Former Mercedes Diesel Owner The only question that matters is "does the Sprinter engine have an EGR valve?" If it does the diesel engine intake manifold will foul with diesel exhaust gases at around 60000 miles. Repairs cost, at a minimum $6000. If the diesel engine's oil cooler is located in the valley between cylinder banks, it will fail at around 65000 miles. Cost unknown but would involve tearing off the entire injection system. Good luck! When we bought the Mercedes diesel sedan I said it would be the last car we purchased. I was wrong. It was the last Mercedes we would ever purchase.
I wonder why people are so terrified of diesels in the US. Here in Europe every van is a diesel, and half the passenger cars too. They all have EGR, most have a DPF. Yet you can drive 300k km without having problems with any of those... And the fuel consumption of diesel vans is around like 26 or more mpg, so I wonder what do u guys do to it over there.
I was partners with a Ford dealer on a truck rental business. Half of my fleet was gasoline and half was diesel. All maintenance costs such as oil changes, fuel filters, air filters etc was at least three times as much with the Diesel engines. That’s comparing Fords to Fords. I’m sure Mercedes maintenance costs would be even more. Over the years I owned and operated thousands of Transit Vans. They performed flawlessly. I would highly recommend them.
Definitely agree that the Sprinter is underpowered. And like others have stated, I have never had a vehicle in the shop more than our Sprinter. I love our van and have spent a lot of time and money on it. However, we are selling it because we cannot be in the middle of nowhere with a service issue and no MB dealer for 400 miles.
We sequentially owned two Sprinter chassis RVs. A 2016 Airstream Interstate that thankfully we traded on a superb 2016 Leisure Travel Van after only six months of grief with the Airstream. Now we own a 2022 Coachmen Beyond on a 2021 Ford Transit AWD. Having driven the Sprinter and Transit chassis RVs in real world RV travel, the Transit is far and away a more enjoyable vehicle to drive. It cruises effortlessly up and down hills, the adaptive cruise control works flawlessly. The Sprinter labored up hills and was too underpowered to quickly and safely pass even the slower 18-wheelers on any incline. We just had our first Ford oil change and service at the local Ford Fleet dealer nearby. Just drove in without needing an appointment. Left our Transit because they needed to wait for the rack to be available that holds dualies. Cost just $100, and in and out within 24 hours! With the Mercedes we had to schedule appointments weeks in advance, sometimes drive over 50 miles to find a Sprinter MB dealer service, pay 5 to 7 times that amount for the same service. Also, MB Sprinters are not approved for bio-diesel. It was always challenging to find the right diesel station to fill up the Mercedes, often having to phone in advance. The DEF was always a mystery as the Sprinter chassis we had lacked a DEF gauge. Filing it and being sure it didn’t run out was a real nuisance. The Ford is as enjoyable to drive and maintain as a big friendly SUV! Astonishingly the Ford has superior quality control on its build than the MB. We replaced our two MB car/SUVs with two Subarus. Couldn’t be happier. I will agree that the Sprinter has a more rough and ready appearance, the seats are superbly more comfortable, and it’s a higher status vehicle. Alas, the Ford has the stigma of low cost to purchase and maintain! Driving the Sprinter was a labor. Driving the AWD Transit is a labor of love.
As a Fleet Manager who has seen everything the Sprinter can and will throw at you for over 15 years, be prepared. First and foremost. Have several local options for maintenance and repairs. Ideally a very competent dealer who has trained personnel who know the Sprinter and their issues. Same for an independent shop. I can't stress how important this is. A tech or shop who dabbles with these vs a trained competent tech can be a nightmare both short and long term... Second, and much more difficult in my opinion is a network of repair shops/dealers for issues on the road. This in my opinion would be a major deterrent in owning one as an RV. The coverage in the US of shops and even dealers that are competent with the Sprinter is appalling. Be prepared to spend a lot of money annually on maintenance. The "payback" for us as a commercial distributor varies annually but is usually in the 50K range.. It's an expensive vehicle to own and operate and not as reliable as anyone likes but if your going to put a lot of mileage on it and have a good network for repairs and maintenance it can work. The Transit in the commercial sector is just the opposite. Utilized for lower mileage applications and much lower maintenance costs and better coverage on the road. Won't last as long as the Sprinter but in my opinion makes more sense as an RV platform.
@@computer__eyez I have had a ProMaster, 136, for 4 years and almost 50l.000 miles. To date maintenance has been minimal. I had a question when in Fairbanks and the Ram dealer got me in that afternoon. Rubbing muffler diagnosed and repositioned and I was back on the road. Also, in my 12,600 mile Alaska trek I averaged to my amazement 19.2 MPG and that was with Falken Wildpeak A/T3W tires. We did over 1,500 miles of dirt roads, Dempster, (to the Arctic Circle), Eagle, Top of the World, McCarthy without trouble. But being only front wheel drive, it is not the rig you would want on gnarly two track routes.
@@dougal9439 thanks a lot Dougal. I have been researching ProMaster and wanting to pick one up, from all the data I’ve gathered. This knowledge you have illuminated me with, along with my own research… it seems I am being lead to go with a ProMaster. That Alaska trek, I was envisioning as I am reading your astonishment, brings a smile to my face. Impressive indeed! I plan to visit Alaska at some point, it is *high* on my list. Everyone I know wants to go to the Caribbean, I want to drive to Alaska.
What Transit loses in clearance it gains in interior height. I think most people would prefer roomier cabin over couple of inches of extra clearance, but if your mission is going to places less driven, those 2 inches may become a deal breaker. For a regular road warrior though, Transit wins hands down and this video very nicely explains it.
This comment (interior height) does not match up to what I heard? I am very much in tune with heights (6'3") and Mercedes had me sold while speaking of headroom, etc
As bad as the dealer service cost are going to be on the Ford, the Mercedes will always be more expensive. I have came close twice on buying a Sprinter based RV, but thoughts of bringing my RV to the local Mercedes dealership keeps giving me chills!
Fortunately, I found a local Mercedes authorized repair shop that can accommodate my sprinter base RV for oil changes. Service A and B costs way more at the Mercedes van service shop near me. Currently I take my 2005 Tundra with a camper shell on my off road trips.
I have a 2020 Transit with 30k we put on it in close to 3 years. My maintenance costs are $260 for 3 services. Ford pass points have paid for about $200 of that.
@Frank Furter and not all Mercedes places service Sprinters. I had a problem when traveling in northern IL and had to go to FOUR dealers to find one who did!!
Not disagreeing for disagreement sake... but what price difference? The Sprinter cargo van is $3k more... which is about 5%... but the sprinter gets 20-25% better fuel mileage. Perhaps that doesn't resonate with someone that only puts a few thousand miles on them every year.
We’ve been driving our 2014 Sprinter as our daily car with long trips several times a year. Our gvw is 8900 pounds, we have a 2 wheel drive 4 cylinder turbo engine. We get 25mpg and live in the mountains. I regularly drive 60-65 mph up steep mountains on I-5. We pay 12$ for DEF about every 1500 miles. It has been a great van for the 70k miles we’ve driven it. Maybe we just got lucky, but I wanted to share my experience over the past 5 years. Best wishes and thanks for a great video.
Our first RV was a Mercedes based Winnebago View ( a B+ class RV) with the 6 cly diesel. Never had a Mercedes anything before so was excited at first. However got tired of tippy handling, especially in wind due to Mercedes not extending wheel track in rear. Even checking tire pressures was a pain as rear duals were so far back under the body. The biggest thing by far however was maintenance ands repair costs. I could have made a house payment for what an oil change cost, but that was not the worse cost. The worst cost was engine/ exhaust sensors going out four times at a cost of over $1500 each - not to mention the cost of having to go out of our way on RV trips to find a Mercedes dealer and wait for it to get repaired. This is stuff the "RV reviews" online and in magazines don't touch on. Two years ago we traded for a good old Ford E450 based, slightly larger B+ and all has been trouble free, don't need to finance my house for an oil change. Rear duals come out to the edge of the body, and body is wider, and shorter, no more arriving to RV site tired due to fighting the wind. No more trying to find a Mercedes if something needs repair!
At a certain point, don't you just change your own oil? There looks to be plenty of room in the engine bay of a Sprinter and there's plenty of clearance to scoot under it. Is it difficult? I just bought a Sprinter and didn't expect oil changes to be costly.
why would you service a german car/van at a stealership? just go to any reputable shop and get it done at a fraction of a cost, search for parts online and instead of 1500 for a sensor you pay 150. I had a e90 BMW M3 (the V8 one) for a few years and stealership would quote me around $600 for AN OIL CHANGE, cause some BS reasons, while the a reputable local shop that I usually see working on supras and gtr's all the time charged me $250 ($180 was just the cost of oil and filter)
I have an RV based off of a Ford E450 cutaway chassis. Sure my MPG is not as good as a Mercedes diesel but diesel reliably runs $1 more per gallon and just one unfortunate Mercedes priced repair bill can buy a lot of gas. This and the lack of worry associated with the well-regarded 450 Ford engine. Who needs to live in constant fear of Mercedes reliability or lack thereof.
The newer Mercedes diesels are a HORRIBLE choice. The days of Mercedes diesels being reliable, long running engines are over. We had a GL class SUV (same 3.0L engine as the sprinter) and it was a maintenance nightmare. It would constantly say the DEF fluid was empty when it wasn't (meaning we had to replace expensive sensors again and again or become stranded) and to top it all off, by 80K miles the timing chain was stretched to the point we had to replace it. Many thousands of dollars. Timing chains aren't designed to be replaced. They should last the lifetime of the engine.
As a Brit, years ago, we had 4 TV channels with a few car shows between them. Remember, those series had separate staff dedicated to sound, camera, lighting, script, direction and production. I'm sure each series cost a small fortune to make and paid for the lifestyles of the above staff. The video you have made is as well presented and informative as any of those past professional car series. Excellent.
I knew a Sprinter tech back a couple years ago, and with the stories he told me about maintenance cost, parts, labor and especially rust issues with that van after a couple of years, I would go for a Transit anytime.
One of the reasons we went Promaster. Surprising to me during my research how awful so many people said the MB is. That said, the PM isn't a Toyota, quite a few minor build defects and concerns over longevity.
In the UK pretty much all the big supermarket grocery delivery vans, Tesco, Asda, Sainsburys, Ocado, Morrisons, are Mercedes, with the odd Transit or Iveco here and there. Those are used sixteen hours a day, seven days a week, 362 days a year. So they must all be happy with reliability and service costs.
I’ve had my Thor sprinter for 4 months now and been enjoying everything about it, no regrets. I’m glad we picked it over a transit build. At the end of the day you got to enjoy what you see in your driveway. Put a smile in my face that I own one.
What a great head to head compare. These are the two vans we are looking at. So really appreciate the time you took to prepare and produce this video. Great job.
I like how you're not trying to push one van manufacturer over the other. I agree on most of your points regarding looks, power, comfort, service. I have a Leisure Travel Van built on a Sprinter 3500 cutaway chassis. But if I were to choose a more nimble option for my camping adventures, I would seriously look at the transit myself.
Great video! After owning and traveling in Sprinters for several years, we bought and converted our first Transit. Yes, I agree the Sprinter is better looking but once you drive the Transit, looks start to matter less. The Transit is the “spork” of vans, not the winner of the beauty contest but it checks all the boxes when it comes to versatility.
