.co
    Special thanks to my wonderful team of researchers, editors & managers!
    Disclaimer: I mean no disrespect to anyone that I talk about in this video. Everything in this video is publicly available information that myself and my team have found and compiled into one piece. This video will cover especially sensitive topics, viewer discretion is advised.While we make every effort to fact-check our sources and make sure all our information is correct - no action should be taken in reliance upon the information in this video. Please keep the comments respectful and kind. All opinions in this video are mine alone.
    Thank you for watching!! Xx

Комментарии • 1,5 тыс.

  • @sydan-wv9tm
    @sydan-wv9tm 3 месяца назад +6521

    someone said that ”men are scared of being catfished when they go on a date. women are scared that they will get murdered” and i think thats a good way to put it

    • @tostibroodje7525
      @tostibroodje7525 3 месяца назад +214

      You know what's sad, I had this same conversation with my little brother a little while ago. And he seriously had the nerve to say "Well, can't women tell when a man will be a murderer or dangerous?" I told him obviously no, otherwise there wouldnt be so many cases. Im glad he at least kinda understood afterwards. But ive heard this way of thinking from more men I know. And I'm from a more "foreward" thinking country, so that should tell you enough on how it goes on everywhere

    • @HAHdoesit
      @HAHdoesit 3 месяца назад +46

      I don’t think sayings like this should exist because men can be murder victims too.. everyone should be cautious no matter the gender and yes okay men are known to be stronger than women but that’s not always the case, it’s merely a stereotype I’m not trying to be rude I just don’t think this should be a thing

    • @Grodis420
      @Grodis420 3 месяца назад

      whats more likely is raped or hurt in another way

    • @tobiaslawrence8928
      @tobiaslawrence8928 3 месяца назад +18

      You don't think guys don't experience the same thing?

    • @iamchelseafromthegram5746
      @iamchelseafromthegram5746 3 месяца назад

      @@tobiaslawrence8928no where near as much as women do

  • @thelittlestpika
    @thelittlestpika 3 месяца назад +2842

    As Elenor said, it's almost impossible to accidentally end someone's life with rough sex but the fact that there was blood EVERYWHERE makes it obvious that something much more violent and awful happened.

    • @reallyrics3177
      @reallyrics3177 3 месяца назад +121

      That’s what I was wondering..the autopsy didn’t mention bleeding, only bruising & choking

    • @tf9241
      @tf9241 3 месяца назад +63

      The problem is it is a hotel room, it could have been another guest, say a woman who had issues with her cycle, or another incident with Jesse and a girl. The fact the autopsy only focuses on the bruises and no possible stab wounds or anything that would produce blood, makes me think that maybe the blood was from something else. His previous relationships said he was definitely a character, wouldn’t surprise me if he had played rough before

    • @availanila
      @availanila 3 месяца назад +52

      ​@@tf9241 strangled people bleed usually from the ears, nose and mouth.

    • @MommaSullens
      @MommaSullens 3 месяца назад +21

      Did he make any cuts to fit her in the luggage?

    • @cocorocherraffaello6629
      @cocorocherraffaello6629 3 месяца назад

      ⁠​⁠@@tf9241HOWEVER… he went and rented the carpet cleaner, why would he need that🤔

  • @lizardparty6984
    @lizardparty6984 3 месяца назад +1075

    The fact that he claims putting her in that suitcase was traumatic for him really goes to show he only thinks of himself, truly disgusting.

    • @kelsiealice3164
      @kelsiealice3164 3 месяца назад +30

      this is what i was thinking 🤢 traumatic for him, yet how did he think poor grace felt? this world is so scary

  • @anyabreen6179
    @anyabreen6179 3 месяца назад +923

    I remember the media coverage of this case was absolutely disgusting. The guy wasn't even named for ' his protection' but Grace's entire sexual history was plastered everywhere in detail 💔

    • @cecilia1300
      @cecilia1300 3 месяца назад +40

      What the hell???

    • @itsbecco
      @itsbecco 3 месяца назад +12

      his name was leaked and the integrity of the trial was almost jeopardised

    • @grw_gg
      @grw_gg 2 месяца назад +34

      if the killer had been a woman she would have been named and shamed so fast. such a shame that sexism is still alive and well, but people just pretend it’s not.

    • @sallylees467
      @sallylees467 2 месяца назад +6

      That's not true. His identity was being protected as he was in another court case for abusing other women and if his name was made public it would have helped him on the next case as he could claim he didn't get a fair trial.

  • @scribble3210
    @scribble3210 3 месяца назад +1785

    I met Jesse once in 2018 He was dating my ex’s cousin. He was at a family wedding. He told my sister he was a police officer from Australia. He’s a compulsive liar. When he was dumped he listed her number on a sex workers site so people would call her. Awful man

    • @mayvm13
      @mayvm13 3 месяца назад

      Wow what an asshole!!! I’m glad he didn’t stick around in your lives

    • @shelceegraves1241
      @shelceegraves1241 3 месяца назад +122

      Yikes! I'm happy she made it out of the relationship and hope she is doing ok now! 🙏

    • @mandyb2245
      @mandyb2245 3 месяца назад +82

      Ew, what a sicko!

    • @eprobllama
      @eprobllama 3 месяца назад +42

      Omg that’s horrifying

    • @rachaelm3298
      @rachaelm3298 3 месяца назад +47

      Thats so fcked up.. glad she didnt become victim of something worse by him.. Can never be too careful..

  • @tvmayer
    @tvmayer 3 месяца назад +2812

    I once hooked up with a man who went from playfully choking me to full on punching and strangling me. It was the most terrifying moment of my life. Let this serve as a reminder that consent must be given throughout sexual activity and silence is not a yes. My heart breaks for sweet Grace for the horror she must have experienced. Jesse is evil and should never be released.

    • @travelsandbooks
      @travelsandbooks 3 месяца назад +159

      I'm so sorry that happened to you.

    • @alex_2342
      @alex_2342 3 месяца назад +106

      I hope you're ok now. I'm glad you didn't get killed that day/night

    • @joelystevenson3795
      @joelystevenson3795 3 месяца назад +60

      I hope you reported him, I’m so sorry you went through that

    • @Thepriestessdeath
      @Thepriestessdeath 3 месяца назад +1

      @@joelystevenson3795stop telling people to report and actually lesson to sa survivors. Not okay. You’re privileged.

