"Ibn Sina is annoying," Sean Carroll

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 4 фев 2025

Комментарии • 96

  • @adamgulamhusein8768
    @adamgulamhusein8768 5 месяцев назад +73

    People need to realize he’s saying this with begrudging appreciation and admiration. He’s not bad-mouthing Ibn Sina

    • @notmyname3556
      @notmyname3556 Месяц назад

      It's sarcasm, cause he's the real life Sheldon and Tony Stark combined who became a professor of a subject in a short amount of time.

  • @treenahally4358
    @treenahally4358 5 месяцев назад +18

    This is how humanity moves forward through mutual cooperation and peaceful coexistence.

  • @HereticforGod
    @HereticforGod 3 месяца назад +21

    Annoying how impressive he was is what he means

    • @khalil4978
      @khalil4978 Месяц назад

      obivously I don't get how people don't get it

  • @LifeGoesOnInIran
    @LifeGoesOnInIran Месяц назад +5

    He was mainly a philosopher. The physician stuff was a side gig

  • @SufiyanMullaji-uc3xv
    @SufiyanMullaji-uc3xv 5 месяцев назад +10

    Ibn Sina Muslim Persian did what Christians intellects Failed miserably to do
    Born: Afshona, Uzbekistan
    Died: 22 June 1037, Tomb of Abu Ali Sina, Hamedan, Iran
    Influenced by: al-Farabi, Aristotle, Al-Biruni, Abu Bakr al-Razi, Muhammad, Hippocrates, al-Kindi, Galen, More
    Parents: Setareh, Abdullah
    Spouse: Yasamin
    Era: Islamic Golden Age
    Ibn Sina was a devout Muslim and sought to reconcile rational philosophy with Islamic theology. He aimed to prove the existence of God and His creation of the world scientifically and through reason and logic.
    Abu Ali Al-Hussein Ibn Abdullah Ibn Sina, known in the West as Avicenna, was one of the most eminent Muslim physicians and philosophers of his days whose influence on Islamic and European medicine persisted for centuries. He was named by his students and followers as “Al Shaikh Al Ra'ees” or the master wise man.
    You won't see Muslim's naming Shakespeare as SheikhSpeare🥴

    • @gerardford9706
      @gerardford9706 5 месяцев назад

      Ibn Sina's achievements had nothing to do with Islam. He was originally a Zoroastrian. The same goes for almost all Iranian scholars and bright minds.
      Muslims and Arabs like to leech off of Persian culture and advancements by claiming that these bright minds became who they were because of Islam. Frankly the majority of Iranian scholars not only were atheist/agnostic, they didnt even approve of the Islamic rule.

    • @quintrankid8045
      @quintrankid8045 3 месяца назад

      Did he get the name Avicenna recently? Or was it in the medieval period when moving names across a dozen languages and a continent must've been like playing a game of telephone?
      Do you think ibn Sina succeeded in proving the existence of god with logic?

    • @SomebodyStoIeMyToast
      @SomebodyStoIeMyToast 18 дней назад

      ​@@quintrankid8045actually I haven't read anyone his books but when I'll do I'll tell ya

  • @ShayanGoidarzi
    @ShayanGoidarzi 4 месяца назад +8

    Aveccina❤❤🇮🇷🇮🇷🇹🇯🇹🇯

  • @zhenlim4422
    @zhenlim4422 Год назад +18

    Wajar, karena ilmu pengetahuan yang dulu adalah hal-hal mendasar, yang sederhana, cukup melihat hasil Eksperimental nya di alam secara langsung. Berbeda dengan sekarang, jadi Polymath itu sulit, karena ilmu pengetahuan sekarang sudah lebih kompleks, misal dulu kita bisa ngebuat rumusan Matematis sederhana tentang gerak, namun sekarang sudah mengenai rumusan Matematis tentang partikel yang sangat-sangat kecil yang mana hal ini juga membutuhkan akselerator partikel yang besar, apalagi mau jadi dokter? Agak sulit, tapi itu bukan tidak mungkin. Banyak juga Polymath yang produktif di era kontemporer ini. Contohnya ya Sean Carroll ini, dia seorang Filsuf dan juga sekaligus Fisikawan teoritis..btw filsuf bisa dikata sebagai Polymath esensial

  • @aesternew
    @aesternew 12 часов назад

    Are u serious
    he wasn't persian
    He was born in Bukhara: Uzbekistan 🇺🇿

  • @Nochelun
    @Nochelun 9 месяцев назад +10

    Wow didn't know about him

    • @zebakhawaja
      @zebakhawaja 5 месяцев назад +2

      He's the most popular person in Persian and Arabic nations

  • @bascogolfer5210
    @bascogolfer5210 7 месяцев назад +17

    Long live Ibin Sina!

    • @GalaticHunter
      @GalaticHunter 6 месяцев назад +3

      he died a lot ago

    • @faizan9.8
      @faizan9.8 5 месяцев назад

      He is still alive in the hearts of muslims​@@GalaticHunter

    • @GalaticHunter
      @GalaticHunter 5 месяцев назад

      @@faizan9.8 cant argue about that

  • @Dasyuhan
    @Dasyuhan Месяц назад +1

    How was he a persian when he was born in Northern iran, thousands of km away from persia province????

