She did this in the past as well when asked about Onions price hike, her response I don't eat Onions, she is the FM minister of India, a sabjiwala could have tackled that question better
How this has anything to do with BJP? Unlike other politicians, she had basic decency to not insult income tax payers rather accepted that it's indeed unfair for income-tax payers! Probably she herself is from same class.
@@rka-truthalwayswins5127 Neither Nehru nor his grandson are the FM of India at the moment.. For every problem, Nehru or his grandson are not the solution dude.Pity
First time shameless?? BJP is shameless (and so is congress). I remember a line from some movie i can't remember but it said "Ham se ladne ka junoon to la paoge lekin haramjadgi kaha se laoge?"
@@mchannel1365Aql k dushman, ye tu kabhi bhi na samjhega. Pollution k liye govt khak kuch kar rahi hai. Population mehnat kar k firse zyada tax de rahi hai. Govt k na kami sif andhbhakt ko hi nhi dikti
atleast if the taxes improve our quality of life, it is still fine, but that also does not happen, members of the votebank laugh at us like as we are fools
@@aryandahariya3118 Democracy doesn't mean you can spit on nature and somehow the elected gouvernment will solve all your answers, you can change but things will only get worse from here on Then you might invite Britan or Chinese invason some way or another, or massive civil war for basic things like water, food Personally I don't think most Indian ppl are capable of understanding nature, civic things, forget about more global things...everything is massively produced using fertilizers to keep ppl like happy at any cost
I am a CA Student and do study both Income tax and GST. In past 5 years goverment have tried to collect tax like never before. Amended so many provisions and they did not leave any place from where they could not collect taxes. Result of this is that record number of high net worth individuals have left India in last 4-5 years because they have to pay around 35-40% of tax to the government. Also paying GST on every single commodity is also another issue. Just imagine that you work really hard to make money and almost 50% of is taken away by the government. It's like working half of your life for the government. And still the facilities you get are not up to the mark. Bad roads, mediocre construction, poor transport in metropolitan cities like Mumbai, Delhi etc. Who would want to live in a country like this.
This is the reality & truth, even i am a honest tax payer from last 18yrs.i didn't get any benefit from government. Till now, i dont even own a house. I am getting little salary after all deductions & goes for my personal expenses, kids education & Medical expenses etc. I am thinking of leaving job & wanted to be in BPL category, where i get benefits from government like ration, free medical treatment etc. What to do? Being a middle class person, i cannot send my kids to government schools & cannot avail government hospital facilities, due to worst infrastructure in this country. This is our fate & have to live till our death.
Active partner cannot ask for facility, tax redumption, development, saftey, job. Sleeping partner can get security, job, tax benefits, bank balance. 😂
lol do you know only 2 % of india pay direct taxes properly indirect taxes may be there but if you want the government to do smthing for you then we should also pay our taxes accodringly
True but chaman chomu bhakths will never understand this . Bhakts are happy with 5 kg free ration . On average we are paying 45% of our income as tax .only for the finance minister to do corruption , "May pyaz nahi khati ".......
Those who are doing they are doing mistake... They should be here and educate other about the same... Dhruv Rathee is doing.... Alone he cannot do but only a team can do anything
@@mchannel1365 dude India's total fertility rate is already 2, so the population growth rate has already stabilised, so you don't need to get stressed over this issue. We already have a population of more than a billion people you cannot change that anymore by 2100 our population would slowly drop and would only be a billion.
Media in our country forgot to question the government instead they were praising her attire .... she wore blue saree and pink blouse during budget presentation ... heights of chatu media
I also thought so, but if we really think about her tenure of FM we see that our country had to go through a lot since the time of COVID 19, Russia- Ukrainian, Israel etc. still out economy is one of the best performer in whole of India. If we consider this point, i think she had done her job well.
A central Finance Minister has no answer/idea on how the taxes are incurred on the transactions performed. You can't be jovial on serious questions like this. Government looting Public in the name of taxes!! Great Nation!!
This is a genuine issue which should not be ignore by a person running the ~4 trillion dollar economy. This is not the healthy democracy as you are accountable to citizens of India it's your duty to justify vaguely and not to answer in a senseless manner.
@@pulkitjain8135 he din say anything about anyone else. He just said we don't want such candidates. People like you are the reason why people stop questioning and our country has to make do with such candidates kyuki sadiyo see hote aa raha hai
This was not a joke miss minister. When somebody complains that Govt is terrorising citizens with tax terrorism , you should have answered it very seriously.
Question asked in 2 mins. Answered in 2 secs. This shows that she is not fit to be a financial minister of India. We are working hard to earn money and these people have no concerns for public. This is absolutely shameful. Can't even consider that they will do something. But instead cracking lame jokes and trying to deviate from the topic.
@@mchannel1365are you bewakoof are what India population was more at the time of Congress period as well but they weren't saying because of population population Like you andhbakts only people like this escape easily of you want to control population you don't have kids
@@mchannel1365 "no one can help" free ration dena band kardo or mandir masjid pe paisa waste karna band kardo local business ko govt promote kare to bahut kuch ho sakta hai lekin tumhari buddhi ka kuch nahi ho sakta
In UAE taxes are 0% Full facilities Better Business opportunities, Better Healthcare Better Education Better Lifestyle Full income in Hand (as u don’t have to pay Taxes) In India everything is opposite And High taxes with minimal facilities. He asked a great question We need answer for this mam
The only countries which come close to this are the developed countries but their GDP per capita is higher so they don't experience the heat of these taxes as much as we do. BJP has failed completely.
@@fazer79 You are missing the point. For the taxes they pay, they get free education, health, social security and pension. And to add to that, their infrastructure and quality adherence is top notch.
