I cried when Yuju cried, as a buddy I was very nervous because this song along with glass bead are our most precious ones, but they did awesome. The third boy (from left to right) his voice surprised me the most. Thankfully he got the chance to show it!
Yaodong's voice really catches my ear. It sounds so soothing and makes me want to listen to it everytime. I can't help myself to repeat his part even in FICTION performance 🤧 Everyone did a good job! Wishing everyone to be successful ~ Proud BUDDY here!
Walaupun udh di lihat beberapa kali tetap aja merinding. Gk ekspek banget tony... Suara lu keren banget ton aslii, pokoknya kalian berempat harus debut🔥🔥🔥
Everyone did a great job. Dongun is like a real K-pop star. He's good at singing, and he's also good at composing. Donghun, who sings the best, gave up most of his parts to others and showed his leadership by focusing on the high notes songs. Actually, this program has a fixed ending. I'm just sad that I can't see you anymore. I'll always cheer for dongun after hearing from you through RUclips
Terimakasih sudah membawakan lagu fenomenal ini, buddy dibuat terharu nontonnya, stage dan suaranya sangat cocok dan indah, semoga kalian bisa debut!!! makasi udah buat uri yuju nangis wkwk padahal buddy juga cengeng nontonnya wkwk
My favorite song, maybe everyone likes it. A cover song that makes me happy, proud, and touched. Remembering that GFriend will reunite in 2025. Sending my best wishes to all of you!❤😊
I'm wandering unable to approach you Although I like you I'm looking elsewhere The more we try to get close The more our hearts grow further We are revolving because we can't meet We are like parallel lines No way, we will meet I will always wait I wasn't able to tell you but I liked you Like a dream from the younger days, like a miracle If I could run through time and become an adult I will hold your hand in this cruel world I try to approach you but we keep missing each other I'm still unable to say that I like you When I see you hesitate I guess we are still too young We aren't closing in, that one tiny bit We are like parallel lines Someday I will tell you all the things I didn't say I will approach you always I wasn't able to tell you but I liked you Like a dream from the younger days, like a miracle If I could run through time and become an adult I will hold your hand in this cruel world Even when we're trapped in time and get lost We will eventually meet Please know that I am sincere Only if you hurry I wasn't able to tell you but I liked you Like a dream from the younger days, like a miracle If I could run through time and become an adult I will hold your hand in this cruel world Promise me this I hope you don't change Smile at me then like you do now If time goes by and I become an adult Amidst the divergence, I will hold your hand
Thank you for singing this song for us. As we know GFriend being popular since this song release and everyone like it. Until now so many people still listening this. And you all singing it so well. I love that. Thank you guyss.
Me: cry
Everyone: cry
Yuju: cry
Hongki: where's the message? 😂😂😂😂
He's always logical no matter what
And I dont know what kind of logic he had 😂
@CarlosGarcia-cr1pd he's 100% T fr 😭
身為Buddy 真的覺得很感動
是不是改成慢版啊?好好聽
@@R1star829是的 改編的非常好
Buddy 簽到
@@R1star829是演唱會版本
作為小女友的出道飯
這首歌真的最大亮點在耀冬身上
唱功好就不多提了
感情表達絕對是最準確的一位
重複聽了很多次
只有他最貼近時間流逝這首歌的情緒
真的希望更多人可以注意到他😢
浚赫的話也表現得不錯
但表情上覺得有一點點可惜
如果再調整一下應該會更吸引人>
Tony耀冬不愧是有多年演員的底子, 唱歌感情特別融入, 好有味道!! 是這首歌成功的重要關鍵呢! 難怪導師會特別點名稱讚呢!! 請大家多多幫Tony投票喔!! (我是下載浪TV)
沒粉這首歌的任何人
但耀冬真的表現得很好
第一段給他唱直接把大家帶到這首歌的情緒裡
但其他人鏡頭照到都讓我有點出戲
I cried when Yuju cried, as a buddy I was very nervous because this song along with glass bead are our most precious ones, but they did awesome. The third boy (from left to right) his voice surprised me the most. Thankfully he got the chance to show it!
The third one is 耀冬. I am obsessed with his voice, too.
