I would say anything in space is multigenerational, due to only a rocket ships small payloads. In science we have cancer research and nuclear fusion which we haven’t figured out. And large projects like Golden gate, Hoover Dam and even cathedrals that are in constant replacement due to aging.
@@musicguy20 Space for sure. Thats surely an outlier? Most people aren't working on a space station. Bridges etc make sense, although building something from the ground up where you never see it finished is mentally different to maintaining something thats already there-at least in the way I was thinking about it
I always learn something interesting from your videos but this one struck a chord in me because of my recent infatuation with cultural hubs and mega projects. Well done!
I am losing my hopes on humanity reading this comment section. People praising the Ai slop and people saying it's expensive to make videos with actual photos. Please stop using Ai generated images it ruins everything I liked about this channel and tbh I'm beginning to think everything is Ai in this channel
@ It is,reading the second one now that’s good too.i love a medieval yarn and I’m a brick/stone layer so I found it fascinating(love going to cathedrals and castles and taking in the workmanship from so long ago)
I actually know that first painting of the triumphant king on a white horse, and he is actually looking with dread at an icon of Jesus with the crown of thorns, its haunting and I love it.
Can you stop using AI images for things that we have imagery for, like what is the need for AI generated miedival paintings when we have plenty of those in existance? Just showcases lazy video making.
Y'll Think backwards. Everyone should avoid copyrights and use original images. He'd have to go out there and take pictures himself and halla make 1 video per year.
You forgot prague new town, wich was biggest mega project in medieval Europe. "Charles IV ... conceived here the largest urban planning project of the Middle Ages, and at the time, its equal could not be found in Europe. the mid fourteenth century in Europe there was no other city, in which an enclosed building project was organized and executed on such a scale, over two square kilometers. There is no other city, in which 18 to 27 meter-wide roads were created; where an arterial road was wide three-quarters of a kilometer long and over 60 meters wide and in the New Town alone was the central marketplace larger than most entire cities of this time including its walls." Prague New town Wikipedia section 'Importance'
Angkor in Cambodia is also very impressive; it covered an area that was comparable in size to New York's 5 boroughs combined, it was the largest pre-industrial city on Earth. They also constructed Angkor Wat, which is the largest religious monument on the planet. And lastly, their water management system was very complex. I'm also very impressed by the Grand Canal in China.
Great show, that I am becoming used to seeing and growing to expect! As a vocal note: I think I know who you are learning presentation voice over from. Whether that is true isn't the matter; it's a coincidence that a V/O artist can get into. Unless their is a gun real or not, pointing to your head, read your copy leasurally--otherwise it becomes "pushed," as in "Move along, we've got more to see." You know the copy so well it is easy to do so. Your audience has not had the sort of prep work you have had--they need to think about what they see, and most importantly, what you share. As you talk about lengths and distances in meters, consider adding the distance in meters=XX miles, without trying to jam all the words into the audio. Same issue we spoke of just a moment ago. Irrelevant information to a listener becomes noise. Panning shots and various distances from the buildings or structures might give things a literal visual to apply distances to. Lotsa good information and in ways that makes contemplation something to linger on. Do you have a music track on your productions? I'm between sets of hearing aids. 😊 Floating in and out of these contemplative thoughts that you present visually music, the elements, such as the seasons of the months that the topic you present are. Even wind chimes, background voice mumblings might add a professional's touch. Forgive me if these suggestions annoy or are not thought of as helpful. My once lovely PC is a smoking ruin and I am going nuts with nothing to do but harass creators that are at least getting their work available to show.😒 Feel free to harrass me back after I figure out how to build this wheel-thing everyone has been talking about~
Some things from India 700c-1500ce to add: The irrigation network and urban planning of Vijayanagara, the Konark Sun, Temple, the Somnath and Rudra Mahalaya Temples, the Round city of Anahilapataka, the University of Somapura Mahavihara, the Khumbhalgarh Fort Wall, the Gangaikonda Cholapuram Reservoir, the Brihadeeshwara Temple, the Bhojeshwara Temple, the Rani Ki Vav Stepwell, the Swayambhu Temple of Warangal, the Chola Dams, the Kailasa Temple and the Ellora Caves, the Cyclopean Bhojpur Dam and the Bhojtal Lake, the Kashi Vishwanath Temple, the Multan Sun Temple, the Irrigation networks of Champaner and Mandavgarh, the Sahasralinga Talav, the Hoysaleshwara Temple, the Tungabhadra Dam, the Udaisagar Lake, the Muddak Maur Dam, Varanasi Bridge, Veeram Lake, Tiruvannamalai Rajagopuram etc
Those windmills and polders weren’t a creation of the “Dutch” but from their southern neighbours in Belgium and Northern France, the first dutch ones were only created around 200 years later compared to the ones in Flanders.
