Egypt vs Israel In The Tank Battle For Sinai | Greatest Tank Battles | Timeline
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 31 май 2024
- Desperate to reclaim territory lost six years previously, Egypt launched an attack against Israel in 1973. Egypt suffered huge losses, but the battle brought lasting peace.
It's like Netflix for history... Sign up to History Hit, the world's best history documentary service and get 50% off using the code 'TIMELINE' bit.ly/3a7ambu
You can find more from us on:
/ timelinewh
/ timelinewh
This channel is part of the History Hit Network. Any queries, please contact owned-enquiries@littledotstudios.com
![DRAGON BALL: Sparking! ZERO - Fused Warriors Trailer [BUDOKAI TENKAICHI Series]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/84p4Lvyfyes/mqdefault.jpg)
![Darren Waller - Who Knew (Her Perspective) [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/GytDjB8u6bM/mqdefault.jpg)
People who said Egypt won lost their mind.
When Egypt failed to achieve its objective. These people start to "invented" some objectives to make it look like Egypt won, as if they live in Sadat's mind.
اذا لماذا. انسحبت. تذكر تم دعمكم. بالجسر الامريكي.لم يكن مع. مصر احد حتى الاتحاد. السوفيتي كان. يتكلم. الكلام. فارغ.
@@mohamadrajab3544
What are you trying to say lol
The thing is that I have noticed, never underestimate the opponents. That's what I have noticed about war doc's. I really like watching them. I myself have been spared this pain of war but many in my bloodline have not. I appreciate my freedom that all have died an fought for. Thanks be to God n man who provide all I have. Thank you.
As a soldier who's fought in several battles I can tell u ... Combat is glorious honour. Being able to kill ur enemy is fun
@@deneshbhaskar3944 then you are a liar or a psychopath. No one with Honor thinks that way. I guess all your battles are in Call of Duty.
@@trustedsource1273 he's indian, never trust a word of what they say
@@deneshbhaskar3944 maybe ur a mercenary..it is not fun to kill anybody...it's often a matter of life or death..or one's military or patriotic duty...but never fun..Killing another human being should never be fun...Some people would jail u for shooting a fox..or a rabbit..hunting is considered an activity or passtime..and is rarely given the term "fun" Fox hunting may look like a sport...it's of course a blood sport.We humans seem to be blood thirsty .At least we get charged a liscence fee for hunting..legal hunting.Perhaps it will replace killing people...in war..for fun..as u say.Pathetic cocept killing people as being fun.✌💜
The Sinai Peninsula, a vast Desert in Western Egypt. Where did you buy your map? North Korea?
😂
Lol
The script writer/narrator should be fired
In comparison with Israel is really vast.
@@navidkarimi2552 Oh bro 🤣🙄 He said that not because they said Vast, but because they said Western Egypt, and The Sinai is in Eastern Egypt actually lol.
You are so Awesome. Thank You for the upload.
Good video, but it gives the impression that the Israeli Air Force did not play a significant role. They did suffer significant losses to SAMs early on, but adapted and ended up playing a significant role both against Syria and in the counter attack against Egypt.
But Sinai belongs to us so we won the war and you get the paper of peace 😅😅😅👋👋
@@a.m347 your country is one of the poorest in the world, people literaly starve in streets
@@kittycatcat6962 This is yourself exactly 😉😂😂
@@a.m347 nope, fridge is bursting I get mad because we have to throw out food sometimes....sad 🇪🇬 is so poor, used to be the breadbasket of the Mediterranean, now its just a gross disgusting place where children starve
You don't even have clean water or constant electricity lmao. Kee0 believing in (p)is(s)lam@@a.m347
Excellent documentary,
I thoroughly enjoyed it.
Thank you.
How could you enjoy this? Sttting in front of a laptop and watching this video game is one thing.But being part of a war and fighting for your life and that of your country is a different story.The screams of wounded,,bleeding soldiers who were to die in a couple of minutes or being paralysed for the rest of their lifes are not mentioned.They were just "casualties".This kind of history narration is irritating.With all the background music and the "beautiful" tank firing,people are invited to get their snacks and alcohol beverage ready to "enjoy" what humans most love:action,fighting and killing.
Want to connect to your communist dad Stalin?
@The_Jaguar_ Knight How did you now? Yepp.I had a bottle of wine and some chips in front of me.Everytime a tank blew up I was whistling and clapping my hands.🤢
Thank you Timeline. 😊 Great documentary
around minute 19:30, it is said "with their surrounded soldiers rescued" or something similar. it's important to note that this is not entirely true, as some posts fell captive (out of 505 soldiers in the post-line, 126 were killed or are missing, 162 were captured, 65 stood still in a remote post unreachable by the egyptian army, and 123 were able to withdraw
Impressive documentary! Great work! The most interesting part was to see veterans talking about their perspective. When we were working on Yom Kippur War Simulator veterans perspective from both sides was extremely valuable for us.
Great History Col.
