I am also US citizen from Maryland. Very nice topic. People in India from low are obsessed because they are either brainwashed from agents and or what they see in movies. I know couple of 17-18 year old kids from Karnal whose parents took loans worth Rs 50 lakh. They came here illegally via Mexico. Now they are applying for asylum since it is the easiest way for them to get legal status. We have Pannu like attorneys who promote these because it benefits them
Indian cinema especially for Hindi cinema there are 2 threats: first is for hindi language cinema which bombay film industry make which is controlled by non hindi region artists and cultural influence especially Punjabi and promote their culture, and who also exploits hindi region arts, languages, culture, history etc. And it lacks isolated artists who has been unconsciously been matured in their immediate society and can create individualistic original fantasies. 2nd threat is our film industries is monopolized by westernized elites, who live in a emotional western political fantasy (self image, world view) who has accepted being a subject of western mainstream, and who copy paste western socio politico philosophical cultural artistic elements, and who copy paste western trend of using labels, categories to practice and promote same minded closed labelled groupism
Dear Prof. Khan, It is not primarily that people are not having hope in India but there is aspiration in Indian to go abroad and become reach quickly.. it is same like so many people come to Mumbai to become star but ended up in dire situation..
It is widely reported here in local media that these agents charge more than ₹30-40 lakhs, and any Indian willing to pay that kind of money, can't be poor, by any standard, these people are curse to India and Indian society, Indian govt should punish these people
I had same emotions when watched it. Indians are totally giving priorities to education... And I really do not understand, vicky kaushal could have tried for tourist visa , as he was planning only 1-2 day travel... The base of the movie is baseless 😂😂
Out of 303, only 21 were from Gujarat. It is sad, but it is also possible that this kind of service is only available to Punjab and Gujarat. Other states, this facility is not even available. Most of those who leave Punjab to Canada also do farming. It is just ghar ki murgi daal barabar.
Does citizens of other counties also uses name INDIAN when they enter illegally? I am not denying migration but how many of them are actual Indian? Because Pak, Bang, Afg also say they r Indian
I won't ever leave my country Bharat. Most BJP supporters and RW won't even consider leaving country. I'm shocked, if no you showed are actual Indian citizens n not citizens from other countries calling themselves INDIAN
@@goodfellow4967No bro, If you are illlgal immigrant from RAWANDA then chances of getting caught is more. If you said Indian, India's goodwill help them in smooth process as indians have good reputation in USA
They give 30-40 lakhs to go there, they are not poor but they want to earn in dollars and spend in rupees, they buy properties in india and become rich. That is reverse ppp😂
Sir do you know what is tax rate in india without getting any visible benefit and Salary is also very low this is the main reason of migration and I also think to do so
Sir i dont think its about hopelessness..its about greed..most of the dunki people are from punjab and gujrat .which are rich states ..but these people are not satisfied..they are really greedy..i know many people from punjab who are farmers and have sufficient land to farm...but because they see their neighbours and all they want to do the same. Same case with gujratis. U wont see many people from UP,bihar,mp,etc doing that..they might be poor and can go to work in other states but major people for dunki are from punjab and gujrat. Please stop blaming india for it since none of the other states people do it. How many from ur own state Andhra do dunki..?? Since ur a professor u should not talk directly like that ..u should talk based on data. If india is so bad why no tamils, no Maharashtrian, no northeast people, no bihari, etc are going ..why only punjab and gujratis..?? The reason is very simple they have more money hence more greed.
@@ProfMuqtedarKhan sir like i said punjabis and gujratis are full of greed and are know for taking shortcuts. I know them as my wife works with B2B firm and had to deal with lot of gujratis. This is good for bussiness and thats why gujrat has progress but like i said when ur neighbours is in US doing good even if u have enough..that wont be sufficient for u. And punjabis and gujratis are know for this kind of silly comparison. BJP or non BJP has nothing to do with it. Its more about the society u have around.
@@ProfMuqtedarKhan due to social environment of these states. And India is huge country with population that why it is more as compared to another nation.
The entertainment angle is to bring people in to theatre, with out that it would be like documentary and commercial flop. I have nt yet seen the movie, but, based on your comment, I guess the movie didnt want to encourage people to follow the migration in that pattern.