This is the most embarassing Govt. in Indian history. If you imagine Manmohan Singh, Shashi Tharoor, Chidambaram or Kejriwal being questioned a question like this. Every one of these would have given a valuable answer over this usual rehearsed nonsensical smirk of these incumbent people sitting in govt.
@@AbhirupSarkar-r2h Rapist Ministers, Electoral bonds, Adani scams, Deterioted Inflation, Petrol Hikes, etc...dont get me started man. These people are not qualified to run a country.
the answer is obvious ... yes we all have to pay multiple taxes. Hapoens in US and Africa too. Happened in India for all these years. May be further tax reforms needed . . But to compare with the corrupt gang is a joke.
My salary 14 lakh for which income tax 2.25 lakh i bought a car for 10.lak for (7.2lak +2.8tax) which tax 28% 2.8lakh gst then road tax tax on insurance tax on accessories so totally 11.5 lak . for 14 lakh salary i got a 7 lakh worth car nearly 50% eaten by govt now i have to pay toll
You why it is like this... Because of freebies offered by the state govt and BJP is trying to put an end to it. But people won't vote for the govt which is not offering freebies. All these taxes can be reduced, if the centre and state govt reduce freebies and invest in govt projects.
@@avenkatraj bjp waived off 16 lak crores to corporates loans in 10years ..Bjp closed down entire business of BSNL which is India's largest network & assets . Nearly 7 states buying electricity from adani for ,7.84 instead of ,3.54 in that way bjp spent nearly 4lakh crores excess .bjp under pmfby paying 2 lakh crore was paid as insurance to corporates like reliance hdfc but they settled not even 1.5% as claim of 2lakh crore through railways they pay nearly 4600 cr per yr as premium but they not even paid 30cr as claims .in lakhs of crores they loot the country legally & pay to corporates according to CAG it was found that nearly 100-102% price were hiked for road contracts projects tunnels etc comparing to old rates in that way they estimate 7.5lakh crores in railways they say 400% increase for all projects like bridges track works upgrade station ..now railways getting privatised as it was a loss .for ur info i tried for suvidha pvt train from Bangalore to Mumbai it shows 8000+ rupees for a 3rd Ac dynamic price for Modi selfie points railway spent nearly 1500cr across india but u are saying freebies for public is our burden i never enjoy any freebies but I don't believe it's as a burden it's a offer by state govt as social justice to vulnerable group in chennai Amma mess offer food for 5 rupees is it a burden to u .they offer scholarship for sc st MBC bc is it a burden to u .they offer free food books laptop cycle to govt students below 2.5lk is it a burden to u
@@dharani288 so I don't have a car am I begging infront of their house ? Coming to your statistics 28% is GST and rest you spent on other accessories on that GST is small amount how does it sums up to 50% tax would be somewhere 35-38% on overall 14 lakh car value 2. Do you think all these money is going to Central government ? 3. Do you think people didn't had tax and toll before 2014 on cars (there was no GST but there was excise, service and other tax you would only know when you went to purchase back then ? 4. Do you think other country's don't have tax and tolls ? 5. So blaming on government eating money do you own all the roads you travel which doesn't have tolls ? 6. Do you think ambanis and adani don't pay tax ( they might not pay more tax but thier wealth used in their companies pay a lot of corporate tax. 7. You stated your salary income is 14 lakh rupees so your tax is 2.25 but the current government made a relaxation under 115bac now your tax would be 1.2 lakh ( considering you have no other significant income ) which is lakh lesser if you can't figure out contact a better CA. I'm not blaming anyone but fact is everybody is taking out our hard-earned money but the impact they are creating with that money is not satisfactory. People should not question on tax. thier is no point. We need to question their accountability towards development. but the ex government was more horrible than this government. God knows what would happened such wars and pandemics had happened during Congress rule
@@premlatamenon6081 Shameless because they are taxing like a socialist and giving social benefits like a capitalist. In other words, Indian middle class is soo f*****.
Aur 255 ka bhi 225 bana diya itna insecurity aur tumhe kya lagta hai 2024 ka baad chunav nehi hoga?😂 Kin kin ko seriously lete ho tumlog 😂 jokes ki tarah lo
Petrol is imported India is slave to Middle east or Russia Stupid ppl buying more vehicles to become slaves where bycycles can be used for short distances Indian ppl are 5000 yrs behind current human evolution
निर्मला सीतारमण के अर्थशास्त्र के सिद्धांत:- 1. मैं प्याज नहीं खाती। 2. मेरा भी माइक बंद हुआ था। 3. ए स्लीपिंग पार्टनर कैननॉट आंसर सीटिंग हीयर। End of economics.
What a brilliant question this man raised. But the Minister did not have any answer as usual! Nirmala Sitharaman will be remembered as the "Worst Finance Minister" India has ever seen!
I am sure if he had asked a random motivational question or something like 'What is your favorite color?', she would have given a long and cheerful answer. But now she is avoiding a question that cannot be ignored. How shameless!
She smiles when question is thrown to her from her near and dear north ppl....but when similar question comes from any general hapless public from south especially from TN....all she could show is her angry face and bark 'go and ask stalin'....
When the men was talking. Literary I felt the pain " with the hard earned money after paing taxes on it we as a traders taking high rise on trade finally on those profits govt is taking away half of it" water was rolling in my eyes.