@@serahyasona8461Free Palestine. Why this Jewish state was not built in the US of America ? As of the 1930s, the Jewish population in the United States was estimated to be around 4.2 million. Meanwhile the Jewish population in British Mandate Palestine experienced significant growth due to Jewish immigration from Europe. According to historical estimates, by the late 1930s, there were approximately 400,000 to 450,000 Jews living in British Mandate Palestine. This demographic shift played a significant role in the development of the region's demographics and ultimately had an impact on the political dynamics that led to the establishment of the State of Israel in 1948. When majority of the Jews were in USA why not give them a state there its simple 4,200,000 in USA vs 400,000 in Palestine. In simple words "Why was the State of Israel not established in the United States, where the Jewish population was much larger than in British Mandate Palestine during the 1930s?" Why come and live in a place where supposedly everyone is their enemy?
Very informative historical video!
I doubt its truthfulness.
They chose Amnon Reshef out of all people to be the front man of this video, and it casts heavy doubts on it.
I heard from one of the soldiers under his command a more accurate version of the truth.
Could have been better to just let a lower ranking (at the time) soldier or even officer to tell what Amnon Reshef said, and it would be one difference between truth and lie.
In other words, in addition to what Amnon Reshef hid in this video, the experiences he shares are other people's experiences.
Most of the time, a colonel sits in a much safer position than his subordinates.
Many thanks!!
Great battle clip
Thanks.
Why do we not give credit where credit id due, God had a hand in this. God doesn't go back on his word, Praise his wholly name.
Okay, my 2 cents: The sound effects are way too loud compared to the voices. The repetitions are annoying. Still, interesting and informative vid! Tanks!
Greets, T.
I completely agree, also dont interview a guy that is only interested in bragging about his combat achievements lol. The others were good.
@opener of the world : thanks man, I'll check 'm out. Appreciate it!
You'd think they could find a Hebrew interpreter who speaks good English. The sound in this video doesn't cut it in many ways.
@@kixigvak AGREED; also the splicing stunk----
I think the sound effects and volume somehow get messed when copied over and over. I've noticed the same thing with some movies that I copied from VHS to digital. Maybe not, but that's what I've experienced.
كَم مِن فِئَةٍ قَليلَةٍ غَلَبَت فِئَةً كَثيرَةً بِإِذنِ اللَّهِ. A small army of newly established Israel defeated the entire Islamic world.
I see a lot of nationalism and subjectivism on both sides in the comments, but the facts are what they are: the only ones who lost this war were the Syrians. Egypt demonstrated that it could be capable of carrying out a successful offensive against Israel, after years of preparation and making excellent use of the infantry with its anti-tank weapons (the Israeli army made the serious mistake of making a military doctrine in which they prioritized the use of tanks without the necessary support from infantry and artillery). But, the truth is that after crossing the canal and establishing defensive positions several kilometers from the canal, the Egyptians also made the inexplicable mistake of not maintaining their push into the Sinai (something that, together with Syrian pressure, would have left Israel vulnerable), giving the Israeli army time to organize, repel the Syrians in the North, stop all the Egyptian assaults launched late and then organize a counter-offensive that managed to cross the channel (using, now yes, the support of the infantry to clear the way for the tanks) and that if it had not been for international pressure from the USSR and the United States, they would have managed to surround the rest of the Egyptian troops that were defending the other side of Sinai and incidentally leave them to at the mercy of aviation (the attack created an opening in the anti-aircraft umbrella) or unable to prevent an advance towards Cairo that would have ended in disaster. It is more than obvious that the Yom Kippur War is a total draw (despite the fact that in this documentary, they want to give the title of winners to the Egyptians), the two sides had successes and failures on the battlefield, however Israel manage to overcome the score at the end; However, more than a military victory, it ended up being a diplomatic victory for both sides, since the two of that technical tie were able to restore their martial pride and at the same time sign a treaty that benefited them mutually, except for Syria (as I said above, the only loser), since the only reason Israel wanted the Sinai was to keep the attacks away from its border, a danger that ended with the final peace with Egypt and in turn the only thing Egypt wanted was to recover the Sinai, achieved it by recognizing Isreal, they both won (no one can say that they are above the other).
whoever made these visuals needs a medal
not the one in 21:06, since they are kv 1 tanks that the egyptians didn't use
also this video was originally taken from the greatest tank battles series
I was a PFC Veterinary Tech at Ft. Dix in early October 1973. My Veterinary Colonel called me at home at about 430 AM and said, “Hays, get in here we’re going to war”
I saw a comment in the Golan heights video from a 101st airborne vet saying they were also ready to go in the Sinai when they heard the war broke out there seems like you guys were ready to go as well?
I was assigned to the 2nd Bn 78th Field Artillery unit in Germany during this war. We were put on high alert and we were very concerned about going to war.
What a great documentary film !
I like how they got veterans from both sides of the war, I wonder it was for the vets to meet again after all those years.
They probably still has grudges and anger after their comrades who had been killed but given they are both driven by national patriotism and militant religious passion, I think it's all concealed in the cover of respect.
