Real Private Investigator Plays “Her Story” | Let's Play Part 1

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 2 авг 2024
  • Real private investigator, Steve Morrow attempts to solve the mysteries of "Her Story" in this two part let's play!
    Her Story / Sam Barlow
    #ProfessionalsPlay #HerStory #Detective
    Credits: www.buzzfeed.com/bfmp/videos/...
    Check out more awesome videos at BuzzFeed Multiplayer!
    bzfd.it/2IKk8SH
    GET MORE BUZZFEED:
    www.buzzfeed.com
    www.buzzfeed.com/videos
    / buzzfeedvideo
    / asis
    / buzzfeedmultiplayer
    / buzzfeedviolet
    / perolike
    / ladylike
    BuzzFeed Multiplayer
    BuzzFeedBlue is now BuzzFeedMultiplayer, your new home for all things gaming, cosplay, real life recreations, interviews with celebs, board games, real professionals playing games, challenges, and more! If this sounds like the stuff you’re into then please subscribe today!
    Love BuzzFeed? Get the merch! BUY NOW: goo.gl/iquQQD
    MUSIC
    Licensed via Audio Network
    SFX Provided By AudioBlocks
    (www.audioblocks.com)
    STILLS
    black brick wall, brickwork background for design
    Dmitr1ch/Getty Images
    VIDEO
    young curly woman showing something unpleasant in husband's phone while he is cooking , they are shouting and quarrelling, man is angry and irritated
    silverkblack/Getty Images
    Nervous criminal male worried during interrogation by female police detective
    Motortion/Getty Images
    Detective searching links between crimes on board with red string, connection
    Motortion/Getty Images
    CCTV split screen, surveillance monitoring
    Vitalii Stefiuk/Getty Images
    Handcuffed soldier in military army clothes
    stevanovicigor/Getty Images

Комментарии • 1,3 тыс.

  • @buzzfeedmultiplayer
    @buzzfeedmultiplayer  5 лет назад +1937

    Tune back in tomorrow for the conclusion of the game and to hear Steve's theory of what happened!

    • @javiersalazar492
      @javiersalazar492 5 лет назад +5

      His game theory thanks for watching (sorry for the cringe)

    • @neat24
      @neat24 5 лет назад +14

      2:30 I think this man was confused about the way they write dates in Europe. You should have given him the heads up

    • @bcfilms498
      @bcfilms498 5 лет назад +3

      Real Chef plays cooking simulator !!!!

    • @cameron3652
      @cameron3652 5 лет назад

      Go see super best friends play or SBFP play the game. It's nice commentary if you guys want to see more reactions to the game.

    • @duzkjustjerkedoff3284
      @duzkjustjerkedoff3284 5 лет назад

      Love the LA noire classical music

  • @kelseydangerous
    @kelseydangerous 5 лет назад +12592

    "I looked through 50 hours of footage"
    I can't even pay attention to an hour long TV show without being on my phone....

    • @feong_feong5172
      @feong_feong5172 5 лет назад +74

      Omg!!! Hi Kelsey! I love you! I'm a total fan of the 100 baby challenge. Lovelots😘

    • @shainahhensley5221
      @shainahhensley5221 5 лет назад +22

      Girl, same!

    • @krissywilliams1714
      @krissywilliams1714 5 лет назад +52

      kelsey thank you for making chelsea a bisexual icon

    • @emmaismyname8197
      @emmaismyname8197 5 лет назад +6

      Hahaha

    • @gracetracy8825
      @gracetracy8825 5 лет назад +8

      Omg I love u sooo much. I love ur one hundred baby challenge it made me start sims.

  • @averymillington9457
    @averymillington9457 5 лет назад +8952

    did anyone else think her tapping while she was alone in the interrogation room was morse code?

    • @jabberwocky3269
      @jabberwocky3269 5 лет назад +976

      Its their twin code

    • @luciacuevas611
      @luciacuevas611 5 лет назад +296

      This reminded me of Sherlock

    • @avasweeney6614
      @avasweeney6614 5 лет назад +269

      Avery Millington THATS WHAT I WAS THINKING

    • @mayaaasmr
      @mayaaasmr 5 лет назад +238

      What she said when she was tapping is L-O-W-Y

    • @parentalcryptid
      @parentalcryptid 5 лет назад +603

      @@mayaaasmr actually, it's Love U

  • @nwdidipu
    @nwdidipu 5 лет назад +1869

    Can we appreciate how the PI is really good at finding keywords to search that the story kinda sounds like it's in order? That's a really nice job

    • @cPilot88
      @cPilot88 4 года назад +11

      Yeah but he fucked up at 8:35 , and that is important info at least about transportation

    • @ionnryx
      @ionnryx 3 года назад +78

      @@cPilot88 Don't Worry, He's Human. He Can Make Mistake, No Human Is Perfect.

    • @kasiamleczarska9078
      @kasiamleczarska9078 21 день назад

      Actually he wasn't very good, missed lots of keywords. He never figured out why she went to Glasgow, what was with her and performing, about the wig, he never even checked for "twins". He missed a lot of the story. But I guess he probably had limited time to play. It took me two-three evenings to get everything.

  • @rei.of.sunshine
    @rei.of.sunshine 5 лет назад +5573

    Next episode: *Real person plays The Sims*

    • @janxh01
      @janxh01 5 лет назад +70

      LOL they have a lot of that already.