Those people who do nothing in life are leaving the country.How much would you earn abroad? If I talk in US dollars, I earn $950 a month and live comfortably in India.And does not even feel sad over the death of such an illegal migrant 😢😢
I found Dunki movie very bad as well. It seems Srk promoting human trafficking by justifying it fair as brits came to India for over 100 years. I was aware of this situation but what surprises me is the amount of money they pay to come meaning they are not really from very poor background. Alas grass is really greener on the other side
Sir being senior iam seeing young generations want quick Money. Many many are not that qualified. And as population increased triple To get seat in good college Rare, competition very high So these are main reasons as per my Assessment. Another Reason is freebies from Govt Monthly free ration, extra money in hand made them very lethargic. What can one say, but should not blame govt
Sorry Sir.I have a different point of view. Did British come legally in India? Was colonialism a legal entry ? India too has crores of illegal Bangladeshis and Rohingya Muslims immigrants. !!! It is a human issue. Tell me one name of today's American Citizen, who or whose parents or forefathers didnot come from outside America legally or illegally. Today, total numbers of Indians ( both NRIs and PIO) settled abroad, is just 3.5 Crores . And total population of India today is 140 Crores. Population of every country in the West is declining. They need people from outside. It is simply a demand and supply issue. And also a phenomenon of reverse colonialism, more peaceful and more friendly. In a few years, Indians will be part of the Ruling Establishment of most countries of the world. This is also compatible with our Vasudev Kuttumbukam _world is but a Family concept.
Although most of the Dalits in Punjab are landless labourers yet average poverty is less in comparison to other states have. People in India has limitless freedom especially for politically influential sections which is making things chaotic. In comparison to this West has straight forward system, which attracts people from third world countries.
Sir I don't know about your choice but may be you AB fan. But this old SRK is back with full of emotions. We India has emotions connect that west world do not understand. Belive me SRK is back with this movie as compare to Jawaan and Pataan
Statically from punjab, Gujrat and andhra. These are the three states people have a khujli to go out. They are well to do here and living good but just the unknown glamor what they think they will get there attract them.
Sir ! You may be wrong.No one in India leaving country because of harassment & partiality on basis of their religion or caste.Bharat is the most secular and tolerant country in the world who adopt even the most barbaric & radicalized Islamic invaders in it.There may be only one reason why very few people are leaving India that they have excess amount of corruption money or they are day dreaming to be rich very soon for life style of western world.
I think you are very far away from the reality of India.You know India through propaganda channels interviews etc.People that want to leave India in this way are those who are uneducated, want fast money through shortcuts and are greedy.
I think u moved from India long time ago you need to talk to those people who are educated and live among those people. I can tell you very well why is this happening in Punjab , Haryana and Gujarat only. Even Khalistan is also connected with this
Migration achchha hai BJP-RSS ke liye bolne wale samajhdar log chale jayenge and dollar bhi bhejenge. Jo india me youth honge vo bhakt,radicalised, BJP-RSS ke supporter balle-balle.....😂😂🤣😂😂
![Summer Walker - Heart Of A Woman [Official Lyric Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/SFddctbZzw8/mqdefault.jpg)
I am also US citizen from Maryland. Very nice topic.
People in India from low are obsessed because they are either brainwashed from agents and or what they see in movies. I know couple of 17-18 year old kids from Karnal whose parents took loans worth Rs 50 lakh. They came here illegally via Mexico. Now they are applying for asylum since it is the easiest way for them to get legal status. We have Pannu like attorneys who promote these because it benefits them
Sad. Specially of they do not get asylum.
Indian cinema especially for Hindi cinema there are 2 threats: first is for hindi language cinema which bombay film industry make which is controlled by non hindi region artists and cultural influence especially Punjabi and promote their culture, and who also exploits hindi region arts, languages, culture, history etc. And it lacks isolated artists who has been unconsciously been matured in their immediate society and can create individualistic original fantasies. 2nd threat is our film industries is monopolized by westernized elites, who live in a emotional western political fantasy (self image, world view) who has accepted being a subject of western mainstream, and who copy paste western socio politico philosophical cultural artistic elements, and who copy paste western trend of using labels, categories to practice and promote same minded closed labelled groupism
Interesting observation.
Dear Prof. Khan, It is not primarily that people are not having hope in India but there is aspiration in Indian to go abroad and become reach quickly.. it is same like so many people come to Mumbai to become star but ended up in dire situation..
MADRASA CHHAP GUTTER KIDA KHAN ALWAYS HAPPY TO PRESENT INDIA IN BAD LIGHT
I watched the film 🎬 Dunki and loved it. Very realistic thematization of a complex problem.