Yo man I absolutely never comment on video's but you seem like a good channel, enjoyed the video but get rid of those sporadic ai pics they really disturb the video
1:45 with all of the Dutch master artists and how ubiquitous windmills are in their paintings, you really chose to use an AI image and not even a good one? Heck one of the most popular paintings in Washington DC's National Gallery of Art is "The Mill" by Rembrandt. A painting of a lone windmill on a hill!! Trying to make sense of what the AI was doing with all of those ladders will make you dizzy lol
But those mills and polders weren’t even a creation of the Dutch but from the Flemish, Well offcourse the same is also true of the early Dutch masters that were the Flemish Primitives. Crazy how the Netherlands can take all the credit from their neighbours history and they seem not even make a problem of it.
@ The modern country of the Netherlands was unexisting and the name was nothing more than a reference to the region made of seperate autonome provinces controlled by foreign empires or a personal union of nobility with the power & importance centered in the southern lands. The Dutch identity was unexisting before the split and simply grouped as Flamingi, after that Dutch a synonym for Germans was used in reference. The shift to Amsterdam with also the Golden age only started because of the willingness to accept the wealthy immigrants fleeing Catholic persecution, the other regions of the modern Dutch country weren’t given this privilege. The Flamingi traders of the Low Countries had been working for the Portuguese exploring & colonizing new lands relocated their operation to protect their business, Amsterdam became an international center for trade, the majority population of Amsterdam being foreign wealthy families also gave their culture of inovation, knowledge of science and entrepreneurship to the Dutch lands for at least a century until this dominant position changed again from outbreaking wars. Flemish today seem to allways be mad against their French speaking citizens while maybe if The Netherlands stopped claiming their history as their own and they Flamignant could stop playing the angry victim, also having so much pride based on others history is a bad look
Say would you mind doing a video about the island of Rhodes in medieval times? I know a group of knights ruled Rhodes and they clashed with the Ottoman Turks but that’s about it.
6:48 - You don't want to take a close look at this painting. First you notice mutant hands. Then mutant faces. Then an attempt to just NOT show hands. Too funny. Whether painting or AI, they still had trouble with hands.
At least half of the real pictures in this video are centuries older/younger or kind of out of context. I know it is hard to find good and fitting pictures, but I would really prefer the more accurate way. Also, don't mix medieval and modern times (for example, the coffee fact, ...). Thank you for the expense.
@@owlthepirate5997 sorry, I forgot to reply. More of a smell than a taste. Kinda like the scent of unfinished particle board in a humid environment. A good scent in my opinion. Or maybe I just had a small seizure. either way take care!
Baroque Churches were not built in the Middle Ages, there are hundreds of images to illustrate this talk , why include anachronistic ones which do not give credibility to your presentation?
yes, there is a Herehuis or Gentlemans manor in Amsterdam from somewhere in the 16oo's which has a gablestone with the owner, a black merchant. So it seems they even had trading companies that must have been quite succesfull, at least for the example above.
@@Burzy109one of Henry VIII’s trumpeters was Black, man by the name of John Blanke, look it up. People travelled plenty back then, black skinned people definitely went to Europe just as white skinned people went to Africa. Being ignorant of history is one thing, demanding other people remain so is quite another.
Look at the image at 11:28 of this video and others. If you think for a second that "...these architectural wonders were built with only the resources and manpower available in the Middle Ages." then you genuinely must be high. There's not a chance that these masterpieces were built in the ways that we are being told, sorry.
Those AI images of the Great Wall of China were kinda crazy. I love the videos from this channel overall, but really hate AI-generated images.
Until you can't tell anymore 😂
Yup the quality has gotten sloppy
The AI take on walls of China hit me like a cannonball
use refences, not AI art plz
@gahmuretvanbegonia994 copyrights bro, cant keep on using people stuff and expect monetization. So bear with it.
@@OpenMindAi-r3t And pray tell what was used to TRAIN said AI?
Could it be photos and drawings?? You have AI in your name too, so shush.
@@OpenMindAi-r3tnope. There are tons of copyright free stock images available
@@OpenMindAi-r3tmoney over us 😢😿😿
@serpavr2820 Each and every, has to dine. we all have to eat.
