He didn't failed, Indian Naval Mutiny Resistance with British Raj was because of soldiers of Netaji Bose (Azad Hind Fauj) It was a reason why British gave up India
He cleared Indian Civil Services Exam (ICS) with just 6-7 months preparation, Rank-4. He resigned from that topmost position & risked his career, faced taunts for his motherland.
In a way, it's wrong to say that Netaji failed. The naval mutiny, and violent protests against the british conducted by armed Indian soldiers/police who were getting laid off, along with the anger a huge part of the population had in general against the British after the trials against INA members. Even if Netaji's army failed, he was still able to get India free by making a huge part of the population revolt violently (in Clement Atlee's words as well). Even if he failed tactically, he won strategically
exactly naval mutiny was result of INA establishment.I dont think he failed.But ya when we say faild he failed in the front game for which we can thank to mr jinnah and mr gandhi.mr gandhi fighting the bohrs war in africa and teaching non violence in country.every time i see hi face on my currency note i feel like replacing it with netaji.
that line literally brought me down in tears... "we admire leaders who failed... leaders who failed gloriously...", what a line... true hence they are remembered forever whereas the immortalized father of the nation merely lies in the scraps of barter paper...
@@Mahishasur I as a bengali can tell you that netaji nowadays is getting recognition he deserves.The young generation has started admiring netaji rather than admiring gandhi .
His failure was tactical but He won strategically. He succeeded in igniting the fire in the hearts of the Indian Navy and the common man. Their combined revolt forced the British to leave Bharat. I wish India would get a leader like him today....
Indeed . Man he was one of the topper of ICS exam 1921 , he kicked that job for his country . It need guts . Can you imagine any UPSC aspirant getting rank in top 10 in his very first attempt getting Ias in and then say he want to do something else . Netaji and Swami Vivekananda should be inspiration for every youth of India 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Netaji is our pride definitely. He gave everything for the Nation. I do have one more who dedicated his life for the Nation i.e. Veer Vinayak Damodar Savarkar.
I think his objective was to create a parallel army and government but on larger scale than militia ..because one of the main factors behind India's British occupation was British Indian army ... A good paying parallel army with indian head should have been good option for indian soldiers as well
If we see the surface we get the idea that Netaji failed, but if you dive in deep you would realise he did not, he once said "An individual can die but his idea would live forever". What Netaji did was he instilled the idea to fight for own motherland, which played a big role in the Naval Mutiny and that mutiny forced British to leave India. Netaji's idea that Indian soldiers must only fight for India made many Indian soldiers reconsider their loyalty for the empire and the empire was ruling in India because of those soldiers. So, we need to sit down and introspect did Netaji really fail?
Personally I disagree this headline pf the topic . As an ordinary mortal , in one of my stitnts as the Head of a Factory ,on the joining date , I was introduced to the Factory staff by the president director that" I was a failed Head " . I took it in literal lighter sense, not taking seriously . Later when I took a firm stand during my tenure reforming old unproductive practices , I proved him wrong . Imagine the great leader Subasji , his soul will not forgive us from heaven if we use the term he failed . Literally it pains me too much to see the headlines . Never again use this comments against the great Netaji Subasji. Please .
He didn't failed sir. The Battle of Haldighati was a stalemate and The Battle Of Dewair where Maharana Pratap crushed Mughal army so badly that akbar never dared to look at Mewar during his lifetime.
For those who think netaji failed, should know and read about the conversation between the British PM Attlee and Bengal governer after 2nd world war, where the Governer asked the PM that u r the most powerful right now on world stage, why r u leaving india now, becoz of gandhi? And the PM replied, "SUBHASH CHANDRA BOSE". Thats what difference Bose & INA made. Its not a loss. It is a win and its becoz of him. Whoever still think the Indipendence is due to Ahinsa only & only should dig, read and understand the events in history apart from popular narrative and history school books. There is contribution of many many great people known & unknown in the independence of india. The narration of the conversation i stated above is said to be in in Britain, it can be true it can be false but one should think, The INA was containing 25 lakh soldiers at that time think what it could have done, today indian army is of approx 15 lakh soldiers. This is an example of the reason why some historical facts are still unknown to public coz of the Narrative building excercise. Remeber, "To establish Peace, One must be Powerful first."
The fact that he could have just settled down with his wife abroad and never come back, but that man came back just to be called names. That's why I admire him, he had a goal.
Exactly dude like he had a great lifestyle he cleared ics exam and even could settle with his wife in abroad but he stilll chose his country and its freedom over everything.