I own a Ford Transit 350 and am very happy. service is easily available at our Ford dealership. I am 5'4" tall so height is no problem because the Sprinter is a few inches taller. Bed wise I can sleep across and there is plenty of room for my dog too. the kitchen and upfront shower are great and convenient. the van is easy to drive on all terrain and pickup speed is great I am happy to own the 350 Ford Transit dual axle camper van.
I think Transit looks way better than Sprinter. The only problem I have (living in Europe) is that I can only buy Ford with diesel engine, unless I get used, imported one from USA.
I have a med roof med length transit 3.5 natural aspirated AWD 2021, gas miles low 16.2 to high 19 mpg, 10 speed transmission and lower powered motor than eco boost is slower going up hills but down shifts 2-3 gears depending on slope, 31 gal tank can go 500 mile without refueling, drivability is great, people watching from behind have mentioned how the transit hugs the curves with stock tires and is easy getting in and out. Also custom order allows front swivel seats, totally satisfied for my uses! Also with my avalanche grey color, I have a more custom feel than all those generic 4x4 Sprinters loaded to the kilt with roof racks, ladder, and rear door lockers because of overbuilt camper interiors, I have placed a generic pickup carpet kit from my 8’ bed pickup that allows full floor length hauling and when sleeping the carpet kit has full length bed and storage in both wheel well cabinets plus is totally removable leaving a full size cargo van floor footage, I’m very happy as this option verses Sprinter has saved me $50,000 and more over the camper build Sprinter.
A few of the Sprinter features you noted are now available in the Transit as of 2022- Keyless push button start and 360 degree cameras. The 22's also have a larger infotainment screen, though the downside of that is more of the controls are onscreen instead of easier to use buttons. We've got a 2021 148" HR Transit we love, and chose it over the Sprinter for many of the same reasons you did.
I once had a problem with a Ford campervan in the middle of nowhere, Arizona. A small garage in a tiny town fixed it up, no problem. I think the point about maintenance and repairs is an especially good point if you're planning on traveling to remote areas (eg, Utah, Arizona, etc) where finding a Mercedes repair shop could be really hard if not impossible.
Very detailed and honest comparison. I bought my 4x4 Sprinter in 2015 but for the more accessible maintenance, I would have preferred the Transit if they had the AWD option. There were two after market conversions to 4x4 but they were very expensive (approx 20,000$) and not very reliable. The Sprinter is very good, I prefer the diesel engine, I like the van, and never had a problem in 135,000 miles. Regular maintenance is actually easy done even by a non-professional like me and parts are not expensive ( labor at the dealership is) but every time when I drive in a remote area, far from home, I keep thinking what would I do if something malfunctioned in my van`s engine. I always carry tools and a diagnostic device, RUclips offers a lot of info, but I am not sure I would be able to fix something broken. My ideal van would be an AWD Transit with the diesel engine.
I have the sprinter. true 4x4. Thank you for really researching. I do a lot of overlanding and off roading. I have the struts and 4.3 van compass suspension. It was a must to make the vehicle drive well not just off road but on freeway driving. I found the 4x4 sprinter is unremarkable for off road beyond just groomed fire roads. Prior to my sprinter I had a F150 with same motor as your ford and loved the power. You are so right on that it is actually up to you. I do all my own service, but I am not going to lie. Mercedes has made it very difficult for one to do service by design, but with research and some mechanical skills it is not hard to do an A service or B service yourself. Thanks again for the video.
That was interesting, they both had some positive points going for them. The limiting service availability & power on the Sprinter were significant reasons to choose the Transit. Take care guys.
@@Weretherussos No one is going rock crawling with these vans. Nor will they do serious off-roading in their camper van. These AWD/4x4 vans are meant for regular National Park dirt roads (light off-roading).
Likewise, the service availability (and power! I did not realize that the Sprinter put out < 200 hp!) in itself outweighs just about everything. Transit is the clear choice for me. And Thanks Russos for this video! It definitely helped me decide which one to get (if and when I get one that is).
@@robertlee3778 all diesel engines have significantly less horse power than the gas engines because gas engines work at higher rotations per minute. It means that the cylinders rotate a lot but with less force. The torque is important and that is the force transmitted to the wheels. Ford is superior there as well, 400lbs/ft compared to 325.
I own a long, tall 350 Transit with limited slip, AWD, and (OMG!) ecoboost. Keeping the speed between 60 and 65 the mileage stays between 14 and 16 mpg.
Having both I have the exact same feelings. I wish the transit interior was as polished as the sprinter. I do like driving the transit better and I think it’s more ‘car like’ on longer rides. Great video..
I have experience with the sprinter van working for Amazon but I would want the upgraded Ford Transit for all the reasons you said. Thinking ahead about services is really important and having more headroom is important for me. The sprinter is a fantastic van but it isn't worth the extra costs if you can't afford it or would rather use your money for other things.
Joe and Kait, my main reason for choosing the LT was after reading all of the MB horror stories on FB. People getting stranded for literally months without the use of the van, just scared me out of the MB. Good comparison of main points of each. Many thanks guys!
One problem with comparing these two vans is they're both changing pretty quickly. For instance you point out the Transit doesn't have push button start, but it's now an option on the 2022s. The screen got bigger and it gained 360 cameras too. The Sprinter, otoh, is dropping that 4x4 system for AWD and a different engine. So all the aftermarket accessories will have to be redone, probably a max of 2 inch lift, but it will probably more readily available and easier to get serviced than the current 4x4. And maybe none of that matters anyway if you can't afford brand new and are comparing, say, 2020s. But in that case as you go back in the time the Transit loses features pretty quickly, as Ford has been aggressively updating it.
Ford parts cost half MB parts. Ford service is half also. The 3.5 EcoBoost V6 is in millions of Ford cars and is a proven reliable engine. The MB has lots of $$$ Problems. Lets be honest.
He's not comparing "changing" vans. Your mind is wrapped around a brand. He's comparing "these" vans - not the brands. He's clearly comparing utility and efficacy. What he has done makes sense. You are sharing an unrelated opinion that has no place logically, nor reasonably.
My husband has the ford truck with this exact engine. Hes been waiting ALL SUMMER for some transfer case part on theFord. All summer. They told him to drive but he’s risking destroying the engine. Luckily we have a GMC explorer high top family van & has been driving it instead. I used to love Ford. Not anymore. We live in the suburbs of Chicago. Hes called everywhere & NO one has the part! Ford has lost our loyalty
As a Professional Sprinter tech, just cannot even look to a Ford side. 😂 When you said that Ford is more comfortable than Sprinter - I was smiling 🙈☺️. Test drove many Ford’s - even though they are always chasing Sprinter Van - I don’t think they will ever be close. Ford is famous for cheapest, creepiest plastic, just awful seats, terrible seating position, idiotic design of battery location and much much more. I am not saying anything about drivetrain - ask one of your 3000 dealers about cost of transmission oil change on your beloved Ford. You will be surprised. Newer Sprinter has some issues with electronics, but I am sure that MB will update it soon. Older Sprinter versions are very reliable, and long lasting. DEF can be fixed or upgraded. Most of the owners just neglect service on time. And then are very surprised why it fails. I’ve personally seen in my shop Sprinter with 899k miles, 495k miles etc. Will your gasoline ford last that long? Very questionable. Unfortunately many stealerships across the country are just a bunch of crooks and idiots. And it makes service a nightmare. But there are many dedicated independent Mercedes places that provide excellent service. I personally would never ever choose Ford over Sprinter. And my advice to anyone who is in doubt - go with Sprinter, you will not regret!
Having driven a sprinter for the past 8 years (both the 4cyl and 6cyl diesels) my thoughts are this: The current gen Sprinter looks so much sexier than the current Transit both inside and out. But unfortunately the sprinter is just a maintenance nightmare and what some might now know so that not all Mercedes dealerships have a sprinter tech so that 400 dealer number is likely significantly less in terms of dealerships where you can have your sprinter worked on.The Transit is so much better in a lot of ways but I just can’t get over the looks of it. The sprinter is just so sexy but it comes with a LOT of baggage. In the end I think the Transit is objectively better but subjectively the sprinter looks 10x sexier. If you care about that kind of thing 😬
At the end of the day the sprinter is a high maintenance woman and we know no matter how good she looks in the end she's going to cost you the most and certainly won't be so sexy to you ....like my pappy use to say beauty is only skin deep but ugly if Plum to the Bone !!!
Also consider the fact that the diesel sprinter will have all the EPA garbage problems that come along with all it's emissions systems. Your engine will literally be disabled and you won't be able to drive it if the computer detects a failure in any of the emissions components. Troubleshooting and repairing emissions can cost thousands of dollars.
Love that you used identical Storyteller builds for this comparison, it really brings the focus to the increasingly small differences between these two very capable platforms. Others have noted that the 2022 12" console in the Ford Transit has 360 camera view and feels very well integrated (with Fordpass, wifi and carplay). I'll be curious to revisit this in 2023 when Sprinter gets a new AWD system.
+1 .. Torque is where its at. End of Story the Transit 3.5 V6 twin turbo w/10sp gearbox. .. Now, that said. . An ECU Chip tuned the MB 3.0 turbo diesel w/7sp gearbox and the engine output difference btw the Transit & Sprinter is less, much less. .. P.S., At present (MY2023) the USA MB Sprinter only offers a H.O. 4cly turbo diesel; Which surpasses the former 3.0 6cyl. turbo diesel.
Really interesting comparison. I went with a promaster because it was wider with squarer walls. It’s not a 4 wheel drive so I guess it’s not part of your comparison but I love it. And it gets 16-20 mpg.
I bought a Sprinter 4x4 because I need the clearance to get to my favorite backcountry campsites. Plus I have had numerous mechanical problems in the past with Ford vans.
Serviceability was my deciding factor in getting the Ford instead of the sprinter. I really wanted the sprinter but getting it worked on was going to be a pain because I live in a smaller town and to get it serviced I would have had to drive it over 2 hours away from me. With the Ford I could get oil changes and any major issues taken care of in my hometown.
A little late to the comments, but this was a great comparison. I have a sprinter 4x4 I built out myself. We would have bought a transit if we had been able to find one in 2021. Transit easier to drive and MUCH faster. But I am happy with my sprinter. Looks great, so well built. I appreciate the (supposed) longevity of the diesel engine. Biggest benefit is that it's much easier to get campervan upgrades for the sprinter. As a DIYer, that makes it so much easier. Not relevant if you're buying a storyteller or other upfitted one.
This is a pretty good comparision, but I will say you will always pay more for 4X4's and Diesel engines. One thing that was not discussed and is extremly important to me is longevity and resale value. The Sprinter wins here. Diesel engines will last twice as long as gas and get much better fuel economy. The only qualm I have with this video is I think the MPG was inaccurate. That might be due to driving styles but Sprinters ussually get 18-22 MPG. For instance in our Sprinter I get about 16-18 in city and 20-24 hwy.
Very true but the difference in resale value is easily off set with the cost of repairs and maintenance on the Sprinter. Also, the reason I compared these two particular vans was because they have the same components like roof rack, awning, larger aftermarket wheels/4x4, tires, etc. This all negatively affects gas mileage and hence why it’s lower than what you might see on another van.