Tex public sa lake karja adani ambani ka maf karega of hardworking farmers raste par hai jita pasa in amir satho ka maf kiya na bjp ka utne paso ma kisan o ko msp guarantee dijasakti thi. illiterate, chor, jumla Modi hatao dash bacho... government taking tex from people but no facility giving to them.... we need to change government 😢
@@amrapali-gs3co ya as this soo called unethical government begins to eradicate all the law and moral values which was so disturbing too saw everyday they can definitely put laws on every time
Being a businessman, atleast, he got the opportunity to raise his concern before the FM. While he still can claim many deduction incurred or said to be incurred for his business, what is the fate of hapless salaried class. While salaried employees pay more than 30% income tax what security do they get from the Govt. Every year I pay income tax of about 15 lakhs and I had a heart attack last year. Had I not survived, my family would have been financially devastated since I am a pvt sector employee and my company doesn't provide any team insurance. The govt does nothing in such a scenario. They don't even provide deduction for huge medical expenses paid out of our own pocket. It is a pity.
Honest taxpayers are suffering due to Income tax burden. First income tax on salary, then GST on anything you buy, multiple taxes when you buy shares. Middle class is burdened.
i don’t understand why journalists were laughing after listening her reply.. this shows their lack of seriousness towards holding the government bodies,officials and ministers accountable..
Being a Businessman Govt of India is my sleeping partner, I take the risks, if any losses bear out it is I who will face the consequences,If any mishappening occurs whole responsibility will be put on my shoulder but If I start making profit govt will take the share in everything while purchasing the product I will be required to pay Gst,I will have to pay fares for transportation for my product again the fare Gst will be charged from me, Again once the product reaches the counter I need to create a Gst bill where again I'll b required to show Gst and plus each and every month somehow I earn more I have to answer to govt how did I earned more this month... This govt needs to go!!
You will have no buffer to keep and will become poor any time . Government will take money when you earn.When you are in loss ,it will make you more poor .
A sleeping partner cannot answer sitting there, but they should answer at least when she got back to the office. Middle class Indians are swamped with income tax, cgst, sgst, highway tolls and what not. BJP has created a cash flow system that is choking crores of Indias. Saddest part is tomorrow if another party comes to power, they will happily continue this system without any consideration.
![I.N "HALLUCINATION" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/n5B5q1Hwt_U/mqdefault.jpg)
He asked a very genuine question, she just simply skipped.., negligence
ignorance
Why blame on her
Blame on modi
Modi has retained her after so much critisization from people
Means she is not deciding modi is deciding
arrogance not negligence
It's arrogance
Such an irresponsible answer from someone in such a responsible position
She needs to go
She did this in the past as well when asked about Onions price hike, her response I don't eat Onions, she is the FM minister of India, a sabjiwala could have tackled that question better
atleast she is doing press conference , look at our PM🤣
One of Worst FM
Yes just like kharge answer
No matter what govt does for the people, the people are always unsatisfied
Indian Govt’s Logic:
Taxes similar to USA.
Facilities similar to Afghanistan.
😂😂
😂
Not Afghanisthan it should be somalia as afghanisthan is not a democracy now
Us ka tax collection dekha hai kabhi?
@@shauryapratap7343 bhai tax na deke jo paise bachaaye h unse ek dictionary kharid lena aur usme “similar to” and “equals to” me difference dekh lena.
This is why no BJP neta takes unscripted questions
How this has anything to do with BJP?
Unlike other politicians, she had basic decency to not insult income tax payers rather accepted that it's indeed unfair for income-tax payers!
Probably she herself is from same class.
Oh my poor FM 😂 @@riscnx
As IF that selected PM Nehru or his incompetent grandson Rahul have any competence to answer any worthy questions!!
@@rka-truthalwayswins5127
Neither Nehru nor his grandson are the FM of India at the moment.. For every problem, Nehru or his grandson are not the solution dude.Pity
Worst finance minister
Outside: smiling
Inside: who gave mic to him ? All questions are out of syllabus 😀
After it she went to Modi way
🤣
@@SKumar-bs7zz what Modi gonna do? He probably can't even divide numbers lmao.
ED bhejdo
Whereas another politician whose only achievement is his last name would have said "First question is BJP question"
First time Nirmala Sitaraman is seen shamelessly smiling. Her reply was actually "Sleeping partner only sleeps and does nothing else"
@@alfredkingsly Stupid react
First time shameless?? BJP is shameless (and so is congress). I remember a line from some movie i can't remember but it said "Ham se ladne ka junoon to la paoge lekin haramjadgi kaha se laoge?"
Its not first time
Aur doh modi ko vote
Jabh congress ka koi mla ya leader kuch karenge toh koi khasar nahi chorega badash nikalne meh
@@toyir4934 Bhai side mat pakdo. BJP haramjadi hai lekin congress bhi hai. Haan lekin BJP se achcha hai ki Congress satta mein rahe.
seriously this is valid question for every Indian paying so many taxes.
Every Indian who doesnt give any damn about population or pollution,
at this point, no one can help
@@mchannel1365no excuse we give taxes directly or indirectly so she should answer the question
@@mchannel1365Aql k dushman, ye tu kabhi bhi na samjhega. Pollution k liye govt khak kuch kar rahi hai. Population mehnat kar k firse zyada tax de rahi hai. Govt k na kami sif andhbhakt ko hi nhi dikti
atleast if the taxes improve our quality of life, it is still fine, but that also does not happen, members of the votebank laugh at us like as we are fools
@@aryandahariya3118
Democracy doesn't mean you can spit on nature and somehow the elected gouvernment will solve all your answers,
you can change but things will only get worse from here on
Then you might invite Britan or Chinese invason some way or another, or massive civil war for basic things like water, food
Personally I don't think most Indian ppl are capable of understanding nature, civic things, forget about more global things...everything is massively produced using fertilizers to keep ppl like happy at any cost
I am a CA Student and do study both Income tax and GST.
In past 5 years goverment have tried to collect tax like never before. Amended so many provisions and they did not leave any place from where they could not collect taxes.
