Human Trafficking: How Pakistanis get smuggled via "Dunki" (Dinghies) | BBC Documentary - BBC URDU

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 2 мар 2023
  • اٹلی میں پیش آنے والے کشتی کے حادثے سے پاکستان میں ایک بار پھر انسانی سمگلنگ کے بارے بحث شروع ہو گئی ہے۔ لیکن یہ ’ڈنکی‘ ہوتا کیا ہے اور لوگ کس طرح سمگل ہوتے ہیں؟ جانیے ہمارے ساتھی موسیٰ یاوری کی اس دستاویزی فلم میں
    فٹج بشکریہ: حسن زیدی
    #dunki #pakistan #migrants #border
    CLICK HERE to subscribe to BBC Urdu:
    bbc.in/1GsJCMR

Комментарии • 1,4 тыс.

  • @EcomGypsy
    @EcomGypsy Год назад +32

    This documentary should be played on all Pakistani channels once a month. Awareness is education.

    • @afshakhalil6826
      @afshakhalil6826 2 месяца назад +1

      Sir mera brother b waha se nekala gaya ha uski story be bohat afsos ki ha

    • @haleemsharar3046
      @haleemsharar3046 Месяц назад +1

      شکریہ BBC : حلیم شرر کراچی پاکستان

  • @tariqmahmood9827
    @tariqmahmood9827 Год назад +41

    ایک نہایت اہم اور دل کو دکھا دینے والا موضوع جس کی طرف سے ہماری حکومتوں نے آنکھیں بند کر رکھی ہیں مگر ہر سال یہ کئی گھرانے اجاڑ دیتا ہے
    بی بی سی کا شکریہ شاید کوئی ایک ضمیر جاگ جائے

    • @maheshsahu8789
      @maheshsahu8789 Месяц назад

      Pakistani government know very well about all failures

  • @QadeemyNuskhay
    @QadeemyNuskhay Год назад +56

    میں تو اس ماں کی وجہ سے رو رہا ہوں۔کہ اسکے سینے میں کتنا غم ہے۔خدا سب کو دکھوں سے بچائے

  • @AbdulLatif-im2vv
    @AbdulLatif-im2vv Год назад +68

    Thanks BBC to highlight such issues

    • @muhammadnaeemkhan3580
      @muhammadnaeemkhan3580 Год назад

      In Pakistan every department and every top official tyrant and corrupt

  • @alibutt1993
    @alibutt1993 Год назад +24

    This breaks my heart. This is a reminder to people who are watching with unrecognised privilege to be thankful and humble all the times.

  • @anamullah8963
    @anamullah8963 Год назад +40

    یا اللہ تعالی اس وقت میں مکۃالمکرمہ میں ہوں اپنے حبیب کے صدقے اس مکۃ المکرمہ کے صدقے جتنے بھی دنیا میں غریب لوگ انسان بستے ہیں اللہ تعالی ہم سب کو اپنے غیب کے خزانوں سے ہر قسم کی حفاظت اور مدد فرما اور جنہوں نے ہمارے ملک کو اس حال میں پہنچایا ان سب کو پوری دنیا کے سامنے ننگا کرکے عبرت کا نشان بنا دے میرے مولا آمین ثم آمین

  • @wasif4471
    @wasif4471 Год назад +57

    آخری دفعہ آیا ، غسل کیا، کفن پہنا، اور چلا گیا۔۔۔ اور میرا دل پھٹ گیا یہ سن کر💔 اللہ اس ماں کو صبر دے اسے صحت دے💔

    • @naeemqureshi3911
      @naeemqureshi3911 Год назад +1

      AAMEEN

    • @Rkan27
      @Rkan27 Год назад +1

      V v tragic

    • @SukhrajSingh-li7vy
      @SukhrajSingh-li7vy Месяц назад

      😢😢😢😢o yaar maa tu maa hundi a buhat dukh hua dil ko tusi Sade panjabi veer ho

  • @intersalman
    @intersalman Год назад +42

    The pain in that mother’s voice breaks my heart. May Allah make it easy for her.

    • @jitendarchauhansauthasia
      @jitendarchauhansauthasia Год назад +2

      Apne allha ko bulao koi allha nhi hain galat afwah udi hain sirf sanatan

    • @abcdef1709
      @abcdef1709 Год назад +3

      ​@@jitendarchauhansauthasia plastic surgery with elephant head sahi ha kya

    • @AA-go7ve
      @AA-go7ve Год назад

      @@jitendarchauhansauthasia nice joke 🤣🤣🤣

  • @rafiasyed9622
    @rafiasyed9622 Год назад +143

    کیا بنا دیا ہےاس ملک کا ان حرم کھانے والوں نے ۔ غریب لوگوں کے بچوں کو بھی کھا گے یہ 😥

    • @shahnawaz5670
      @shahnawaz5670 Год назад +1

      Beshak

    • @sulhrisulhrig8441
      @sulhrisulhrig8441 Год назад +2

      Right ya Pakistan nii h gharee awam k liye ya jahanam h

    • @hamidkhanwazir3810
      @hamidkhanwazir3810 Год назад +1

      بلکل ایسی ہیں

    • @fizzel5711
      @fizzel5711 Год назад

      They are cannibals 😡

    • @ashjoshi8094
      @ashjoshi8094 Год назад

      The agencies , your political leaders and your madrassas you love so much has robbed you guys dry, aur jazba badawo tum jo kalma padnewalli me say ho

