I think the ref overdid. It had no impact on the game whatsoever even if he had broken the rules, which he did. I don't believe his teammates blame him for that though that call was just necessary.
5 лет назад+47
@@mariuszj3826 Ref did their job. I'd imagine the player would intentionally miss the goal. This is far from fair play.
@@mariuszj3826 sometimes you have too feel for the ref. Remember the ref who gave a yellow card for a guy who took his shirt off for his Dad's remembrance. If the refs hadn't checked it they'd have been asked as to why they ignored it. The rule enforcers sometimes have it tough.
Why does the camera focus on the Asian looking player on 00:48 the fault was made by a different guy, I wanted to see the actual person who make the mistake not his teammate.
in the african champions leage i have seen once an algerian team playing at home against a morrocan one and the algerians kids working in the stadium threw balls into the field to make the ref stop the opposing team twice , one of them was a goal refused because they were 2 balls , the second was a 1v1 with goal keeper but the ref stopped it again . i think this happened 3 years ago in a semi final match or quarter final . and no they were not underraated teams , one of those 2 teams have a history against big european teams , it was the one that bayern defeated to win the world cup of teams .
I was amazed by this. But I looked it up in FIFA rules and they changed. If a substitute does this the the game is restarted with a free kick or penalty. It used to be a drop ball but that's been changed at some point. Amazing.
There was time when the guy executing penalty would kick the ball to side, just because that is right thing to do. I would be ashamed to celebrate this goal...:(
I'm sure you all would. If the penalty was a league winning goal or a relegation saving goal, you'd never play for that club again if you purposefully missed. What if you're playing lower division football and there is a huge goal bonus in your contract? It's easy to say what we think we would do, but if I got a 10k goal bonus in my contract I'm taking the shot.
M G That was a mistake but it still is a penalty and the decision to be a sportsman is on the other team to miss the penalty on purpose and let the game continue.That’s just my opinion.
@@albiidrizi9745 If that's a penalty, the game is finished as a spectator sport. Also, this decision is completely inconsistent with decisions in the same game, never mind other games this season.
12th man on the pitch, he interfered with the play. you also have to think theres stats and bets going on, that would have been a goal kick but the ball never actually crossed the line, so the goal kick cant be officially awarded
@@francoismaurice5773 Because some rules are ambiguous. Even though this was a clear infraction of the rule, the ref could have just been like don't do it again this is your last warning. He could have awarded an indirect freekick but he decided to award a penalty for a little known rule. I doubt the player had any malicious intent by just stopping the ball before it rolled out of play. The rule doesn't specifically say that he had to give a penalty but he did. He could have just given a yellow too.
@@francoismaurice5773 not every rule has to be strictly followed. The ball was definitely going out and that guy didn't do anything suspicious. A thing considered suspicious and that should have been penalized, was when Simeone threw a ball into the field when the opponent were on a counter attack and the ref didn't give anything. You think the offense in this video is worse than that offense?
@@francoismaurice5773 I understand your POV that the ref was just being professional. It doesn't make him a bad ref if he didn't enforce the rule in this specific situation, which would've been, in my opinion, a better solution
The rule had to be enforced. If not then it would make a mockery of the laws of the game. This week the guy stops a goal kick next week a corner etc. The player knew he shouldn’t touch the ball on the field of play. His mistake he take the consequences. I bet his manager ripped him in the changing room
But the call he made is in no way related to any rule. The rule says it should be an in-direct freekick from where the foul was committed. It was a wrong call from the referee(s)
Rules are rules for a reason. You can't criticise a referee for a correct implementation of a clear law, and you can't criticise a team for capitalising on a competitive advantage they have been given. There is nothing wrong with red-team (can't remember the club, my bad) scoring the penalty, and the referee made the correct decision according to the Laws of the Game. If this is something that angers you, then criticise IFAB or FIFA, not the referees whose job it is to implement their laws.
I get there are rules, but this is such bullshit. Why looking for this? But not look if a corner is right. This situation is so irrelevant to the game, but out of some wrong asinged corners they score.....
