What's even more heartbreaking in the context of the war is that there are STILL a lot more horrendous battles to come (the Battle of Arras took place TWO days after the events of 1917): Passchendaele, Cambrai, the German Spring Offensive etc., throwing into doubt all the characters we've encountered throughout.
That’s the point of the end of this scene. General MacKenzie makes the disappointing (albeit true) point that just because Schofield managed to relay orders to stop the attack, it doesn’t necessarily mean that he changed much in the long run. If anything, he just merely delayed the deaths of many of these men involved. The general had hoped that today would’ve been the beginning of the end, only to be met with word that nothing was going to end anytime soon. Both men are right, here. That’s the solemn beauty of it.
This scene was just so powerful. One soldier who wasn't going to let anything stop him by taking the order to the Colonel. He knew that he had a mission to prevent further bloodshed and stop what was essentially a slaughterhouse. He was bloody brilliant in the film. 1917 for me was actually really entertaining and the cast was amazing. Benedict yet again delivering brilliant voice acting. I imagine that all high ranking officers were completely oblivious to how suicidal the frontal attacks from commonwealth troops were becoming during the early years of The Great War. And yet, all it takes sometimes is the will of single man to do whatever was neccessary and to accomplish the mission! You can all have your opinions as always but I loved the film! Sam Mendes yet again delivering
Not-fun fact, modern plastic/reconstructive surgery was developed in direct response to a need. Some of these guys were getting non fatal but absolutely DEVASTATING facial injuries. Harold Gillies was the pioneering surgeon… he would go on to give *5000 men* their lives back.
I hate absolutely hate fake reactors those who make the channel then 1 watch stuff they’ve seen so they can get there cry ready etc or being over dramatic like bruh
@@hisakoichiki3126 Lame, overused rebuttal. You think he has the power to avoid them in a compilation like this? Use your head little fella They're cringe reactions, we don't watch their personal channels obviously. Clueless
@@flowy3422 Why does he "have problems"? He's not wrong, their ignorance is a bit annoying. That one Asian woman on the top row third person in, her especially "why can't he just tell them to stop"..... like lol, are you serious? She's not the brightest of bulbs. Does she not understand how rank works (or just the fact that ranks exist) in the military, or have even the smallest amount of common sense?
"why cant they just score the goal" "why cant he i dont know go faster in his car to win?" "tornado warnings? pfft its just some wind" different people have different things they know about, you would think so too if you didnt learn about military and ranks
@@mysteriousj3019 Shes doing too much, thats fake af. Theres no even tears coming out... i'm a girl, i got emotional but shes faking it too much, even her "heavy" breathing is being faked...
![[DRAGON BALL LEGENDS REVEALS ＆ STUFF] LEGENDS FESTIVAL 2024 Special Edition Part 1](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/mV5bGIswTtQ/mqdefault.jpg)
What's even more heartbreaking in the context of the war is that there are STILL a lot more horrendous battles to come (the Battle of Arras took place TWO days after the events of 1917): Passchendaele, Cambrai, the German Spring Offensive etc., throwing into doubt all the characters we've encountered throughout.
A terrible time to be alive
Arras... ah fuck a massive cock up past the 2nd day.
That’s the point of the end of this scene. General MacKenzie makes the disappointing (albeit true) point that just because Schofield managed to relay orders to stop the attack, it doesn’t necessarily mean that he changed much in the long run. If anything, he just merely delayed the deaths of many of these men involved.
The general had hoped that today would’ve been the beginning of the end, only to be met with word that nothing was going to end anytime soon.
Both men are right, here. That’s the solemn beauty of it.
@@thefunguy5069 news flash buddy war is still happening! 😅
@@twelved4983 colonel Mackenzie
Lmao that one girl who said "just tell them you cant go" yeah like theyre going to obey a corporal's command 😂😂😂
Bro some of these reactors man lol
"War's cancelled fellas"
even if they magically listened he could only tell a few dozen out of thousands lol
They'd be like : "And get court-marshalled? I'd rather the bullets " :D
i love these mega reactions, its like I'm in a theater with everyone around me
This scene was just so powerful. One soldier who wasn't going to let anything stop him by taking the order to the Colonel. He knew that he had a mission to prevent further bloodshed and stop what was essentially a slaughterhouse. He was bloody brilliant in the film. 1917 for me was actually really entertaining and the cast was amazing. Benedict yet again delivering brilliant voice acting. I imagine that all high ranking officers were completely oblivious to how suicidal the frontal attacks from commonwealth troops were becoming during the early years of The Great War. And yet, all it takes sometimes is the will of single man to do whatever was neccessary and to accomplish the mission! You can all have your opinions as always but I loved the film! Sam Mendes yet again delivering
3:17 "did he start this off? he went over and everyone else started going over" 🤣🤣🤣
Not-fun fact, modern plastic/reconstructive surgery was developed in direct response to a need. Some of these guys were getting non fatal but absolutely DEVASTATING facial injuries.
