真的非常感謝你們。我真的非常喜歡你們。我敢保證我能說你們是我從小從接觸U兔。不管是小時候看卡通還是看動漫國高中追星追劇聽歌。你們是我最喜歡的。我非常希望台灣的人民能認識你們。你們不像別人聽聽而已然後講講感覺。你們會去理解。理解歌詞。理解背後要給的含義。甚至是更深入去了解。真的非常感謝你們。我是異性戀者我非常希望同性戀可以早日獲得人權。早日成為歷史正確的一方。thank you so much and I love you so much ❤
I cried when I watched the video. I really cannot understand why some people just cannot accept the fact that there are people who are different from them, who have different interests from theirs, who act differently from how they act; then they bully these people. I like your reflections and discussions in the later part. That reminds us how we should treat others and teach our children at home and in school.
First I want to say I was so touched everytime I saw this viedo. It's so thankful to you, for doing this background story reaction related to Jolin's Tsai song. People usually hear songs and then just pass through, but you are the rare one who's not only listen but eager to dig out what's story behind the song which was really sweet. Again thanks for you to do this viedo, this really lead some effection when the song launched; and Jolin is definitely one of the best singer ever in Taiwan. Thank you. (A fan in Taiwan)
You both are most wonderful and beautiful girls, indeed. To me, you are also delivering positive and supportive messages and encouragements, as Jolin does, to the world in a different way.
I was wondering when the reaction for "womxnly" is going up and it is definitely worth the wait! Than you guys for reacting to this documentary first!! It means a lot!!
I am very grateful to myself for supporting me! I thought how helpless I was, and often I was beaten and forced to take off my pants..... It feel sucks... Everything has been the past! To all 🌹bullied you are not alone.. I be with you! Ps:Jolin also doing her part! Full of positive attitude so proud of her! So thankful my youth has Join Tsai!
I am so surprised that you reacted to this video. Thanks for your reaction. It made me cry again. Especially when you talk about your own kids. I haven't been a mother yet. While to be a teacher,I won't forget what you said.
Thank you so much for still following my message. There is an event on the Internet, the topic is 1000 foreigners watch "Jolin Tsai's MV" in 2015, 2 ladies are the most noticed foreigners, because you always make people feel the most sincere angel existence joy. In fact, 2 ladies and Jolin Tsai are essentially the same, because your pure angelic heart surpasses other foreigners, so your 2 ladies have gained a lot of fans in Taiwan. Jolin Tsai and your efforts and justice finally made Taiwan's ruling government back down and finally passed the same-sex marriage law in 2019. Your justice and fearless spirit made Taiwan the first country in Asia to legislate same-sex marriage. Thank you so much for your selfless love. Finally, I would like to thank you for enduring my poor English. God bless you 2 angels.
So u can understand how conservative we r in Asia now, and jolin has courage to change it little by little, she film and share this documentary in PLAY concent, after this, she sing "we r all different yet the same" to remind us to learn sth from the past, never let it happen again
This is my first time saw “葉詠誌”documentary , I can not stop crying That’s sooooo touching my heart, Education is the most important Stoping bully and make suck things happen again! Thanks for your guys make the video and That’s sharing love in the world .
I am totally agreed to you girls!! I will just burst to tears everytime I watched this documentary, its not the fault of the childrens as I do agreed that nobody is borned to hate or bullied each other, parents, teachers and every adults they get in touch with totally holding a very big responsibility on educating the correct message and be a good role model to the childrens.
Can't help tearing when seeing this MV. I love Mom Yeh's speech on KH Pride Parade, so encouraging, so fearless. And thank you make this video to help other countries' viewer to understand Taiwan LGBTQ situation.
when i first time saw this video i was crying. After that, I'd reviewed this many times because this video is so meaningful and touching for me. Today see your reaction, I cried again.
thank you for reviewing this non-music documentary. I was first watching this video clip right in Jolin's concert. Of course, I teared up. After watching your reaction, I am truly appreciative that more people get to see his story. Thank you so much. Thank you.