A 6 year old could make crayon drawings that would look 100 times better than AI generated slop
Thanks for NOT depicting medieval people as backward and stupid. ❤
building something you know you won’t see finished is wild. there are not many people who are approaching tasks like that today
GRR Martin is though ;)
That will never be the case these days. Modern tools are so efficient.
Generational was very common in history.
I would say anything in space is multigenerational, due to only a rocket ships small payloads. In science we have cancer research and nuclear fusion which we haven’t figured out. And large projects like Golden gate, Hoover Dam and even cathedrals that are in constant replacement due to aging.
@@musicguy20 Space for sure. Thats surely an outlier? Most people aren't working on a space station. Bridges etc make sense, although building something from the ground up where you never see it finished is mentally different to maintaining something thats already there-at least in the way I was thinking about it
Please stop using AI generated content, it sticks out like three sore thumbs.
One of them pointing backwards.
It is better so. Sometimes Ai gets creative and gives more.
Are you a bot or why would you say something so profoundly stupid
It can be very useful though
@@OpenMindAi-r3t It's absolutely worse. What a bad comment.
I always learn something interesting from your videos but this one struck a chord in me because of my recent infatuation with cultural hubs and mega projects. Well done!
The thing I like about medieval architecture is that they built things to last, whereas now we don't, we build for profit
Its called survivorship bias.
Cologne cathedral was only completed in 1880, after an over 300 year halt in its construction.
I love this subject! I love MedievalMadness!
I am losing my hopes on humanity reading this comment section. People praising the Ai slop and people saying it's expensive to make videos with actual photos.
Please stop using Ai generated images it ruins everything I liked about this channel and tbh I'm beginning to think everything is Ai in this channel
For my tastes, medieval buildings make a great topic for content
Watching pillars of the earth, this video is spot on.
Just read it👍
@drewtatt6487 I will get the book, must be great
@
It is,reading the second one now that’s good too.i love a medieval yarn and I’m a brick/stone layer so I found it fascinating(love going to cathedrals and castles and taking in the workmanship from so long ago)
I actually know that first painting of the triumphant king on a white horse, and he is actually looking with dread at an icon of Jesus with the crown of thorns, its haunting and I love it.
Can you stop using AI images for things that we have imagery for, like what is the need for AI generated miedival paintings when we have plenty of those in existance? Just showcases lazy video making.
Y'll Think backwards. Everyone should avoid copyrights and use original images. He'd have to go out there and take pictures himself and halla make 1 video per year.
Or how ridiculous and expensive it is to make videos with pictures
You forgot prague new town, wich was biggest mega project in medieval Europe.
"Charles IV ... conceived here the largest urban planning project of the Middle Ages, and at the time, its equal could not be found in Europe. the mid fourteenth century in Europe there was no other city, in which an enclosed building project was organized and executed on such a scale, over two square kilometers. There is no other city, in which 18 to 27 meter-wide roads were created; where an arterial road was wide three-quarters of a kilometer long and over 60 meters wide and in the New Town alone was the central marketplace larger than most entire cities of this time including its walls."
Prague New town Wikipedia section 'Importance'
"How did they build such grand churches with limited manpower and technology?" Dragons, of course.
Aliens maybe.
@@jackesioto Alien dragons.
@@eriknelson2833 King Ghidorah of course
Angkor in Cambodia is also very impressive; it covered an area that was comparable in size to New York's 5 boroughs combined, it was the largest pre-industrial city on Earth. They also constructed Angkor Wat, which is the largest religious monument on the planet. And lastly, their water management system was very complex.
I'm also very impressed by the Grand Canal in China.
I have fallen in love with this channel.
This was fab. Thanks
Your AI content has killed my joy i will not be watching you anymore. Authenticity is no longer here.
Bye 👋🏻
I support you, we lose the human touch because of AI
ITALY: *Builds 50km ditch*
CHINA: «Hold my tofu.»
*Builds 21.000km of wall made of brick and mortar over all kinds of treacherous terrain*
China: commits endless genocides and kills millions of people
Italy: discovers the new world
Great show, that I am becoming used to seeing and growing to expect! As a vocal note: I think I know who you are learning presentation voice over from. Whether that is true isn't the matter; it's a coincidence that a V/O artist can get into. Unless their is a gun real or not, pointing to your head, read your copy leasurally--otherwise it becomes "pushed," as in "Move along, we've got more to see." You know the copy so well it is easy to do so. Your audience has not had the sort of prep work you have had--they need to think about what they see, and most importantly, what you share. As you talk about lengths and distances in meters, consider adding the distance in meters=XX miles, without trying to jam all the words into the audio. Same issue we spoke of just a moment ago. Irrelevant information to a listener becomes noise. Panning shots and various distances from the buildings or structures might give things a literal visual to apply distances to.