    • @Thepriestessdeath
      @Thepriestessdeath 3 месяца назад +76

      Never let anyone make you feel bad for not reporting it. Sorry that happened to you and wish you all the healing in the world and sending you love.

  • @avocadogal443
    @avocadogal443 3 месяца назад +402

    I once matched a guy on tinder, the first message I received from him was "have you heard about that man that killed his tinder date?". Yes I have. And you sir are getting a block.

    • @b_sav
      @b_sav 3 месяца назад +4

      Y’all are desperate 😂

    • @saharah101
      @saharah101 3 месяца назад +29

      That’s terrifying

    • @awesomekoga7848
      @awesomekoga7848 3 месяца назад +4

      👍🏼 be safe!

    • @funkunko
      @funkunko 2 месяца назад

      stop dating men. seriously.

    • @kurtism
      @kurtism 2 месяца назад +10

      @@b_sav???

  • @broimliterallyjustagirl
    @broimliterallyjustagirl 3 месяца назад +831

    the rough sex defence makes me so horribly angry, this case is the first one i think of when i hear that phrase. the absolute audacity to try and explain it away, its sickening.

    • @fruityblue9784
      @fruityblue9784 3 месяца назад +33

      Yeah it’s insane. Like how is doing something violent during that activity somehow making it okay? It doesn’t! You know when you’re physically, mortally harming someone! And if you don’t, that’s still on you! She didn’t ask for any of that. I’m a masochist and there’s absolutely no way someone could confuse consensual pain caused to me over non consensual. Ugh.

    • @wolfzmusic9706
      @wolfzmusic9706 3 месяца назад +6

      Yes, it is usually horrible. However I did actually see a case a while ago where a guy accidentally electrocuted his wife to death during s*x. It's quite sad.

    • @sfmd5764
      @sfmd5764 3 месяца назад +24

      The case of Elaine O’hara (which Eleanor has covered) has a similar “rough sex defence” where the sick murderer try to say that she consented to bdsm so she basically consented to her death. It’s just as weird and sick as the gay panic defence!

    • @bucketree
      @bucketree 3 месяца назад +9

      It’s so wrong, its like the diff between play wrestling and WWE 😮

    • @xXKandyKatXx
      @xXKandyKatXx 3 месяца назад +1

      "B-b-but she wanted to be murdered..."
      🥺

  • @lillymetcalfe9330
    @lillymetcalfe9330 3 месяца назад +789

    I went to the same university as her, she graduated the year before me when this happened. The whole university held a vigil and charity events to raise awareness for violence against women - it was incredibly sad. RIP Grace

    • @alanalangley9675
      @alanalangley9675 3 месяца назад +12

      I go to UOL. I’ll be thinking of Grace when I’m on campus 😔

    • @rianroberts16
      @rianroberts16 3 месяца назад +3

      ​@@alanalangley9675 same

  • @alyxandersimon5096
    @alyxandersimon5096 3 месяца назад +1383

    NZer here! NZ has low crime rates for kidnappings and such because the police here (dependant on city) are very selective on what requires their attention! They'd much rather turn a blind eye to some teens drinking in a friendly neighbourhood than ignore an intoxicated person get tugged away by someone. In my experience I've been asked quite a few times for proof I know a drunk mate that I'm pulling into an uber. They're not amazing but bouncers here do not mess around about any possible druggings/intoxicated people getting pulled around. I told a bouncer once that a guy was making me uncomfortable and he said "That makes 2 people saying he's weird, I'll get him out." so while I've still been harassed the second they spot it they act on it :)

    • @soppphhhuuuu
      @soppphhhuuuu 3 месяца назад +126

      i wish police everywhere were like this. one of my friends overdosed when underage and drinking and the paramedics was far more concentrated on our age than the dying girl

    • @alyxandersimon5096
      @alyxandersimon5096 3 месяца назад +42

      @@soppphhhuuuu you're so incredibly strong for going through that. I hope you're doing better now and wish you and your families all the love possible.

    • @nikitadecruy3135
      @nikitadecruy3135 3 месяца назад +32

      I agree, nz is super safe compared to other countries. But this case held every single nzers heart.

    • @alliebean3235
      @alliebean3235 3 месяца назад +17

      while a lot of bouncers are pretty onto it, we do have cases like that one bar in Christchurch that recently was exposed for a serial roofie ring done by the owners/bartender. i feel safe in bars most of the time, but u can also never be too careful!

    • @xemu001
      @xemu001 3 месяца назад +3

      also from new zealand :]

  • @HAHdoesit
    @HAHdoesit 3 месяца назад +619

    A minimum of 17 years is CRAZY for murder!! I hope he never gets out honestly!

    • @Akku8581
      @Akku8581 3 месяца назад +9

      That's a life sentence here in NZ

    • @charlessarver1637
      @charlessarver1637 3 месяца назад +1

      He shouldnt

    • @chris95myers72
      @chris95myers72 3 месяца назад

      I said the exact same thing.

    • @bryiahtuffley4288
      @bryiahtuffley4288 3 месяца назад +4

      The justice system here is awful!! Police are usually quite useless too.
      So much crime goes unnoticed.
      Its not safe here

    • @kaylagray2222
      @kaylagray2222 3 месяца назад +3

      Here in NZ it's a joke somebody usually gets 12 years for murder

  • @ericamorgan2928
    @ericamorgan2928 3 месяца назад +1839

    the random "blue ass waterr" in the american accent is taking me outtt 😭

    • @Lovelee2105
      @Lovelee2105 3 месяца назад +18

      Faaaaacts!!!!

    • @my_final_curtain.
      @my_final_curtain. 3 месяца назад +9

      Timestamp ?🤭🤭

    • @jae4387
      @jae4387 3 месяца назад +32

      @@my_final_curtain.9:25

    • @alanalake6762
      @alanalake6762 3 месяца назад +34

      Nah she’s acc so funny

    • @whoa_livia
      @whoa_livia 3 месяца назад +12

      You’re right lol she’s hilarious

  • @beckyasmr7239
    @beckyasmr7239 3 месяца назад +443

    Okay alittle side note after seeing the footage of him getting in the elevator twice w the suitcase tht her body was in and seeing two different people get in the same elevator is so terrifying! Like imagine being in an elevator w killer who has the victim in a suitcase and u hav absolutely no idea. It really makes u think about how many times we can pass something so awful and have absolutely no idea!