@@vuvuvu6291 Egyptian still hold respect compared to Syria
@@vuvuvu6291 religious passion? wtf?
hey BTW I CAME TO THIS VIDEO TO LEAVE A DISLIKE BEHEAD NON JEWS
Why would an Israeli warrior want to meet an Arab? Their government’s have said the destruction of Israel is their goal. I wouldn’t meet with them other than on the field of battle.
Someone needs to take all the awesome military recreations done between 1995 and 2010 and redo them in 4k...keeping the incredible interviews with vets now passed.
B
Not all vets have passed. Far from it.
@@shipless33 Who said they did? What are you talking about? I said "keeping the interviews from those that have passed". Let me explain to you: if the person passed, keep that interview material and redo the other content. Not sure how you got "all vets are dead" from that.
@@jstenberg3192 Okay, just sayin' :)
@@shipless33 Sorry if it sounded like a rant. The internet and all. Lol. Peace my friend.
There’s just something about the T-55 tanks that I love so much! probably the look of it but also getting a bunch of them as vehicles for my plastic army men collection when I was little.
Indian T55 tanks blew up almost 200 Pakistani tanks in 1971 war
Start collecting them now bread Plus all the plastic model soldiers and paint them
I was commander of T 55 ,in czechoslovak army.
@@myguitarjoeany stories?
It's funny Egypt was terribly defeated again, yet still they claim victory in that war.. It's like a sport fan claiming victory in lost game just because of an early lead in the first 10 minutes of the game. This is how the egyptian media and education system portrays this war, claiming victory when you are in reality routed and badly defeated.
1:31
"There is no retreat. We have only one alternative: victory." - Col. Jacob "Jacky" Even
Yea and they retreaded in the end 😂
Thanks!
The Sinai peninsula is on the eastern side of Egypt, not on the west side of Egypt
Nothing was mentioned that this war was also called the Yom Kippur War or The Day of Atonement War - a day of fasting. The Israelis were fasting on that day. That's why the Egyptians picked that day to attack.
of course the israelis were not fasting. they had to fight back !
Sneed
So did us our soldiers were fasting too because we launched war during Ramadan
It was also Ramadan
@@wanderingRebel69 To quote Brezhnev.
We have offered them (the Arabs) a sensible way for so many years. But no, they wanted to fight. Fine! We gave them technology, the latest, the kind even Vietnam didn't have. They had double superiority in tanks and aircraft, triple in artillery, and in air defense and anti-tank weapons they had absolute supremacy. And what? Once again they were beaten. Once again they scrammed. Once again they screamed for us to come save them. Sadat woke me up in the middle of the night twice over the phone, "Save me!" He demanded to send Soviet troops, and immediately! No! We are not going to fight for them."
4 November1973
Thank you ,
You know nowt Dan Snow !
Very informative documentary!
Difficult to concentrate when the interviewee, the translator and the music are all playing at once.
and we get over exaggerated 90s era explosions that zoom past all other levels of audio
Qué bueno sería tener estos docs en español !
It's not about the machine. It's about the men behind the machines.
I stand with the Children of Israel, Moses and Jacob!!
😒 and what about the children of Ishmael ??
Moses never existed! Even the Israeli archeologists admit that!
I own actual Pics from this Battle, as my Uncle was a Reporter and Camera Man at the Battle and he left the photos to me knowing I was very impressed with hie time in the field of battel with only a Camera and a Pencil and Paper.
Are they share any where we can see?
Take out the repetition, and this video might be about 10 minutes long.
American/Canadian documentaries...
@@ihebbenrhouma3957
yes they need numerous repetition before it penetrates into the sparse material between their ears
And this is already an improved, edited version with most of the repetitions already cut from it.
This is part of why they recently (2021-8) reuploaded their videos.
I between commercial breaks & trips to the fridge... great reminder of why I completely quit watching TV. I know how to tap the right side of the screen 3times & then back 1 if needed
Excellent technical introducing of this video
misleading , israel ater crossing were heavily beaten in two cities they tried to over take so being miles from cairo was completely useless
Best episode of season 2.🤘
So many stories, so many wars, and I love it!
@opener of the world
what's with the copy paste repetition?
@opener of the world Bro you should keep quiet how that tiny nation destroyed your army twice and were on the brink of capturing Cairo. 4 big Arab countries were defeated by that small nation of under 10 million people. It's shameful.
Operation “Nickel Grass”
If it wasn’t for the mighty US,there would be no Israel today.
Wars are not won by infantry! Sadat was a genius.
🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸 helped the Israelis.
Of course we did, the US tends to do that. Then years later, we're having to fight the same people we armed. Bad things happen when you have others fight your battles for you. That's not always the case of course, just the irony in it all gets me. Give it some time and I promise there will be US soldiers and allies getting killed by the weapons we left with the Taliban.
