@@Amy-cw6qs shes not dying by being 3 pounds under weight. And those people dont care for her health, they dont even know her. People just like to comment on other peoples lives.
thats true. i feel like most contestants are just there for the money. who knows. i really would love to loose weight but its hard for me because i like food. i only weigh 190 lbs so im not as big as she was. if i was at the show i wouldnt care about the money. if i win thats a bonus for me but if i loose the weight i wanted im even more happy
She’s MUCH thinner than the presenter in the white dress and you can bet your parents college savings that the presenter was chosen among a pool of 30 women for attractiveness
@@dsgarden.....Your point? Her bmi is only slightly under (by approx 3 pounds) and she doesn't look bony at all, in fact she looks happy and healthy. She didn't just do weight loss exercises, she also worked out. She look completely normal to me and I don't believe there is anything wrong with her.
Im really sad that after she was able to lose all that weight people still shame her like wtf. Before it was like “lose the weight” and now its like “gain some weight”. People need to shut up, this was part of the game and she freaking nailed the challenge be proud of her
NeeYoDeeO in her case, being at her final weight aged her the most. When she was a few pounds heavier than her final weigh in goal, she looked younger.
LynRuiz yeah I think it’s cause she lost it so quickly it made her look gaunt in the face. In follow up interviews I think she said she gained like 20 pounds since that weigh in and her face looked really healthy.
I know a lot of people are dumb and believing that she lost too much weight but I believe what the people who put some thought into it are concerned about the time span it took. I think it’s great she lost so much but there are complications if you lose it too fast. But she’s healthy and there is no big deal to worry about.
CSGO Tips and Tricks you idiot. It doesn't matter how fast she lost weight, that doesn't make you anorexic. Being anorexic means that you are way below the healthy weight. And I'm not saying that it's not unhealthy to lose weight so fast, I'm saying that she's not anorexic, so stop being such a dumbass... P.S. I'm a man... I don't know where you got the woman part from...
exactly! everyone's different and if she decided to possibly take up a more rigorous sport such as endurance running or and kind of endurance athletics, of course she'll drop in lbs. but it's different for everyone.
I think its the time it took for her to lose weight. There's an episode on house md/greys wherein they said its still anorexia even if shes weight training because her heart may fail so its normal for people to be concerned.
+Kayli 'Kiyo' Mills (MewKiyoko) 105 is getting dangerously close to the point of losing the fat you NEED. Girls can slip easily into a state of mind where they lose too much weight, sometimes to the point where their own organs break down. This is NOT healthy. This may encourage more girls to adopt unhealthy weight loss, to the point where it injures them. It's about where is this going to lead, and the lack of safe motivations from the show. They should be motivating people to be healthy, not to lose more weight than they need to and trade their health for MONEY.
+Ruki Sar Based on the percentage and number of fat slobs in the west, i think the risk of girls losing too much weight is laughable. 105 at 5'4" is not THAT skinny.
It depends your definition of skinny which can differ for a man or woman, I say 5'4 and 105 is skinny for anyone, Someone can still be thin but have a healthy BMI if it's above 18.5. Her's is slightly below that. Besides too much weight can be bad, lets say if they become anorexic, bulimic, etc.
Much relief after going through this stuff ruclips.net/user/postUgkxVYhghKWmrUgXARZ_ydZTvmmcrw5L0I5i Stress no doubt affects my blood sugar levels. Taking a walk usually helps bring them down. Eating sweets is not my favorite, but if i take a large portion of them, my blood sugar level rises high. I think it's the high concentration of the glucose flowing into the bloodstream all at once. This is a lesson worth taking note of. This is a great material to learn from.
I agree 100%, half of these people would rather see her unhealthy at 260 pounds. She's slightly too thin, but she'll definitely get back to around 115-120 and look great.
I love how when we talk about obesity everyone starts shouting “the bmi scale isn’t an acurrate representation of health!!” But when this person is just slightly underweight, it’s okay to use that as a reason to criticize this person
Dude they’re not criticizing her weight. They’re concerned about how fast she lost it. Losing too much weight in such a short amount of time is not good for anyone
Slightly under the healthy index? Many people in Asia are always slightly under the healthy index and we're perfectly fine, I rather be slightly under the health index than to be massively over the health index. Besides, she's not starving herself, she's exercising and eating less, that's not bad. Unless she starts developing bulimia or anorexia, I don't see any problem in this.
Rachel Lim: She isn't Asian though. Asians are tiny and have a different body frame and smaller bone structure. It's often hotter in their countries. That's basic biology. Bergmann's law. Even animals in colder countries have more mass and are bigger. The average German or Scandinavian girl is taller and has bigger hips and shoulders with a different bone structure. So even the skeletons would look bigger next to Asians. So they have to weight more and need more amount of food and they gain weight more easily. Same goes for people in cold countries like Russia. Guess where most white people in the USA are from? Right: Europe. Often Germany or Great Britiain.
@@denisenova7494 The problem with how you reason is that you basically tether your entire argument on Bergmann's law and then attribute that to humans. Bergmann's law is mainly for animals, and the major critique of it is that it has very little to do with latitude but with how long the food availability lasts. In northern countries, it lasts fewer months than in southern. I was going to tell you to check the actual statistics on body composition and bone density whilst also adjusting for starvation cycles in these countries. But I feel that would just shoot straight over your head so I am just going to say this: CHECK THE NATIONAL BASKETBALL LEAGUE. WHERE ARE THOSE PLAYERS FROM? ARE THEY SHORT?
+believeitspossible I think the real issue is that she used clenbuterol and possibly other steroids. yeah, no loose skin anywhere after losing 60 percent of her weight in such a short period of time.
+believeitspossible it's not about 'judging' or 'criticising', it's a genuine concern for her HEALTH that she's gone from being very overweight to clinically underweight in a short space of time, absolutely nothing to do with what she looks like...
J M No, she/he's not. This is a genuine health concern. Losing that much weight in a short period of time is a very massive concern especially with how one eats
Damn all you lucky bitches and here I am at 5 foot 2 inches weighing around 125 pounds....😩 I'm happy for you guys though cause it's always better to be slightly under weight than overweight lol
@@fatboitino2 Yes, but there are much safer ways for a morbidly obese person to lose that weight. Making them run or do box jumps is STUPID. Imagine 500 LBS of pressure being applied directly to their joints when jumping. Also, not everyone on The Biggest Loser is "morbidly obese". Some have not reached that level yet. In any case, a healthy rate of fat loss is 1 - 2.5 pounds per week. Perhaps this can be slightly increased for obese people. And it should be mainly changes to diet along with light impact exercise like swimming. You cannot train a morbidly obese person the same way you would train an Olympic athlete. Their bodies are different. They could have a heart attack at any moment. By shifting the focus away from heath and towards what the scale shows and making it a competition to how many pounds someone can drop at once is very wrong. This is why so many people who are on the Biggest Loser end up gaining all the weight back, if not more.
@@KishoreG2396 I'm not discussing the methods of the show, that's entirely different. Their methods are completely unsafe for obese individuals. Surprised there aren't more injuries
@@KishoreG2396 Also, an acceptable rate of fat loss is technically 1-.5% of one's weight per week. The higher the weight, the more can be loss, technically. I agree with what you're saying though. I know how this all works. However, that's not what's being discussed here (surprisingly)
She actually looks very healthy you can tell she has a very athletic muscular body, she was just very dedicated and put in lots of work, nothing wrong with that at all
"very athletic muscular body" Nah, she is very "unmuscular" but its fine. The thing is that she really seems to be mentally affected by this. Its so easy to get an eating disorder
Michel The prevalence of eating disorders is less than 10% of the population. It's really not "easy" to get one. It's "easy" to claim to have one. Moreover, there is a difference between "disordered eating" and "eating disorder." Big difference in fact. I'm sorry friends of yours have experienced it, but it's quite offensive to trivialize eating disorders as something "easy to catch." It's not like a cold or flu, it's a mental illness that takes years to develop, and is influenced by many things, most of which have nothing to do with weight or body size. Everybody is so quick to jump to the terms "anorexia" or "bulimia" these days without actually knowing what it takes to be diagnosed with them.
Jasmine Kassam That just what I didnt mean. This show is almost designed for ppl to "evolve" eating disorders. I consider it a eating disorder when a person gets so thin that he or she has to be hospitalized or when someone ALWAYS thinks about food in a con´trolling matter. Her supposed ED does not show cause thats her goal. Its shows when lets say shes having a party for her daughter or whatever and eats carrots in instead of a piece of cake. Then she and other says "oh, its just because of my diet, I cant eat this" Its super easy to "get" a ED. My niece is on her way there, I see it in how she acts around food. I talked to her mom about this over a year ago. Always gets the respond that she is fine, its just a phase. Thats how my ex gf got her anorexia. She almost died. Then she got healthy and started lifting weights. Now she has orthorexia and is basically training her body to pieces. Everybody STILL says she is fine and has a great body. Ive been around it so much I almost can read when someone has a problem. Its so incredible how common it is.