    • @waylonsmith1832
      @waylonsmith1832 5 лет назад +225

      ACTUAL GOD PLAYS THE SIMS

    • @xethified
      @xethified 5 лет назад +53

      Fake person plays The Sims

    • @Mythtic
      @Mythtic 5 лет назад +36

      There’s not enough real people for that

    • @FarikoWishless
      @FarikoWishless 5 лет назад +9

      @@Mythtic DAM

  • @anthony8382
    @anthony8382 5 лет назад +1015

    The give away - she touches the wrong cheek when commenting on how the bruise is gone because of her fast metabolism.

    • @wonder777warrior6
      @wonder777warrior6 4 года назад +2

      Anthony the give away of what? Please clarify?

    • @pierrelemagnifique205
      @pierrelemagnifique205 4 года назад +76

      Wonder777 Warrior on one video she has a tattoo on another not. On one she has a bruise on another after only a couple of days she has not. When she got her hair up she always talks about how they were fighting sometimes meanwhile hair down = calmer demeanor and more thoughtful.
      We are seeing two persons. Twins. Accomplices who murdered the husband.

    • @lucifuge927
      @lucifuge927 4 года назад +6

      Wonder777 Warrior in one video she had her bruise on her right cheek, this time when they asked about the bruise she touched her left cheek

    • @theducvu5196
      @theducvu5196 4 года назад +4

      To be fair I’ve once forgotten which of my legs a bruise was on because it healed overnight.

    • @Virg099
      @Virg099 4 года назад +2

      How about the clothes? I noticed it's usually either red or blue

  • @TheAlyssa458
    @TheAlyssa458 5 лет назад +5743

    So in one video of short sleeve she has a tattoo..... the next she doesn’t. Hannah and eve are twins that were separated, one hid in the attic. One of the twins killed Simon for some reason.

    • @jamlesspa
      @jamlesspa 5 лет назад +63

      TheAlyssa458 omg I didn’t notice that!!!!

    • @DG2508-
      @DG2508- 5 лет назад +322

      I was waiting to see if someone else realized it or if I was crazy...

    • @hypestdeano9882
      @hypestdeano9882 5 лет назад +494

      also with the bruise - one day the girl with her hair up had a bruise on the left side of her face, another day when asked about it, the girl with her hair down touched the right side of her face and said it went away

    • @WeIIWeIIWeIIWhatDoWeHaveHere
      @WeIIWeIIWeIIWhatDoWeHaveHere 5 лет назад +309

      I think Eve killed Simon because Hannah was moving on with her life. Based on the mannerisms of each twin, it seems like Eve is more dominant and a bit aggressive; perhaps vengeful. Whereas Hannah seemed like everything was fine before Eve came along.

    • @honeybear3000
      @honeybear3000 5 лет назад +143

      Thank you i kept muttering their twins not a split personality, Florence kept one telling the real mother that she died so that she could keep her.

  • @adiorei
    @adiorei 5 лет назад +1010

    *WELL WE NOW ALL KNOW ON HOW TO WEAR A HEADPHONES IN A DETECTIVE WAY*

  • @leahgreenberg4164
    @leahgreenberg4164 5 лет назад +1881

    Just realized 3 min in that the dates seem “out of order” because in Europe it’s more common to do day/month/year instead of the more American month/day/year haha 😂

    • @maximilianopena
      @maximilianopena 5 лет назад +140

      I'm having metric deja vu's now, is there anyone that doesn't use day/month/year? Besides americans that is.

    • @zyukitty4187
      @zyukitty4187 5 лет назад +69

      @@maximilianopena in asians country like china or japan , they use year/month/day

    • @maximilianopena
      @maximilianopena 5 лет назад +93

      @@zyukitty4187 didn't knew that, still does makes more sense than month/day

    • @bbasae993
      @bbasae993 5 лет назад +107

      @@maximilianopena In Latin America it's day/month/year, Americans just like things their way I guess, because you know... Freedom!

    • @bcv7266
      @bcv7266 5 лет назад +8

      Lmaooo as soon as I saw 18 at the front I found this comment

  • @sahneeyah4813
    @sahneeyah4813 5 лет назад +3463

    Real SWAT team plays rainbow six siege

  • @OppaiGod
    @OppaiGod 5 лет назад +750

    I guess everyone in the comments are suddenly pro detectives

  • @astridmyst
    @astridmyst 5 лет назад +172

    I love how popular this is making Her Story again. I watched IHasCupquake play it years ago and got so excited hearing that there would be a series with a private investigator playing it. Such a great game and quite a brilliant concept.

  • @lilahloverr11
    @lilahloverr11 5 лет назад +784

    Anybody notice the investigator wrote down the car info backwards? Cavalier shared by the couple & the van for work owned by Erik his boss.

    • @ilovetosing166
      @ilovetosing166 5 лет назад +67

      Diana White YES. I’m not that far into the video but I’m afraid it’s gonna affect his choices

    • @H3crack
      @H3crack 5 лет назад +1

      Yeah I did

    • @AshleyTheSwift
      @AshleyTheSwift 5 лет назад +39

      Also though the pub was called Rockingham Arms, not Rockington. For a private investigator, he's not as attentive as you might think.

    • @tokiimato
      @tokiimato 5 лет назад +98

      @@AshleyTheSwift maybe because he knew it was a game and that there were cameras recording his reactions so yeah the pressure is real i guess.

    • @Instaslam
      @Instaslam 5 лет назад +96

      He's also doing this all in one straight shot without rewatching everything.
      There's a reason he said he once took 50 hours for watching tapes.