You know, the striker should not have celebrated that. He got a freebie out of a unnecessarily harsh call. Either score and don't celebrate 'cause it had nothing to do with what you did or do the fair-play and miss it.
2010 world cup quarter final Uruguay vs Ghana Suarez was literally the last man and standing on the line ......no one ever said a goal should have been awarded to Ghana .....people were okay with the penalty....remember???.............
Imagine being a fan sitting watching that having paid whatever you paid to get in. Oft. that guy will be lucky to be allowed to warm up again let alone play for the club he's just signed for lmao.
@@howardtreesong4860 There was no need for him to touch it though. His team were winning so there was no rush to get the ball back in play. He wasn't on the field so he has no reason to touch the ball.... Absolute brain fart moment. It's been a year since I posted that comment so I had to re-watch the video to know what I was even talking about here. Still stand by my comment.
Imagine if that rule didnt exist, u can line up all the bench players near the goal line and the ball will never go out and play resumes every time....
The twelfth man rule is in place to prevent unfair play. This had no effect on the game. Everyone stopped playing to prepare for the goal kick. Just as the would have done had he not touched it.
Personally I would have just played the ball out of bounds from the penalty. Right through the exact same spot where it was heading out from the first shot.
@@UnkreativerJunge yes i agree rules should be followed, but in this case the ball was definitely going out so the ref was unjust to give the penalty. very bad decision imo
1:09 - How can they spot and punish for that offence but do nothing about another attacking player being in the D when the penalty kick is struck. I believe the penalty kick should have been retaken.
I’m sorry right, but if VAR can see that the sub touched the ball before it went out of play, why on Earth were they too incompetent to see the keeper was off his line when the penalty was struck? Double standards?! That’s a retake!
My bad. I gotta say, in England I don’t think this var is adding much to the game. Making decisions like this one in a country who have been using it for a year longer than most, and should be able to implement it better than most ...its sanitising the game into boredom territory. Until it’s ready to be used as effectively as it is in rugby, get it off our pitches!
It's really stupid. I'd say. Rules are necessary but use your common sense! The ball was clearly going outside. What's the point of giving a penalty when he didn't intervene in getting a chance for the opponents.
I dont want to imagine the locker room for that poor guy
KevinUltimat3 the team that conceded the penalty won the match. So I don’t really think they cared that much.
I think the ref overdid. It had no impact on the game whatsoever even if he had broken the rules, which he did. I don't believe his teammates blame him for that though that call was just necessary.
@@mariuszj3826 Ref did their job. I'd imagine the player would intentionally miss the goal. This is far from fair play.
@@mariuszj3826 sometimes you have too feel for the ref.
Remember the ref who gave a yellow card for a guy who took his shirt off for his Dad's remembrance.
If the refs hadn't checked it they'd have been asked as to why they ignored it.
The rule enforcers sometimes have it tough.
True
If I introduce this kind of rule in my neighborhood ..... I would probably get killed you know
Cuz living in sweden is very dangerous
@@duque10k2 It is nowdays. They've made huge mistakes with immigrants.
Malmö?
It's the current Laws of the Game. So, it is in your neighbourhood
Don’t let that distract you from the fact that 2nd league has VAR technology in Germany
The best 2nd league of the World
@@J450N26 lmao that’s funny
As if it would cost so much for a few TVs.
they love technology in Germany, just look at their bobsleigh programme
And you guys have football pitch in arabia or elswhere?
Having just been signed, that was literally his first competitive touch of the ball for his new club.
He wasn’t even in the game and he got a yellow card.
If you talk about Asian guy, you must to know... he wasn't the guy who touched the ball. It was the guy with blonde hair, standing next to asian guy.
Poor guy got a yellow card even as a substitute.
Coach: Adminho, I want you to warm up!
*Starts warming up*
Adminho: Oh... the ball. I’ll just pass it back
Everyone: 😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫
@@bundesliga oh god the emojis
It's better than a red as a substitute.