    • @Jordan-nw4sj
      @Jordan-nw4sj 3 месяца назад +44

      The average person will walk past 36 murders in their life. We've studied this.

    • @joebloggs619
      @joebloggs619 3 месяца назад

      OK, Goigle, right b now, yet another of my comments was made to v a night. Typically just before an ad comes on. Please investigate the problem. It is probably Hoigle or You Tube employees doing this.

    • @shelceegraves1241
      @shelceegraves1241 3 месяца назад +15

      I immediately thought, "I am going to forever side eye anyone with a suitcase in an elevator, even in hotels!".

    • @shelceegraves1241
      @shelceegraves1241 3 месяца назад +3

      ​@@Jordan-nw4sj Well. That's terrifying information I now have rattling around in my head.

    • @shelceegraves1241
      @shelceegraves1241 3 месяца назад

      ​@@joebloggs619I think it might be a random glitch in the app. It's happened to me a few times. I usually just retype it and post it again and usually don't have anymore issues.

  • @spud6195
    @spud6195 3 месяца назад +377

    A woman, or even a man, can consent to being choked during sex and yet some people see that as 'oh they consented to being strangled to death'. BIG difference between sex where a person has given their consent to being choked and murder and the fact that so many fail to realise this and use 'the rough sex defence' is sickening. To claim it was an accident is such BS...you would be able to feel the difference in a consenting, conscious person and someone who has passed out. If that's not enough to make you stop and it gets to the point where the person dies it's MURDER plain & simple

    • @Aleutica
      @Aleutica 3 месяца назад +14

      i agree that it would have been obvious through body language that she was no longer consenting. however there's another big issue here that a lot of people are unaware of concerning choking during sex, i'll copy paste what i mentioned in another comment:
      "i do want to point out how dangerous any form of strangling is, even if you do consent. there's been misinformation going around that there's a "correct" way to choke someone (blood chokes vs air chokes). blood chokes can slow/stop blood from reaching your brain while air chokes can crush your windpipe. both can end up in severe injury or even death. this is more likely when men do it to women as men have 70% stronger grip strength than women (and don't always recognise their own relative strength) and women have thinner neck skin tissue, although it's possible with both men and women"
      sometimes the injuries from choking are only noticeable several days later too, and by then it's too late

    • @maddieb.4282
      @maddieb.4282 3 месяца назад

      @@Aleuticado you have any statistics or cases where consensual choking actually caused injuries?

    • @Aleutica
      @Aleutica 3 месяца назад

      @@maddieb.4282 www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9201570/ which shows a difference between women who had been choked vs those who had never been. there were some differences in brain scans. this was a sexual study
      www.kemh.health.wa.gov.au/~/media/HSPs/NMHS/Hospitals/WNHS/Documents/Patients-resources/SARC---Non-fatal-strangulation.pdf and this is more general, about choking in general and the risks

    • @Aleutica
      @Aleutica 3 месяца назад +3

      @@maddieb.4282 i think my other reply might have gotten auto-deleted, but there's a study called "Frequent and Recent Non-fatal Strangulation/Choking During S*x and Its Association With fMRI Activation During Working Memory Tasks" that shows those who have been strangled during s*x have different brain scans
      there's also a government of western australia article that goes into the issues with it, and it wasn't purely about s*x, it was just about strangulation in general

    •  3 месяца назад +2

      @@AleuticaI think if you’re consenting to it and both parties are understanding then you can both find the right amount of pressure to not cause any harm, and plus not do it for long periods, take breaks, but obviously for some it doesn’t work like that and they go too hard and don’t listen to the person being chocked which is really sad!

  • @pathemeleski
    @pathemeleski 3 месяца назад +419

    It really says something that a man's biggest fear on a blind date, it that the girl doesn't look like what she says, while a woman's greatest fear is being murdered.😢

    • @kaplingnag7267
      @kaplingnag7267 3 месяца назад +4

      Lovely generalizing ❤️ you're making sexism obsolete and saving innocent men and women with this

    • @ozy-mq8ei
      @ozy-mq8ei 3 месяца назад

      @@kaplingnag7267what are you talking about? that person didn’t say anything sexist. yes, men can be victims of SA and murder. we know that. but the majority of SA victims are women. that’s a fact.

    • @saturn888
      @saturn888 3 месяца назад +37

      @@kaplingnag7267 men can’t be victims of sexism because there is no oppressive structure oppressing men just because they’re men. however, one thing to keep in mind is intersectionality. men of color experience gender based violence because of racism. not sexism. it’s complicated to explain especially in a comment section but that’s how the world works. do some research.

    • @charlotte-7700
      @charlotte-7700 3 месяца назад +16

      @@kaplingnag7267when did they ever say that this applies to *all* men or women? right, they didn't. you're reading too much into it. also, like someone else already said, men can't experience sexism because they aren't systematically oppressed

    • @pathemeleski
      @pathemeleski 3 месяца назад +2

      @kaplingnag7267 it's not a generalization. It's a fact. It's the result of a psychological study that came up with these results. While men CAN be murdered, it is NOT one of their fears when going on a date. It is something women fear.

  • @prettygremlin1015
    @prettygremlin1015 3 месяца назад +556

    Aw man. When I was 21, I went to a guy’s house for a date, and told him straight up before I even left my own house that I didn’t want to do anything sexual. He picked me up, drove an hour to his place, and then immediately proceeded to undress me and not take no for an answer. He hid my phone from me, choked me intensely, “gave me a massage” which caused awful pain and bruises on my back and chest, and proceeded to just take advantage of me because I couldn’t fight back. This case hits close to home for me, and I’m so grateful I got out of it alive. My heart goes out to her family.