  • @janicecoleman5830
    @janicecoleman5830 5 лет назад +1941

    Wait No. They're twins. The midwife lied said one baby died but kept one (Eve) who found out when she was 8 and probably killed her. Then went and found Hannah and lived it the attic. And then they would switch places. And have to mirror everything that happened to each other. They grew up and Hannah really loved Simon and they would go away for holiday because Hannah wanted to be alone with Simon without Eve. Then Hannah got pregnant but Eve couldn't. So I'm assuming Eve decided that Hannah couldn't have the baby and planned a "miscarriage". Eve was jealous of Hannah and Simon, and felt left behind so she killed Simon.

    • @beatevangarderen5916
      @beatevangarderen5916 5 лет назад +8

      Janice Coleman wow

    • @emmaforde3745
      @emmaforde3745 5 лет назад +27

      That’s what I was thinking!

    • @janicecoleman5830
      @janicecoleman5830 5 лет назад +8

      Lol what? I just paid attention

    • @iMariyellerz
      @iMariyellerz 5 лет назад +3

      Wow this is great!

    • @collinsanders562
      @collinsanders562 5 лет назад +98

      Janice Coleman i feel like that’s too obvious because i was thinking the same thing. as you keep paying attention to the videos, split personalities start making more and more sense because they claim that it’s a “we” thing.

  • @Mihawk16
    @Mihawk16 5 лет назад +231

    "I don't know. I guess The Rock?" I knew it! The murderer was Dwayn Johnson!

    • @jbark678
      @jbark678 5 лет назад +11

      Nah, there's no way she can smell what the Rock is cooking.

    • @sonicx7488
      @sonicx7488 2 года назад +1

      @@jbark678 he stays hungry he devours

  • @booksandcrochethooks
    @booksandcrochethooks 5 лет назад +542

    He should've questioned that strange tapping sequence she did on the table. Definitely seemed like a Morse code or some sort of tap code to me! (Not that I know anything about either, but it was suspicious.)

    • @parentalcryptid
      @parentalcryptid 5 лет назад +40

      Yup, it's a tap code (not morse though)

    • @parentalcryptid
      @parentalcryptid 5 лет назад +20

      @Lee Peele not in the video this guy saw, but in another video where she taps a message she does make a mistake. pretty sure this is just "LOVEU"

    • @parentalcryptid
      @parentalcryptid 5 лет назад

      @Lee Peele yep! that's what I was thinking of!

    • @parentalcryptid
      @parentalcryptid 5 лет назад

      @Lee Peele it was before, but no worries

    • @thegirlwhoisme
      @thegirlwhoisme 5 лет назад +13

      He made a face but didn't say anything on it

  • @willkeating2617
    @willkeating2617 5 лет назад +635

    Everyone watching this, there’s no clear ending to the story. However you interpret it, is how you interpret it. Some people believe their twins and some people believe it’s the multiple personalities. The people using her story as proof that it’s two different people with the midwife lying and stealing her sister.
    The game is specifically building that up for you to believe her, she could easily have fabricated that. It’s not as easy as you think.

    • @viepng
      @viepng 4 года назад +19

      Well one of them has a tattoo and one of them doesnt

    • @iliketrains3370
      @iliketrains3370 4 года назад +76

      @@viepng it could easily be a fake one, the mere presence of it can disprove it since she's suppose to hide a murder, you don't put obvious signs like that out in the open

    • @gaming1zanagi-1999.
      @gaming1zanagi-1999. 4 года назад +12

      @@iliketrains3370 welp I think it is possible if she had DID cause those who had DID had different "self" inside them thus those "self" may or may not take hold the main "self" of them if they had severe DID or lowering their awareness of their other "self". So I agree that they had DID instead of twins cause technically speaking those who had DID technically had their own "siblings" inside their own body

    • @dykevader01
      @dykevader01 4 года назад +1

      Tattoo, my dude.

    • @baydiac
      @baydiac 4 года назад +15

      Lady Dyke Vader You commented “tattoo” when two months before someone already proposed that and got dunked on. Why. Your motives are a mystery.

  • @carlotta4th
    @carlotta4th 3 года назад +40

    I've seen a lot of people play this and it's interesting to get a PI perspective. I notice that (probably due to his irl job) he's focusing more on people names, locations names, and appearance descriptions. I've yet to see a single normal player pay attention to what Simon was wearing, but it makes sense that a PI would hone in on that.

    • @Kumagoro42
      @Kumagoro42 Год назад +2

      To be fair, players quickly realize we're not meant to search up where Simon is (which is where knowing what he was wearing would be useful), since we learn Simon is dead pretty soon into the story. The detail only exists because the first videos are from when Hannah was reporting Simon as missing, and the police would ask for a description.

  • @parentalcryptid
    @parentalcryptid 5 лет назад +188

    I saw a playthrough of this game a while ago, (Geek Remix) and I'm confident that I worked out the story from it.
    PS, you can change the appearance of the screen in game, and if you give it the retro look (how it looked at 1:35 ) whenever the screen goes dark, you can see a reflection of your character in the screen. (I think it happens when you uncover a major bit of evidence.)
    PS, if they need ideas for key words to look up, try "wind" (should give you the rest of the song) , "window", "fairytale", "secret" "attic", "blonde" and "mirror". Any names should be checked, (Hannah, Eve, Florence etc.)
    And the Tapping is a Tap code. (different to morse code, letters are based on number of taps) (I think that's explained if you look up "tap", but not 100% sure.)
    the people from the play through I saw translated it, but I don't want to say what was said cos it's major spoilers.
    I'll leave the translations on the last video of the game, if they don't translate the messages during the video.
    The code in this video isn't really a spoiler for the story, so I'll translate it : LOVEU

    • @LemonBarchie
      @LemonBarchie 5 лет назад +18

      Kitsune Cat ahhh I immediately thought the tapping was a code!!