Subhash Chandra Bose inspired many young age freedom fighter and guide them honestly how to love our Nation. The grate sacrifices of Netaji gives us a spark in our heart to work like freedom fighters towords our Nation. I am a Bengali and Netaji took a special place in my heart from my childhood. 🇮🇳
I also admire deeply Hitler for his great help to Netaji. It is historically truth that Hitler had immense respect for Bose and he organised the supreme possible security in land, sea and air for protecting Bose during his legendary mythical 3 month submarine journey from Germany to Japan. Hitler ordered his generals that in case of any emergency, the decision of Bose will be absolute. Hitler treated him as the head of free India. Also Musolini requested Netaji to continue all his activities from Italy. Ready information is available on the great book "AMI SUBHASH BOLCHI" by Sailesh Dey. This book is a precious historical document of Indian freedom struggle.
hitler didn't have any respect for Netaji. They were all busy with Aryan superiority and humiliated Netaji. Ofc Netaji had to suck it up because he didn't have ammunitions and other things and germans provided this to him
I'm not saying that what Hitler did was right because it's a true fact that millions of Jews died because of him and all the hate that he receives is totally justified but I have a question, why don't Winston Churchill receives same type of hate which Hitler gets? It's because of his policies which created a famine in Bengal and it killed more than 3 million people. Hilter hated Jews with a passion and Churchill also hated Indians with that same type of passion.
Anyone standing up for their land is no failure. Even if just to fill the que facing a firing squad, they die free with honor and fulfilment not failure. If you are willing to sacrifice this body for your people then there's no failure. It can insight the land to stand up. Great man love to learn more. Thanks for your historical sharing 💯🙏
Yes Netaji failed but His leadership, courage & valour still inspired millions... & in Beerbiceps podcast you had said that peace can only be acquired by strength , yeah its Netaji's mindset at that time....
Loved your beautiful words for Netaji. Just wish to add: Netaji spend two long years of his life in the notorious Mandalay jail in Burma. This was one of the two deadly jails of the British era, the other being Andaman's Cellular jail. Also, Netaji did not ultimately fail. His aim was India's political liberation. And his fight contributed indirectly in awakening the Indian sepoys and particularly the navy, leading to the exit of the Raj. We can say he failed in the sense that he was unable to prevent the establishment of a proxy govt. in India due to his absence at that crucial period. For the same reason, he also failed to prevent the partition.
i respect the way you are educating and how determined phrases your vocabulary holds while answering such benighted questions and keeping a straight face
#AskAbhijit I have a follow up question on this regarding Netaji's failing. What are your thoughts on the statement that was made by Clement Attlee saying that Netaji was responsible for India's independence? Is there any truth to this? From what I understood apparently Netaji and the INA with their actions had inspired the armed forces to resist the British which lead to the naval mutiny. Even though these attempts had failed it created a situation where the British could no longer trust their Indian soldiers. If this is true then Netaji was actually successful in a way.
INA trials and Royal Navy Mutiny proves Netaji was successful 🔥 ... Clement Atlee's statement proved Netaji was successful 🔥 .... You and me are living in an independent nation proves Netaji was successful 🔥
To all the people arguing if Gandhi should be the father of Nation or Subhash Chandra Bose, here are few insights for you, If Shivaji Maharaj, Guru Gobindh Singh ji, Maharana Pratap were sons of Nation so are Gandhi and Bose, although Bose would be the son mother India would be more proud of lol
no bro gandhi was puppet of britishers whenever britishers scolded gandhi he calmly listened to them and changed the route for freedom can you tell me wherever gandhiji used to go why he always carry girls with him instead of boys while netaji was highly educated he covered entire 2 years syllabus of civil sevices in 6 months and secured 4th position in that exam but rather living a lavish and luxurious life in uk he chose his people and country gandhi tried a lot to spread hate regarding netaji in everyones heart but he failed whereas nehru family removed entire history of netaji from every possible source and wrote their own history and sacrifice in our text books🙃
It feels good to read the comment section. People are getting to know the truth and are able to identify the truth ON THEIR OWN. Our true forgotten legends are coming back and those so called heroes who did nothing but destroy this country are being thrown away too. Change is coming slowly but steadily.
Sir for few days I have been watching , serial ahilyabai and I'm very fascinated to know about Malhar Rao(Subedar of indore) , who established its kingdom in Indore. Can you please tell some unknown facts about the king (Malhar Rao). And was he one of the most underrated kings in the Indian history??
Shrimanta Sardar Malharrao Holkar wasn't a king but one of the powerful Maratha sardar and a loyal adminstrator to the Throne of emperor of Bharat the Chhatrapati 🔥
Bose was a vast improvement on that clown Gandhi and his loin cloth. Where on this planet does a race take pride in cultural regression. I mean like....WTF!