It is widely reported here in local media that these agents charge more than ₹30-40 lakhs, and any Indian willing to pay that kind of money, can't be poor, by any standard, these people are curse to India and Indian society, Indian govt should punish these people
MADRASA CHHAP GUTTER KIDA KHAN ALWAYS HAPPY TO PRESENT INDIA IN BAD LIGHT
It has nothing to do with economy. It is a Punjabi fascination. Paida hote hi kasam khate hain Kanneda visa chahiye...
Sir I really love you because of unbiased analysis.,.thank u sir love u a lot
So nice of you
MADRASA CHHAP GUTTER KIDA KHAN ALWAYS HAPPY TO PRESENT INDIA IN BAD LIGHT
Sir, why did you leave India ?
I had same emotions when watched it. Indians are totally giving priorities to education...
And I really do not understand, vicky kaushal could have tried for tourist visa , as he was planning only 1-2 day travel... The base of the movie is baseless 😂😂
They could have called the cops about domestic abuse and maybe saved her life.
Nice analysis Sir; no substitute to hard work, patience & dedication! Bombay film industry is trivializing this sad reality as entertainment
Out of 303, only 21 were from Gujarat. It is sad, but it is also possible that this kind of service is only available to Punjab and Gujarat. Other states, this facility is not even available. Most of those who leave Punjab to Canada also do farming. It is just ghar ki murgi daal barabar.
Does citizens of other counties also uses name INDIAN when they enter illegally? I am not denying migration but how many of them are actual Indian? Because Pak, Bang, Afg also say they r Indian
Zz
lol use ur mind it’s more easy for them to get asylum to those countries name
I won't ever leave my country Bharat. Most BJP supporters and RW won't even consider leaving country. I'm shocked, if no you showed are actual Indian citizens n not citizens from other countries calling themselves INDIAN
@@goodfellow4967No bro,
If you are illlgal immigrant from RAWANDA then chances of getting caught is more. If you said Indian, India's goodwill help them in smooth process as indians have good reputation in USA
They give 30-40 lakhs to go there, they are not poor but they want to earn in dollars and spend in rupees, they buy properties in india and become rich.
That is reverse ppp😂
Mr. Khan, very out of the box video..really enjoyed
Thx
Glad you liked it. Thanks
Sir do you know what is tax rate in india without getting any visible benefit and Salary is also very low this is the main reason of migration and I also think to do so
Great analysis sir 👏
Sir i dont think its about hopelessness..its about greed..most of the dunki people are from punjab and gujrat .which are rich states ..but these people are not satisfied..they are really greedy..i know many people from punjab who are farmers and have sufficient land to farm...but because they see their neighbours and all they want to do the same. Same case with gujratis. U wont see many people from UP,bihar,mp,etc doing that..they might be poor and can go to work in other states but major people for dunki are from punjab and gujrat. Please stop blaming india for it since none of the other states people do it. How many from ur own state Andhra do dunki..?? Since ur a professor u should not talk directly like that ..u should talk based on data. If india is so bad why no tamils, no Maharashtrian, no northeast people, no bihari, etc are going ..why only punjab and gujratis..?? The reason is very simple they have more money hence more greed.
The above is pure nonsense
Totally agree
After nearly 20 years of BJP Govt, Gujaratis are still migrating why? All the south Indians migrate legally. IT, Docs etc...
@@ProfMuqtedarKhan sir like i said punjabis and gujratis are full of greed and are know for taking shortcuts. I know them as my wife works with B2B firm and had to deal with lot of gujratis. This is good for bussiness and thats why gujrat has progress but like i said when ur neighbours is in US doing good even if u have enough..that wont be sufficient for u. And punjabis and gujratis are know for this kind of silly comparison. BJP or non BJP has nothing to do with it. Its more about the society u have around.
@@ProfMuqtedarKhan due to social environment of these states. And India is huge country with population that why it is more as compared to another nation.
Intelligent review Sir.
डंकी। वाले वो लोग। होते है जो लायक तो नहीं होते पर जिंदगी में बहुत ज्यादा पैसे। कमाना चाहते है इसलीय वो किसी भी हद तक चले जाते है या गिर जाते है
19:10
Do more movie review sir please jo aapko aachi lage uska review jarur dijiye gaa
The entertainment angle is to bring people in to theatre, with out that it would be like documentary and commercial flop. I have nt yet seen the movie, but, based on your comment, I guess the movie didnt want to encourage people to follow the migration in that pattern.