I was with the 82nd airborne. We was the first unit to deploy there as a peace keeping force. Then relieved by the 101st airborne in no November 1982
I was with 2/327th and went there in Aug 1983…
Quite hot
Beautiful sound.mousic. Derek Wist
A lot of Egyptians claimed that Israel has military supremacy by US support. USSR Premier Leonid Brezhnev said otherwise:
"We have offered them (the Arabs) a sensible way for so many years. But no, they wanted to fight. Fine! We gave them technology, the latest, the kind even Vietnam didn't have. They had double superiority in tanks and aircraft, triple in artillery, and in air defense and anti-tank weapons they had absolute supremacy. And what? Once again they were beaten. Once again they scrammed [sic]. Once again they screamed for us to come save them. Sadat woke me up in the middle of the night twice over the phone, 'Save me!' He demanded to send Soviet troops, and immediately! No! We are not going to fight for them."
Range is everything in these kind of tank battles.
reported this video for copyright violation because the original is from National Geograpic Channel and i mailed them about this act of violation
@@rachelabrantegil3937 Sissi, these documentaries are available all over youtube with multiple other channels not to mention the entire internet. They should be available to anyone as they are years old now
@@rachelabrantegil3937 look at the description, they literally obtained the license to distribute the documentary. Also, National Geographic does not produce military documentaries. I have no idea what you were smoking when you reported the video
Important, but not singularly.
My father was a first lieutenant in the October War in the artillery corps of the Egyptian Second Field Army
Sadly his service in war was necessary to peace.
glad that you guys are living in peace now. better for both sides mate.
Long live Israel
@@Coolidge2329 how old are you?
Israel
Nice and interesting historical documentary of the 67 and Oct war,but I was a bit annoyed by the frequent loud explosions😎
So you're annoyed by loud explosions in a documentary about war? Lmfao the irony!!!
@@Blackhawks87 well said😂
Things I noticed about documentaries of the Yom Kippur War
1.) never mention the air battle of Mansoura
2.) never mention the Battle of Suez
3.) never mention the Battle of Ismalia
ده اللي انا لاحظته برده ومش في الفيديو ده بس في معظم الفيديوهات الاجنبيه اللي بتتكلم عن حرب أكتوبر
@@user-pf9jh9hj8s بية الضبط ما انا قلت كلو الفيديوهات عن الحرب دية متكلمش عن المعركات دول
This show is about tank battles, not an entire war.
@@Thomas_TdK exactly
Why would they? It's clearly about tense tank battles
dm this was a difficult war to survive if i imagined that some one can survive !!
My uncle did luckily.
Israelis lived for generations knowing that the October 1973 war was a defeat for Israel, a fact that all Israelis know, while Egyptians have been celebrating every year since then.
The famous victory speech given by Sadat in the Egyptian Parliament on October 6, Egyptians celebrate the National Day of the Great October Victory. Then with the spread of the Internet and communication sites, the Israelis woke up from a deep slumber. Then they remembered and said we won. This is ridiculous..........................
..
Egyptian army is the first established army on earth and the human factor that lead to the victory as Egyptians fight in harsh conditions the desert.its no surprise, Egypt may get sick but never die.
Love my History Channel!
@opener of the world LOL LOL LOL LOL ...Arabs will always be Arabs and refuse to see REALITY!!! LOLOLOLOL
Opener, the Arabs were not good people back then. Hahaha!@
Egypt did not have Ariel Sharon and Moshe Dayan.And they never will have such geniuses
Music way too loud.
The spokesman did a booboo at the beginning that the producer didn't catch. He stated, "The Sinai Peninsula . . . a vast desert in WESTERN Egypt." The Sinai is the northeastern corner of Egypt.
not very clever, left right, up down = basic error
The second I heard him say "western," I worried about how accurate this video would be.
تحيا مصر ولحد النهارده الي في القلب لسه موجود😊
I agree the best solution is ‘ simply to make peace’ . Would be good if we all value human lives.
It's your volume which is high
him and his father are great at this
@opener of the world again im sure if you look you will find film of the egyptains in cages crying to go home so what is your point ? it sounds like you dont like them .lol
In the end, Egypt lost again, but somehow, they are proud of the defeat. It is like a tennis player who played against federer, played a brilliant 1st set, but in the end lost, again.
Let's not forget that when they reached the cease fire israel was in the west part of the canal, 90 km from Cairo.
When faced with the consequences of your hubris rather than learn and grow...double down.
If Egyptians play against Federer, they would be like:
" My ball landed on Federer's side after 1st serve, therefore I win"
great time!
It was not mentioned but a big reason why the fighting stopped was because of political pressure from the USA and USSR on Israel and Egypt respectively. America was supporting and supplying Israel militarily and the USSR was doing the same with Egypt. In effect, it was a proxy war between the USA and USSR. American and Soviet military advisors were also on the ground and there was the fear that it would get to the stage where American and Soviet military personnel would get dragged into the fighting as well. This was something the 2 superpowers did not want and brokered a ceasefire.
@justsayen c63 Russia has nothing to do with the war. Sadat expelled the Russian experts a year before the war. All that Russia was doing was giving Egypt the old weapon possessed by the sterile twenty-one MiG planes against the modern Phantom and Mirage planes. But the Egyptians had a different opinion
@@abomoaaz7245 Keep crying loser, You wouldn’t even be able to start war again without the USSR Helps after the six day war.