    • @ZombiesGoRawrrrrr
      @ZombiesGoRawrrrrr 3 месяца назад +63

      i’m so sorry that happened to you :( people are so terrifying

    • @joebloggs619
      @joebloggs619 3 месяца назад +4

      Google, please investigate. Yet another of my comments has just vanished, probably some illicit data collection going on. It typically happens just before an ad comes on and it only happens in relation to comments on videos by women, dealing with feminist type issues.

    • @WakeyWakeyEggsandBakey
      @WakeyWakeyEggsandBakey 3 месяца назад +19

      Terrifying. I hope you've found a measure of peace and security in your life. Love from England ❤

    • @smithamy1982
      @smithamy1982 3 месяца назад +21

      Never go back to their house if you don't want anything sexual to happen. It doesn't matter if you tell them you don't want anything sexual beforehand. What did you think you guys were going to do at his place that was an hour drive away from your place? Play boardgames? No offense but you shouldn't ever put yourself in that position where you are alone and they have full control of the scenario, it's just not smart. You clearly didn't deserve what happened but hopefully you learned from the situation and won't put yourself in that position again.

    • @XYZ-kb3mm
      @XYZ-kb3mm 3 месяца назад

      @@smithamy1982 you should be so, so ashamed of yourself. imagine saying this to someone’s face after they’ve just told you this story. that should show you how truly pathetic your comment was.

  • @briarfv
    @briarfv 3 месяца назад +206

    Kiwi here and the whole country hates this guy. My heart breaks remembering Grace’s story and I remember requesting it from you years ago. Thank you for covering

  • @alex_2342
    @alex_2342 3 месяца назад +353

    This is why I always tell my friends to share their location with me and the guys name and profile just in case something happens I could help with the case (has happened before and the profile + location helped them find her again)

    • @sshhrroomm
      @sshhrroomm 3 месяца назад +17

      i hope their alright. happy they were found again!

    • @alex_2342
      @alex_2342 3 месяца назад +23

      @@sshhrroomm thankfully, after a lot of therapy she is doing well. Thank you, please be safe if you go on an online date (if you're old enough)

    • @wmadar
      @wmadar 3 месяца назад +7

      oh my goodness!! i hope your friend is okay ❤

    • @alex_2342
      @alex_2342 3 месяца назад +3

      @@wmadar she is, I actually was with her when I posted that comment, she's doing really well :)

  • @molliefitzpatrick8157
    @molliefitzpatrick8157 3 месяца назад +195

    1:25 me realising I've watched every single video for the past 6 years 😦😦😦😦 you're the longest relationship I've ever had 😂

  • @JE4-1
    @JE4-1 3 месяца назад +389

    . I think back on all the risks I took at her age, and think how lucky I am to be alive. I was so stupid, gullible, and naive. Some of those risks were even more foolish than Grace's. Almost enough to give me "survivors' guilt". I definitely had an angel watching over me!

    • @bambaolina
      @bambaolina 3 месяца назад +42

      same!!! looking back i can’t believe some of the stuff i did and i feel so lucky that it didn’t end badly for me. it makes me physically cringe every time i think about it.

    • @jasminebanks5710
      @jasminebanks5710 3 месяца назад +21

      Same, I "shouldn't" be alive due to my antics. So grateful to have survived my 20s!

    • @macielawrence9361
      @macielawrence9361 3 месяца назад +15

      Literally me now at the age of 21 to realise how many bad situations I was in with older men as a 16 to 18 Yr old and being into bdsm and going out late at night even if not drinking even just for a walk but would never do that now amd I same belive I am incredibly lucky that something like this didn't happen to me 😢 rip Grace amd ladies pls be careful something like this could happen at any age 💔

    • @orishabaleyler8907
      @orishabaleyler8907 3 месяца назад +2

      Same

    • @ashleighnewell3265
      @ashleighnewell3265 3 месяца назад +1

      Same I cannot believe the situations I literally chose to put myself in yikes

  • @nbdjz1058
    @nbdjz1058 3 месяца назад +238

    as someone who has practiced rough sex safely and consensually many times, it makes me so mad when anyone tries to defend actual abuse and harm with this "excuse"

    • @maddieb.4282
      @maddieb.4282 3 месяца назад +25

      Same, it’s ridiculous as someone who has experienced both to compare consensual BDSM to abuse. They are COMPLETELY different experiences so dramatically that I know anyone comparing them is totally vanilla lol

    • @pixiepunk25
      @pixiepunk25 3 месяца назад +8

      I completely agree

    • @broidkanymore-zc4lt
      @broidkanymore-zc4lt 24 дня назад

      rough sex isnt safe

    • @nbdjz1058
      @nbdjz1058 24 дня назад +1

      @@broidkanymore-zc4lt yes it is if you're both experienced consenting adults who are very familiar with and respectful of each others boundaries.

    • @pixiepunk25
      @pixiepunk25 24 дня назад

      @@broidkanymore-zc4lt 🤣 yes it is with the right person

  • @faithgreensmith6971
    @faithgreensmith6971 3 месяца назад +152

    The footage of the women in the elevator with him while he has those suitcases is horrifying. could you imagine finding out there was a body in those suitcases that you were NEXT TO

  • @Alejojojo6
    @Alejojojo6 3 месяца назад +69

    Choking? Then why was all that blood in the carpet of the hotel room??? Something is fishy.

    • @4stacia
      @4stacia 3 месяца назад +5

      Yhhh I’m thinking about that

  • @Mornotoky
    @Mornotoky 3 месяца назад +164

    Never turning my location off ever again. This is just soo sad.😢

  • @briarfv
    @briarfv 3 месяца назад +63

    Another heartbreaking thing about this is that Grace’s father David was diagnosed with cancer after Jesse’s trial and passed away in November 2020 after all of the heartbreak this family had already been through. Hope Grace and David are resting peacefully 🕊️

  • @bethtweedy5128
    @bethtweedy5128 3 месяца назад +134

    17 freaking years??? And you are serious??? I’m hoping that this is a bad joke!! Life without parole would be almost enough.

    • @volcanicfae
      @volcanicfae 3 месяца назад +10

      That is the life sentence in nz :(

    • @joleeneriksen7680
      @joleeneriksen7680 3 месяца назад +4

      And welcome to our fucked up justice system 😀….

