By the way, the epilogue will serve as a great consolation for what has just happened, it is a nice tribute to those of us who played rdr1, and at the same time it is an ending that leaves you very satisfied.
Kind of.Most people can understand him fighting between the good and bad side of him.But at the end of the day Arthur was a scumbag person that murdered and destroyed peoples lives for his own personal gain.Just because he was charismatic and occasionally did nice things doesn’t excuse any of his horrific actions.Point is,if you knew someone like Arthur in real life,you’d stay as far away from him as possible and you damn sure wouldn’t shed a tear if he died.
@@BrooklynBalla I agree, he was the only most sympathetic out of the group. Then John becomes even more sympathetic in a way in the epilogue and even more in rdr1. Either way arthur is my 1st favorite then John and Dutch as 3rd. I love the entire story between all of them also Jack's redemption was also pretty nice
Arthur’s personality is so human, but his skills is just beyond human, he’s basically a one-man army. He uses McCree’s ult whenever he wants, it’s high-noon for him even in the night time.
i guess for woman sure, how ever allot of them cried when john got killed in number one also, how ever I have seen this phenomenon in other games too, Last Tiger storyline in battlefeild 5 is an example where ive seen that, as well as in unexpected events where mains or good friends of mains are killed off like in the Yakuza series from sega
Hosea: "how do you want to die, Arthur?" Arthur: " I don't care about all that. Just turn me West so I can watch the sunset and remember all of the great times we had..."
I love that he died facing the sunrise, symbolises how his ending was different than he wanted or planned but in the end, he ended up a better man :) he didn’t get what he wanted but he got what he needed
@@andrewrodriguez6172 I've seen it a dozen times and seen a hundreds of playthroughs....I still tear up. So impactful and so emotional. Such great writing.
lol that sucks. we’re all hit hard by it but ppl don’t understand when u tell them it’s bc of a video game. sounds silly but its amazing how fictional characters affect us
@@billygoat12 I don’t get how it’s silly, tbh. People cry over movies/tv shows, books and music, right? It’s all art, so why not a video game you’ve invested so much time in?
For me Arthur’s horse that died was Buell, Hamish’s fav horse he gave to Arthur when he died. So that part was heartbreaking, the horse that reminded Arthur of the one friend he made outside of crime that they both bonded on their love of the outdoors during their finals days.
Jack? Come here, son. I know you're scared. But Miss Tilly is gonna keep you safe. You're a good kid. Be brave, son. Where will you go, Uncle Arthur? *Uncle Arthur is gonna go get your Momma.*
When Arthur says to the Swanson "You're getting real sentimental". In other words, it is what it is and we both know what it is. Nothing else needs to be said about it.
I feel like I’m torturing myself whenever I replay it lol. It’s fun in the beginning, just getting drunk with Lenny and partying with the gang… then it slowly devolves, and I know where it’s headed and it’s like torture forcing myself to play it again. But I love it lol😂😂
I’d like to double down on your exact statement I even had the game spoiled for me and you could obviously see it coming once get gets diagnosed but I still cried all the way until I got control of John and them I’m pretty sure I cried even more tears of joy realizing how things have come full circle from RDR1
They did a superb job as they always do. Its like that film Braveheart the woman always forever cry when he gets executed because they see wallace NOT as a criminal, raider, lawbreaker, ect. But as a handsome rouge rebel who fought for a just cause and lost. Even though his fellow clansmen win at Bannockburn in 1314. That is how they view Arthur.
"I'm helping John... I'm not turning into Dutch." That is just about the hardest line I've heard from anyone I've seen play this game. It's a canon line in every person's head who chose the honorable storyline. God bless, Sienna...
Same with Arthur. Remember the way he cried for Dutch when Dutch ran off at the industry? It was so sad 😭. Arthur acts like a big baby around Hosea and Dutch
@kartikayysola Genuinely so depressing that it makes me wish RDR2 was the only entry, because the epilogue ends on a (mostly) happy note with John making ammends and wrapping up lose ends
I'll freely admit as a man pushing 40 at the time, when that horse fell I had to put the controller down for five minutes and step away, and by the time the credits rolled I was flat out ugly crying. Even watching this now so many years removed from the first time, I could feel the tears coming once again. This will always rank in my top three greatest of all times for that emotional connection alone. A true masterwork. It's the people who can keep stone faced through it all that worry me.
Yeah I agree this game by far above anything else had a profound impact on me I lost my dad to brain cancer around this time he was a big fan of western movies he would have loved playing this game with the hunting and fishing when Arthur got sick in the game it kinda paralleled my dad silly to say a game has that kind of impact but it did this is literally a perfect game.
@@m4sterrr553 That's probably a reasonable assessment, but it's also unfair to say that just because you don't cry you didn't feel emotion from the story. Some people aren't criers and if they are they can cry at different things. I'm in touch with my emotional side, not a huge crier though. When Arthur died I just straight felt numb from being sad. I didn't cry but I was just sitting there with my controller depressed that that happened. When they wanted me to play as John, I put down my controller as I couldn't continue the game in that state. Don't worry I've since seen the whole game.
I know it's a bit of a cliché to say these days but this game literally changed my life. Anyone who has the courage to show their reaction in this way online is really refreshing to see - something we don't get very often on RUclips. Great video.
Yeah I think it was really nice to see an unashamed and uncut open reaction. So many would cut the video or pause and try to suppress the tears or whatnot... Almost teared up along with her while re-watching this and this ending definitely got me good when I played it.
For me it wasnt Arthur's death sence that made me cry, it was when he was riding his horse back to the camp at the cave and when he is remembering all the ppl he had helped, that got me and still to this day it always makes me cry that part in this game, Arthur was one of them well written and well performed characters ever made I reckon
Same thing happend to me, I knew it was gonna be the final moments of Arthur, combined with the music and the "Maybe it's a sign, Arthur try... try to do the good thing" hit me like a truck
@@suprakong9966 Ive seen ppl play this part on youtube before i played it and didnt hit me till i played the game itself and u arthur grows u and it was hard to lose him, I still break down when he rides on his horse for the last time with him remembering back etc
@@suprakong9966 plus when he say goodbye to Sadie and Abigail always gets the tears starting to flow, I just love arthur and the the voice actor did a perfect job on him
@@WilliamRumpf01200 yes to all, they all hit me more than Arthur’s actual death. Hell, even Arthur telling Jack he was going to get his mama made me emotional. Don’t get me wrong , his death was sad, but by that time I was just thankful he accomplished what he wanted and he got to die on his own terms watching the sunrise and no longer in pain
@@deadpool981 Arthur's Death has to be the saddest thing in a game I reckon, Ive played RDR2 a few times and his death always brings a tear to my eye. yeah that thing about Jack was sad as well
Please don't apologize for crying, you're definitely not the only one to have this reaction. It's was a really sad moment and I don't blame you, but I also hope you don't stop playing here. I know it hurts, but keep going. You won't regret it.