@@bundesliga that very funny😆😂
Ref pointed at everyone on the line. So all of them got the card
Why does the camera focus on the Asian looking player on 00:48 the fault was made by a different guy, I wanted to see the actual person who make the mistake not his teammate.
Stupid cameraman👌
That's right lol
Because initially he was laughing sarcastically. But once the penalty go in, the laugh and smiles were gone
You're right, you're very sharp-eyed.
Probably, German cameraman who thinks only foreigner was capable of doing something stupid like this.
Has this been ever applied before in the history of the sport?
in the african champions leage i have seen once an algerian team playing at home against a morrocan one and the algerians kids working in the stadium threw balls into the field to make the ref stop the opposing team twice , one of them was a goal refused because they were 2 balls , the second was a 1v1 with goal keeper but the ref stopped it again . i think this happened 3 years ago in a semi final match or quarter final .
and no they were not underraated teams , one of those 2 teams have a history against big european teams , it was the one that bayern defeated to win the world cup of teams .
It's a new law
Last season in Polish 3rd or 4th league. You could probably find more situations in other lower leagues across the world.
www.theguardian.com/football/2014/apr/14/substitute-iran-football-match-runs-on-save the funniest version of 12th man
yes. ruclips.net/video/5xJojiHn62o/видео.html
I was amazed by this. But I looked it up in FIFA rules and they changed. If a substitute does this the the game is restarted with a free kick or penalty. It used to be a drop ball but that's been changed at some point. Amazing.
The woman on cbs who claimed that Gabriel simply made a mistake in the Bayern game should watch this.
Don't worry the team with the penalty lost the game 😊
Doesn't make what happened any different?
@@bigupliquidchilli8709 lol they won in the end so who cares
@@ultraomenmurat9937 So what happened is okay, because they won?
@@bigupliquidchilli8709 it is a stupid pen if they won off of that it would have been annoying
@@ultraomenmurat9937 goal difference and stuff man. Football is not always about just wins
If germany wouldn’t have this crazy thing that substitus have to warm up behind the goal, this would have never happened
There was time when the guy executing penalty would kick the ball to side, just because that is right thing to do. I would be ashamed to celebrate this goal...:(
This is the comment I was looking for. I can't imagine taking that penalty - I would've put it wide on purpose.
Agree
Yeah man, I thought he will kick it aside.
The substitute would probably have kept it in tho
I'm sure you all would. If the penalty was a league winning goal or a relegation saving goal, you'd never play for that club again if you purposefully missed. What if you're playing lower division football and there is a huge goal bonus in your contract? It's easy to say what we think we would do, but if I got a 10k goal bonus in my contract I'm taking the shot.
This is literally insane and inconsequential to the game.
No penalty. Bit of common sense please
100 percent theres no impact on game its flying out. I believe the rules say refcould award indirect free kick from the spot too
I say that’s a pen but at least miss it on porpuse and countinue with the game man he didn’t mean to do that, that was a genuine mistake
@@albiidrizi9745
what's the game coming to?
This is an absurd suggestion
M G That was a mistake but it still is a penalty and the decision to be a sportsman is on the other team to miss the penalty on purpose and let the game continue.That’s just my opinion.
@@albiidrizi9745
If that's a penalty, the game is finished as a spectator sport.
Also, this decision is completely inconsistent with decisions in the same game, never mind other games this season.
Shame on the team for taking that penalty seriously. Any team with an ounze of sportsmanship would've passed it to the goalkeeper
Forget the pen. Celebrating it is even worse.
I thought I'm all alone.
If he could just playing sportive, got the goalie back, he could be their hero.
They deserved the penalty because that idiot made an unsportmanship mistake
It's a correct decision
If i was the guy who take the penalty i will miss it
The funny thing is the Asian wasn’t the one that touch the ball tho
I'm honestly a bit confused. It had zero effect on the game so why
Because those are the rules
@@NOs3216 explain
12th man on the pitch, he interfered with the play. you also have to think theres stats and bets going on, that would have been a goal kick but the ball never actually crossed the line, so the goal kick cant be officially awarded
If you don't enforce that rule then you could just swarm the pitch and score everytime
@@ratedpending Common sense can be used as well. VAR is there to fix errors, not to gift stupid goals out of nowhere.