"An individual may die for an idea, but that idea will reincarnate itself in thousand other lives" -Netaji' s statement proved to be true He may have failed himself, but his idea ignited millions of Indians which ultimately lead to our freedom
Once there was an owner of a beautiful house. There was a certain wall in his house that he realised served no purpose and wanted to bring down. He announced to the town folks that a certain wall needs to be pulled down but only using kicks. Who ever kicks the wall hard enough to make it fall, gets the reward. One by one, people started coming and kicking. The wall didn't budge. Sometimes it so happened that someone was really brave and strong, they shook the wall but still couldn't break it. Then came a man with an army. He with the support of his army, was able to shake the wall and weaken it to a great extent. But the guy too couldn't pull the wall down. Then came an old man and slightly kicked the wall and the wall fell. The owner of the house (not realising that the wall had already become weak after being kicked for so long by so many people so many times) thought that the old man was really strong and impacful and gave the reward to him.
People admired him cuz he knew chances of success wasn't in his favor but he never stopped despite what the outcome was he either gets freedom or die trying but never give up
Let's tranding #Netaji in upcoming 15 August and show mirror to Gandhian socialist+ communist people 🔥🔥🔥🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳... Abhijit chavda sir please 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏 kindly take initiative for this 🔥🔥... Jai Hind 🇮🇳
Hello Abhijit sir, I have 1 question for you: In my childhood my grandfather used to say "in the year 1942 Netaji after making Mayanmar Independent from British rule, he asked for help from 1 of the greatest personnel from Indian politics to arrange support of rest India to kick out British from India". Could you please check and confirm which history is correct?
Simple.... A society admires Warriors, not people who show one side of face after being salpped on another. Netaji was the true liberator of Bharat. The spark he created in British Indian army led to the Naval Mutiny of 1946, which led to the decision of British to exit India. 🇮🇳
Such an excellent answer given by abhijit chavda sir , its so true that leader should lead from front and as far as freedom is concerned, leader will risk his life first than his counterpart or their soldiers. Not like sitting beside britishers and let his people dying for practising satyagraha. Its like rat don’t want to run thinking one day cat will stop eating them.
In the words of Clement Attlee (PM of Great Britain then), the British left because of the impact of Netaji Bose. The impact of the non-violent movement was "minimal" on their decision to leave India.
My friends and everyone in my generation is busy preparing for a life to live in US and Europe. I watch Netaji's picture and think only when I change myself will I change everyone. He is my motivation to do something for my country. If I would have been alive during his time I would surrender myself and all my wealth to him and for India. I would follow him to hell and back. Such is his legacy, he was no way a failure.
very well said Sir, he failed because of that time politicians who deliberately planned to harm Netaji and postured him like a Villain ,and some how they succeeded also .....Netaji had the power to turn the tide since Indian masses followed him in large numbers. His speeches had the fuel in the fire effect. Netaji's approach was to vibrate of British Government and creating such an impact on their mind that they are forced to leave India.
Netaji is that student in class who worked very hard for a test which was super hard but he answered the paper with all his efforts with no unfair means , However still failed. We all respect him for his efforts.
Moreover naval mutiny was done in favour of INA which eventually helped India in getting independence and INA won non stop for 4 5 months before logistics collapsed due to Japanese withdrawal and onset of monsoon, INA proved that mighty British can be challenged and defeated, battle of Kohima is considered deadliest war in world war 2 where British Indian army was fighting against Indian national army , all these achievements in few year proves he is one the greatest leader of all time
Well, Did he fail? PB Chakraborthy was at that time the Chief Justice of the Calcutta High Court and was also serving as the acting Governor of West Bengal. He wrote a letter to the publisher of RC Majumdar's book, A History of Bengal. In this letter, the Chief Justice wrote, "When I was acting Governor, Lord Attlee, who had given us independence by withdrawing British rule from India, spent two days in the Governor's palace at Calcutta during his tour of India. At that time I had a prolonged discussion with him regarding the real factors that had led the British to quit India." Chakraborthy adds, "My direct question to Attlee was that since Gandhi's Quit India movement had tapered off quite some time ago and in 1947 no such new compelling situation had arisen that would necessitate a hasty British departure, why did they had to leave?" "In his reply Attlee cited several reasons, the principal among them being the erosion of loyalty to the British crown among the Indian army and Navy personnel as a result of the military activities of Netaji," Justice Chakraborthy says. That's not all. Chakraborthy adds, "Toward the end of our discussion I asked Attlee what was the extent of Gandhi's influence upon the British decision to quit India. Hearing this question, Attlee's lips became twisted in a sarcastic smile as he slowly chewed out the word, m-i-n-i-m-a-l!
