Just to point out Throwing knives don't disappear in rdr1. There's better spots to slide down in rdr1, and some in rdr2 glitch a bit too. Arthur can't actually swim easily, he's a mid swimmer. It would have been cool to show rdr1 fighting mechanic which is more glitchy but offers a bit more possibilities than rdr2. The foam on water is particularly well made, along with the smoke from the cauldron and the fire below, those are impressively made. Very cool video. Always enjoyable to see how great both those games are
The water itself in rdr2 is soo damn realistic though rdr1 water wasn’t too bad either if you see, that’s why I always say that rockstar beats their own shit and no one else could. I imagine how many guys would they have who give them the realistic idea to implement in the game, whether be physics or how the realistic perspective works 😮
The only game that came closest to having a feature like this was GTA 4, where you could pick up objects from the ground (bricks, rocks, cans, bottles, etc.) and throw them at people. So I think it would be something innovative and cool. Imagine you're on a mission where you're ambushed, captured and left in a place full of enemies, without any firearms, and you have to rely only on melee weapons and hand-to-hand combat to survive. A function to throw knives and axes or even a heavy object like a brick would be very useful in this situation!
I started playing RDR on PC a week ago and while I absolutely adore the game and I think that it's even better to the sequel in some ways but holy fuck how is RDR2 still easily the most gorgeous game to date despite soon being over half a decade old already. Rockstar fucking COOKED and I hope RDR3 or a similar game is in the works.
What’s crazy is that it doesn’t even have a dedicated series s or X version of the game so when you play on a Xbox series X it’s running an Xbox one X version of the game but it’s still one the the most beautiful games I’ve ever played
@@mr.shorty7310 I thought you were comparing both games which to see is better cause obviously you can’t do that cause 14. Year age gap your just seeing what’s changed I see that now
@@ZahraShayesteh-ib2hd yeah they did not becoz in 1 he dies by just standing in the water on a certain face level. That time they didn’t have or don’t know why they decided not to implement it, as they did in gta 4. But they had to keep it real as rdr1 is sequel to rdr2, so they had him drowning realistically as possible in game: where he don’t stand but struggle in water for 10secs until he drowns
I like both of them tbh they are both stunning. RDR2 just edges it much better graphics and missions. RDR1 doesn't look dated at all compaired to some older games. I'm enjoying playing it after completing RDR2!
i will never understand why rockstar made the hatchet and axe a throwable weapon in the game, kind of stupid since we already have tomahawks and with a hatchet you cannot throw them in real life because they are long, you would most likely fig the throw or hit yourself in the face with the handle, having them as melee would have been better. look at skyrim its a 20 year old game and it has 2 handed melee for giant weapons but your not mobile and cant block and 1 handed weapons for quicker and weaker swinging but instead of red dead redemption 2 doing that they just copy and paste the axe and hatchet into a tomahawk so you throw them.
Fun fact about red dead 1, R* didn’t know how to make the swimming animations for John so in red dead 2 they just rolled with it and said he can’t swim
I think john just can't swim cause I dide in water as him in rdr2 too, he didnt even try to swim at all, all stamina just drains instantly and health bar starts going down quick unless you gtfo the water FAST...
The swimming isnt exactly fair in the games "lore" John aka the main protagonist in RDR 1 cant swim while Arthur the main protagonist of RDR 2 can swim you should redo the test after reaching the ending of the game (still results in john drowning)
Rdr2 has better graphics better physics and customisation while in rdr1 u cant make ur own outfits u cant customize ur gun but both games are good but theyre very different in my opinion
![[4K] Slow Motion Brutal Kills #3 - Red Dead Redemption 2](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5CCfkTBvGj8/mqdefault.jpg)
Are you playing RDR 1 again?
yes im gonna play it
h
No 😢
Yes
Yes
Just to point out
Throwing knives don't disappear in rdr1. There's better spots to slide down in rdr1, and some in rdr2 glitch a bit too. Arthur can't actually swim easily, he's a mid swimmer. It would have been cool to show rdr1 fighting mechanic which is more glitchy but offers a bit more possibilities than rdr2. The foam on water is particularly well made, along with the smoke from the cauldron and the fire below, those are impressively made.
