Phala Phala Debate | MPs vote on the Section 89 panel report
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 27 авг 2024
- Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs, Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma, has voted in favour of the establishment of an impeachment committee. Voting in the National Assembly was done manually after MPs debated whether to adopt the Section 89 panel report, which found that President Cyril Ramaphosa may have a case to answer after the foreign currency was stolen from his Phala Phala farm two years ago. Dlamini-Zuma broke ranks and ignored party voting instructions. She was followed by Supra Mahumapelo, Mervyn Dirks and Mosebenzi Zwane, while Minister Lindiwe Sisulu left the chamber during the voting time and hence did not vote. Tandi Mahambehlala changed her vote to No, saying her first vote was incorrectly captured.
For more news, visit sabcnews.com and also #SABCNews on all Social Media platforms.
May South Africans take note of all those who said "NO".
What difference will that make? You don’t vote for the individuals but the party and it’s for the party to add or remove them from the party list. You have no visibility or influence on that.
@@khaltsharivist365 Technically, it does make a difference... It's almost exclusively the entire ANC cabinet that voted "NO"
People are voting for their stomach not for the interest of the people of RSA. Our prayer is let every concealed corruption deeds be exposed.
Ppl of ANC are evil u hv to be ashamed of urslf
This guy is Confident 😂😂😂Got my vote juju
ANC ministers 😂😂😂..speaking for their stomachs 😏😏
Always
True
It's a shame
It shows on them.
😂 Speaker saying that you don't get intimidated easily doesn't assure that you are not intimidated
Maybe that is why the dollars were kept in a sofa , for emergencies like this …
What in the old age home is going on in the anc
In 2024 all South Africans should vote NO for the ANC and let them feel what we are feeling with their NO vote.
U vote no for the ANC, don't tell South Africans how to vote
Who are you telling us what we should do and who do you think you are..
@@raimantsiea8581foolish citizens who always votes corrupt individuals.Poor South Africa
Do they ever think of the God's commandments.
1. Thou shall not steal
2.Thou shall not lie
3.Thou shall not kill.
4.Love your brother as you love yourself.
Zuma. Thou shall.not steal. Eskom is sinking today. Zuma stole from us and Phala phala sold his own cows and they stole from him. Yayvi nto. Zuma a fat thief. Ntloko yet yetapile
Come voting time i vote No for anc
We as South Africans, would like the governing party to fulfilled their decades promises . We are sick and tired of deceiving by them just like previous decades.
Vote for another party. That's how it works - they promised, you voted, they failed you, you fire them. Or is there something wrong with your brain?
Its easy dont vote for the ANC
Until you vote, you'll realize apartheid it's possible again and until you vote you'll realize to be like Zimbabwe it's possible.
Whistle blowers and those who stand against criminals and corruption are at risk
They have broken Gunnies record on that
Why would a speaker decide how should elected members of parliament should cast their votes mostly on a very serious matter such as this?
It's just a joke parliament. I see foolishness
To take advantage of winning
Because parliament gave her those powers.
If you have something to hide you would want a secret vote. If you don't have anything to hide you won't have a problem with the speaker deciding on how to vote public or secret.🗳
Mxm
ANC is full adult that's why never progress
Corruption is a disease 🦠
Julius will tell you straight
all the crooks are protecting the bigger crook
This ANC members are just protecting their jobs
I think that there must be a demand for the fulfilment of the constitution. People are acting on the fear and selfishness. The country (the full population) must be taken into consideration and not some childish desires (acting in the innocence fellings). A president of a real country can never do what Ciril Sir did.... 👀👀
DID url see how Sisulu ran away left NDZ hanging 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Mamu Zuma was not hanging dont be stupid the woman is rich in mind
That stupid ran away and left the other old stupid Mamu Zuma. She was.like a tortoise when it was done for Zuma. Stupid old Mama Zuma
These corrupt politicians
Can we call this a "' FAILED STATE"' yet ? US the people , the TAX PAYERS , the PEOPLE who are meant to be represented by these ppl , feel FAILED !!!!!!!!!!!! BY THE STATE !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
If you want to see how cruel leaders of political parties are, let any member of EFF vote against the desire of its leader let alone clap hands for the ANC. Did he expel a member for accepting condolences money?