  • @shaikhazharuddinbadar8990
    @shaikhazharuddinbadar8990 Год назад +12

    پاکستان کو ایک سچی و امانت دار قیادت کی ضرورت ہے

    • @aqeelali5517
      @aqeelali5517 Месяц назад

      Abhi arahi hai sachi qiyadat rasty mai hai

  • @travellingwithirfan7505
    @travellingwithirfan7505 Год назад +55

    The guy is speaking 100% true.
    I am also a survivor of this game. Alhamdolillah Allah gave me second life went back to pakistan and went to Bahrain. In bahrain i got good job and now i almost have all countries visas including Canada, USA, UK and Europe etc. and have visited all of them.
    My message is for everyone is to be patience Allah has plan for everyone just keep doing good and believe in hard work. Say No to shortcuts.

    • @vivekkumarsingh5178
      @vivekkumarsingh5178 Год назад +6

      Tum log iske layak ho Islam k Naam pr bna tha desh Pakistan jannat hona chahiye jannat chhod k kyo bhaag rahe ho wo illigal

    • @abhishek4702
      @abhishek4702 Месяц назад

      ​@@vivekkumarsingh5178india me kya hai esa bhi karab hal hai

    • @regularguy2391
      @regularguy2391 Месяц назад

      @@vivekkumarsingh5178Vivek, just to let you know, may be you are not aware that there are not many but only 9000 illegal Indians in prison in US. They all crossed from Mexico and many illegal Indians in UK, try to find it on Google or on RUclips, the comment you wrote does not suit any Indian well, India has all social ill and poverty same like Pakistan, first try to get knowledge about Indians overseas May be after that you will be careful to write comments.

  • @m.hussain3877
    @m.hussain3877 Год назад +21

    یا گھر آ کے ملا گا یا اخبار تے 😭
    It's made me cry

    • @adma7298
      @adma7298 Год назад

      Over population with no responsibility.
      Suicide bombers and suicide migrants. No difference.

  • @idreesawan4409
    @idreesawan4409 Год назад +12

    Superb...... Hats off to BBC for this documentary.... aa sensitive topic which needs to be discussed....

  • @SyedShah-qp1ui
    @SyedShah-qp1ui Год назад +23

    اناللہ وانا الیہ راجعون
    اللہ تعالیٰ وارثین کو صبر جمیل عطا کرے ۔ آمین ثم آمین ۔ بیٹا پال پوس کر سمندر کی لہروں کے سپرد ہوگیا ۔

  • @yogeshsharma4429
    @yogeshsharma4429 Год назад +14

    This mothers pain melt my heart 😢oh god why every guy wants to go behind Europe & no place is better than your born place...love your motherland where our ancestor live his whole life with hardwork & give us a legacy to live like them.

    • @waseemij
      @waseemij 3 месяца назад

      Nice theoretical talks...

    • @ur786.1
      @ur786.1 Месяц назад

      Exactly. You'd rather live in poverty than lose your life

  • @Nas59734
    @Nas59734 Год назад +543

    خدا رہ آپ اپنے بچوں کو غیر قانونی طریقے سے ملک سے باہر نہ بھیجیں جس کے نصیب میں جتنا رزق ہوتا ہے اس کو مل کر رہتا ہے اپنے بچوں کی زندگیوں کو محفوظ بنائیں

    • @adma7298
      @adma7298 Год назад +12

      خدارہ بچوں کی تمہید باندھنے سے پہلے سوچ لیں

    • @MBYT211
      @MBYT211 Год назад +6

      Great answer 😊

    • @fahimulhaq2698
      @fahimulhaq2698 Год назад +6

      صحیح کہا آپ نے

    • @ismailbaloch7154
      @ismailbaloch7154 Год назад

      جنرل عاصم منیر نے کہا ہندو بنیا صرف سود لیتا ہے۔ لیکن یہ ظالم چینی بنیا تمہارے گردے بھی لے جاتے ہیں اور ہر بڑے غبارے والی پنجابی لڑکی کی پھدی بھی.. یا علی مدد!!!g s7dc

    • @sarina5352
      @sarina5352 Год назад +14

      Absolutely agree with you, I live in the UK and came here to study. Luckily got married to British but at the same time we work sooooooooo hard abroad. People don't realise that, what they see in the west is nothing but just a dream which is nothing close to reality. Even people who are born here are homeless. I don't understand why the hell people do such things. I do understand that, people think if one person goes from the family others can have better life but why not legally. It's the same money and infact safe and nothing to loose. I would say often many are greedy and selfish especially when they start putting pressure on their older children..