I cried when I first time saw this video on Jolin‘s concert. Now I cry again with you. This kind of story maybe happens everywhere in this world. Hope one day, no one has to gone through this anymore.
everything u guys said are really heart touching, I had been bullied since primary school just because I have short hair and not willing to wear skirts. and the teacher is the one who started it, my pants always got cut without my knowing. people can be really mean to other....
Another great post video commentary. It is sad sometimes teachers become jaded about the well being of the kids they should be responsible of. It's even worse when some of them choose to turn a blind eye just because the kid doesn't fit their world view. Most teachers are still amazing though. It's just some who are vindictive and indifferent towards real suffering when they totally could do something about it.
im so late, but i remember seeing this back when i saw her concert here in hong kong. im so glad that the lgbt community are more accepted now in taiwan.
玫瑰少年歌詞裡最動人與著名的一句話
你並沒有罪，有罪的是這世界
簡單一句話打動了多少人的心
很開心見到你們的反應
氣憤、傷心…學校並沒有同情葉媽媽，而是為了維護自己的表面而要葉媽媽隱瞞
只為了往後的一點髒錢
不公社會下的犧牲品，我們永遠弔念
每次只要聽到葉媽媽說 你們不要哭 你們沒有錯 我就哭到不行Q~Q 到底為什麼要這樣對待我們?
RyanFly 抱你一個～～～不要哭，我們都在
@@chenairda8529 謝謝妳~~~~ 大家一起加油Q~Q
RyanFly 不過看葉媽媽影片可以盡情哭沒關係（反正我也會哭）
秒哭爆哭的
我雖是直男，但我感同身受，我誓死撐同志權益！
沒想到你們會做這片反應！開心你們又讓我再哭一次了
我覺得好啊、先了解故事之後再做womxnly的reaction,up主很用心、給推
@@kydchanoo 舞蹈版比較無法呈現歌詞傳達的意境、超期待正式版mv的
他們已經知道玫瑰少年是在說這一段故事了 有些國外朋友們還不知道 希望能傳達出去 蔡女王 謝謝你
主要是有 英文高手 幫外國朋友翻譯 他們看得懂 就知道 很多影片 很有意義
希望也有大大可以翻中字讓台灣人民看看這個優秀優質的影片。認識她們。
好險這部影片 蔡依林發布的官方有特別加英文字幕 讓更多人了解
真的
美的句點
@@stay3507l
我在公投前，有把這影片給我媽媽看
看一次哭一次的影片
妳們超暖心的😭😭
玫瑰少年這首歌就是紀念 葉永鋕
這段視頻已看過N遍 每次看每次心有戚戚焉 若案情不單純 只能對殘忍下手的人說：不是不報 是時機未到
有一說是葉永鋕是自己跌倒，並非被人直接加害，但追根究底來看，如果不是因為被霸凌，他也不需要在上課時間去廁所，也就不會受傷沒人發現，因此那些霸凌他的人終究還是害死葉永鋕了😢
與別的RUclipsr 不一樣，認真了解歌曲中的故事，真的很用心！
霸凌一直存在…關注不會讓霸凌消失，但至少減少傷害
曾經有個朋友說，他反同婚，是為了不讓他們受到傷害，所以他要去投票反對，是因為他覺得他們那些人將會傷害到自己。這個說法真是令我感到不可思議，只能跟他說，你有資格替別人的人生做決定嗎?你有資格剝奪別人的選擇權嗎?你預估的事情未必會發生，但是這個當下，你才是實質正在做出傷害的行為，後來他說，他也不知道要怎麼面對這種事，然後他說他投贊成了，雖然他應該現在還是不知道同志是發生什麼事。
I started crying when I heard his mom's voice and his pictures. He is such a sweet and thoughtful boy😭
謝謝你們 這種事不只會發生在台灣
要是我們能在更認識自己和別人的不同之處
去包容而不是歧視
悲劇就會減少...