    • @latronqui
      @latronqui 5 лет назад +3

      Wow! That code thing is really cool.

    • @avasweeney6614
      @avasweeney6614 5 лет назад

      But what is it is French Morse code🤷🏼‍♀️

    • @parentalcryptid
      @parentalcryptid 5 лет назад

      @@avasweeney6614 no, it's not morse at all. Essentially, the number of taps relates to a letter. You can look up the letter grid to work out how to translate it.

    • @raineinspaine5986
      @raineinspaine5986 5 лет назад

      I was looking for another Geek Remix fan!! I love this game because of them

  • @mults1623
    @mults1623 5 лет назад +3710

    Am I the only one who's 100% sure that they're twins??????

    • @bbasae993
      @bbasae993 5 лет назад +242

      Yeah, and it seems like they were doing the same as in "what happened to Friday?" Where the 2 took turns to pretend to be the same person. I just wonder why??? Why couldn't they live like regular sisters?

    • @mults1623
      @mults1623 5 лет назад +158

      @@bbasae993 I think it's because of the "she told my mother I was dead thingy" maybe everyone except the lady that put them both in the attic thought that there were only one girl named Hannah or Eve

    • @malw6323
      @malw6323 5 лет назад +260

      @@bbasae993 i think the implication is that the midwife, florence, took one of the twins from their mother just after birth and told the woman one of her children is dead so she could keep Eve for herself as she always wanted a family, but couldn't have one after her husband died. the twins found out about each other, the real parents didn't have a clue, the kids managed as well as kids could.

    • @bbasae993
      @bbasae993 5 лет назад +77

      @@malw6323 oh, that makes so much sense, still feels a bit strange as to why they couldn't tell the parents but I think if "Eve" killed Florence that would give them a reason not to tell the truth

    • @darkceptor44
      @darkceptor44 5 лет назад +52

      im not a detective but i really like investigation games, you cant be 100% sure in any situation

  • @Pinkstarclan
    @Pinkstarclan 5 лет назад +24

    this guy seems super professional (probably bc he IS) and I'm loving his approach here

  • @ninjahell1
    @ninjahell1 5 лет назад +1988

    What is my perfect crime? I break into Tiffany's at midnight. Do I go for the vault? No, I go for the chandelier. It's priceless. As I'm taking it down, a woman catches me. She tells me to stop. It's her father's business. She's Tiffany. I say no. We make love all night. In the morning, the cops come and I escape in one of their uniforms. I tell her to meet me in Mexico, but I go to Canada. I don't trust her. Besides, I like the cold. Thirty years later, I get a postcard. I have a son and he's the chief of police. This is where the story gets interesting. I tell Tiffany to meet me in Paris by the Trocadero. She's been waiting for me all these years. She's never taken another lover. I don't care. I don't show up. I go to Berlin. That's where I stashed the chandelier.

    • @eiiesig2651
      @eiiesig2651 5 лет назад +141

      LMAO I CANT-

    • @ninjahell1
      @ninjahell1 5 лет назад +228

      @@eiiesig2651 Laughing is a sign of weakness in primates. One of many defects as human.

    • @namemenoah
      @namemenoah 5 лет назад +47

      @@ninjahell1 Tell Mose I said hello.

    • @ninjahell1
      @ninjahell1 5 лет назад +76

      @@namemenoah Mose is dead.

    • @adamkaban8507
      @adamkaban8507 5 лет назад +65

      I saw this somewhere else it's odd it's almost is as though it was magically moved from one place to another without interfering with the original I feel as though it has had this happen many times I feel as though finding the original at this point would be difficult if not impossible

  • @s_lee
    @s_lee 5 лет назад +16

    17:00 for anyone wondering what the tap code translates to, it’s ‘love u’

  • @itsjennii
    @itsjennii 5 лет назад +314

    In one of the videos it looked like they did a lie detector test on her? You should look more into that!

    • @XaerQwickBlade
      @XaerQwickBlade 5 лет назад +60

      He probably didn't bother following that up because most investigators find polygraph tests ineffective. Measuring heart rate and etc tells you if a person is nervous, not why or if what they said is actually true. Coaching for polygraph tests, while not full proof, is often effective for manipulating results.

    • @loveandheart08
      @loveandheart08 5 лет назад +10

      ^^its true. If you manage to stay calm when you’re lying then there’s no way for the polygraph to “dictate” youre lying. They’ve done studies on this, it’s just a way to manipulate and deceive the perpetrator

    • @KasumiRINA
      @KasumiRINA 4 года назад

      @@XaerQwickBlade Paul Ekman's Telling lies has a whole chapter on ridiculousness of the polygraph... If you watched Lie to Me with Tim Roth (based on it), they show a few times than a person can act like he's nervous simply because he's seeing a hot woman enter the room. Really, you need to know WHY said person feels that emotion.

    • @mydogeatspuke
      @mydogeatspuke 4 года назад +1

      People seem really hung up on the fact that polygraphs aren't valid as they can be tricked, but she was still being interviewed. If you ignore the results but still listen to her answers you could gather more information. It's weird that nobody realises that.

  • @raykapi
    @raykapi 5 лет назад +136

    It’s like that movie on Netflix “What Happened to Monday”

    • @annatylor6919
      @annatylor6919 5 лет назад +3

      SugarSnap i was literally just thinking that

    • @thegirlwhoisme
      @thegirlwhoisme 5 лет назад +4

      I was just about to comment this!! "It's basically 'what happened to monday'without as many bodies involved!"