They won't vote against the desire of their leader because all members of the eff share the same vision
You telling the truth
@@sauljunior6510 no they don't, they don't.
Spot on 🎯
We got the whole payroll for ANC with the “NO”! 😂😂😂
Guys these ANC people are gun pointed by an invisible Gun on their heads!! I really feel for them
Do you know Julius will fight for them until secret ballot and will win u will c, were doing this to Zuma but after secret won.
Invisible gun for real
Waar was Lindiwe Sisulu Zuma,sy het Nkosazana DZ allenige gelos.
Circus voting
Dlamini Zuma She brave and proven integrity even in the dark clouds….
For the fact that is the only one stood against all odds and differ that is amazing
But you must also remember that she supported her ex-husband when parliament voted on the Nkandla saga, do you also call that bravery
Does two wrongs make right?, If you were once wrong, it doesn't mean that you always have to be wrong.
She put her country first b4 her Anc & her position
@@thembamotaung9134 you are indeed a revengeful simpleton...she is more brave than all your feebleminded ancestors
SHE. IS A SELL OUT. SHE. HATES OUR. PRESIDENT BECAUSE. HE. DEFEATED. HER. IN A BALLOT. HOW CAN YOU. VOTE. TO. IMPEAGH YOUR. OWN. PRESSIDENT
You can tell, from ANC member, who wanted to say yes but said no. 🤦🏾♂️
This party haena polelo pele. I like how they have been given a long rope n they bizi killing themselves. Dear time u r great.
Ponelo*
@@lolomkwanazi6954 You nailed it, Next (ELECTIONS) vote Big .....Biggest NO to ANC
When you watch this you understand why people need to vote, voter turnout is always disappointing and we are seeing the effects of that.
what a joke.
We shall remember those who go said no when we go to vote😢
ANC acts like they are alone in this state
Love how Juju is able to articulate himself so well through his anger.
ANC must go the all criminals
what's going on in SOUTH AFRICA
Where did you get that emoji
If we were really United we were gng to vote DA but they also look after their own its about race n not the nation so sad to b in RSA
If you are black and you vote for a white man to rule over you. You deserve everything bad in your life. DA is a racist party that shouldn't rule in a black country
This was wrong, this NO people is like they are playing.
I was waiting for Naledi Pandoor s No in that “nice” English
Hong Hong 🤣
This just shows that if ANC wanted the people of Azania to have their land back they could make it happen.
No they can’t, they were defeated this time last year trying to amend section 25 of the constitution. They could not get 2/3 majority with DA & EFF amongst others voting against the amendment. Yes there was a time when it was mechanically possible but not now, that boat has long sailed. Mbeki delivered for ANC 2/3rd majority to change constitution and Zuma squandered it…2024 might be coalition government and that will come with its own challenges about who gets to eat first.
Thomas Sowell has these wonderful nuggets, “Politics is the art of making your selfish desires seem like national interest”…”no one will ever really understand politics until they understand that politicians are not trying to solve our problems. They are trying to solve their own problems - of which getting elected and re-elected are #1 and #2. Whatever is #3 is far behind.
Will they give the land to the Khoi/San....I doubt it.
This people there are afraid to lose their job that's all.
We knew Zuma Zuma Nkandla will be yes
You should have asked the speaker to read the rules she read before the voting. The rule spoke of those who may not have voted, not corrections of the votes
Zwane Gupta family
you all over man , sit down
President Malema 🔥💯🌟
We will show u come 2024
But lets converse and decide on who we are voting for. United we are strong.
we showed them
Hope has been lost for this parliament as long as Ramaphosa remains president
Yes
This is a joke!
South Africans should do what the ANC has demonstrated.Unify behind an opposition, vote with a common goal so can rid our nation of the rot that has built up...its like a ingrown toenail at this point. Useless n painful.😮
So what were they going to achieve by votiog yes. The ANC would simply install a even more corrupt person if Ramaphose was forced to step down. I am mo fan of the ANC
You’d think these are smart people…
Ingabe nifakelwe malini lamaxoki adayisa ngezwe lethu.
Sisule no Dlamini Zuma
Voting processes flawed
Im worried about tha jobs of those ANC members who voted yes... They have just made tha biggest mistake of their lives🤣
Corrupted MPs,how can this peoples staying close to each others while just saying no, others will be intimidate.