@@ashleyforever4457 how is it unhealthy? I get that she lost the weight very fast so it was very extreme but, she herself is taking about much better she feels and it's not like we are all doctors who have examined the condition of her body.
Never said they hated HER, you swine. They hate the fact that their team got their asses kicked. And who's to say she's not healthy? Keep buying into entertainment opinion's and we'll see who the idiot is.
Padre-D Productions Going from 260 to 105 in a few months required some extreme training that probably resulted in days, maybe even weeks, of not eating. You can be underweight and people feel that this is going to low. There is no damned if you do damned if you don't scenario. This is a going to far to one end and then going to far to the other. There's is a middle ground that people should be hitting. RememberRox People say a lot of things. People who are over 300 lbs have said they felt great and health, as have people under 100 lbs.
Oh, and yo-yo-ing is another dangerous possibility. The stress it puts on the body to lose weight quickly, does harm to every internal system. That harm shows up later in life, so people don't make the connection. To gain the weight back, creates even more damage. Fat stores toxins. Fat is a great protector. So, while it is unhealthy to be obese, losing weight needs to be done in a way that doesn't attack the body/hate the fat (as fat is a good thing in moderation). When you lose weight quickly, toxins stored in the fat to protect the body, are released into the body quickly, and the body can't heal itself properly. If you lose weight at a slow, consistent rate--the body can cleanse the body of those toxins. And that's just one of the many ways in which it's bad to lose weight too quickly...
I think its the amount she lost in such a little time is the worrying thing. I almost died from anorexia. I went from obese to underweight within 6 months (actually slightly less). I lost 90lbs and was lucky to have my heart beating.
XakashinaX... Youre an idiot. bmi for someone at 5'7 and 140lbs is LEGIT HEALTHY! It's a bmi of 21!!!! yikes. you might want to actually learn what an overweight bmi is. Overweight bmi: 25+ and a obese bmi is 30+.... lol yikes.
ariel make em mad being obese takes a toll on your body. I’m not making a dig, just like being overweight and losing the weight can age u + toxins from foods that generally cause obesity make you look older. Could be it
Princess Mia being "overweight" doesn't automatically equate to being unhealthy. just like being skinny doesn't automatically equate to being healthy, as you can see here.
No one says “man, she gained too much weight too fast.” Even though 60% of America is overweight, and they are dying of heart disease and type 2 diabetes in droves. Basically no one statistically is dying from losing weight too fast.
@@ReplyGuy22345 If she maintains the weight loss and allows her body to adjust, it doesn't even matter. The issue with losing to fast the difficulty in maintaining and stress on the body. Obviously, if she was overly obese her entire life- she needed to do something dramatic and a slow deficit wasn't going to work for her
She busted her ass, she worked hard. Don't hate on other people's progress if you don't have the guts to do it yourself. BMI is out dated and don't mean shit.
This is promoting a disease. Anorexia ain't a fuckin joke. She has a full blown eating disorder skin and bones…. but what do I know I've only been involved with fitness for 8 years. No one is hating on her I feel bad for her, it's the shows and networks fault for allowing this bullshit… possibly the trainers
+kaminoneh bhoot Thanks for that... I've seen old people with loose skin but not a young person. I stretched out to over 60 excess lbs when I was pregnant in my teens and had no loose skin when I returned to normal...
Oh COME ON. 5'4 and 105 pounds is still a LOT healthier than 5'4 and 260 lbs. Her old BMI was 44.6! And healthy is between 18.5-24.9. This woman is only 3 pounds below the healthy weight- and that's nothing. Some runway models are 20+ pounds below the healthy weight. I'm sure she could gain that 3 lbs no problem. Her losing 155 lbs is definitely a LOT more difficult than gaining 3 lbs and a much bigger achievement.
But if her bmi was slightly over the recommended, everyone would chime in with "the bmi doesn't apply to alllll....she's just thicccccc....a bit more weight doesn't harm youuuu...". Hypocrisy at its finest.
The Unpopular Opinion no! It’s never right to do that to yourself. Take it easy, and no matter what weight you are heavy or not everyone is unique and amazing in their own way
BMI means nothing. BMI is useful to look at statistics for populations but isnt as important for individuals whats concerning is the rate at which she dropped the weight, but she is much healthier now than before. All in all it was a great thing for her. She also likely was dehydrated for the weigh in in order to 'win' which makes her BMI look lower than it actually is. If she was just 3 lbs heavier shed be normal weight according to BMI.
It is not that much about her weight it's that this show is celebrating unhealthy behaviour i.e. losing weight really fast. It's not how you do it. It's eating disordered.
@@denisenova7494 but the whole point is to lose weight so you don't have to face complications in later life, and she hasn't had any negative effects from not being obese so far...
Augustine Daudu There is no health problem with losing weight fast , did you hear them give any ? any evidence ? I drop over 20 pounds in 2 weeks of water fasting every march and there is nothing bad
She isn't too thin at all. As long as she's healthy and her doctors say she is doing well then Kudos to her! Anyone would go to extreme under pressure to lose it quick with money on the line. People are so quick to judge others.
Did u not hear the doctor say this isn't healthy weight for a "5"4 girl , to be honest this is kinda weird that is the normal weight of a 12 year old girl like I weigh 105 and I'm "5'3 but Ik I'm not fat bc the doctor says I'm heathy so that's all that matters
Kailee Moore you don’t get to say if she’s healthy or not. Only doctors can do that, she’s better now than before and many women are very skinny bcs that’s how they‘re
ÖRLOGSKAPTEN #MAKERUclipsGREATAGAIN BMI isn't reliable tbh. It doesn't take account for your body composition. I could look great and toned and feel amazing but be considered overweight because of muscle mass and such
trmbne2014 no, it's a biological fact that thinner people are more physically appealing. It's because they have a better likelihood of being healthy and producing healthy offspring. Were you attracted to her when she was morbidly obese? Because if so, something is probably wrong with your mental chemistry. Objectively, she became much more attractive after losing the weight.
Phoebe O'Donnell body fat is important to those hormone functions but only a little bit really. You don’t need a whole lot of body fat for that to work normally. She’s fine, this isn’t really unhealthy. She is a few pounds beneath the average BMI range for her height and age, that’s not unhealthy, just not average which doesn’t mean healthy. It’s not the appearance she’s being awarded for either, it’s the fact of how much she lost and how drastic a change it was in a good direction. I don’t know her personally, but unless she has a legitimate eating disorder, this ain’t a problem.
She did amazing and I am sure nobody would question her current weight if she had never been obese before. But.... I just wonder where is her loose skin?!?!?! Amazing
Well not necessarily. Now this is a very extreme example but if you were lost in the wilderness with no food. You can use you fat reserves to live so. Lol. It’s a survival aspect kind of.
Ashley Kleinvehn I’m defending her. She did great. It’s not unhealthy either, she is just a few pounds beneath average. And for her frame, that might be perfect.
When she was (edit) *overweight*everyone said”omg she’s too fat” now that she lost weight everyone says “omg she’s too skinny” at what point are people satisfied I mean NEVER!? if she feels good it’s her body she can do what ever the heck she wants to do so STOP JUDGING!
She lost that much to win the competition you know it wasn't because she wanted to look that skinny. After the show she went up to around 125 to be at a weight she was comfortable with.
Mariana Santana you make me real mad, you know it’s not healthy to lose that much weight? She literally weighs less than me idiot. She obviously lost that much to win the competition. And, have you ever heard of water cutting? You literally remove liquid from your body to gain weight. She probably used that way. And we say whatever we think alright? It’s called freedom of speech idiottt. And she could die from that amount of weight loss.
Mariana Santana were not judging. We’re caring about her health because she is UNDERWEIGHT she lost so much pounds in such a little time that it’s not healthy. People these days think that being overweight or underweight is ok or healthy well it’s not! It’s not healthy for her.
Emily Mcgoldrick well, its her life and she can do whatever she wants with it. She probably signed a contract that told her the results and risks of joining the game show. We are not responsible for her actions and have no right to judge her.