Harold Gillies was the pioneering surgeon… he would go on to give *5000 men* their lives back.
This is genius, i have waited this scene reaction since several times ago
So incredible.
I hate absolutely hate fake reactors those who make the channel then 1 watch stuff they’ve seen so they can get there cry ready etc or being over dramatic like bruh
then simply dont watch them and move on 😂
@@hisakoichiki3126 Lame, overused rebuttal. You think he has the power to avoid them in a compilation like this? Use your head little fella
They're cringe reactions, we don't watch their personal channels obviously. Clueless
@@hisakoichiki3126 I’m talking abt from this compilation buddy I don’t watch them but I seen this video and clicked it and they happen to be in it
These annoying girls saying that he should tell them to stop the attack when he's just a corporal...
you have problems
@@flowy3422 Why does he "have problems"? He's not wrong, their ignorance is a bit annoying. That one Asian woman on the top row third person in, her especially "why can't he just tell them to stop"..... like lol, are you serious? She's not the brightest of bulbs. Does she not understand how rank works (or just the fact that ranks exist) in the military, or have even the smallest amount of common sense?
@@flowy3422 Are you slow
"why cant they just score the goal"
"why cant he i dont know go faster in his car to win?"
"tornado warnings? pfft its just some wind"
different people have different things they know about, you would think so too if you didnt learn about military and ranks
@@TheSwordOfTheJedi-u2pshe's probably thinking he's holding the orders of the highest rank and anxiety over the scene has smudged the details.
please do more of 1917!
There should be a special prison for people who talk all the way through movies.
Mr beast games could be XD
In a theater? Sure. On a channel specifically for reacting to the movie? Probably not.
@@PhoenixPalmer88 You're talking over a movie now, arn't you.
@JamesPassmore-z7r what is your point? These people are supposed to talk about the movie, it's a reaction video
@@Unamed-xl4re If I have to explain it to you, you wouldn't understand. Go in peace.
It's always the same with these mashups. It's a game of guessing who's reacting genuinely, and who's clearly faking it. This video's an easy round.
First wave p lng Yun pero sobrang Dami na
remarkable
Still lost hundreds of thousands
omg please do the ending pleaseee omg
Can you do.the Sonic 3 trailer reaction mashup please?
すごい映画ですね～😮
Great generation
Great war cenimatic history world war 1
Why is that girl crying top right 2nd she is so dramatic
Oh, I don't know, maybe because it's a very emotionally charged scene that the entire film has been building up to, perhaps
whats wrong with having emotion? u're weird af lil bro😂
@@gthanavi1597it’s not having emotions it’s fake reactions. You’re dumb for falling for it
yeah i was watching the video and hearing she crying is like stfu
Have you even played RDR2????? Arthur’s gotta be one of the most heart breaking deaths in a game I ever experienced
Why is she crying
She really dislikes violence. She cries during most movies for different reasons.
I mean, he was already late. All those men were running to their death. It's really emotional if you think of it.
@@mysteriousj3019 Shes doing too much, thats fake af. Theres no even tears coming out... i'm a girl, i got emotional but shes faking it too much, even her "heavy" breathing is being faked...
More important question...
WHY WAS THOR CRYING?
woman womaning, let the woman woman.
Now imagine this but you're an 8 year old 🇵🇸🇺🇦
Noooooooooo
Men: *Objective commentary and then silence (watching the scene)
Women: bla bla bla, crying, bla bla bla, crying, bla bla bla, crying and bla bla bla.
The 1917 was boring, nothing like SPR.
You wanted an SPR rip-off? 1917 was incredible, seeing it in cinemas would change your mind. Also of course it's not like SPR wrong war
that reactor crying is overdramatic. She is acting way too hard, and it shows.
Yeah, you can ignore those who fake reacts. I can already tell who are you talking about