The speaker was foolish to let mps voting openly and speaker new how to gave anc advantage
Dude. It was rigged from the get go. These people make me sick
Where do they get these speakers Mara?
Tjoooh silixoki
Abantu abadala kanje nokuphapha nx… country leaders
The fundamentals of Democracy, my X should be a silent one when voting not for the whole world to know. Guys be careful of this Administration thats why we are sitting with Stage 6 LoadShedding because of No. we need to pray for this.
I just saw sheeps ANC
On Point man On Ponit,look at the faces of opposition they can smell the Truth.
However the whole party must be removed out of power
We ruled by fooled and childish old people.
Nathi sithi no ANC on 2024
we need to🚩🚩 this🚉🚉🚎, NO To ANC ON 2024 elections till to♾‼
ANC, YES TO BREAD AND NO TO CONSTITUTION OF SOUTH AFRICA. 😂😂😂😂😂
It's Obvious Most of these ANC members are voting No because they are Afraid to lose their jobs. Big ups to Mam' u Nkosazana Zuma. We must stand up for the truth no matterwhat. The truth shall set you free.
It ended in tears. No more outright majority to shield corruption. Voters showed who the real boss is 🤣🤣🤣, Arrogance iphelile. Time to pay!!
Disgrace worse from old grannies and grandfathers kuvotwa ngathi kuse eHolo lomphakathi elokshini 😃
Hawu she ran???🤣😂🤣
This is a JOKE
I voted for ANC for a long time but I have achieved nothing, no decent work no RDP house and so forth,but no one to blame, how about I become a member of parliament I thought the members of parliament are very dignified people but when I look at them and how they speak I think I can fit to the ANC part.
I ANC ibolile
Kubole ugogo wakho
Decomposed for real sana
You can see that the county is going nowhere with such an elderly leadership who should be enjoying their pension and also their are liers 🤔🤔what a shame it is
Malema looks weird in red. He can look awesome in orange 👁️
Disgusting why can't they just say a simple descent No or Yes....fooling around
I hate oppression
Mazuptaholo is no surprise
My gosh! We're not gonna rest due to this vuvuzela called Malema 🙄
You really understand him better. Vuvuzela😂😂
You are so blind
@@sauljunior6510 his followers are.they don’t even realize many contradictory statements he made in exuberance of his verbosity
@Vs aka the sinner : Leave Malema alone wena Vuvuzela ndini. He is not your class. You are just a wannabe like any Tom, Dig naboHarry. Gee Pad Jou Vuvuzera
When do we start discussing how we are all voting come 2024? I think an open discussion will allow us to have a way forward and not speculate or have doubts. Whatever party we decide on be it EFF, ActionSA, DA or even the same ANC. Let's discuss and move united.
ANC yam it's old stuff
Old stuff is better than young nyaopes
Gore nkabe ke na le bazooka...
😂😂😂😂o dire eng Ka yona?
I like the speaker, she is very beautiful. i have never seen such a beautiful old lady. Politics aside😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Letting the world know your affinity for old women 🥺
I agree shes beautiful
Awww Mandela ✌️😅😅😅
All culprits "NO"
shame on you its unbelivable what no what are u defending i dont understand
This is a joke. ANC is a joke
They're not a joke but the ruling Party.
Europe Global Justice Big NO
ANC is aged party. cemetery is nearer.
When you are part of the group of thieves...
Italy minori testimoni un grandissimo mal nostro vita
Italy natale un grandissimo big fector schoola bambini tutti
Mahambe lala😅 I cant
He did it on purpose 🤣🤣🤣
Imagine if all people voted loke this🤮
So it means you do get intimidated, just not easily. What's grest about that lexicon in semantics meant to be to us? Us meaning ordinary people., just so that you are not intimidated. This Parliament is weird.
Eff so active in everything
"party line" 23:04 and mahambelala 59:40
Ngiyi anc impela kodwa cha ukukhwabanisa sesadlula ngakho and silimaza iqembu ngo2024 abantu abazosivotela siyizigehengu beku wine oyes kulamavote
It's a shame choosing their seats. Hiyooooooo