  • @hassanakajadibhai1858
    @hassanakajadibhai1858 Год назад +12

    غربت برائی کی جڑ ہے اور پاکستان تو ماشاءاللہ سب سے آگے

  • @RahulSharmaKDM
    @RahulSharmaKDM Год назад +4

    God Aap sab ko Khush rakhe yaar
    Kisi ko bhi kaam karne bahar na jana padey...
    Love from India❤️ keep smiling guys😊

  • @ibrarhussain3092
    @ibrarhussain3092 Год назад +2

    Good episode 👏 👌 🙌
    اللہ تعالیٰ رحم فرمائے

  • @ashashley844
    @ashashley844 Год назад +19

    Watching ami g broke my heart. May Allah bless her.

  • @faryalkhan6918
    @faryalkhan6918 Год назад +22

    At the end knowing that mudasar finally went to Oman made me say Allahamdulilah,may Allah help him and give him halal rizq ameen.

    • @adma7298
      @adma7298 Год назад

      Telling lies, false statements for rizq e halal.

    • @ismailbaloch7154
      @ismailbaloch7154 Год назад +1

      جنرل عاصم منیر نے کہا ہندو بنیا صرف سود لیتا ہے۔ لیکن یہ ظالم چینی بنیا تمہارے گردے بھی لے جاتے ہیں اور ہر بڑے غبارے والی پنجابی لڑکی کی پھدی بھی.. یا علی مدد!!! 8sdc 7

  • @ishaqahmad6592
    @ishaqahmad6592 Год назад +31

    Every school and TV channel should show this every weekend to educate the generation. It may help many people to not take any risk . Family is everything. Thank you bbc for meltdown our heart .❤

    • @rukhsananaseer4194
      @rukhsananaseer4194 Год назад

      Lol government wants this illegal immigration and revenues.

  • @virendraSingh-je3sx
    @virendraSingh-je3sx Год назад +17

    Tragic and heart breaking. Awareness creation is only solution.

  • @ghulamdastgeer6599
    @ghulamdastgeer6599 Год назад +122

    My eyes are full of tears...😭😭😭.. When this mother said about her son that he said either I would be in cars or in newspaper... My heart was brolen... I believe that they are innocent people... Govt of Pakistan is responsible for these casualties because these people try to leave this country due lack of employment opportunity and evil of inflation.... Actually they go for suicide and govt is responsible for that...

    • @malkahans
      @malkahans Год назад +7

      I agree, they paid taxes to the govt, it is the responsibility of the govt either give job or give unemployment bonus
      Heart breaking

    • @wildae.
      @wildae. Год назад +4

      sadly you are absolutely correct.

    • @sadafsherazi9427
      @sadafsherazi9427 Год назад +1

      😢

    • @onestepaday110
      @onestepaday110 Год назад +1

      Allah pochy ga 😢

    • @shimantagoswami4781
      @shimantagoswami4781 Год назад +2

      Agar pak strict birth control policy, poligamy, control nehe keya to halat aur kharab hoge.
      Religious teachings and instruction, promote by molla, maulavi, Pak cannot control populations grouth.

  • @Multigia
    @Multigia Год назад +57

    خدا نے آج تک اس قوم کی حالت نہیں بدلی۔
    نہ ہو خود خیال جس کو اپنی حالت کے بدلنے کا۔

    • @vantagehistory1813
      @vantagehistory1813 Год назад +2

      phir punjabi bolo..............
      kiunke british ne 1 scheme launch ki thi......
      6 ana lo punjabi qaida do or urdu qaida lo scheme.........
      urdu speaking or media punjabi k against bht racist he.........
      karachi me in k areas me ja kr dekho....
      to punjabi kiu unki language bolte he??????
      i dont hate urdu.........
      mgr jb ap kisi ko gali doge to wo apki language kiu bole?
      ye to gulami he...........
      mgr hmari punjabi language kia urdu se kam he?
      nhi ..
      phir hm apni language bolenge.........
      basic azadi he ye hr insan ki

    • @ahad657
      @ahad657 Год назад +3

      ​@@vantagehistory1813 o mera bhai Punjabi khud apni mother language bolte Nahin

    • @akhtarzaidi9454
      @akhtarzaidi9454 Год назад

      نہ ھوُ جسکوُ خیال، آپ اپنیِ حالتَ کے بدلنےِ کا ؟
      علامہ صاحب نے مندرجہ بالا الفاظ لکھے تھے،،

    • @akhtarzaidi9454
      @akhtarzaidi9454 Год назад

      @@vantagehistory1813
      Bhaiya may ray aap sao baar apni zabaan ko qaomi zabaan bana loo, hamay koey shikwa nahee, laykin yeh yaad rakhoo ke Panjabi sirf aik zilaa Punjab ke zabaan haey, jab ke Urdu aik bainul aqwami yani international language ( zabaan ) haey.
      Aap Sindhi, Balouchi, Pashto, Jis ko chaho apni qaomi zabaan bana dalo, ham kaon hotay hain aitraaz kar nay walay ? Laykin in zabanow ko dunya me koi nahee janta, quen ke yeh moqami zabaan haey. Jab ke Urdu puray Bharat aur sari dunya me boli jati aur pahchani jati haey.
      Ham Urdu wale toh Pakistan 🇵🇰 bana kar, aur Abdul Qadir Khan, atomic bomb 💣 bana kar bahot pachta rahay haen.

