@@Meon-kpop-distributions i think you shouldn't count the lead part, because usually they isn't sing or singing together in harmonize part for live version
Yeah try, but it's still her voice and it can be heard in the song. Therefore this is a like distribution so it should be based on the song, not the live bc lives, they dance in real-time so they can't sing everything
Over Power i think for other songs that’s true but in this song you can clearly hear the member’s voice overpowering the other members so i’d count it anyways
@@maiseree1511 Im sure g i dle gets much more likes and views *checking their last videos* look at that, No has 15.000.000 views and it was made before senorita, but senorita has 27.000.000 even if it was made a little bit later
@@Cuppcakechocolate thats the word i was looking for, they do have fame, but blackpink is just as good as them but bc of trending they have much more fame, not that they dont deserve it but other groups do need more love.
5 лет назад+389
in album distribution, results would be something like this: #5 YERI = 88,5s #4 IRENE = 104,1s #3 JOY = 164,8s #2 WENDY = 168,9s #1 SEULGI = 180,2s
LaLxisaa || um.. you know main vocalists don’t always have to be first..the main vocalist is the person who has the best singing technique, gets the harder parts like high notes, and mostly sings the prechorus or chorus. not the most lines, that can be something, but not always
@@matiashdhd7755 there are small differences in sound based on the center of the chorus sections. So, when Irene was center, her voice was the lead of the mixed part, then Seulgi's when she was center. Then Joy and Wendy respectively. The deeper tones have different levels of depth depending on who is leading. Wendy and Seulgi are much more supported in comparison to Joy or Irene.
@@Wynn.E Then what about the last chorus? This one wasn't counted by the channel. And to me the last one sounded like Yeri was the most prominent during it.
@@Wynn.E no, really they sound the same. the first part of the first chorus sounds the same as the first part of the second chorus, and the second part of the first sounds like the second part of the second. you can type a comment on the official video with the time stamps, that way is easier to so see what i'm talking about. so it's either Irene and seulgi, joy and wendy or all of them. to me it's all of them
The distribution isn't actually that bad. I feel like Yeri had more than what was accounted for. It's definitely one of the better line distributions for Red Velvet. I'm actually kinda proud at how fair it is. Edit: Thanks for the likes 🤗
The other chorus' the leads shouldn't have been counted because no one is leading anything in the audio and probably wont in lives. They're all singing. However the last chorus yeri actually leading it and should've been counted
xxx revelink because yeri stans are always extremely desperate for any line in the song to be yeris. I don’t think any of the chorus “leads” should’ve been counted, but the last one is definitely joy then seulgi again. You can hear a difference between the two sections. But yeah shouldn’t be counted in a distribution
@@SicaRun because the other choruses didn't really have any prominent voice, except the last one. Understand the statement before jumping into stupid remarks
0:51 Yeri + Joy 0:53 All (Mostly just Yeri and Seulgi but you can hear Joy's lower harmonies) 0:58 Yeri + Joy 1:00 All 1:01 Its a mixture of voices. First part is Irene + Joy then second part is Seulgi + Wendy. Seulgi also does bg vocals. 1:28 Seulgi + Joy 1:30 All 1:54 Seulgi + Wendy then Irene + Joy (center in the choreo does not matter, especially in choruses where they sing together) 2:47 All (Yeri does not lead, her voice iust stands out. Kinda like how Seulgi's voice stands out in the nananana in the last part)
According to Music Bank:- (1st Chorus) Irene leads the first part Seulgi leads the second part (2nd Chorus) Joy leads the first part Wendy leads the second part (Last Chorus) All
@@stephanieannetancastillo7821 i hear other member voice in every chorus too, but the word 'leading' means that one member who sing more loud and the rest member just like doing the harmonizing. it's clearly yeri lead the last chorus
Guys if you have a look at music core encore performance this week, Irene and yeri are the only two harmonising together at the bridge so that can be added to their lines as well!!