Lotsa good information and in ways that makes contemplation something to linger on.
Do you have a music track on your productions? I'm between sets of hearing aids. 😊 Floating in and out of these contemplative thoughts that you present visually music, the elements, such as the seasons of the months that the topic you present are. Even wind chimes, background voice mumblings might add a professional's touch.
Forgive me if these suggestions annoy or are not thought of as helpful. My once lovely PC is a smoking ruin and I am going nuts with nothing to do but harass creators that are at least getting their work available to show.😒 Feel free to harrass me back after I figure out how to build this wheel-thing everyone has been talking about~
Let the madness commence ⚔🏰
Some things from India 700c-1500ce to add: The irrigation network and urban planning of Vijayanagara, the Konark Sun, Temple, the Somnath and Rudra Mahalaya Temples, the Round city of Anahilapataka, the University of Somapura Mahavihara, the Khumbhalgarh Fort Wall, the Gangaikonda Cholapuram Reservoir, the Brihadeeshwara Temple, the Bhojeshwara Temple, the Rani Ki Vav Stepwell, the Swayambhu Temple of Warangal, the Chola Dams, the Kailasa Temple and the Ellora Caves, the Cyclopean Bhojpur Dam and the Bhojtal Lake, the Kashi Vishwanath Temple, the Multan Sun Temple, the Irrigation networks of Champaner and Mandavgarh, the Sahasralinga Talav, the Hoysaleshwara Temple, the Tungabhadra Dam, the Udaisagar Lake, the Muddak Maur Dam, Varanasi Bridge, Veeram Lake, Tiruvannamalai Rajagopuram etc
great piece, MM
I love your videos!
These AI images need this whole video taken down
you should do a video of living with epilepsy in the middle ages!!
I dont mind ai. Keep on, keeping on. Maybe copyright pictures will chill now that ai is used.
I was enjoying the video, but then I saw the AI images, nope, not watching slop sorry.
the AI images look bad
When did he ever use one???
@@guglielmo7191 So you didn't look at the thumbnail pic, huh? Or half of the video?
Those windmills and polders weren’t a creation of the “Dutch” but from their southern neighbours in Belgium and Northern France, the first dutch ones were only created around 200 years later compared to the ones in Flanders.
I think I’ve learned so much from your channel, but the ai stuff has me worried that some of it was just randomly generated nonsense.
Yo man I absolutely never comment on video's but you seem like a good channel, enjoyed the video but get rid of those sporadic ai pics they really disturb the video
I feel like the Dutch turning a sea into a country should be higher on the list.
Its literally the first one
Adding another voice to the *please don’t use AI* chorus. This channel is better than that! I’ll def be unfollowing if you keep using AI
These could all be their own video. I'd not hold it against you. ❤💯
Cool video, but please stop using that AI crap.
1:45 with all of the Dutch master artists and how ubiquitous windmills are in their paintings, you really chose to use an AI image and not even a good one?
Heck one of the most popular paintings in Washington DC's National Gallery of Art is "The Mill" by Rembrandt. A painting of a lone windmill on a hill!!
Trying to make sense of what the AI was doing with all of those ladders will make you dizzy lol
Maar dat is niet van de middeleeuwen
But those mills and polders weren’t even a creation of the Dutch but from the Flemish, Well offcourse the same is also true of the early Dutch masters that were the Flemish Primitives. Crazy how the Netherlands can take all the credit from their neighbours history and they seem not even make a problem of it.
@ crazy bro
@@inigo9000 because flanders was just a part of the Netherlands until 1848
@ The modern country of the Netherlands was unexisting and the name was nothing more than a reference to the region made of seperate autonome provinces controlled by foreign empires or a personal union of nobility with the power & importance centered in the southern lands. The Dutch identity was unexisting before the split and simply grouped as Flamingi, after that Dutch a synonym for Germans was used in reference. The shift to Amsterdam with also the Golden age only started because of the willingness to accept the wealthy immigrants fleeing Catholic persecution, the other regions of the modern Dutch country weren’t given this privilege. The Flamingi traders of the Low Countries had been working for the Portuguese exploring & colonizing new lands relocated their operation to protect their business, Amsterdam became an international center for trade, the majority population of Amsterdam being foreign wealthy families also gave their culture of inovation, knowledge of science and entrepreneurship to the Dutch lands for at least a century until this dominant position changed again from outbreaking wars. Flemish today seem to allways be mad against their French speaking citizens while maybe if The Netherlands stopped claiming their history as their own and they Flamignant could stop playing the angry victim, also having so much pride based on others history is a bad look
Good stuff
So.... not the Tartarians then 😂 we need to give our ancestors more credit!