+Jane L She gained about 20 pounds a few months after the finale and has said that she agrees she was probably a bit too skinny at the finale and feels like she's at her perfect weight now
I remember my first reaction to this was she lost too much, and for the record I'm a thin physically fit man, my wife a thin physically fit woman thought the same thing. She looked almost skeletal, but she was trying to win an enormous amount of money and she did what she had to to earn the victory. If she just puts five-ten pounds of lean weight back on after the shows finale she'd look perfect. If you watch the second to last episode she looked perfect at that point healthy and strong.
"If she gained five-term pounds she'd look perfect" you are literally promoting the problem we are criticizing. What you think of her weight doesnt matter. No one care what weight you think she would look "perfect" at, you're just telling her what to do with her body to be more physically appealing to what you personally see as healthy. You dont get to pretend to be supportive then tell her she's look better if she gained 5 pounds
@@SaraH-jn5db ok she'd look healthy, how about that? You can believe what you want but it's not healthy to starve yourself to skin and bones, it's called anorexia. It's not my "opinion" that anorexia and obesity are unhealthy, and I highly doubt she would have starved herself to that weight if she wasn't competing for a cash prize. It's the reason I hate the biggest loser in general, it's making a game out of a serious life threatening problem and substituting one unhealthy obsession for the other extreme isn't healthy or a good example for impressionable men and woman. Also I wrote this over a year ago, you're a bit late to the party aren't you?
@@davidmayberry3190 here's a reply two years later then. She's perfectly healthy and has a fitness Instagram, let's see what ELSE you can come up with to disapprove of. Also the fact that you and your wife are both lean and on the muscular side just shows you have no idea of what it feels like to be obese and losing over 100 pounds to completely reinvent your body from inside and out. There's this thing called a healthy dose of sadism when you have to lose that much weight to keep going, which is night and day compare to always being thin and just putting on a measly 5-10 pounds of muscle.
she looks fine.. athletic and muscular to me.. obviously much healthier than when she started her journey.. I don't understand why everybody except her doctor is worried.. seriously everyone's opinion, including random twitter users, was taken.. everyone except those you are professionally qualified to comment.
@@illshankyousogoaway8124 she has a fitness Instagram and is healthier than ever. Just take the L and stop hiding behind jealousy. People who fat shame are literally using the same "I am just concerned" argument all the time.
Lauren Gustafson I'm a nutritionist in canada and we use 18, What you have to look at is the bodyfat % muscle mass body composition anyway, nothing indicates that she's unhealthy right now.
Marie Ada I'm a nutritionist and personal trainer, it's not accurate in the sense that it doesn't take into consideration if your weight is muscle or fat but ppl who can have health problems are usually way under 18, still.
The healthy benchmark is actually 18.5, but whatever... the BMI didn't count her frame type. Being boney equals sickness not health. If you think this slinky individual is healthy, I highly recommend you get your money back from whatever place your got your accreditations and degrees from, because this woman is clearly not healthy looking. She looks typical of Hollywood actresses and reminds me of Christian Bale from "The Machinist". She has no mass which is why her eyes are snuck in and her bones protrude. A healthy individual doesn't have that. She has aged dramatically too. She is 24 but looks way older... wtf!?
I’m happy to hear she put on 20lbs after the show. She stays out of the spotlight, including social media, but she’s stated that she feels like she’s at her perfect weight.
I’m surprised about everyone’s negative reaction to her 105lb frame. I weigh 170 pounds and I’m pressured and made to feel bad by almost everyone around me for not being skinny and having a chubby stomach. Even when I weighed 134 pounds I was told to lose weight. People I know believe the skinner the better. I started going to the gym because I can’t bare to look at my body anymore. I’m not fat, I’m an ‘average’ size girl. Whatever that means.That’s society in a nutshell.
Is she dead? Is she crying? Is she complaining? Is she not proud? Exactly she's smiling and she's proud if she's happy I'm happy they knew what they signed up for and she's looking like a goddess anyway
It's supposed to be a guideline, if you feel fine and your BMI is 19(skinny side) or 24(chubby side) no one should care. But if you are constantly out of breath, have trouble sleeping, headaches etc(endless list) then weight can be an indicator. Your BMI is 19 and you are constantly out of breath, damn that doesn't sound good, maybe you eat too little or are malnourished. And vice versa. But if someone has a BMI of 17 or 27 then their diet needs to change, if they are an average person with a 9 to 5 deskjob
people will be always jelous of something, maybe, instead of sitting in front of your screens right now, you do something with your life? Stop bullying her, stop making stupid comments, it's her body and she feels great in it. That's what matters. I came here cause Jerry Ward was saying something about that girl, never heard of that show and of her before ever.
Thank you! You are the first one to mention this. People are crying wolf over the fact that she was skinny, and borderline anorexic. People don't realize SHE CAN GAIN SOME OF THE WEIGHT BACK AND BE PERFECTLY HEALTHY! Lay off people, get a grip!
I hate when fitness trainers think they know what it's like to be morbidly obese it's not just physically depleting it's mental to and it's never been harder to lose weight ever since now
omg people judged her for being too big now people are judging her for being to small, the poor thing cant win and must feel terrible about the constant criticism she's faced from society, can everyone just let her be happy
It is because she lost too much weight, too fast and could be suffering from a life threatening illness now. The show should be promoting healthy weight loss, not starvation diets. She may need help.
Exactly what I was thinking. Looks can be deceiving, and everyone's body is different. Just because you're a certain height doesn't mean you have to conform to the same exact criteria as everyone else. People enjoy shaming others whether or not they're "too fat" or "too skinny."
but look at her face! look on google. her face is all bones. it is empancipated. she is the smallest so far. she is WAAAAY thinner than all of the other winners. once you go that low, its VERY hard to get back to A HEALTHY WEIGHT. people who have never had an eating disorder or anorexia, its hard for them to understand. her whole mental mind will be changed. she thinks she looks healthy right now. it will be difficult for her to chage her mind set for her to gain weight again. this is a downward spiral. I had anorexia, I know. I had an eating disorder. I was obsessed with food, and did the opposite and got obsessed with not eating and exercising. look her up on google and she all her photos. her arms and legs are too skinny. her face is gaunt. Im 130 at 17 and im lean. this is ridiculous. shes way to thin and sadly, she can't even see it. the judges faces were shocked!!!!!!! that's why twitter is roaring with how thin she is! this is not healthy and strong. she is bony..
Mike Hawk Do not bring bmi in to this. The BMI scale is one of the most ludicrous "measurements of health" ever. It is completely inaccurate and is not a good determination of a persons health.
You all are fucking ridiculous and mean at first people doubted her, called her fat, and ugly but now that she is skinny you want to keep on judging her .. you can not please society honestly i'm glad she got that weight off , did you see her smile I know she felt good about herself how can she honestly keep being happy with herself if the world is still bringing her down for something that she thought would make society happier not only you all but herself and her family. grow the fuck up for once, and stop dissing her for something she thought would be right.
You do realize that she was damaging her body to win money right? She lost her period, was extremely dehydrated and her hair was falling out. I wouldn't be happy for her. You are blind if you really think this show is about a glorious journey to a healthier life.
well you did not realize that I did not know all that was happening to her, and I am not blind lol, but you guys yeah society are not happy with anyone! yes she was unhealthy as a fat ass not she is unhealthy as a skinny ass! what the fuck do you guys want her to be? huh no one can please you guys, its her fucking life if she wants her hair to fall out let that shit fall out in the end are you picking it up off the floor nope, or even if she wants diabetes are you going to be the one buying her meds nope! so why the fuck are we setting here disagreeing on eachothers comments? bye now
You hate skinny people. So you're judging people purely based off of their appearance. You're just as bad as someone who says they hate overweight people. God, this is ridiculous. What an ignorant fuck.How do you just shove all skinny people into one category of assholes? Sorry you went through all that but we don't all act nasty. I don't like you because you seem like you're judgemental before you even know someone.
TaBelieveKally Theres a difference between skinny and healthy. Sure she's skinny but the journey she took was not healthy. This could come back to bite her in the ass
I never watched the show. Never heard of the person until today. And the methods they employ for this show-not even for this particular person-are not healthy. It's crash dieting. If you want to lose weight sustainably, 1-2 lbs/week is advisable. Employing gradual sustainable changes that you can maintain over the long term. I've seen the show before (it's been a few years) and the way they approach weight loss-drop as much as humanly possible as quick as humanly possible and you get money...? Not healthy.
Dam, she was probably insulted countless times for being overweight and then she immediately had to suffer criticisms for losing it
Hiro funny how it works huh 😂
People have to say something
Yeah and
It's not criticism these people are concerned for her health
@@Amy-cw6qs shes not dying by being 3 pounds under weight. And those people dont care for her health, they dont even know her. People just like to comment on other peoples lives.
For $250,000 I would starve and dehydrate myself too. Then grab the cash and head to a buffet.