Classless guy taking the penalty and celebrating like that..........what a goon
Really feel bad for the substitute.
If I were the ref I wouldn't give it as a penalty because it didn't have any effect on the game whatsoever.
Exactly
@@francoismaurice5773 Because some rules are ambiguous. Even though this was a clear infraction of the rule, the ref could have just been like don't do it again this is your last warning. He could have awarded an indirect freekick but he decided to award a penalty for a little known rule. I doubt the player had any malicious intent by just stopping the ball before it rolled out of play. The rule doesn't specifically say that he had to give a penalty but he did. He could have just given a yellow too.
Regardless what happened he broke a rule inside the penalty area
@@francoismaurice5773 not every rule has to be strictly followed. The ball was definitely going out and that guy didn't do anything suspicious.
A thing considered suspicious and that should have been penalized, was when Simeone threw a ball into the field when the opponent were on a counter attack and the ref didn't give anything. You think the offense in this video is worse than that offense?
@@francoismaurice5773 I understand your POV that the ref was just being professional. It doesn't make him a bad ref if he didn't enforce the rule in this specific situation, which would've been, in my opinion, a better solution
*ONE OF THE MOST BIZARRE MOMENTS IN FOOTBALL HISTORY!!*
0:33 who is he?
I wish u guys would show more highlights from the bundesliga 2
The rule had to be enforced. If not then it would make a mockery of the laws of the game. This week the guy stops a goal kick next week a corner etc. The player knew he shouldn’t touch the ball on the field of play. His mistake he take the consequences. I bet his manager ripped him in the changing room
But the call he made is in no way related to any rule. The rule says it should be an in-direct freekick from where the foul was committed. It was a wrong call from the referee(s)
@@frederiksteffensen4083 No, because the faul happened in the penalty box. Therefore a penalty.
After ghost goal by Kiessling, there is another controversial thing happened in Bundesliga 😅
Why would you not just let it go?🤦♂️🤣
Yea but would you do that?
I know ur gonna say yea but just imagine being there in his shoes.
Like what would you actually do.
Not his fault.
Well he's trying to do his job the best he can. I mean he is a Bundesliga 2 referee bro, I'm sure he's got ambitions lol
Do you mean the player? Probably just reactions. As a long term football player, when the ball comes towards you, you touch it 🤷🏼♂️
Because he doesn’t know the laws of the game. Like all other players...
Thanks a lot mate..!
Everyone thinks that Asian player touched the ball but he didn't.
I would miss the penalty on porpuse that was a mistake
No it wasn't
I'm here for 0:47 and 1:02.. what a legend
The cameraman zoom on the wrong guy.
It should be Eberwein, not Korean Seo.
The cameraman racist, prejudice on Asian, or just clueless, I don't know.
it's racist bro, as an asian I know it.
@@Anuitu2u
"One of the most bizarre moments in Bundesliga 2 history"
Yes!
It's really that big of a deal!!
Apparently the opponents ignore what fair play is...
They should have missed on purpose
Emagine producing this law in your local tournament 😂
0:35 You can't really tell with this camera angle he touch the ball inside the line.
Shouldn't the coach tell his player to put the penalty wide on purpose? How is this fair play?
Because that idiot on the sideline should not be so stupid to touch a ball that was still in play?
Why are they showing the Asian guy face, when in actually it was Michael Eberwein?🤦🏼♂️
Pretty classless to take the penalty after that instead of missing on purpose.
Never warm up near the goalpost.
Makes sense to me. Well done ref and VAR team
You serious? This is one of the most pathetic uses of VAR I've ever seen. VAR is the shitstain of football
M'boussy could have done a fair play, he could have missed the penalty.
why would he do that?
Fair Play. As I wrote.
@@necromonger666 it woulda been against fair play if he woulda missed on purpose
@@prplt No it wouldn't. I know you think you're being clever, but you're not.
Yeah, I was expecting that.
This must be a lesson to anyone out there.