耀冬part
0:12導入 0:55合唱 1:34合音
1:45高音 2:17合唱
我們耀冬終於被大家看見啦🥹
真誠的情感流露跟穩定輸出的唱功,這次二公也代表著上次fiction絕對不是僥倖,耀冬一直都很努力,節目到現在肉眼可見的持續在進步,做得太好啦我們耀冬!!!
努力是不會被辜負的!未來可期的孩子🫶🏻加油!!!
Pick 耀冬,從fiction 開始被他的表演吸引,為了最後那一聲,我不知道重看了fiction 幾次了,畫面也很有意境。
這次的演出也很棒,我很喜歡耀冬跟宇閎的部份,Tony不多說,不止是歌聲還有他帶起來的情緒,大家都被感動到;宇閎唱的很高亢,也覺得很好聽,Yuju指導要像吟詠的部份,我也覺得處理的很好
東運跟浚赫唱歌技巧很好,單聽音樂很好聽,但看畫面,表情讓我蠻出戲的😓
再聽一次還是好喜歡Tony跟宇閎的歌聲啊,Tony好耐聽,唱歌時眼神閃閃發亮,宇閎好適合搖滾,好想聽他倆唱洪基的歌🤭
又再聽了一次,還是覺得東運跟宇閎會讓人蠻出戲,耀冬跟浚赫比較在狀態內,表情聲音是搭配的,等於四個人不是同一個心境,所以洪基才會說聽了不知道要傳達什麼嗎?
然後我發現這幾次練習時,耀冬真的蠻會提出想法的,對老師有點到的地方積極想對策,很積極但又不搶戲,前面跳舞的表現也不錯,所以如果真的要選vocal進出道組的話,比起選技巧好的東運,我覺得選外型、唱功、虛心受教的耀冬更適合。
雖然但是 還是想提醒一下是耀冬,留言區好多人都打錯(?
歡迎大家多多稱讚耀冬🥳
宇閎感覺是咬字問題?上一次公演就有覺得他的咬字有點可惜(但上次沒被提
東運感覺真的是他唱腔還沒轉過來,他目前唱法還是有點樂團(?),上次CMB其實有幾個地方也唱的太炫技了,只是老師可能一定要找人誇
認同~
看了很多遍還是覺得耀冬和浚赫才是真的在表演這首歌
感情很好唱功也在線
東運的話表情管理還要再努力
而且歌聲感受不到他想表達的情緒
宇閎則是聲線比較吃虧
而且發音不太準確會讓人比較出戲
@@studying1010 沒問題,秒改😂
气氛真的变得好奇怪 ᆢ 这里有收钱的评论区吗?
四個人都很會唱,也唱的很好,
但耀冬的聲音乾淨又清亮⋯⋯
耀冬開頭很像喃喃自語的演唱,之後的高音也很完美❤好好聽又很深情的感覺😍
每次公演都會挖到新的寶藏男孩,耀冬這首歌真的詮釋得很好,期待他日後的表現
這首真的有耀冬帶入情緒才可以
耀東起點初舞台帶來的印象輸人家,如果他也能只唱歌的話是不是就不用這樣繞路?
而且fiction他表現很好也莫名沒有獲得評價
浚赫也是不錯,老師教的他有做調整
東運技巧很好但唱起來有些匠氣
耀冬聲音溫暖純粹很適合詮釋這首的情緒
兩位都很厲害👏
耀冬好帥❤
太會唱了 一直在進步
太替你開心了
繼續保持繼續閃閃發亮⭐️
Tony初舞台到底發生什麼事😂?fiction突然開始發現Tony唱得好好呢~
被別人帶跑調吧😂😂那種狀態下能不跑調也蠻厲害的😂
也有可能初舞台太緊張
但他真的越來要耀眼了
越來越帥 唱的好有感情
Di bawain sama 4 orang aja udh keren bgtt apa lgi 6 orang😭🫶🏻
Yaodong's voice really catches my ear. It sounds so soothing and makes me want to listen to it everytime. I can't help myself to repeat his part even in FICTION performance 🤧
Everyone did a good job! Wishing everyone to be successful ~
Proud BUDDY here!