Jaishankar ji ke Russiya visit pr bhi apne vichar rakhiye
Those people who do nothing in life are leaving the country.How much would you earn abroad? If I talk in US dollars, I earn $950 a month and live comfortably in India.And does not even feel sad over the death of such an illegal migrant 😢😢
Dunki means in my view is 'Persistence'
Mai v hairan hu😢
I have stopped watching Hindi movies long back... never going to visit theatre for watching Hindi movies in future.
I found Dunki movie very bad as well. It seems Srk promoting human trafficking by justifying it fair as brits came to India for over 100 years.
I was aware of this situation but what surprises me is the amount of money they pay to come meaning they are not really from very poor background. Alas grass is really greener on the other side
Sir being senior iam seeing young generations want quick
Money. Many many are not that qualified. And as population increased triple
To get seat in good college
Rare, competition very high
So these are main reasons as per my Assessment. Another Reason is freebies from Govt
Monthly free ration, extra money in hand made them very lethargic. What can one say, but should not blame govt
Sorry Sir.I have a different point of view.
Did British come legally in India?
Was colonialism a legal entry ?
India too has crores of illegal Bangladeshis and Rohingya Muslims immigrants. !!!
It is a human issue.
Tell me one name of today's American Citizen, who or whose parents or forefathers didnot come from outside America legally or illegally.
Today, total numbers of Indians ( both NRIs and PIO) settled abroad, is just 3.5 Crores .
And total population of India today is 140 Crores.
Population of every country in the West is declining.
They need people from outside.
It is simply a demand and supply issue.
And also a phenomenon of reverse colonialism, more peaceful and more friendly.
In a few years, Indians will be part of the Ruling Establishment of most countries of the world.
This is also compatible with our Vasudev Kuttumbukam _world is but a Family concept.
Although most of the Dalits in Punjab are landless labourers yet average poverty is less in comparison to other states have. People in India has limitless freedom especially for politically influential sections which is making things chaotic. In comparison to this West has straight forward system, which attracts people from third world countries.
Better let's do Sam Bahadur movie conversation
Sir I don't know about your choice but may be you AB fan. But this old SRK is back with full of emotions. We India has emotions connect that west world do not understand. Belive me SRK is back with this movie as compare to Jawaan and Pataan
I have no problem with SRK, in fact I identified SRK's return in my review as one of the seven highs of 2023.
@@ProfMuqtedarKhan Sir , Dunki is not that much bad movie, specially made for NRI
Dr. Khan sahib , SRK ki Movies hain hi Bekaar ....... bass Kangana ki Tejas se behtar Movie aaj taq bann hi nahin saki 😜😜😜😜😜
Sir 1 person cost for dunki is around 50 lakh no poor person can afford this.
It is continuing from a very long time , ultimately more than 50% got citizenship.
Shahrukh Khan has only one aim for making movies and that is putting India down. Make the movie Dunki a flop.
Statically from punjab, Gujrat and andhra. These are the three states people have a khujli to go out. They are well to do here and living good but just the unknown glamor what they think they will get there attract them.
Sir ! You may be wrong.No one in India leaving country because of harassment & partiality on basis of their religion or caste.Bharat is the most secular and tolerant country in the world who adopt even the most barbaric & radicalized Islamic invaders in it.There may be only one reason why very few people are leaving India that they have excess amount of corruption money or they are day dreaming to be rich very soon for life style of western world.
Why...it's a okay movie...lot of political signalling...but still okay movie...
❤👍
It's realy shocking and shameful after watching your full video....
Sir with due respect your criticism is not fare
I think you are very far away from the reality of India.You know India through propaganda channels interviews etc.People that want to leave India in this way are those who are uneducated, want fast money through shortcuts and are greedy.
Why did you left India.
Itna bakwas movie😢 soch bhi nahi sekta.
Koi is film ko dekh ke apna paisa barbad na kare. 😮😮
I think u moved from India long time ago you need to talk to those people who are educated and live among those people. I can tell you very well why is this happening in Punjab , Haryana and Gujarat only. Even Khalistan is also connected with this
Migration achchha hai BJP-RSS ke liye bolne wale samajhdar log chale jayenge and dollar bhi bhejenge. Jo india me youth honge vo bhakt,radicalised, BJP-RSS ke supporter balle-balle.....😂😂🤣😂😂
Bcz they want a shortcut
Subject achha liya hai parantu film impress nahi karati hai.
1st
MADRASA CHHAP GUTTER KIDA KHAN ALWAYS HAPPY TO PRESENT INDIA IN BAD LIGHT
MADRASA CHHAP GUTTER KIDA KHAN ALWAYS HAPPY TO PRESENT INDIA IN BAD LIGHT