Result of this is that record number of high net worth individuals have left India in last 4-5 years because they have to pay around 35-40% of tax to the government. Also paying GST on every single commodity is also another issue.
Just imagine that you work really hard to make money and almost 50% of is taken away by the government. It's like working half of your life for the government. And still the facilities you get are not up to the mark. Bad roads, mediocre construction, poor transport in metropolitan cities like Mumbai, Delhi etc.
Who would want to live in a country like this.
Yes you are right. Either levy Direct tax or levy Indirect tax, not both.
@Anything98645 high net worth individuals don't need reservation. They have enough money.
@Anything98645 open category
@Anything98645 it's called commen sense...
I am also trying hard to leave the country because it's heartbreaking to see the tax I am paying and not getting the benefits out of it
This is the reality & truth, even i am a honest tax payer from last 18yrs.i didn't get any benefit from government. Till now, i dont even own a house. I am getting little salary after all deductions & goes for my personal expenses, kids education & Medical expenses etc. I am thinking of leaving job & wanted to be in BPL category, where i get benefits from government like ration, free medical treatment etc. What to do? Being a middle class person, i cannot send my kids to government schools & cannot avail government hospital facilities, due to worst infrastructure in this country. This is our fate & have to live till our death.
Taxes are everywhere but public facilities nowhere 😑 .
Even toilet in railway station are paid
Active partner cannot ask for facility, tax redumption, development, saftey, job.
Sleeping partner can get security, job, tax benefits, bank balance.
😂
lol do you know only 2 % of india pay direct taxes properly indirect taxes may be there but if you want the government to do smthing for you then we should also pay our taxes accodringly
True but chaman chomu bhakths will never understand this .
Bhakts are happy with 5 kg free ration .
On average we are paying 45% of our income as tax .only for the finance minister to do corruption ,
"May pyaz nahi khati ".......
illiterate, chor, jumla Modi hatao dash bacho
No shame left in FM, such a shameless lady.
why? because she is lady?
@@mcprasanth76 Because she didn't reply the common man question and you tell me what should I call her "shameless FM" instead. Lmao 🤣
@@RohitTiwari-mo8mi😂😂😂
she is hopeless ,clueless,wisdom less laughting stock
Italian matha ki jaiii kothadimai 🤣🤣🤣
Who wants that man as finance minister..😅😅
This is the reason why Intelligent and hardworking men leave India for better future 😢
And women too! The power is in the hands of snake charmers, fake political science graduates, rickshaw drivers and others.
sad but true 👍
Those who are doing they are doing mistake... They should be here and educate other about the same... Dhruv Rathee is doing.... Alone he cannot do but only a team can do anything
@@SantoshSingh-yp4vp I support Dhruv Rathee 100%
People like him can change the nation
But i’m afraid hatred has already taken over the country
@@Suhailkhan05 Hatt rohingya
The taxation system in India is ridiculously high and need immediate intervention.
Only kejriwal can do this
So are the people who aren't stopping with population
at this point, no one can help
@@mchannel1365 dude India's total fertility rate is already 2, so the population growth rate has already stabilised, so you don't need to get stressed over this issue. We already have a population of more than a billion people you cannot change that anymore by 2100 our population would slowly drop and would only be a billion.
@crictv2992Bro yesterday I bought a tiny hand made ganesh idol for my car dashboard. They have made 14% GST on that 🥲
@crictv2992 beacuse nirmala thinks these are luxury things. so she is charging 28%
Hats off to that person for raising valid questions
That is a genuine question crores of Indians have & the FM has no answer & simply laughs it off 🤷♀️
She is puppet of PMO
Puppet don't give answer
Media in our country forgot to question the government instead they were praising her attire .... she wore blue saree and pink blouse during budget presentation ... heights of chatu media
😂😂😂
Media praise or condemn people for no reason. Irresponsible!!
1. 2 जी घोटाला 2008(1.76 lakh crore)
2. सत्यम घोटाला 2009 (12,320 crore )
3. कॉमनवेल्थ घोटाला 2011 (70,000 crore)
4. भारतीय कोयला आवंटन घोटाला 2012(1.86 lakh crore)
5. टाट्रा ट्रक घोटाला 2012 (170 crore)
6. कैश -फॉर-वोट घोटाला 2008(40 crore )
7. आदर्श हाउसिंग सोसायटी घोटाला 2011 (14000 crore)
8. नेशनल हेराल्ड केस 2011( 5000 crore)
9. रॉबर्ट वाड्रा-डीएलएफ भूमि case 2013( 50 crore)
10. चारा घोटाला 1996 (950 crore)
11. गाजियाबाद पीएफ घोटाला 2008 (6.5 crore)
12. Harshad Mehta Scam1992(4000 crore)
13. हसन अली खान scam 2007 (36000 crore)
14. IPL scam 2009(1975 crore)
15. आवास ऋण घोटाला 2010 (1000 crore)
16. अग्नि प्रवण पनडुब्बी घोटाला 2005(1100 crore)
17. Chopper scam: 2012 (3700 crore)
18 . Sharda chitfund scam 2013 (50,000 crore)
Desh ka anpd gavaar neta kesa ho rahul gandhi jaisa ho 😂
I call the media as TV Dalle (the word media doesn't suit them)
Media has been bought by government it's not free
"Government - A sleeping partner" geniusly phrased
Salute to who have asked this questions..
Question:🗿🗿🗿
Answer:🤡🤡🤡
Galat hi sahi Pr answer toh de deti😂
Itne bde frustrated question ke baad reply Ata hai "hummm" 😂
👏
💯💯💯💯💯✅✅
😂😂😂😂
Answer:
If Government is not sleeping partner.... Ambani & Adani buy 3 to 4 States in India 😊
Vo tab bhi sates ko sarkaar se jyada accha rakhte 🤡
Worst FM of Bharat ever..