Even 99% of today's leaders do not come close to 10% of Netaji's Quality, honesty and values...his rank was fourth in ICS Exam(IAS equivalent)...could easily live a prosperous life...instead dedicated his everything for our independence...just imagine fighting against mighty USA as of today...that also militarily from the scratch...building an army, arrange money arms, planning etc all...just one person did that...Salute 🇮🇳🙏
"Only one outstanding personality of India took a different and violent path, and in a sense India owes more to him than to any other man" - The Last Years of British India, distinguished British historian Michael Edwardes. In reference to Subhas Chandra Bose.
Mandalay jail in Burma for Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose and Lokmanya Tilak for many years but five star jails for Gandhi and Nehru at aga khan palace and yerawada respectively.
![GEEK TIMË [OFFICIAL AUDIO]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ry-6RvkH880/mqdefault.jpg)
"We admire people who fail GLORIOUSLY!"
Words to live by.
He didn't failed, Indian Naval Mutiny Resistance with British Raj was because of soldiers of Netaji Bose (Azad Hind Fauj)
It was a reason why British gave up India
@@aryanyadav3690 He means that Netaji himself failed to liberate India. We are not talking about the aftermath of his death.
He cleared Indian Civil Services Exam (ICS) with just 6-7 months preparation, Rank-4.
He resigned from that topmost position & risked his career, faced taunts for his motherland.
In a way, it's wrong to say that Netaji failed. The naval mutiny, and violent protests against the british conducted by armed Indian soldiers/police who were getting laid off, along with the anger a huge part of the population had in general against the British after the trials against INA members. Even if Netaji's army failed, he was still able to get India free by making a huge part of the population revolt violently (in Clement Atlee's words as well). Even if he failed tactically, he won strategically
The names of INA regiments mush have sent a shiver down the spine of the British army. Gandhi. Nehru, Azad and Subash.
exactly naval mutiny was result of INA establishment.I dont think he failed.But ya when we say faild he failed in the front game for which we can thank to mr jinnah and mr gandhi.mr gandhi fighting the bohrs war in africa and teaching non violence in country.every time i see hi face on my currency note i feel like replacing it with netaji.
@@harshsaraswat7024 Right
@@harshsaraswat7024 and this was his actual goal to spark that revolution to wake up the sleeping Lion which is india.
Was about to comment that. Well said. ❤️
that line literally brought me down in tears... "we admire leaders who failed... leaders who failed gloriously...", what a line... true hence they are remembered forever whereas the immortalized father of the nation merely lies in the scraps of barter paper...
Indian never appreciate Netaji because Netaji was Bengali I truly believe that
@@Mahishasur NO!! you are wrong and probably a Pakistani or Bangladeshi or their Islamist supporter!!
@@rka-truthalwayswins5127 😂😂😂 you Hindi people never understand
@@Mahishasur I as a bengali can tell you that netaji nowadays is getting recognition he deserves.The young generation has started admiring netaji rather than admiring gandhi .
@@roll1swarnajeetaich9b42 yes but only little bit
His failure was tactical but He won strategically. He succeeded in igniting the fire in the hearts of the Indian Navy and the common man. Their combined revolt forced the British to leave Bharat.
I wish India would get a leader like him today....
Indeed . Man he was one of the topper of ICS exam 1921 , he kicked that job for his country . It need guts . Can you imagine any UPSC aspirant getting rank in top 10 in his very first attempt getting Ias in and then say he want to do something else . Netaji and Swami Vivekananda should be inspiration for every youth of India 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Yess
I want to say the same
Your last line is so emotional but wrong. This time we are living in will never creat leader like him.
@@___SSS___ Roman Saini, the founder of unacademy was an Ias officer who left the post to pursue entrepreneurship.
He is ICON of the country 🙏
He did not fail. We enjoy this freedom because of him 🙏
Some goals are so worthy, it's glorious even to fail ~ "captain Manoj Kumar Pandey"
❣️❣️
You brought tears in my eyes Sir.We did nothing for him and are still doing nothing.
since Netaji's topic is being discuss, lets take a moment and appreciate the contribution of Anuj Dhar for investigating the Netaji's ambiguous death
🙏
🙏
Deep in our heart we all know that Netaji was the catalyst for our freedom.
Netaji is our pride definitely. He gave everything for the Nation. I do have one more who dedicated his life for the Nation i.e. Veer Vinayak Damodar Savarkar.
Netaji was inspired by savakar book and his personality to fought for India.
He did something with an impact. Unlike Congress and gandhi who failed with their impotent non-violent struggle.
@@theWorldOfIss he was inspired by Lenin
Darpok Savarkar's army resisted Netaji's azad hind fauz from entering India.