  • @shadowmonarchix2699
    @shadowmonarchix2699 4 года назад +13

    Wow I thought being a PI was more sneaking around James Bond style
    but this is different, really makes you respect all the people taking the time to organize all this info

  • @stxph_anie
    @stxph_anie 3 года назад +7

    There is something so endearing about this private investigator, I feel like I could trust him with my life. It was fun to watch his mind going while he played this game.

  • @prettynoice8852
    @prettynoice8852 5 лет назад +37

    Next episode: A real convict plays the escapists

  • @Side-by-side1
    @Side-by-side1 5 лет назад +223

    30:13 "Smelly cat, smelly cat, what are they feeding you?" - oh sorry. Wrong song?

  • @cyb3rd0ll88
    @cyb3rd0ll88 5 лет назад +12

    I like how this channel inputs people with the same job as what the game is being played for them.

  • @raffy234
    @raffy234 5 лет назад +14

    If that private investigator ever asked me any questions.. boy, would I have a hard time lying to him if I felt like I had to... he seems so charming and nice... I would want him to like me and not betray "his trust" (which is to say, how much does a person, especially a private investigator, trust a stranger / witness / possible suspect?)

  • @stuckonhim2much
    @stuckonhim2much 5 лет назад +128

    Goat plays goat simulator 🐏

  • @GameBoy_6135
    @GameBoy_6135 5 лет назад +18

    (Hannah/Eve) - *begins playing guitar and singing*
    Steve Morrow - *looks at staff person off camera*
    LOL!!!

  • @joannned5517
    @joannned5517 5 лет назад +411

    He got the van and car bit the wrong way round🤦🏼‍♀️🙈

    • @thatcokestuff
      @thatcokestuff 5 лет назад +2

      I was about to say this hah

    • @SaruCharmed
      @SaruCharmed 5 лет назад +4

      He also got Rockington Arms wrong. Called it Rockingham I think.

  • @colehaney8836
    @colehaney8836 5 лет назад +4

    It was cool to see him go into full detective mode. Love seeing these guys give their all at games like this.

  • @Sprudlepuddel
    @Sprudlepuddel 5 лет назад +1

    These kinds of videos are really compelling to watch. Thanks for putting them up!

  • @2sportshooter
    @2sportshooter 5 лет назад +77

    Reminds me of “What happened to Monday”

  • @Nene.127
    @Nene.127 5 лет назад +341

    My theory is Hannah & Eve are twins. The mid wife couldnt have children so she told their mom one died so she could keep one (Eve). Eve read the midwifes diary & found out that she wasnt her mom & pushed her down the steps & said it was an “accident”. She found Hannah & they decided to switch out lives. They eventually get tired of fighting & Eve leaves. Later on in life when Hannah gets pregnant by Simon, Eve gets jealous because she said she couldnt get pregnant & probably killed Simon. That or Eve got pregnant by Simon because he thought it was Hannah & Hannah got upset

    • @timvvs
      @timvvs 5 лет назад +1

      mrzredvelvetcupcake wow this is really good

    • @latronqui
      @latronqui 5 лет назад +7

      I think the same, except I'm not sure that Eve ever leaves. That's why Hanna keeps trying to go on holidays, so Eve can't go with them.

    • @Nene.127
      @Nene.127 5 лет назад +1

      latronqui 28:00 she says they got tired of fighting & she left. Im not sure if that was when she was still hiding in the attic or after Simon.

    • @maikofr6735
      @maikofr6735 5 лет назад +4

      I think they were sharing Simon... Eve and Hanna could have killed because simon had another affair when they went to a bar with a girl friend helen... They argued about it and killed Simon in the process because they knew that the other twin was having another affair and it was with the guy Eric and got her pregnant... Or maybe Simon was having affair with Eric snd the girl is trying to push it on Eric how he killed Simon....

    • @RabidDogma
      @RabidDogma 5 лет назад +5

      That's literally the plot. That's not a theory. They were twins. One has a tattoo and the other doesn't.

  • @Beengtzon
    @Beengtzon 5 лет назад +576

    Hannah and Eve are twins. The midwife, Florence, stole Eve at birth and told the mother she died. When Eve had read Florence’s diary and realized Florence was not her real mother, she pushed Florence down the stairs, even though Eve says it was an accident. After that, she ran across the street to Hannah. Hannah and Eve lived their lives together as Hannah, whilst the other one of them was in the attic. Eve was the outgoing one and was good with boys, whilst Hannah was shy. So Eve reeled in all the boys Hannah wanted, but not Simon, which made Eve jealous. Also, Eve couldn’t get pregnant to match Hannah’s pregnancy, so they weren’t the same anymore. SO, EVE KILLED SIMON AND HANNAH HELPED HER HIDE THE BODY in the basement so they could sort out their alibi.

    • @confused_reader
      @confused_reader 5 лет назад +45

      I couldn't believe he hadn't put together that they're twins

    • @jen-te1zt
      @jen-te1zt 5 лет назад +28

      Idk why he didn't understand that they were twins it was made very clear

    • @lorenavinaja2372
      @lorenavinaja2372 5 лет назад +19

      The tattoo!!!!!! How did he not see it

    • @MariaDias-lk7mw
      @MariaDias-lk7mw 5 лет назад +1

      Yaaaaaaas!