@@SiennaMaria I have played the game more than once, have seen an unknown number of playthroughs, and I get teary-eyed every. Single. Time. Sure, maybe part of it is a sympathetic response, but such a powerful story. I don't think any game, movie or story has inspired so much emotion as this one. Especially chapter six. P.S. play the epilog and you will get some much needed closure.
Keep going and even play the first red dead redemption which was praised highly before rdr2 came out. Same hard hitting story with the same characters.
My wife bought me this game when it came out on the ps4, i wasn’t really a campaign guy because i was playing a lot of call of duty, now that nobody plays online anymore, I’ve decided to play all campaign games that i never finished. I decided to restart red dead 2 and man…. What a game. Almost cried when Arthur died. I wake up every morning thinking about how Arthur was amazing as a person. Truly one of the best games I’ve played in my life.
Shoot, I am a 62 year old combat vet and even I cried when he died! God bless your tender little heart!!❤ This is my all time favorite game and I have played all the way through 4 times now and still find things
god... he really did. he deserved a life with Mary... the mission where he goes to see a play with her is the most fun Arthur probably ever had in the year before he passes away... Arthur was a good man..
@@8K240hz And still, Arthur won. He died making sure John got out and had a good life, and despite what happens in RDR, theres a good 4 year gap of perfect ranch family life that John gets to experience, and I bet Arthur is glad he helped make that happen.
This game teaches that no one, ever is beyond redemption, it's never ever too late too change and that anyone is capable of becoming a better person because they can. Be the light that shines into your own darkness.
This game has such an amazing way of making us feel through Arthur. I literally feel sicker as the story progresses. The mission where he rides off to confront the camp, I feel this horrible claustrophobia and panic as if I’m on my last legs. What a character, and what a game. I’m still in awe of it all these year later.
Had strep throat when I played through the end for the first time. I got progressively more ill throughout the week, Arthur was also getting sicker at the time. It was an immersive experience I could’ve lived without considering it was real hard to breathe before I got better… that being said I feel so much closer to Arthur because of that. Although I got better. Arthur didn’t.
Jesus, I'm a 43 year old man and you made me cry harder than I did the first time I played through Arthur's ending. Man, what a powerful experience Rockstar created.
You grow so attached to Arthur throughout the whole game, that his death hits so incredibly hard. The only game ive ever played that genuinely made my eyes tear up. RDR2 is such an utter masterpiece.
There's some people, who most likely haven't played RDR 1, that don't continue playing after Arthur's death, and leave John's story hanging. But for those of us fans who have played RDR 1, the epilogue is a giant love letter, since we get to play as John again and we get to see the events that lead us into that first game. PS: The epilogue is set 8 years after the main game, so it's set in 1907.
I think of Arthur Morgan a lot of the days of my life. No fictional character has made an impact on me like he has. Seeing you cry made me relive it all over again. I love how genuine you are
Yup. That’s the reaction I expected. This game destroyed me like no film or show ever has. Wrecked me. I instantly started a new game cuz I couldn’t handle the loss lol.
same! I just finished my 5th playthrough a few days ago and instantly started a new game... I missed Arthur way to much, now I'm spending as much time as I possibly can with Arthur and taking my time progressing. I love John, but there's something incredibly special about Arthur.
I sobbed like you did and I ain't ashamed of it. That was the saddest shit I've ever seen in any media. Every breath john, Jack and Abigail take after arthur died was bought and paid for with Arthur's life.
Yeah, it felt unreal to play after that, shock and only thinking about Arthur's death. Same happened to me. But I finished it, the revenge calms you down a bit.
@@biancaman4930yea you really feel empty like you didn’t get to grieve for someone that isn’t real Arthur Morgan really is a top tier character in games
53:40 this is the moment when everyone are completely with their heartbroken. Four years later and this game is still awesome, you are really into the character.
She wins. I've seen people cry during the ride back to camp, the horse dead scene and maybe Arthur death. She takes the cake crying even during the epilogue
I feel your pain. As silly as it sounds losing Arthur was like losing a close friend. It actually hurts your heart no matter if he was real or not you spent so much time with him he became real.
I've shed tears, even cried of a lot of things, but I've never ugly-cried uncontrollably as I did after Arthur's death. The name "Arthur Morgan" will never be forgotten to me. I've spent over 150 hours in one single playthrough with Arthur, which is way way WAY more than I've spent in any other singleplayer game. After that, I've never been able to start a new game because I don't wanna do that to Arthur again ;( (or to me lol) Your reaction was priceless ♡ R.I.P Arthur Morgan
This is a legit reaction. I’ve stopped playing for the first time during the campaign after this. Fort a week maybe. I don’t know. This game is a masterclass in immersion. Arthur wins you in 10 seconds. You playing as him is like a godly way to root for him. And you feel like you are in control of that. You die, try again. Arthur is there. But when that control is taken away from you, and you are back to real life. Where you in fact have no turning back on events. No save point. That breaks you really hard if you feel like I’ve just described. It’s a true grief. Is cool how games give us the opportunity to see a life time of a possible person on a given universe. And also can teach us how to understand the inevitability of death. Great video. Subscribed.
The advantage of everyone who has NOT played the first part - they can believe that John is dead, which adds tension. Those who have played the first part know that he CAN'T be dead ...
I cried just as hard, and I still cant get over Arthurs death. Ive never had a game or a movie or any piece of fiction impact me like this. It is as if it really happened. The tragedy of it all just absolutely broke me. And when I randomly found Arthurs grave as John I broke down sobbing again, mourning him as if he were a real person that I knew and loved.
This was so sad, I can’t even deal.. what an amazing Game and Journey! I am really enjoying your journey through this Game, I am glad John and his Family made it out. Wondering what will happen next! Hope you’re having a lovely day! 🤗
Your pained cries under your breath surmise my own experience with this ending. I played this game AGAIN to my boys death, in honorable fashion. While my wife was getting ready to go out to dinner. And with tears still in my eyes, I cried for a man I have never met. But in his story, I saw a reflection of the good in humanity I will never forget. Thank you for sharing your raw emotions, in such a way that I can relate.
I could feel her pain. When I finished my 1st play though I was crying so hard that it was hard to breathe and I was shaking. It hurts dude. Feels like you where part of it. No one that i have told ab it understands
I couldn't handle it when my horse died. She was the first horse I ever bought, the brown one I forgot what her name was. When Arthur mourned her going away, this game felt like more than just a game. I still look for ways on the internet for an alternate ending where Arthur and his horse live. I don't think this game broke me, if anything, it made me emotionally stronger after all the crying that I did.
