Looking back on this I think I did yes.Unfortunately my is very temperamental. But I’m working on being better videos with better results all the time. They were tasty tho… hope you try them both again
@@ChristopherShaun Yea no problem, making cookies probably took me 10 tries to get right lol! Every time a step was fudged and then I had major issues with my oven calibration. I learned a lot, but here's something I know shared by all bakers: So basically any cookie u make u need to pull out when just it browns around the edges and it looks like wet in the middle. Let them cool for 2 minutes then pull them off immediately, using your parchment paper, pull it so u get all the cookies on the paper onto your counter or cooling rack so it doesn't get hard or steamed.
Thank you for this review ! I love both of their recipes! But I am just very not sure about the cold butter, I broke one of my hand mixer trying to break the cold butter !
unfortunately I haven't tried levain cookies yet. I just wanted to see which one was best out of these two. I understand that might be a bit pointless if I wanna know which one tastes similar haha
Wow thanks so much! That’s awesome to hear. Also that’s a very bold statement. I mean he is awesome but I’ve not tried his recipe yet. Maybe that’s one for the future.
Jemma’s wasn’t it. The dough was way too dry and that is NOT Levain! I’ve never understood the complexity people encounter with recreating this dough because it is very simple. Levain tells people exactly what to do. I’ve tasted better cookies than Levain’s. I really enjoyed this video 😊
Im gonna hold my hands up, I did over bake them as my oven was pretty dodgy. But I’m glad you enjoyed the video still. I promise to do better next time
I've made cupcake jemmas recipe. If you make it right should be gooey in the middle not crumbly.
Yea I wondered this. I haven’t made them but have watched other reviews where they looked a lot more like that. Might be over baked
I wish he continued this series!
You over baked the cookies for cupcake Jemma mine came out crunchy outside and gooey inside every time.
Looking back on this I think I did yes.Unfortunately my is very temperamental. But I’m working on being better videos with better results all the time. They were tasty tho… hope you try them both again
@@ChristopherShaun Yea no problem, making cookies probably took me 10 tries to get right lol! Every time a step was fudged and then I had major issues with my oven calibration. I learned a lot, but here's something I know shared by all bakers: So basically any cookie u make u need to pull out when just it browns around the edges and it looks like wet in the middle. Let them cool for 2 minutes then pull them off immediately, using your parchment paper, pull it so u get all the cookies on the paper onto your counter or cooling rack so it doesn't get hard or steamed.
Ok he made jemma's wrong because it's 230g butter not 250g butter!!
Also he's using demerara sugar not soft brown sugar!!!
I really love this foodfight format - addictive!
U made cupcake jemma recipe wrong.. I have made many of her recipes .. exactly as is and they turn out wonderful
The only thing I got wrong was my oven. It sucks haha. So was in there bit too long. But I did say they were awesome. I couldn’t even decide a winner
can you do Delish's levain cookie vs Joshua Wiessman's levain cookie?
Beautiful cookies! I really like the presentation of the recipe ❤ Great work! With the comparison I like the idea, it was interesting!
Thanks so much.
That's NOT fair. You played it safe and didn't upset the two biggest RUclipsrs 😁😁
I don't know which one to like more, they are both great looking 👍
Me either!
Thank you for this review ! I love both of their recipes!
But I am just very not sure about the cold butter, I broke one of my hand mixer trying to break the cold butter !
Ahhh no that’s not good. Hand mixers maybe arnt quite strong enough. I’m sorry to hear that. Rest in peace hand mixer.
Can you please make a brioche with cinnamon butter from Levain bakery?
You forgot to mention which one is closer to levain bakery
Nicely done chef love the comparison between two great channels and the cookies look great. 👍
Thanks so much.
So which one the most similar with the original Levain?
unfortunately I haven't tried levain cookies yet. I just wanted to see which one was best out of these two. I understand that might be a bit pointless if I wanna know which one tastes similar haha
This is an awesome video! Thank you so much!!
Both were over baked and not like a Levain cookie. Need to redo and follow recipe more closely.
Agree
it looks like both of them were overbaked
amazing video!!!
Wow thanks so much! That’s awesome to hear. Also that’s a very bold statement. I mean he is awesome but I’ve not tried his recipe yet. Maybe that’s one for the future.
keep the dough in fridge for 3 days and it will give a night and day diffrence. and no need to use good vanilla(americas test kitchen)
What does that do? Does it "ripen" the dough? Or is it more about hydration?
Yeah but I had to follow the two recipes. That’s the point of the video haha.
More than likely it will develop a bit more flavour as it give the ingredients a good time to get to know each other and become a family
Great great great ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Thank you
Jemma’s wasn’t it. The dough was way too dry and that is NOT Levain!
I’ve never understood the complexity people encounter with recreating this dough because it is very simple. Levain tells people exactly what to do. I’ve tasted better cookies than Levain’s.
I really enjoyed this video 😊
Im gonna hold my hands up, I did over bake them as my oven was pretty dodgy. But I’m glad you enjoyed the video still. I promise to do better next time
My vote's for joshua's cookie🙋♀️
It is a difficult decision