@@anuragsarkar7671 for sometime but after that he realised when commies started backstabbing
I think his objective was to create a parallel army and government but on larger scale than militia ..because one of the main factors behind India's British occupation was British Indian army ... A good paying parallel army with indian head should have been good option for indian soldiers as well
We should never forget Netaji, he is the true inspiration of willpower and sacrifice 🙌
Jai hind ❤️
If we see the surface we get the idea that Netaji failed, but if you dive in deep you would realise he did not, he once said "An individual can die but his idea would live forever". What Netaji did was he instilled the idea to fight for own motherland, which played a big role in the Naval Mutiny and that mutiny forced British to leave India. Netaji's idea that Indian soldiers must only fight for India made many Indian soldiers reconsider their loyalty for the empire and the empire was ruling in India because of those soldiers. So, we need to sit down and introspect did Netaji really fail?
True
👍
Personally I disagree this headline pf the topic .
As an ordinary mortal , in one of my stitnts as the Head of a Factory ,on the joining date , I was introduced to the Factory staff by the president director that" I was a failed Head " .
I took it in literal lighter sense, not taking seriously .
Later when I took a firm stand during my tenure reforming old unproductive practices , I proved him wrong .
Imagine the great leader Subasji , his soul will not forgive us from heaven if we use the term he failed .
Literally it pains me too much to see the headlines .
Never again use this comments against the great Netaji Subasji. Please .
@@Behappy11231almost everybody is unanimous that he may have lost in the battlefields but ultimately won us our freedom.
Even Maharana Pratap failed. But he was the only Rajput to have common sense to understand Mughals were invaders, not real Indians
He didn't failed sir. The Battle of Haldighati was a stalemate and The Battle Of Dewair where Maharana Pratap crushed Mughal army so badly that akbar never dared to look at Mewar during his lifetime.
Hardly any mention of our great hero in our textbooks still so much respect and admiration for him that was the power of Netaji🔥
For those who think netaji failed, should know and read about the conversation between the British PM Attlee and Bengal governer after 2nd world war, where the Governer asked the PM that u r the most powerful right now on world stage, why r u leaving india now, becoz of gandhi? And the PM replied, "SUBHASH CHANDRA BOSE". Thats what difference Bose & INA made. Its not a loss. It is a win and its becoz of him.
Whoever still think the Indipendence is due to Ahinsa only & only should dig, read and understand the events in history apart from popular narrative and history school books. There is contribution of many many great people known & unknown in the independence of india. The narration of the conversation i stated above is said to be in in Britain, it can be true it can be false but one should think, The INA was containing 25 lakh soldiers at that time think what it could have done, today indian army is of approx 15 lakh soldiers. This is an example of the reason why some historical facts are still unknown to public coz of the Narrative building excercise. Remeber,
"To establish Peace, One must be Powerful first."
Very true.
Whoever asked the question definitely needs praise for his courage to ask this type of question
indeed
The escape from his house story, is a classic and very inspiring story
Netaji was a true leader in every sense.
The fact that he could have just settled down with his wife abroad and never come back, but that man came back just to be called names. That's why I admire him, he had a goal.
Exactly dude like he had a great lifestyle he cleared ics exam and even could settle with his wife in abroad but he stilll chose his country and its freedom over everything.
Subhash Chandra Bose inspired many young age freedom fighter and guide them honestly how to love our Nation. The grate sacrifices of Netaji gives us a spark in our heart to work like freedom fighters towords our Nation. I am a Bengali and Netaji took a special place in my heart from my childhood. 🇮🇳
Netaji is the pride of India 🔥🔥
I also admire deeply Hitler for his great help to Netaji. It is historically truth that Hitler had immense respect for Bose and he organised the supreme possible security in land, sea and air for protecting Bose during his legendary mythical 3 month submarine journey from Germany to Japan. Hitler ordered his generals that in case of any emergency, the decision of Bose will be absolute. Hitler treated him as the head of free India. Also Musolini requested Netaji to continue all his activities from Italy. Ready information is available on the great book "AMI SUBHASH BOLCHI" by Sailesh Dey. This book is a precious historical document of Indian freedom struggle.
Do you know why Hitler respected & helped Netaji? Do You? That's, one very interesting, as well as great story.
hitler didn't have any respect for Netaji. They were all busy with Aryan superiority and humiliated Netaji. Ofc Netaji had to suck it up because he didn't have ammunitions and other things and germans provided this to him
Hitler was nothing more than a psychopath
@@BhogarkkuGuruvadiyaan cuz his aim was also to defeat britain in India. enemy's enemy is friend.
I'm not saying that what Hitler did was right because it's a true fact that millions of Jews died because of him and all the hate that he receives is totally justified but I have a question, why don't Winston Churchill receives same type of hate which Hitler gets?