😂😂😂 couldn't agree more
AAAAAAAMEN!!
You will get that one person to criticize you in social media
thats true. i feel like most contestants are just there for the money. who knows. i really would love to loose weight but its hard for me because i like food. i only weigh 190 lbs so im not as big as she was. if i was at the show i wouldnt care about the money. if i win thats a bonus for me but if i loose the weight i wanted im even more happy
spoyledbratt u made my day!
Society will never be satisfied
She’s MUCH thinner than the presenter in the white dress and you can bet your parents college savings that the presenter was chosen among a pool of 30 women for attractiveness
@@dsgarden.....Your point? Her bmi is only slightly under (by approx 3 pounds) and she doesn't look bony at all, in fact she looks happy and healthy. She didn't just do weight loss exercises, she also worked out. She look completely normal to me and I don't believe there is anything wrong with her.
Fuck Society
Im really sad that after she was able to lose all that weight people still shame her like wtf. Before it was like “lose the weight” and now its like “gain some weight”. People need to shut up, this was part of the game and she freaking nailed the challenge be proud of her
It’s Britney ikr
She looks fine. The BMI charts aren’t for everyone. I’m shocked that she’s 24. She can pass as a 39-42 yr old
LynRuiz weight ages you
NeeYoDeeO in her case, being at her final weight aged her the most. When she was a few pounds heavier than her final weigh in goal, she looked younger.
Maddy Y aww that’s an unfortunate tradeoff. My aunt lost 150lbs and had the opposite effect. She looks baby faced and 25 years younger.
LynRuiz yeah I think it’s cause she lost it so quickly it made her look gaunt in the face. In follow up interviews I think she said she gained like 20 pounds since that weigh in and her face looked really healthy.
LynRuiz being really skinny often makes people look a lot older
THIS literally proves that no matter if you’re fat or skinny. You’re gonna get judged.
Messed up society
why does this have only 60 likes
EXACTLY!
🤦♀️🤦♀️
They are both extremes and neither are healthy
@@radiotete1e278 no one is perfect. im sure you arent
This is skinny shaming
Just as bad as fat shaming
I know a lot of people are dumb and believing that she lost too much weight but I believe what the people who put some thought into it are concerned about the time span it took. I think it’s great she lost so much but there are complications if you lose it too fast. But she’s healthy and there is no big deal to worry about.
It’s not skinny shaming, they’re only criticising how fast she lost weight.
it’s not too skinny it’s just worry about being 105lbs
@@Charizarzar its her body and yes it's skinny shaming
Florancer girl bye
Listen... She's much healthier now than she was 260 pounds
Kevin Ku right
Obviously it’s easier to gain weight than lose it but then again she literally looks like she was in a hunger strike
A-M-R-O true
someone could eat junk food everyday & stay extremely skinny because it’s not “real” food. skinnier isn’t always healthier
At 115 lbs overweight- nobody says a word
At 3 lbs underweight- SHE IS GOING TO DIE!!!
All I see a committed girl and people hating on it because they can’t be that committed.
she has a fitness instagram she didnt gain the weight back at all.. unlike a lot of winners of this show..
If we never saw the fat version of her, people would not be in shock seeing the skinny her.
@@hardowider5054 she was pretty skinny before she got fat. she was a state champ swimmer when she was younger.
Too much commitment in just a short amount of time can be because of disordered eating lmao
Ranch excuse me? I’m fat yeah but not a beached whale and she is way too skinny now she over did it
Suprised i dont see much loose skin.🤔
Maybe surgery
The winner of the shows get their surgery paid for thats why they go on the show
AlphaDrizzy you don’t always have loose skin also she could have had surgery
AlphaDrizzy she has scars from the weight loss surgery
Maybe she wasn't as big
People concerned about her health. Dude she was 260 pounds
CSGO Tips and Tricks do you know what anorexia is dumbass? shes far from anorexic
CSGO Tips and Tricks you idiot!
CSGO Tips and Tricks lol salty much??? 😂😂😂😂
CSGO Tips and Tricks you idiot. It doesn't matter how fast she lost weight, that doesn't make you anorexic. Being anorexic means that you are way below the healthy weight. And I'm not saying that it's not unhealthy to lose weight so fast, I'm saying that she's not anorexic, so stop being such a dumbass...
P.S. I'm a man... I don't know where you got the woman part from...
CSGO Tips and Tricks the healthy weight for her size is between 110 and 130 pounds, and she's 105... So where's the anorexia in there????
“Her BMI is slightly below healthy” oh you mean like all marathon runners and endurance athletes?
exactly! everyone's different and if she decided to possibly take up a more rigorous sport such as endurance running or and kind of endurance athletics, of course she'll drop in lbs. but it's different for everyone.
I think its the time it took for her to lose weight. There's an episode on house md/greys wherein they said its still anorexia even if shes weight training because her heart may fail so its normal for people to be concerned.
Cassia McKamey
This is so off topic but I always do this when I see someone with a pfp like that
*The Neighbourhood*
Those people aren’t healthy though, and they’re well aware of that. It’s not healthy to stress your body out that much.
Exacly and what about models there probably way under there BMI
She's lean, she has muscle, she's not too thin. Does calling a thin woman unhealthy make you feel better about being overweight or?
+Kayli 'Kiyo' Mills (MewKiyoko) 105 is getting dangerously close to the point of losing the fat you NEED. Girls can slip easily into a state of mind where they lose too much weight, sometimes to the point where their own organs break down. This is NOT healthy. This may encourage more girls to adopt unhealthy weight loss, to the point where it injures them. It's about where is this going to lead, and the lack of safe motivations from the show. They should be motivating people to be healthy, not to lose more weight than they need to and trade their health for MONEY.
It's a bit low, but until she's under 12% bodyfat, the issue is not that she lost too much fat.
+Kayli 'Kiyo' Mills (MewKiyoko) she has no muscles , ok? xD
+Ruki Sar Based on the percentage and number of fat slobs in the west, i think the risk of girls losing too much weight is laughable. 105 at 5'4" is not THAT skinny.
It depends your definition of skinny which can differ for a man or woman, I say 5'4 and 105 is skinny for anyone, Someone can still be thin but have a healthy BMI if it's above 18.5. Her's is slightly below that. Besides too much weight can be bad, lets say if they become anorexic, bulimic, etc.
Much relief after going through this stuff ruclips.net/user/postUgkxVYhghKWmrUgXARZ_ydZTvmmcrw5L0I5i Stress no doubt affects my blood sugar levels. Taking a walk usually helps bring them down. Eating sweets is not my favorite, but if i take a large portion of them, my blood sugar level rises high. I think it's the high concentration of the glucose flowing into the bloodstream all at once. This is a lesson worth taking note of. This is a great material to learn from.
I think 5'4 and 105 pounds is way healthier than 260 pounds for a woman
this X 1000
It absolutely is. It's only the speed of the weight loss that is concerning, not the actual final weight itself.
I agree 100%, half of these people would rather see her unhealthy at 260 pounds. She's slightly too thin, but she'll definitely get back to around 115-120 and look great.
True, but there are probably a lot of women who are 150, and jealous of her achievements.
totally
I love how when we talk about obesity everyone starts shouting “the bmi scale isn’t an acurrate representation of health!!” But when this person is just slightly underweight, it’s okay to use that as a reason to criticize this person
So true. I have abs and the bmi says I'm fat it's because I'm so muscular
Dude they’re not criticizing her weight. They’re concerned about how fast she lost it. Losing too much weight in such a short amount of time is not good for anyone
Grace Young same here. My BMI says overweight in a women’s size 6 and 14% body fat.
Lmao. True. True.
BMI is a terrible scale. It was based off of a runners body. Not everyone’s body should look like and be the size of a runners body.
Slightly under the healthy index? Many people in Asia are always slightly under the healthy index and we're perfectly fine, I rather be slightly under the health index than to be massively over the health index. Besides, she's not starving herself, she's exercising and eating less, that's not bad. Unless she starts developing bulimia or anorexia, I don't see any problem in this.
Rachel Lim True. And it also depends on the weight of the bones, the % muscle or the % fat, each must take into account each individual, individually.
Rachel Lim: She isn't Asian though. Asians are tiny and have a different body frame and smaller bone structure. It's often hotter in their countries. That's basic biology. Bergmann's law. Even animals in colder countries have more mass and are bigger. The average German or Scandinavian girl is taller and has bigger hips and shoulders with a different bone structure. So even the skeletons would look bigger next to Asians. So they have to weight more and need more amount of food and they gain weight more easily. Same goes for people in cold countries like Russia. Guess where most white people in the USA are from? Right: Europe. Often Germany or Great Britiain.