@@Weretherussos Would have to disagree there. I’m not sure how the price of repairs would offset the resale value? Sprinters tend to break less and have more reliable parts. The repairs might be costly but I bet overtime they’re similar to how much and how frequent fords are repaired. Plus the engine is going to last 2 or 3 X as long vs a gasoline engine. If the ford and sprinter are getting similar mileage than there must be considerably more weight in the Sprinter. The MPG’s on a diesel vehicle should offset the price difference you pay at the pump and help offset some of the expenses like the more frequent oil changes that a diesel vehicle requires. I’ve owned Diesels most of my life and Mercedes’ diesels at that imo they make the best Diesel engines on the planet. In the short term the gasoline engine is probably cheaper but if you’re planning to keep your vehicle for more than 5, 10,15 years the diesel is going to cost you less in the long run and it’s going to resell for more.
Just found you and I'm very happy we did. Been fighting with myself over ford vs MB for about a year. I keep landing on the MB due to 4WD. We live in CO and 4WD is essential for winter mountain trips. Yet your comments about lack of climbing power and service options make me think I'm back to Ford. My father-in-law would never forgive me for buying a Ford but he hated foreign cars more! THANKS again!
Great comparison video, those are small things that make a big deal. I actually prefer the Transit after driving for Amazon, I hate the shifter & I don’t like push button starts. But you pointed out some things I didn’t notice
We have the sprinter with 40k miles on it always serviced at Mercedes at the proper time and the engine just blew, very disappointing only 40k. We have a good warranty and they said they would take care of it because our service history was excellent so no arguments from them. But still a diesel that goes bad at 40k. Im leaning on selling it as soon as it fixed and going with the transit van, its cheaper to service.
Whats strange that you find plenty Sprinter with high mileage still running but the Ford Diesels do not make more than 200.000km before the motor dies. At least it is the situation here in Germany. You find numerius of the Fords with dead engine or early replaced engines. Regarding costs and maybe some extra stuff in the cabin, one can say any other van is better than a Mercedes. But when it comes to reliability of the 3.0 in the Sprinter, I could not say there is something that could top it. Basically you need to know what the lady wants. Bring it to MB for any small problem is not a good idea to save money.
Excellent video! I was fixed on getting a Sprinter, after hearing all your comparisons, I think a Transit would be the smarter choice for my purposes, thanks!
Everything else aside, when you said you had your foot buried to the floor and it was losing speed going uphill, that's enough for me. I can't stand an underpowered vehicle, especially a "go-anywhere" vehicle that could accumulate things on your journeys. Great review.
Thanks for doing a great comparative video. As someone who loves German engineering, I gravitate toward the Sprinter, but in terms of practicality the Ford would be the logical choice. As you pointed out, Ford dealers are nearly everywhere. Safe travels!
Interesting video. Thank you. We have the MB, very satisfied but here is what I dislike: 1) Too many electronic sensors make you totally at the mercy of MB for maintenance. You need the MB computer to fix many issues, even a 300$ OBD2 tester don't work. 2) Dealership are scarce. Here in Quebec, we had owners have their RV towed 800 km to a dealership, and the wait time for repair is 3 months. (Not a typo, 1-2-...3 months). 3) The dreaded 'you have 10 starts left. Inacceptable for anyone, especially for travelers. And there is no way to bypass, even in an emergency situation. I still love ours, but because we boondock a lot in remote areas, the next RV will be on a Ford chassis.
We`ve had our 4x4 Sprinter for over a year now, and love it. Average around 16 MPG between freeway and city/trails. We did upgrade the suspension to a Van Compass 4.3 which helps a lot with off roading as well as freeway high winds. Only thing I don’t like is when stopping on an incline, the turbo has to spool up before it will move. Sometimes, I wonder if it will move at all even with my foot smashed on the accelerator. Never test drove the Transit, though wish I had. I did test the Ram, and really disliked it mostly due to lack of torque and stopping power. This was after owning 2 Ram pickups that I thought were great.
We have a ford truck with this same engine. Parts unavailable all summer of ‘23. Not drivable. We just bought a sprinter rv, our 2nd, and will hope its ok. Our 1st one, other than alignment was fine
@@user-3tf67bk46u i know it needs a few parts. Believe it or not, its a GASKET!! We would normally have just put something that fit but last year we put a few gaskets on our boat’s vacuum toilet system. And one failed right out of the Amazon box. They looked & felt identical. Both toilets needed this duckbill thing. We found one Dometic but had to order a 2nd non-dometic one from Amazon. a boat mechanic found us one and that was the issue. We couldn’t believe that it failed bit it did. We cannot take a chance with an “engine”
Interestingly Transit despite not having 2 speed transfer case has a lower 24:1 overall crawl ratio than Sprinter with low range 20:1, thanks to granny gear 9 speed auto. Transit also has an optional limited slip differential in the rear. The Sprinter has an open diff. The Sprinter also doesn't have a center diff lock. So off-road it traction is a problem Transit will usually come out on top. The Sprinter will get ahead on ground clearance.
When i sold my 2012 sprinter I thought i'd never buy a Ford or (gasp) Promaster. But after driving the Ford (with ecoboost) i was blown away. I purchased a 350 ext high roof and couldn't be happier. service and maintenance costs are so much easier. Everything is less expensive on the Ford and its so easy to work on it (adding super springs, sumo springs, lighting, etc...) The one complaint i have with my ford transit is the quality of materials in the cabin. The plastic is cheap and feels like its from the 90's. Hard and rigid. But its a van and not a car/suv so i'm OK with that. great video comparison
This is very helpful. I've had an LT on order since last September, but given the long wait I finally bought a used Classic. I haven't canceled the LT order yet and was hoping to see comparisons like these. The power, or lack thereof, on the Sprinter makes me nuts. But, given the recent price increase on the LT and paying almost $15k in sales taxes and fees to register it after just going through that on the Sprinter, I'm not sure the power difference is worth tens of thousands of dollars.
We have a transit and ABSOLUTELY LOVE IT! We didn't do a traditional build - but we have a "base camp on wheels" and couldn't be happier!! ~Karen & Shannon WOY
Thanks for the review. My experience with MB is fewer dealers and much higher maintenance repair costs than Mazda, for example. I've owned both brands as well as Ford, Chrysler, Nissan, Kia. Now in the market for a camper van. Will take a serious look at Transit after this review.
I drove a fully loaded EcoBoost Transit from MA to Denver. Even going constantly uphill on the high plains, I was getting about 15mpg. And did get 17 on one stint.
This was great, my husband and I have teetered between gas and diesel and feel that the gas will serve us better as well. Head room, handling, power, looks like the transit is the best fit for us as well. Thanks for the great comparison
Here's another ding on the diesel fuel option. As if it wasn't stressful enough to find diesel on your travels, you can't get 5% sulfur everywhere as suggested by Mercedes for the fuel. So many stations only have a Biodiesel option. This means it will run a little dirtier and you'll have to get oil changes more frequently than the standard 20, 000 miles.
Thank you for taking the time to do this side by side comparison. Good job as always Joe and a thumbs up to the camera gal! I’m driving my third Ford with an ecoboost engine and they perform great through mountains.
I chose a transit purely on the used market price, servicing and maintance costs. Buy used was less than half the price for a newer transit with lower milage, servicing and replacement parts are also much cheaper. First thing i upgraded i the transit was the drivers seat because it was a literal pain in my arse and lower back. Thanks for the review, safe travels andGod bless one and all.
I have a 2020 AWD Transit 250 that I converted. I agree the MB looks nicer on the outside. I live in Tahoe and mostly use my van for skiing in the winter and music festivals in the summer. I haven't had any issues yet but it takes me about 3 weeks to schedule an oil change and rotation at the local dealer in Reno and the dealer sucks!! No way I would ever be treated like they do at a MB dealership!! I ski over 100 days every year and having a van is a huge game changer no matter what van you have! I will say I'm blown away with the AWD on my Transit, it's a beast!! I've had Outback's and Highlanders in the past and the Transit is much better in the snow, hands down!! My main reasons for getting the Transit over the Sprinter was price and I didn't want a diesel. Once Ford came out with AWD in 2020 I got one!! The thing I don't like about my Transit is no push button start, I have it on my Highlander and love it!! Safe travels no matter what you drive!! Aloha!!
The Ford all day long! One thing I can’t stand is driving an under powered vehicle! Driving from LA to the tip of Baja Mexico I go over numerous mountain passes and pass big rigs and slow moving vehicles regularly. Also, I’m 6’4” tall… I would need that extra head space! Seems like the choices are: Sprinter, sexy but under powered and higher maintenance. Transit, more reliable, powerful, and low maintenance.
After having two diesel-engine Sprinters, I would not touch another diesel vehicle in the US again, no matter who manufacturers it. Enough with the check engine light, dirty filter, failed sensors, limp mode, last-minute change of route just to find a MB van dealership. Towards the end of the ownership, I was almost trying to avoid using the vehicle because of that feeling of uncertainty.
Great info -The selectable 4×4 system, with low range, will no longer be available next year on the Mercedes-Benz Sprinter 2023 they are going to AWD. Different engines too.
The Transit is now available with a split screen 360 view camera system and push button start as well. If it is the same system that is in my F-150, it works very, very well.
Thank you for the video, you are a likeable host . Currently driving a high roof Ram Promaster, I love this van had it new since 2019 , so much fun to drive, it's a hybrid of a work and camper van in Graphite Great . I owned a new 2018 transit unfortunately it was a P.O.S. traded it for my 2019 Promaster
18 months ago I ordered a 2023 transit xlt hd awd high top. My reordered 2024 came in 3/7/2024. The 360° camera on the 10" display is a plus this year. What an awesome vehicle to drive.
Great comparison! I am shopping now, and maybe as more of an update, Ford also offers a pushbutton start now and depending on what package you get for interior upgrade, you also can get a 360° view camera. By the way, I have no clue how those cameras work because they literally look to me like the cameras hovering over the middle of the van! For me, the entryway of the transit is some thing I would have to get used to because I am fairly tall, and I do have to duck down… I got to use one that had a handle installed on the pillar, and that actually helped, because when I grabbed it, I naturally went more forward into the van then up and into the van.
Thanks for the comps. How about comparing the Ram Promaster with either of these two? Also, you didn't mention cost differentials: Just did a Costco price comp with the these two and the Ram: The Sprinter was the two wheel drive version and the Transit had the base engine. All were moderately "loaded" with extra alternators when available, RV option for the Ram and Sprinter: Results: MSRP: Ford: $55,000. Ram: $58,220 Sprinter: $62,000.
I would also opt for the Transit. It's always in AWD, so no surprises when hitting an icy patch under acceleration. And at 6' 2" I definitely need the extra headroom. And today's diesels, with their regen and DEF systems, are unnecessarily complicated. The Ecoboost is also much better suited for towing and for driving in mountainous areas. I would not be doing any serious off roading, so the Sprinter two speed transfer case is not needed, and again, adds unnecessary complexity. Finally, as was pointed out, it's much easier to find a Ford dealership, as well as people who know how to work on them and also, parts availability is going to be much greater.
We bought a new Winnebago ERA Sprinter diesel in 2019. Kept it only 9 months. Broke down on highway on 2nd trip out and quoted repair cost was 12k not covered since they claimed we didn’t use clean diesel. Fortunately our RV insurance paid the repair bill but learned quickly that repairs would be a nightmare. Only certain dealers can repair and none in our major metro area could even do a front end alignment. Fear of what would happen in Utah or Wyoming caused us to rethink ownership. If I were to go back to class B it would be a Ford.
One of the main advantages of a Class B (van) over other form factors of RV's is the ability to easily fit into standard parking places. Urban parking spaces are nominally 20 feet long, but the 22 foot Ford Transits fits just fine. The 24 foot Sprinter is pushing it a bit. Adding a cargo box or bike rack on the back makes the difference even more critical.