It's because of his policies which created a famine in Bengal and it killed more than 3 million people. Hilter hated Jews with a passion and Churchill also hated Indians with that same type of passion.
Anyone standing up for their land is no failure. Even if just to fill the que facing a firing squad, they die free with honor and fulfilment not failure. If you are willing to sacrifice this body for your people then there's no failure. It can insight the land to stand up. Great man love to learn more. Thanks for your historical sharing 💯🙏
Yes Netaji failed but His leadership, courage & valour still inspired millions... & in Beerbiceps podcast you had said that peace can only be acquired by strength , yeah its Netaji's mindset at that time....
Loved your beautiful words for Netaji. Just wish to add: Netaji spend two long years of his life in the notorious Mandalay jail in Burma. This was one of the two deadly jails of the British era, the other being Andaman's Cellular jail. Also, Netaji did not ultimately fail. His aim was India's political liberation. And his fight contributed indirectly in awakening the Indian sepoys and particularly the navy, leading to the exit of the Raj. We can say he failed in the sense that he was unable to prevent the establishment of a proxy govt. in India due to his absence at that crucial period. For the same reason, he also failed to prevent the partition.
Legit question and Authentic Answer clearing all doubts....
'He chose to fight for India's independence', this is good enough reason to admire him irrespective of whether he achieved the end goal or not.
The real father of nation- Netaji Subhashchandra Bose
Nah, no one can be father of Motherland, he's a proud son of mother India
@@sauryavikramsingh8189 yes he was.. But the title which was given to a British bootlicker should have been given to Netaji
@@sahilrana5219 no, If Maharana Pratap, Shivaji Maharaja Guru Govindh Singh ji were the son of Mother India, so is Mr Shubash Chandra Bose
@@sauryavikramsingh8189 when did I deny he wasn't??
@𑀪𑀸𑀭𑀢𑀯𑀭𑁆𑀱𑀻 sanatani agreed, I'd like to add Shambhaji Maharaj, Peshwa Bajirao and Rao Ajeet Singh to the list too though.
i respect the way you are educating and how determined phrases your vocabulary holds while answering such benighted questions and keeping a straight face
Thankyou so much Sir.
You have answered my all questions related to our Indian History.
And I'm totally agree with you.
#AskAbhijit I have a follow up question on this regarding Netaji's failing. What are your thoughts on the statement that was made by Clement Attlee saying that Netaji was responsible for India's independence? Is there any truth to this? From what I understood apparently Netaji and the INA with their actions had inspired the armed forces to resist the British which lead to the naval mutiny. Even though these attempts had failed it created a situation where the British could no longer trust their Indian soldiers. If this is true then Netaji was actually successful in a way.
INA trials and Royal Navy Mutiny proves Netaji was successful 🔥 ... Clement Atlee's statement proved Netaji was successful 🔥 .... You and me are living in an independent nation proves Netaji was successful 🔥
To all the people arguing if Gandhi should be the father of Nation or Subhash Chandra Bose, here are few insights for you, If Shivaji Maharaj, Guru Gobindh Singh ji, Maharana Pratap were sons of Nation so are Gandhi and Bose, although Bose would be the son mother India would be more proud of lol
no bro gandhi was puppet of britishers whenever britishers scolded gandhi he calmly listened to them and changed the route for freedom can you tell me wherever gandhiji used to go why he always carry girls with him instead of boys while netaji was highly educated he covered entire 2 years syllabus of civil sevices in 6 months and secured 4th position in that exam but rather living a lavish and luxurious life in uk he chose his people and country gandhi tried a lot to spread hate regarding netaji in everyones heart but he failed whereas nehru family removed entire history of netaji from every possible source and wrote their own history and sacrifice in our text books🙃
Gandhi was the son who betrayed the nation.
don't include mr gandhi with such greats
@@GrooveGalaxy33 yes, my bad
@@sauryavikramsingh8189 plzz don't apologize. If you read about Gandhi's pedophilia with his own cousins, you will feel ashamed
Netaji>>>>>Chacha ji and Bapu Ji combined.
Period.
Don't compair supreme with traitors
@@munnatripathi1972 faxx
@@munnatripathi1972Even Netaji had some very wrong/questionable beliefs. He was still thousand times better than Gandhi.
@@ReligioCritic Gandhi was a traitor a mtrfkr Netaji is supreme.
@Shruti R Chacha Nehru.
Salute to netaji. He will always be admired.
I think because of the control of India by Britishers and Gandhi . We lost our National Hero .
Jai Hind , Jai Bharat 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏 thank you Chawda ji for this knowledge....
Dear Sir , I respect you from the bottom of my heart , because you are just revealing the truth
Jai hind🇮🇳
Thanks Abhijit ji for such a brilliant explanation.