Denise Nova Hmmm, that makes sense. Good point.
@@denisenova7494 The problem with how you reason is that you basically tether your entire argument on Bergmann's law and then attribute that to humans. Bergmann's law is mainly for animals, and the major critique of it is that it has very little to do with latitude but with how long the food availability lasts. In northern countries, it lasts fewer months than in southern.
I was going to tell you to check the actual statistics on body composition and bone density whilst also adjusting for starvation cycles in these countries. But I feel that would just shoot straight over your head so I am just going to say this: CHECK THE NATIONAL BASKETBALL LEAGUE. WHERE ARE THOSE PLAYERS FROM? ARE THEY SHORT?
Truth! I'm slightly under, and I'm still breathing fucking fine, thank you very much lol
people will JUDGE you no matter what!! "she's too overweight" , "she's too underweight"...criticism either way. sad.
+believeitspossible I think the real issue is that she used clenbuterol and possibly other steroids. yeah, no loose skin anywhere after losing 60 percent of her weight in such a short period of time.
+believeitspossible it's not about 'judging' or 'criticising', it's a genuine concern for her HEALTH that she's gone from being very overweight to clinically underweight in a short space of time, absolutely nothing to do with what she looks like...
believeitspossible They are not judging, they were concerned about her Heath.
believeitspossible wow you are right applaud
J M No, she/he's not. This is a genuine health concern. Losing that much weight in a short period of time is a very massive concern especially with how one eats
I'm 5'4 and 107lb..Are my organs gonna burst for being under the bmi chart by 1 percent? 💀
Funny...I'm 5'4" and 106 lbs and I'm constantly lectured about my ever so slightly underweight bmi.
I'm 5'4 and 105 lbs so I think I'm ded
Y'all, I'm 5'4 and a half now, and I'm 105lb now since the holidays are over. I guess I'm REALLY gonna die.
Damn all you lucky bitches and here I am at 5 foot 2 inches weighing around 125 pounds....😩 I'm happy for you guys though cause it's always better to be slightly under weight than overweight lol
I’m 5’1 and 95 pounds 😬 it’s not that healthy and I’m trying to gain a little bit, but it’s not as crazy as people are making it seem
People are so quick to say someone's too skinny but when she was big it was totally fine. Ridiculous.
amen
yup
Mariah Carey Fan Who said it was fine??? if it was, she would not have made the show in the 1st place.
Mariah Carey Fan No one ever said it was fine. In fact they said they're both two extremes at opposite ends.
Plus she is a healthy weight being short at 105
She went from obese to thigh gap lmao
+PsyWolf98 no to skeleton,
+Vegan johnathanru if you were a real vegan you would be skeleton
ChocolatePoop1301 that has nothing to do with anything. Vegan is a lifestyle not a starvation diet.
Vegan is also a mild form of retardation.
Alaskan Thunderfuck You're an immature idiot.
You train her to lose weight, she loses it. Then everyone: “She lost too much” what even is society 🤦♀️
It is VERY unhealthy and dangerous for someone to lose that much weight at once.
@@KishoreG2396 Being morbidly obese is unhealthy
@@fatboitino2 Yes, but there are much safer ways for a morbidly obese person to lose that weight. Making them run or do box jumps is STUPID. Imagine 500 LBS of pressure being applied directly to their joints when jumping.
Also, not everyone on The Biggest Loser is "morbidly obese". Some have not reached that level yet. In any case, a healthy rate of fat loss is 1 - 2.5 pounds per week. Perhaps this can be slightly increased for obese people. And it should be mainly changes to diet along with light impact exercise like swimming. You cannot train a morbidly obese person the same way you would train an Olympic athlete. Their bodies are different. They could have a heart attack at any moment.
By shifting the focus away from heath and towards what the scale shows and making it a competition to how many pounds someone can drop at once is very wrong. This is why so many people who are on the Biggest Loser end up gaining all the weight back, if not more.
@@KishoreG2396 I'm not discussing the methods of the show, that's entirely different. Their methods are completely unsafe for obese individuals. Surprised there aren't more injuries
@@KishoreG2396 Also, an acceptable rate of fat loss is technically 1-.5% of one's weight per week. The higher the weight, the more can be loss, technically. I agree with what you're saying though. I know how this all works. However, that's not what's being discussed here (surprisingly)
At least she lost all the weight!! She can easily gain those extra pounds to help her gain weight by eating healthily and in normal amounts.
She actually looks very healthy you can tell she has a very athletic muscular body, she was just very dedicated and put in lots of work, nothing wrong with that at all
"very athletic muscular body"
Nah, she is very "unmuscular" but its fine. The thing is that she really seems to be mentally affected by this. Its so easy to get an eating disorder
It's "easy" to get an eating disorder? Really?... Wow the misinformation these days.
Jasmine Kassam Several girls close to me has and has "beaten" it. Its by experience and education, not some information.
Michel The prevalence of eating disorders is less than 10% of the population. It's really not "easy" to get one. It's "easy" to claim to have one. Moreover, there is a difference between "disordered eating" and "eating disorder." Big difference in fact. I'm sorry friends of yours have experienced it, but it's quite offensive to trivialize eating disorders as something "easy to catch." It's not like a cold or flu, it's a mental illness that takes years to develop, and is influenced by many things, most of which have nothing to do with weight or body size. Everybody is so quick to jump to the terms "anorexia" or "bulimia" these days without actually knowing what it takes to be diagnosed with them.
Jasmine Kassam That just what I didnt mean. This show is almost designed for ppl to "evolve" eating disorders. I consider it a eating disorder when a person gets so thin that he or she has to be hospitalized or when someone ALWAYS thinks about food in a con´trolling matter. Her supposed ED does not show cause thats her goal. Its shows when lets say shes having a party for her daughter or whatever and eats carrots in instead of a piece of cake. Then she and other says "oh, its just because of my diet, I cant eat this"
Its super easy to "get" a ED. My niece is on her way there, I see it in how she acts around food. I talked to her mom about this over a year ago. Always gets the respond that she is fine, its just a phase. Thats how my ex gf got her anorexia. She almost died. Then she got healthy and started lifting weights. Now she has orthorexia and is basically training her body to pieces. Everybody STILL says she is fine and has a great body.
Ive been around it so much I almost can read when someone has a problem. Its so incredible how common it is.
She seems to look fit though with muscles. Not just bones
No
Stop hating don’t u think she’s been through enough first getting fun of being obese now getting criticized for being to thin that’s not fair
Hoor Al kaloti: To be fair people should critizise the show and not attack her.
But thats unhealthy
@@denisenova7494 Criticize the show ? I agree.
@@ashleyforever4457 how is it unhealthy? I get that she lost the weight very fast so it was very extreme but, she herself is taking about much better she feels and it's not like we are all doctors who have examined the condition of her body.
I'm anorexic. She triggers me.
Damned if ya do, Damned if ya don't.. One word: HATERS
No one hates her you idiot, some people are concern for her, that's all.
Never said they hated HER, you swine. They hate the fact that their team got their asses kicked. And who's to say she's not healthy? Keep buying into entertainment opinion's and we'll see who the idiot is.
Padre-D Productions I agree with you. Thin does not equal unhealthy! She says she feels great, and she's healthy, that's all that should matter.
Padre-D Productions
Going from 260 to 105 in a few months required some extreme training that probably resulted in days, maybe even weeks, of not eating. You can be underweight and people feel that this is going to low. There is no damned if you do damned if you don't scenario. This is a going to far to one end and then going to far to the other. There's is a middle ground that people should be hitting.
RememberRox
People say a lot of things. People who are over 300 lbs have said they felt great and health, as have people under 100 lbs.
After losing all that weight I think she looks great but a lot older doesn't she ? !
a bmi of 18 isn’t even THAT underweight. it’s literally right at the start of being underweight.
zavia romanova hahaha mine is 13 😂ops
Honey Kommentator that’s awful
It's not yet underweight but I'd be on the lookout, same as when you have a BMI of 25, it's not overweight but I'd be watchful
@@honey2691 that is actually bad, mine is 21
Honey Kommentator please get professional help! You are loved and it’s important to love yourself as well
Because slightly below healthy is as worse as 140 pounds above healthy ?
lol she can gain a bit of weight but you guys are shitting yourselves
Exactly
Oh, and yo-yo-ing is another dangerous possibility. The stress it puts on the body to lose weight quickly, does harm to every internal system. That harm shows up later in life, so people don't make the connection. To gain the weight back, creates even more damage. Fat stores toxins. Fat is a great protector. So, while it is unhealthy to be obese, losing weight needs to be done in a way that doesn't attack the body/hate the fat (as fat is a good thing in moderation). When you lose weight quickly, toxins stored in the fat to protect the body, are released into the body quickly, and the body can't heal itself properly. If you lose weight at a slow, consistent rate--the body can cleanse the body of those toxins. And that's just one of the many ways in which it's bad to lose weight too quickly...
idk, if she's developed an unhealthy relationship with food/body now, and is afraid to go back to being "ugly," she might lose even more weight.