We’ve all learnt something! 😯
@@bundesliga If I could only "store" all those informations in my head or at least a large portion, it would be great but I tend to forget a lot.
Rules are rules for a reason. You can't criticise a referee for a correct implementation of a clear law, and you can't criticise a team for capitalising on a competitive advantage they have been given. There is nothing wrong with red-team (can't remember the club, my bad) scoring the penalty, and the referee made the correct decision according to the Laws of the Game. If this is something that angers you, then criticise IFAB or FIFA, not the referees whose job it is to implement their laws.
I get there are rules, but this is such bullshit. Why looking for this? But not look if a corner is right. This situation is so irrelevant to the game, but out of some wrong asinged corners they score.....
at least Kiel won in the end so not too traumatic for that player
Why is the camera showing the Asian guy like it was him who touched it?
If the other team had honor, it would have missed the penalty on purpose
This comment needs more upvotes
Imagine being that player if this a world cup final match, and lost 0-1 cause of this. How would u guys feel
Is it an actual rule that this is a penalty?
If anything an indirect free kick would've made way more sense imo
@@THO-BRO2000 I'm agreeing on that, I don't even want to imagine the look he got from his teammates in the lockerroom tbh.
@@THO-BRO2000 Ya but the rulebook says that it has to be a penalty
But because it was in the penalty box, it therefore is a penalty. Otherwise, indirect freekick...
There are no rules but there are laws. The referee applied the law correctly here.
You know, the striker should not have celebrated that. He got a freebie out of a unnecessarily harsh call. Either score and don't celebrate 'cause it had nothing to do with what you did or do the fair-play and miss it.
Even more: not only he didn't deserve, he only got the penalty because of his terrible shot before. So he got a prize because he sucked.
Crazy penalty
That’s why it’s the second division
That’s an indirect free kick at most tbh
Thats so dumb. Thats it of internet for me today 🙄
2010 world cup quarter final Uruguay vs Ghana Suarez was literally the last man and standing on the line ......no one ever said a goal should have been awarded to Ghana .....people were okay with the penalty....remember???.............
Soulobia Chipunza cause Suarez wasn’t a substitute...
Totaly different story... how do you even think of that
No, I don't remember.
Why i love rules in football
so why do they show this asian player twice? Looks like he did the mistake
Because the camera person is an absolute piece of twoddle
A crazier decision was not awarding a penalty to koln last night against mainz...
Fair play to ref
Talk about FairPlay...
I mean I love Bochum seeing how I’ve supported them for 11 long years but that was just unfair
Quem veio pelo Flow?
Eu
Eu só os br curiosos
Imagine being a fan sitting watching that having paid whatever you paid to get in. Oft. that guy will be lucky to be allowed to warm up again let alone play for the club he's just signed for lmao.
If there is no room for an honest mistake in a club how are they ever keeping people on the team?
@@howardtreesong4860 There was no need for him to touch it though. His team were winning so there was no rush to get the ball back in play. He wasn't on the field so he has no reason to touch the ball.... Absolute brain fart moment. It's been a year since I posted that comment so I had to re-watch the video to know what I was even talking about here. Still stand by my comment.
Pas totalement fake , cest un match Kiel - Bochum sauf que le joueur sanctionné c'est Michael Eberwein et mas celui quon voit sur la video
Tolissos nice curler is 💥💥💥💥💥
The camera man zoomed on the wrong guy. The Asian Player did not commit this foul. I don’t know if this is accidental or racist
The rules of the game that I know say it should be an indirect free-kick
VAR for the ball on the line but not the encroachment into the Penalty Arc by the red player at the left of the screen.
This is covered in the IFAB circulars.
0:58 If i was this guy i wouldn't DARE to celebrate that goal, because i would seemed like a complete braindamaged idiot ...
Such a situation will only be punished.
If the ball stop in the lane in opposite team mate what will be decided?
Decide team ball stop.
THIS IS THE FOOTBALL WE WANT ??????
Imagine if that rule didnt exist, u can line up all the bench players near the goal line and the ball will never go out and play resumes every time....