As a Buddy, i’m so proud of them 😭
其實我覺得是眼神的問題,還有太著重於表演。我覺得大家的表情透露出的情感不太一樣,感覺想的東西不太一樣,可能因此導致所謂的「訊息模糊不清」。然後好像東運是負責控制合音的,所以可能相對來說沒那麼入戲,我覺得是可以理解的,但就是如果把這當成表演的話,反而導致看起來出戲,然後就回到第一個問題,有人是在表演,有人是發自內心的,有人在注重舞台呈現,所以看起來怪怪的。但我還是很愛啦OwO
喜歡的話大家要幫耀冬多多投票!!
他真的很需要大家的支持🥹🙏🏻
2:18 紙花飛到耀冬頭上XD 好可愛
唱得好好聽!!!
被紙花pick的耀冬XD
2:22 the trainee that’s singing sinb’s part here has such a captivating voice, it was totally a great idea to give him this line
希望耀冬可以出道😢
再次被耀冬給感動,感謝你一直以來的努力!大家都看到你很努力也一直在進步!會一直為你加油的!我們耀冬是最棒的❤️😭
Walaupun udh di lihat beberapa kali tetap aja merinding. Gk ekspek banget tony... Suara lu keren banget ton aslii, pokoknya kalian berempat harus debut🔥🔥🔥
真心覺得2:09宇閎跟浚赫這個合音很好聽 這幾天腦袋都會回放這一段❤
這應該也可以列入經典名場面了吧
不聽不知道 聽純享版才知道合音真的超強!!!
耀東和東運 真的唱的太好了
2:44 The last part make me cry 😭 the best vocal
耀東很有唱功高音都唱的上去不會破音ㄝ⋯⋯
宇閎很棒~~~~雖然看到有人對宇閎踩一捧一讓我很不爽 但懶得跟他爭辯 無限支持宇閎✨✨
浚赫不只高音,連中低音域也能駕馭
和東運一定要出道啊!
繼續用暖嗓療癒觀眾~
喜歡東運浚赫!!
上個舞台因為最後高音就有注意到耀冬了
這次直接被圈粉!!!
情緒帶入感滿滿😭唱的好好!!❤
真心覺得他們進步好多🥺
聲音變得好飽滿溫暖 情緒也更投入😢
可惜沒有字幕 不然又會看到落淚😢😢
這首歌重新詮釋後 讓我聽的很感動 感動到哭的那種😂! 雖然導師有講評還不夠完美 但我真的覺得很棒!!!
耀冬從fiction 開始歌聲表現就很突出加油!!! 真希望scool 如果也有單獨歌唱的小隊該有多好!!
雖然不懂唱歌,可是覺得他們唱的很好,可是也覺得像洪基老師說的不知道想要傳達的訊息是什麼
但是想要給宇閎點讚 因為就覺得他的表情有帶給我 像YUJU導師說的感情
“不是單純失戀或是被甩 而是一直保持那份純粹一次次奔向對方”
堅定的眼神跟語氣
曜冬過程中也是有!但是ending的時候看起來很難過😢
但還是幫4位推推 真的唱的太好了🫶🏻
美的讓人雞皮疙瘩…情感溢滿到了最高、充滿力量卻又帶著柔美的悲傷感😢❤選曲真的很棒也證明了多元化
這個舞台真的完全被耀冬圈粉❤
好可愛又好會唱😍😍
Everyone did a great job. Dongun is like a real K-pop star. He's good at singing, and he's also good at composing. Donghun, who sings the best, gave up most of his parts to others and showed his leadership by focusing on the high notes songs. Actually, this program has a fixed ending. I'm just sad that I can't see you anymore. I'll always cheer for dongun after hearing from you through RUclips
Terimakasih sudah membawakan lagu fenomenal ini, buddy dibuat terharu nontonnya, stage dan suaranya sangat cocok dan indah, semoga kalian bisa debut!!!
makasi udah buat uri yuju nangis wkwk padahal buddy juga cengeng nontonnya wkwk
My favorite song, maybe everyone likes it. A cover song that makes me happy, proud, and touched. Remembering that GFriend will reunite in 2025. Sending my best wishes to all of you!❤😊
❤
miss Gfriend😢
buddy is still here❤
只聽到純享版的真的要去看節目,很精彩!其實這組右邊三隻唱歌都頗有底子(左邊那隻還有點太直白太嫩),這首歌讓我看到黃耀冬!被圈粉了!可以聽得出來兩個韓國選手有深厚的歌唱訓練基礎,但耀冬的聲音更內斂有感情很耐聽!希望後面還有更多歌唱的表現機會呀!