Very cool video. Always enjoyable to see how great both those games are
Thank you :D
The water itself in rdr2 is soo damn realistic though rdr1 water wasn’t too bad either if you see, that’s why I always say that rockstar beats their own shit and no one else could. I imagine how many guys would they have who give them the realistic idea to implement in the game, whether be physics or how the realistic perspective works 😮
Rdr1 water>>>>>>
How is rdr1 wster better?
RDR 1 =Sharp Visual
RDR2 =Blurry Visual
Yes, I have noticed that too. Rdr2 is blurry af.
Because of TAA being a mess
you can make it sharp by changing few settings on pc version
You're saying like rdr2 has no visual lol . Retard
TAA is fixable on pc.
I wish GTA 5 also had the ability to throw axes and knives. I hope it returns in GTA 6. It's really cool!
Might be wrong but I don’t know if any GTA game had throwing melees
What's the point of silencers then
The only game that came closest to having a feature like this was GTA 4, where you could pick up objects from the ground (bricks, rocks, cans, bottles, etc.) and throw them at people. So I think it would be something innovative and cool. Imagine you're on a mission where you're ambushed, captured and left in a place full of enemies, without any firearms, and you have to rely only on melee weapons and hand-to-hand combat to survive. A function to throw knives and axes or even a heavy object like a brick would be very useful in this situation!
What do silencers have to do with it?!
@@GTA_APODI_1609 rdr 2 uses knives as a stealth mechanism. Why would you need knives in GTA?
The swimming one is wrong. Arthur can swim in the water, but after you become john, you can no longer swim.
Dutch didn't teach John how to swim
There is a line in RDR 2 from Arthur to John that mentions "You can't swim"
During Rdr 1 era xbox 360 always had good Graphics idk why
I started playing RDR on PC a week ago and while I absolutely adore the game and I think that it's even better to the sequel in some ways but holy fuck how is RDR2 still easily the most gorgeous game to date despite soon being over half a decade old already. Rockstar fucking COOKED and I hope RDR3 or a similar game is in the works.
What’s crazy is that it doesn’t even have a dedicated series s or X version of the game so when you play on a Xbox series X it’s running an Xbox one X version of the game but it’s still one the the most beautiful games I’ve ever played
Why are you comparing a 14 year old game to a 6 year old game that’s ahead of its time and I don’t mean this in a rude way it’s just a question
cos its rdr 1 v rdr2. Whats the problem with it? Its a comparison video to see the changes
@@mr.shorty7310 I thought you were comparing both games which to see is better cause obviously you can’t do that cause 14. Year age gap your just seeing what’s changed I see that now
@@Youchump in some ways rdr1 is better ngl
@@nekjottiI haven't played it yet, but infinite bounties and random encounters sounds lit 🔥
Also i heard tall trees is way scarier
@@Theneonguy789 haven't played rdr1 yet either, but I'm saving up 🤞
John can't swim 🤣 even in the red dead redemption 2
In rdr2 for 5-10 seconds it really can but after that it drowns easily.
Shut up
They don’t make animations for him
Shut up
@@ZahraShayesteh-ib2hd yeah they did not becoz in 1 he dies by just standing in the water on a certain face level. That time they didn’t have or don’t know why they decided not to implement it, as they did in gta 4. But they had to keep it real as rdr1 is sequel to rdr2, so they had him drowning realistically as possible in game: where he don’t stand but struggle in water for 10secs until he drowns
Low brightness rdr 2 look beautifull
2:16 yoy. Listen the music. 2 musics in one
7:00 rdr1 is goat
1:10 RDR 2 is the Goat 🐐
Hmmm I wonder if there’s a Lone Ranger Outfit
I like both of them tbh they are both stunning. RDR2 just edges it much better graphics and missions. RDR1 doesn't look dated at all compaired to some older games. I'm enjoying playing it after completing RDR2!
