Canister Topped Stoves Performance in the Wind by Flat Cat Gear
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 29 окт 2024
- www.flatcatgea...
/ flatcatgear1
#flatcatgear
You can tell a lot about a stove's efficiency just by looking at the flame pattern. Here we tested 9 different canister topped stoves in a Wind Tunnel at 0 / 4 / 8 mph. When the wind starts to pick up, you can really tell the differences between each stove. We test the following stoves:
BRS 3000T
Fire Maple 300t
Fire Maple Hornet II
Etekcity
Snow Peak LiteMax / Kovea SupaLite
Soto Amicus
Soto WindMaster 4 Flex
Pocket Rocket 2
Pocket Rocket Deluxe
amazing video
Great demonstration
I wonder if the Fire Maple was built specifically for the G3 Petrel pot so that the legs fit into the grooves, reducing distance between burner and pot.
I absolutely believe this to be true
I'd love to see an update of this with the original MSR PocketRocket added. I still have one, and it's my backup, now, but it would be interesting to see how it performs in a similar test.
It should be somewhere between the Fire Maple Hornet II and the Pocket Rocket 2: not great in teh wind. That's why we make windscreens for them.
Windscreen, Windscreen, windscreen!!!!! ☝️
Agreed, agreed, agreed!
I've always wondered why anyone would bother with the SOTO Windmaster, considering the awful pot support design (which is why I chose the Amicus, instead), and now I understand why. Its support to pot distance is much, much lower than even the Amicus.
Excatly! The Amicus is a great stove. the WindMaster is just better.
That tiny glowing red leg of the BRS3000 makes me wonder if it’s possible get it hot enough to bend under the weight of a full pot
Possible. But they are not the only ones who can get teh pot support arms red hot.
I have heard anecdotal evidence that this is something that actually happens with the BRS3000T.
The pocket rocket 2 is a weird middle ground stove.
It’s not as compact as a BRS3000, but more compact than the pocket rocket delux, and it’s about the same with wind as the BRS3000, so what’s the point of it?
At that price point, the Soto Amicus is probably a better choice. Just my opinion.
So it looks like, in my very amateur opinion, the closer the burner is to the pot, the more efficient the burner can perform in higher winds. Which makes sense with stoves like the MSR Windburner, which has a close burner with an intergrated windscreen system on how well it works. I know its not a stove that would be featured in a Flat Cat Gear video, but a very well performing stove nevertheless.
Well, the MSR WindBurner is the Gold Standard for fuel efficiency and robustness in the wind.