Standard non eco boost V6 will get you 15 mpg and better reliability at the cost of power. Probably closer to the sprinter in power with better MPG and much lower cost. Lower height of a transit is also a huge plus for cargo vans.
I upgraded my 2020 4x4 sprinter with a rear diff air locker and Agile Offroad RIP kit. I also understand you can add aftermarket power module to increase power. That said, in 4 low with locker, I have no problem climbing steep off road grades. I'm not too concerned about highway power as there is plenty 99% of the time. Love our Sprinter and I could turn around and sell it for a hefty profit.
I doubt it you will sell it for any profit after all the money you have put into it.. And how about calculating your hours of labor at $100 per hour min? Still profit?
Thank you for a great comparison. We've been torn between Mercedes b class vs Ford Coachman Beyond RB and this helps. The interior height is a biggie as my husband is 6'1", plus I've not found a Mercedes with a RB twin set up. We like this floorplan as it feels so much more open than others. Anyway, thank you. Love your videos.
As you may see from a prior comment, we owned two MB sprinter vans and now own a 2022 Coachmen Beyond 22C AWD Li3. We really love our Beyond. It may not have the room of the Sprinter LTV 2016 Unity, but it is so much more nimble to drive and park. The build quality is excellent. The Li3 is worth the money. You can get a better deal depending on shopping as price varies a lot from dealer to dealer.
I´m a Ford guy. We have the European Model called Nugget (much smaller) and we love it. Costwise and maintenance is much better than all of the Mercedes and VW vans. Maybe some day we´ll have this big guy, too :)
Nice comparison. I have a question. You mentioned that Mercedes has just under 400 dealerships nationwide. But not all dealerships are equipped to work on Sprinters so the 400 dealerships are the ones that can work on Sprinters or is the numbers of Mercedes dealerships for Sprinters far less? You two produce really good and interesting content. Keep up the good work!
@@Weretherussos OMG join one of the many Sprinter groups and get the info on local dealers..MB or non MB in the know. This vid sounds like an info mercial for Ford. Happy trails!
Great review! Probably one of the best unbiased reviews. I recently purchased a Revel and am loving it. Like you had mentioned, selection is subjective. Right out of the dealer I went to Owl Vans and had a suspension kit and extended fuel tank installed. Definitely a must have. It’s new so no issues. I like the engineering behind the Sprinter, it’s a Mercedes, it’s different and very appealing!
I personally prefer the Ford Transit for many of the reasons you states. I am 5’1” and need the medium roof, plus it uses gas and is more economical for interstate driving, and can easily convert from city driving to camping mode with little effort AND I have a lot of places I can go if I have mechanical issues. I also like the option to use the Ford Transit as a “mobile hotel” when space is tight at family gatherings, camping or vacations. Since Chevrolet does not make a camper an model, it is no problem to switch to a Ford.
@@davidpatton7298David, vehicles DO NOT VOTE! SOUTHERN GIRLS believe in simplicity and value for our money regardless of who you vote for! KEEP IT SIMPLE SWEETIE 💋 Good vans don’t come cheap to buy or to upkeep, so we value quality over glitzy interiors and fancy technology.
We liked your comparison. I was fortunate to build our in 2019 so was able to get a Quigley 4x4 conversion which with bigger tires and aftermarket suspension is almost 4" higher than stock an IMHO is extremely capable off road and a better comparison to Sprinter 4x4. We have 32,000 miles of mostly off road adventures under its wheels and are extremely happy with our choice. The 3.5 EB motor is simply awesome off road. This is especially true at higher altitudes, or when crawling in 4 low and you need precision.
Nice comparison. With all the things you said you liked better about Sprinter (appearance, higher stance, seats, suspension, b/u camera, push button start, MPG, etc) surprised you went with Transit. Most people are not going to want to pay thousands of extra $$$ to change out the seats and do expensive suspension upgrades to a brand new van. Other things to consider: The peak torque/HP verses RPM curve is important, you cannot just compare ft-lbs of torque between two engines without the associated RPMs. Mercedes 6-cyl diesel hits peak torque at only 1400 RPM while the Ford Ecoboost engine has to rev-up to a much higher 2500 RPM to deliver peak torque, nearly twice as high RPM as Sprinter and Ecoboost doesn't hit max HP until 5,000 RPM, which is the max value indicated on the Sprinter tachometer. I cannot imagine operating my Sprinter engine anywhere near 5000 RPM, most of the time it stays around 2500-3000 RPM while driving. This along with the gasoline vs diesel cycle efficiency difference means the Ford gas engine is working much harder and wearing out faster. Diesel engines are far superior for long road trips and last longer than gasoline engines, the reason why diesel is preferred in most OTR fleet vehicles. For city driving and lots of start-stops like an Amazon delivery van gasoline engines are the way to go. Love my '19 4x4 Sprinter, zero problems in almost three years and plenty of power. Just got back from CO at over 12k elevation and zero issues keeping 70 mph on hills. I can also go 20k miles between oil changes so all this talk of fewer places to get service is irrelevant to me, I just plan my service around my trips unless I am in my hometown, which has a great MB dealer.
What a helpful video, thanks guys! I have a 2003 T1N Sprinter 158 wb Class B and driving her makes me so happy! So fun and pleasurable to drive. Her factory seats are also incredibly comfy which is really helpful for my bad back. But oh boy, service can really be a struggle! Since purchasing in 2019 I have put about 10k into repairs. As much as I am emotionally attached to her, I do think about selling pretty often. But with the cost of RV's being insanely expensive, I try and push away the idea of cost sunk fallacy and keep fixing her instead of actually selling and buying something newer and non-Mercedes. Bottom line, my RV is paid for so I'm keeping her for now. All that being said, I would 100% NEVER but a newer Sprinter. As bad as my repairs have been (the worst being a 6k new transmission), the modern versions seem waaay worse. Either way, when I decide to let her go, my next RV will most likely be Ford or Ram.
Great video. Thanks. I was really surprised to see the Transit have more headroom then the Sprinter. From the outside it looks like the Sprinter would have more.
I have a '14 Sprinter 3500 as a work vehicle. It weighs just under 5 tons, fully loaded. It has absolutely no problem on hills. In fact, it is much better than a Ford E350 I had previously, which bogged down on uphills. Number one thing I would recommend is getting an extra 3 years on the warranty. We had several repairs in the first 5 years of ownership. We also got the emissions upgrade, which added several items to a renewed warranty. Oil change is expensive but is half as often as a gasoline vehicle. Service B is over $1,000, but I do some of it myself to reduce costs. I am 6'-1" and can easily stand inside with clearence. Maybe this model is different. Also the drivers seat area is far roomier in a Sprinter. I have heard good things from business owners with Transit vans, so it sounds like Ford worked hard to upgrade from the very dated econoline vans.
Great video! Seems like maintainability is my priority for cross country travel. The other stuff can probably be handled, like swapping out the seats, putting on a lift, etc.
Seems like a lot of people complain about service costs on the Sprinter. Oil changes are easy - the big thing is needing 12.5 qts. of oil, but you can buy it at Walmart. The DEF goes in about every 2k miles and takes about 5 minutes. Even the fuel filter change is easy although not inexpensive, but at every 20,000 miles it’s reasonable. Even the transmission maintenance is fairly easy. Do the maintenance right and the MB will take care of you.
You’re absolutely correct, however my point on the service is that if it’s that difficult to get an oil change then what happens when something serious happens?
Great video. I just got rid of my 2016 sprinter. Had nothing but problems with it since day one. Looking into a ford now. Just wondering about those twin turbos now. Not a big fan of turbo engines. Can these turbo engines be trusted? Thanks.
Perfect timing,I’m looking for a short wheel base van to use as a daily driver and be able to pick up and go at will. My interest is a used Roadtrek agile but this review is heaven sent.Off road is not important to me.
Great comparison. My friends all choose the Transit over the Sprinter. I love my Sprinter and I’d probably love the Transit, too, for different reasons. But, the clearance on my Sprinter 4x4 has been essential for boondocking and exploring national forest land. I’ve gone over some very unkempt, gnarly terrain and anything with a lower clearance wouldn’t have cleared the rocks and ruts. And, the van is pretty 🤣. Ps I wanted diesel hoping that this thing will keep running for a very long time. I use it as my RV and my daily driver. I’m fortunate to have a local Mercedes dealer who gets me in within a day for service. That’s unheard of in most parts of the country and I could see how not having that type of access to a dealer would be tough. At the end of the day, we’re out there in our vans, whatever make/model they are, and we’re living life, making memories.
Former Mercedes Diesel Owner
The only question that matters is "does the Sprinter engine have an EGR valve?" If it does the diesel engine intake manifold will foul with diesel exhaust gases at around 60000 miles. Repairs cost, at a minimum $6000. If the diesel engine's oil cooler is located in the valley between cylinder banks, it will fail at around 65000 miles. Cost unknown but would involve tearing off the entire injection system. Good luck!
When we bought the Mercedes diesel sedan I said it would be the last car we purchased. I was wrong. It was the last Mercedes we would ever purchase.
Delete all that non sense
@@mountainstream8351 you will eliminate 90% of these issues but if they test emissions in your area you probably can’t
I wonder why people are so terrified of diesels in the US. Here in Europe every van is a diesel, and half the passenger cars too. They all have EGR, most have a DPF. Yet you can drive 300k km without having problems with any of those... And the fuel consumption of diesel vans is around like 26 or more mpg, so I wonder what do u guys do to it over there.
Removed the DPF, EGR and have a top end low cost million mile mobile
I was partners with a Ford dealer on a truck rental business. Half of my fleet was gasoline and half was diesel. All maintenance costs such as oil changes, fuel filters, air filters etc was at least three times as much with the Diesel engines. That’s comparing Fords to Fords. I’m sure Mercedes maintenance costs would be even more. Over the years I owned and operated thousands of Transit Vans. They performed flawlessly. I would highly recommend them.
I appreciate you sharing your experience based opinion. To me it holds more weight than some of the other comments.
I think this was the BEST comparison of vans I have ever seen. You were fair and honest and used two comparable vans. Thanks for your review.
Definitely agree that the Sprinter is underpowered. And like others have stated, I have never had a vehicle in the shop more than our Sprinter. I love our van and have spent a lot of time and money on it. However, we are selling it because we cannot be in the middle of nowhere with a service issue and no MB dealer for 400 miles.
We sequentially owned two Sprinter chassis RVs. A 2016 Airstream Interstate that thankfully we traded on a superb 2016 Leisure Travel Van after only six months of grief with the Airstream. Now we own a 2022 Coachmen Beyond on a 2021 Ford Transit AWD. Having driven the Sprinter and Transit chassis RVs in real world RV travel, the Transit is far and away a more enjoyable vehicle to drive. It cruises effortlessly up and down hills, the adaptive cruise control works flawlessly. The Sprinter labored up hills and was too underpowered to quickly and safely pass even the slower 18-wheelers on any incline. We just had our first Ford oil change and service at the local Ford Fleet dealer nearby. Just drove in without needing an appointment. Left our Transit because they needed to wait for the rack to be available that holds dualies. Cost just $100, and in and out within 24 hours! With the Mercedes we had to schedule appointments weeks in advance, sometimes drive over 50 miles to find a Sprinter MB dealer service, pay 5 to 7 times that amount for the same service. Also, MB Sprinters are not approved for bio-diesel. It was always challenging to find the right diesel station to fill up the Mercedes, often having to phone in advance. The DEF was always a mystery as the Sprinter chassis we had lacked a DEF gauge. Filing it and being sure it didn’t run out was a real nuisance. The Ford is as enjoyable to drive and maintain as a big friendly SUV! Astonishingly the Ford has superior quality control on its build than the MB. We replaced our two MB car/SUVs with two Subarus. Couldn’t be happier. I will agree that the Sprinter has a more rough and ready appearance, the seats are superbly more comfortable, and it’s a higher status vehicle. Alas, the Ford has the stigma of low cost to purchase and maintain! Driving the Sprinter was a labor. Driving the AWD Transit is a labor of love.