Manmohan Singh.
As if you are even a nominee
@@adityade897she is the worst Finance Minister, Pathetic
@@riscnxBest Finance Minster India ever had, India went from Millions to Billions
I also thought so, but if we really think about her tenure of FM we see that our country had to go through a lot since the time of COVID 19, Russia- Ukrainian, Israel etc. still out economy is one of the best performer in whole of India. If we consider this point, i think she had done her job well.
A central Finance Minister has no answer/idea on how the taxes are incurred on the transactions performed. You can't be jovial on serious questions like this. Government looting Public in the name of taxes!! Great Nation!!
Excellent question sir
Dekho besharm neta kesa hota hai. Ye halat hoti hai, jab koi unscripted sawal pooch le to😂😂
Tu to besharam hai tere language se pata chalta hai
Haan accha FM toh wo hota hai jo ghar ke gamlo me crore rupey ki gobhiya lgata hai.
P chidambram
@@dheerajrawat7079 don't worry,once Congress will come in power,u'll find gold vegetables at her farm...
@@praveengupta4017 It should be your.
1. 2 जी घोटाला 2008(1.76 lakh crore)
2. सत्यम घोटाला 2009 (12,320 crore )
3. कॉमनवेल्थ घोटाला 2011 (70,000 crore)
4. भारतीय कोयला आवंटन घोटाला 2012(1.86 lakh crore)
5. टाट्रा ट्रक घोटाला 2012 (170 crore)
6. कैश -फॉर-वोट घोटाला 2008(40 crore )
7. आदर्श हाउसिंग सोसायटी घोटाला 2011 (14000 crore)
8. नेशनल हेराल्ड केस 2011( 5000 crore)
9. रॉबर्ट वाड्रा-डीएलएफ भूमि case 2013( 50 crore)
10. चारा घोटाला 1996 (950 crore)
11. गाजियाबाद पीएफ घोटाला 2008 (6.5 crore)
12. Harshad Mehta Scam1992(4000 crore)
13. हसन अली खान scam 2007 (36000 crore)
14. IPL scam 2009(1975 crore)
15. आवास ऋण घोटाला 2010 (1000 crore)
16. अग्नि प्रवण पनडुब्बी घोटाला 2005(1100 crore)
17. Chopper scam: 2012 (3700 crore)
18 . Sharda chitfund scam 2013 (50,000 crore)
Desh ka anpd gavaar neta kesa ho rahul gandhi jaisa ho 😂
This is India's FM, She wont listen
LeNirmala - Yeh toh out of syllabus hai 💀
This is a genuine issue which should not be ignore by a person running the ~4 trillion dollar economy. This is not the healthy democracy as you are accountable to citizens of India it's your duty to justify vaguely and not to answer in a senseless manner.
Shamelessness at its peak😂😂😂
How the F is it shamelessness?
It would have been shameless if she insulted income-tax payers like Chitambarm did.
Thinking is difficult, that is why most people judge Carl Jung
Good quote@@premlatamenon6081
@@riscnxya the classic andhbhakt reply for ooruga maami's answer 😂
So are the people who aren't stopping with population
at this point, no one can help
Taking serious questions lightly..what a minister.
"I don't have any answer for that" toh press conference kiya kiyun? 🙂
How come she have the answer when the states are also involved
@Dr.Kraig_Ren please go to Germany.
@Dr.Kraig_Ren if u can afford going please do
Public ki har chik chik ka answer karna is not her duty what she does is in the best interest of public but people are always complaining
@Dr.Kraig_Renwhat train are you talking don't just put the vande bharat image on your head we got more trains than that failure of engeneering 😂
We don't want such FM who couldn't
Answer such logical questions
You can stick to RaGandu vdos, full logic 😂
Aur Konse ne ans kar diya? Baki ke muh se kuch nikalta hi nhi tha, sab kuch duba diya tha, khud kuch na aye dusro pe bhokte raho
@@pulkitjain8135 he din say anything about anyone else. He just said we don't want such candidates. People like you are the reason why people stop questioning and our country has to make do with such candidates kyuki sadiyo see hote aa raha hai
@@pulkitjain8135chup kr andh bhakt
@@surajp2495 bro she answered it.But in a illogical way😂
This was not a joke miss minister. When somebody complains that Govt is terrorising citizens with tax terrorism , you should have answered it very seriously.
Question asked in 2 mins. Answered in 2 secs. This shows that she is not fit to be a financial minister of India. We are working hard to earn money and these people have no concerns for public. This is absolutely shameful. Can't even consider that they will do something. But instead cracking lame jokes and trying to deviate from the topic.
Toh tere hisaab se kaun honi chahiye FM Kharge 😂😊
@@RashmiKumari-qo3ot teri maa
@@RashmiKumari-qo3ot PAPPU GANDHI
@@RashmiKumari-qo3ot Koi Sensible aadmi, jo tumare tarha sawalo pe hasse na.
Iske hisab se kisi maulvi ko bana dena chahiye jo fir se jizya impose kare bharatiyo ke upar aurr shariya implement karey.
Shameless minister..hope she is removed in next term
Yes with FEKU MODI she will be removed after 4 June
She is not even contesting
There is a huge possibility that the entire government will be removed in the next election.