    • @PakiNewsNetwork
      @PakiNewsNetwork Год назад

      aaho

  • @haleemsharar3046
    @haleemsharar3046 Месяц назад

    شکریہ بی بی سی ۔ سلام اور دعائیں محترم ۔ خیراندیش برائے اہلُ وطن و اہل دنیا سر ۔
    حلیم شرر کراچی پاکستان

  • @ogamiyashin2036
    @ogamiyashin2036 Год назад +26

    کاش اتنی ہمّت اور طاقت اُن چور ڈاکو لٹیرے حکمرانوں کے خلاف کی ہوتی جنکی وجہ سے آج یہ حالات ہوگئے ہیں تو یہی ملک یورپ جیسا بن چُکا ہوتا۔

    • @HassanAli-ep2bk
      @HassanAli-ep2bk Год назад

      Pakistan m kamny wala bnada Allah ki madad sabhut kma skta ha

  • @pravinghorpade2349
    @pravinghorpade2349 Год назад +3

    Such heartwarming documentary 👍

  • @ayeshasiddiqa3387
    @ayeshasiddiqa3387 Год назад +3

    Ahhhhh speechless..............

  • @kuldeeps90
    @kuldeeps90 Год назад +12

    I was in Turkey back in 2018 on an invitation of Turkish Industrial Development Authority for a project and while my stay i was kindda shocked by the sheer number of Pakistani youth lingering around the streets and corners waiting to cross through Georgia or Mediterranean and Caspian route. How come Pakistani Embassy in Turkey can not know this?

  • @bakhtawarishaq2933
    @bakhtawarishaq2933 Год назад +10

    Salute to all men who risk thier lives to feed their families!!! we respect you all

  • @mahnoorsw0rld482
    @mahnoorsw0rld482 Год назад +17

    *ہم صرف پیسوں میں دیوالیہ ہونے نہیں جا رہے بلکہ تمیز، کردار، حلال، انصاف، اخلاقیات، برداشت، انسانیت، حیاء اور غیرت میں بھی دیوالیہ ہوچکے ہیں۔*

  • @sultanaqamar372
    @sultanaqamar372 Год назад +37

    سب سے بڑی وجہ غربت ہے جس کی وجہ سے محنتی اور طاقتور نوجوان یہ مشکلات اٹھانے پر تیار ہو جاتے ہیں عقل انکی کم ہوتی ہے جب ہی غلط لوگوں کی باتوں پر یقین کر لیتے ہیں افسوسناک حقایق ہیں۔

    • @FatimaZahra-ec6bp
      @FatimaZahra-ec6bp Год назад +5

      بلکل اور حکومت ہماری لوگوں کو روزگار دینے سے قاصر ہے

    • @sadafnaazar
      @sadafnaazar Год назад +2

      Inko samjhyo t kahta Hain kush ni hota Jana ha humhain

  • @Hamda_Chaudhary
    @Hamda_Chaudhary Год назад +3

    Heart wrenching and heart breaking

  • @khalidsumair5878
    @khalidsumair5878 Год назад +16

    Thanks to BBC and all team for making such films with examples... hamara media to mafia bn gya hy... ya Allah pak pakistan pr rehm farma

    • @raoali1341
      @raoali1341 Год назад +1

      With the conseus of Ulema we can not Make a uniform law, so if according to Hanafi school of thought a girl can marry without the presence of WALI then how can you say that it is Haram nikkah because there is no consensus.

  • @sehrgeevailatheradiance
    @sehrgeevailatheradiance Год назад +4

    SUCH A GREAT content, salute

  • @saddam2659
    @saddam2659 Год назад +6

    Really tragic & heartbreaking😓

  • @siddiquifaizan8369
    @siddiquifaizan8369 Год назад

    very heart touching video

  • @amirmuhammed7687
    @amirmuhammed7687 Год назад +4

    Very nice & informative Research shared with us. Thanks.

  • @absarahmedkhan2109
    @absarahmedkhan2109 Год назад +151

    A former housemate of mine, half Afghan half Pakistani by blood and Pakistani resident went to UK through dunki. That was back in 2001/2 when the war started. I would always ask him to narrate his story and he would always do that everytime I asked him, around 2-3 times. It was such a thrill listening and also feeling sad on the tragedy he and his dunki-mates faced. Many died. He survived. After reaching UK all the way through land route in six months he called back home. Everyone by then had assumed he has died either fighting in war or in some blast in Peshawar. His story, that he first told me in 2006, still shakes me.

    • @ismailbaloch7154
      @ismailbaloch7154 Год назад

      جنرل عاصم منیر نے کہا ہندو بنیا صرف سود لیتا ہے۔ لیکن یہ ظالم چینی بنیا تمہارے گردے بھی لے جاتے ہیں اور ہر بڑے غبارے والی پنجابی لڑکی کی پھدی بھی.. یا علی مدد!!! 87dc

    • @kamranhashmi1575
      @kamranhashmi1575 Год назад +7

      Pakistani by blood?is there such people?