The twelfth man rule is in place to prevent unfair play. This had no effect on the game. Everyone stopped playing to prepare for the goal kick. Just as the would have done had he not touched it.
Some common sense is needed there. There's no way that ball was staying in
@@francoismaurice5773 because some don't make sense and just blindly following every rule is stupid
@@francoismaurice5773 don't think you quite crasp common sense. It's okay tho mate, when you get out of primary school you'll learn
Van Gogh wasn't known for his common sense
It did stay in because he kicked it before it crossed the line!
Personally I would have just played the ball out of bounds from the penalty. Right through the exact same spot where it was heading out from the first shot.
Never Bummer and then get bollocked by you’re team mates fans and coach
Why is that even a rule??? It didn't have any effect on the game
@K4 Josiah Ya the rules are interpreted very strictly in the Bundlesliga
12 man on the field... What... Dont u guys know, that this sport is 11 vs. 11 ??
Of course it did! It stopped the ball going out of play.
Even the camera guy was confused, he focused on the wrong guy 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 the asian substitute was not the guy..
No te puedo creer que el reglamento sea así
the attacker should of just missed on purpose that is so unfair to score a goal in this manner but they lost in the end so serves them right
How so? This rule exists for a reason. I've seen players stop a goal from happening while warming up.
@@UnkreativerJunge yes i agree rules should be followed, but in this case the ball was definitely going out so the ref was unjust to give the penalty. very bad decision imo
I'm confused. does eberwein an asian name?
cameraman focused on the wrong guy. Asian guy didn't interrupt the game. Cameraman made a mistake
I wonder which rule book they used to determine that call
The laws of the game of course which are standard everywhere.
1:09 - How can they spot and punish for that offence but do nothing about another attacking player being in the D when the penalty kick is struck. I believe the penalty kick should have been retaken.
I’m sorry right, but if VAR can see that the sub touched the ball before it went out of play, why on Earth were they too incompetent to see the keeper was off his line when the penalty was struck? Double standards?! That’s a retake!
If it's the keeper's foul and the ball goes in, there is never any retake.
Only retake if not score!
My bad. I gotta say, in England I don’t think this var is adding much to the game. Making decisions like this one in a country who have been using it for a year longer than most, and should be able to implement it better than most ...its sanitising the game into boredom territory.
Until it’s ready to be used as effectively as it is in rugby, get it off our pitches!
RACISM!! Camera men redirected the camera to the Asian player while he was not the culprit.
Lol I’m sure it was an accident
Well! What did i just watch?
Insane
Que Sacanagem cara, o cara deveria isolar o pênalti.
Sucks for the keeper bc he woulda had a clean sheet that match
lol the asian guy wasn't who touched the ball, the cameraman was so confused so he focused on the dumbest-looking substitute out there
Oh come on. Use your judgment ref. The ball was going out regardless. T.he intent of the rule was to prevent interference. This wasn't interference.
How much did the bookies pay the referie to do that?
O cara só acreditou que tinha feito merda depois que o adversário meteu o gol de pênalti, olha a cara do maluco rsss
Why is that a pen?
I don’t believe what I just saw.
I guess rules are different for Bayern München right?
Var in 3 liga next year then
no no
VAR in rock bottom Kreisliga (district league) next season
white mirror society no no no VAR in Sunday league!!
What the camera close up the Asian ?
Because they are to blame for everything!
The way this commentator says the "b" and "p" pisses me off for some reason
It's really stupid. I'd say. Rules are necessary but use your common sense! The ball was clearly going outside. What's the point of giving a penalty when he didn't intervene in getting a chance for the opponents.
Well that was a Strange one lol
What if the red team's substitute touched the ball from the same spot? Would the blue team get a penalty too?
No, they would have had a free kick of course.
Think the ball was out anyway. Or at least on the line. Even still everyone knew it was out. Poor lad got done dirty wrong place wrong time.
Ze rules are ze rules!
Ref is a jobsworth. Shame Bielsa wasnt their manager. He would have sorted it.