The line distribution isn't awful. But I do wish Wendy had more lines considering she is main vocal and I want her to shine as main vocal. Seulgi is an amazing singer and I love her voice -it is so soulful-, but I wish Wendy had more lines.
i honestly think irene does all the zimzalabim parts and members just get to be in the center during the chorus just to balance things out but I could also be wrong lol
Being a main vocalist doesn't mean she should have most lines. Being main vocal means usually taking care of the vocally challenging/important parts like Wendy's ICONIC high note here.
Seulgi: 31.4 Wendy: 24.7 Joy: 24.0 Irene: 19.0 Yeri: 16.3 Edit: I was bored so I just did this even tho there is already a thing in the video showing the results
This is nearly perfect. Almost same as the live's lyrics but some parts are different. And i think this is the most accurate one. Thank you for your hardwork! Btw from the live's lyrics the last chorus is all of them not only Yeri (sorry for my bad english)
I just came back from the future to tell you that your line distribution was about accurate and that all the people that were angry about the last chorus was wrong.
2:47-3:02 (15s) If Joy and Yeri’s leads are counted Final Distribution: 1. Joy (39.0s) 2. Seulgi (31.4s) 3. Yeri (31.3s) 4. Wendy (24.7s) 5. Irene (19.0s) This is approximate. I’m not professional, so I’m not counting the 00.? (?)’s. If I did, it wouldn’t matter that much.
I thiiiiink Yeri and Irene do the soft lines in between the solo parts of the bridge. I could be wrong though, I am just basing it off of who looked like they were singing in the comeback showcase I saw. ANd I agree with everyone else, that is def Yeri's voice over powering/leading the others in the final chorus.
Nice line distribution this is better than private myoui because private myoui don't count their lines in chorus and hexagon will edit the voice like a chipmunk and the speed will get faster.
The voice that sound the same in the 1st and 2nd chorus but if you actually hear it closely, it does sound like Irene/Seulgi/Wendy/Joy. The voice tune can be identified clearly if you listen to it.
Yeri and Wendy and Irene are goddesses of the M/V n' Seulgi and Joy are the goddesses of vocals!!!! Equal! No? No hate on Yeri, she is also good at singing
Soo I was just listening to CLC - Me, then I wanted to watch this video, when the intro played I thought I was being possessed 😂😂 Love you CLC and Red Velvet LoL (even though I don't stan you guys, I still love you guys 😂)
You didn’t count Irene and Yeri’s adlibs in the bridge,Joy and Yeri’s lead in the last chorus and Wendy’s last nanana part.If you counted those the distrubition would be: 1-Wendy 33.6 2-Yeri 31.6 3-Joy 31.5 4-Seulgi 31.4 5-Irene 27.0
Wtf is this line distribution? Why does everyone say this is fair? Its not fair at all if we look at Wendy. SM always does dirty her...she is the MAIN vocalist for gods sake. Then why is she not the first one?? Seulgi is already main dancer and lead vocalist...Wendy rarely has any lines in the previous comebacks, but her adlibs are never missing. She only will get screentime if she is in the center but how much I saw from the choreo she will be on side most of the times. So at least SM should have to give her more lines if she is the group's main vocalist.
Beside ice cream cake, Russian roulette, rookie, bad boy and zimzalabim wendy always get 1st line distribution for title track. Let lead vocal like joy and seulgi shine, both of them really good like main vocal.
@@selenaazalea3604 so its half of the amont of their comebacks she didnt get the most lines xD Seulgi shines becaus she is the center along with Irene and also the main dancer and LEAD vocalist. Joy is also lead vocalist and she has equally center positions during the choreos and good lines in the songs. So nooouu, if anyone has to shine more and also deserves the spotlight that's Wendy. Sorrynotsorry.
![[Clean Inst.] Red Velvet 레드벨벳 '짐살라빔 (Zimzalabim)' (Inst.)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/_3N07kE8Ku8/mqdefault.jpg)
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
if Leads are counted, then in the last chorus, Yeri leads. Her and Joy's voice can clearly be heard.