They gave you bunch of the most advance SAM anti-aircraft batteries, MiG-21 a supersonic jet fighter and interceptor aircrafts, T-62 battle Tanks one of the best in that time, huge amounts of anti Tank Missiles and other big- small arms and equipment too, so what else do you want from them, Their nuclear Missiles too?😏🙄😏😏🙄😏
@Mando
Actually,Israel has nukes. So no. Don't even try that. On the other hand,you're both right. Conventionally,Egypt could win against Israel today. But I think israeli aviation would again be decesive factor in such conflict.
@@duskosekulic5143 The Egyptian Air Force is stronger than Isr_ael's air force, and isr_ael cannot use nuclear weapons, and Egypt has deterrent weapons, and the Egyptian army can now wipe Isr_ael off the map, but the problem is in America and in countries that support Isr_ael
@@idontlikekibboub.5192
Don't be fooled,offcourse Israel would use nukes in case egyptian overrunning IDF by sheer manpower. It's matter of survival,nothing else.
Glad they have made peace with each other.
I wouldn't say that.....
Ya, they’re total BFF’s!
Only when Ethiopia become more powerful and a major regional power, only then Israel will be safe from any and all Egypt threats.
They don't really forgive there enemies in that area of the world, nowhere really.
Not peace with evil Israel, 55 years they stole land from Palestine, they make wall to isolated people from Palestine, they make them in prison for nothing, they bombing population innocent. Israel =allied with Satan long years ago.
1973 was a geopolitical situation, Israel wants direct talks with Arabs, refused 3rd rogers plan where they just retreat to mitla passes and ask for part of Sinai or to remain in some of sinais strategic positions, they also refused nonagression agreement offered by Egypt before the war were they would have security guarentees like today . Egypt just didn't want direct negotiations that dont involve the Americans. So sadat launched the war to involve the American as their weapons got destroyed by Soviet ones, as well as to break the idea that security alone guarentees peace .
After the peace the Egyptian got something like 1-2 billion of aid per year
@@kevobrien7346
Yes the shewing gum ,that destroyed our army , economy and soceity to support radical terrorism ! , that we have to rebuild it now after 40 years as it went straight to corruption and making us weaker. Tgey can shocel it down their ar**
the jumpscare at 12:22 literally made me shart lmao. Ill wait til is over plus itll crust n be easier to clean but anywho they shoulda counter attatcked on lake tahie and needle pine ridge
@opener of the world STOP your BS and propaganda. Are you related to Nasser who blamed his defeat on his commander?
Why is the annoying music so loud?
I know right? It's like they turned the annoying music channel way up.
Agrees 100% . I believe we prefer less music’ less production and just an informative, balanced documentary and history.
I don’t believe your target audience is in the 18-24 range. More like 45+ . Thanks
Setting a battle MOOOOOOOOOOD😮
I remember all of President Sadat's problems with the Soviets until he had enough of them and expelled them from Egypt before the war began.
The Soviet Union wanted the situation to remain as it is and did not want Egypt to launch a war to restore its occupied lands. It was asking them repeatedly for weapons not like those serving in the Soviet army, but to make it even after Israel steps
And they were meeting him with refusal for 5 years. Sadat asks them for weapons that contain technology, and the Soviets refuse and say we will provide you with defensive weapons and not offensive in nature. Weapon models. So old that they stipulated that Sadat should not use these weapons without their permission, knowing that Egypt was paying the price of this weapon to the Soviet and Arab countries and stopped spare parts before the outbreak of the war
Until Sadat came to the conclusion that the Soviets did not care about the occupation of the lands of Egypt and all that concerned them was their interest with America until he expelled all the Soviet experts before the start of the war.
In other words, the Soviets knew it was a stupid move to attack Israel. Sadat didnt listen and it cost him his air force, his tank corps and thousands killed. Eventually it cost him his life. Still think it was a good move?
@@johnkidd1226 No, in other words Egypt could have done a lot more with better weaponry and negotiated better terms but Soviets thought they knew the capabilities of the Egyptian army better than they actually did.
@The_Jaguar_ Knight What choice did he have. It was either lose an all out war with Israel or choose to make peace. The people didnt realize that was the choice.
@@johnkidd1226 Sadat didn't make peace with Israel to avoid war, he made peace because after expelling the soviets he needed a new ally which is the us.. after the peace agreement he secured us funding and weaponry and of course got Sinai back. he could have just settled for a ceasefire like Syria did.
@@johnkidd1226 Yes it was a good move. We have Sinai. You don't.
The October war ended as the biggest and most fantastic military victory for the IDF, and for any army ever.
Oyez, Oyez, Oyez!