左邊那隻換成振浩 會更完美
他唱fiction的時候也超帥的喔~不同風格
希望更多人可以注意到他
@@MEILIA-t2z 我覺得他需要換個造型,也許新髮型?目前這路線有點平啊!
Tony真的唱的很好
再来一次 tony真的唱了戳我 张宇闳也是 声线好适合 大家都唱的好好 🥺
0:43 준혁아 이번에도 너밖에 안보였어 넌 최고야
Tony的聲音很有帶入感 東運也很值得稱讚呀 幾乎一直在合音 也是負責堆疊情緒的
看到這則留言的大家,動動手指幫耀冬投票吧❤
很喜歡東運的歌聲 我反而是在他唱的時候流淚的 合音也讓這個舞台變得很精彩!
2:11 東運的合聲和高音 讚 ,他唱歌確實有些太花的習慣,但能給他點時間改嗎? 才三個月太短了
我固定投他,但票好難上去🥲
如果大家喜歡他的話,希望能每天都幫忙投他 不然蠻難進出道7人的
東運的聲音真的是我的pick, 他人氣不高嗎?😨😨
歐耶 純享終於出來了🤩
耀冬唱得真好💗
宇閎的情緒融入誏我為韓語歌曲動心,加油🎉,期待你出道讓更多人看到你
Glass bead and rough will always have a special place in my heart as a buddy. Thank you for giving our song an extra level of emotion ❤
有一说一 东运的和声让这首歌变得很有层次👍🏻
宇閎真的很棒😭希望大家多注意到他
真的很喜歡他的唱法跟聲音 每次聽了都很感動😭🫶
宇閎聲音很有辨識度
Yaodong proud make YUJU cried💖🥺thank you for singing it beautifully for our YUJU🥺💖🫶🏻
當初看首播的時候就發現那個紙片,真的是神來一筆
好扯 東尼唱的很好!拜託出道🥹
They nailed this Rough cover, glad they won!
這組真的聲音很合,而且合音很美🥰認真會聽哭的那種❤~論純粹聽覺享受,會一刷再刷停不了😊👍👍
耀冬真的好棒😍😍😍😍😍
@@莊子涵-d4x 真的被他帥到了欸
真的唱歌唱得我泛淚了
耀冬厲害!
I miss GFriend 😢
Love this cover so much.
I can feel it, I cried 😭
耀冬這次唱的也很好耶!感覺是貼合原唱感覺的
浚赫這次感覺比較細膩,合音的部分好好聽~
宇閎這次也不錯,不過可能是因為發音問題仍然沒克服,有幾個音唱的有點可惜(上次CMB就有含滷蛋的問題)
東運是知道他會唱,但從上次開始就有點過度炫技的狀況出現,唱法不太適合歌曲,上次CMB因為是比較帥的歌曲還可以,但這次歌曲情感比較細膩,這樣唱就可惜了
如果要用歌曲感覺選夢之隊應該會選前兩位,東運這次之後真的要更加重視詮釋問題了
ᆢ不知道李东云在哪个部分展示了过度的实力 ᆢ
不要在不了解的情况下随便说话
東運明明就不錯啊???我不懂炫技在哪,yuju老師說要改的地方他也改了,我不覺得哪裡有不適合的?
回樓上兩位
先說這是我個人聽感啦,他跟隊友一對比很明顯,他的唱法真的一直都比較樂團
我覺得他是目前最會唱的沒錯,在上一集我還覺得他應該就是未來主唱擔了,但聽完這集覺得他不能每首歌都用這種唱歌方法唱……依他的實力,用適合的方法唱腔來唱一定會更精彩
沒有覺得他不行,是覺得他表現方法可以多樣一點,yuju老師說的那個其實還是存在他的尾音,只是沒練習時那麼明顯,不代表完全沒有
2:11 東運的合聲和高音 讚 ,他唱歌確實有些太花的習慣,但能給他點時間改嗎? 才三個月太短了
我固定投他,但票好難上去🥲
如果大家喜歡他的話,希望能每天都幫忙投他 不然蠻難進出道7人的
耀冬一直在進步一直努力閃亮著
謝謝你們支持 一起支持偶像真好❤️🔥
This are the vocals of the new group. Now the allrounder have to prove that they can come near this.