As a Fleet Manager who has seen everything the Sprinter can and will throw at you for over 15 years, be prepared. First and foremost. Have several local options for maintenance and repairs. Ideally a very competent dealer who has trained personnel who know the Sprinter and their issues. Same for an independent shop. I can't stress how important this is. A tech or shop who dabbles with these vs a trained competent tech can be a nightmare both short and long term... Second, and much more difficult in my opinion is a network of repair shops/dealers for issues on the road. This in my opinion would be a major deterrent in owning one as an RV. The coverage in the US of shops and even dealers that are competent with the Sprinter is appalling. Be prepared to spend a lot of money annually on maintenance. The "payback" for us as a commercial distributor varies annually but is usually in the 50K range.. It's an expensive vehicle to own and operate and not as reliable as anyone likes but if your going to put a lot of mileage on it and have a good network for repairs and maintenance it can work. The Transit in the commercial sector is just the opposite. Utilized for lower mileage applications and much lower maintenance costs and better coverage on the road. Won't last as long as the Sprinter but in my opinion makes more sense as an RV platform.
This is a very helpful comment, thank you for it!
Totally agree. Weve had nothing but problems with a Winnebago View. OUTRAGEOUS charges for service and extremely limited network.
thank you for this in-depth. What about ProMasters? Would they be difficult to maintain, in comparison to the sprinter & transit?
@@computer__eyez I have had a ProMaster, 136, for 4 years and almost 50l.000 miles. To date maintenance has been minimal. I had a question when in Fairbanks and the Ram dealer got me in that afternoon. Rubbing muffler diagnosed and repositioned and I was back on the road. Also, in my 12,600 mile Alaska trek I averaged to my amazement 19.2 MPG and that was with Falken Wildpeak A/T3W tires. We did over 1,500 miles of dirt roads, Dempster, (to the Arctic Circle), Eagle, Top of the World, McCarthy without trouble. But being only front wheel drive, it is not the rig you would want on gnarly two track routes.
@@dougal9439 thanks a lot Dougal.
I have been researching ProMaster and wanting to pick one up, from all the data I’ve gathered. This knowledge you have illuminated me with, along with my own research… it seems I am being lead to go with a ProMaster.
That Alaska trek, I was envisioning as I am reading your astonishment, brings a smile to my face. Impressive indeed!
I plan to visit Alaska at some point, it is *high* on my list. Everyone I know wants to go to the Caribbean, I want to drive to Alaska.
What Transit loses in clearance it gains in interior height. I think most people would prefer roomier cabin over couple of inches of extra clearance, but if your mission is going to places less driven, those 2 inches may become a deal breaker. For a regular road warrior though, Transit wins hands down and this video very nicely explains it.
This comment (interior height) does not match up to what I heard? I am very much in tune with heights (6'3") and Mercedes had me sold while speaking of headroom, etc
@@ISNAP4UThe Ford has 3 inches more interior height.
As bad as the dealer service cost are going to be on the Ford, the Mercedes will always be more expensive. I have came close twice on buying a Sprinter based RV, but thoughts of bringing my RV to the local Mercedes dealership keeps giving me chills!
Fortunately, I found a local Mercedes authorized repair shop that can accommodate my sprinter base RV for oil changes. Service A and B costs way more at the Mercedes van service shop near me. Currently I take my 2005 Tundra with a camper shell on my off road trips.
I have a 2020 Transit with 30k we put on it in close to 3 years. My maintenance costs are $260 for 3 services. Ford pass points have paid for about $200 of that.
Now I can't say for the awd, but we switched to the transit as are delivery vehicle because of how cheap it is to maintain.
You must not be a man.
@Frank Furter and not all Mercedes places service Sprinters. I had a problem when traveling in northern IL and had to go to FOUR dealers to find one who did!!
Forgot to mention price difference. That alone is a decision maker. Great video thank you. ❤
Not disagreeing for disagreement sake... but what price difference? The Sprinter cargo van is $3k more... which is about 5%... but the sprinter gets 20-25% better fuel mileage. Perhaps that doesn't resonate with someone that only puts a few thousand miles on them every year.
We’ve been driving our 2014 Sprinter as our daily car with long trips several times a year. Our gvw is 8900 pounds, we have a 2 wheel drive 4 cylinder turbo engine. We get 25mpg and live in the mountains. I regularly drive 60-65 mph up steep mountains on I-5. We pay 12$ for DEF about every 1500 miles. It has been a great van for the 70k miles we’ve driven it. Maybe we just got lucky, but I wanted to share my experience over the past 5 years. Best wishes and thanks for a great video.
That’s great! The older pre 2019 4x4 Sprinters seem to get better MPG and are more reliable
Our first RV was a Mercedes based Winnebago View ( a B+ class RV) with the 6 cly diesel. Never had a Mercedes anything before so was excited at first. However got tired of tippy handling, especially in wind due to Mercedes not extending wheel track in rear. Even checking tire pressures was a pain as rear duals were so far back under the body. The biggest thing by far however was maintenance ands repair costs. I could have made a house payment for what an oil change cost, but that was not the worse cost. The worst cost was engine/ exhaust sensors going out four times at a cost of over $1500 each - not to mention the cost of having to go out of our way on RV trips to find a Mercedes dealer and wait for it to get repaired. This is stuff the "RV reviews" online and in magazines don't touch on. Two years ago we traded for a good old Ford E450 based, slightly larger B+ and all has been trouble free, don't need to finance my house for an oil change. Rear duals come out to the edge of the body, and body is wider, and shorter, no more arriving to RV site tired due to fighting the wind. No more trying to find a Mercedes if something needs repair!
My sprinter is stuck in Knoxville with a $16,200.00 estimate for a fuel system replacement because of bad fuel. 🤬
At a certain point, don't you just change your own oil? There looks to be plenty of room in the engine bay of a Sprinter and there's plenty of clearance to scoot under it. Is it difficult?
I just bought a Sprinter and didn't expect oil changes to be costly.
why would you service a german car/van at a stealership? just go to any reputable shop and get it done at a fraction of a cost, search for parts online and instead of 1500 for a sensor you pay 150.
I had a e90 BMW M3 (the V8 one) for a few years and stealership would quote me around $600 for AN OIL CHANGE, cause some BS reasons, while the a reputable local shop that I usually see working on supras and gtr's all the time charged me $250 ($180 was just the cost of oil and filter)
I have an RV based off of a Ford E450 cutaway chassis. Sure my MPG is not as good as a Mercedes diesel but diesel reliably runs $1 more per gallon and just one unfortunate Mercedes priced repair bill can buy a lot of gas. This and the lack of worry associated with the well-regarded 450 Ford engine. Who needs to live in constant fear of Mercedes reliability or lack thereof.
The newer Mercedes diesels are a HORRIBLE choice. The days of Mercedes diesels being reliable, long running engines are over. We had a GL class SUV (same 3.0L engine as the sprinter) and it was a maintenance nightmare. It would constantly say the DEF fluid was empty when it wasn't (meaning we had to replace expensive sensors again and again or become stranded) and to top it all off, by 80K miles the timing chain was stretched to the point we had to replace it. Many thousands of dollars. Timing chains aren't designed to be replaced. They should last the lifetime of the engine.
As a Brit, years ago, we had 4 TV channels with a few car shows between them. Remember, those series had separate staff dedicated to sound, camera, lighting, script, direction and production. I'm sure each series cost a small fortune to make and paid for the lifestyles of the above staff.
The video you have made is as well presented and informative as any of those past professional car series. Excellent.
Appreciate that - thank you
I knew a Sprinter tech back a couple years ago, and with the stories he told me about maintenance cost, parts, labor and especially rust issues with that van after a couple of years, I would go for a Transit anytime.
One of the reasons we went Promaster. Surprising to me during my research how awful so many people said the MB is. That said, the PM isn't a Toyota, quite a few minor build defects and concerns over longevity.
Meh, just sell it once the extended warranty runs out.
In the UK pretty much all the big supermarket grocery delivery vans, Tesco, Asda, Sainsburys, Ocado, Morrisons, are Mercedes, with the odd Transit or Iveco here and there. Those are used sixteen hours a day, seven days a week, 362 days a year. So they must all be happy with reliability and service costs.
Our Ford has been undrivable ALL summer of ‘23 because of “no parts” to repair available! I think they are all going to AMAZON!!
I’ve had my Thor sprinter for 4 months now and been enjoying everything about it, no regrets. I’m glad we picked it over a transit build. At the end of the day you got to enjoy what you see in your driveway. Put a smile in my face that I own one.
Interesting mindset "image is everything "!
@@chrisdevalcourt648 I want German supermodel looks with a decent personality 🤣
YOU like it. That’s what matters at the end of the day, not other people’s random opinions.
As long as it stays in your driveway, I think you'll be fine.
What a great head to head compare. These are the two vans we are looking at. So really appreciate the time you took to prepare and produce this video. Great job.
I like how you're not trying to push one van manufacturer over the other. I agree on most of your points regarding looks, power, comfort, service. I have a Leisure Travel Van built on a Sprinter 3500 cutaway chassis. But if I were to choose a more nimble option for my camping adventures, I would seriously look at the transit myself.
Great video! After owning and traveling in Sprinters for several years, we bought and converted our first Transit. Yes, I agree the Sprinter is better looking but once you drive the Transit, looks start to matter less. The Transit is the “spork” of vans, not the winner of the beauty contest but it checks all the boxes when it comes to versatility.
I own a Ford Transit 350 and am very happy. service is easily available at our Ford dealership. I am 5'4" tall so height is no problem because the Sprinter is a few inches taller. Bed wise I can sleep across and there is plenty of room for my dog too. the kitchen and upfront shower are great and convenient. the van is easy to drive on all terrain and pickup speed is great I am happy to own the 350 Ford Transit dual axle camper van.
I think Transit looks way better than Sprinter. The only problem I have (living in Europe) is that I can only buy Ford with diesel engine, unless I get used, imported one from USA.
@Grzech I agree, the Ford does look better imo.
Did you convert your Transit to 4WD? If so, who did the job and how much did it cost?
@@joeblow1942 Quigley and another company (I forgot their name) make 4x4 conversions and they cost approx 20,000. Ford comes with factory AWD
I have a med roof med length transit 3.5 natural aspirated AWD 2021, gas miles low 16.2 to high 19 mpg, 10 speed transmission and lower powered motor than eco boost is slower going up hills but down shifts 2-3 gears depending on slope, 31 gal tank can go 500 mile without refueling, drivability is great, people watching from behind have mentioned how the transit hugs the curves with stock tires and is easy getting in and out. Also custom order allows front swivel seats, totally satisfied for my uses! Also with my avalanche grey color, I have a more custom feel than all those generic 4x4 Sprinters loaded to the kilt with roof racks, ladder, and rear door lockers because of overbuilt camper interiors, I have placed a generic pickup carpet kit from my 8’ bed pickup that allows full floor length hauling and when sleeping the carpet kit has full length bed and storage in both wheel well cabinets plus is totally removable leaving a full size cargo van floor footage, I’m very happy as this option verses Sprinter has saved me $50,000 and more over the camper build Sprinter.