Thank you sir🙏
So true Netaji was THERE ! Truly admirable. Deep deep respect for him .
Ahijit ji what you told is absolutely right. If possible, please make a full length videos one on Netaji and another on Savarkar. Thank you sir.
It feels good to read the comment section. People are getting to know the truth and are able to identify the truth ON THEIR OWN. Our true forgotten legends are coming back and those so called heroes who did nothing but destroy this country are being thrown away too. Change is coming slowly but steadily.
He was, He is & He will.....always be our HERO, core of our hearts.
Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose lives within us, Jay hind
Wow I almost had tears in my eyes. Love Netaji. Jai Hind 🙏🏽
We must Change Indian Army to Indian National Army
Also as far as i can remember he cleared the civil service exam of the Empire but chose not to SERVE them.
Thank you for this video ❤
One who tries , he isn't a failure , he is a warrior soul that deeply spirituality rooted to our yogic tradition ! 💙
Sometimes trying impossible is enough to scare ur opponent, war can be fought in minds too.
True Words Sir ❤️❤️💯💯
3:40 what a line sir 🙏🙏🙏🙏
salute and love for Netaji bose, he will always stay in the heart of the indian people ❤️❤️
Yes!
I can assure from bottom of my heart that we both are true Indians from heart sir ❤️love you and my country. Jai hind🇮🇳
Sir for few days I have been watching , serial ahilyabai and I'm very fascinated to know about Malhar Rao(Subedar of indore) , who established its kingdom in Indore. Can you please tell some unknown facts about the king (Malhar Rao). And was he one of the most underrated kings in the Indian history??
Shrimanta Sardar Malharrao Holkar wasn't a king but one of the powerful Maratha sardar and a loyal adminstrator to the Throne of emperor of Bharat the Chhatrapati 🔥
Excellent analysis
Bose was a vast improvement on that clown Gandhi and his loin cloth. Where on this planet does a race take pride in cultural regression. I mean like....WTF!
Thank you
"An individual may die for an idea, but that idea will reincarnate itself in thousand other lives"
-Netaji' s statement proved to be true
He may have failed himself, but his idea ignited millions of Indians which ultimately lead to our freedom
5 star jail 😂😂
Very good trolling sir..!! Keep it up..
Svatantraveer Savarkar, Lokamanya Bal Gangadhar Tilak, we admire them also.
Once there was an owner of a beautiful house. There was a certain wall in his house that he realised served no purpose and wanted to bring down. He announced to the town folks that a certain wall needs to be pulled down but only using kicks. Who ever kicks the wall hard enough to make it fall, gets the reward. One by one, people started coming and kicking. The wall didn't budge. Sometimes it so happened that someone was really brave and strong, they shook the wall but still couldn't break it. Then came a man with an army. He with the support of his army, was able to shake the wall and weaken it to a great extent. But the guy too couldn't pull the wall down. Then came an old man and slightly kicked the wall and the wall fell. The owner of the house (not realising that the wall had already become weak after being kicked for so long by so many people so many times) thought that the old man was really strong and impacful and gave the reward to him.
People admired him cuz he knew chances of success wasn't in his favor but he never stopped despite what the outcome was he either gets freedom or die trying but never give up
Freedom is not given
It is Taken
Jai Hind
Let's tranding #Netaji in upcoming 15 August and show mirror to Gandhian socialist+ communist people 🔥🔥🔥🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳...
Abhijit chavda sir please 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏 kindly take initiative for this 🔥🔥... Jai Hind 🇮🇳
Netanji was not a politician but a real hero fighter....who had one target. But politicians failed him.
Hello Abhijit sir, I have 1 question for you: In my childhood my grandfather used to say "in the year 1942 Netaji after making Mayanmar Independent from British rule, he asked for help from 1 of the greatest personnel from Indian politics to arrange support of rest India to kick out British from India". Could you please check and confirm which history is correct?
who is that
Simple.... A society admires Warriors, not people who show one side of face after being salpped on another. Netaji was the true liberator of Bharat. The spark he created in British Indian army led to the Naval Mutiny of 1946, which led to the decision of British to exit India. 🇮🇳
Such an excellent answer given by abhijit chavda sir , its so true that leader should lead from front and as far as freedom is concerned, leader will risk his life first than his counterpart or their soldiers. Not like sitting beside britishers and let his people dying for practising satyagraha. Its like rat don’t want to run thinking one day cat will stop eating them.
In the words of Clement Attlee (PM of Great Britain then), the British left because of the impact of Netaji Bose. The impact of the non-violent movement was "minimal" on their decision to leave India.
Hey Sir
How to deal with intellectual left wing people who supress anyone who doesn't have that much level of knowledge........