真的非常感謝你們。我真的非常喜歡你們。我敢保證我能說你們是我從小從接觸U兔。不管是小時候看卡通還是看動漫國高中追星追劇聽歌。你們是我最喜歡的。我非常希望台灣的人民能認識你們。你們不像別人聽聽而已然後講講感覺。你們會去理解。理解歌詞。理解背後要給的含義。甚至是更深入去了解。真的非常感謝你們。我是異性戀者我非常希望同性戀可以早日獲得人權。早日成為歷史正確的一方。thank you so much and I love you so much ❤
谁吧这个视频翻译成中文然后转发出去让更多人看到永志的故事，他不应该白白被牺牲，他的故事应该唤起更多人的觉悟，纪念永志
beecher brit 巡演串场片应该是自带字幕的
是的！影片內 自帶中文及英文字幕。
這部影片是Jolin 在她的前一張專輯[Play]內收錄的，Jolin特地為其拍的紀錄片。然後，這一次的專輯，更是收入了 玫瑰少年 呢！
原版玫瑰少年記錄片是有中英文版。
無法想像多少的孩子們在這樣的陰影下長大，生病的是這些觀念偏差的大人，還帶頭霸凌....
眼淚一直不停的流😭😭
葉媽媽真的很偉大
点赞起来，让永志的故事让更多人知道，永志的故事不能被遗忘
I cried when I watched the video. I really cannot understand why some people just cannot accept the fact that there are people who are different from them, who have different interests from theirs, who act differently from how they act; then they bully these people.
I like your reflections and discussions in the later part. That reminds us how we should treat others and teach our children at home and in school.
看你們哭我自己又哭一次
謝謝你們兩位美女
這是一個值得社會重視以及警惕的悲傷故事~希望這個世界再也不會出現~必須用生命和血來換得的教訓~
超感動的!!感謝jolin讓更多人知道!!多元族群!!一邊看，眼淚一直流!!嗚
每次都看都會哭！
真的，之後就不太敢再看了，太心碎😢
看了心裡很酸很難過！當葉媽媽喊孩子們，我真的眼淚一直流
说的就是我自己 我和他有着一摸一样的童年经历 深有感触😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
加油
加油
我們絕對不能懦弱，加油
我曾被歧视 被起外号 被脱裤子
坚持下去，撑过去后，你回头看会发现自己很了不起，更爱你自己
真的好感動
First I want to say I was so touched everytime I saw this viedo.
It's so thankful to you, for doing this background story reaction related to Jolin's Tsai song.
People usually hear songs and then just pass through, but you are the rare one who's not only listen but eager to dig out what's story behind the song which was really sweet.
Again thanks for you to do this viedo, this really lead some effection when the song launched; and Jolin is definitely one of the best singer ever in Taiwan. Thank you. (A fan in Taiwan)
You both are most wonderful and beautiful girls, indeed. To me, you are also delivering positive and supportive messages and encouragements, as Jolin does, to the world in a different way.
妳們的反應讓我感動到鼻酸
很開心能看到你們的影片
希望這些影響力強大的藝人能將這樣的性別教育影片,流傳好幾百年 ! 臺灣加油
每次看每次哭，台灣婚姻平權加油
I was wondering when the reaction for "womxnly" is going up and it is definitely worth the wait! Than you guys for reacting to this documentary first!! It means a lot!!
Jonny Tang my囧尼 啾咪
Karonen Wong 💗
很棒的影片，內容讓人流淚很有共鳴
Thank you, crying with us...
couldn’t stop my tears
You're so sweet and considerate, love you❤
I cried everytime when I see this video 😭😭😭
Thanks for your reaction！
I am the same age with 葉永鋕!
It happened everyday just like this in my generation ...