I think its the amount she lost in such a little time is the worrying thing. I almost died from anorexia. I went from obese to underweight within 6 months (actually slightly less). I lost 90lbs and was lucky to have my heart beating.
XakashinaX... Youre an idiot. bmi for someone at 5'7 and 140lbs is LEGIT HEALTHY! It's a bmi of 21!!!! yikes. you might want to actually learn what an overweight bmi is. Overweight bmi: 25+ and a obese bmi is 30+.... lol yikes.
she's still healthier now then b4
Whatever goes Thin doesn't equate healthy.
What? No she isn't, wtf?
Bonita L I don't recall saying it does :)
Zari valentine It's closer to healthy than morbidly obese
CaT Vee yes she is fuck ass
If she’s 24 then I’m 8
Grace Hunziker she started at 24
ariel make em mad being obese takes a toll on your body. I’m not making a dig, just like being overweight and losing the weight can age u + toxins from foods that generally cause obesity make you look older. Could be it
Grace Hunziker you were 260 pounds when you were 8 jeez are you ok
That Rasist fuck down the street 🤦♀️
She looks 10 years older on the after picture
from age 24 to age 42 in a matter of months
sad isnt it
Boitumelo Koopedi exactly, she looked beautiful and healthy before
no she was over weight it was not healthy
Princess Mia being "overweight" doesn't automatically equate to being unhealthy. just like being skinny doesn't automatically equate to being healthy, as you can see here.
artie yeah of course but before she weighed 260 pounds with was not healthy
105 pounds is better than being obese
Tomm Swiift It is
And
Yup!
And it will always be
Unless it's too skinny for her height. Then she can look sick and malnourished
No one says “man, she gained too much weight too fast.” Even though 60% of America is overweight, and they are dying of heart disease and type 2 diabetes in droves. Basically no one statistically is dying from losing weight too fast.
Zachariah Gray she lost the weight too quickly
@@ReplyGuy22345 If she maintains the weight loss and allows her body to adjust, it doesn't even matter. The issue with losing to fast the difficulty in maintaining and stress on the body. Obviously, if she was overly obese her entire life- she needed to do something dramatic and a slow deficit wasn't going to work for her
As long as she's happy then who are we to judge...
angela b when she could be unhealthy
she may be happy and her organs may shut down soon. cool, eh?
angela b this is unhealthy and she could die so most people are supporting her while others are trying to keep her healthy
She couldve starved herself our binge and purge.
As long as we apply the same standards to her previously-overweight self, I agree completely
She busted her ass, she worked hard. Don't hate on other people's progress if you don't have the guts to do it yourself. BMI is out dated and don't mean shit.
But if you look at her, you just tell that she looks underweight, ignoring numbers and BMI.
This is promoting a disease. Anorexia ain't a fuckin joke.
She has a full blown eating disorder skin and bones…. but what do I know I've only been involved with fitness for 8 years. No one is hating on her I feel bad for her, it's the shows and networks fault for allowing this bullshit… possibly the trainers
> BMI is out dated and don't mean shit.
AH OH,
looks like we have a fatty!
Point and laugh everyone.
Dagger Blood haha blind fuck
John Chen what?!? Rachel looks fine to me.
Hey, she won $250,000. I would have literally starved myself for that amount of prize money. Leave her alone.
how did she not have saggy skin??
+XxEmmJayxX She is YOUNG... if she had been in her 50's for example she would be saggy now!
+kaminoneh bhoot Thanks for that... I've seen old people with loose skin but not a young person. I stretched out to over 60 excess lbs when I was pregnant in my teens and had no loose skin when I returned to normal...
+XxEmmJayxX Clenbuterol and a few other "supplements" to assist. She did this with the help of drugs.
+XxEmmJayxX I used to be only 20 lbs overweight, even after i lost all that, i have lose skin on my tummy that doesn't look normal on my body now
+kaminoneh bhoot If they won't disclose, then how do you know?
Oh COME ON. 5'4 and 105 pounds is still a LOT healthier than 5'4 and 260 lbs. Her old BMI was 44.6! And healthy is between 18.5-24.9. This woman is only 3 pounds below the healthy weight- and that's nothing. Some runway models are 20+ pounds below the healthy weight. I'm sure she could gain that 3 lbs no problem. Her losing 155 lbs is definitely a LOT more difficult than gaining 3 lbs and a much bigger achievement.
This is a good example that no matter what you do. people will always find something to criticized about you. And also she perfectly healthy now
well she doesnt look 24 anymore.. she looks like she is in her 40s tbh.
She’s gonna look better soon
I’m 39 and look in my 20’s
She look 20 yrs older after losing all those weight
how long until ketosis
True!
Fuck is wrong with you fat shit. She actually looks good now
She looks like a skinny old bag now
Harman Khinda she look like a skeleton
But if her bmi was slightly over the recommended, everyone would chime in with "the bmi doesn't apply to alllll....she's just thicccccc....a bit more weight doesn't harm youuuu...". Hypocrisy at its finest.
Why are you bringing thick girls into this?
So sad that they criticize her for being overweight now too skinny. This poor girl can't win
24 years old but looks 42
Jared Sheldon that’s true .
"had a cheek bone"
Jared Sheldon Yeah she lost that cheek bone a while ago 😂
That's because she was overweight and lost the weight quickly causing the skin to go loose.
stop the bullshit.
They’re just butthurt she succeeded her goal, she even passed it. A queen
Overweight people get more hate than underweight people maybe i should throw up and starve myself to feel more accepted
The Unpopular Opinion no! It’s never right to do that to yourself. Take it easy, and no matter what weight you are heavy or not everyone is unique and amazing in their own way
That is not good...
@@ashleyk8406 how
v Because she went too far...
Where is all the excess skin? Just staying
NIllY ELS ikr
NIllY ELS are you blind?? That's why she looks older excess skin
Daphne Goldlee what about on the body and other parts?
I think she tucks it in
Your staying ?
no matter what happens someone will always be "offended" by anything anyone does.
Ah~ I can hear the jealous women hating from a distance
And and
She’s so short, 105 isn’t that skinny for a girl that height
Just women, eh? Smh 🙄
@@sparklebutt1119 why would men be jealous of a woman looking good?
Why because skinny people are put on pedistoles
BMI means nothing. BMI is useful to look at statistics for populations but isnt as important for individuals whats concerning is the rate at which she dropped the weight, but she is much healthier now than before. All in all it was a great thing for her. She also likely was dehydrated for the weigh in in order to 'win' which makes her BMI look lower than it actually is. If she was just 3 lbs heavier shed be normal weight according to BMI.
It is not that much about her weight it's that this show is celebrating unhealthy behaviour i.e. losing weight really fast. It's not how you do it. It's eating disordered.
@@denisenova7494 but the whole point is to lose weight so you don't have to face complications in later life, and she hasn't had any negative effects from not being obese so far...
Your weight is based on your body composition
Augustine Daudu There is no health problem with losing weight fast , did you hear them give any ? any evidence ? I drop over 20 pounds in 2 weeks of water fasting every march and there is nothing bad
Big Red What the hell is water fasting...Is that when you don’t drink water? That sounds super unhealthy.
She isn't too thin at all. As long as she's healthy and her doctors say she is doing well then Kudos to her! Anyone would go to extreme under pressure to lose it quick with money on the line. People are so quick to judge others.
Did u not hear the doctor say this isn't healthy weight for a "5"4 girl , to be honest this is kinda weird that is the normal weight of a 12 year old girl like I weigh 105 and I'm "5'3 but Ik I'm not fat bc the doctor says I'm heathy so that's all that matters
Kailee Moore you don’t get to say if she’s healthy or not. Only doctors can do that, she’s better now than before and many women are very skinny bcs that’s how they‘re
ENFP PINK BUBBLE But Her BMI is under being healthy so obviously she's too skinny.
ÖRLOGSKAPTEN #MAKERUclipsGREATAGAIN BMI isn't reliable tbh. It doesn't take account for your body composition. I could look great and toned and feel amazing but be considered overweight because of muscle mass and such
Sarah Zietz s
You just can't win in this messed up society 😕
True. It’s not attractive to be skinny, chubby or fat. What do we do?