    • @manuel_elastico3163
      @manuel_elastico3163 5 лет назад +99

      @@confused_reader But like lets be honest he does this professionally, theres a lot of factors he had to consider. He did mention they could be twins but he also said that they could have split personalities. theres a process and he's just trying to know what happened so that he can come to an accurate and better conclusion. Please no hate thanks

  • @maybeitszz
    @maybeitszz 4 года назад +5

    23:10
    That reminds me of that movie "What Happened To Monday" where there were 7 twins who lived the same life as the same person because the world at the time only allowed one child for each family.

  • @yipyip818
    @yipyip818 5 лет назад +16

    Okay there's high key vibes of the movie, “What Happened to Monday”

  • @magalimizuki3752
    @magalimizuki3752 5 лет назад +29

    Ya'll feeling smart now because the Investigator didn't solve the case fast enough? lol.

  • @hitchmercedes1599
    @hitchmercedes1599 3 года назад +1

    love how he takes this serious and taking notes! perfect rewiev!

  • @GeorginaMarsden
    @GeorginaMarsden 5 лет назад +21

    This is such an underrated and amazing game, I'm so glad it's getting more recognition by being played by Buzzfeed!

  • @deealexandra6928
    @deealexandra6928 5 лет назад +321

    Hannah and Eve both spell same name backwards, one ring one without. Twins?

    • @brifo3394
      @brifo3394 5 лет назад +42

      And the tattoos as well, one is missing and the other has one.

    • @oldvlognewtricks
      @oldvlognewtricks 5 лет назад +10

      Rings can be removed.

    • @oldvlognewtricks
      @oldvlognewtricks 5 лет назад +14

      Sasuke Uchiha The tattoo disappears again in a later interview. It’s either two people, a fake tattoo, or she uses make up to cover it up.

    • @oldvlognewtricks
      @oldvlognewtricks 5 лет назад +20

      Sasuke Uchiha Doesn’t prove it. It could be two personalities communicating with each other, or the twins used the code, and the habit causes them both to tap a message for the other twin when under stress.
      Or she’s a psychopath, and making it all up.
      You can like your preferred theory, but there’s no definitive proof of either side. Saying it makes zero sense without evidence isn’t a terribly good argument.
      You could mention the fact that one twin stops having period and can’t conceive while the other is pregnant - I like that in support of the multiple personalities theory.
      But why did Simon make two mirrors? Whose were the extra set of fingerprints? Who got the speeding ticket while Hannah was at work?

    • @mydogeatspuke
      @mydogeatspuke 4 года назад +4

      She was wearing a ring in one interview and not another so they're two different people? You do know people can just... take a ring off right? 😂😂😂😂

  • @ijust_pj197
    @ijust_pj197 5 лет назад +95

    The song she sings is a real song called Wind and Rain by Gillian Welch & David Rawlings and it precisely talks about two sisters that felt in love with the same man but he felt in love with one over the other. Even the song talks about one sister drowning the other because of that.
    The song title is a methaphor for the two sisters been so different from each other, one been the wind and the other the rain "oh the wind and rain" as in " oh the two sisters." Im not a private inverstigator and took me 5 seconds to search of the songs really existed.
    Here is the lyrics:
    There were two sisters of county Clair
    Oh, the wind and rain
    One was dark and the other was fair
    Oh, the dreadful wind and rain.
    And they both had a love of the miller's son
    Oh, the wind and rain
    But he was fond of the fairer one
    Oh, the dreadful wind and rain.
    So she pushed her into the river to drown
    oh, the wind and rain
    and watched her as she floated down
    oh, the dreadful wind and rain.
    and she floated till she came to the millers pond
    oh, the wind and the rain
    dead on the water like a golden swan
    oh, the dreadful wind and rain.
    as she came to rest on the riverside
    oh, the wind and the rain
    and her bones were washed by the rolling tide
    oh, the dreadful wind and rain.
    and along the road came a fiddler fair
    oh, the wind and rain
    and found her bones just a lying there, cried
    oh, the dreadful wind and rain.
    so he made a fiddle peg of her long finger bone
    oh, the wind and the rain
    he a made a fiddle peg of her long finger bone, crying
    oh, the dreadful wind and rain.
    and he strung his fiddle bow with her long yeller hair
    oh, the wind and the rain
    he strung his fiddle bow with her long yeller hair, cried
    oh, the dreadful wind and rain.
    and he made a fiddle fiddle of her breast bone
    oh, the wind and rain
    he made a fiddle fiddle of her breast bone, cried
    oh, the dreadful wind and rain.
    but the only tune that the fiddle could play was
    oh, the wind and rain
    the only tune that the fiddle would play was
    oh, the dreadful wind and rain...

    • @astridmyst
      @astridmyst 5 лет назад +10

      Wow I had no idea it was a real song. That's so smart to add into this game.

    • @m.Xander_562
      @m.Xander_562 5 лет назад +5

      Dude you need a buzzfeed mini series lol 👏
      I had a feeling that song was too well put together just for this show /game
      Bravo!

    • @latronqui
      @latronqui 5 лет назад +1

      Thanks!

    • @jacquimichelle5100
      @jacquimichelle5100 5 лет назад +5

      It’s based on an even older song called cruel sister. I found a performance here: ruclips.net/video/705i5A5KTP8/видео.html

    • @clarelim847
      @clarelim847 5 лет назад +4

      *County Clare. It's an actual place in Ireland so I guess it's referring to that?