That you had such a powerful reaction to Arthur’s death shows what an epic tale and beautiful game Red Dead Redemption 2 is. I’ve played it through 3 times now and I found new things every time. It’s simply the best game I’ve ever seen. And I wish there was another one on the way.
Someone needs to get this gal a Powerade and a hug. Arthur Morgan is without a doubt in my mind, the most human character in a video game, ever. I've seen so many people grieve his loss as though he were a real person, like a friend or family member even, and I find that amazing.
Thank you for this reaction as I feel like I finally grieved for Arthur. I hadn’t shed an actual tear even though I hated that he died, but seeing you broke down made me cry too. I felt guilty that I hadn’t cried for him until now.
I've played this game so many times, but I still crying like a baby. There were a few games that touched me, but none even come close to RDR2. Its so massive... it smashes me everytime again. It's okay to cry because it shows how badly you've been through the game. You've been Arthur for half a year... that's a long time. It's like something was taken from you. I would have loved to hug you, but I think we all felt the same way!
Thank you for sharing such a vulnerable moment. I played this game alot but you made me cry like it was my first time. Thank you so much for giving me that feeling
You had a genuine sad reaction like many of us. Those who cried their hearts out or shed at least a tear, knows how great this game has been. I am not gonna get into much detail about how sad I felt, all I would say is, 2nd time i tried playing, I just couldn't get myself to go beyond chapter 2....Watching now after 3-4 years, I still have the same sadness as I did playing it for first time.
53:08 That moment broke me big time. Alice was with me the whole game, through so many missions and flying bullets, she did. To see how she came down like that, I was not prepared at all.
The reason the train didn't stop before reaching the bridge and instead continued the path and fell off the cliff was because the train driver was dead, like Bill said just before jumping off the train: 24:13 (it's implied Bill accidentally killed the driver).
But what I don’t get is that, WASNT the train going to Annesberg (deffo not how you spell it) but we went from Sant denis to up north of valentine?? I’m just confused😭
@@SiennaMaria I think it was because the soldiers and train driver knew from the moment you jump on the train that it is being robbed. So they probably wanted to make the gang's(or what was left of it) life a little harder. I think so anyway.
@@SiennaMaria The train took the other line I think, the one that was being built during the game that had a couple of minor missions for Arthur to do.
On the "Last Ride" scene as arthur rides towards the camp, i feel like universally everyone realises this is it, the moment, the decider for arthurs story. Such a powerful moment. Kudos.
I’ve played this game several times through and I remember the first time and I remember just bawling for 30 minutes. I had to pause the game lol. Now I’m watching you play it and I’m sitting here crying again 😭
I had to pause too at the start of the Marston section and go collect myself in a bathroom too.. then got back and decided "Nope, can't" and continued the next day. This game and Last of Us 2 are the only games that have made me so much emotions that I've had to deal with stuff for a while, almost like with real events. (I know the latter is very divisive, so won't state any more opinions on the game or it runs a risk of becoming another argument, but I am happy about games daring to cause such strong emotions [and in TLoU2's case; deliberately making the player feel hate towards an aspect of the game] and I hope we get varying degrees of that in the future as well)
Arthur has been the only character I have ever fully cried over. Especially in a video game. He just felt so human and Rockstar did an amazing job at connecting us with him
I was not as visibly devestated, but when they rolled right into the epilogue with so little time to process, I had to quit the game for a day before continuing.
@@Quotenwagnerianer Oh my god, I never quite realized till my third play through how little time they give you to process what happened between Chapter 6 & the epilogue. 😭
Before the final ride started, i knew what was gonna happen. So I paused the game, sat in bed, crying whilst watching RUclips for about 40 minutes. Ended up crying like 5 times that day😀
Your reaction to everything is so reassuring to me, because i was actually sobbing all the way from arthur saying goodbye to sadie and abigail until the very end. Good to see someone who felt the same strong things i felt :)
thank you for being so sincere. Arthur taught us that with the time left, we can still make a difference and try to be better....he is a good man The story is sad but is epicT^T After playing it twice, I still can’t accept Arthur’s ending but he was redeemed
I’m honestly so glad mine was a blind play through. I knew nothing of the first game so moments like John’s death and his return were so unexpected and real to me, also being able to see Dutch turn from a good man to who he becomes in RDR1 was such a shock and surreal being able to see it unravel before me. Now I’ve just finished RDR1 and it’s become my favourite gaming series of all time. I don’t think I’ll ever forget the events of either game in my lifetime, especially the ending of Arthur’s story. Unforgettable….
This game and the witcher 3 are the only games that I just felt absolutely lost and depressed when I finished them because I didn’t know what to play after since I was so moved by those games.
I'm guessing you got the Empress Ciri ending based off of your comment since it's the more sadder one of the good endings, unless god forbid you got the bad ending on your first playthrough. At least Witcher 3 had the B&W dlc to follow up with the main story, really wished that RD2 got single player dlc too but sadly the devs seem to be more interested in putting more attention on their "monetized online content" (which just boils down to GTA Online since they've been mostly neglectful towards RD2 Online from what I've heard) for profit than they do about expanding their single player experiences.
I have watch more then 20 different reactions to Arthur's Death and yours it is best one so far. I know you can't compare pain and suffering, but you make me cry again...for a hundred time. Please keep playing this amazing game with John, and you will have Redemption at the End. :-)
ikr, I've watched literally dozens of different people cry at this game but she was absolutely broken. It almost felt like it was my first time seeing it again😢
Thank you. This is the only video i saw on your channel so far, i'm going to be honest about it. It showed up in the suggested videos. Of course it did, there is something about this game and this part especially that i keep going back to so i've watched many clips of people playing through this same game section, crying their hearts out. Your video had to come up at some point. I'm almost 47 years old, i've been playing videogames since the commodore 64 era. This game was the most true and beautiful thing i have ever experienced when it comes to videogames. I'm greatful for it, from the deepest of my heart. And yes, this part is heartbreaking, i went through very similar emotions you went through in the same intensity. I cried my soul out (the death of the horse might be the only difference. Yes, it is sad, of course, but it never got to me too bad in over 10 playthroughs of this unique experience) and i'm greatful for it. It's heartbreaking to see someone going through the same emotions i went through, but at the same time i'm so greatful to see other people's suffering thanks to this epic tale. Thanks to Arthur. You were still crying when the story continued with John, Abigail and Jack. As much as i did. It's as if we both needed more mourning time. And i can find proof in it, you didn't realize what was being said by John and Jack just as i didn't in my first playthrough: John asks Jack what the name of the king of the round table was and Jack replies "King Arthur". It seems that went over your head just as much as it did to me during my first playthrough. I'm thankfull for your honesty, for sharing this with us. Yes, it is heartbfeaking. But at the same time i mostly feel gratitude to have the chance to share these emotions with other people, all over the world. Arthur will always live forever in our hearts. Like a real person we learnt to get to know. Again, thank you. It's been a holesome delight seeing what you went through. I know exactly how you felt and how you still feel.