  • @ingridn0g
    @ingridn0g 3 месяца назад +74

    I just gotta say that I'M LIVING for how PASSIONATE and angry you are in this video. I am a r*pe survivor and it's amazing to see a woman I admire so much react that strongly to such crimes.
    Sex related crimes are always such complicated matters because of all the misoginy involved, and because, even when we (the victims) survive, we are scarred for life. There is no justification, no possible explanation or excuse for abusing someone.

  • @daveings9485
    @daveings9485 3 месяца назад +42

    its so insane to me that pretty much every single moment of this was caught on cctv except the actual murder, and he still has the balls to insist he didnt do it at first

  • @x27ev
    @x27ev 3 месяца назад +87

    From a New Zealander, specifically Auckland, i remember when this case was made public and it was so haunting for every single person in auckland, the city was so quiet and empty for WEEKS after this case. Genuinely horrific

    • @sophielewis49
      @sophielewis49 3 месяца назад +9

      Aucklander here also - it's haunting seeing photos of places he went too, knowing they're so close to home

    • @tf9241
      @tf9241 3 месяца назад +6

      Same. I lived in Auckland around the time this case happened and I was working at the Warehouse he got the suitcases from. I would be in town late at night to get the bus home from my shift or my shift from my other job. It was scary to be a young woman out by myself late at night.

    • @x27ev
      @x27ev 3 месяца назад

      @@sophielewis49 i had to stop watching when Eleanor started talking about Sky City

    • @itsbecco
      @itsbecco 3 месяца назад +2

      the girls all came together at that time, like none of us felt alone, sharing each others live locations and going out in pairs or groups… i still feel like it’s haunting when i’m in the waitakere area

    • @x27ev
      @x27ev 2 месяца назад

      @h-mz7yk okay here are my main points:
      1. you will be shocked at how expensive gas is
      2. the food here is a lot better
      3. rest stops are usually safe
      4. you can travel each island with a vehicle (you will need to boat to get from the north island to the south island)
      5. meeting new people is very easy here

  • @DaisyxDella
    @DaisyxDella 3 месяца назад +91

    It’s so heartbreaking how someone can easily take someone else’s life and act as if it’s just another day the next day.

  • @TurnerIntoAMommy
    @TurnerIntoAMommy 3 месяца назад +40

    I used to work in a prosecutor's office. I saw an uptick of the "sex gone wrong" defense after 50 Shades, and honestly, that's sad. These books and movies (especially the movies) have given men, and some women, a possible out or way to get a lesser sentence because there's no way to prove 100% someone is or isn't into that kind of stuff. It's very sad. This guy knew exactly what he was doing and it wasn't playful sex or anything like that. He is a murderer plain and simple.

  • @miyah4142
    @miyah4142 3 месяца назад +113

    the “pretty little liars” theme song 😭❤️ ironic cause for some reason, she looks like she coulda been a part of that cast.

    • @Whatisthiseh
      @Whatisthiseh 3 месяца назад +4

      I spotted that too :( so sad and love pll

    • @LBeditz07
      @LBeditz07 3 месяца назад +4

      I thought I was the only one that noticed that😭

  • @stephisom8292
    @stephisom8292 3 месяца назад +133

    Nowhere in his story is the answer to how there was so much blood showing up on the carpets?? You don’t get that many footprints from a bit of blood coming out of someone’s nose

    • @cmjohnsonhuckaby
      @cmjohnsonhuckaby 3 месяца назад +23

      I thought the same thing!!!

    • @SatumainenOlento
      @SatumainenOlento 3 месяца назад +11

      It might be a blessing that we do not know. Some details can be extremely distressing and cause long term trauma. I remember 2 cases which details haunt me 😵😵😵

    • @LG11330
      @LG11330 3 месяца назад +3

      Also, it’s a hotel room so was it definitely all Grace’s blood?

    • @Saturnm0ss
      @Saturnm0ss 3 месяца назад +7

      @@LG11330where would that much blood come from though except from her?

    • @gracesedan4759
      @gracesedan4759 3 месяца назад +4

      @@SatumainenOlentoYou don’t have to go into detail, but I’m just curious what cases? If you don’t mind me asking of course.

  • @charlotterobb5435
    @charlotterobb5435 3 месяца назад +39

    He also had later convictions of sexual assault against an ex partner in 2020 and was found guilty. He told the judge that he was 'full of shit'. Such a charming guy. Hes right where he belongs.

  • @imogenaurora
    @imogenaurora 3 месяца назад +73

    YESSS! As a New Zealander, I have been wanting you to cover this case for years. I used to live close to where her body was found. This case was haunting and absolutely heartbreaking.

  • @lalafuschiva
    @lalafuschiva 3 месяца назад +53

    my big sister is the same age as grace, it’s crazy to think that it could have been my sister. this is someone’s child, friend, cousin, sibling (?), backpack traveler, classmate, former date, everything. she’s not only a victim in a murder, but a victim in sexism. may she rest in peace

  • @blackcatcrochet
    @blackcatcrochet 3 месяца назад +54

    She was perfectly fine in South America but was murdered in New Zealand. She seems like such a unique, amazing, and strong woman it's sickening that such a waste of space loser was what took her from this world.

    • @justaperson6254
      @justaperson6254 3 месяца назад

      young kiwi woman here (20, almost 21). we have a major problem with misogyny, rape culture, and shitty men.
      new zealand usually is safe, but like everywhere else, we have unsavoury characters. my mum has been extremely protective of me against disgusting males like jesse.
      may grace rest in peace.

  • @emilymoran3224
    @emilymoran3224 3 месяца назад +38

    This man is so vile to not only did what he did but he also had the nerve to try blame Grace for her own death. I was also about to mention that he went on a date while her body was in his room but you just brought it up 🤢 his past behaviour really shows what kind of person he truly is. Watching back the CTV footage of that day is absolutely chilling 😢

  • @Gh0stsh4rk_
    @Gh0stsh4rk_ 3 месяца назад +43

    Honestly the fact she was knowledgeable about bdsm would make me less likely to buy Jessie’s story. You’re telling me a woman who knows how dangerous choking can be and that safe words, boundaries, and consent are key aspects of safe bdsm would ask a man to choke her out of the blue without any prior discussion..?