張嘉顯 把名字打對會顯得你更尊重
I am very grateful to myself for supporting me! I thought how helpless I was, and often I was beaten and forced to take off my pants..... It feel sucks... Everything has been the past! To all 🌹bullied you are not alone.. I be with you! Ps:Jolin also doing her part! Full of positive attitude so proud of her! So thankful my youth has Join Tsai!
每次看影片都一定哭！
I am so surprised that you reacted to this video. Thanks for your reaction. It made me cry again. Especially when you talk about your own kids. I haven't been a mother yet. While to be a teacher,I won't forget what you said.
Because of your reaction video, I watch this documentary again. And burst into tears with you two.
It proves that “be yourselves and be kind to one another” is a shared value.
聽到金曲獎作曲人剃刀講說這首歌獻給所有自由的靈魂
Thank you for your angelic kindness.
Thank you so much for still following my message. There is an event on the Internet, the topic is 1000 foreigners watch "Jolin Tsai's MV" in 2015, 2 ladies are the most noticed foreigners, because you always make people feel the most sincere angel existence joy. In fact, 2 ladies and Jolin Tsai are essentially the same, because your pure angelic heart surpasses other foreigners, so your 2 ladies have gained a lot of fans in Taiwan. Jolin Tsai and your efforts and justice finally made Taiwan's ruling government back down and finally passed the same-sex marriage law in 2019. Your justice and fearless spirit made Taiwan the first country in Asia to legislate same-sex marriage. Thank you so much for your selfless love. Finally, I would like to thank you for enduring my poor English. God bless you 2 angels.
We need more voices like you said in our society !!!
So u can understand how conservative we r in Asia now, and jolin has courage to change it little by little, she film and share this documentary in PLAY concent, after this, she sing "we r all different yet the same" to remind us to learn sth from the past, never let it happen again
This world will be better if more and more people as warm as you ❤️
So glad you guys watched this vid! This documentary really touched me as well...
This is my first time saw
“葉詠誌”documentary ,
I can not stop crying
That’s sooooo touching my heart,
Education is the most important
Stoping bully and make suck things happen again!
Thanks for your guys make the video and That’s sharing love in the world .
I am totally agreed to you girls!! I will just burst to tears everytime I watched this documentary, its not the fault of the childrens as I do agreed that nobody is borned to hate or bullied each other, parents, teachers and every adults they get in touch with totally holding a very big responsibility on educating the correct message and be a good role model to the childrens.
超级感动！人人平等，人人都有幸福的权利
Can't help tearing when seeing this MV. I love Mom Yeh's speech on KH Pride Parade, so encouraging, so fearless. And thank you make this video to help other countries' viewer to understand Taiwan LGBTQ situation.
Love you two. Thanks for your videos, I really like them 💕
謝謝你們在聽了玫瑰少年之後願意再花時間來看這段紀錄片。我們的努力在今年有了成果，台灣花了19年的時間，終於在2019/5/17這一天宣佈同性伴侶可以登記結婚了喔：）
You are so brave enough to see the documentary......
看了這個影片真的會讓人想哭
但是哪怕立法已通過同婚
對於那些恐同者們來說，他們像化石一樣的腦袋也永遠不會改變
我有一位女同事就是恐同者，她不斷的批評同婚
還說現在孩子已經很少了，大家都不想生了，政府居然還同意同婚
每次聽到她講那些屁話，我都很想飆髒話
禁止同婚就能挽救出生率嗎？這是哪門子的屁話？？
難不成為了挽救出生率，就必須犧牲那些同志的權益嗎
經濟不景氣才是最根本的原因
因為養不起孩子，所以大家才不想生
想挽救出生率，要從挽救經濟做起，經濟好了，大家才會想生孩子
我家人跟你同事想法是一樣，我也聽他們這樣說也很生氣，想說你們卻忘了姪女是雙性戀者也是在侮辱自己家人，誰說同性戀不能生小孩，現在醫學發達能人工受孕，或是可領養方式，曾看過一部真實紀錄影片，是女女戀，兩位女生都人工受孕一起懷孕呢，沒有什麼不一樣，雖我不是同性戀者，也滿支持同性結婚。
@@Hana-ip7qm 兩個男生要怎么生小孩呢
@@katrinalui3390 你問這個問題沒有意義啊，就算禁止同婚，同性戀者們也不會結婚生小孩，我一直很困惑，同婚到底跟出生率有什麼關係
@@foxphc 就是有人覺得沒有同婚大多數人都會乖乖結婚生孩子，有了同婚很多人就會跟同性在一起不結婚生子。
他們有的人認為同性戀是病可醫，或是可以扭轉，或是限制雙性戀的人去同婚從而保持出生率....?