Every time I watch this I cry. It just gets you more and more every time you come back and do this mission. Such a beautiful and sad story at same time. Masterpiece of a game ! Goated game for me by million miles !
This is what it means to be human. The one who sheds so many tears on a stage of a play is a human being with a heart and conscience. You even made me cry. You are an emotional human being. I hope you always stay like this. It is very difficult to be human, but you are truly human.
This video and this playthrough is a perfect example of why so many gamers come back and watch people play this game, it’s because it’s our way of re experiencing a masterpiece and your playthrough is one of the best reactions to this game. It’s been a hell of a journey keep up the good work
This video not only made me subscribe to you, but i also shared the same feelings as you. It was so tough on me too. Thank you for showing this game the respect it deserves.
Arthur has been one of the few characters in any video game that actually felt so human.
By the way, the epilogue will serve as a great consolation for what has just happened, it is a nice tribute to those of us who played rdr1, and at the same time it is an ending that leaves you very satisfied.
Kind of.Most people can understand him fighting between the good and bad side of him.But at the end of the day Arthur was a scumbag person that murdered and destroyed peoples lives for his own personal gain.Just because he was charismatic and occasionally did nice things doesn’t excuse any of his horrific actions.Point is,if you knew someone like Arthur in real life,you’d stay as far away from him as possible and you damn sure wouldn’t shed a tear if he died.
@@BrooklynBalla I agree, he was the only most sympathetic out of the group. Then John becomes even more sympathetic in a way in the epilogue and even more in rdr1. Either way arthur is my 1st favorite then John and Dutch as 3rd. I love the entire story between all of them also Jack's redemption was also pretty nice
@@BrooklynBalla Nah that's just you.
Arthur’s personality is so human, but his skills is just beyond human, he’s basically a one-man army. He uses McCree’s ult whenever he wants, it’s high-noon for him even in the night time.
I'm willing to bet that Aurther's death is one of the most cried over scenes in video game history...great play thru!
for me its the only video game scene ever
i guess for woman sure, how ever allot of them cried when john got killed in number one also, how ever I have seen this phenomenon in other games too, Last Tiger storyline in battlefeild 5 is an example where ive seen that, as well as in unexpected events where mains or good friends of mains are killed off like in the Yakuza series from sega
I believe Lee's drawn out death in Telltale's The Walking Dead series was an emotional one for many as well.
FF7 for many
This is the only video game story that I have cried for…
Arthur walking into heaven:
"HAHA, FOUND YA LENNY."
😂😂😂😂
And Lenny Said :
ARTHUR , WHAT ARE YOU DOING.*
LENNY MA BOOAAA
Reunited with his horse
Yeah definetly after robbing the bank in valentine hes in heaven
Right@@RafaielGames
Hosea: "how do you want to die, Arthur?"
Arthur: " I don't care about all that. Just turn me West so I can watch the sunset and remember all of the great times we had..."
Plot twist: he dies facing east, into the sunrise.
@@derekwoodford9955 but he got buried facing west on top of a mountain
@@chairforce664 The question was how do you want to die, not where do you want to rest....
I love that he died facing the sunrise, symbolises how his ending was different than he wanted or planned but in the end, he ended up a better man :) he didn’t get what he wanted but he got what he needed
@@laurentuck7835 nice pic
I seen a lot of people cry when Arthur died, you took it real hard
Same I teared up a lot when arthur passed away.
I think she kept the same horse for the entire game too. I knew she was really going to cry hard when her horse died. :(
@@Darkswordz she did. it's the black shire we get from hosea back in chapter 2 to sell to the stable or keep
@@andrewrodriguez6172 I've seen it a dozen times and seen a hundreds of playthroughs....I still tear up. So impactful and so emotional. Such great writing.
I watched a lot of playthroughs. I felt this one. We've ALL been there... well, all of us who played it in earnest.
This was one of the sincerest reactions I've ever seen.
You'd be a terrible cop with those judgement skills lmao
@@HunterMagunter u r a terrible human being already
Only if you would see mine 😂
@@HunterMagunter She literally has tears in her eyes and is missing shots after she started crying when she saw John get arthurs hat
@@__mindflayer__ faking for views lmao
By the way, the actors in this scene all deserve every award an actor can get.
You mean the streamer?
@@realaveragejonNo he's talking about the actors
Actor who played Arthur got best actor award at the Game Awards. Well deserved.
@@Swalker20659Except god of war got GOTY which it shouldn’t have
@@emma6648 I agree, God of war was very good but RDR2 was way better, It should have taken it.
I remember having to go into work the same night I played this mission… the worst shift I’ve ever worked through in my life
Same
Went to the gym after
I went to my badminton training schedule after that.
lol that sucks. we’re all hit hard by it but ppl don’t understand when u tell them it’s bc of a video game. sounds silly but its amazing how fictional characters affect us
@@billygoat12 I don’t get how it’s silly, tbh. People cry over movies/tv shows, books and music, right? It’s all art, so why not a video game you’ve invested so much time in?
When Arthur says goodbye to his dying horse it hit HARD.
Top 3 saddest moments in history
3) Hodor dies
2) Arthur's horse dies
1) Kevin Malone spills his famous chili
@@pekkalaitinen8769"Hold the door" 💔
For me Arthur’s horse that died was Buell, Hamish’s fav horse he gave to Arthur when he died. So that part was heartbreaking, the horse that reminded Arthur of the one friend he made outside of crime that they both bonded on their love of the outdoors during their finals days.
Especially if it's Buell. Subsequent playthroughs, I save Buell for John in the Epilogue. Once is enough for me to watch him die.
it didnt lmao,
That bit when Tilly starts to say I'll miss you and Arthur cuts her off with "me too sweetheart" gets me every time
Jack? Come here, son.
I know you're scared.
But Miss Tilly is gonna keep you safe.
You're a good kid.
Be brave, son.
Where will you go, Uncle Arthur?
*Uncle Arthur is gonna go get your Momma.*
When Arthur says to the Swanson "You're getting real sentimental". In other words, it is what it is and we both know what it is. Nothing else needs to be said about it.
That is when I started crying, then the tears didn't stop
* too
In the credits it shows her living the high life in St Denis. I guess she kept a lot of the money Arthur gave her
I'm a grown ass man, and a self proclaimed "tough guy" and i cried like a baby my first playthrough of this.
Hahahahahahahahhaha
I feel like I’m torturing myself whenever I replay it lol. It’s fun in the beginning, just getting drunk with Lenny and partying with the gang… then it slowly devolves, and I know where it’s headed and it’s like torture forcing myself to play it again. But I love it lol😂😂
I’d like to double down on your exact statement
I even had the game spoiled for me and you could obviously see it coming once get gets diagnosed but I still cried all the way until I got control of John and them I’m pretty sure I cried even more tears of joy realizing how things have come full circle from RDR1
same
"self proclaimed tough guy" aka: never been in a fight but can grow a beard and has a beer belly
It's a tradition to come back here and feel the pain again.