I wasn’t sure about that but I‘ll update this video if live performances state that it‘s either not lead in general or else ;D
@@Meon-kpop-distributions i think you shouldn't count the lead part, because usually they isn't sing or singing together in harmonize part for live version
Yeah try, but it's still her voice and it can be heard in the song. Therefore this is a like distribution so it should be based on the song, not the live bc lives, they dance in real-time so they can't sing everything
Over Power i think for other songs that’s true but in this song you can clearly hear the member’s voice overpowering the other members so i’d count it anyways
@@josephkim1113 he/she is talking about stages like mcountdown where we can see the lyrincs with who's singing
Yeri is definitely leading the final chorus
Where?
@@dcpurplee 02:46
Yes😍
Yess
it sounded like a combination of Yerin and Joy's voice.
just sayin✌🏻
For those who ask the ending song, its weki meki - picky picky
stan weki meki to get clear skin ✨
@@schizophwenia I Stan them too
yeet talent
Don’t sleep on weki meki ❤️
i just know their song and got addicted,they have strong and iconic comeback
It sounds like yeri is leading the 3rd zimzalabim chorus
A I think so too!
But it also sounds like Seulgi lol
@@subliminalowll yeah bc all of them are singing together, just like in the rest of the choruses...
It is all but Yeri leads it.
night time, my time it just sounds like yerim (and maybe Seulgi) are leading the 3rd chorus?
Let's just take a moment to appreciate the heavily underrated girl groups at the beginning and end
CLC - ME
Weki Meki - Picky Picky
I assure you, after the big 3 girl groups (Twice, BP, RV) CLC is up there with the likes of (g)-idle, izone and gfriend. So they're not underrated
@@maiseree1511 Im sure g i dle gets much more likes and views *checking their last videos* look at that, No has 15.000.000 views and it was made before senorita, but senorita has 27.000.000 even if it was made a little bit later
as well as Fromis_9
Humorflix YPTH y mas clc is still quite known though. I wouldn’t say underrated but they ain’t appreciated enough tbh
@@Cuppcakechocolate thats the word i was looking for, they do have fame, but blackpink is just as good as them but bc of trending they have much more fame, not that they dont deserve it but other groups do need more love.
in album distribution, results would be something like this:
#5 YERI = 88,5s
#4 IRENE = 104,1s
#3 JOY = 164,8s
#2 WENDY = 168,9s
#1 SEULGI = 180,2s
You pit ut yeri first and i was so shocked but i saw #5 YERI and was sad
Love that the lead vocalist has more than the main vocalist
LaLxisaa || um.. you know main vocalists don’t always have to be first..the main vocalist is the person who has the best singing technique, gets the harder parts like high notes, and mostly sings the prechorus or chorus. not the most lines, that can be something, but not always
@@jada1811 And the main dancer is on the edge during the dance break. Red Velvet is about showing off how every member is good at everything.
Seulgi!🤗 im so happy for her but no for yeri (
FINALLY SOMEONE WHO COUNTED THE CHORUS
both choruses sound exactly the same...
@@matiashdhd7755 there are small differences in sound based on the center of the chorus sections. So, when Irene was center, her voice was the lead of the mixed part, then Seulgi's when she was center. Then Joy and Wendy respectively. The deeper tones have different levels of depth depending on who is leading. Wendy and Seulgi are much more supported in comparison to Joy or Irene.
@@Wynn.E Then what about the last chorus? This one wasn't counted by the channel. And to me the last one sounded like Yeri was the most prominent during it.
@@Wynn.E no, really they sound the same. the first part of the first chorus sounds the same as the first part of the second chorus, and the second part of the first sounds like the second part of the second. you can type a comment on the official video with the time stamps, that way is easier to so see what i'm talking about. so it's either Irene and seulgi, joy and wendy or all of them. to me it's all of them
@@meral_k Personally, I can't tell that one. It sounds like a mix of Yeri and Joy because they both share that nasal tone projection style
I think Yeri lead the last chorus, cause her voice high pitch
WANNABLE, EXO-L, BLINK, NEVERLAND, AROHA Fan Kpop she did
Yeri's definitely leading the last chorus, because you can hear her voice pushed ahead of all the girls
The distribution isn't actually that bad. I feel like Yeri had more than what was accounted for. It's definitely one of the better line distributions for Red Velvet. I'm actually kinda proud at how fair it is.