Why is it acceptable for someone to be "slightly over" their BMI than be slightly under. So stupid
Nicole Stanford as your more likely to get ill being a stone underweight than a stone overweight
It's not. Look at all of the angry people.
260 lbs isnt slightly over your BMI
welcome to my life
Fr
Honestly , she does look like she aged about 14 years.
Yeah but she looks more attractive because she's healthier, she should still put on a few more pounds though cause she's underweight.
How come I'm not attracted to her?
trmbne2014 um... because different people have different preferences. What a foolish question.
Romono Pilowki exactly. People have a variety of preferences. You made a foolish statement in your first comment
trmbne2014 no, it's a biological fact that thinner people are more physically appealing. It's because they have a better likelihood of being healthy and producing healthy offspring. Were you attracted to her when she was morbidly obese? Because if so, something is probably wrong with your mental chemistry. Objectively, she became much more attractive after losing the weight.
2014: She lost a little more than is healthy
2019: Health at every size
its not how much it she lost its how fast she lost it
people just can't be pleased
She looks absolutely amazing, I think we shouldn’t be criticizing her
Phoebe O'Donnell body fat is important to those hormone functions but only a little bit really. You don’t need a whole lot of body fat for that to work normally. She’s fine, this isn’t really unhealthy. She is a few pounds beneath the average BMI range for her height and age, that’s not unhealthy, just not average which doesn’t mean healthy. It’s not the appearance she’s being awarded for either, it’s the fact of how much she lost and how drastic a change it was in a good direction. I don’t know her personally, but unless she has a legitimate eating disorder, this ain’t a problem.
She did amazing and I am sure nobody would question her current weight if she had never been obese before. But.... I just wonder where is her loose skin?!?!?! Amazing
Better than being fat tho
ya she looks way healthier
Well not necessarily. Now this is a very extreme example but if you were lost in the wilderness with no food. You can use you fat reserves to live so. Lol. It’s a survival aspect kind of.
Zach Johnston m
O
Zach Johnston still not healthy idk what your trying to to say soo...
mellow m but it’s not her organs might fail on her and she might die so not necessarily healthy
I wonder if there would be any controversy if it was a guy that lost 60% of his weight.....
Yes 🙄
People wouldn’t defend him and say people are “jealous” unlike this chick lmao.
Ashley Kleinvehn I’m defending her. She did great. It’s not unhealthy either, she is just a few pounds beneath average. And for her frame, that might be perfect.
When she was (edit) *overweight*everyone said”omg she’s too fat” now that she lost weight everyone says “omg she’s too skinny” at what point are people satisfied I mean NEVER!? if she feels good it’s her body she can do what ever the heck she wants to do so STOP JUDGING!
She lost that much to win the competition you know it wasn't because she wanted to look that skinny. After the show she went up to around 125 to be at a weight she was comfortable with.
Mariana Santana you make me real mad, you know it’s not healthy to lose that much weight? She literally weighs less than me idiot. She obviously lost that much to win the competition. And, have you ever heard of water cutting? You literally remove liquid from your body to gain weight. She probably used that way. And we say whatever we think alright? It’s called freedom of speech idiottt. And she could die from that amount of weight loss.
@@minzy9279 it's 2018. Is she die already?
Mariana Santana were not judging. We’re caring about her health because she is UNDERWEIGHT she lost so much pounds in such a little time that it’s not healthy. People these days think that being overweight or underweight is ok or healthy well it’s not! It’s not healthy for her.
Emily Mcgoldrick well, its her life and she can do whatever she wants with it. She probably signed a contract that told her the results and risks of joining the game show. We are not responsible for her actions and have no right to judge her.
Is she 24 years old?!!?! She looks like 40!!
+Jane L She gained about 20 pounds a few months after the finale and has said that she agrees she was probably a bit too skinny at the finale and feels like she's at her perfect weight now
watcheem she looks like 34
I remember my first reaction to this was she lost too much, and for the record I'm a thin physically fit man, my wife a thin physically fit woman thought the same thing. She looked almost skeletal, but she was trying to win an enormous amount of money and she did what she had to to earn the victory. If she just puts five-ten pounds of lean weight back on after the shows finale she'd look perfect. If you watch the second to last episode she looked perfect at that point healthy and strong.
"If she gained five-term pounds she'd look perfect" you are literally promoting the problem we are criticizing. What you think of her weight doesnt matter. No one care what weight you think she would look "perfect" at, you're just telling her what to do with her body to be more physically appealing to what you personally see as healthy. You dont get to pretend to be supportive then tell her she's look better if she gained 5 pounds
@@SaraH-jn5db ok she'd look healthy, how about that? You can believe what you want but it's not healthy to starve yourself to skin and bones, it's called anorexia. It's not my "opinion" that anorexia and obesity are unhealthy, and I highly doubt she would have starved herself to that weight if she wasn't competing for a cash prize. It's the reason I hate the biggest loser in general, it's making a game out of a serious life threatening problem and substituting one unhealthy obsession for the other extreme isn't healthy or a good example for impressionable men and woman. Also I wrote this over a year ago, you're a bit late to the party aren't you?
@@davidmayberry3190 here's a reply two years later then. She's perfectly healthy and has a fitness Instagram, let's see what ELSE you can come up with to disapprove of. Also the fact that you and your wife are both lean and on the muscular side just shows you have no idea of what it feels like to be obese and losing over 100 pounds to completely reinvent your body from inside and out. There's this thing called a healthy dose of sadism when you have to lose that much weight to keep going, which is night and day compare to always being thin and just putting on a measly 5-10 pounds of muscle.
she looks fine.. athletic and muscular to me.. obviously much healthier than when she started her journey..
I don't understand why everybody except her doctor is worried.. seriously everyone's opinion, including random twitter users, was taken.. everyone except those you are professionally qualified to comment.
Nikita Giri it's not how much she lost it's how quickly she lost it
Atheletic and muscular??. Not to be rude but I dont see any muscle at all or atleast not enough muscle.
She does have muscle, but her weight is a little too low. She could do with a good 10 to 15 more pounds on her. That would be a very good weight.
poor girl....she must be thinking that anything she does/ any way she looks, she'll always be judged and criticized
believeitspossible it’s not judging we’re just concerned about her organs failing and her might dying
@@illshankyousogoaway8124 she has a fitness Instagram and is healthier than ever. Just take the L and stop hiding behind jealousy. People who fat shame are literally using the same "I am just concerned" argument all the time.
muscular 105lb is healthier than fatty 260lb
She's thin. Not muscular
@@berlinwall6674 I think she has anorexia that's why she doesn't look muscular even though she trained everyday during the game show.
Ifk it seems unhealthy she is literally the weight of a 12 year old
I’m inspired.
2 sit-ups later never mind
Blue Spike what a comment 😂
1 sit up then burger.. 🍔
lnaooo
She looks great im really proud of her!!!
And unheañlhy
@@ashleyforever4457 She's 3 pounds underweight. I'm at that BMI and I've never been told I look unhealthy.
@@ashleyforever4457 stfu
Omg why can’t people just be happy for people when they make a goal😭😭😭
Me personally I woulda lost as much weight as possible too to win and gain a little back afterwards
keont'e pringle The best comment so far.
keont'e pringle From what i gather she apparently has put on a bit more weight. So it's likely exactly what you are saying occurred.
+keont'e pringle Me too! For $250,000 I would be anorexic for a few months then go back to eating healthy.
the thing is, it's easier to gain than lost, especially when she lives in America. So i wouldn't worry about her tbh.
This lady weighs the same as me and I'm 12 lol
Gray and Ethan Mendes omg same.what does this mean like am i overwieght for my age or no
roaar tiger - lol ur underweight 😂😂
It depends on your height to
I'm heavier than her and I'm 12....
X BOX 12 weighing 105 is unhealthy to you???
She literally looks healthy. This just proves that you’ll be judged no matter what
So true !
Haters gonna hate 😐😑
"looks" - this is the problem. She LOOKS great. The WAY this show made people lose weight was dangerous.
OMG ppl are going fucking crazy with this, her BMI is 18 and healthy range is 18-25 so she's fine
>18.5 is healthy. 18 is not.
Lauren Gustafson I'm a nutritionist in canada and we use 18, What you have to look at is the bodyfat % muscle mass body composition anyway, nothing indicates that she's unhealthy right now.
Ahh, assumed you were from the U.S. I have a degree in nutrition/dietetics we use 18.5
Marie Ada I'm a nutritionist and personal trainer, it's not accurate in the sense that it doesn't take into consideration if your weight is muscle or fat but ppl who can have health problems are usually way under 18, still.