    • @drjabble
      @drjabble Год назад +4

      @@kamranhashmi1575 He's Afghan, But had to use Pakistan I.D to go abroad as no visa's were being processed in Afghanistan.. 90% Afghans abroad are by Pak I.D docs

    • @fizzel5711
      @fizzel5711 Год назад +4

      @@kamranhashmi1575 Pakistani = nationality
      Ethnic groups = pasthutn, Sindhi , Baluchi , Punjabi are main

    • @syedahmedx8807
      @syedahmedx8807 Год назад +1

      Fake story bro indeed

  • @munizariffat7969
    @munizariffat7969 Год назад +5

    I am literally crying to hear all this 😢😢.

  • @saminayasmin6801
    @saminayasmin6801 Год назад +2

    ALLAh pak KY Piyary Nabi. SAW) NY Simple life simple diet. Sare zindgi 😍 kush Rhin Allah's ❤️ blessings

  • @farooqjimi
    @farooqjimi Год назад +1

    very important & great documentary thanks for this.

  • @kunwarnasir5007
    @kunwarnasir5007 Год назад +4

    ہر شخص کیلیۓ، اسکے اپنے ملک میں، ترقی کے بہت سے مواقع ہوتے ہیں۔ صرف تھوڑی سی تلاش کرنی ہوتی ہے۔
    بندہ نے، اللہ کی مدد سے، کئی ناامید اشخاص کو ترقی کے راستہ پر چلنے میں مدد کی۔ آج وہ کامیابی کی مثال ہیں۔ الحمداللہ

  • @mercpindi5522
    @mercpindi5522 2 месяца назад +1

    Allah subki muskhilein asan kare

  • @khanafsarkhancaptain309
    @khanafsarkhancaptain309 Год назад +2

    اے زندگی تیری تلاش میں یہ لوگ
    اتنا چلتے ہیں کہ مر ھی جاتے ھیں

  • @dubiouswords7851
    @dubiouswords7851 Год назад +119

    It’s such a sad story. I was lucky to be born in Canada because my father immigrated here from Pakistan in the 1970s. I wonder what my life would have been if he had not educated himself and moved away. I don’t have to wonder too much because my cousins boys and other young men from my village have just left Pakistan to try to illegally immigrate to Europe via Libya. This is too close to home. Very sad.

    • @vinsin328
      @vinsin328 Год назад +8

      What about Two Nation Theory?

    • @dubiouswords7851
      @dubiouswords7851 Год назад +2

      @@vinsin328 lol what about it?

    • @muslima6689
      @muslima6689 Год назад +12

      You shouldn't be proud of yourself to be a so called Canadian national, great leader Jinnah came all the way from England for this Nation and we are proud of him , we would never be proud of the people who left when Pakistan needed them the most🙂

    • @drjabble
      @drjabble Год назад +2

      @@vinsin328 Wonder why most off these people coming are ACTUALLY INDIAN's...

    • @LoverBoy-hl7rz
      @LoverBoy-hl7rz Год назад +1

      I would never leave pakistan for canada, extremly cold weather, lonliness, racism, who would want that. Pakistan is better.

  • @SyedAsadHasnainBukhari
    @SyedAsadHasnainBukhari Год назад +12

    Heart wrenching
    I'm in tears 😢

  • @shahzadasunu1524
    @shahzadasunu1524 Год назад +1

    Mashahllah bohat achi video banae hai ❤ good information

  • @muhammadumar.9392
    @muhammadumar.9392 Год назад +2

    14:49 heart wrenching words of mother

  • @anwarshaikh4388
    @anwarshaikh4388 Год назад +21

    پاکستانی والدین سے استدعا ہے کہ اپنے بچوں کو اس طرح بے یارومددگار مشکلات مصاٸب اور ذلتوں کے حوالہ نا کریں۔رزق اللہ دینے والا ہے کم کھالیں کم پہن لٕیں روکھی سوکھی پر گذارا کریں مگر ان سبز باغوں سے بچیں

  • @mwaseemmansha2773
    @mwaseemmansha2773 Год назад +12

    إِنَّا لِلّهِ وَإِنَّـا إِلَيْهِ رَاجِعونَ
    اللہ پاک اپنے پیارے حبیب مُحَمَّد صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم کے صدقے انکی مغفرت فرمائے اور جنت الفردوس میں اعلی مقام عطا فرمائے اور تمام لواحقین کو صبر جمیل عطا فرمائے
    .آمیـــــــــــــــــن ثم آمیــــــــــــن يارب العالمیـــــــــــــــــن♥️🤲⁩⁦♥️⁩

  • @ranaadnankhan6906
    @ranaadnankhan6906 Год назад +2

    اللّٰہ پاک ماں جی کو صبر جمیل عطا فرمائے

  • @thecuttingedge.9751
    @thecuttingedge.9751 Год назад

    Thanks a lot to BBC for showing such things

  • @sarfzone
    @sarfzone Год назад +12

    Visited Refugees camp in Bosnia.
    It was surprised for me to know that there were 10,000 refugees from Pakistan and only 3 men were from India.

    • @verjeshnarzary9514
      @verjeshnarzary9514 5 месяцев назад +1

      When you can get visa by legal way why go via illegal, indians go via legal visa but illegally overstays.