The whole government needs to change for good
This Government has to go
Speechless ,❌ shameless ✅
This is all poor and middle class people's question. But no answer 😢
So are the people who aren't stopping with population
at this point, no one can help
@@mchannel1365are you bewakoof are what India population was more at the time of Congress period as well but they weren't saying because of population population
Like you andhbakts only people like this escape easily of you want to control population you don't have kids
Modi and Nirmala working for Rich and corporates not for middle and poor class.
illiterate, chor, jumla Modi hatao dash bacho
@@mchannel1365
"no one can help"
free ration dena band kardo
or mandir masjid pe paisa waste karna band kardo
local business ko govt promote kare to bahut kuch ho sakta hai
lekin tumhari buddhi ka kuch nahi ho sakta
Shameful that this is our FM!!!! At least she could've said a line or two for those very much logical questions!!!!! ⁉️
She is not even understanding what was the question about?😂😂😂😂
Result of minimum governance(employee) maximum governance(ministers) 😂
@@jitendrakumar-ni4ys 🤣🤣🤣
This is exactly what u get when u let incompetent jokers run the country 😂
Her smile says everything
Probably the first time she understood the question.
100 % true ..... We will answer you in the election ...
illiterate, chor, jumla Modi hatao dash bacho
Very Logical Question...🔥💯
What a intelligent and strong reader this person is who is asking Question
What a class levels of questions
The Prime minister is speechless for 10 years for questions raised by citizens.
In UAE taxes are 0%
Full facilities
Better Business opportunities, Better Healthcare
Better Education
Better Lifestyle
Full income in Hand (as u don’t have to pay Taxes)
In India everything is opposite
And High taxes with minimal facilities.
He asked a great question
We need answer for this mam
Overall taxes in the country are coming 44 to 48%. This is torchurous
Exactly 😢
The only countries which come close to this are the developed countries but their GDP per capita is higher so they don't experience the heat of these taxes as much as we do. BJP has failed completely.
@@fazer79 You are missing the point. For the taxes they pay, they get free education, health, social security and pension. And to add to that, their infrastructure and quality adherence is top notch.
@@fazer79 taxes are from long time BJP not modified anything. That is the problem
@subramanyamraju9738 No, they just hiked the already existing taxes.
This is the most embarassing Govt. in Indian history.
If you imagine Manmohan Singh, Shashi Tharoor, Chidambaram or Kejriwal being questioned a question like this. Every one of these would have given a valuable answer over this usual rehearsed nonsensical smirk of these incumbent people sitting in govt.
Chamcha dected
Actually they are more corrupt.
@@AbhirupSarkar-r2h yes, we saw it with election bond, didn’t we?
@@AbhirupSarkar-r2h Rapist Ministers, Electoral bonds, Adani scams, Deterioted Inflation, Petrol Hikes, etc...dont get me started man. These people are not qualified to run a country.
the answer is obvious ... yes we all have to pay multiple taxes.
Hapoens in US and Africa too. Happened in India for all these years. May be further tax reforms needed .
.
But to compare with the corrupt gang is a joke.
Superb 👏👏👏
Because Tai has no idea what she has to do
She would have answered "I don't invest in shares and I live in rented house" 😂😂😂😂😂
She lives in a luxurious house at our expense.
Valid question..
My salary 14 lakh for which income tax 2.25 lakh i bought a car for 10.lak for (7.2lak +2.8tax) which tax 28% 2.8lakh gst then road tax tax on insurance tax on accessories so totally 11.5 lak . for 14 lakh salary i got a 7 lakh worth car nearly 50% eaten by govt now i have to pay toll
You why it is like this... Because of freebies offered by the state govt and BJP is trying to put an end to it. But people won't vote for the govt which is not offering freebies.
All these taxes can be reduced, if the centre and state govt reduce freebies and invest in govt projects.
@@avenkatraj bjp waived off 16 lak crores to corporates loans in 10years ..Bjp closed down entire business of BSNL which is India's largest network & assets .
Nearly 7 states buying electricity from adani for ,7.84 instead of ,3.54 in that way bjp spent nearly 4lakh crores excess .bjp under pmfby paying 2 lakh crore was paid as insurance to corporates like reliance hdfc but they settled not even 1.5% as claim of 2lakh crore through railways they pay nearly 4600 cr per yr as premium but they not even paid 30cr as claims .in lakhs of crores they loot the country legally & pay to corporates according to CAG it was found that nearly 100-102% price were hiked for road contracts projects tunnels etc comparing to old rates in that way they estimate 7.5lakh crores in railways they say 400% increase for all projects like bridges track works upgrade station ..now railways getting privatised as it was a loss .for ur info i tried for suvidha pvt train from Bangalore to Mumbai it shows 8000+ rupees for a 3rd Ac dynamic price for Modi selfie points railway spent nearly 1500cr across india but u are saying freebies for public is our burden i never enjoy any freebies but I don't believe it's as a burden it's a offer by state govt as social justice to vulnerable group in chennai Amma mess offer food for 5 rupees is it a burden to u .they offer scholarship for sc st MBC bc is it a burden to u .they offer free food books laptop cycle to govt students below 2.5lk is it a burden to u
No point in blaming the government for that save 14 lakhs don't purchase a car.
@@MaxStan-uj2vx so want us to beg outside Ambani adani houses
@@dharani288 so I don't have a car am I begging infront of their house ?
Coming to your statistics 28% is GST and rest you spent on other accessories on that GST is small amount how does it sums up to 50% tax would be somewhere 35-38% on overall 14 lakh car value
2. Do you think all these money is going to Central government ?
3. Do you think people didn't had tax and toll before 2014 on cars (there was no GST but there was excise, service and other tax you would only know when you went to purchase back then ?
4. Do you think other country's don't have tax and tolls ?
5. So blaming on government eating money do you own all the roads you travel which doesn't have tolls ?
6. Do you think ambanis and adani don't pay tax ( they might not pay more tax but thier wealth used in their companies pay a lot of corporate tax.