The healthy benchmark is actually 18.5, but whatever... the BMI didn't count her frame type. Being boney equals sickness not health. If you think this slinky individual is healthy, I highly recommend you get your money back from whatever place your got your accreditations and degrees from, because this woman is clearly not healthy looking. She looks typical of Hollywood actresses and reminds me of Christian Bale from "The Machinist". She has no mass which is why her eyes are snuck in and her bones protrude. A healthy individual doesn't have that. She has aged dramatically too. She is 24 but looks way older... wtf!?
I’m happy to hear she put on 20lbs after the show. She stays out of the spotlight, including social media, but she’s stated that she feels like she’s at her perfect weight.
I’m surprised about everyone’s negative reaction to her 105lb frame. I weigh 170 pounds and I’m pressured and made to feel bad by almost everyone around me for not being skinny and having a chubby stomach. Even when I weighed 134 pounds I was told to lose weight. People I know believe the skinner the better. I started going to the gym because I can’t bare to look at my body anymore. I’m not fat, I’m an ‘average’ size girl. Whatever that means.That’s society in a nutshell.
Is she dead? Is she crying? Is she complaining? Is she not proud? Exactly she's smiling and she's proud if she's happy I'm happy they knew what they signed up for and she's looking like a goddess anyway
One word: Jealousy
Morgan Listenbee yuppppppp
I know, I'm around 105lbs and other girls even grown women are so rude about my weight, I also loose weight very quickly.
how describe i dont what you mean please thanks
“Emaciated”, seriously? BMI doesn’t determine whether you’re healthy or not.
It's supposed to be a guideline, if you feel fine and your BMI is 19(skinny side) or 24(chubby side) no one should care.
But if you are constantly out of breath, have trouble sleeping, headaches etc(endless list) then weight can be an indicator. Your BMI is 19 and you are constantly out of breath, damn that doesn't sound good, maybe you eat too little or are malnourished. And vice versa.
But if someone has a BMI of 17 or 27 then their diet needs to change, if they are an average person with a 9 to 5 deskjob
That depends on your bmi.
I just wanna know how her skin is so smooth and not stretched out
She was obese not morbidly obese there is a difference between the two . I was 180lbs now i am down to 141lbs but would like to lose more.
The people who are shaming her show that they are jealous to her achievement. 😕😕
Uhh no I don’t want to be 105 pounds
Jealous of white men putting skinny white women om a pedistole nah they have low self esteem
Well i have 90 pounds but im 4'5 so i guess its normal
people will be always jelous of something, maybe, instead of sitting in front of your screens right now, you do something with your life? Stop bullying her, stop making stupid comments, it's her body and she feels great in it. That's what matters.
I came here cause Jerry Ward was saying something about that girl, never heard of that show and of her before ever.
Fuck the skinny bitches Mann I rather have a thicky instead of a stick
BattlePL bitch please
She was monitored by doctors, trainers, and nutritionists. Yet she gets criticized. Sad.
BREAKING NEWS:
Biggest Loser winner Rachel Frederickson tells Us Weekly that she has reached her perfect weight, *after gaining 20 pounds.*
Now you can stop bitching!
Thank you! You are the first one to mention this. People are crying wolf over the fact that she was skinny, and borderline anorexic. People don't realize SHE CAN GAIN SOME OF THE WEIGHT BACK AND BE PERFECTLY HEALTHY! Lay off people, get a grip!
105lbs isnt too thin. people get over it
It depends on the person's height. In her case, 105 pounds is too low for her. That's a weight for a 4'9 - 5'0 ft person.
Gabriel Apostol Thank you.
considering how tall i am, if it was my Weight, i'd be suffering from anorexia
potthead meg bull shit. it dépends on the height
What doesn't stir controversy in America, really?
I feel like I shouldn’t eat cookies anymore
Naila Din: Why not? Don't let the media manipulate you and don't let them stop you from doing what you like and loving yourself.
the host of this show looks the same weight as her, lol hypocrites
I think she looks great.
Yes thats right she's so pretty
I hate when fitness trainers think they know what it's like to be morbidly obese it's not just physically depleting it's mental to and it's never been harder to lose weight ever since now
Why does she look older now tho
Loose skin
starvation ages you
texting stories lose skin...
Honestly I have been overweight my whole life, working on losing weight, I would much rather have to deal with under BMI vs over
You cant control her life so dont judge . As long as she is happy let her
omg people judged her for being too big now people are judging her for being to small, the poor thing cant win and must feel terrible about the constant criticism she's faced from society, can everyone just let her be happy
It is because she lost too much weight, too fast and could be suffering from a life threatening illness now. The show should be promoting healthy weight loss, not starvation diets. She may need help.
blueyes6474 you mean skinny not small theres a difference
I've been curious about how she's doing but none of her social media has been updated since 3 years ago.
Um...I'm 5'3" and weigh 104 lbs. and my doctor said I'm perfectly healthy. Pretty sure Rachel will be fine.
Exactly what I was thinking. Looks can be deceiving, and everyone's body is different. Just because you're a certain height doesn't mean you have to conform to the same exact criteria as everyone else. People enjoy shaming others whether or not they're "too fat" or "too skinny."
And I can't even loose 10 pounds..
The issue isn’t how much she lost, it’s how quickly she lost it. 52 pounds a month?
Exactly its better to lose weight slow and do cardio as well as lifting weights but people are stubborn nowadays
Her BMI is 18, only 0.5 below the Underweight/Healthy line.
but look at her face! look on google. her face is all bones. it is empancipated. she is the smallest so far. she is WAAAAY thinner than all of the other winners. once you go that low, its VERY hard to get back to A HEALTHY WEIGHT. people who have never had an eating disorder or anorexia, its hard for them to understand. her whole mental mind will be changed. she thinks she looks healthy right now. it will be difficult for her to chage her mind set for her to gain weight again. this is a downward spiral. I had anorexia, I know. I had an eating disorder. I was obsessed with food, and did the opposite and got obsessed with not eating and exercising. look her up on google and she all her photos. her arms and legs are too skinny. her face is gaunt. Im 130 at 17 and im lean. this is ridiculous. shes way to thin and sadly, she can't even see it. the judges faces were shocked!!!!!!! that's why twitter is roaring with how thin she is! this is not healthy and strong. she is bony..
xxcrazycoloredhairgirlxx The pictures make me want to vomit.
***** lol sorry your right I spelled it wrong :p
The reason her BMI is still almost in the healthy range is because she's so short...
Now, if she was 5'7" or 5'8", THAT would be dangerous.
Mike Hawk Do not bring bmi in to this. The BMI scale is one of the most ludicrous "measurements of health" ever. It is completely inaccurate and is not a good determination of a persons health.
Rachel was dedicated and reached her goal, she is happy and healthy now and that's important. Good job!
She didn't look 24 years old afterwards....
You all are fucking ridiculous and mean at first people doubted her, called her fat, and ugly but now that she is skinny you want to keep on judging her .. you can not please society honestly i'm glad she got that weight off , did you see her smile I know she felt good about herself how can she honestly keep being happy with herself if the world is still bringing her down for something that she thought would make society happier not only you all but herself and her family. grow the fuck up for once, and stop dissing her for something she thought would be right.
You do realize that she was damaging her body to win money right? She lost her period, was extremely dehydrated and her hair was falling out. I wouldn't be happy for her. You are blind if you really think this show is about a glorious journey to a healthier life.
well you did not realize that I did not know all that was happening to her, and I am not blind lol, but you guys yeah society are not happy with anyone! yes she was unhealthy as a fat ass not she is unhealthy as a skinny ass! what the fuck do you guys want her to be? huh no one can please you guys, its her fucking life if she wants her hair to fall out let that shit fall out in the end are you picking it up off the floor nope, or even if she wants diabetes are you going to be the one buying her meds nope! so why the fuck are we setting here disagreeing on eachothers comments? bye now
You hate skinny people. So you're judging people purely based off of their appearance. You're just as bad as someone who says they hate overweight people. God, this is ridiculous. What an ignorant fuck.How do you just shove all skinny people into one category of assholes?
Sorry you went through all that but we don't all act nasty. I don't like you because you seem like you're judgemental before you even know someone.
TaBelieveKally Theres a difference between skinny and healthy. Sure she's skinny but the journey she took was not healthy. This could come back to bite her in the ass
I never watched the show. Never heard of the person until today. And the methods they employ for this show-not even for this particular person-are not healthy. It's crash dieting. If you want to lose weight sustainably, 1-2 lbs/week is advisable. Employing gradual sustainable changes that you can maintain over the long term. I've seen the show before (it's been a few years) and the way they approach weight loss-drop as much as humanly possible as quick as humanly possible and you get money...? Not healthy.