    • @inunaaz8800
      @inunaaz8800 2 месяца назад

      Arey bhai India se bhi bhar bharke ja rhe hai jaake Dhruv raathe ki video dekho India ka bhi bhut bura haal hai​@@verjeshnarzary9514

  • @pioneer2321
    @pioneer2321 Год назад +9

    The grass isn’t greener on the other side. The sooner Pakistan know this the better. Stay where you are and keep your family safe.

  • @sairsky
    @sairsky Год назад +2

    I literally cried watching this. I wish Pakistan grow that strong enough to protect her common man.

  • @glamourbywajeeha8082
    @glamourbywajeeha8082 Год назад +1

    Ya Allah is mulk par apna khas karam frma day
    Aameen

  • @obaidullahnoori7066
    @obaidullahnoori7066 Год назад +19

    More such documentaries should be made and put on local media to bring awareness. The condition of immigrants and ways were not fully shown to aware people.

    • @adrkhubaib2582
      @adrkhubaib2582 Год назад

      Koi faida nhe jub rozana gar say gaalian parhti hain beroozgari k tanay miltay hain to banda soochta ha ya aik dafa mar jay ya phir bhar bhaar maray

  • @waqasakram116
    @waqasakram116 Год назад +3

    Thank you BBC for this story. The boy who died was living near my village

  • @beauty9123
    @beauty9123 Год назад +2

    Thanku bbc for highliting this

  • @RealMuhammadHassan
    @RealMuhammadHassan Год назад

    Thanks BBC for this Documentary 👏👏👏

  • @user-gj3pu7ek2s
    @user-gj3pu7ek2s Год назад +5

    کاش کے ہم کبھی اِس ملک میں پیدا ہی نہ ہوتے۔

    • @ahmadbutt2845
      @ahmadbutt2845 Год назад

      Nhi Bhai aisy nhi kehna chaiye Allah k har Kam me hikmat amli h Allah NY sabar k b kha h

    • @meeshakhan8062
      @meeshakhan8062 4 дня назад

      کاش واقئ ھم اس ملک میں نا ہوتے

    • @meeshakhan8062
      @meeshakhan8062 4 дня назад

      کاش واقئ اس ملک میں نا ھوتے ھم

  • @Ram20698
    @Ram20698 Год назад +12

    Sab log apne desh me raho bahar mat jao apne desh ko develop karo
    ❤from India 🇮🇳

  • @statusdream5595
    @statusdream5595 Год назад

    Behtreen video

  • @khulad-e-zahra6360
    @khulad-e-zahra6360 Год назад +1

    Ya Allah sub k rizq me barqat ata kr apny habib s.a k saqy ... mola subki mushkil ko asani me tabdeel kr dy ameen 🤲🙏

  • @muneebahmad7633
    @muneebahmad7633 Год назад +22

    Please make more videos to educate people
    Very good effort 👍

  • @foysalkhan2821
    @foysalkhan2821 Год назад +3

    Allah ji pls mere mulk ko itna khush haal kr dy k kisi behn bhai ko aisi preshanian na daikhni parain

  • @misterjack347
    @misterjack347 Год назад +1

    Bas aik hik dua hai ke Allah is Maa ke dil ko sakoon de kissi na kissi tarah. Ameen

  • @fk3512
    @fk3512 Год назад +1

    Heart touching video 😭😭😭😭🤲🤲🤲🤲🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @vahaab
    @vahaab Год назад +5

    I am British citizen and I think BBC should make a documentary on england poverty drugs and prostitution.

    • @GunwantBhambra
      @GunwantBhambra Год назад +1

      Do you realize this is BBC urdu not BBC English

  • @sarina5352
    @sarina5352 Год назад +50

    Absolutely agree with you, I live in the UK and came here to study but I saved struggled in Pakistan then I came to study. . Luckily got married to British but at the same time we work sooooooooo hard abroad. People don't realise that, what they see in the west on TV screens is nothing but just a dream which is nothing close to reality. Even people who are born here are homeless. I don't understand why the hell people do such things. I do understand that, people think if one person goes from the family others can have better life but why not legally. It's the same money and infact safe and nothing to loose. I would say often many are greedy and selfish especially when they start putting pressure on their older children. Pllllllllease stop living in dreams and be practical. Often I feel bad for these people because there's no one to guide them that, it's absolutely wrong way to make their lives better. No one gives you even water for free in the west.

    • @bilalshah817
      @bilalshah817 Год назад +4

      Very appreciated words ,
      No one gives you even water for free in the west.
      Any condition love you country live freedon , beautyfull Pak

    • @mansoormagsi1752
      @mansoormagsi1752 Год назад +1

      sis i highly appreciate to you well done your word word is Gold

    • @danielmacwan
      @danielmacwan Год назад +4

      Gurudwara in southall gives free meal

    • @asiakusy
      @asiakusy Год назад

      Well said

    • @sarina5352
      @sarina5352 Год назад +3

      @@danielmacwan so true not everyone is lucky to live close to GURDWARA or free meals stations. Trust me situation in the UK at the moment is hell.