喜歡 Tony 的表達
只有宇閎沒有悲傷的表情~~,但整首歌合音超棒.好聽!
東運很會❤❤
真的很好聽TATTTT
耀冬!!!!!!!
主場line就是耀東和東運了 振浩當領唱比較適合
I'm wandering unable to approach you
Although I like you I'm looking elsewhere
The more we try to get close
The more our hearts grow further
We are revolving because we can't meet
We are like parallel lines
No way, we will meet
I will always wait
I wasn't able to tell you but I liked you
Like a dream from the younger days, like a miracle
If I could run through time and become an adult
I will hold your hand in this cruel world
I try to approach you but we keep missing each other
I'm still unable to say that I like you
When I see you hesitate
I guess we are still too young
We aren't closing in, that one tiny bit
We are like parallel lines
Someday I will tell you all the things I didn't say
I will approach you always
I wasn't able to tell you but I liked you
Like a dream from the younger days, like a miracle
If I could run through time and become an adult
I will hold your hand in this cruel world
Even when we're trapped in time and get lost
We will eventually meet
Please know that I am sincere
Only if you hurry
I wasn't able to tell you but I liked you
Like a dream from the younger days, like a miracle
If I could run through time and become an adult
I will hold your hand in this cruel world
Promise me this I hope you don't change
Smile at me then like you do now
If time goes by and I become an adult
Amidst the divergence, I will hold your hand
Thank you for singing this song for us. As we know GFriend being popular since this song release and everyone like it. Until now so many people still listening this. And you all singing it so well. I love that. Thank you guyss.
Best rough cover😭🩵
為什麼這個舞台我每次聽 每次都會流淚 其實浚赫的投入度我也很喜歡
these guys should form boy band
i hope all of them debuts❤❤❤❤
並不清楚原本的音樂,1:17 ~ 1:33 的留白 鋼琴、管絃樂為底 加入電吉他帶點憂鬱的神情 透過鼓聲開始拉抬精采的部分 2:50 ~ 2:56 的電吉他再次拉回傷心、不捨 真的不想哭也很難 閉上眼東運的聲音會一直想聽 睜開眼我會一直想看著耀冬
好喜歡這組這首歌的表演
每個都帶有豐富的感情去演唱
聽了我也很感動
難怪yuju也哭了
感謝純享版釋出~~
this is my favourite cover of rough from now on
合音好漂亮啊~~女團的歌可以呈現出這樣的舞台很厲害!
很喜歡浚赫的表現👍👍
宇閎的音色不錯 但感覺整體可以再雕琢練習一下~~
這首真的好讚
背景的一開始時間倒轉
像是為了讓我們回到小女友的年代
加上後面的背景學校也跟mv很像
Tony的嗓音真的很適合這首歌
看到yuju含淚就好想跟著哭
Jdii rinduu gfriend😭😭❤️❤️
Came straight here from one tiktok edit 😍😍
2:11 東運的合聲和高音 讚 ,他唱歌確實有些太花的習慣,但能給他點時間改嗎? 才三個月太短了
我固定投他,但票好難上去🥲
如果大家喜歡他的話,希望能每天都幫忙投他 不然蠻難進出道7人的
我也是固投他 但感觉这选秀确实热度不怎么大 很难吸粉😢
+1 每天都投他1票
这首是真的好听,和声也和谐
This reminded me 2am and btob ofcourse my gfriend era. Though they have a little mishaps like what their mentor said, their voice reached my heart
唱得很美❤
gosh, i miss gfriend already
永支耀冬
@@whm9004 一起下載浪live支持起來
@@whm9004 謝謝支持 一起支持起來下載浪live 投票讓他順利出道
Their performance is sooo goood (im buddy)
耀東超棒😭
東運加油👍
Yaodong for group..but all vocal is 👍👍👍👍
東運真的好棒ㅠㅠ
耀冬唱的讓人好感動
the instrumental is so beautiful, combined with the heavenly vocal performance it creates magic
這組合很棒🙂↕️
你們四個自己組一團吧⋯⋯還想繼續聽你們唱別首歌呢❤
超好聽他們4位是寶藏男孩❤