  • @denarahafoka6528
    @denarahafoka6528 5 лет назад +38

    look at 24:58 and see the bruise is on her left cheek but at 11:13 shes feels her right cheek
    25/06/94 to 27/06/94 3 days after it looks like she had forgotten it was on her left cheek instead of the right completely making me think the "twins" or "same" person are switching throughout the interviews. Which can show they are guilty and trying to cover it up by pretending to be eachother or one of the twins is faking to be both twins so the other doesn' fk things up. At 25:15 the women is saying that if one gets hurt the other has to aswell meaning that my theory was about them is pretty much saying they have broken one of the rules and is going to be discovered

  • @diversidadecientifica5450
    @diversidadecientifica5450 4 года назад +2

    It's so cool for me that already played the game see his emotions through each part of it and see how similiar they were to mine. In the beginning you're so confident that you are investigation is going the right way and the game somehow breaks all of it. The Eve's part kind must turned his head upside down hahaha

  • @USA00STEVEN
    @USA00STEVEN 5 лет назад +16

    Damn the tapping part was creepy

  • @_zulu..inc_1605
    @_zulu..inc_1605 5 лет назад +80

    Can we talk about how when she said “We, I, we” I was thinkin like... maybe she has split personality disorder

    • @dumbspaghetti_
      @dumbspaghetti_ 4 года назад +9

      DID*

    • @urdad9506
      @urdad9506 4 года назад +2

      MadelineZ_ArtZ ! same thing i believe but i prefer using the term DID

    • @dumbspaghetti_
      @dumbspaghetti_ 4 года назад +2

      @@urdad9506 I think DID is more respectfull. I am friends with a system and it seems wrong calling it split personality disorder when they are all different people.
      Sorry if I make no sense I'm just dissy.

  • @kellycaaws
    @kellycaaws 5 лет назад

    This is just as fascinating as I hoped it would be!! Wow so good.

  • @tomiwaaina5499
    @tomiwaaina5499 4 года назад +4

    EVE IS ALSO A PALINDROME! i know this doesn't help the case but its the only detail I noticed and it made me feel like a genius

  • @AnniM88
    @AnniM88 5 лет назад +116

    I think they are twins, one had to life with the midwife until they somehow got back together. or something like that...

  • @jasminet1981
    @jasminet1981 5 лет назад +6

    I can’t stop thinking of ‘what happened to Monday’ the movie

  • @sijojohn2207
    @sijojohn2207 3 года назад +2

    I like the way he did not overreact while listening carefully

  • @NothingGoodHere1001
    @NothingGoodHere1001 5 лет назад +1

    OMG I almost forgot about this game! And I LOVE these types of videos!

  • @alexcali8663
    @alexcali8663 5 лет назад +6

    At the beginning he’s talking about the dates being out of order, but what he doesn’t understand is that in Europe they order the dates by day/month/year. In America We do month/day/year.

  • @findingperspicacity764
    @findingperspicacity764 5 лет назад +15

    I love Pro Play series so much! This is hella cool 😍

  • @val0077
    @val0077 5 лет назад

    Whoa this is super cool, really excited to watch the rest

  • @krashtheman
    @krashtheman 5 лет назад +1

    Probably my favourite video of this series

  • @adiorei
    @adiorei 5 лет назад +23

    Next: *A real baby plays a baby simulator*

  • @spacedandy15
    @spacedandy15 5 лет назад +5

    " i looked through 50 hrs of footage
    i can't even stay awake watching this video

  • @YumyDream
    @YumyDream 5 лет назад

    Part 1?!?! Are you kidding me?! I’m way too invested now, what am I gonna do until you post part 2? :(

  • @ZoroElric
    @ZoroElric 5 лет назад

    man i love this game, wish there's more games like this. thanks for playing it

  • @chewedupgum4989
    @chewedupgum4989 3 года назад +4

    After reading through some comments and seeing the video its pretty easy to tell Hannah and Eve apart
    Eve is the confident one , i think she also performs judging by how she played the guitar, how she dresses and her manerism .
    Hannah is basically calm and abit clueless about all this i think . She didnt talk that much but when she did she talked ab her normal life before the murder . She's more of a simple house wife , always having tied up hair and pretty simple clothing while Eve had more of a flare to her
    Not saying they're twins or just different personalities , they're just two people mentally

  • @lolam4209
    @lolam4209 5 лет назад +5

    I know it’s a game but the clips are creepy. It creeps me out

  • @monkeyman123321
    @monkeyman123321 5 лет назад +1

    I remember this game. It's great watching how other people work the game.

  • @nichoeastronomo4043
    @nichoeastronomo4043 5 лет назад +12

    Next episode: Real Assasin Plays Assasins creed

  • @CARLSONMHG
    @CARLSONMHG 5 лет назад +35

    curveball, shes actually in a psychiatric ward and she is Hannah, Eve, Simon and Eric all in one beautiful mind.

  • @SupremeLeaderKimJong-un
    @SupremeLeaderKimJong-un 5 лет назад +155

    Kim Jong-un plays as Kim Jong-un in Hearts of Iron IV

    • @jakep7018
      @jakep7018 5 лет назад +3

      Zachary Williams *Terrible*... smh

  • @freyjathehealer5559
    @freyjathehealer5559 2 года назад

    I love this game. If you haven’t played it but watched this video it’s not spoiled for you. There’s so many secrets. Like so many questions and answers

  • @cardcaptorsnaruto
    @cardcaptorsnaruto 4 года назад

    This is so interesting! I watched Jesse Cox play this game and it took him forever to get to the conclusions that he is easily coming to.