A few of the Sprinter features you noted are now available in the Transit as of 2022- Keyless push button start and 360 degree cameras. The 22's also have a larger infotainment screen, though the downside of that is more of the controls are onscreen instead of easier to use buttons.
We've got a 2021 148" HR Transit we love, and chose it over the Sprinter for many of the same reasons you did.
Good to know - thank you
I once had a problem with a Ford campervan in the middle of nowhere, Arizona. A small garage in a tiny town fixed it up, no problem. I think the point about maintenance and repairs is an especially good point if you're planning on traveling to remote areas (eg, Utah, Arizona, etc) where finding a Mercedes repair shop could be really hard if not impossible.
Very detailed and honest comparison. I bought my 4x4 Sprinter in 2015 but for the more accessible maintenance, I would have preferred the Transit if they had the AWD option. There were two after market conversions to 4x4 but they were very expensive (approx 20,000$) and not very reliable. The Sprinter is very good, I prefer the diesel engine, I like the van, and never had a problem in 135,000 miles. Regular maintenance is actually easy done even by a non-professional like me and parts are not expensive ( labor at the dealership is) but every time when I drive in a remote area, far from home, I keep thinking what would I do if something malfunctioned in my van`s engine. I always carry tools and a diagnostic device, RUclips offers a lot of info, but I am not sure I would be able to fix something broken. My ideal van would be an AWD Transit with the diesel engine.
I have the sprinter. true 4x4. Thank you for really researching. I do a lot of overlanding and off roading. I have the struts and 4.3 van compass suspension. It was a must to make the vehicle drive well not just off road but on freeway driving. I found the 4x4 sprinter is unremarkable for off road beyond just groomed fire roads. Prior to my sprinter I had a F150 with same motor as your ford and loved the power. You are so right on that it is actually up to you. I do all my own service, but I am not going to lie. Mercedes has made it very difficult for one to do service by design, but with research and some mechanical skills it is not hard to do an A service or B service yourself. Thanks again for the video.
My father and I have a 2021 awd eco BEAST transit and could not be happier.
That was interesting, they both had some positive points going for them. The limiting service availability & power on the Sprinter were significant reasons to choose the Transit. Take care guys.
Thanks Bonnie - you as well
@@Weretherussos
No one is going rock crawling with these vans. Nor will they do serious off-roading in their camper van. These AWD/4x4 vans are meant for regular National Park dirt roads (light off-roading).
@@travelinman482 Excellent comment.
I would add that these vehicles are for work in the city and paved roads.
Likewise, the service availability (and power! I did not realize that the Sprinter put out < 200 hp!) in itself outweighs just about everything. Transit is the clear choice for me.
And Thanks Russos for this video! It definitely helped me decide which one to get (if and when I get one that is).
@@robertlee3778 all diesel engines have significantly less horse power than the gas engines because gas engines work at higher rotations per minute. It means that the cylinders rotate a lot but with less force. The torque is important and that is the force transmitted to the wheels. Ford is superior there as well, 400lbs/ft compared to 325.
Great comparisons. The vast network of Ford Dealerships throughout the country is a huge plus.
I own a long, tall 350 Transit with limited slip, AWD, and (OMG!) ecoboost. Keeping the speed between 60 and 65 the mileage stays between 14 and 16 mpg.
Having both I have the exact same feelings. I wish the transit interior was as polished as the sprinter. I do like driving the transit better and I think it’s more ‘car like’ on longer rides. Great video..
I have experience with the sprinter van working for Amazon but I would want the upgraded Ford Transit for all the reasons you said. Thinking ahead about services is really important and having more headroom is important for me. The sprinter is a fantastic van but it isn't worth the extra costs if you can't afford it or would rather use your money for other things.
Joe and Kait, my main reason for choosing the LT was after reading all of the MB horror stories on FB. People getting stranded for literally months without the use of the van, just scared me out of the MB. Good comparison of main points of each. Many thanks guys!
I bought a Mercedes diesel, and babied it from day one. Then, the transmission went out and cost a fortune. NEVER buy a Mercedes!
What year and model?
What Facebook groups you belong to to hear those stories?
One problem with comparing these two vans is they're both changing pretty quickly. For instance you point out the Transit doesn't have push button start, but it's now an option on the 2022s. The screen got bigger and it gained 360 cameras too. The Sprinter, otoh, is dropping that 4x4 system for AWD and a different engine. So all the aftermarket accessories will have to be redone, probably a max of 2 inch lift, but it will probably more readily available and easier to get serviced than the current 4x4. And maybe none of that matters anyway if you can't afford brand new and are comparing, say, 2020s. But in that case as you go back in the time the Transit loses features pretty quickly, as Ford has been aggressively updating it.
J
Ford parts cost half MB parts. Ford service is half also. The 3.5 EcoBoost V6 is in millions of Ford cars and is a proven reliable engine. The MB has lots of $$$ Problems. Lets be honest.
He's not comparing "changing" vans. Your mind is wrapped around a brand. He's comparing "these" vans - not the brands. He's clearly comparing utility and efficacy. What he has done makes sense. You are sharing an unrelated opinion that has no place logically, nor reasonably.
My husband has the ford truck with this exact engine. Hes been waiting ALL SUMMER for some transfer case part on theFord. All summer. They told him to drive but he’s risking destroying the engine. Luckily we have a GMC explorer high top family van & has been driving it instead. I used to love Ford. Not anymore. We live in the suburbs of Chicago. Hes called everywhere & NO one has the part! Ford has lost our loyalty
Really appreciate the honest comparison! Just wish Ram would offer a 4x4, especially with full time off-roaders in mind.
I've heard but never seen the European version of the ProMaster that has a 4wd system. Unfortunately you can't get it here.
@@Weretherussos in EUROPE ITS THE FIAT DUCATO,,NOW THAT, ITS ANOTHER EURO CO OWNS CHRYSLER, RAM, THERE FIAT DIESEL EINGINES HERE NOW !, 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
As a Professional Sprinter tech, just cannot even look to a Ford side. 😂 When you said that Ford is more comfortable than Sprinter - I was smiling 🙈☺️. Test drove many Ford’s - even though they are always chasing Sprinter Van - I don’t think they will ever be close. Ford is famous for cheapest, creepiest plastic, just awful seats, terrible seating position, idiotic design of battery location and much much more. I am not saying anything about drivetrain - ask one of your 3000 dealers about cost of transmission oil change on your beloved Ford. You will be surprised.
Newer Sprinter has some issues with electronics, but I am sure that MB will update it soon. Older Sprinter versions are very reliable, and long lasting. DEF can be fixed or upgraded. Most of the owners just neglect service on time. And then are very surprised why it fails. I’ve personally seen in my shop Sprinter with 899k miles, 495k miles etc.
Will your gasoline ford last that long? Very questionable. Unfortunately many stealerships across the country are just a bunch of crooks and idiots. And it makes service a nightmare.
But there are many dedicated independent Mercedes places that provide excellent service.
I personally would never ever choose Ford over Sprinter. And my advice to anyone who is in doubt - go with Sprinter, you will not regret!
Having driven a sprinter for the past 8 years (both the 4cyl and 6cyl diesels) my thoughts are this: The current gen Sprinter looks so much sexier than the current Transit both inside and out. But unfortunately the sprinter is just a maintenance nightmare and what some might now know so that not all Mercedes dealerships have a sprinter tech so that 400 dealer number is likely significantly less in terms of dealerships where you can have your sprinter worked on.The Transit is so much better in a lot of ways but I just can’t get over the looks of it. The sprinter is just so sexy but it comes with a LOT of baggage. In the end I think the Transit is objectively better but subjectively the sprinter looks 10x sexier. If you care about that kind of thing 😬
Don’t forget about the Stough 4x4
At the end of the day the sprinter is a high maintenance woman and we know no matter how good she looks in the end she's going to cost you the most and certainly won't be so sexy to you ....like my pappy use to say beauty is only skin deep but ugly if Plum to the Bone !!!
Sexy things usually come with baggage in my experience.
If you get stuck in the middle of the road, being sexy doesn’t really help….
@@ES-vt4zn if you’re wallet runs dry, the sexy thing will need a new home
Also consider the fact that the diesel sprinter will have all the EPA garbage problems that come along with all it's emissions systems. Your engine will literally be disabled and you won't be able to drive it if the computer detects a failure in any of the emissions components. Troubleshooting and repairing emissions can cost thousands of dollars.
Love that you used identical Storyteller builds for this comparison, it really brings the focus to the increasingly small differences between these two very capable platforms. Others have noted that the 2022 12" console in the Ford Transit has 360 camera view and feels very well integrated (with Fordpass, wifi and carplay). I'll be curious to revisit this in 2023 when Sprinter gets a new AWD system.
Love remote start and wi fi. Can also schedule starts for my Transit on the app.
+1 .. Torque is where its at. End of Story the Transit 3.5 V6 twin turbo w/10sp gearbox. .. Now, that said. . An ECU Chip tuned the MB 3.0 turbo diesel w/7sp gearbox and the engine output difference btw the Transit & Sprinter is less, much less. .. P.S., At present (MY2023) the USA MB Sprinter only offers a H.O. 4cly turbo diesel; Which surpasses the former 3.0 6cyl. turbo diesel.
Really interesting comparison. I went with a promaster because it was wider with squarer walls. It’s not a 4 wheel drive so I guess it’s not part of your comparison but I love it. And it gets 16-20 mpg.
I bought a Sprinter 4x4 because I need the clearance to get to my favorite backcountry campsites. Plus I have had numerous mechanical problems in the past with Ford vans.
Serviceability was my deciding factor in getting the Ford instead of the sprinter. I really wanted the sprinter but getting it worked on was going to be a pain because I live in a smaller town and to get it serviced I would have had to drive it over 2 hours away from me. With the Ford I could get oil changes and any major issues taken care of in my hometown.
A little late to the comments, but this was a great comparison. I have a sprinter 4x4 I built out myself. We would have bought a transit if we had been able to find one in 2021. Transit easier to drive and MUCH faster. But I am happy with my sprinter. Looks great, so well built. I appreciate the (supposed) longevity of the diesel engine. Biggest benefit is that it's much easier to get campervan upgrades for the sprinter. As a DIYer, that makes it so much easier. Not relevant if you're buying a storyteller or other upfitted one.
This is a pretty good comparision, but I will say you will always pay more for 4X4's and Diesel engines. One thing that was not discussed and is extremly important to me is longevity and resale value. The Sprinter wins here. Diesel engines will last twice as long as gas and get much better fuel economy. The only qualm I have with this video is I think the MPG was inaccurate. That might be due to driving styles but Sprinters ussually get 18-22 MPG. For instance in our Sprinter I get about 16-18 in city and 20-24 hwy.
Very true but the difference in resale value is easily off set with the cost of repairs and maintenance on the Sprinter. Also, the reason I compared these two particular vans was because they have the same components like roof rack, awning, larger aftermarket wheels/4x4, tires, etc. This all negatively affects gas mileage and hence why it’s lower than what you might see on another van.