It was setup between Sadat and Golda directed by Kissinger
In your dreams Sinai is Egyptian now.and the EDF is the greatest Armey of the world. 🇪🇬
@@ibrahimaladawy lol
victory ? victorious side don't return occupied lands , and if so I don't see Israeli people celebrating this war every year as you do in six days war and that's simply because the October war was total humilaction Israel forces which lead to lose entire Saini and Suez canal
Didn't know Timeline produced Greatest Tank Battles
They didn’t. They license the different videos from the owners.
Why too many animation and why too little of any historical photos or video. The animation became distracting.
Sinai peninsula is in the eastern desert of Egypt not west.
It is to the west of Israel yes. But east of Egypt
I bet Israel now has secret tanks with iron dome defence system, waiting for someone to attack...😂.
At just after 21 minutes, talking about the failed Syrian offensive, we see what are clearly Russian KV-1s and then at 25:54, talking about the devastating destruction of the Egyptian tanks advancing through the Sinai, there is footage of an Israeli M-51 burning - I don't think M-51s were used on that front.
The Sherman was redesigned by Israel and became known as the M-50 and M-51. In the States they were referred to as "Super Shermans. They were ulimately outfitted with 105 mm cannons which required a comprehensive turret design change. They were given a diesel engine and heavier armor. Actually, a few Shermans were used in the '73 war mostly in the Golan but a few in the south as well. Near Gaza I spoke with one of the tank commanders as he stood in the turret. In the first days of the '73 war four companies of Shermans (and Centurions) stopped Syrian T-62s and T-55 tanks and pushed Iraqi Tanks back into Syria.
It should be noted that while state of the art equipment is an advantage, it is the manpower that ultimately makes the difference as was displayed with the tanks both in '67, where T-62 tanks (which were the most advanced at the time), lost to Israeli Shermans, and '73 as well.
Shermans were still around in '77 when I was a an instructor at a tank firing range in southern Israel. Those commanders were amazing in that they gafawed at the modern range finding equipment of the M 60 series of tanks -- they would use a raised thumb! and hit just as successfully. Don't ask me how, I haven't a clue.
Nothing to do with actual documentary or politics, just a true little story and an opinion of an old man. In 1976 my family sailed from Italy to South Africa through Suez Canal, which was reopened to international shipping in 1975. The Sinai side, which before post Yom Kirup war agreement was held by Israel by was clear and empty, while on Egyptian side one could still see remnants of destroyed military equipment many of it Russian origin. My father, who was WW2 veteran, kept looking at it and nodding his head . When I asked why, he said:" Israel. They fought again, beat them up again, survived again, and took care of what was theirs -that was a win" .
For Sadat's great victory in regaining the Sinai in return for peace, he was assassinated.
Not true. He was assassinated by Islamists, whom he oppressed, and who wanted to turn Egypt to Afghanistan.
@@liordagan9342 Like I said, he was assassinated... whatever is your point??
@@robskalas
It wasn't about the peace with Israel. He didn't die for peace. He needed European loans, American weapons, and nobody would give Egypt a loan if they were afraid of another war. He stated many times, that's it's about getting the land back, and as soon as Israel is weak, Egypt will attack.
戦争は嫌だが戦車に乗ってみたい=3
Planning, Quality of weapons, Discipline and proper training of troops, weather, Intelligence on your opponents strength and weakness, the will of your people(Nation). Taking those into account will lead to victory.
Today this kind of tank battle is impossible. I mean this long. Both sides would have destroyers air-to-land ability to strike, Su-30 and F-22 Raptor, both originally to meet one and other in mid-air buth both now able to drop bombs and and other nasty stuff on the offence side infantry. And missiles, that is another story. ( I'm not saying that they have these modern fighters at any side yet but similar little older pieces of aviation art and craft like Su-27 and F-18 Hornet).
Only watched 1:39, couldn´t here what they where saying. To much sound effects and music.
Not many would know, but Nixon, who saw a potential ally in Egypt after Sadat snubbed the Soviet Union, played both sides during this conflict: He continued the American policy of diplomatically supporting Israel alongside placing a nuclear powered fleet in the Mediterranean in case Israeli Forces advanced too far into Egyptian territory.
Israel could have taken Cairo. Americans stopped them.
@@scottymackay1801 rather than Americans, Nixon stopped them. Foreign Policy mattered to him fanatically.
The rest of the Arabs would have joined if they went further. Don't get me wrong total annihilation of Islam would be a great goal but back then the West wasn't poised for a 2 front war with soviet Russia still holding the eastern states of Europe under its yolk
@@ozepaul Arab world itself was divided between the pro-US regimes like Kuwait, Jordan, Turkey(before it's invasion of Cyprus), Persia and Saudi Arabia on one side and Soviet backed governments like Baathists in Iraq n Syria alongside Socialists in Libya and Algeria on the other.
Plus, like I've mentioned, Americans themselves didn't want a protracted conflict and would by default pressurize Israel into withdrawing knowing Israel had already inflicted defeat upon Egypt.
@@Timberwolf1992 defeat? They couldn't even enter small city like Suez and say defeat oh yeah let's not forget air battle of mansoura....
Let’s make it into a movie !!