    • @SpiritMachine582
      @SpiritMachine582 Месяц назад

      because the whole region was called Persia and it was ruled by Persian kings and of course through his writings we know he saw himself as a Persian :)

    • @Dasyuhan
      @Dasyuhan Месяц назад

      @SpiritMachine582 it was called persian empire, not persia and it was in north from altai to sudan in the south, denube river in the west to punjab in the east. You call all this persia?
      By this logic every Egyptian, turk, greek, punjabi, arab, and nubian is persian

    • @SpiritMachine582
      @SpiritMachine582 Месяц назад

      @@Dasyuhan yes it was all Persia or how you call it the Persian empire but the people are not all Persians. you may find some small evidence of Persia in their genes (the Egyptians, Arabs, turks...) but the true Persians where always a very small group of people who became so famous and powerful just through innovation and technology.

    • @Dasyuhan
      @Dasyuhan Месяц назад

      @SpiritMachine582 exactly the point. People from THE PERSIA. the modern day province of fars in south iran, the place of the origin of the Achaemenids

  • @kook.vengeance
    @kook.vengeance 5 месяцев назад +3

    He was philosopher too

  • @fatima7284
    @fatima7284 5 месяцев назад +4

    Yes, that's how Islamic golden ages rules. When you can create a wonderful society, brilliant people can do their brilliant things.

  • @notmyname3556
    @notmyname3556 Месяц назад

    You wonder about Albert Einstein's IQ level. Now let's talk about Ibnu Sina's IQ level 🥲

  • @احمدمحمود-ر1م2خ
    @احمدمحمود-ر1م2خ Месяц назад

    Why do westrens say tha he is Persian... actually in Muslim history we call not him Persian...in fact he is Uzbekistan...he learnt in Bukhara and Samarkand schools and most of his books in arabic because that time it was like English now so i think Europeians misunderstood that ...they think the wolrd is two empires rome and parsia so if he is not romanian so he is Persian

    • @SpiritMachine582
      @SpiritMachine582 Месяц назад +1

      listen small Ahmad, the whole region was ruled by Persians at that time and still is or do you really think your Uzbekistan would exist for one day without IRAN??? also through his own writings we know that he saw himself as a Persian :)

    • @احمدمحمود-ر1م2خ
      @احمدمحمود-ر1م2خ Месяц назад

      @SpiritMachine582 i know you Iranians are liars

    • @SeyedArashAkbarkhanzadeh
      @SeyedArashAkbarkhanzadeh 29 дней назад

      He was Persian.

    • @احمدمحمود-ر1م2خ
      @احمدمحمود-ر1م2خ 29 дней назад

      @@SeyedArashAkbarkhanzadeh i am sorry he is not

    • @SeyedArashAkbarkhanzadeh
      @SeyedArashAkbarkhanzadeh 29 дней назад

      @@احمدمحمود-ر1م2خ literally search up Ibn Sina ethnicity on google. Persian will come up

  • @SpiritMachine582
    @SpiritMachine582 Месяц назад

    annoying are you and the people listening and clapping for your nonsense. there is a reason why this joke tries to destroy the legacy of a man who helped millions of people through his knowledge over centuries!!!!

  • @powerball200
    @powerball200 6 месяцев назад +1

    Cope harder, Sean 😂

    • @orionfreed6763
      @orionfreed6763 2 месяца назад

      He’s being facetious, he clearly admires Ibn Sina

  • @TheRepentanceProject
    @TheRepentanceProject 8 месяцев назад +10

    Bunch of childish individuals.

    • @jihooney-1448
      @jihooney-1448 8 месяцев назад +7

      Ibn Sina (Avicenna) literally shaped how we look at medicine, philosophy and poetry today. So much so, he’s known as the father of early modern medicine (not to mention the fact he saved the life of a Persian ruler as a teenager). I urge you to read more about him. It’s not crap just because you can’t understand it. Heck, you couldn’t have typed this baseless and fact less comment without algorithms (which was founded by another great mathematician)

    • @TheRepentanceProject
      @TheRepentanceProject 8 месяцев назад +5

      @@jihooney-1448 not talking about ibn sina, chill. I'm talking about the individuals in video.

    • @TheRepentanceProject
      @TheRepentanceProject 8 месяцев назад +1

      ​@jihooney-1448 I don't know where you assume I'm talking about ibn sina?

    • @jihooney-1448
      @jihooney-1448 7 месяцев назад +1

      @@TheRepentanceProjectIf not, then who were you talking about? I’m sorry for assuming but the way you worded it without giving any other information just led me to believe you were talking about him being a “childish individual”

    • @TheRepentanceProject
      @TheRepentanceProject 7 месяцев назад +1

      @jihooney-1448 I'm talking about the professors, I just think it's comical and amazing. You got two professors who studied their respective fields for probably a long time and haven't come close to what ibn sina has discovered.

  • @Mirtalha84
    @Mirtalha84 6 месяцев назад

    Cope 😂😂😂

  • @farhadfarhadian1111
    @farhadfarhadian1111 Месяц назад

    Ave Sina thé father of medicine 1000 AD when the ancestors of this guy in Europe were in total darkness and ignorance

  • @Tvgott
    @Tvgott 16 дней назад

    So jealous 😂😂😂😂 till today

  • @TimMalik-p2b
    @TimMalik-p2b 3 часа назад

    Ibn sina was from uzbekistan

  • @yasminkirmani9795
    @yasminkirmani9795 2 месяца назад

    So what ?You are annoying to me .