It always makes my eyes water again
you seriously found her crying not cringe and not understand she is acting lol
@@usm2247how do you know she is acting?
A comment to remind you 😭
100%
i've seen this ending like 50 times and i'm still crying.
can relate
WHY would you not?🥲
Struggle is real bro it’s same for me i cry every fucking time
Lmao
Me too brother
Title: I am broken beyond repair
Rockstar Games: Everything is coming together, exactly as I planned.
@@randomguywithagoatee253 no
They did a superb job as they always do. Its like that film Braveheart the woman always forever cry when he gets executed because they see wallace NOT as a criminal, raider, lawbreaker, ect. But as a handsome rouge rebel who fought for a just cause and lost. Even though his fellow clansmen win at Bannockburn in 1314. That is how they view Arthur.
Hope they do it with GTA 6 even though it'll be tough
"I'm helping John... I'm not turning into Dutch."
That is just about the hardest line I've heard from anyone I've seen play this game. It's a canon line in every person's head who chose the honorable storyline. God bless, Sienna...
I never cried in a videogame, but that last ride with Arthur.... Damn I couldn't held my tears.... Amazing game.
“That’s the way it is”
Same
Only characters I cried about were Arthur and Joel Miller those 2 man I loved em that’s why it was hard to see them die
Same for me
That's the part that got me too, the last ride after saying bye to Abigail. It was perfectly done, and sad as hell!
John confronting Dutch always breaks my heart. He really sounds like a kid that was abandoned by his dad, and that really fuckin hurts
RDR1 hits so fucking different now after RDR2
Same with Arthur. Remember the way he cried for Dutch when Dutch ran off at the industry? It was so sad 😭. Arthur acts like a big baby around Hosea and Dutch
@kartikayysola Genuinely so depressing that it makes me wish RDR2 was the only entry, because the epilogue ends on a (mostly) happy note with John making ammends and wrapping up lose ends
The Saddest Trophy achievement of all "Redemption". Every RDR fan was crying when they got it.
I'll freely admit as a man pushing 40 at the time, when that horse fell I had to put the controller down for five minutes and step away, and by the time the credits rolled I was flat out ugly crying. Even watching this now so many years removed from the first time, I could feel the tears coming once again. This will always rank in my top three greatest of all times for that emotional connection alone. A true masterwork. It's the people who can keep stone faced through it all that worry me.
Yeah I agree this game by far above anything else had a profound impact on me I lost my dad to brain cancer around this time he was a big fan of western movies he would have loved playing this game with the hunting and fishing when Arthur got sick in the game it kinda paralleled my dad silly to say a game has that kind of impact but it did this is literally a perfect game.
Pushing 40 myself and cried my heart out. Was soo worth it.
Unfortunately I think I was one of those stone faced people 💀 was a bit sad but that's it I guess 😕
@@kronniikk1957 i feel like these are the type of people who rushed the story on their first playthrough and got the bad honur ending
@@m4sterrr553 That's probably a reasonable assessment, but it's also unfair to say that just because you don't cry you didn't feel emotion from the story. Some people aren't criers and if they are they can cry at different things. I'm in touch with my emotional side, not a huge crier though. When Arthur died I just straight felt numb from being sad. I didn't cry but I was just sitting there with my controller depressed that that happened. When they wanted me to play as John, I put down my controller as I couldn't continue the game in that state. Don't worry I've since seen the whole game.
I know it's a bit of a cliché to say these days but this game literally changed my life. Anyone who has the courage to show their reaction in this way online is really refreshing to see - something we don't get very often on RUclips. Great video.
It was definitely a scary thing to do but I prefer to be as open as possible about my feelings!
@@SiennaMaria Exactly.
HOW IT CHANGE YOU ?
Yeah I think it was really nice to see an unashamed and uncut open reaction. So many would cut the video or pause and try to suppress the tears or whatnot...
Almost teared up along with her while re-watching this and this ending definitely got me good when I played it.
@@SiennaMaria i simply love you great playthrough i subbed
She is the embodiment of the entire gaming community when Arthur passed.
Real
For me it wasnt Arthur's death sence that made me cry, it was when he was riding his horse back to the camp at the cave and when he is remembering all the ppl he had helped, that got me and still to this day it always makes me cry that part in this game, Arthur was one of them well written and well performed characters ever made I reckon
Same thing happend to me, I knew it was gonna be the final moments of Arthur, combined with the music and the "Maybe it's a sign, Arthur try... try to do the good thing" hit me like a truck
@@suprakong9966 Ive seen ppl play this part on youtube before i played it and didnt hit me till i played the game itself and u arthur grows u and it was hard to lose him, I still break down when he rides on his horse for the last time with him remembering back etc
@@suprakong9966 plus when he say goodbye to Sadie and Abigail always gets the tears starting to flow, I just love arthur and the the voice actor did a perfect job on him
@@WilliamRumpf01200 yes to all, they all hit me more than Arthur’s actual death. Hell, even Arthur telling Jack he was going to get his mama made me emotional. Don’t get me wrong , his death was sad, but by that time I was just thankful he accomplished what he wanted and he got to die on his own terms watching the sunrise and no longer in pain
@@deadpool981 Arthur's Death has to be the saddest thing in a game I reckon, Ive played RDR2 a few times and his death always brings a tear to my eye. yeah that thing about Jack was sad as well
1:03:33 , Arthur himself confirms that he won by that smirk. Redemption is his. The Greatest Protaganist of all time.
I can’t bring myself to realize that it’s just a game, I literally came across this and cried again with you seeing Arthur’s death.
I don't think enough people appreciate the absolutely PERFECT music selections by rockstar. Amazing.
This song was specifically made for rdr2.
God damn man all of them soundtracks are perfect
Why do you say that? They won awards for it.
I think they do
they didn't choose they make it
Please don't apologize for crying, you're definitely not the only one to have this reaction. It's was a really sad moment and I don't blame you, but I also hope you don't stop playing here. I know it hurts, but keep going. You won't regret it.
100% am going to keep playing😭
another reason to continue playing u have to get revenge on Micah...
@@SiennaMaria I have played the game more than once, have seen an unknown number of playthroughs, and I get teary-eyed every. Single. Time. Sure, maybe part of it is a sympathetic response, but such a powerful story. I don't think any game, movie or story has inspired so much emotion as this one. Especially chapter six.
P.S. play the epilog and you will get some much needed closure.
@@TheJohmac exactly my friend. That’s what I felt. Never been so connected with the hero of any story, book, movie, video game or tv show.
