It was a festival sometime around '70/'71 in Holland that featured Jefferson Airplane and Carlos Santana. The footage of this show is available on the concert video "Stamping Ground."
You are so right. They actually wrote their own music - didn't have a bunch of song writers etc. writing songs for them to sing like they do today. It is like a sausage machine nowadays. No real talent. There are bands like Foo Fighters, Velvet Relover et al who do their own writing, but generally it is talentless boy (and girl) bands prancing around on stage 'singing' other peoples songs.
Ummagumma album version of this extraordinary simphony is to me the most elaborate performance of the Floyd. But this dark sided and desperate Kralingen recording has always been one of my favs
Pink floyd's Saucer Full of Secrets, I was commenting on what I hear at my end, that the recording was not clear and I thought it was possible the compression for RUclips made it sound bad, and the symbols were too loud for my taste for this song. Pink Floyd is one of my favorite bands, since 1968.
it's a little rough and ready, but man the passion and energy! think it's the "stamping ground" film. man, wouldn't you just love to hear this sucker properly remastered? sure there's mistakes, but wright's totally into it, and mason's burning. - thewordofgord
I think backthen musicians just were out there to make music, not to please the Label execs as they have to today. That's why a band like PF wouldn't make it today. Everything is made for under 5 minutes formats. But all that aside, we are very fortunate that times were different and a band like Pink Floyd came to be.
Looks a lot better than the last one, which someone said it was a studio version. Does anyone remember the album with a large head on it. I thought it was Relics, but the one on web site "PF" was different picture.
dude...i'm a huge gilmour fan but you might want to rethink what u just said. it aint possible. Hendrix was from another planet. And his legacy is just 4 years of music..
Hate Division Bell? It's much more in line with the Pink Floyd sound than The Wall, Final Cut or Momentary Lapse of Reason. And for that reason I enjoy it more.
what kind of organ is that? it deosnt look like a farfisa compact duo that Rick used to play this. So may be it is a Hammond m-100 that used in the studio version...
@MrCkufu juz play around wit the notes. have patience n you'l find the progression. try not to rely on tabs. makes you a better guitarist when u learn it by ear
Your really upset about somebody critisizing Gilmour. The last bit of comfortably numb is indeed in the same key different octive, i will agree on that. But the basic spine, if you will, are both in the same spot on the fret board. You have no idea how simplistic this man really is? I've been playing guitar for 11 years and when i was just fourteen i realized how easy it is to play any form of floyd.
I don´t think so. Remember Roger Made a good job with that disk...what is it´s name?..amm... oh yes..The Dark Side of The moon... Rick just plays the keyboards he doesn´t create the music.
LoL, did you see Dave's vocals? Ahhahha.. I think Rick Wright is the most talented person in the group there. Because: - Dave was a child as you see, he was newest and newbiest. - Roger didn't have a musical talent, Syd was according his bass. - Nick was the "normal"(?) man. I mean he said that: "I wish I would be a racer". I think he was just doing his job, kicking the drums, I don't believe that he gave something to the group. All of these makes Rick best member of that era.
The constant symbol crashing is so loud and am surprized you don't complain about that. What I can hear of Gilmore sounds like a bass vocal. The drummer used way too much symbol that you can barely hear the other instruments. I just look at it as an experiment that didn't turn out the best they could have done, so move on to what works.
Where's that quote from? When I Google it, I only get this video. I'd also like to use this opportunity to diss both you and Cesgord on account of grammar.
one thing that kind of annoys me about pink floyd videos sometimes is that they have all these stupid effects for half of it and i jsut want to see the band
He does have a nice voice, but what I originally said was that he butchered this particular performance. He sounds great on all the Pompeii videos and he sounds good on many albums. He just sounds like a cat being strangled by a violin in this one. I said that strats are quacky. They are indeed quacky and twangy, that's one of the attributes Fender aims for, it's sound is desirable for many artists. I for one don't like the sound, and find them to have very little sustain and too much treble.
Comon anyone can use a slide. Gilmour is another example of simple playing being regarded as epic. Pink Floyd is indeed about the passion but Gilmour is beyond predictable in his guitar playing technique, what can he honestly do? Play a Blues Scale back and forth and maybe introduce an old Blues lick? Comon! The solos for Money and Comfortably Numb are on the exact same scale just played in a different pace! I love all of the members of Floyd to death but he really butchers songs sometimes.