  • @bayliedanielle9071
    @bayliedanielle9071 3 месяца назад +26

    my partners ex used to flat with Jesse. One night he came home drunk they were so scared, she had pushed her furniture up to her door and had a knife in her hand just incase…he would tell the most exaggerated lies about himself wether it was about his job family etc. a total compulsive liar. I remember driving past the forest where grace was found, such a sad airy feeling. Her story shook our country. Rest in love Grace ❤

  • @annagardiner8351
    @annagardiner8351 3 месяца назад +23

    This case makes me sick. How could he blame Grace for her own death? We all know damn well that the “rough sex” excuse is utter bullshit. You don’t accidentally kill someone. The body makes a physical, subconscious effort to save itself when it’s suffering. This man is the devil, and quite frankly, I’m so sick of men in general, blaming women for pain, suffering, and even deaths that THEY cause because THEY are the ones with sick, twisted fantasies. Grace was young, this man was older. He had every chance to stop something before it got out of hand and he didn’t. Not only did Grace die at the hands of this man, but now he gets to sit there and act like it’s her fault. God, I’m so tired.

  • @laurengriffiths6297
    @laurengriffiths6297 3 месяца назад +42

    Congrats on 6 years!! You are a part of so many of our weekly routines so thank you 💕

  • @JustyPeachy
    @JustyPeachy 3 месяца назад +106

    There's something about hearing your own name in a true crime story. I feel for Grace and as a fellow Grace, I wish her peace.

    • @beanastronaut
      @beanastronaut 3 месяца назад

      For real!!!!

    • @gracesedan4759
      @gracesedan4759 3 месяца назад +2

      Hello, fellow Grace, I’m Grace. But yeah, something about hearing your name in a case really hits different.

    • @funkunko
      @funkunko 2 месяца назад +4

      way to make it about you..

  • @sharongrigg5336
    @sharongrigg5336 3 месяца назад +22

    Just thought I'd add another tragic part to this story, Grace's dad David passed away just after the trial finished from cancer. He was ill during the trial but was determined to be there. RIP Grace & David

  • @EyeLoveKats
    @EyeLoveKats 3 месяца назад +9

    This is so bittersweet, because other girls finally got to speak up about but how they are survivors but sadly Grace was brutally murdered by this sick man.

  • @sarajackson3198
    @sarajackson3198 3 месяца назад +47

    I was wondering whether you would be covering this case. I studied at the University of Lincoln at the same time as Grace, graduating on the same day, I have mutual friends who studied/were friends with her. It’s very surreal because at the time it was a complete shock to the entire university and the community as a whole. I didn’t know her personally but I knew she used to love playing hockey so the university held a tournament for her in memoriam. It was truly devastating to hear this when it happened, thank you Eleanor for covering this with such dignity. Rest in peace Grace.

    • @charlotterobb5435
      @charlotterobb5435 3 месяца назад +4

      I live in NZ and it was so heartbreaking when it happened. I remember crying as our prime minister was on the news saying that Grace should have been safe here. She really should have been.

    • @sarajackson3198
      @sarajackson3198 3 месяца назад +4

      @@charlotterobb5435 I know :( it was devastating! But NZ were so supportive of Grace and her family, and the rare occasion that the police actually managed to find and capture her killer so quickly and efficiently.

  • @EvieR7286
    @EvieR7286 3 месяца назад +14

    Grace’s story is one that has made a permanent mark on New Zealand, the whole country feels terribly that someone visiting was unsafe and lost their life. as well as the Love Grace handbag appeal which helps victims of domestic abuse, I often see it around the city

  • @dannii2323
    @dannii2323 3 месяца назад +48

    "Living like a tortoise" is the cutest thing I've ever heard ❤

  • @jadeskipper5708
    @jadeskipper5708 2 месяца назад +6

    “So if you start to feel any sympathy towards him at all?!?!? …. You can get rid of it. You can get rid of it right now.”
    EXACTLY! I have the same reactions and I’m always clapping when you make remarks and comments.
    Tell ‘em, baby!

  • @tehannah0
    @tehannah0 3 месяца назад +42

    not me just finishing your last video and getting recommend this (I panicked thinking I missed a vid) and then realized it says uploaded 37 seconds ago lol 😭😂 … needless to say love your videos eleanor!!!

  • @tiahmorey3931
    @tiahmorey3931 3 месяца назад +36

    Getting a notification for an Eleanor neale video as soon as you get in the bath is heaven

    • @relicrainbow
      @relicrainbow 3 месяца назад +1

      I wish I had a bath tub 😭

  • @jamiedanklefs9125
    @jamiedanklefs9125 3 месяца назад +20

    There should absolutely be a rating system for dating apps lmao

  • @bucketree
    @bucketree 3 месяца назад +21

    This breaks my heart as a kiwi, Grace should have been safe here, she should have had a great experience and should have been the one country her family could relax and know we would all as a nation be kind and friendly as most kiwis are, it broke our collective hearts that she was robbed of her future and her family had to go through the hell that this act of predation and murder lead to. Her family were so gracious and forgiving it was incredible the way they worked with the police and accepted our nations grief as part of their own. Arohanui Grace 😢

  • @Kat-V
    @Kat-V 3 месяца назад +14

    One thing about Eleanor's videos is that they never leave me feeling stupid or uninformed. Anything that could possibly be unclear, she will explain it! Like that you can't message strangers on tinder or that Luminol is a liquid, I just thought blood shone under the light naturally. And Ellie just explains everything to keep everyone caught up

  • @JayDee14121
    @JayDee14121 3 месяца назад +13

    The audacity of this man to say he chose the spot for safety reasons yet ended up literally murdering her is next level.

  • @tjxness
    @tjxness 3 месяца назад +20

    congrats on 6 years of youtube. your definitely one of the best true crime youtubers out there. keep it up!

  • @torievictoria
    @torievictoria 3 месяца назад +11

    He'd deserve a life sentence even if Grace's death had been accidental and he'd never had a chance to save her. By his own admission, he made every possible effort to ensure her loved ones would never know what had happened to her. He was content with a lifetime of that torment for everyone close to her, because he was afraid he might get in trouble. That's despicable enough all on its own.