雖然不排除雙的可能性，但是硬要拆散情侶，硬是要同性戀跟女性結婚，可能是真的不知道同妻的悲劇吧?想也知道會造成各種各樣的悲劇，以前資訊不流通，又有各種社會傳統壓力，將那些悲劇隱藏甚至說成喜劇，不知道不代表沒有悲劇! 看了一些悲劇故事，比起壓迫他人還不如順其自然，不然人口的負增長說不定會加劇。
Katrina Lui 艾爾頓強跟他老公幾個孩子要不要看看啊
I cry again after watch your video.😥😥😥
My love and thank go to Angelina and her friends. This channel is so great, delivering both educational and recreational messages. ❤️❤️❤️
感激
我又在哭了一次了
when i first time saw this video i was crying. After that, I'd reviewed this many times because this video is so meaningful and touching for me. Today see your reaction, I cried again.
thank you girls, so emotional vid, thank you...
你們讓我也跟著哭了！加油
thank you for reviewing this non-music documentary. I was first watching this video clip right in Jolin's concert. Of course, I teared up. After watching your reaction, I am truly appreciative that more people get to see his story. Thank you so much. Thank you.
Love you guys! Great reaction
I cried when I first time saw this video on Jolin‘s concert. Now I cry again with you. This kind of story maybe happens everywhere in this world. Hope one day, no one has to gone through this anymore.
Thank you ❤️
Thank you for reacting this document , Can’t hold my tears when I see it every single time
這影片太讚了
太有心了 看了这纪录片片再看mv 真的太有心了
OMG....You let me cry.....again >
everything u guys said are really heart touching, I had been bullied since primary school just because I have short hair and not willing to wear skirts. and the teacher is the one who started it, my pants always got cut without my knowing. people can be really mean to other....
This power has been won by our comrades. After May 24, Taiwan is the only country where Asian comrades can marry. I am proud of being a Taiwanese.
這紀錄片一開始講話我就哭了😭
雖然沒有中文翻譯，可是前面還是讓我紅了眼睛，台灣以前就是這樣，能掩蓋事實就想掩蓋
鬼娃恰吉 我只能聽得懂播放葉媽媽專訪的對話內容，都能聽出她們的憤怒、傷心、感動、不捨～～～～
其實不只台灣，全世界很多地方都是這樣，瘋狂想掩蓋事實與真相
比如我們都知道的韓國《熔爐》
最近還看到一部丹麥的電影
（應該是19、20世紀初的事件）則是在描寫一個專收男孩的育幼院的校長、老師都會體罰、性侵、虐待、虐打.......（真人真事改編的電影，因為小孩子們都是孤兒，也沒人要，更不敢求救.....）
現在有人做了中文的CC字幕惹喔~
蔡依林，让这个世界更平权。她有贡献！
thanks for sharing this reaction, i didn't know about this video clip...thanks +1000
Thank you ! Love u too
看一次哭一次 本來在學校負責保護孩子們的老師卻變成了加害者的幫兇
QQ
我國小時同學A+B會偷吃C的中餐，我每次都會幫C出頭
結果是我出頭一次就被罰站+罰寫+寫聯絡簿說我在學校找碴惹麻煩不服管教
老師只覺得只要C不會回家和家長反應+把我這個雞婆鬼罰到安靜就天下太平了
校園老一輩老師們真的非常保守，我們在教育大學讀書時其實看教授就知道了，但現在我們這群中新生代非常關注這個，我們上課其實也都會跟孩子談到這故事，但部分家長和老一輩資深老師和長官校長真的.................