Again, all you are pegging is me. It's no longer about Gilmour. Please calm down, it's absolutely pointless and immachure to use such volgarity in this sort of arguement. If you will please retype that last comment, becuase I understand less than half of that. But what ever your the one that's getting upset. I don't have enough knowledge to speak of Pink Floyd, well you obviously don't have enough knowledge to defend Pink Floyd. Again, your not making any sense, your talking about me not Gilmour
Carloteiro, Gimour said that he was better than Hendrix! If you want a rational direction with your life, I'm sure that maybe the idea of Gilmour being ignorant will help you. jackflashrj, what i felt from his playing was just gurble from his voice and the muddy distortion from the combination of what ever the hell he's put his strat through. To each his own, but my own is that Gilmour butchered this version. Some things never change ;)
Success means nothing to me actually. Is it egotistical to critisize? If it be, then you are indeed a hypocrit for critisizing me. Critisism is just one of the endoresments the first amendment gives anybody. It is a heathly thing to have ones opinion, but you, you have absolutly no rational direction or purpose toward what I'm talking about. Feal free to join in the aguement when you can type more than one sentence defending Gilmour and not bashing me.
okay Mr. B miner... "Finally" whatever. It's a good tune. So your saying Waters with the Percussion role is more egostistical than the guitarist whom said he was better than Hendrix? I know all about roger waters, he's a brutal song writer and he took the band in his own direction, upset at the government,father died in Black Friday ,etc. Back on the actual subject. Gilmour is egotistical aswell as roger Gimour butchered this particular performance with his banshee voice and quacky Strat.
you need the lord jesus in your life living without jesus will only bring you porblems in this life and saying badwords is a great sin mary queen of heaven said that heavy metal music is unhealthy the demons do fear mary the mother of jesus God can for give you of anything only if you just say sorry than you will find true peace that this world doesnt have check on this its true on youtube -words from our lord to st. faustina and God bless you
I really don't understand how "passion" justifies how sucky gilmour is. He's just another EGP. (Egotistical Guitar Player/or Extra Gay Player for some).
hi hows life going for you i hope fine did you know that jesus values you he cares about you if you need him he there for you and you can talk to your angle plseae check out this its real on youtube- ewtn.com messeges from our lady mary of heaven and words from our lord to st. faustina on his devine mercy we are sinners God knows that but its good to say sorry to God and we can find true peace most peolpe that go to hell is cause of hate for God and love for porn jesus can for give a sinner
Que. Gran. Banda... Que gran. Grupo... Su musica. Nos hace viajar por el tiempo y el espacio.. y en Nuestas. Mentes.. también.🧐 👌🏼
Amazing that it has been over 40 years and they still rock. This music and this band were ahead of their time. No question about that.
THIS IS MY FAVORITE VERSION : EPIC and GLORIOUS ,
PINK FLOYD IS THE SOUNDTRACK OF MY LIFE...
What a beauftiful and amazing song! Great performance!
This is truly amazing to see. To me this is the time where Pink Floyd was at its best musically speaking. Before all of the drama began. I love it
Wonderful from the beginning!
This esoteric performance was recorded live at Kralingen/Holland in 1970. Wish
I was there !
It was a festival sometime around '70/'71 in Holland that featured Jefferson Airplane and Carlos Santana. The footage of this show is available on the concert video "Stamping Ground."
wonderful performance!
Incrível a sintonia dos 4. Eles forma um só.
THAT WAS AWESOME!!
I wish they had the whole song but this is still amazing.
wow if only we never had the X-Factor today maybe music would still be as good as this
Well done. True to form.
o h yea i agree with you amazing dude i love this too a lot
wonderful
Gran músico que deja una gran contribución a la música. Seguramente se fue tranquilo y satisfecho. RIP.
You are so right. They actually wrote their own music - didn't have a bunch of song writers etc. writing songs for them to sing like they do today. It is like a sausage machine nowadays. No real talent. There are bands like Foo Fighters, Velvet Relover et al who do their own writing, but generally it is talentless boy (and girl) bands prancing around on stage 'singing' other peoples songs.
You did it! You replyd to his coment! I knew you could do it.
Ummagumma album version of this
extraordinary simphony is to me the most
elaborate performance of the Floyd. But
this dark sided and desperate Kralingen
recording has always been one of my favs
What a trip........
Wow!
Pink floyd's Saucer Full of Secrets, I was commenting on what I hear at my end, that the recording was not clear and I thought it was possible the compression for RUclips made it sound bad, and the symbols were too loud for my taste for this song. Pink Floyd is one of my favorite bands, since 1968.