  • @lilymeadowcroft5002
    @lilymeadowcroft5002 3 месяца назад +24

    I have been waiting for you to cover this case! It was such a horrific crime that happened in NZ, a place that people come to and think is safe. I remember this case like it was yesterday. The way that scum tried to defend himself in court disgusted every single NZer at the time. His name was suppressed in NZ until after he was prosecuted and I remember how angry people got at that, especially because it was suppressed in the UK and we could access those articles
    I think for tourists especially they don’t often hear the bad things that actually happen. I can name multiple times that hitchhikers were killed. I remember my mum picking up a young woman from Germany and her telling us how much she loved how safe it was.

    • @tf9241
      @tf9241 3 месяца назад +2

      Fun fact, though the name suppression was a thing, I worked at the store where he got the suitcases from (not on the day he got them, that sick bastard) and we all knew his name cause obviously the police were asking for CCTV footage.

  • @gabrielleglinski4400
    @gabrielleglinski4400 3 месяца назад +52

    It wasn't until a couple of years ago that I realized that the British/European term "backpacking" as in like "backpacking across Europe" meant traveling with just a backpack and not roughing it in the woods with a tent across Europe for 9 months lol

  • @gracie5122
    @gracie5122 3 месяца назад +15

    I heavily researched this case for my law coursework, thank you for covering this absurd defence 🙏

  • @beccaboo9560
    @beccaboo9560 3 месяца назад +8

    As an NZer, this case shocked the whole country. New Zealand has such a low crime rates for kidnapping so everyone was so shocked something like this could happen here.

  • @icypassionz
    @icypassionz 3 месяца назад +5

    There are two types of people who accidentally hurt someone, the ones that try their best to save that person, and the one that try their best to hide the body

  • @Magggneto
    @Magggneto 3 месяца назад +10

    Eleanor gently explaining scat has me screaming

  • @louw.6526
    @louw.6526 3 месяца назад +10

    How dramatically eleanor tells the story is most of the reason why i love her videos 👏

  • @sophlou2367
    @sophlou2367 3 месяца назад +6

    she was a uni of lincoln alumni and when it happened there were posters up everywhere, bless her heart

  • @suefairbrother3556
    @suefairbrother3556 3 месяца назад +10

    As a kiwi I still feel deeply ashamed that this happened to Grace in our country. R. I. P. Grace and her father. Much love to her family and friends 🙏 from New Zealand 🇳🇿
    Living in a hotel when on a benefit,is emergency housing, the government pays for it.

  • @yonkerz1605
    @yonkerz1605 3 месяца назад +47

    Im a 22 year old girl as well, one night I was drunk and met up with basically a stranger I met at work earlier that day. I live about an hour from Chicago and met him there. At night, alone, in the city, (a very dangerous one) drunk, with a man I just met. We had a sexual experience and he also tried choking me without my consent. I was so very lucky he stopped and didnt have too bad of malicious intentions. Its hard to forgive myself for putting myself in such a dangerous situation but I THANK GOD I am still *ALIVE*.
    PLEASE PLEASE do NOT do anything I just mentioned. If you're drunk, always be with someone close to you. Its so sad we have to take such precautions and my heart absolutely breaks for Grace.
    Please stay safe everyone!

    • @b_sav
      @b_sav 3 месяца назад +2

      Are y’all slow😂 you telling me you’re linking with random people while you’re drunk

    • @Saturnm0ss
      @Saturnm0ss 3 месяца назад +14

      @@b_savare you slow? Victim blaming really? Get therapy

    • @b_sav
      @b_sav 3 месяца назад +3

      @@Saturnm0ss it’s not called victim blaming clearly if there’s evil people in this world why would you meet up with someone while being drunk

    • @b_sav
      @b_sav 3 месяца назад +3

      @@Saturnm0ss it’s common fucking sense why even go on dating apps at all. Those sites are setup city

    • @yonkerz1605
      @yonkerz1605 3 месяца назад +8

      @@b_sav clearly you've never been drunk before. I was incredibly stupid yes, but I wasn't in the right state of mind. No way I would do that sober.
      Thanks for making me feel worse about myself

  • @psychxos
    @psychxos 3 месяца назад +4

    congrats on the 6 years of videos! proud of you, keep up the good work! as someone with rank OCD, your videos are apart of my every day self-care routine, so I always appreciate them.

  • @NoorLevyrroni
    @NoorLevyrroni 3 месяца назад +3

    i watched videos about this case before but i will definitely watch it by you again because i just can’t mess any of your videos. it’s very therapeutic to me weird to say this about a true crime video but it’s the truth watching you helps with my depression and anxiety so thank you.

  • @jjwolfeegirl91wolf8
    @jjwolfeegirl91wolf8 3 месяца назад +4

    I always have that cheek to cheek smile when you upload a video! Can't believe you've been on RUclips for six years. Congrats on all your achievements hun. You put in so much hard work and effort girl! Love you Ellz ❤️❤️

  • @salidge
    @salidge 3 месяца назад +4

    Hi Eleanor! I live in the city this happened and it's effected our whole country so much. Thank you sm for covering it, its so important that Grace's story stays alive and gets out there. Seeing her family travel over here and look for her, just to then find her body was heartbreaking to see and I just cant comprehend it.

  • @martacapela8527
    @martacapela8527 3 месяца назад +6

    Wow, time flies. Cant believe I've been watching you for so long. I remember when you covered the James Bulger case. Sadly that is one of the cases that has never left my mind. Keep up the good work!!

  • @angelwut469
    @angelwut469 2 месяца назад +5

    Annnnd this is why I don’t go back to someone’s hotel room, house or anything like that alone with them, on the first date, or at least without letting someone know beforehand. You could literally be on a date with your own potential murderer and not even know it. Scary

    • @sallylees467
      @sallylees467 2 месяца назад +2

      My friend had her drink spiked on a casual Sunday 5pm date at a restaurant.