Edit: Thanks for the likes 🤗
Jimin Babie i wish her rap part was longer , sorry for my bad E
Russian roulette was to good to be did one more time😔
Wendy's parts are the best here. Her voice was so refreshing and clear
The best line distribution channel!!!!!
Wow Seulgi
Yeri and Seulgi sound SOOOO GOOD TOGETHER😍😍😍❤❤
The other chorus' the leads shouldn't have been counted because no one is leading anything in the audio and probably wont in lives. They're all singing. However the last chorus yeri actually leading it and should've been counted
Why the other chorus shouldn't be counted but the one lead by Yeri should? Lol
yeri isn’t even for the center for that lead...i think it’s joy singing
@@SicaRun exactly lmao hahahahahaha so what's her point? duh
xxx revelink because yeri stans are always extremely desperate for any line in the song to be yeris. I don’t think any of the chorus “leads” should’ve been counted, but the last one is definitely joy then seulgi again. You can hear a difference between the two sections. But yeah shouldn’t be counted in a distribution
@@SicaRun because the other choruses didn't really have any prominent voice, except the last one. Understand the statement before jumping into stupid remarks
0:51 Yeri + Joy
0:53 All (Mostly just Yeri and Seulgi but you can hear Joy's lower harmonies)
0:58 Yeri + Joy
1:00 All
1:01 Its a mixture of voices. First part is Irene + Joy then second part is Seulgi + Wendy. Seulgi also does bg vocals.
1:28 Seulgi + Joy
1:30 All
1:54 Seulgi + Wendy then Irene + Joy (center in the choreo does not matter, especially in choruses where they sing together)
2:47 All (Yeri does not lead, her voice iust stands out. Kinda like how Seulgi's voice stands out in the nananana in the last part)
Hi ZSunder!!
are you also a part of sm 😳 like how you’re bbc’s 16th employee
Seulgi and wendy's last part took my wig to neverland
album distribution next!! hihi tnx for the vid
According to Music Bank:-
(1st Chorus)
Irene leads the first part
Seulgi leads the second part
(2nd Chorus)
Joy leads the first part
Wendy leads the second part
(Last Chorus)
All
Did anyone tell you that you are the best before?
If they didn't I will say it always ¥ØɄ ₳ɌɆ ₮ĦɆ ɃɆ$₮
02:47 I think yeri who lead this part
i was about to say lmao (i think i also hear joy a bit tho?)
i think it’s joy, since she’s in the center for this part
i hear irene's voice clearly too
@@stephanieannetancastillo7821 i hear other member voice in every chorus too, but the word 'leading' means that one member who sing more loud and the rest member just like doing the harmonizing. it's clearly yeri lead the last chorus
@@truptsecond8579 that's what i meant, but anyway thanks for telling :))
I think Wendy is Leading that 'nanana' part at the end. Yeri is *DEFINITELY* leading the last chorus.
Imagine how much closer the distribution would be if Yeri had the lead in Seulgi’s chorus 😱
Guys if you have a look at music core encore performance this week, Irene and yeri are the only two harmonising together at the bridge so that can be added to their lines as well!!
If yeri leading last chorus :
1. Seulgi 31.4s
2. Yeri 30.9s
3. Wendy 24.7s
4. Joy 24.0s
5. Irene 19.0s
Kuroo_ 47 SEULGI GODDAMNIT
Main vocal in top 3 .woooww but not always .😂😂😂
What happened to my eyesight..
Is this true..
@@Cheese_Doggy12 Idk.But it sound like yeri In last chorus.but we dont know
holy crap yeri is half of a second behind the first place
JOY!!!!!!!!! gotta love my girl
My queen Joy got more lines like she deserves 😩✊
The line distribution isn't awful. But I do wish Wendy had more lines considering she is main vocal and I want her to shine as main vocal. Seulgi is an amazing singer and I love her voice -it is so soulful-, but I wish Wendy had more lines.
Your line distribution is great!