@@Weretherussos Would have to disagree there. I’m not sure how the price of repairs would offset the resale value? Sprinters tend to break less and have more reliable parts. The repairs might be costly but I bet overtime they’re similar to how much and how frequent fords are repaired. Plus the engine is going to last 2 or 3 X as long vs a gasoline engine. If the ford and sprinter are getting similar mileage than there must be considerably more weight in the Sprinter. The MPG’s on a diesel vehicle should offset the price difference you pay at the pump and help offset some of the expenses like the more frequent oil changes that a diesel vehicle requires. I’ve owned Diesels most of my life and Mercedes’ diesels at that imo they make the best Diesel engines on the planet. In the short term the gasoline engine is probably cheaper but if you’re planning to keep your vehicle for more than 5, 10,15 years the diesel is going to cost you less in the long run and it’s going to resell for more.
Just found you and I'm very happy we did. Been fighting with myself over ford vs MB for about a year. I keep landing on the MB due to 4WD. We live in CO and 4WD is essential for winter mountain trips. Yet your comments about lack of climbing power and service options make me think I'm back to Ford. My father-in-law would never forgive me for buying a Ford but he hated foreign cars more! THANKS again!
We’ve heard the Ford AWD system in snow is really good
Great comparison video, those are small things that make a big deal.
I actually prefer the Transit after driving for Amazon, I hate the shifter & I don’t like push button starts. But you pointed out some things I didn’t notice
We have the sprinter with 40k miles on it always serviced at Mercedes at the proper time and the engine just blew, very disappointing only 40k. We have a good warranty and they said they would take care of it because our service history was excellent so no arguments from them. But still a diesel that goes bad at 40k. Im leaning on selling it as soon as it fixed and going with the transit van, its cheaper to service.
That happened to a friend of ours as well
Love the DRZ on the back on the Transit. A man of culture, I see. Cheers!
Whats strange that you find plenty Sprinter with high mileage still running but the Ford Diesels do not make more than 200.000km before the motor dies. At least it is the situation here in Germany. You find numerius of the Fords with dead engine or early replaced engines.
Regarding costs and maybe some extra stuff in the cabin, one can say any other van is better than a Mercedes. But when it comes to reliability of the 3.0 in the Sprinter, I could not say there is something that could top it.
Basically you need to know what the lady wants. Bring it to MB for any small problem is not a good idea to save money.
Excellent video! I was fixed on getting a Sprinter, after hearing all your comparisons, I think a Transit would be the smarter choice for my purposes, thanks!
You’re welcome!
Everything else aside, when you said you had your foot buried to the floor and it was losing speed going uphill, that's enough for me. I can't stand an underpowered vehicle, especially a "go-anywhere" vehicle that could accumulate things on your journeys. Great review.
Thanks for doing a great comparative video. As someone who loves German engineering, I gravitate toward the Sprinter, but in terms of practicality the Ford would be the logical choice. As you pointed out, Ford dealers are nearly everywhere. Safe travels!
This is one of the best comparison videos to date. Outstanding work!
Interesting video. Thank you.
We have the MB, very satisfied but here is what I dislike:
1) Too many electronic sensors make you totally at the mercy of MB for maintenance. You need the MB computer to fix many issues, even a 300$ OBD2 tester don't work.
2) Dealership are scarce. Here in Quebec, we had owners have their RV towed 800 km to a dealership, and the wait time for repair is 3 months. (Not a typo, 1-2-...3 months).
3) The dreaded 'you have 10 starts left. Inacceptable for anyone, especially for travelers. And there is no way to bypass, even in an emergency situation.
I still love ours, but because we boondock a lot in remote areas, the next RV will be on a Ford chassis.
Good summary - thank you for sharing that.
Thank You Russos for the great information, very helpful.
My pleasure!
We`ve had our 4x4 Sprinter for over a year now, and love it. Average around 16 MPG between freeway and city/trails. We did upgrade the suspension to a Van Compass 4.3 which helps a lot with off roading as well as freeway high winds. Only thing I don’t like is when stopping on an incline, the turbo has to spool up before it will move. Sometimes, I wonder if it will move at all even with my foot smashed on the accelerator. Never test drove the Transit, though wish I had. I did test the Ram, and really disliked it mostly due to lack of torque and stopping power. This was after owning 2 Ram pickups that I thought were great.
And I think the ram is front wheel drive only! Not good
for traction when building out a camper with all the weight
on the rear .
at work we have a 2wd 3500 dually, it gets over 25 mpg. yes it is a dog up hill
We have a ford truck with this same engine. Parts unavailable all summer of ‘23. Not drivable. We just bought a sprinter rv, our 2nd, and will hope its ok. Our 1st one, other than alignment was fine
@@user-3tf67bk46u i know it needs a few parts. Believe it or not, its a GASKET!! We would normally have just put something that fit but last year we put a few gaskets on our boat’s vacuum toilet system. And one failed right out of the Amazon box. They looked & felt identical. Both toilets needed this duckbill thing. We found one Dometic but had to order a 2nd non-dometic one from Amazon. a boat mechanic found us one and that was the issue. We couldn’t believe that it failed bit it did. We cannot take a chance with an “engine”
Transit engine and transmission is basically same as F150 Ecoboost, the most common vehicle in the US, so most parts not going to be an issue.
Interestingly Transit despite not having 2 speed transfer case has a lower 24:1 overall crawl ratio than Sprinter with low range 20:1, thanks to granny gear 9 speed auto. Transit also has an optional limited slip differential in the rear. The Sprinter has an open diff. The Sprinter also doesn't have a center diff lock. So off-road it traction is a problem Transit will usually come out on top. The Sprinter will get ahead on ground clearance.
When i sold my 2012 sprinter I thought i'd never buy a Ford or (gasp) Promaster. But after driving the Ford (with ecoboost) i was blown away. I purchased a 350 ext high roof and couldn't be happier. service and maintenance costs are so much easier. Everything is less expensive on the Ford and its so easy to work on it (adding super springs, sumo springs, lighting, etc...)
The one complaint i have with my ford transit is the quality of materials in the cabin. The plastic is cheap and feels like its from the 90's. Hard and rigid. But its a van and not a car/suv so i'm OK with that.
great video comparison
Thanks! Glad your enjoying your Transit!
This is very helpful. I've had an LT on order since last September, but given the long wait I finally bought a used Classic. I haven't canceled the LT order yet and was hoping to see comparisons like these. The power, or lack thereof, on the Sprinter makes me nuts. But, given the recent price increase on the LT and paying almost $15k in sales taxes and fees to register it after just going through that on the Sprinter, I'm not sure the power difference is worth tens of thousands of dollars.
We have a transit and ABSOLUTELY LOVE IT! We didn't do a traditional build - but we have a "base camp on wheels" and couldn't be happier!! ~Karen & Shannon WOY
Thanks for the review. My experience with MB is fewer dealers and much higher maintenance repair costs than Mazda, for example. I've owned both brands as well as Ford, Chrysler, Nissan, Kia. Now in the market for a camper van. Will take a serious look at Transit after this review.
I drove a fully loaded EcoBoost Transit from MA to Denver. Even going constantly uphill on the high plains, I was getting about 15mpg. And did get 17 on one stint.
This was great, my husband and I have teetered between gas and diesel and feel that the gas will serve us better as well. Head room, handling, power, looks like the transit is the best fit for us as well. Thanks for the great comparison
You’re welcome!
Here's another ding on the diesel fuel option. As if it wasn't stressful enough to find diesel on your travels, you can't get 5% sulfur everywhere as suggested by Mercedes for the fuel. So many stations only have a Biodiesel option. This means it will run a little dirtier and you'll have to get oil changes more frequently than the standard 20, 000 miles.
Thank you for taking the time to do this side by side comparison. Good job as always Joe and a thumbs up to the camera gal! I’m driving my third Ford with an ecoboost engine and they perform great through mountains.
Awesome! Thank you!
I chose a transit purely on the used market price, servicing and maintance costs. Buy used was less than half the price for a newer transit with lower milage, servicing and replacement parts are also much cheaper. First thing i upgraded i the transit was the drivers seat because it was a literal pain in my arse and lower back. Thanks for the review, safe travels andGod bless one and all.
My favorite is the Mercedes Sprinter, but I'm beginning to like what the Ford Transit has to offer!👍Thanks for sharing!🤗
You’re welcome
I have a 2020 AWD Transit 250 that I converted. I agree the MB looks nicer on the outside. I live in Tahoe and mostly use my van for skiing in the winter and music festivals in the summer. I haven't had any issues yet but it takes me about 3 weeks to schedule an oil change and rotation at the local dealer in Reno and the dealer sucks!! No way I would ever be treated like they do at a MB dealership!!
I ski over 100 days every year and having a van is a huge game changer no matter what van you have! I will say I'm blown away with the AWD on my Transit, it's a beast!! I've had Outback's and Highlanders in the past and the Transit is much better in the snow, hands down!!
My main reasons for getting the Transit over the Sprinter was price and I didn't want a diesel. Once Ford came out with AWD in 2020 I got one!! The thing I don't like about my Transit is no push button start, I have it on my Highlander and love it!! Safe travels no matter what you drive!! Aloha!!
The Ford all day long! One thing I can’t stand is driving an under powered vehicle! Driving from LA to the tip of Baja Mexico I go over numerous mountain passes and pass big rigs and slow moving vehicles regularly. Also, I’m 6’4” tall… I would need that extra head space! Seems like the choices are: Sprinter, sexy but under powered and higher maintenance. Transit, more reliable, powerful, and low maintenance.
After having two diesel-engine Sprinters, I would not touch another diesel vehicle in the US again, no matter who manufacturers it. Enough with the check engine light, dirty filter, failed sensors, limp mode, last-minute change of route just to find a MB van dealership. Towards the end of the ownership, I was almost trying to avoid using the vehicle because of that feeling of uncertainty.
Agreed - that's why I don't want to ever give up my 2000 Ford diesel.
Great info -The selectable 4×4 system, with low range, will no longer be available next year on the Mercedes-Benz Sprinter 2023 they are going to AWD. Different engines too.
The Transit is now available with a split screen 360 view camera system and push button start as well. If it is the same system that is in my F-150, it works very, very well.
Thank you for the video, you are a likeable host .
Currently driving a high roof Ram Promaster, I love this van had it new since 2019 , so much fun to drive, it's a hybrid of a work and camper van in Graphite Great .
I owned a new 2018 transit unfortunately it was a P.O.S. traded it for my 2019 Promaster
18 months ago I ordered a 2023 transit xlt hd awd high top. My reordered 2024 came in 3/7/2024. The 360° camera on the 10" display is a plus this year. What an awesome vehicle to drive.
Thanks for sharing
Great comparison! I am shopping now, and maybe as more of an update, Ford also offers a pushbutton start now and depending on what package you get for interior upgrade, you also can get a 360° view camera. By the way, I have no clue how those cameras work because they literally look to me like the cameras hovering over the middle of the van! For me, the entryway of the transit is some thing I would have to get used to because I am fairly tall, and I do have to duck down… I got to use one that had a handle installed on the pillar, and that actually helped, because when I grabbed it, I naturally went more forward into the van then up and into the van.
Thanks for the comps. How about comparing the Ram Promaster with either of these two?
Also, you didn't mention cost differentials: Just did a Costco price comp with the these two and the Ram: The Sprinter was the two wheel drive version and the Transit had the base engine. All were moderately "loaded" with extra alternators when available, RV option for the Ram and Sprinter: Results:
MSRP: Ford: $55,000. Ram: $58,220 Sprinter: $62,000.