    • @broidkanymore-zc4lt
      @broidkanymore-zc4lt 24 дня назад +1

      i thought stranger danger was common sense but there're still so many naive ppl out there

    • @sallylees467
      @sallylees467 24 дня назад +1

      @@broidkanymore-zc4lt Yes, poor Grace but this was wreakless behaviour. No way should any girl be going to a man's house she's just meet. No only could they kill you but you could also get diseases or anything from the person - she knew nothing about him.

  • @winglessfairy564
    @winglessfairy564 3 месяца назад +24

    I’m 21 turning 22 in 9 days from now. It’s so heartbreaking how you can go from enjoying your life to the fullest, ready to celebrate yet another lovely year of life only for it to end in a few hours….. it’s truly scary being a woman

  • @user-gs4to2xj4f
    @user-gs4to2xj4f 3 месяца назад +3

    Congratulations on 6 years Eleanor! Thank you for all the effort and passion you put into every video. You really do justice to all those victims you've spoken about. You might have physically changed over these 6 years (looked amazing before & after!) but you've always remained your same amazing self, consistently!

  • @Sydneyc2604
    @Sydneyc2604 3 месяца назад +12

    Thank you for blessing us with another one hour episode!!!! ❤

  • @kittengirll1107
    @kittengirll1107 3 месяца назад +3

    Yesss Ellie please keep posting this often it’s strange to say this but u literally keep me sane you have helped me through a dark period in my life I’ve watched u since 2020

  • @samanthadelaney8286
    @samanthadelaney8286 3 месяца назад +1

    Thank you so much for covering this story! I mentioned it in the comments a couple weeks ago and was so happy to see you covered it. Her story deserves to be told. Love you and your channel so much! Stay safe out there. 💖

  • @oll-gamer6841
    @oll-gamer6841 3 месяца назад +9

    HAPPY 6 YEARS!!!
    I've only been a viewer for a few weeks but I love your content, pls keep it up ❤

  • @zetagamings
    @zetagamings 3 месяца назад +8

    My favorite true crimer, you’re always so compassionate and informative, love you El 🥰

  • @rubylugo367
    @rubylugo367 3 месяца назад +5

    Omg you’ve been posting so much lately!! I love watching your videos so muchhh! I always go back and tell my family about the videos every time I watch 😂❤

  • @caidra1395
    @caidra1395 3 месяца назад +2

    AHHHHHH YOU FINALLY DID IT!!! I was hoping you would do this case, I’m so happy. Thank you Eleanor ❤️❤️❤️

  • @sut6360
    @sut6360 2 месяца назад +4

    it’s scary because if this was another country with bad policing then he probably would’ve gotten away with it, i’m glad he’s gotten caught

  • @eggmon420
    @eggmon420 3 месяца назад +5

    As someone who’s into BDSM, there is NO WAY you can “accidentally” choke someone to death. If you see slipping out of consciousness, STOP.

  • @kristaanne2144
    @kristaanne2144 3 месяца назад +26

    But why was there so much blood???? If she was strangled where did all the blood come from???

  • @Beanberries420
    @Beanberries420 3 месяца назад +2

    thank you for all your hard work throughout all your years of creating!! i have always admired how caring you are with these cases, you are such a kind soul ❤️ (side note your hair looks incredible)

  • @Candykisses0022
    @Candykisses0022 3 месяца назад +2

    Wow this is the most extensive coverage of this case. Great job. May she RIP. Scary world we live in

  • @LibrarianofParis
    @LibrarianofParis 3 месяца назад +3

    I really love your videos, they are so well done, carefully researched, and SO respectful of the victim(s)!

  • @MicrowaveCheese33
    @MicrowaveCheese33 3 месяца назад +8

    I have a feeling this wasnt his first time.

  • @allielong2503
    @allielong2503 3 месяца назад +2

    Eleanor, you are one of my favorite creators! Your energy is so comforting to me regardless of the material your videos cover, and I always watch your storytelling to get myself through the school day

  • @christinaherring9762
    @christinaherring9762 3 месяца назад +2

    I've been here for years! I love your ability to share these stories with such respect. ❤

  • @VictoriaHogg-jr3it
    @VictoriaHogg-jr3it 2 месяца назад +7

    Not a tinder advert before this video 😟

  • @julietterose1619
    @julietterose1619 2 месяца назад +4

    I just don't understand how someone can trust someone else so quickly. I'm glad I did my dating when I still lived at home so any guy picking me up met my entire family and I never went back to a guy's place until I got to know him and he HAD to have roommates or I still wouldn't feel comfortable. He had to have roommates and friends. It's so important to see someone's social life before being alone with them.

  • @_kayleejohns
    @_kayleejohns 2 месяца назад +1

    as a new zealander i love how you make videos for cases that take place in my country, as the likes of grace milane and ben smart and olivia hope have sort of become forgotten down here. would love to see you cover the lachie jones case as there is currently an inquest going on in nz after five years and it would be awesome to have you help bring it to light ❤

  • @riannavasdev1951
    @riannavasdev1951 2 месяца назад +2

    I have been watching your videos since 2018..6 years and i love love love you. this is my first time ever commenting - i live in NZ and as soon as i saw the title i got had a shiver this case is insane i don't think we'll ever forget it.. thank you for covering a case from such a small place of the world

  • @x.hazen.x
    @x.hazen.x 3 месяца назад +5

    I love you sm I've been watching you since the very beginning I'm so proud of how far you've came🥀🖤

  • @em5848
    @em5848 3 месяца назад +3

    My best friend knew her very well. We’re all so sad that this happened. Thank you for sharing her story 🫶🏻

  • @Redhead4life
    @Redhead4life 3 месяца назад +4

    I love your videos ❤️❤️ it really helps me go through my day. A couple months ago i got diagnosed with scoliosis after years and years of back pain. I have to do online school and stay in bed all day. You definitely make my day💞

    • @qipnz
      @qipnz 3 месяца назад

      how do you do that

  • @claraforbes3363
    @claraforbes3363 3 месяца назад +3

    clicking the link immediately! love you so much eleanor ❤️

  • @skyewebley9475
    @skyewebley9475 3 месяца назад +3

    I am from New Zealand, and I remember the first report on the news saying she was missing and then hearing the horrible news a few days later; this case really shocked NZ because you don't hear about a lot of cases like this happening here. Sending so much love to Grace's family