當時公投前，我們都有在學校跟其他老師們拉票，但不得不說那段時間真的很常被處室長官約談XD
不過看到不少中新生代夥伴老師們沒放棄，就覺得還有希望！那些資深的會退休，年輕輩的會蓋過，希望更多老師們可以真正成為孩子們的保護者而不會再有這種事情發生QQ
@@rjrszfeapdn 會有某部分的教師會採取息事寧人的作法..企圖自以為是的縮小事件的擴大或者只看表面去審視事情而不去了解事情背後的真相
台灣是個很虛偽的國家
唉，我今年還在哭.看一次哭一次.
LOVE U~~~~~~~~~
Thank you for reacting to this video. This means a lot to me and maybe a lot of people in Taiwan. Thanks again.
Than you for sharing!! Should of never happened!! Unacceptable!! The song Roseboy was sung by Zhou Shen and Gai against bullying. Their story!
I just want to say thank you!
Thank😂
Another great post video commentary. It is sad sometimes teachers become jaded about the well being of the kids they should be responsible of. It's even worse when some of them choose to turn a blind eye just because the kid doesn't fit their world view. Most teachers are still amazing though. It's just some who are vindictive and indifferent towards real suffering when they totally could do something about it.
真心歡迎來臺灣觀光。
So appreciated you guys watched this documentary. Ur reactions were so real and emotional. Love you 😘
哭到不行😭
im so late, but i remember seeing this back when i saw her concert here in hong kong. im so glad that the lgbt community are more accepted now in taiwan.
只要聽到葉媽媽說：孩子們時我的眼淚一直止不住.......
Great reaction as always.(in tears)
You guys opinion are so true nobody hate somebody when they are born
Thank you for sharing this video to the world!
這個事件承辦的法官及檢查官一輩子要為了這個事情自責不已的過活!若你們真的還有良善的一面就該接下來承辦這樣的案件都要客觀正面的去協助被霸凌的那一方不管是不是LGBT!
謝謝你們 !
nice person with nice video♡
please share this video. Many people/children are still going through this. We need to stand up for them.
真的是每看一次哭一次……😢😢😢
很棒
拜託🙏需要中文翻譯
你可以搜尋葉永誌紀錄片啊
@@魚-g5q 他應該是指這個頻道的CC字幕，她們兩個是講英文的，對於一些中文使用者可能有理解上的困難
@@moowoo-z6h 哦原來他是想知道他們兩個講什麼
影片前：大概就是介紹有人傳了連結給他們 所以他們會來瞧瞧這部影片是什麼
影片中：就是「看醫生？真是沒品的老師！」「老師在幹嘛啊？(永鋕被霸凌的時候)」「學校從來就沒認真看待這件事過」「心臟病並不會造成鼻子跟嘴巴流血好嗎！」
影片結束大概是
1. 我不明白為什麼有人會對別人做出這麼殘忍的事情
2. 我把小孩送到學校之後，老師就有責任要照顧好小孩，不是當這些事情發生的時候袖手旁觀
3. 每個孩子都是白紙，小孩不是天生就這麼壞，是從家長和身邊的人那裡學來的，而且很多會霸凌人的小孩可能是因為他們在家裡也受到不好的對待
4. 這些事情一直都在發生，有一天也可能發生在我們兩個的小孩身上，如果他們被霸凌我一定會在學校辦公室飆罵直到有人能給我解釋為止，反過來也是一樣，如果我們的小孩有霸凌別人，那他回家就慘了
沒時間也沒實力逐字翻譯，但是大致上是這樣，希望有幫助
英文要好好學，真的