Nope! This isn’t live. It’s pre recorded but the pre recorded is made to feel like it’s live. But live singing doesn’t sound like this. That’s okay tho
@@user-ue3ge4fj2m Nope! This isn’t live. It’s pre recorded but the pre recorded is made to feel like it’s live. But live singing doesn’t sound like this. That’s okay tho
@@fie97 It isn’t actually. Don’t be naive. Groups that have just debuted rarely sing live and this is not what singing live sounds like. And that’s okay
@@isabellaelisegarcia4736 we are not. breathing and a few changes of notes won't make it live singing, kindly watch the performance you can clearly see with the heavy choreo and high pitched notes it's impossible they sang every word by every note perfectly without going flat or struggling. That's imposible! They didn't open their mouths the right way to fit the pronunciation of the word nor the note. Kindly be smarter next time
@@reyses1x2 It’s just made to sound like that really. This isn’t sung live by them on stage. But could be sung live in a studio, hence why it is called being pre recorded
@@berekabena5963 it is pre recorded vocals. This is what pre recorded vocals sound like. They just debuted so they won’t be singing live on a lot of places. And that’s okay, that’s just how it is :3
0:34 Eunchae continues to be the least stable with the few lines she has. People who say this is pre-recorded, I totally get that but wouldn't Eunchae not sound like she was doing a workout during her lines?
Fearless live vocals👉🏼ruclips.net/video/oHdDtDapu5g/видео.html
wowwow Sakura's vocal skills have improved
결국 4세대 걸그룹 중 찐 라이브는 엔믹스 한 팀이고 에스파 아이브 르세핌 전부 ar 엄청 깔고 라이브인 척 하는구나ㅋㅋ 다들 북미보고 만든 그룹이라던데 거기가서 케이팝 망신 시키지 마라
the sharp breaths they take… feels like live? is it live? cause some parts sound live. insane if they sang live on debut cause that’s amazing
They sing live in their showcase.. I think they did today especially in yunjin and kazuha last part
@@user-ue3ge4fj2m no they just sang live in their showcase but this one is not live, they used the same live audio from their showcase!!!
Nope! This isn’t live. It’s pre recorded but the pre recorded is made to feel like it’s live. But live singing doesn’t sound like this. That’s okay tho
@@user-ue3ge4fj2m Nope! This isn’t live. It’s pre recorded but the pre recorded is made to feel like it’s live. But live singing doesn’t sound like this. That’s okay tho
아니 이거 댓글 아까 모르고 삭제했는데 ar 아니면 사전녹화일 거임 사전녹화에 숨소리 넣는 경우도 있다 했음
와ㆍ댄스가 격렬해서 숨쉬기조차 힘들텐데 라이브 개쩐다
I think they sang in blue flame
와 잘한다
生歌最高❤
Definitely Pre recorded but that’s okay :3 they just debuted
They actually sang live in their debut showcase, you can watch it in their channel.
@@diosdadoampoc325 its pre recorded too
No it's live
@@fie97 It isn’t actually. Don’t be naive. Groups that have just debuted rarely sing live and this is not what singing live sounds like. And that’s okay
라이브 AR 인것 같음
ar으로 리무버해주세요
It's clearly live you can hear in the chorus
It's pre recorded
@@Jungkook_fr it’s pre- recorded but live. The sound they used is from their showcase performance which was live.
@Mr Grung @Jungkook you're all wrong lol please use headphones to spot the differences
@@isabellaelisegarcia4736 we are not. breathing and a few changes of notes won't make it live singing, kindly watch the performance you can clearly see with the heavy choreo and high pitched notes it's impossible they sang every word by every note perfectly without going flat or struggling. That's imposible!
They didn't open their mouths the right way to fit the pronunciation of the word nor the note. Kindly be smarter next time
@@Jungkook_fr Yes its pre recorded with live voice
Nah man, this is prerecorded with live vocals here and there
Do you know what pre-recorded mean?
It’s pre recorded. And only pre recorded. The pre recorded vocals are made to sound live but this isn’t what live singing sounds like. That’s okay tho
@@idajohansson6921 I disagree, there's definitely some live vocals in there.
@@reyses1x2 It’s just made to sound like that really. This isn’t sung live by them on stage. But could be sung live in a studio, hence why it is called being pre recorded
It’s pre-recorded what’s the point?
Do mr removed vid of their live vocals pls.
Pre-recorded doesn't mean that it not live they filmed this one week before their debut and it was just displayed when it their turn to perform
@@berekabena5963 yeah but then still it’s not live we want to hear live vocals and not pre-recorded vocals
@@KISSOFLlFEJULIE this is not pre-recorded vocals it's a pre-recorded video they filmed this way before they even debuted it's different
@@berekabena5963 it is pre recorded vocals. This is what pre recorded vocals sound like. They just debuted so they won’t be singing live on a lot of places. And that’s okay, that’s just how it is :3
0:34 Eunchae continues to be the least stable with the few lines she has. People who say this is pre-recorded, I totally get that but wouldn't Eunchae not sound like she was doing a workout during her lines?
Ar임
we all 100% know that this is lipsync prerecorded