  • @ghulamaddison
    @ghulamaddison Год назад

    Heart touching😢

  • @m.mudasir4146
    @m.mudasir4146 5 месяцев назад +2

    Thank you BBC News for useful info and awareness👍

  • @samarshahlubana2224
    @samarshahlubana2224 Год назад +18

    I’ve been through this situation to make in the USA…I can feel it nd I’m sorry for all those people who have lost their lives or returned to their home country 😢🇺🇸🇮🇳

    • @loudfiend4051
      @loudfiend4051 Год назад

      Biden is about to end dunki via Mexico in coming months.

  • @musman_ich
    @musman_ich Год назад +4

    In 2020 I was thinking of leaving Pakistan but not illegally after this I started freelancing Now I am happy in Pakistan

    • @drjabble
      @drjabble Год назад +2

      Work Hard and you can become RICH in Pakistan... Help other people too in your country.

    • @zay4110
      @zay4110 Год назад +1

      Brother can u give tips for freelancing? What is a good field to start?

    • @ur786.1
      @ur786.1 Месяц назад

      Well done. Showd you are intelligent and hard working.

  • @janatbakeandcake18
    @janatbakeandcake18 2 месяца назад

    بی بی سی اردو کی مجھے یہ سٹوری بہت اچھی لگی ہے اور بہت سچی ہے
    बीबीसी उर्दू की ये कहानी मुझे बहुत अच्छी लगी और बिल्कुल सच्ची है
    beebeesee urdoo kee ye kahaanee mujhe bahut achchhee lagee aur bilkul sachchee hai

  • @aliraza-ox6wg
    @aliraza-ox6wg 5 месяцев назад +1

    Ooh it was heart wrenching 😢

  • @AA-rv8ok
    @AA-rv8ok Год назад +27

    Heart touching ...Best advice to invest money in Pakistan and work hard. There are more opportunities in Pakistan than anywhere else. Only one requirement work hard and always be positive.

    • @ahmed92ism
      @ahmed92ism Год назад +10

      You are living in fool's paradise.....If that's the case regarding business opportunities & everything....Why people are investing in real estate?
      Plus this era is not of hard work & Pakistan is a lost cause where only corrupt can survive & honesty is meant to be punished.

    • @alikhanmoazzam
      @alikhanmoazzam Год назад +4

      @@ahmed92ism ajj tu chotey villages k log RUclipsrs ban kar paisa kama rahey hai there is always hope

    • @ahmed92ism
      @ahmed92ism Год назад +3

      @@alikhanmoazzam Bro everyone tries.....But you know about our cultural lag regarding camera facing & religious mindset....Majority people are still same unfortunately....
      I am also planning to start but only focusing on unique content so far

    • @alikhanmoazzam
      @alikhanmoazzam Год назад +1

      @@ahmed92ism bruh RUclips k ilawa , copywriting coding they are many skills u can learn but try to find trusted peoples , our society is just focused on producing docs engineers not seeing the job market needs .... Never give in to peer pressure there is no short cut

    • @ahmed92ism
      @ahmed92ism Год назад +2

      @@alikhanmoazzam Agree....
      I know coding but professional level k liye certification karney ka Soch raha but 1st is degree relevant skills

  • @77peacekeeper77
    @77peacekeeper77 Год назад +23

    Need strict laws against DUNKERS, selling dreams to innocent minds. Eventually robbing them of money / lives of dreamers.

  • @knowledgebay9921
    @knowledgebay9921 Год назад +2

    An excellent documentary by BBC , thanks for nice and informative effort

  • @abdulmajid2274
    @abdulmajid2274 Год назад

    Thanks BBC

  • @adnanbhatti7990
    @adnanbhatti7990 Год назад +10

    مجھے یو رپ میں رهتے ھوے دس سال هو گئے ھیں بس اتنا کہوں گا جس نے بھی آنا ہے آؤ مگر لیگل طر یقے سے آؤ ڈ نکی مت لگا و خدا کے لئے 😥😥😥😥😥😥😥

  • @saoodali2700
    @saoodali2700 Год назад +3

    Well done bbc

  • @shafaatbilal9861
    @shafaatbilal9861 Год назад

    Good information.
    While watching this film i am crying.

  • @zubairsiddiqui5022
    @zubairsiddiqui5022 Год назад +3

    ALLAH PAK apnay hifzo amaan me rakhay humaray watan ko or hm pr apna raham farmaey AAMEEN SUMAAMEEN🤲

  • @mikua786
    @mikua786 Год назад +7

    The most important thing is that," Why do people take that life-threatening risk?" Pakistan becomes the country where there is no law, life security, and respect for low income families.

    • @ur786.1
      @ur786.1 Месяц назад

      Pakistanis should use their energy towards improving their own county, the economy, ridding the corruption that had seeped into every pore of society. Yes there is some poverty but it's hardly a war torn country where improvements are impossible

  • @ksuri989
    @ksuri989 4 месяца назад +1

    An eye opener

  • @AbisMixplate
    @AbisMixplate Год назад +1

    Such a painful story.