  • @Vortor
    @Vortor 5 лет назад +3

    It'd be cool to have this guy or another private eye play the shape-shifting detective, fmv game sort of similar dialogue based. Oh, and a classic item based point and click, the insane logic vs trained rational investigation would be interesting

  • @blank2203
    @blank2203 5 лет назад +18

    Omg I can’t believe I’m only a minute late

  • @ayyylmao101
    @ayyylmao101 5 лет назад

    THE P.I.'S BACK!!! I loved the L.A. Noire vid, and I know I'll love this one.

  • @rachsounds
    @rachsounds 5 лет назад +2

    Omg this game, now I just clicked into this video and am so curious about how the pro will perform haha

  • @iMariyellerz
    @iMariyellerz 5 лет назад +324

    WAIT WHAT SHE TOOK HER TWIN’S VIRGINITY WITH A HAIRBRUSH... HELLO LOL
    Edit: 26:51

    • @coolopinion
      @coolopinion 5 лет назад +12

      xoMarielle oh geez I was playing sims while watching this so I didn’t have 100% attention on it I thought they used the hairbrush to give bruises, but now that you say that AHHHHHHHH

    • @iMariyellerz
      @iMariyellerz 5 лет назад +23

      Fava Pineapple hahaha yeah I was appalled when she said that. Like what😳 I was invested in this gameplay 😂

    • @ladymidnight022
      @ladymidnight022 5 лет назад +5

      Fava Pineapple I was also playing sims 😂

    • @sharonanagamuthu6926
      @sharonanagamuthu6926 5 лет назад +6

      I was right next to my MOM when that part came on lmaoo

    • @thatonegooze
      @thatonegooze 5 лет назад +3

      is that considered incest?

  • @lin_3548
    @lin_3548 5 лет назад +4

    25:26 reminds me of the movie “what happened to monday” how if 1 got hurt they all had to match with the same injuries.

  • @hauntedmushroom
    @hauntedmushroom 5 лет назад

    wow i love this series already

  • @collinvinish2808
    @collinvinish2808 5 лет назад +1

    How have y’all not played this game?!? It’s been in the App Store for 4 years!

  • @lisamariejo.7011
    @lisamariejo.7011 5 лет назад +87

    he seems hella tired

    • @jbark678
      @jbark678 5 лет назад +17

      He mentioned watching 50 hrs of recordings pretty casually, so I'm not surprised.

    • @tonyvu9477
      @tonyvu9477 4 года назад +8

      @@jbark678 Could also be the fact that he sat through the L.A. Noir video with that girl who wouldn't stop talking =)

  • @KipsPixels
    @KipsPixels 5 лет назад +7

    Played this game its a great game with a twisted ending.

  • @justsomeguywithtattoos6267
    @justsomeguywithtattoos6267 5 лет назад

    It's hilarious to see how he starts motivated and slowly gets more and more tired

  • @Musicgirl82
    @Musicgirl82 5 лет назад

    Oh man, I love this game! I played it a couple years ago.

  • @rblxduelist
    @rblxduelist 5 лет назад +11

    Nice but I would like to see X prisoner play prison break game if that hasn't come yet

  • @ronknox3376
    @ronknox3376 5 лет назад +9

    Did he finally catch on that this is British and the day comes before the month?....lol

  • @Betherun
    @Betherun 5 лет назад

    Aaaaaand now I hooked. Dammit, I'm watching this at work...at night... 😬😨 The brain is such a wonderfully horrifying organ.

  • @nuggets7428
    @nuggets7428 5 лет назад

    I LOVE THIS SERIES SOOO MUCH(ok tho but not as much as the 100 BB challenge)

  • @yikesu3587
    @yikesu3587 5 лет назад +22

    i love when it says no views but over 100 likes

  • @the_ghost9140
    @the_ghost9140 5 лет назад +6

    I'd love to see a deep sea diver look at subnautica

  • @MrKlimcio
    @MrKlimcio 5 лет назад +1

    I enjoyed that more than playing Her Story by myself.

  • @0ne323
    @0ne323 5 лет назад

    Thank you for not having that host from before on the LA noir ep

  • @FlowersOfIcetor
    @FlowersOfIcetor 5 лет назад +8

    lmao his face when she goes "he was wearing um... a shirt" at 7:54

  • @florence4372
    @florence4372 5 лет назад +102

    "Real Private Investigator" are there any fake ones?

    • @BoHista23
      @BoHista23 5 лет назад +49

      yeah, con artists exist

    • @adanamaru
      @adanamaru 5 лет назад +6

      firstname lastname patty mayo and bounty hunter D

    • @timvvs
      @timvvs 5 лет назад +4

      firstname lastname Armchair investigators

    • @sed9385
      @sed9385 5 лет назад

      Nope, but there are *fictional* ones. 😉😂

    • @claranadine1086
      @claranadine1086 4 года назад

      Yes, me

  • @julsarabe1096
    @julsarabe1096 4 года назад

    When he started to mention the multiple personalities of the woman, I started to get hyped up haha

  • @anaclarapaniago4303
    @anaclarapaniago4303 5 лет назад

    I love this game, i'm so excited

  • @mari_stella
    @mari_stella 5 лет назад +5

    This is like that netflix film what happened to monday

  • @nguyenquanganh7517
    @nguyenquanganh7517 4 года назад +12

    "I didnt murder Simon"
    well she is clearly innocent

  • @vipulgupta4348
    @vipulgupta4348 4 года назад

    I love this game and I played it exactly like this, having the same thoughts. Split-personality, twins, everything.

  • @mikhelangelo9743
    @mikhelangelo9743 3 года назад +1

    This is so cool