Either Acquire knowledge to debate or ignore them thinking they are shit😅
Gaali bak aur nikal Jaa...particularly that C one.
My friends and everyone in my generation is busy preparing for a life to live in US and Europe. I watch Netaji's picture and think only when I change myself will I change everyone. He is my motivation to do something for my country. If I would have been alive during his time I would surrender myself and all my wealth to him and for India. I would follow him to hell and back. Such is his legacy, he was no way a failure.
who called netaji was failed??? He gives freedom in INDIA...
Very well justified
Satyemev Jayate
Jai Hind Jai Bharat 🙏
Sir.. Please make an episode on Swatantryaveer Savarkar. His story is also as same as Netaji...
There is Alluri SeethaRamaraju in the southern part of India who put up a great resistance in 1920. In my perception, they both put great efforts
very well said Sir, he failed because of that time politicians who deliberately planned to harm Netaji and postured him like a Villain ,and some how they succeeded also .....Netaji had the power to turn the tide since Indian masses followed him in large numbers. His speeches had the fuel in the fire effect. Netaji's approach was to vibrate of British Government and creating such an impact on their mind that they are forced to leave India.
Netaji is that student in class who worked very hard for a test which was super hard but he answered the paper with all his efforts with no unfair means , However still failed.
We all respect him for his efforts.
Greatest video ever ✨✨
He should be called as 'father of nation'.
We as a nation failed him .....but he still is the reason for our indipendent nation.
Even Dr. Ambedkar mentiond this in hie BBC interview.
From my childhood Abhijeet, don’t know why, had not read too much history too, probably was part of INA in my past birth 😀👍
Haha even i feel the same i am so much into history of India also Netaji...even now i feel that I wish i could be in INA and see Netaji as the leader.
I would like hear some part of history of veer Savarkar from you sir....
Moreover naval mutiny was done in favour of INA which eventually helped India in getting independence and INA won non stop for 4 5 months before logistics collapsed due to Japanese withdrawal and onset of monsoon, INA proved that mighty British can be challenged and defeated, battle of Kohima is considered deadliest war in world war 2 where British Indian army was fighting against Indian national army , all these achievements in few year proves he is one the greatest leader of all time
Sir can u explain why some leaders like NTR ji and Vajpayee ji are called leaders with no enemies. Please explain ?
He didn't failed Indian Naval War with British Raj is because of soldiers of Netaji Bose (Azad Hind)
It was a reason why British gave up & not Gandhi
Well, Did he fail?
PB Chakraborthy was at that time the Chief Justice of the Calcutta High Court and was also serving as the acting Governor of West Bengal. He wrote a letter to the publisher of RC Majumdar's book, A History of Bengal. In this letter, the Chief Justice wrote, "When I was acting Governor, Lord Attlee, who had given us independence by withdrawing British rule from India, spent two days in the Governor's palace at Calcutta during his tour of India. At that time I had a prolonged discussion with him regarding the real factors that had led the British to quit India."
Chakraborthy adds, "My direct question to Attlee was that since Gandhi's Quit India movement had tapered off quite some time ago and in 1947 no such new compelling situation had arisen that would necessitate a hasty British departure, why did they had to leave?"
"In his reply Attlee cited several reasons, the principal among them being the erosion of loyalty to the British crown among the Indian army and Navy personnel as a result of the military activities of Netaji," Justice Chakraborthy says.
That's not all. Chakraborthy adds, "Toward the end of our discussion I asked Attlee what was the extent of Gandhi's influence upon the British decision to quit India. Hearing this question, Attlee's lips became twisted in a sarcastic smile as he slowly chewed out the word, m-i-n-i-m-a-l!
Even 99% of today's leaders do not come close to 10% of Netaji's Quality, honesty and values...his rank was fourth in ICS Exam(IAS equivalent)...could easily live a prosperous life...instead dedicated his everything for our independence...just imagine fighting against mighty USA as of today...that also militarily from the scratch...building an army, arrange money arms, planning etc all...just one person did that...Salute 🇮🇳🙏
So true...sir
"Only one outstanding personality of India took a different and violent path, and in a sense India owes more to him than to any other man"
- The Last Years of British India, distinguished British historian Michael Edwardes. In reference to Subhas Chandra Bose.
Yes you are corect
Mandalay jail in Burma for Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose and Lokmanya Tilak for many years but five star jails for Gandhi and Nehru at aga khan palace and yerawada respectively.
He was is and always will be the pride of Bengal.
India
Failure is a failure, no bullshit. Blaming Gandhi, Jinnah, Nehru won't make Bose any better.
Failure is a failure.
not all failures are same netaji inspired a lot of people to fight against british in true form