Smiling brave veteran fighting to save his country.
Did egyptian t55 use apds round,or just apc round?
APC rounds were still used since APDS rounds weren’t exported with the tank
@@andsoiderparound9909 HE fired from t54/55 tank could be as effective as HESH
@@richardque1036 it isn’t HESH has more of an explosive mass than the T-54/55 HE rounds. Its also in the name HESH (High Explosive Squash Head Round) compare to the T-54/55 which is just High Explosive. Even with a fuse timer it is still not effective has HESH.
@@albertful1967 It's kinda easy to remember these names and numbers you just need to remember them on what they look like. that or just play war thunder cause every tank that exist is in there.
@opener of the world and so Israeli still won
2:20 Saini is on the EAST side of Egypt, not the west.
How come i knew who will prevail, before i even start watching
My bunker from the time of the Italian occupation of the Adriatic coast, very good, up to 2.5m thick, had only one iron window, but the iron plate inside was concrete. Sager, or our name is Maljutka (Russian), hit a few centimeters above the window, but I, whose bed was behind the window, thought: I'm done. Everything shook. The whole bunker. the insurgent Serbs and the JNA were shooting from the vineyards and we showered them with machine gun fire. some stayed lying down and others ran away. I looked at the window where Maljutka hit. lay on the ground, only the top exploded and 2/3 remained whole. Cumulative rocket only affects metal. Lucky for us in the bunker though once we got a whole pack of 30 and some rocket from the plane hit the bunker and scratched it slightly.
Croatian independence war.
We Croats also had several T-55s that went to the mountain above Knin, the capital of the rebels, in 2 m of snow. In front of them, the bulldozers went and cleared the way. They overwintered hidden there for more than a year. When the storm started, they fired at Knin and went down and brought the town into semi-encirclement. Tactics with which we broke the resistance of the majority of rebel Serbs and the JNA in two days.
Cant believe a tiny nation fought on three fromts 🤕
So kind of you honey
amazing Egyptian fight to get back their territory and revenge, but will not shy to say Israel also fight back bravely at the end it was good ending as both secure their objectives live and let others live with peace
ya know what would have been better? No war at all and no dead people
God promise abraham isaac, jocob to israel future
@@noellagbo5990 And God gave Sinai to Egypt
@@Planet_Xplorer they kept it for 10 more years, extracted as much oil as they could, and gave it back to Egypt in exchange with eternam peace, no nuclear weapons, no more blockades of Tiran and Suez, recognition of Israel. They even had to sacrifice their lead in the Arab league and strain relationships with other Arab countries
@@Bolognabeef LOL...that's proof that they knew 10 years later they still would pay a very heavy price if Egypt resumes the war. During those 10 years Israel begged to keep its 18 settlements and Egypt refused and the settlers were evacuated by force. Arab league? So what? In Israel you had the Agranat commission and Dyan and Golda were fired because of their failures...the funny thing is that a spy told you that the war was coming. Imagine if you didn't know lol.
Bitter lake was my paper route as a child and a 16 day war in October my birthday 10 16
good and interesting testimonies but i don't like using annoying repeating animations, some authentic filming will be better choice
Egyptians rewrite the History with Victory in the such amazing battle
You call that a victory???
@@mike7864 knowing ourselves not need to be approved . throughout million of years egypt being the only and only ones who can turn misery into revolution and victory . At last we need you not to be happy in our happ.
@@mike7864 if that’s not a victory then what is it ?
@@MJ511KW Sad
@@MJ511KW
It would be a victory for the Egyptians if they were able to take back Sinai by force of arms. Not only did they fail, but they also lost territory west of the Sinai during the 1973 war. When hostilities ceased, following intense Soviet pressure, the Egyptian army was surrounded and on the verge of collapse. Israel finally gave the Sinai back in 1978, with the Camp David Accords. Of course, dictatorial governments always turn heavy defeats into triumphs by exploiting the lack of education of their people.
Those Israeli tanks had one of the earliest renditions of ERA on their Magach 3 (battering-ram) I do believe it was called Blazer idk how effective it truly was
Not in this war later
@@wanderingRebel69 In two years an operational laser system
ruclips.net/video/DB2iF_oDo_I/видео.html
The images (not the real footage) are from some video game, maybe of the same type of war.
The Egyptians/Arabs were equipped by the Soviets, because the US didn’t interefere.
The happy look (like a little boy) on Col Reshef’s face (18’) playing at war, well, real war from which he survived.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Nickel_Grass
God is with his people,🙏
The importance of the war was to restore national pride, which it did. They did have much larger aims, and those were blunted of course. The offensive, against the wishes of Sadat's staff, only came about due to Syrian requests(demands).
@Dragomir Ronilac and had encircled the third army so there was no one to stop them
@Dragomir Ronilac No they did! But they also asked us another question. Perhaps you can answer it: Name one single major city Israel managed to capture? 😂
@@Bolognabeef The 3rd army was in good shape and did not surrender. They had fish and water from the canal so they were not starving as it was claimed.
