Jerry Muller: Capitalism and the Jews

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 30 янв 2025

Комментарии • 35

  • @BrianHodgert
    @BrianHodgert 7 лет назад +5

    Let's start the discussion where this one ends. I am so grateful to have watched this. This makes so much sense.

  • @kelseyvickers-k7z
    @kelseyvickers-k7z 3 месяца назад

    why does he glaze over credit is necessary for trade and
    interest is necessary for credit? can someone explain this to me?

  • @-ED-
    @-ED- 5 лет назад +10

    Its not correct that Capitalism is based on exchange. Exchange is just trade and it exists in every type of Economic system and is not in any way connected to Capitalism alone or making up rules of Capitalism. Capitalism is an Economic System, which is a system of PRODUCTION of goods and services. Capitalism is actually based on PRIVATISATION and PoS (Proof of Stake) principle which is basically that the owners of the (majority of the business) are the ones who make all decisions (which also means CENTRALISED decision making).

    • @friedricengravy6646
      @friedricengravy6646 4 года назад

      Capitalism is considered trade because the basic principle is trading labor/production for opportunity/wealth. A society’s economic choice verses communism or socialism.

    • @actualideas8078
      @actualideas8078 4 года назад +3

      friedricengravy are we talking about democratic socialism, cuz there are conservative forms of socialism

    • @-ED-
      @-ED- 4 года назад +3

      @@friedricengravy6646 considering/defining Capitalism as trade is incorrect and reason people don't understand what Capitalism actually is. Its PRIVATISATION of means of production and nature itself, which is in total opposition to nature itself. There is no species in the world that uses other members of its species to fight, control, kill etc others in order to reserve and keep some form of natural resource or other member's work. No animal uses other animals to fight for their "house" from other animals... only human's do this, and its this very idea that poisoned human minds that started the cancer of society in every aspect, as privatisation of everything is what corrupts everything.
      And what every defender of Capitalism is wrong about is using such definition of Capitalism. Capitalism is defined as Private Ownership of means of production, im which there is employer/employee division of power/control and ultimately wealth extraction by the employers/owners/capitalists.... who then, when they get big and powerful thanks to the wealth they extracted over time, buy out and corrupt EVERYTHING.

    • @DontDrinkthatstuff
      @DontDrinkthatstuff 3 года назад +4

      @@-ED- Well said. Capitalism isn't just about trade of goods. That's what hyper capitalist shills always say to make capitalism seem like some natural occurrence. Capitalism is about debt and constant growth/investorism.

    • @DontDrinkthatstuff
      @DontDrinkthatstuff 3 года назад +2

      @@friedricengravy6646 Bullshit. Capitalism is all about debt and usury/interest.

  • @CanalDevir
    @CanalDevir 3 года назад +1

    All the social conditions that favorable helped to develop specifics cultural traits in the Jewish population to be successful in the modern capitalism can be extended to Jewish populations from other continents or is Jewish European condition? Thanks

  • @ApollonianShy18
    @ApollonianShy18 Год назад

    Im her cs of an Idea of Capitalism as described by Max Weber (read from another author) how Reformist n Jewish Capitalism differ - 1st being Rationalised n second Pauper (paria in german) & that in terms of ethics

  • @sunwm2003
    @sunwm2003 3 года назад +3

    Well, chinese are being discriminated by being Chinese and working hard but the Jews are not mentioned any where. What a predetermined path to success!

    • @dandankokorohikareteku2620
      @dandankokorohikareteku2620 3 года назад

      Jews are being discriminated but it’s censored on major platforms wake up

    • @zacharybowers8500
      @zacharybowers8500 3 года назад +1

      @@dandankokorohikareteku2620 by who? The Zionist own the media….

  • @yasseralsaidi1168
    @yasseralsaidi1168 Год назад

    Look for the good in every tribe

  • @NathanWHill
    @NathanWHill 2 года назад +1

    Theoretically rather superficial

  • @globaltoleranceproject
    @globaltoleranceproject 2 года назад +2

    very misleading book this man has written
    i refer to the passage minimizing the Jewish composition of the early Bolshevik revolutionary set

    • @Odysseus88
      @Odysseus88 Год назад +1

      And let’s not forget the Jewish capitalists from NY and London who funded them.
      Ok fine they had an axe to grind with the czar. The globalists of that time period wanted a piece of the pie knowing Russia was going to be industrializing. Think of all that money that could be made!
      I don’t recall any Jews advocating for the reunification of the Reich. I don’t recall any Americans advocating for that either.
      But I do recall communists and Jews spitting on the Kaiser’s Troops just like they spit on our boys coming home from Vietnam.
      I never thought our flag would be a bedsheet for prostitution, homosexuality and abortion, but that is the liberal way.
      When they finally change the sheets who knows what colors they will use.
      And they will change the sheets, this game is for keeps!
      Leon Trotsky who’s real name was Lev Bronstein, first head of the red army, second to Lenin, one could say the George Washington of marxist Leninism is responsible for the Holocaust.
      Judeo Bolshevism must of been real convincing in real time back in those days.
      You don’t think according to this history Jews didn’t have a motivate to network and coordinate on behalf of their interests to the detriment of the “other” once in power? To reshape the world in their image for their benefit as a survival strategy? A type of ethno despotism once in power.
      Look I’m not some tyrant trying to collectivize an identity group in order to justify mass murder. But our world as Europeans is being inverted by these ethnic despots. We’re becoming a minority within the civilizations of our ancestors. What, for corporate interests?
      If we think in terms of the psychology of the Jews based on their history and propaganda it’s no wonder why our world is being dismantled and destroyed.
      In other words, they don’t blame the Nazis for the Holocaust. They blame the culmination of European History going all the way back to the Greeks, especially Christianity for the Holocaust.
      They’ve become the undisputed masters of our reality and they’re perusing policies that are designed to wipe us off the map. We’re becoming a minority within the civilizations of our ancestors. Wtf
      This is not a natural phenomenon metaphysically speaking. This by design.
      But in the flesh I will always deal with the individual as an individual so don’t get me wrong. Besides I was politically defeated before I was even born so who am I to say.
      It’s just politics 😂

  • @yasseralsaidi1168
    @yasseralsaidi1168 Год назад

    And not the otherwY around

  • @MS-in3sl
    @MS-in3sl 4 года назад +3

    is this man a jew?

    • @1995yuda
      @1995yuda 4 года назад

      Why does it matter you dumbass

    • @actualideas8078
      @actualideas8078 4 года назад +5

      1995yuda cuz we’re not retarded

    • @sunwm2003
      @sunwm2003 3 года назад +1

      @@1995yuda bcz they always find a way to get to your life, without you even knowing.

    • @1995yuda
      @1995yuda 3 года назад

      @@actualideas8078 Thats what yo mama told you. But you are.

    • @lbnFadl
      @lbnFadl 3 года назад +4

      Of course. Why do you think he's allowed to even publish a book titled this?