  • @mahnoorrehman545
    @mahnoorrehman545 Год назад +67

    دل خون کے آنسو روتا ھے ایسی باتیں سن کر۔😰اللہ پاک پاکستان کے حالات اتنے اچھے کر دے کے لوگوں کو ایسے سگین فیصلے نہ کرنے پڑھیں۔پاکستان کی غریب عوام پہ اللہ پاک رحم کر آمین۔۔

    • @Mirza.jee99
      @Mirza.jee99 Год назад +2

      Ameen Ameen Ameen

    • @FrogHeat
      @FrogHeat Год назад

      ہانگ کانگ کی جھوٹی پارلیمنٹ کے خلاف مزاحمت کرنے کے لیے، ہمارے یوٹیوب چینل نے دوسری نسل کا میوزک کام “Frogheat” (اصل “Megahit” از آنسن لو) تیار کیا ۔ دوستوں کو پسند کرنے اور شئیر کرنے میں خوش آمدید✨

    • @flower12878
      @flower12878 Год назад

      It's all Allah's fault in the first place if people didn't follow his ways the countries wouldn't be 3rd world simple

    • @AliHussain-mu1xz
      @AliHussain-mu1xz Месяц назад

      Wakiy rit 😢😢😢

  • @kunwarnasir5007
    @kunwarnasir5007 Год назад +4

    اصل مسئلہ ہے کہ، لوگ سوچنے اور مشورہ کی صلاحیت کھو بیٹھے ہیں۔
    امید کو بھلا چکے ہیں۔
    پڑھے لکھے اور کھاتے پیتے لوگ، فقیر سے بھی زیادہ ناامید ہیں۔

  • @DistortedDj
    @DistortedDj Год назад +13

    Nawaz Sharif and Zardari are accountable for this situation of Pakistan

  • @waqasmir76
    @waqasmir76 Год назад

    Heartbreaking

  • @saqibsaghir1771
    @saqibsaghir1771 Год назад

    Very informative video.

  • @mrssubhani8524
    @mrssubhani8524 Год назад +32

    If you are educated, equipped with computer skills and ability to learn different languages then Europe is heaven for you otherwise it is Hell. Alhamdulliallh, I am living in EU last 2 years and working as a Cambridge teacher in international school. Alhamdulliallh proud to be Pakistani 💚

    • @nabeelanwar4511
      @nabeelanwar4511 Год назад +1

      in which city

    • @Padhh...or-AageBadhh
      @Padhh...or-AageBadhh Год назад

      I have been operating computer since 1999, and having customer service experience of 14 years. I know English, Urdu n Hindi. How can i get a job there if u could let me know plz. I am 43, man from India.

    • @alinaseer7874
      @alinaseer7874 Год назад +1

      @Mrs subhani That’s not entirely wrong, if you are educated in any respective which is in demand Europe, you are liable to apply in any of the European council member state. For example, I am an aerospace engineer currently in my 8th semester from Lahore. Hence the best option that I can opt for is Germany which most of us know is an engineering hub of the world. There are several other opportunities available rather than opting for computer science. Indeed, computer studies have evolved substantially into complexities like machine learning, data sciences, AI, and many more. So it is slightly debatable to whether choose computer relevant subjects your major as all subjects are being evolved spontaneously by researches laid down by scholars, teachers and students.

    • @adolft_official
      @adolft_official Год назад

      brother please convert some european girls to islam, it will help islam to grow

    • @mrssubhani8524
      @mrssubhani8524 Год назад

      @@nabeelanwar4511, Portugal, Lisbon

  • @sdnewfashionpoint766
    @sdnewfashionpoint766 Год назад +8

    میں ان حکمرانوں سے کہوں گی کہ اس دنیا میں نہ سہی لیکن آخرت میں تو پکڑے جاو گے تم لوگوں نے ہمارے ملک کو ان حالات میں دھکیلا کہ ہم لوگ بے روزگار ہوتے ہیں ڈگریاں ہاتھوں میں پکڑے ہوئے 😥 یہی وجہ ہے کہ لڑکے اس موت کے سفر پر نکل پڑتے ہیں کچھ ہمیشہ کے لیے دنیا سے چلے جاتے ہیں چند بچ جاتے ہیں اللہ ہمارے حالات کا تو ہی محرم ہے ایسے کیا مستقبل ہوگا ہمارے ملک اور ہماری نسلوں کا

  • @ranashahid3850
    @ranashahid3850 Год назад +1

    والدین ذمے دار ہیں

  • @lafzdilk844
    @lafzdilk844 Год назад

    Thank you so much BBC for this type of videos

  • @AsifKhan-lu1jj
    @AsifKhan-lu1jj Год назад +19

    Very sad 😔
    I worked with Greek migration ministry and had seen suffering of asylum seekers /refugees coming from Pakistan 😔

    • @yesssboss2219
      @yesssboss2219 Год назад +4

      What type of suffering? They cannot have a proper life ever there?

    • @susanwestern6434
      @susanwestern6434 Год назад +2

      Not refugees, economic migrants.

  • @shireens
    @shireens Год назад +9

    Heart breaking to watch this. This guy and many others like him will never be able to recover from the trauma of this journey. I pray n hope people can put this much effort in making their life better in pakistan than going through this torture route that is only a dead end.

    • @ur786.1
      @ur786.1 Месяц назад

      The ordinary person in Pakistan thinks the streets of Europe are paved with gold and money grows on trees. So sadly no, they will continue to take these risks and lives will continue to be lost.