Keep going and even play the first red dead redemption which was praised highly before rdr2 came out. Same hard hitting story with the same characters.
My wife bought me this game when it came out on the ps4, i wasn’t really a campaign guy because i was playing a lot of call of duty, now that nobody plays online anymore, I’ve decided to play all campaign games that i never finished. I decided to restart red dead 2 and man…. What a game. Almost cried when Arthur died. I wake up every morning thinking about how Arthur was amazing as a person. Truly one of the best games I’ve played in my life.
🫂
Yeah You Right , Big Respect For #RogerClark And #RockstarGames
and i hope GTA VI have a good story like everytime
Shoot, I am a 62 year old combat vet and even I cried when he died! God bless your tender little heart!!❤ This is my all time favorite game and I have played all the way through 4 times now and still find things
Stop making shit up
combat vet doesnt mean a thing if your not from us
@@minecraftminer59mineboymin38reconsider existing for me will ya?
whoa. Now that's a different story. I wonder what was your deployment. I respect veterans.
@@minecraftminer59mineboymin38 shush
Arthur deserved so much more. That’s why his end is so painful to watch.
god... he really did. he deserved a life with Mary... the mission where he goes to see a play with her is the most fun Arthur probably ever had in the year before he passes away... Arthur was a good man..
@@8K240hz And still, Arthur won. He died making sure John got out and had a good life, and despite what happens in RDR, theres a good 4 year gap of perfect ranch family life that John gets to experience, and I bet Arthur is glad he helped make that happen.
i havent played rdr1 😭@@Penmont.
@@8K240hzBut I didn’t agree to help her.)
This game teaches that no one, ever is beyond redemption, it's never ever too late too change and that anyone is capable of becoming a better person because they can. Be the light that shines into your own darkness.
This game has such an amazing way of making us feel through Arthur. I literally feel sicker as the story progresses. The mission where he rides off to confront the camp, I feel this horrible claustrophobia and panic as if I’m on my last legs. What a character, and what a game. I’m still in awe of it all these year later.
Had strep throat when I played through the end for the first time. I got progressively more ill throughout the week, Arthur was also getting sicker at the time. It was an immersive experience I could’ve lived without considering it was real hard to breathe before I got better… that being said I feel so much closer to Arthur because of that. Although I got better. Arthur didn’t.
Rockstar taking long time making their games but they always coming out with a W
Bro that part had my heart rate going at 100%
Oh girl, I feel you. I couldnt play games for months after this. RDR2 really broke me.
Me neither
Same I took a month off to get my mind off
6 years passed still crying......
R.I.P Arthur Morgan
Jesus, I'm a 43 year old man and you made me cry harder than I did the first time I played through Arthur's ending. Man, what a powerful experience Rockstar created.
Arthur's end is definitely a tear jerker. This game really gets you emotionally invested.
When I played it Arthur just got shot in the face by Micah.
@@redplaguebecause u got bad honour
You grow so attached to Arthur throughout the whole game, that his death hits so incredibly hard. The only game ive ever played that genuinely made my eyes tear up. RDR2 is such an utter masterpiece.
finished the game, got this ending... cried like a bitch, easily the best game ive ever played
No... You Cried Like A Real Man.
There's some people, who most likely haven't played RDR 1, that don't continue playing after Arthur's death, and leave John's story hanging. But for those of us fans who have played RDR 1, the epilogue is a giant love letter, since we get to play as John again and we get to see the events that lead us into that first game.
PS: The epilogue is set 8 years after the main game, so it's set in 1907.
this man is absolutely right
People that stop after Arthur's death are not people in my opinion
RDR1 is goated
@@Luka2000_ Markiplier did that. I still don't forgive him for it 😔
@@carl_consumer.of.reality and xqc
I think of Arthur Morgan a lot of the days of my life. No fictional character has made an impact on me like he has. Seeing you cry made me relive it all over again. I love how genuine you are
Yup. That’s the reaction I expected. This game destroyed me like no film or show ever has. Wrecked me. I instantly started a new game cuz I couldn’t handle the loss lol.
I think games hit harder cos we spend way more time w the character than we do in movie or tv , even tho theyre shot and written the same.
same! I just finished my 5th playthrough a few days ago and instantly started a new game... I missed Arthur way to much, now I'm spending as much time as I possibly can with Arthur and taking my time progressing. I love John, but there's something incredibly special about Arthur.
I sobbed like you did and I ain't ashamed of it. That was the saddest shit I've ever seen in any media. Every breath john, Jack and Abigail take after arthur died was bought and paid for with Arthur's life.
It was an amazing acting job. Fake garbage reaction. Fake female tears.
I think he did it once and abandoned his family, which is why he didn't want to do it again.
@@FreedomThroughDiscipline
I love how she still couldn't stop crying over Arthur's death even when playing as John 😢
I had to turn it off after Arthur died man. Straight up killed me.
@@s4ss.m8 same here
I kept playing after Arthur died lmao.
Yeah, it felt unreal to play after that, shock and only thinking about Arthur's death. Same happened to me. But I finished it, the revenge calms you down a bit.
@@biancaman4930yea you really feel empty like you didn’t get to grieve for someone that isn’t real Arthur Morgan really is a top tier character in games
Its nice to see after years this game still emotinally ruins people 😂
Lol no only those too easily impressed
Cry over a game dats weak
@@Paghmani1sher bro ur hard as
@@nametag4972 yes i is hard
@@Paghmani1sher nah man you just have no emotion
@@Waive33 i do but cant get easily impressed and emotional over some game
Its not dat great
53:40 this is the moment when everyone are completely with their heartbroken. Four years later and this game is still awesome, you are really into the character.
It feels so empty and sad to visit the same places as John. That empty feeling...man..this game is the greatest
i’ve never seen anyone this affected by Arthur, really just shows how much of an amazing character he is
And to think I cried more then her
She wins. I've seen people cry during the ride back to camp, the horse dead scene and maybe Arthur death. She takes the cake crying even during the epilogue
It’s genuinely so amazing to see how much great writing can affect someone.
i was living a bad and dark life,
Arthur Morgan is the reason of changing my whole life,
You've my respect Mr.Morgan
I feel your pain. As silly as it sounds losing Arthur was like losing a close friend. It actually hurts your heart no matter if he was real or not you spent so much time with him he became real.
I've shed tears, even cried of a lot of things, but I've never ugly-cried uncontrollably as I did after Arthur's death. The name "Arthur Morgan" will never be forgotten to me.
I've spent over 150 hours in one single playthrough with Arthur, which is way way WAY more than I've spent in any other singleplayer game. After that, I've never been able to start a new game because I don't wanna do that to Arthur again ;( (or to me lol)
Your reaction was priceless ♡
R.I.P Arthur Morgan
VOCÊ FALOU TUDO OQUE EU SENTI NA HORA, NÃO ME SINTO O UNICO AGORA HAHAHHA
Yeah man, started a new playthrough and now I'm hesitating
@@Randomeris1 haha xD
When I have to do low honor I am doing the Micah mod, can't force myself to make Arthur a bad man.