i will never understand why rockstar made the hatchet and axe a throwable weapon in the game, kind of stupid since we already have tomahawks and with a hatchet you cannot throw them in real life because they are long, you would most likely fig the throw or hit yourself in the face with the handle, having them as melee would have been better. look at skyrim its a 20 year old game and it has 2 handed melee for giant weapons but your not mobile and cant block and 1 handed weapons for quicker and weaker swinging but instead of red dead redemption 2 doing that they just copy and paste the axe and hatchet into a tomahawk so you throw them.
What? Did you forget you can
Block with a 2h warhammer
1:48 omg he can't swim like tommy vercetti
Yes he can't swim
@@Cat-h5s shut up
John can swim rockstar don’t make animations
Fun fact about red dead 1, R* didn’t know how to make the swimming animations for John so in red dead 2 they just rolled with it and said he can’t swim
I think john just can't swim cause I dide in water as him in rdr2 too, he didnt even try to swim at all, all stamina just drains instantly and health bar starts going down quick unless you gtfo the water FAST...
RDR1>GOW3
RDR2>GOW 2018
Rdr1>>>> all of them
1:16 bro why theres blood?💀💀 is the horse on his period?💀💀☠️
Its coming from arthur, maybe hes having his period
@ yup xdd
Amazing video bro❤️
Thank you :D
I wonder why you compare John to Arthur
Thats a good video keep it up❤
The swimming isnt exactly fair in the games "lore" John aka the main protagonist in RDR 1 cant swim while Arthur the main protagonist of RDR 2 can swim you should redo the test after reaching the ending of the game (still results in john drowning)
the npc also couldn't swim in rdr1 one tho.
8:19 mexsico is beutiful❤
Hi bro first view me ❤😅😊
Hello bro
🎉🎉🎉
VERY incredible FRIENDS I LIKE RDR1 IS SO AWSOME. THE BEST IS RDR2 IS BETTER
you should do john vs john, not arthur vs john
Ha mai khelra winlator me mobile pe 😅😅
👍👍👍
rdr 1 great grand father of tommy so he cant swim
Good video👍
Thank you :D
Nice 💚💚💚🔥🔥🔥
Thank you :D
nice
Thank you :D
yes
Rdr2 has better graphics better physics and customisation while in rdr1 u cant make ur own outfits u cant customize ur gun but both games are good but theyre very different in my opinion
❤❤
💚💚💚
good
Thank you :D
1:23 bro is cooked💀
wow
Yes 💚💚💚🔥🔥🔥
great competition
Always 1😊
RDR 1 like GTA 4
RDR 2 like GTA 5
Best video best RUclipsr
I just finished RDR 1 recently. Definitely worse in many ways compared to RDR 2 but the game felt more like a wild west than RDR 2.
make rdr2 attention to details❤
Rdr1>>>>>>>
Nice !
Wow 🎉🎉🎉1😂😂😂💚💚💚🔥🔥🔥
Rdr1>>>>>>❤❤❤
🎉🎉🎉😂😂😂💚🔥🔥🔥
Hello ⚔️⚔️⚔️💚💚💚🔥🔥🔥
Hello bro
Hey Bro
Hello bro
Red dead 1 needs remake
hello
😂😂😂🎉🎉🎉
i5 gen 8 can play it?
XDDDDDD 1:15
RDR1 is so unrealistic, who thinks RDR2 is better?
Итог обы рд норм игры каждый для себя определит какую играть
Rdr1>>>>>>2
RDR 2 IS THE BEST GAME EVER
Rdr 2 best
this is called first
RDR 1 is better than RDR 2
First
We need RDR3 🫂 i hope soon
FIIIRRRSSSTTTT PIN 📌 PLSSSS🎉🎉🎉🎉
Wow THANK YOU FOR THE HEART ONESPOT 😍😍😍😜
🎉🎉🎉
❤❤❤