Ukraine Crisis - Analysis by Prof. Deepak Malhotra (HBS) & Jonathan Powell - Harvard Business School

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 23 ноя 2024
  • At an event held on March 2, 2022, Prof. Deepak Malhotra & Jonathan Powell provide a strategic analysis of the Ukraine crisis and respond to audience questions. Topics include: the likelihood and types of further escalation, how the conflict is likely to end, the prospects for a future negotiated agreement, what parties should be thinking about with regards to negotiation, how to make sense of Putin's strategy, what to do if Putin decides to use tactical nuclear weapons, how the sanctions strategy is likely to play out, what types of precedents might the current conflict create, how is the geopolitical landscape likely to change, the impact of the crisis on China's decision making on Taiwan, and more.

Комментарии • 30

  • @petercollier9073
    @petercollier9073 2 года назад +5

    My apologies, I may have comments on content later but is there a reason why the camera man has chosen satellite view to cover this debate so that we view the discussants from 30,000 miles above the earth?

  • @mastercerisdi
    @mastercerisdi 2 года назад +7

    Thank you for the expertise and your objective analysis of the situation, Prof. Malhotra! It was more than insightful. These conversations help a lot.
    Sadly, as a seasoned negotiator I expected Mr. Powell to try and put himself in the other party's shoes while he instead propagated a political agenda. This, I am afraid, is adding fuel to the fire rather than helping de-escalate the situation.

  • @rishiocity
    @rishiocity 2 года назад +3

    Insightful Session! Thank you, Prof. Deepak Malhotra.

  • @linaaboudheir3878
    @linaaboudheir3878 2 года назад +3

    Very interesting when the question of Iraq invasion popped up , why is it different This happened when Iraqi authorities did notify the Embassador of USA in Baghdad hours before & got US blessings , there were other motives for big powers we know this v well

  • @Ryan-zd1vb
    @Ryan-zd1vb Год назад

    is there anything similar published for the israel-palestine conflicts. i would love to hear more of your views on the subject

  • @DiogoAssis77
    @DiogoAssis77 2 года назад +1

    Very clarifying session. Thank you HBS

  • @PaulLembo
    @PaulLembo 2 года назад +2

    Thank you for sharing.

  • @shaikzameeruddin9398
    @shaikzameeruddin9398 2 года назад +1

    I was expecting this from you, Sir... Big fan 😁

  • @TAFFAREEEEEEEEELLLL
    @TAFFAREEEEEEEEELLLL 2 года назад +1

    Very clarifying. Thanks!

  • @qingzhou9983
    @qingzhou9983 2 года назад +2

    There is no way Russia would allow NATO to have troop in Ukraine. 1) NATO currently does not have enough troops on scale to fight Russia in Ukraine. 2) Just few troop in Ukraine as does not deter Putin. And most likely Putin would invaded first when there are sign of NATO troop moving into Ukraine. 3) Taiwan announced the US trainers in Taiwan to force a conflict between US and China. US wisely denied these are troops, but trainers. Foreign troop in Taiwan is a Red Line for China. It will cause War right away. These two experts did not mention the danger of US troop in Ukraine or Taiwan. This is very serious Problem.

  • @fanzheng1412
    @fanzheng1412 2 года назад

    Regarding difference between Taiwan and Ukraine. Isn't it a huge difference that most countries' official stance (including US) recognizes Ukraine as an independent country and Taiwan as part of China? People might disagree, but does not these international agreements mean something? Well, maybe not. I hope it does.

  • @barbginther2171
    @barbginther2171 2 года назад +4

    Exactly , Russians are people , too. Everyone's sacrificing and suffering . The world suffers .

    • @stanislavserman1200
      @stanislavserman1200 2 года назад

      Poor Russians who complain that they don't have access to Netflix and McDonald's. What about those Ukrainians who struggle for life, live in captivity, without water supply, electricity and proper food. Instead of it, they are being harassed, abused, deprived of basic needs etc. Tell me about the suffering of Russians.

  • @linaaboudheir3878
    @linaaboudheir3878 2 года назад +2

    Thank you Mr Jonathen for your honest response Absolutely double standards, you can even hear and see it on the Mefia Look at Syrian refugee & Palestenian’s , & What we see on the media Ukrainian refugees , more & more to be said on that front

  • @zana4464
    @zana4464 2 года назад +1

    good time prof. please give me several name of best book about negotiaion. thanks a lot

    • @HarshdeepMehta
      @HarshdeepMehta 2 года назад +1

      Buy one written by presenter, Deepak Malhotra.

  • @Alexander-qz6px
    @Alexander-qz6px 2 года назад +2

    I read Depak Chopra first and was very irritated.

  • @karimjr28
    @karimjr28 2 года назад

    Great discussion, but didn't Tony Blair authorize the war on Iraq, including civilian killings?

  • @rupamtiwari8031
    @rupamtiwari8031 2 года назад +1

    Then what usa done to Cuba when Russia made its millitary base in Cuba on Cuba request that's the double standard which which most West analyser doing

  • @Yngwie2024
    @Yngwie2024 2 года назад +4

    All of an sudden everyone is an expert i Russia and Ukraine and stupidly siding with one of two highly criminal countries (being Ukraine much worse than Russia)

  • @kristen4954
    @kristen4954 2 года назад

    😕 pr໐๓໐Ş๓

  • @curtisvalle5141
    @curtisvalle5141 2 года назад +6

    Seeing the masks, still...... dilutes any message somehow. Sad Prof. DM is great

    • @deepakmalhotra8983
      @deepakmalhotra8983  2 года назад +10

      Mask rule was in effect until March 3. Session took place on March 2. But I'm not sure how the mask interferes with the message when (a) the camera is so far away you can barely see the faces anyway, and (b) the speakers are mic'd and so the sound is getting fed clearly and directly into the recording.

    • @carlosmorales-miranda7714
      @carlosmorales-miranda7714 2 года назад

      Mask don’t work and limit the facial expression that come with your analysis
      Next time you can break the status quo!!

  • @joeprepper1476
    @joeprepper1476 2 года назад +1

    LOL still wearing masks