2:36 - 2:40 Irene and Yeri
I lovelovelove Wendy!!! She's from my hometown!! :)
Wendy's highnote just snatched my wig off (:
Wendy my god that damn voice is soo strong
ZIMZALABIMMMMM
Well for me this is JOY and YERI'S ERA Y'ALL DON'T JUDGE ME
yeri didnt shine here lol. Shes the only member who didnt get a center in the chorus
Kim namjoon you misspelled Joy and Wendy🙂
@@ordinarysuperstar2860 aw actually all of them shined:)
@@cheesemonster3947 all of them shined:)
@@kimnamjoon8975 I agree
Seulgi And Wendy ABS Is Wow!!!😮😮😮
i honestly think irene does all the zimzalabim parts and members just get to be in the center during the chorus just to balance things out but I could also be wrong lol
Irene and Seulgi, not just Irene.
agree
On music Bank they counted the leads and said nobody leads the last chorus so this distribution according to Music Bank is correct.
Tbh its really fair
@@megantheestallionsgynecologist main vocal =/= most lines. It means best technique. Besides, Seulgi is 2nd Main with Joy and Irene as Lead Vocals.
Being a main vocalist doesn't mean she should have most lines. Being main vocal means usually taking care of the vocally challenging/important parts like Wendy's ICONIC high note here.
@@Wynn.E No, Main Vocalist is just Wendy. Seulgi just lead vocalist with Joy.
Yeri and Irene just vocalist and rapper.
@@snsdgivemetwice Joy isn't a lead vocal
H3X4 R17KQ joy is a lead rapper not lead vocal
For those who ask the intro song is Me by CLC
We all know that all members sings in every chorus. I think they base on the lyrics SBS release.
Favorite Red Velvet song ngl
Yeri and Seulgi are leading the third chorus
What the heck, that scared me 😂❤️ CLC ME
STAN CLC
Irene's Deep voice 😍💜 Bless My Ears 😍💕
Yeri leads in the last chorus
#JUSTICEFORYERI 💜
But it's pretty fair lol
WINNER and Red Velvet are the reason I stayed Yeri has never gotten first. That is not fair.
I think irene and selugi are casts spell of flashbacks of there song mixed every where
Slaygi is SLAYING SO HARDDDDDD!!!!!!!! 💛💛
Seulgi: 31.4
Wendy: 24.7
Joy: 24.0
Irene: 19.0
Yeri: 16.3
Edit: I was bored so I just did this even tho there is already a thing in the video showing the results
ya 🎏ZimZalabim
Background music: the whole song
This is nearly perfect. Almost same as the live's lyrics but some parts are different. And i think this is the most accurate one. Thank you for your hardwork!
Btw from the live's lyrics the last chorus is all of them not only Yeri (sorry for my bad english)
I just came back from the future to tell you that your line distribution was about accurate and that all the people that were angry about the last chorus was wrong.
I'm like crazy with the drum part at the end (nananana...) . Sounds happy and "disney"
My Seulgi😻
when i heard me as the intro song, i knew stanning you was the right move.
2:47-3:02 (15s)
If Joy and Yeri’s leads are counted
Final Distribution:
1. Joy (39.0s)
2. Seulgi (31.4s)
3. Yeri (31.3s)
4. Wendy (24.7s)
5. Irene (19.0s)
This is approximate. I’m not professional, so I’m not counting the 00.? (?)’s. If I did, it wouldn’t matter that much.
Okay thanks sm Seulgi is always first than Main vocal you broke my heart
Always first? Seulgi only get first line distribution for rookie, bad boy and zimzalabim.
Except that joy (2 song) and wendy get first.
@@selenaazalea3604 sorry
I thiiiiink Yeri and Irene do the soft lines in between the solo parts of the bridge. I could be wrong though, I am just basing it off of who looked like they were singing in the comeback showcase I saw. ANd I agree with everyone else, that is def Yeri's voice over powering/leading the others in the final chorus.
Wendy is so pretty with short hair
This song is iconic..
wendy in tumbnail❤❤
Wendy looking amazing in the thumbnail😍❤❤👑💋🔥🔥
Wow. I'm not even surprised.
2:42Wendy high note omg so cool!!
Yeri need more lines!
Nice line distribution this is better than private myoui because private myoui don't count their lines in chorus and hexagon will edit the voice like a chipmunk and the speed will get faster.
i like the layout
Red Velvet zimzalabim
Good luck for you.