How many of you can’t ignore how Baghdad looks very much like Atlantis was supposed to look?
Baghdad does look Atlantisn
Say would you mind doing a video about the island of Rhodes in medieval times? I know a group of knights ruled Rhodes and they clashed with the Ottoman Turks but that’s about it.
7:55 - there is no river named Vlatva. The River floating through Prague is called Vltava (pronounced as ˈvʊltəvə, ˈvʌl-/ VU(U)L-tə-və).
The Great Wall is one of the most photographed places on Earth.. it makes everything else in the video feel unreliable
No AI images, please
Great content but please consider using real art instead of AI art; AI stuff is disturbing
i would strongly suggest refraining from the use of AI in historic documentary videos... cant in good conscience leave a like on the video for that
6:48 - You don't want to take a close look at this painting. First you notice mutant hands. Then mutant faces. Then an attempt to just NOT show hands. Too funny. Whether painting or AI, they still had trouble with hands.
How did they move all that dirt?
Dutch mentioned: gekoloniseerd?!
stop with the AI crap
Clicked on the video cuz I was interested, immediately closed it once I saw all the comments about AI art, smh do better bro use real art not ai slop
At least half of the real pictures in this video are centuries older/younger or kind of out of context. I know it is hard to find good and fitting pictures, but I would really prefer the more accurate way. Also, don't mix medieval and modern times (for example, the coffee fact, ...). Thank you for the expense.
I don't mind about the AI images. But please look up how to pronounce Italian names. 'gl' is spoken as 'lee' not 'glee'.
5:14 AOT?
Ai photos fine. Please slow down your narration, like you used to ...its like you're speed reading 😢😢😢
Not enjoyable any more.
Nope, had to work, just like today.
Dont use AI it looks awful
Ai generated content? Dude, I used to like this channel. What a loser of a content producer...
I would rather see the same stock image or a blank screen than those jarring awful ai images. Love the show though!
I can almost taste your thoughts.
That's what sh...you said ,that's what you said .🙄
And what do they taste like?
Get out more 👍
😂
@@owlthepirate5997 sorry, I forgot to reply. More of a smell than a taste. Kinda like the scent of unfinished particle board in a humid environment. A good scent in my opinion. Or maybe I just had a small seizure. either way take care!
Baroque Churches were not built in the Middle Ages, there are hundreds of images to illustrate this talk , why include anachronistic ones which do not give credibility to your presentation?
AI :/
Is there any information on Black people in Europe during the medieval times and whether or not they lived there?
yes, there is a Herehuis or Gentlemans manor in Amsterdam from somewhere in the 16oo's which has a gablestone with the owner, a black merchant. So it seems they even had trading companies that must have been quite succesfull, at least for the example above.
I'd be interested in this too.
No. Accept your own history.
I'd be interested in that.
@@Burzy109one of Henry VIII’s trumpeters was Black, man by the name of John Blanke, look it up. People travelled plenty back then, black skinned people definitely went to Europe just as white skinned people went to Africa. Being ignorant of history is one thing, demanding other people remain so is quite another.
Garbage AI bullshit
Nothing like a bit of slave labour to achieve greatness.
Though most medieval marvels weren't built by slaves
Stop with the AI images. It's lazy.
4:17 AI generated bullshit
Gonna be disliking each one of your videos as soon as I spot AI until you stop using it
Lol
Look at the image at 11:28 of this video and others. If you think for a second that "...these architectural wonders were built with only the resources and manpower available in the Middle Ages." then you genuinely must be high. There's not a chance that these masterpieces were built in the ways that we are being told, sorry.
11:28 is exactly the time related to the Giants of Calabria! This cannot be a coincidence!
@martijnkeisers5900 don't forget the lizard people and crabcats!
@@owlthepirate5997 Almost did! Thank you 😃😅
you are insulting human genius and culture
I'm actually honoring it by not misrepresenting it.
Wow I’m early
Gay
So sick of the "stop using AI crap". If you want to watch the video put up with it. It's not your video to demand how it's presented.
Keep using AI 👍 its only going to keep getting better. To many art snobs in this comment sectoin.
Keep using AI generated content man I could barely tell and it works great
Baghdad…city of peace, HAHAHAHA
more ! ! !
the ai is a literal eyesore 😢