7. You stated your salary income is 14 lakh rupees so your tax is 2.25 but the current government made a relaxation under 115bac now your tax would be 1.2 lakh ( considering you have no other significant income ) which is lakh lesser if you can't figure out contact a better CA.
I'm not blaming anyone but fact is everybody is taking out our hard-earned money but the impact they are creating with that money is not satisfactory. People should not question on tax. thier is no point. We need to question their accountability towards development.
but the ex government was more horrible than this government. God knows what would happened such wars and pandemics had happened during Congress rule
She wants to say that earning by govt = More bond scam for BJP
How the F tax collection has anything to do with any Bond?
1. 2 जी घोटाला 2008(1.76 lakh crore)
2. सत्यम घोटाला 2009 (12,320 crore )
3. कॉमनवेल्थ घोटाला 2011 (70,000 crore)
4. भारतीय कोयला आवंटन घोटाला 2012(1.86 lakh crore)
5. टाट्रा ट्रक घोटाला 2012 (170 crore)
6. कैश -फॉर-वोट घोटाला 2008(40 crore )
7. आदर्श हाउसिंग सोसायटी घोटाला 2011 (14000 crore)
8. नेशनल हेराल्ड केस 2011( 5000 crore)
9. रॉबर्ट वाड्रा-डीएलएफ भूमि case 2013( 50 crore)
10. चारा घोटाला 1996 (950 crore)
11. गाजियाबाद पीएफ घोटाला 2008 (6.5 crore)
12. Harshad Mehta Scam1992(4000 crore)
13. हसन अली खान scam 2007 (36000 crore)
14. IPL scam 2009(1975 crore)
15. आवास ऋण घोटाला 2010 (1000 crore)
16. अग्नि प्रवण पनडुब्बी घोटाला 2005(1100 crore)
17. Chopper scam: 2012 (3700 crore)
18 . Sharda chitfund scam 2013 (50,000 crore)
Desh ka anpd gavaar neta kesa ho rahul gandhi jaisa ho 😂
Wow , what a finanace minister we got , she's smiling at our financial problems
Her husband itself telling BJP won't cross 225.... Shamless FM ever in India 👎👎
What is so shameless ?? Always easy to judge others.
@@premlatamenon6081 Shameless because they are taxing like a socialist and giving social benefits like a capitalist. In other words, Indian middle class is soo f*****.
@@premlatamenon6081 Did coalgate happen ? Was Naveen Jindal corrupt last year ? is Naveen Jindal corrupt now ?
325+ NDA...take a Screenshot of this comment
Aur 255 ka bhi 225 bana diya itna insecurity aur tumhe kya lagta hai 2024 ka baad chunav nehi hoga?😂 Kin kin ko seriously lete ho tumlog 😂 jokes ki tarah lo
Worst financial management in her ministery. High loans on country, high tax on petrol, high toll etc.
Petrol is imported
India is slave to Middle east or Russia
Stupid ppl buying more vehicles to become slaves where bycycles can be used for short distances
Indian ppl are 5000 yrs behind current human evolution
1. 2 जी घोटाला 2008(1.76 lakh crore)
2. सत्यम घोटाला 2009 (12,320 crore )
3. कॉमनवेल्थ घोटाला 2011 (70,000 crore)
4. भारतीय कोयला आवंटन घोटाला 2012(1.86 lakh crore)
5. टाट्रा ट्रक घोटाला 2012 (170 crore)
6. कैश -फॉर-वोट घोटाला 2008(40 crore )
7. आदर्श हाउसिंग सोसायटी घोटाला 2011 (14000 crore)
8. नेशनल हेराल्ड केस 2011( 5000 crore)
9. रॉबर्ट वाड्रा-डीएलएफ भूमि case 2013( 50 crore)
10. चारा घोटाला 1996 (950 crore)
11. गाजियाबाद पीएफ घोटाला 2008 (6.5 crore)
12. Harshad Mehta Scam1992(4000 crore)
13. हसन अली खान scam 2007 (36000 crore)
14. IPL scam 2009(1975 crore)
15. आवास ऋण घोटाला 2010 (1000 crore)
16. अग्नि प्रवण पनडुब्बी घोटाला 2005(1100 crore)
17. Chopper scam: 2012 (3700 crore)
18 . Sharda chitfund scam 2013 (50,000 crore)
Desh ka anpd gavaar neta kesa ho rahul gandhi jaisa ho 😂
निर्मला सीतारमण के अर्थशास्त्र के सिद्धांत:-
1. मैं प्याज नहीं खाती।
2. मेरा भी माइक बंद हुआ था।
3. ए स्लीपिंग पार्टनर कैननॉट आंसर सीटिंग हीयर।
End of economics.
Her answer and behaviour.... exactly like nityananda
The 'E' in Nirmala Sitaraman stands for Economist.
Hahaha hahaha
Hahahahahahahahaha
E stands for Empty
undeddated comment
Where can I find whole video
Very much sums up why Modi ji never gave any unscripted press conference in 10 years
Beautiful question
Beautiful question but Disgusting answer.
Reporter: "What's your age?"
BJP minister: "Yes"
What a brilliant question this man raised. But the Minister did not have any answer as usual! Nirmala Sitharaman will be remembered as the "Worst Finance Minister" India has ever seen!
Dadi ko samjh hi nhi aya hoga question 😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
women hai na calculation main weak hoti hai generally
Ye dadi tumhari 100 dadi se tej hai dimaag mei 😂😂
@@arnavsingh2532 Haan Bhai sahi kaha jab pyaaz aur sabzi na Khao toh dimaag tez hoga hi.
@@ArunKumarmauryaji bhai tumhara halat itna kharab h sunke dukh hua 😂
I am sure if he had asked a random motivational question or something like 'What is your favorite color?', she would have given a long and cheerful answer. But now she is avoiding a question that cannot be ignored. How shameless!