I would also opt for the Transit. It's always in AWD, so no surprises when hitting an icy patch under acceleration. And at 6' 2" I definitely need the extra headroom. And today's diesels, with their regen and DEF systems, are unnecessarily complicated. The Ecoboost is also much better suited for towing and for driving in mountainous areas. I would not be doing any serious off roading, so the Sprinter two speed transfer case is not needed, and again, adds unnecessary complexity. Finally, as was pointed out, it's much easier to find a Ford dealership, as well as people who know how to work on them and also, parts availability is going to be much greater.
We bought a new Winnebago ERA Sprinter diesel in 2019. Kept it only 9 months. Broke down on highway on 2nd trip out and quoted repair cost was 12k not covered since they claimed we didn’t use clean diesel. Fortunately our RV insurance paid the repair bill but learned quickly that repairs would be a nightmare. Only certain dealers can repair and none in our major metro area could even do a front end alignment. Fear of what would happen in Utah or Wyoming caused us to rethink ownership. If I were to go back to class B it would be a Ford.
One of the main advantages of a Class B (van) over other form factors of RV's is the ability to easily fit into standard parking places. Urban parking spaces are nominally 20 feet long, but the 22 foot Ford Transits fits just fine. The 24 foot Sprinter is pushing it a bit. Adding a cargo box or bike rack on the back makes the difference even more critical.
Great honest comparison. I would go with the Mercedes.
Very good comparison vid. The best one I've seen so far. I personally would go with the transit.
Standard non eco boost V6 will get you 15 mpg and better reliability at the cost of power. Probably closer to the sprinter in power with better MPG and much lower cost. Lower height of a transit is also a huge plus for cargo vans.
Always such a great job reviewing and explaining different RVs - thanks Joe
I upgraded my 2020 4x4 sprinter with a rear diff air locker and Agile Offroad RIP kit. I also understand you can add aftermarket power module to increase power. That said, in 4 low with locker, I have no problem climbing steep off road grades. I'm not too concerned about highway power as there is plenty 99% of the time. Love our Sprinter and I could turn around and sell it for a hefty profit.
Will void warranty
I doubt it you will sell it for any profit after all the money you have put into it.. And how about calculating your hours of labor at $100 per hour min? Still profit?
Thank you for a great comparison. We've been torn between Mercedes b class vs Ford Coachman Beyond RB and this helps. The interior height is a biggie as my husband is 6'1", plus I've not found a Mercedes with a RB twin set up. We like this floorplan as it feels so much more open than others. Anyway, thank you. Love your videos.
As you may see from a prior comment, we owned two MB sprinter vans and now own a 2022 Coachmen Beyond 22C AWD Li3. We really love our Beyond. It may not have the room of the Sprinter LTV 2016 Unity, but it is so much more nimble to drive and park. The build quality is excellent. The Li3 is worth the money. You can get a better deal depending on shopping as price varies a lot from dealer to dealer.
@@bobshoe1 Thank you for commenting. It's appreciated.
I´m a Ford guy. We have the European Model called Nugget (much smaller) and we love it. Costwise and maintenance is much better than all of the Mercedes and VW vans. Maybe some day we´ll have this big guy, too :)
Nice comparison. I have a question. You mentioned that Mercedes has just under 400 dealerships nationwide. But not all dealerships are equipped to work on Sprinters so the 400 dealerships are the ones that can work on Sprinters or is the numbers of Mercedes dealerships for Sprinters far less?
You two produce really good and interesting content. Keep up the good work!
You’re correct and I don’t know how many of the 400ish work on Sprinters
True, I lived in Central California and had to drive to Southern California for Sprinter service. Often with the "check engine light on." UN-NERVING!
@@Weretherussos OMG join one of the many Sprinter groups and get the info on local dealers..MB or non MB in the know. This vid sounds like an info mercial for Ford. Happy trails!
Great review! Probably one of the best unbiased reviews. I recently purchased a Revel and am loving it. Like you had mentioned, selection is subjective. Right out of the dealer I went to Owl Vans and had a suspension kit and extended fuel tank installed. Definitely a must have. It’s new so no issues. I like the engineering behind the Sprinter, it’s a Mercedes, it’s different and very appealing!
I personally prefer the Ford Transit for many of the reasons you states. I am 5’1” and need the medium roof, plus it uses gas and is more economical for interstate driving, and can easily convert from city driving to camping mode with little effort AND I have a lot of places I can go if I have mechanical issues.
I also like the option to use the Ford Transit as a “mobile hotel” when space is tight at family gatherings, camping or vacations.
Since Chevrolet does not make a camper an model, it is no problem to switch to a Ford.
@@davidpatton7298David, vehicles DO NOT VOTE!
SOUTHERN GIRLS believe in simplicity and value for our money regardless of who you vote for!
KEEP IT SIMPLE SWEETIE 💋
Good vans don’t come cheap to buy or to upkeep, so we value quality over glitzy interiors and fancy technology.
We liked your comparison. I was fortunate to build our in 2019 so was able to get a Quigley 4x4 conversion which with bigger tires and aftermarket suspension is almost 4" higher than stock an IMHO is extremely capable off road and a better comparison to Sprinter 4x4. We have 32,000 miles of mostly off road adventures under its wheels and are extremely happy with our choice. The 3.5 EB motor is simply awesome off road. This is especially true at higher altitudes, or when crawling in 4 low and you need precision.
Does it have rack and pinion or a steering box?
Nice comparison. With all the things you said you liked better about Sprinter (appearance, higher stance, seats, suspension, b/u camera, push button start, MPG, etc) surprised you went with Transit. Most people are not going to want to pay thousands of extra $$$ to change out the seats and do expensive suspension upgrades to a brand new van. Other things to consider: The peak torque/HP verses RPM curve is important, you cannot just compare ft-lbs of torque between two engines without the associated RPMs. Mercedes 6-cyl diesel hits peak torque at only 1400 RPM while the Ford Ecoboost engine has to rev-up to a much higher 2500 RPM to deliver peak torque, nearly twice as high RPM as Sprinter and Ecoboost doesn't hit max HP until 5,000 RPM, which is the max value indicated on the Sprinter tachometer. I cannot imagine operating my Sprinter engine anywhere near 5000 RPM, most of the time it stays around 2500-3000 RPM while driving. This along with the gasoline vs diesel cycle efficiency difference means the Ford gas engine is working much harder and wearing out faster. Diesel engines are far superior for long road trips and last longer than gasoline engines, the reason why diesel is preferred in most OTR fleet vehicles. For city driving and lots of start-stops like an Amazon delivery van gasoline engines are the way to go. Love my '19 4x4 Sprinter, zero problems in almost three years and plenty of power. Just got back from CO at over 12k elevation and zero issues keeping 70 mph on hills. I can also go 20k miles between oil changes so all this talk of fewer places to get service is irrelevant to me, I just plan my service around my trips unless I am in my hometown, which has a great MB dealer.
Thanks for the insight
The transit has more torque and hp at any given rpm.
What a helpful video, thanks guys! I have a 2003 T1N Sprinter 158 wb Class B and driving her makes me so happy! So fun and pleasurable to drive. Her factory seats are also incredibly comfy which is really helpful for my bad back. But oh boy, service can really be a struggle! Since purchasing in 2019 I have put about 10k into repairs. As much as I am emotionally attached to her, I do think about selling pretty often. But with the cost of RV's being insanely expensive, I try and push away the idea of cost sunk fallacy and keep fixing her instead of actually selling and buying something newer and non-Mercedes. Bottom line, my RV is paid for so I'm keeping her for now.
All that being said, I would 100% NEVER but a newer Sprinter. As bad as my repairs have been (the worst being a 6k new transmission), the modern versions seem waaay worse. Either way, when I decide to let her go, my next RV will most likely be Ford or Ram.
That was the golden age for diesels. We have a 2000 Ford F-350 and it’s actually going up in value
Great video. Thanks. I was really surprised to see the Transit have more headroom then the Sprinter. From the outside it looks like the Sprinter would have more.
Thanks for watching!
I have a '14 Sprinter 3500 as a work vehicle. It weighs just under 5 tons, fully loaded. It has absolutely no problem on hills. In fact, it is much better than a Ford E350 I had previously, which bogged down on uphills.
Number one thing I would recommend is getting an extra 3 years on the warranty. We had several repairs in the first 5 years of ownership. We also got the emissions upgrade, which added several items to a renewed warranty.
Oil change is expensive but is half as often as a gasoline vehicle. Service B is over $1,000, but I do some of it myself to reduce costs. I am 6'-1" and can easily stand inside with clearence. Maybe this model is different. Also the drivers seat area is far roomier in a Sprinter.
I have heard good things from business owners with Transit vans, so it sounds like Ford worked hard to upgrade from the very dated econoline vans.
Great video! Seems like maintainability is my priority for cross country travel. The other stuff can probably be handled, like swapping out the seats, putting on a lift, etc.
Seems like a lot of people complain about service costs on the Sprinter. Oil changes are easy - the big thing is needing 12.5 qts. of oil, but you can buy it at Walmart. The DEF goes in about every 2k miles and takes about 5 minutes. Even the fuel filter change is easy although not inexpensive, but at every 20,000 miles it’s reasonable. Even the transmission maintenance is fairly easy. Do the maintenance right and the MB will take care of you.
You’re absolutely correct, however my point on the service is that if it’s that difficult to get an oil change then what happens when something serious happens?
Great video. I just got rid of my 2016 sprinter. Had nothing but problems with it since day one. Looking into a ford now. Just wondering about those twin turbos now. Not a big fan of turbo engines. Can these turbo engines be trusted? Thanks.
The 3.5L twin turbo has been around for over 10 years and has been well proven from what I've read.
@@Weretherussos
Including the turbos??
I love everything about the sprinter except the power and the upkeep challenges. Thanks so much for the comparison.
The only down side that I've heard of with AWD, is if you loose a tire at 50 percent of it's wear, you have to replace all of them.
You could do tire rotations with your 5 tires by using a full size spare. Then, if it does happen, just replace the spare. AWD is nice.
Perfect timing,I’m looking for a short wheel base van to use as a daily driver and be able to pick up and go at will.
My interest is a used Roadtrek agile but this review is heaven sent.Off road is not important to me.
Great comparison. My friends all choose the Transit over the Sprinter. I love my Sprinter and I’d probably love the Transit, too, for different reasons. But, the clearance on my Sprinter 4x4 has been essential for boondocking and exploring national forest land. I’ve gone over some very unkempt, gnarly terrain and anything with a lower clearance wouldn’t have cleared the rocks and ruts. And, the van is pretty 🤣. Ps I wanted diesel hoping that this thing will keep running for a very long time. I use it as my RV and my daily driver. I’m fortunate to have a local Mercedes dealer who gets me in within a day for service. That’s unheard of in most parts of the country and I could see how not having that type of access to a dealer would be tough.
At the end of the day, we’re out there in our vans, whatever make/model they are, and we’re living life, making memories.
Agreed. Sprinters rock, and the additional ground clearance is excellent.
You, sir, are a steely-eyed review guru. Thanks for the no BS, all-useful, objectively controlled, no superfluous content video!
I appreciate that!
For our lifestyle, the Revel fits us best. I think it’s wonderful that there are options to suit everyone! Congratulations on your storyteller!
Agreed!