Please don't stop. Only way for him to live!
It's comforting to me to see others' emotions experiencing this story, and to know that I'm not crying over Arthur's fate alone
Watching Sienna cry like that made me so sad. It broke my heart actually. 😢
same i just wanted to hug her and hold her and let her cry it all out
This is a legit reaction.
I’ve stopped playing for the first time during the campaign after this. Fort a week maybe. I don’t know.
This game is a masterclass in immersion.
Arthur wins you in 10 seconds.
You playing as him is like a godly way to root for him. And you feel like you are in control of that. You die, try again.
Arthur is there. But when that control is taken away from you, and you are back to real life. Where you in fact have no turning back on events. No save point.
That breaks you really hard if you feel like I’ve just described. It’s a true grief.
Is cool how games give us the opportunity to see a life time of a possible person on a given universe. And also can teach us how to understand the inevitability of death.
Great video. Subscribed.
The advantage of everyone who has NOT played the first part - they can believe that John is dead, which adds tension. Those who have played the first part know that he CAN'T be dead ...
true but its nice to see the other characters (especially arthur's) reaction thinking he died for real
This is so bad worded i had a stroke thanks
@@Daysbb the grammar is perfect, are you alright?
I cried just as hard, and I still cant get over Arthurs death. Ive never had a game or a movie or any piece of fiction impact me like this. It is as if it really happened. The tragedy of it all just absolutely broke me. And when I randomly found Arthurs grave as John I broke down sobbing again, mourning him as if he were a real person that I knew and loved.
This was so sad, I can’t even deal.. what an amazing Game and Journey! I am really enjoying your journey through this Game, I am glad John and his Family made it out. Wondering what will happen next! Hope you’re having a lovely day! 🤗
Thank you so much, I’m so glad you enjoyed it😭
Your welcome! 🤗
Who's gonna tell em about Red dead redemption 1...
Your pained cries under your breath surmise my own experience with this ending. I played this game AGAIN to my boys death, in honorable fashion. While my wife was getting ready to go out to dinner. And with tears still in my eyes, I cried for a man I have never met. But in his story, I saw a reflection of the good in humanity I will never forget. Thank you for sharing your raw emotions, in such a way that I can relate.
I could feel her pain. When I finished my 1st play though I was crying so hard that it was hard to breathe and I was shaking. It hurts dude. Feels like you where part of it. No one that i have told ab it understands
I think the deer fucks you up even more knowing you did a good job on being an honorable person
Seeing the deer walk away actually killed me, I was alrdy sobbing but I just couldn’t breathe at that point I could barely see by that point
I couldn't handle it when my horse died. She was the first horse I ever bought, the brown one I forgot what her name was. When Arthur mourned her going away, this game felt like more than just a game. I still look for ways on the internet for an alternate ending where Arthur and his horse live. I don't think this game broke me, if anything, it made me emotionally stronger after all the crying that I did.
you are weak men!
One of the most genuine reactions I've seen on RUclips so far!
That you had such a powerful reaction to Arthur’s death shows what an epic tale and beautiful game Red Dead Redemption 2 is.
I’ve played it through 3 times now and I found new things every time. It’s simply the best game I’ve ever seen. And I wish there was another one on the way.
I wish there was a way to wipe my memory of this game so I could play it for the first time again. It's too perfect.
@@carl_consumer.of.reality too boring
Someone needs to get this gal a Powerade and a hug. Arthur Morgan is without a doubt in my mind, the most human character in a video game, ever. I've seen so many people grieve his loss as though he were a real person, like a friend or family member even, and I find that amazing.
Why a powerade? And they aren't that popular in the UK.
Im on it
aint nobody got more humanity, than Cole Macgraph - Zeke
@@MikeWilsonBarrett Restores your electrolytes and sodium levels, both of which are lost when crying.
Thank you for this reaction as I feel like I finally grieved for Arthur. I hadn’t shed an actual tear even though I hated that he died, but seeing you broke down made me cry too. I felt guilty that I hadn’t cried for him until now.
I cannot denied that this moment is so far the highest point in gaming history. I also had really strong feeling about Arthur. Epic, just epic.
I've played this game so many times, but I still crying like a baby. There were a few games that touched me, but none even come close to RDR2. Its so massive... it smashes me everytime again.
It's okay to cry because it shows how badly you've been through the game.
You've been Arthur for half a year... that's a long time. It's like something was taken from you. I would have loved to hug you, but I think we all felt the same way!
Thank you for sharing such a vulnerable moment. I played this game alot but you made me cry like it was my first time. Thank you so much for giving me that feeling
You had a genuine sad reaction like many of us. Those who cried their hearts out or shed at least a tear, knows how great this game has been. I am not gonna get into much detail about how sad I felt, all I would say is, 2nd time i tried playing, I just couldn't get myself to go beyond chapter 2....Watching now after 3-4 years, I still have the same sadness as I did playing it for first time.
Couldn’t get past chapter 2 😂😂 give me a break. So dramatic. Great game but come on lmao
Wtf did you find in chapter 2 ? I'm genuinely curious
@@heybignick9333Cry some more
It was an amazing acting job. Fake garbage reaction. Fake female tears.
53:08 That moment broke me big time. Alice was with me the whole game, through so many missions and flying bullets, she did. To see how she came down like that, I was not prepared at all.
This is the realest reaction i have seen, thank you for putting your heart and soul into my favorite game like i did
I remember crying my eyes out for hours after playing this for the first time.
The reason the train didn't stop before reaching the bridge and instead continued the path and fell off the cliff was because the train driver was dead, like Bill said just before jumping off the train: 24:13 (it's implied Bill accidentally killed the driver).
But what I don’t get is that, WASNT the train going to Annesberg (deffo not how you spell it) but we went from Sant denis to up north of valentine?? I’m just confused😭
@@SiennaMaria I think it was because the soldiers and train driver knew from the moment you jump on the train that it is being robbed. So they probably wanted to make the gang's(or what was left of it) life a little harder. I think so anyway.
@@SiennaMaria The train took the other line I think, the one that was being built during the game that had a couple of minor missions for Arthur to do.
On the "Last Ride" scene as arthur rides towards the camp, i feel like universally everyone realises this is it, the moment, the decider for arthurs story. Such a powerful moment. Kudos.
This game made a 38 year old man cry while playing this part….truly a masterpiece
Masterpiece from dan houser for the last time
How?
I never thought a game would make feel melancholic for a fictional character. While playing as John I couldn't believe how much I missed Arthur.
the purest, most sincere and emotional reaction to the ending I've ever seen, you made me cry again
It was an amazing acting job. Fake garbage reaction. Fake female tears.