This is what you call DAYLIGHT ROBBERY.
She is the worst FM ever Karma hits back, Mr. Manmohan Singh ji best Finance minister ever India had.
हर कोई यह वीडियो देख रहा है, इसलिए हमने केवल INDIA ALLIANCE को वोट देने का फैसला किया है। जय कांग्रेस, जय राहुल जी।
Do you know cast of CONGRESS manifesto 35 billion our budget is 45 billion 😂😂😂😂 have some brain 😂😂😂not jihad book
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Congress playing to remove 50 % reservation cap. Shall we die?
who will be FM in india alliance ? Akileshji or Tejashwi 🤭😬🥳
@@gunshimply
First you tell me what is FM 😀😀😀
She deserves all the blessings coming her way.
She smiles when question is thrown to her from her near and dear north ppl....but when similar question comes from any general hapless public from south especially from TN....all she could show is her angry face and bark 'go and ask stalin'....
👍👍👍👍
What a shameless person.
Yes illiterate, chor, jumla Modi hatao dash bacho
Seriously.. this is her answer!! How irresponsible!!
Shameless😂😂
When the men was talking. Literary I felt the pain " with the hard earned money after paing taxes on it we as a traders taking high rise on trade finally on those profits govt is taking away half of it" water was rolling in my eyes.
How unfortunate it is to see our FM couldn’t answer this question
I think he is the only person till now to keep FM quite ... 😂
Very good question but with an unsatisfactory answer from the partners side.
A "sleeping partner"..will dream..
Unsatisfactory? Bro there was no answer 😅
illiterate, chor, jumla Modi hatao dash bacho
Tex public sa lake karja adani ambani ka maf karega of hardworking farmers raste par hai jita pasa in amir satho ka maf kiya na bjp ka utne paso ma kisan o ko msp guarantee dijasakti thi. illiterate, chor, jumla Modi hatao dash bacho... government taking tex from people but no facility giving to them.... we need to change government 😢
Next: Gambling is also allowed with 37% tax on gambling income
Shameless FM, that's the question of every poor and middle income indian
illiterate, chor, jumla Modi hatao dash bacho
Shamless FM
Ma'am thinking where are my aaj tak and Zee news 's intellectual reporters 🥺😭
People should raise more questions like this
Those people will be put to jail if they ask any questions
@@amrapali-gs3co ya as this soo called unethical government begins to eradicate all the law and moral values which was so disturbing too saw everyday they can definitely put laws on every time
Being a businessman, atleast, he got the opportunity to raise his concern before the FM. While he still can claim many deduction incurred or said to be incurred for his business, what is the fate of hapless salaried class.
While salaried employees pay more than 30% income tax what security do they get from the Govt. Every year I pay income tax of about 15 lakhs and I had a heart attack last year. Had I not survived, my family would have been financially devastated since I am a pvt sector employee and my company doesn't provide any team insurance. The govt does nothing in such a scenario. They don't even provide deduction for huge medical expenses paid out of our own pocket. It is a pity.
Same here bro. Feeling like the 18th century taxes collection. Kind of robbery from genuine tax payers with zero extra benifits.
Person goes brutal and brutal with slepping partner
Honest taxpayers are suffering due to Income tax burden. First income tax on salary, then GST on anything you buy, multiple taxes when you buy shares. Middle class is burdened.
Then try being lower middle class if you think they have it easy?
She knows economy is in complete shambles
i don’t understand why journalists were laughing after listening her reply.. this shows their lack of seriousness towards holding the government bodies,officials and ministers accountable..
She is serving notice period... 😅
60 year old still notice period 😂😂😂
In fact as a trader I also have a similar experience... My margin ranges between 10 - 12% with my expenses... But facilitate 12-14% GST on the sale...
Just simply laughed the question off. What a diplomatic and a politcal answer.
We went from P Chidambram to this disaster 😊
The corrupt elitist chidambaram who didn't understand the idea of digital payment and mocked UPI.
One disaster to another disaster both are equally disastrous 😂
forget chidambaram even Jaitley had sense & understood the broad issues. He wasn't an economist but still did a reasonably decent job as FM.
@@maximusdecimus2805 But P chidambaram is a better FM than this brainless arrogant lady!!
@@maximusdecimus2805 chu bhakt check in which year and in whose governemnt the work on UPI started😂
She never answers directly anything
Yes Modi and his Govt should focus this issue very seriously.
Being a Businessman Govt of India is my sleeping partner, I take the risks, if any losses bear out it is I who will face the consequences,If any mishappening occurs whole responsibility will be put on my shoulder but If I start making profit govt will take the share in everything while purchasing the product I will be required to pay Gst,I will have to pay fares for transportation for my product again the fare Gst will be charged from me, Again once the product reaches the counter I need to create a Gst bill where again I'll b required to show Gst and plus each and every month somehow I earn more I have to answer to govt how did I earned more this month... This govt needs to go!!
You will have no buffer to keep and will become poor any time .
Government will take money when you earn.When you are in loss ,it will make you more poor .
Completely agreed, she is killing middle class too. She is the worst Finance minister, taxes are ridiculously high.
No shame at all😂😂
What an answer hats off to her..... Congratulations to the Indian financial system.....
Now I am just imagine that Modi is taking this sort of unscripted questions....😅😅😅 He does not even have the understanding of this things
True statement.
A sleeping partner cannot answer sitting there, but they should answer at least when she got back to the office. Middle class Indians are swamped with income tax, cgst, sgst, highway tolls and what not. BJP has created a cash flow system that is choking crores of Indias. Saddest part is tomorrow if another party comes to power, they will happily continue this system without any consideration.
Seriously she is our FM 😂