@maryamah Sister, I understand your concern; and you have a right to voicing your strong opinion; however, let me respond this way -- every culture is different in its approach. Persians and Baltistanis use Daff (drums) on 10th Moharram. Arabic Nasheeds have music. Even Indians used to use Shehnai (a type of bagpipe, if I am not mistaken) to increase the feeling of pain in nohay/marsiya. Hasan Sadiq, Nusrat Fateh Ali etc are from Faisalabad and they routinely use music [continued ..]
@HaiderImran [continued ...] in their works and personally, I cry faster and a lot easier with a musical note that makes me feel sad. Now, the point of my answer was not to debate and I don't wish to discuss further; however, I just wanted to let you know that this is very common and people across Persia and the Arab world use music and you should not be surprised in the future. May Allah and Panjatan accept our weeping and lamentation over the son of Bibi Zahra, Imam Hussain (AS).
Are these topics which should be SUNG OUT WITH MUSIC????? What is wrong with him??? I am so ashamed, embarassed and disappointed! In Hassan Sadiq and all the people who have commented on this and praised this video.... he could have recited this as a Soz and would have done it justice. The way he has done it is shameful!
I am the first person to dislike this viedo.. and I am a Shia... The reason is just one and it is this: How can Hassan Sadiq sing this with music when the last few ash'aar are about Imam Hussain (a.s) bringing the body of Ali Akbar (a.s) back to the Tents and then the mention of the Bibi Zainab and Qulsoom being robbed of thier chaadar??????
Masha Allah , Hassan sadiq bahut khoob
Boht khoobsurat. Masha Allah.
Wah wah mashahallah mola pak salamat rakhy ap ko
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤sss
@maryamah Sister, I understand your concern; and you have a right to voicing your strong opinion; however, let me respond this way -- every culture is different in its approach. Persians and Baltistanis use Daff (drums) on 10th Moharram. Arabic Nasheeds have music. Even Indians used to use Shehnai (a type of bagpipe, if I am not mistaken) to increase the feeling of pain in nohay/marsiya. Hasan Sadiq, Nusrat Fateh Ali etc are from Faisalabad and they routinely use music [continued ..]
110🧿🙏♥️🤲🤲🤲🤲🤲💐🌹
@HaiderImran [continued ...] in their works and personally, I cry faster and a lot easier with a musical note that makes me feel sad. Now, the point of my answer was not to debate and I don't wish to discuss further; however, I just wanted to let you know that this is very common and people across Persia and the Arab world use music and you should not be surprised in the future. May Allah and Panjatan accept our weeping and lamentation over the son of Bibi Zahra, Imam Hussain (AS).
Are these topics which should be SUNG OUT WITH MUSIC????? What is wrong with him??? I am so ashamed, embarassed and disappointed! In Hassan Sadiq and all the people who have commented on this and praised this video....
he could have recited this as a Soz and would have done it justice. The way he has done it is shameful!
I am the first person to dislike this viedo.. and I am a Shia... The reason is just one and it is this: How can Hassan Sadiq sing this with music when the last few ash'aar are about Imam Hussain (a.s) bringing the body of Ali Akbar (a.s) back to the Tents and then the mention of the Bibi Zainab and Qulsoom being robbed of thier chaadar??????