Never apologize for emotion it's what makes us human 💗
It was an amazing acting job. Fake garbage reaction. Fake female tears.
The first time I played this game I cried like a baby so many times. I’m playing it again with a pain in my heart.
I've replayed this game countless times, and I get emotional every time.
girl i was crying just as much as you non stop after that horse scene
I’ve played this game several times through and I remember the first time and I remember just bawling for 30 minutes. I had to pause the game lol. Now I’m watching you play it and I’m sitting here crying again 😭
😂😂😂😂
I had to pause too at the start of the Marston section and go collect myself in a bathroom too.. then got back and decided "Nope, can't" and continued the next day.
This game and Last of Us 2 are the only games that have made me so much emotions that I've had to deal with stuff for a while, almost like with real events. (I know the latter is very divisive, so won't state any more opinions on the game or it runs a risk of becoming another argument, but I am happy about games daring to cause such strong emotions [and in TLoU2's case; deliberately making the player feel hate towards an aspect of the game] and I hope we get varying degrees of that in the future as well)
1:16:53 that moment when you re almost overcoming one thing, but then you remember something else to be sad about
I’m crying at that part 😭😭my poor baby
Love your passion and emotion. I'm a grown as-s man and I cried too
Arthur has been the only character I have ever fully cried over. Especially in a video game. He just felt so human and Rockstar did an amazing job at connecting us with him
Omg I've never seen someone so broken after Arthur died. Should of took a minute to gather yourself. Rolled right into Strawberry a mess lmao
U hell lmao
I was not as visibly devestated, but when they rolled right into the epilogue with so little time to process, I had to quit the game for a day before continuing.
@@Quotenwagnerianer Oh my god, I never quite realized till my third play through how little time they give you to process what happened between Chapter 6 & the epilogue. 😭
Before the final ride started, i knew what was gonna happen. So I paused the game, sat in bed, crying whilst watching RUclips for about 40 minutes. Ended up crying like 5 times that day😀
Rolled right into Strawberry a mess took me out 🤣🤣🤣🤣
I cry every time i see this ending. It hurts me in a way i just cant explain. Amazing play through. May Arthur Rest In Peace
Your reaction to everything is so reassuring to me, because i was actually sobbing all the way from arthur saying goodbye to sadie and abigail until the very end. Good to see someone who felt the same strong things i felt :)
1:02:25 ese "Dutch please" de la chica me rompió el corazón 💔
I feel you.
I didn't cry when i played the game myself, but seeing you crying playing it, it made me almost cry lol
thank you for being so sincere.
Arthur taught us that with the time left, we can still make a difference
and try to be better....he is a good man
The story is sad but is epicT^T
After playing it twice, I still can’t accept Arthur’s ending
but he was redeemed
I’m honestly so glad mine was a blind play through. I knew nothing of the first game so moments like John’s death and his return were so unexpected and real to me, also being able to see Dutch turn from a good man to who he becomes in RDR1 was such a shock and surreal being able to see it unravel before me. Now I’ve just finished RDR1 and it’s become my favourite gaming series of all time. I don’t think I’ll ever forget the events of either game in my lifetime, especially the ending of Arthur’s story. Unforgettable….
This game is better than most Hollywood movies
This game and the witcher 3 are the only games that I just felt absolutely lost and depressed when I finished them because I didn’t know what to play after since I was so moved by those games.
I'm guessing you got the Empress Ciri ending based off of your comment since it's the more sadder one of the good endings, unless god forbid you got the bad ending on your first playthrough. At least Witcher 3 had the B&W dlc to follow up with the main story, really wished that RD2 got single player dlc too but sadly the devs seem to be more interested in putting more attention on their "monetized online content" (which just boils down to GTA Online since they've been mostly neglectful towards RD2 Online from what I've heard) for profit than they do about expanding their single player experiences.
I have watch more then 20 different reactions to Arthur's Death and yours it is best one so far. I know you can't compare pain and suffering, but you make me cry again...for a hundred time. Please keep playing this amazing game with John, and you will have Redemption at the End. :-)
ikr, I've watched literally dozens of different people cry at this game but she was absolutely broken. It almost felt like it was my first time seeing it again😢
Thank you. This is the only video i saw on your channel so far, i'm going to be honest about it. It showed up in the suggested videos. Of course it did, there is something about this game and this part especially that i keep going back to so i've watched many clips of people playing through this same game section, crying their hearts out. Your video had to come up at some point. I'm almost 47 years old, i've been playing videogames since the commodore 64 era. This game was the most true and beautiful thing i have ever experienced when it comes to videogames. I'm greatful for it, from the deepest of my heart. And yes, this part is heartbreaking, i went through very similar emotions you went through in the same intensity. I cried my soul out (the death of the horse might be the only difference. Yes, it is sad, of course, but it never got to me too bad in over 10 playthroughs of this unique experience) and i'm greatful for it. It's heartbreaking to see someone going through the same emotions i went through, but at the same time i'm so greatful to see other people's suffering thanks to this epic tale. Thanks to Arthur. You were still crying when the story continued with John, Abigail and Jack. As much as i did. It's as if we both needed more mourning time. And i can find proof in it, you didn't realize what was being said by John and Jack just as i didn't in my first playthrough: John asks Jack what the name of the king of the round table was and Jack replies "King Arthur". It seems that went over your head just as much as it did to me during my first playthrough. I'm thankfull for your honesty, for sharing this with us. Yes, it is heartbfeaking. But at the same time i mostly feel gratitude to have the chance to share these emotions with other people, all over the world. Arthur will always live forever in our hearts. Like a real person we learnt to get to know. Again, thank you. It's been a holesome delight seeing what you went through. I know exactly how you felt and how you still feel.
Watching that back again and the way you felt brought me to tears. Empathy is a strong feeling. Xx
Every time I watch this I cry. It just gets you more and more every time you come back and do this mission.
Such a beautiful and sad story at same time.
Masterpiece of a game !
Goated game for me by million miles !
This is what it means to be human. The one who sheds so many tears on a stage of a play is a human being with a heart and conscience. You even made me cry. You are an emotional human being. I hope you always stay like this. It is very difficult to be human, but you are truly human.
Overreaction with the crying showed the emotion was clearly for views.
Especially looking at the camera constantly.😂
A great reaction. The way we all felt. like you, I loved my horse. It’s what makes this game one of the best.
This video and this playthrough is a perfect example of why so many gamers come back and watch people play this game, it’s because it’s our way of re experiencing a masterpiece and your playthrough is one of the best reactions to this game. It’s been a hell of a journey keep up the good work
This video not only made me subscribe to you, but i also shared the same feelings as you. It was so tough on me too. Thank you for showing this game the respect it deserves.
Micah- He’s the rat,Dutch!
Arthur- *I gave you all I had*