*HOOO HAHAHA ARE YOU READY FOR THIS?!!!??? ZIMZALABIMMMMM*
Omg iconic
If you look for the hidden vocals Yeri is Second✨
The voice that sound the same in the 1st and 2nd chorus but if you actually hear it closely, it does sound like Irene/Seulgi/Wendy/Joy. The voice tune can be identified clearly if you listen to it.
Z
ZI
ZIM
ZIMZ
ZIMZA
ZIMZAL
ZIMZALA
ZIMZALAB
ZIMZALABI
ZIMZALABIM💝
I’ve never seen anyone count Lead that’s cool
thank god u're still here
I don't care if it was only 16 seconds, Yeri OWNED this song!
Yeri and Wendy and Irene are goddesses of the M/V n' Seulgi and Joy are the goddesses of vocals!!!! Equal! No?
No hate on Yeri, she is also good at singing
This distribution line is well made, since it counts the chorus, laughter and etc.😊
Red velvet ❤
Wendy and Yeri's slayin' this comeback y'all.
Soo I was just listening to CLC - Me, then I wanted to watch this video, when the intro played I thought I was being possessed 😂😂 Love you CLC and Red Velvet LoL (even though I don't stan you guys, I still love you guys 😂)
2:47 lead (yeri and joy)
And in 'nanananana' i think it's seulgi
Kuroo_ 47
I think it’s all
This intro 😍
In Red Velvet: Joy was lost a Sing
In Weki Meki: Lua was lost a Sing
In Clc : Eunbin was lost a Sing
I think yeri is Lead in the last chorus.
Secrets Channel russian roulette is better
@@rifqiathaillah7394 there are different concept.
I love how you use clc's me and weki meki's picky picky.
Wendy love you!1!1!❤😷👑
So do it like me ♪ stan CLC
1:54 Yes Queen!
YERI IS LEADING THE 3TH CHORUS!
You didn’t count Irene and Yeri’s adlibs in the bridge,Joy and Yeri’s lead in the last chorus and Wendy’s last nanana part.If you counted those the distrubition would be:
1-Wendy 33.6
2-Yeri 31.6
3-Joy 31.5
4-Seulgi 31.4
5-Irene 27.0
I'm sure Yeri got least screen time and center.
#smimsuingyou
Yeri killed her parts though
@@Star-kx7gb yessss
Wendy got like 5 seconds less of screen time I think, I watched a screen time distribution
@@muneebahad8861 i need to watch it i guess😕
@@myheadhurts5929 The screen time distribution is by Lei SaMo, or just search up Zimzalabim screen time distribution
intro!!!!!! CLC❤❤❤❤
Omg I just found out only today that their colours are in the order of the the rainbow
This is REALLY even for a red velvet song
Omg Seulgi
For those of you who ask :
Intro - CLC : ME
Outro - Weki Meki : Picky Picky
Wtf is this line distribution? Why does everyone say this is fair? Its not fair at all if we look at Wendy.
SM always does dirty her...she is the MAIN vocalist for gods sake. Then why is she not the first one?? Seulgi is already main dancer and lead vocalist...Wendy rarely has any lines in the previous comebacks, but her adlibs are never missing. She only will get screentime if she is in the center but how much I saw from the choreo she will be on side most of the times. So at least SM should have to give her more lines if she is the group's main vocalist.
Beside ice cream cake, Russian roulette, rookie, bad boy and zimzalabim wendy always get 1st line distribution for title track.
Let lead vocal like joy and seulgi shine, both of them really good like main vocal.
@@selenaazalea3604 so its half of the amont of their comebacks she didnt get the most lines xD Seulgi shines becaus she is the center along with Irene and also the main dancer and LEAD vocalist. Joy is also lead vocalist and she has equally center positions during the choreos and good lines in the songs.
So nooouu, if anyone has to shine more and also deserves the spotlight that's Wendy. Sorrynotsorry.
This is super fair
2nd chorus: Joy and Yeri sing the first zimzalabim part then Wendy sings not only Joy and Wendy I think?
This is very random but CLC and Weki Meki included is just 🤧👌
This Is For SchoolWork I know right?