The aims were not blunted. The objective was to get Sinai and they did exactly that.
It's funny Egypt was terribly defeated again, yet still they claim victory in that war.. It's like a sport fan claiming victory in lost game just because of an early lead in the first 10 minutes of the game. This is how the egyptian media and education system portrays this war, claiming victory when you are in reality routed and badly defeated.
Poor presentation, too many repetitions, cheap & loud music suppressed the voices.
Col. Amnon Reshef is my hero!!!
Never Forget Real victors of War General SaadEl shazly. & General Ariel Sharon
21:05 just throw some ww2 footage of KV-1's that makes sense.
Good catch!
@@robskalas lol thanks!
The story is now told from one side unfortuntly , and this is always a big mistake for documentarians
In order to make a strong documentary film, the story must be from both sides Then you will tell the whole story
The Chinese farm was one of the biggest and strongest battles that took place during the October War, but we wonder who is facing who and what forces actually intervened to transform the results. And swings that happened
Everyone who is talking now, with my respect, knows that they were fighting and behind them was a super air bridge that compensated their losses without any problems
Even with all of that, Egypt achieved it's goals in 1973, crossing in over 100,000 over the canal, taking barlev line, advancing 20km east of the canal under airdefence coverage, holding position until a U.S cease fire takes effect. Egypt didn't want to take all of sinai in 1973 cause they new that Israel is the U.S 51st state.
Go make your own then.
@@ma.s2386 They didn't exactly achieve victory there did they - did you not watch the video? The Egyptians sued for peace because their 3 rd Army was surrounded, their elite tank division had been all but destroyed and the Israelis were 100km from Cairo. Meanwhile, the Syrians had their offensive wiped out and surrendered. They did hold most of the Barlev Line and the Israelis knew from then on it was impossible to hold. In the long run, I agree the Israelis had no choice but to give the Sinai back - next time they might not had it so easy.
@@chrisparnham surrounded the 3rd army of 100,000 soldiers with what ? 60 tanks and 1600 soldiers ?
Moving 60 tanks behind enemy lines if really far from being surrounded.
Suez canal is already 100km away from eastern cairo, you say it as it if they gained vast ground or something.
Like i have said winning or losing depends on the objectives.
Egyptians accomplished their objectives, Israelis didn't. As simple as that.
@@ma.s2386 Watch the video again
i need a full soundtrack of the background music
Sınai is not in Western Agypt but in eastern Agypt.
Why WW2 Russian KV1s at 21mins - 21.09? Trying to fill out the so called documentary
LOL
Our army fought either with t34 which been used during ww2
@@mohamedsalahkhedr8813 Very true, but you didn't have KV1s in 1967? Just T34/85, JSII, SU100 and a few ISU152s - so the history books say.
@@jjsmallpiece9234 I'm not sure but the Soviets delivered to us their junk equipments from the ww2 time and most of our migs 21 were unmodernised, export versions armed with 2 AA missiles. So the comparison here is unfair with the Israeli army whose armed with advanced american weapons. But our belief is to retake the land, dignity, victory, and we succeed.
Although this video is well produced it is inaccurate both geographically and contextually. No mention is made of the fact that the surprise attack occurred on one of the most holy days in the Jewish calendar, Yom Kippur.
It would be the equivalent of Israel attacking an Arab nation on Ramadan. It would have been rightfully condemned by the world as a dastardly act.
No condemnation of the Arab attack took place.
No mention of the fact that the Israeli Intelligence raised the matter of Egyptian troop maneuvers with their American friends to be told not to worry, that it was only training exercises once more.
A fatal mistake.
How many times does the video have to show the Israeli soldier saying it felt like the whole Negev was trembling.
So redundant.
The war ended with the Egyptian third army completely surrounded and cut off from their supply lines, Prisoners of War, thirsty and hungry, humiliated and relying on Israeli compassion to allow UN help to save their lives.
This humiliating defeat after an initial encouraging start to their war is omitted from the Arab narrative of the war trying to paint what was a humiliating defeat as a victory. It forced Sadat to accept Israel's existence, give up military aspirations and negotiate a peace settlement with Israel.
Something Israel was prepared for all along.
It was a wake up call for Israel and a morale downer but ultimately a stunning Israeli victory which forced the reality of the need for negotiations for Peace on Sadat.
Syria never made that peace with Israel. Look at Syria today.
Look at Israel today.
Tell me who won.
Um to your response, I look at Israel today, and see her without Sinai 😂😂😂
@@peternader6479u think Egypt won Sinai ???? lol it was given to Egypt as peace offering after Israel won
@peternader6479 it took great strength to conquer the Sinai Peninsula from Egypt twice. It took greatest strength to give it back twice for the prospect of peace.
Keeps repeating itself
The Egyptian army is one of the strongest armies in the world. It proved its strength in the wars of the Pharaonic and Islamic civilizations and even in the wars of the Ottomans led by Muhammad Ali. The Egyptian army is defeatable and was defeated by the Romans, the Ottomans, Alexander and the British, but it returns again with strength.