Rick Wright, no te olvidaremos (1943-2008)
It's been like that since the electric microphone was introduced and Bing Crosby hit the charts.
Look up "the American Songbook" to understand.
it's a little rough and ready, but man the passion and energy! think it's the "stamping ground" film. man, wouldn't you just love to hear this sucker properly remastered? sure there's mistakes, but wright's totally into it, and mason's burning.
- thewordofgord
I think the quality is quite good when you take the year under the consideration.
this inducts me to floyd
They have to release a Saucerful of Secrets Immersion set!!!
just a bunch of long haired kids having fun....and making rock music history.
He's realy creative.
FLOYD POWER!
I think backthen musicians just were out there to make music, not to please the Label execs as they have to today. That's why a band like PF wouldn't make it today. Everything is made for under 5 minutes formats.
But all that aside, we are very fortunate that times were different and a band like Pink Floyd came to be.
THE BEST VERSION!!! GET OVER POMPEII
Freedom
@BrettMayaAllisonTory
thanks.. i reckon it was amazing..
Looks a lot better than the last one, which someone said it was a studio version.
Does anyone remember the album with a large head on it. I thought it was Relics, but the one on web site "PF" was different picture.
a few jazz drummers in the 50s used them
dude...i'm a huge gilmour fan but you might want to rethink what u just said.
it aint possible. Hendrix was from another planet. And his legacy is just 4 years of music..
noooooooooooooo , yo me quedo con la version en estudio , es mas loca de hecho y escucharlo con audifonos y drogado es el maximo placer xD
great song but needs more sound, i like this version
beautiful ,made me cry. i love floyd.is this particular performance available on a dvd or vhs somewhere?
Relics had a mask sort of thing on the cover of the reissue.
@seantheman121
Wright's contributiton to the momentary lapse of reason was very minimal... me thinks..
thats a great video to one of my favorite music pieces,,but the sound quality is aweful..thnx anywayz
great version... different but just as good as the ummagummma version. does anyone know where and when this was recorded?
wow your smart
wow mason
"A Saucerful of Secrets" (Roger Waters, Richard Wright, David Gilmour, Nick Mason)
No Barrett...
This is my new favorite version of this song. Is there a bootleg this is on?
@seantheman121 I agree with you 100%
Hate Division Bell? It's much more in line with the Pink Floyd sound than The Wall, Final Cut or Momentary Lapse of Reason. And for that reason I enjoy it more.
same part of the fretboard actually. same key same octive. :)
what kind of organ is that? it deosnt look like a farfisa compact duo that Rick used to play this. So may be it is a Hammond m-100 that used in the studio version...
18 anos
@TEMPmichaelhansen
Holland Pop Festival in Rotterdam
Pink Floyd wrote "Dogs".
I don't think it drew much of an audience back then either... they only got REALLY famous after Dard Side of the Moon.
First Roger, then gilmour... that's it
Sounds good to me.
In that case I'll admit that I misjudged him.
AH AH AH
I can't read lips.Can someone tell me what is Roger saying at around 4.30?
@MrCkufu juz play around wit the notes. have patience n you'l find the progression. try not to rely on tabs. makes you a better guitarist when u learn it by ear
wikiqoute
type David Gilmour
3rd qoute states:
"Jimi Hendrix isn't as good as me!"
I would have liked to see the whole performance instead of just an excerpt. Good stuff, though.
Your really upset about somebody critisizing Gilmour.
The last bit of comfortably numb is indeed in the same key different octive, i will agree on that. But the basic spine, if you will, are both in the same spot on the fret board.
You have no idea how simplistic this man really is? I've been playing guitar for 11 years and when i was just fourteen i realized how easy it is to play any form of floyd.
I don´t think so.
Remember Roger Made a good job with that disk...what is it´s name?..amm... oh yes..The Dark Side of The moon...
Rick just plays the keyboards he doesn´t create the music.
If you think i suck then be a critic on my videos, not in the middle of this eventuallity.
Thank you
SORRY! I completely misread that. I thought you wrote BETTER instead of LATER...
LoL, did you see Dave's vocals?
Ahhahha..
I think Rick Wright is the most talented person in the group there. Because:
- Dave was a child as you see, he was newest and newbiest.
- Roger didn't have a musical talent, Syd was according his bass.
- Nick was the "normal"(?) man. I mean he said that: "I wish I would be a racer". I think he was just doing his job, kicking the drums, I don't believe that he gave something to the group.
All of these makes Rick best member of that era.
good version but pompeii is my favorite
Well the PEOPLE aren't... the BAND is though.
omg waters with short hair ???? o_O
The constant symbol crashing is so loud and am surprized you don't complain about that. What I can hear of Gilmore sounds like a bass vocal. The drummer used way too much symbol that you can barely hear the other instruments. I just look at it as an experiment that didn't turn out the best they could have done, so move on to what works.
Where's that quote from? When I Google it, I only get this video. I'd also like to use this opportunity to diss both you and Cesgord on account of grammar.
one thing that kind of annoys me about pink floyd videos sometimes is that they have all these stupid effects for half of it and i jsut want to see the band
I mean... Since when does "passion" justify a sloppy performance?
He does have a nice voice, but what I originally said was that he butchered this particular performance. He sounds great on all the Pompeii videos and he sounds good on many albums. He just sounds like a cat being strangled by a violin in this one.
I said that strats are quacky. They are indeed quacky and twangy, that's one of the attributes Fender aims for, it's sound is desirable for many artists. I for one don't like the sound, and find them to have very little sustain and too much treble.
so what if hendrix was over rated, he was fucking good! dont you think theres a reason
he's over rated?
i change my opinion, this is better than ummagumma, and better than pompeii.. too bad the recording is awful.
Mason rules
Comon anyone can use a slide. Gilmour is another example of simple playing being regarded as epic.
Pink Floyd is indeed about the passion but Gilmour is beyond predictable in his guitar playing technique, what can he honestly do? Play a Blues Scale back and forth and maybe introduce an old Blues lick? Comon! The solos for Money and Comfortably Numb are on the exact same scale just played in a different pace!
I love all of the members of Floyd to death but he really butchers songs sometimes.
Gilmour kinda butchered it :(
he does sound bad in this one
Again, all you are pegging is me. It's no longer about Gilmour. Please calm down, it's absolutely pointless and immachure to use such volgarity in this sort of arguement. If you will please retype that last comment, becuase I understand less than half of that. But what ever your the one that's getting upset. I don't have enough knowledge to speak of Pink Floyd, well you obviously don't have enough knowledge to defend Pink Floyd. Again, your not making any sense, your talking about me not Gilmour
Carloteiro, Gimour said that he was better than Hendrix! If you want a rational direction with your life, I'm sure that maybe the idea of Gilmour being ignorant will help you.
jackflashrj, what i felt from his playing was just gurble from his voice and the muddy distortion from the combination of what ever the hell he's put his strat through.
To each his own, but my own is that Gilmour butchered this version.
Some things never change ;)
Success means nothing to me actually. Is it egotistical to critisize? If it be, then you are indeed a hypocrit for critisizing me. Critisism is just one of the endoresments the first amendment gives anybody. It is a heathly thing to have ones opinion, but you, you have absolutly no rational direction or purpose toward what I'm talking about. Feal free to join in the aguement when you can type more than one sentence defending Gilmour and not bashing me.
Wow jehovah witnesses at youtube i'm out of here
okay Mr. B miner... "Finally" whatever. It's a good tune. So your saying Waters with the Percussion role is more egostistical than the guitarist whom said he was better than Hendrix? I know all about roger waters, he's a brutal song writer and he took the band in his own direction, upset at the government,father died in Black Friday ,etc. Back on the actual subject. Gilmour is egotistical aswell as roger Gimour butchered this particular performance with his banshee voice and quacky Strat.
you need the lord jesus in your life living without jesus will only bring you porblems in this life and saying badwords is a great sin mary queen of heaven said that heavy metal music is unhealthy the demons do fear mary the mother of jesus God can for give you of anything only if you just say sorry than you will find true peace that this world doesnt have check on this its true on youtube -words from our lord to st. faustina and God bless you
I really don't understand how "passion" justifies how sucky gilmour is. He's just another EGP. (Egotistical Guitar Player/or Extra Gay Player for some).
hi hows life going for you i hope fine did you know that jesus values you he cares about you if you need him he there for you and you can talk to your angle plseae check out this its real on youtube- ewtn.com messeges from our lady mary of heaven and words from our lord to st. faustina on his devine mercy we are sinners God knows that but its good to say sorry to God and we can find true peace most peolpe that go to hell is cause of hate for God and love for porn jesus can for give a sinner
thats blasephy. division bell didnt have ROGER OR SYD! Division Bell is the worst album! Come onnnn it came out in 1994! THIS IS WAYYYY BETTERRRR!!!!
That´s sooo fuckin´true!11